Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1022; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1186
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 19 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 14804/2024
- Sections
- 20, 20(2), 135, 20(4), 20(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1186 : 2024 INSC 1022 Parswanath Saha v.
Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 14804 of 2024)
20 December 2024 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment setting aside the decree of specific performance passed by the Trial Court in favour of the plaintiff-appellant. Headnotes† Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.20, prior to the 2018 Amendment – Discretion as to decreeing specific performance – Agreement of Sale was executed by the predecessor of the defendantsrespondents (husband of respondent no.1 and father of respondent no.2) in favour of the plaintiff-appellant however, he died before the execution of the Sale deed – Defendants declined to execute the Sale Deed – Decree of specific performance passed by Trial Court in favour of the plaintiff – Decree set aside by High Court holding that the predecessor of the defendants was unable to foresee the hardship that would be caused to him and the family at the time when he executed the Agreement of Sale w.r.t the suit property and the defendants were able to establish that except the suit property they did not have any other property and if they had to part with it that would cause hardship to them – Correctness: Held: Not correct– High Court erred in taking the view that the plaintiff was not entitled to the decree for specific performance as it would cause hardship to the defendants – It overlooked the fact that the question of hardship in terms of Section 20(2)(b) r/w explanation (2) bears reference to hardship, which the defendant did not foresee at the time of entering into the contract – The issue of hardship would come into play only if it was established by cogent evidence that predecessor of the defendants who executed the Agreement of Sale was unable to foresee the hardship at the time * Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1187Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr. of entering into the contract – The explanation elucidates the point of time at which the hardship has to be determined with reference to the circumstances existing at the time of the contract, except where the hardship has been caused from an act of the plaintiff subsequent to the contract – Nothing in the pleadings or evidence shows that there was a hardship of the kind which the predecessor of the defendants did not foresee at the time he executed the Agreement of Sale or that the hardship which the defendants would face is the result of an act of the plaintiff based on his supervening acts – Defendants brought nothing on record to show that the suit property was the only shelter available to them – In fact, the evidence on record shows that the predecessor of the defendants was not getting along well with them and the defendants were residing separately – It was only when he passed away that the defendants tried to take over the suit property – Impugned order set aside, decree of the Trial Court restored with modification as stated. [Paras 33-36, 43] Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.20, prior to the 2018 Amendment – Discretion as to decreeing specific performance – Refusal to decree specific performance on the ground of ‘hardship’: Held: The jurisdiction to decree specific performance is discretionary – The discretion is not arbitrary but is “sound and reasonable”, to be “guided by judicial principles” – The exercise of discretion is capable of being corrected by a court of appeal in the hierarchy of appellate courts – Sub-section (2) of Section 20 contains a stipulation of those cases where the court may exercise its discretion not to grant specific performance – Section 20 as it stood prior to the 2018 Amendment shows as to under what circumstances ‘hardship’ can be taken into consideration in refusing specific performance – It is not possible to enumerate the different circumstances which constitute a hardship and the question of hardship will have to be adjudged in the facts and circumstances of the case. [Paras 27, 28] Words and Phrases – “mere” – Specific Relief Act, 1963 – ss.20(4), 20(2)(a)-(c) – Explanations – Discussed. [ Paras 8, 29] Case Law Cited K. Narendra v. Riviera Apartments (P) Ltd. [1999] 3 SCR 777 : (1999) 5 SCC 77; Nirmala Anand v. Advent Corpn. (P) Ltd. & Ors. 1188 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports [2002] Supp. 2 SCR 706 : (2002) 8 SCC 146; K. Prakash v. B.R. Sampath Kumar [2014] 13 SCR 702 : (2015) 1 SCC 597; Nanjappan v. Ramasamy & Anr [2015] 2 SCR 606 : (2015) 14 SCC 341; Ferrodous Estates (Pvt.) Ltd. v. P. Gopirathnam (Dead) & Ors., 2020 INSC 586 : [2020] 13 SCR 673; Sanghi Bros (Indore) Pvt. Ltd. v. Kamlendra Singh, 2023 SCC OnLine Del 5528; Jayakantham & Ors. v. Abhaykumar [2017] 2 SCR 355 : (2017) 5 SCC 178; Kamal Kumar v. Prem Lata Joshi and Ors. [2019] 1 SCR 54 : (2019) 3 SCC 704; Shenbagam and Ors. v. K. K. Rathinavel (1969) 2 SCC 539; Ouseph Varghese v. Josph Aley [1970] 1 SCR 921 : (1969) 2 SCC 539; G.W. Davis v. Maung Shwe Go, 1911 SCC OnLine PC 25; Prakash Chandra v. Narayan [2012] 5 SCR 444 : (2012) 5 SCC 403 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Chitty on Contracts (27th Edn., 1994, Vol. 1., at p. 1296). List of Acts Specific Relief Act, 1963.
List of Keywords Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963; Prior to the 2018 Amendment; Decree of specific performance; Hardship; Refusing specific performance/Refusal of specific performance of the contract; Act of the plaintiff subsequent to the contract; Agreement of Sale; Sale Deed; Predecessor of the defendants; Residing separately; Hierarchy of appellate courts; Discretion not to grant specific performance; Court of appeal.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 14804 of From the Judgment and Order dated 29.07.2022 of the High Court of Tripura at Agartala in RFA No. 28 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Pijush Kanti Roy, Sr. Adv., Mrs. Kakali Roy, Rajan K. Chourasia, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ajit Pravin Wagh, Advs. for the Respondents.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1189Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr. Judgment/Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Tripura in Regular First Appeal No. 28 of 2019 dated 29.07.2022 by which the High Court allowed the appeal filed by the respondents herein (Original Defendants) and thereby quashed and set aside the judgment and decree passed by the Civil Judge West Tripura, Agartala granting Specific Performance of Agreement of Sale in Title Suit No.135 of 2016 instituted by the appellant herein (Original Plaintiff).
3. Facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarised as under:
(a) The appellant herein (Original Plaintiff) instituted Case No. T.S. 135 of 2016 in the Court of Civil Judge Senior Div. (Court No. 1) West Tripura, Agartala and prayed for the following reliefs:
(i) A decree for declaration of the entitlement of the Plaintiff to get the execution, registration and possession of the suit land from the Defendants as part performance of the contract following the registered deed of Agreement for Sale dated 27.05.2016.
(ii) A decree for mandatory injunction directing the Defendants to execute and register the sale deed in respect of the suit land in favour of the plaintiff and to handover the possession of the suit land to the plaintiff as part performance of the contract in pursuance of the deed of Agreement for Sale within a specified period failing which to execute and register the sale deed in respect of the suit land in favour of plaintiff and to hand over possession of the suit land to the plaintiff through the Ld. Court by enforcing the decree as may be passed.
1190 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(iii) A decree for permanent injunction restraining the defendants and their agents from making any kind of transfer of the suit land to others or to give any mortgage, lease, etc of the suit land till disposal of the present suit.
(b) It appears from the materials on record that the husband of the respondent no. 1 herein and father of the respondent no. 2 herein namely Late Prabha Ranjan Das was the lawful owner of the suit property.
(c) The appellant herein entered into a registered Agreement of Sale dated 27.05.2016 with respect to the suit property. The total sale consideration fixed was of Rs. 17,50,000.00 (Rupees Seventeen Lakh Fifty Thousand only). An amount of Rs. 4,00,000.00 (Rupees Four Lakh only) was paid to Late Prabha Ranjan Das by the appellant herein towards earnest money.
(d) Prabha Ranjan Das passed away on 05.07.2016 leaving behind the respondents (Original Defendants) as his lawful heirs.
(e) The appellant herein called upon the respondents herein to execute the Sale Deed in accordance with the terms of the Agreement of Sale dated 27.05.2016 duly executed by Prabha Ranjan Das.
(f) The respondents herein declined to execute the Sale Deed. In such circumstances, the appellant herein was left with no other option but to institute the suit, seeking specific performance of the contract.
(g) In the suit, the Trial Court framed the following issues:
(i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and nature?
(ii) Has the plaintiff any cause of action to institute the instant suit?
(iii) Has the plaintiff entered into a registered agreement for sale dated 27.05.2016 with Prabha Ranjan Das (predecessor of the defendants) to purchase the suit land?
(iv) Are the averments available in the plaint in respect of readiness and willingness to perform the part of the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1191Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr. contract in its true construction sufficient to enforce specific performance as prayed for?
(v) Is the plaintiff entitled to get a registered sale deed in terms of agreement for sale?
(vi) Is the plaintiff entitled to get a decree as prayed for?
(vii) What other relief / reliefs the plaintiff is entitled to?
(h) The suit ultimately came to be allowed in favour of the appellant herein vide judgment and decree dated 20.11.2018. The operative part of the order passed by the Trial Court reads thus: “In the result, the suit is decreed with cost in favour of the plaintiff with following directions:
(a) the defendant No. 1 Smt. Bandana Modak (Das)
shall execute a Registered Deed of Sale on behalf of herself and also being the guardian on behalf of her minor son i.e. defendant No. 2 Master Diptanu Das in favour of the plaintiff Shri Parswanath Saha for the suit land measuring 1 ganda 1 kara of land alongwith building thereon measuring 529 sq.ft appertaining to Khatian No.347 having R.S. Plot No.151 within a period of forty five days from the date of drawing up of decree failing which the plaintiff will be entitled to get the Sale Deed be executed through this Court as per law subject to payment of rest consideration amount of Rs.13,50,000/- (thirteen lac fifty thousand) only by the plaintiff to the defendants;
(b) the defendants shall hand over the possession of the suit land to the plaintiff immediately after execution of the above mentioned Sale Deed along with all the documents of title relating to the suit property which are in the defendants’ possession or power.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Sheristadar of my Court is hereby directed to prepare the decree in the light of my above judgment and to place it before me for my signatures within 15 (fifteen) days from the date of passing of this judgment.
1192 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Make necessary entry in the Trial Register.
Thus this case is disposed of without contest.”
(i) The respondents herein (Original Defendants) went in appeal before the High Court. The High Court allowed the appeal essentially on the ground that Late Prabha Ranjan Das was unable to foresee the hardship that would be caused to him and the family at the time when he executed the Agreement of Sale with respect to the suit property. The High Court accepted that Late Prabha Ranjan Das executed the registered Agreement of Sale with respect to the suit property and had also accepted Rs. 4,00,000.00 (Rupees Four Lakh only) by way of earnest money. However, as stated above, the High Court took the view that the defendants have been able to establish that except the suit land they do not have any other property and if they had to part with the suit property that would cause lot of hardship to them.
(j) The High Court while allowing the First Appeal filed by the defendants observed as under:
“17. Apart from the aforesaid facts, we find that the submission of learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the plaintiff that the defendants have not pleaded the fact of hardship in their written statement is not correct. The defendants have specifically stated in their written statement that except the suit land they have no other piece of land and they require the suit land for their own residential purpose and they cannot expect to dispose of their only piece of land and building standing thereon which would render them homeless, shelterless and roofless. This pleading is also supported by their evidence. Even from the evidence of the witnesses of the plaintiff, it is established that the defendant no. 1 used to reside in the house of her father at Beltali. The plaintiff deposing as PW-1 specifically stated that he along with his staff met with the defendant No.1 personally in the house of her father at Beltali, Agartala on 21.08.2016 and told her as to whether she could obtain the said Survivor Certificate and the Guardianship Certificate. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1193Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr.
18. From such evidence of the plaintiff, there cannot be any doubt that the defendants had no shelter other than the father of the defendant no.1 and according to us, this admitted fact is enough to prove the hardship of the defendants that the defendant no.1, who along with her minor son would be rendered homeless and shelterless, if the suit for specific performance of the agreement of sale (Exbt.1) is decreed in favour of the plaintiff.”
19. Applying the well settled principle that it is not always necessary to grant specific performance simply for the reason that it is legal to do so, we are of the opinion, that the case in hand is a fit case to exercise our discretion rejecting the plaintiffs claim to ask the defendants to execute the deed of sale in terms of Exbt.1 as decreed by learned court below.
20. As a sequel, we hold that the plaintiff is not entitled to get a decree for specific performance of the agreement of sale (Exbt.-1) and the defendants are not under any obligation to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff in the light of the agreement of sale (Exbt.-1). However, the plaintiff is definitely entitled to get refund of the earnest money, which he paid to late Prabha Ranjan Das, the predecessor of the defendants along with interest at the rate of 8% per annum. The defendants shall refund the said earnest money of Rs.4,00,000 (Rupees four lakhs)
along with simple interest at the rate of 8% per annum to the plaintiff from the date of the institution of the suit within a period of 3(three) months from today.”
4. The appellant herein being dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is here before this Court with the present appeal.
RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF LAW
5. Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 as it then stood i.e., prior to the 2018 amendment reads as under:
1194 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “20. Discretion as to decreeing specific performance.-(1) The jurisdiction to decree specific performance is discretionary, and the Court is not bound to grant such relief merely because it is lawful to do so; but the discretion of the Court is not arbitrary but sound and reasonable, guided by judicial principles and capable of correction by a Court of Appeal.
(2) The following are cases in which the Court may properly exercise discretion not to decree specific performance.-
(a) where the terms of the contract or the conduct of the parties at the time of entering into the contract or the other circumstances under which the contract was entered into are such that the contract, though not voidable, gives the plaintiff an unfair advantage over the defendant; or
(b) where the performance of the contract would involve some hardship on the defendant which he did not foresee, whereas its non-performance would involve no such hardship on the plaintiff; or
(c) where the defendant entered into the contract under circumstances which though not rendering the contract voidable, makes it inequitable to enforce specific performance.
Explanation 1. — Mere inadequacy of consideration, or the mere fact that the contract is onerous to the defendant or improvident in its nature, shall not be deemed to constitute an unfair advantage within the meaning of Clause (a) or hardship within the meaning of clause (b).
Explanation 2.— The question whether the performance of a contract would involve hardship on the defendant within the meaning of clause (b) shall, except in cases where the hardship has resulted from any act of the plaintiff subsequent to the contract, be determined with reference to the circumstances existing at the time of the contract.
(3) The Court may properly exercise discretion to decree specific performance in any case where the plaintiff has [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1195Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr. done substantial acts or suffered losses in consequence of a contract capable of specific performance.
(4) The Court shall not refuse to any party specific performance of a contract merely on the ground that the contract is not enforceable at the instance of the other party.”
6. The relief of specific performance having its roots in equity, the Specific Relief Act, 1963, prior to its amendment has preserved the discretion of the Court not to grant the relief even though the agreement is specifically performable in law. The only fetters imposed by the statute on the exercise of the discretion are that the discretion must not be exercised arbitrarily but soundly and reasonably and guided by judicial principles. The phrase “capable of correction by a Court of appeals” has been inserted possibly to indicate the necessity for the Trial Court to state the reasons for exercising its discretion in a particular way. The circumstances when specific performance mentioned in the Clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Sub-section (2) of Section 20 cannot be granted are not expressly exhaustive. They indicate the situations in which the Court may properly exercise discretion not to decree specific performance. However, certain considerations have been excluded as relevant factors. These are contained in Explanations 1 and 2 to the Section as well as in Section 20(4). It is to be noticed that each of these exclusions are preceded by the word “mere”. The word “mere” in the context means “sole”. In other words, any one of those factors by itself would not justify the exercise of discretion against granting specific performance. The factors cumulatively or with other factors may form the basis of a decision not to grant specific performance.
7. Hardship of the defendant may be one of the grounds which may be taken into consideration for exercising its discretion by the Court in refusing to grant a decree for specific performance of contract.
POSITION OF LAW
8. In K. Narendra v. Riviera Apartments (P) Ltd., reported in (1999) 5 SCC 77 this Court held as under:
“29. Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 provides that the jurisdiction to decree specific performance is 1196 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports discretionary and the court is not bound to grant such relief merely because it is lawful to do so; the discretion of the court is not arbitrary but sound and reasonable guided by judicial principles and capable of correction by a court of appeal. Performance of the contract involving some hardship on the defendant which he did not foresee while non-performance involving no such hardship on the plaintiff, is one of the circumstances in which the court may properly exercise discretion not to decree specific performance. The doctrine of comparative hardship has been thus statutorily recognized in India. However, mere inadequacy of consideration or the mere fact that the contract is onerous to the defendant or improvident in its nature, shall not constitute an unfair advantage to the plaintiff over the defendant or unforeseeable hardship on the defendant. The principle underlying Section 20 has been summed up by this Court in Lourdu Mari David and others v. Louis Chinnaya Arogiaswamy and others (1996) 5 SCC 589 by stating that the decree for specific performance is in the discretion of the Court but the discretion should not be used arbitrarily; the discretion should be exercised on sound principles of law capable of correction by an appellate court.
xxx xxx xxx
35. … Possession over a meagre part of the property was delivered by the appellant to the respondents, not simultaneously with the agreement but subsequently at some point of time. To that extent, the recital in the agreement and the averments made in the plaint filed by the respondents are false. On a major part of the property, the appellant has continued to remain in possession.
As opposed to this, the respondents have neither pleaded nor brought material on record to hold that they have acted in such a way as to render inequitable the denial of specific performance and to hold that theirs would be a case of greater hardship over the hardship of the appellant. Upon an evaluation of the totality of the circumstances, we are of the opinion that the performance of the contract would involve [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1197Parswanath Saha v. Bandhana Modak (Das) and Anr. such hardship on the appellant as he did not foresee while the non-performance would not involve such hardship on the respondents. The contract though valid at the time when it was entered, is engrossed into such circumstances that the performance thereof cannot be secured with precision. The present one is a case where the discretionary jurisdiction to decree the specific performance ought not to be exercised in favour of the respondents. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
9. In Nirmala Anand v. Advent Corpn. (P) Ltd. & Ors., reported in (2002) 8 SCC 146 this Court held as under:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.