Kailas S/O Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1117; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 935
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Manoj Misra, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 15 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 4041/2025
- Sections
- 65B, 293(1), 391, 8, 20, 65, 2, 293, 386, 465, 52, 114
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 935 : 2025 INSC 1117 Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v.
The State of Maharashtra (Criminal Appeal No. 4041 of 2025)
15 September 2025 [Manoj Misra* and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the High Court was justified in ordering a re-trial; if not, then what would be the appropriate order that may be passed in this appeal.
Headnotes† Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 – ss.8(c) r/w 20(b)(ii)(C) – Punishment for contravention in relation to cannabis plant and cannabis – Search and seizure operation leading to recovery of contraband-Ganja weighing 39 kgs from the hut of the appellant-accused no. 1 and accused no.2 – On disclosure by two accused, complicity of accused no.3 came to light and on accused no.3’s arrest, complicity of accused no.4 came to light – Trial court relied on the video recording of the raid to corroborate the substantive evidence led during trial and convicted accused nos.1 and 2 and acquitted the other two accused – High Court set aside the conviction and sentence, however, remanded the matter for a re-trial since the video-recording was not converted into admissible evidence; the chemical examiner/analyst not produced as a witness; non-production of remnant samples; and non-production of representative samples – Sustainability: Held: Order by the High Court ordering re-trial not sustainable – As regards the admissibility of video recording-Compact Disc, the High Court opined that the video would become relevant only if it is played during deposition of each witness so that the witness could explain its contents in his own words resulting in a transcript of the video, is a strange and unacceptable reasoning since the CD is an electronic record and once the requirement of s.65B is fulfilled it becomes an admissible piece of evidence, and the video recorded therein is akin to contents of a document which can be seen and * Author 936 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports heard to enable the court to draw appropriate inferences – On facts, search and seizure operation was sought to be proved by oral evidence of witnesses, the video, was perhaps to corroborate the oral testimony – Video was played in court in the presence of all accused as well as both sides counsels and the presiding officer, upon seeing the video, could spot and confirm the presence of witnesses as well as the accused at the time of search and seizure, in such circumstances, re-trial is not required only to explain the video – As regards the non-production of the chemical examiner as a witness, no such requirement of law that Chemical Examiner would have to be called in each NDPS case to prove the report when it is otherwise admissible u/s.293(1) CrPC – Moreover, from the judgment of the trial court it appears that the Chemical Examiner’s report was admitted in evidence – Nothing in High Court’s judgment that any objection was raised in respect of exhibiting the Chemical Examiner’s report – As regards, non-production of remnant samples and representative samples, prima facie, there existed material to indicate that the seized contraband was sent in a sealed condition for preparation of inventory – Thereafter, inventory was prepared, samples were drawn and sealed; and the samples were sent to FSL in a sealed condition, which found the seal intact – High Court, however, observed that the representative sample was not opened before the Court at the time of recording of statement of the concerned witness – This was not a ground to direct for a re-trial when the appellate court has power to take additional evidence u/s.391 CrPC – Direction for restoration of appeals before the High Court for a fresh decision – Impugned order of the High Court set aside. [Paras 19, 21, 31, 33-36] Case Law Cited Ukha Kolhe v. State of Maharashtra [1964] 1 SCR 926 : AIR 1963 SC 1531; Nasib Singh v. State of Punjab and Another [2021] 13 SCR 566 : (2022) 2 SCC 89; Jitendra and Another v. State of M.P. [2003] Supp. 3 SCR 918 : (2004) 10 SCC 562; Ashok v. State of M.P. [2011] 4 SCR 253 : (2011) 5 SCC 123; Vijay Jain v. State of M.P. [2013] 4 SCR 293 : (2013) 14 SCC 527; Noor Aga v. State of Punjab [2008] 10 SCR 379 : (2008) 16 SCC 417; Union of India v. Jaroopram [2018] 1 SCR 618 : (2018) 4 SCC 334; Baldev Singh v. State of Haryana (2021) 18 SCC 523; Vijay Pandey v. State of U.P. [2019] 10 SCR 774 : (2019) 18 SCC 215; State of Rajasthan v. Sahi Ram [2019] 14 SCR 1117 : (2019) 10 SCC 649 – referred to.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 937Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra List of Acts Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985; Evidence Act, 1872; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Re-trial; Recovery of contraband; Contraband; Raid; Transcript of the video; Search and seizure operation; Corroborate the oral testimony; Chemical Examiner’s report; Non-production of the seized contraband during trial; Ganja; Video recording of the raid; Remanded to judicial custody; Re-trial with judicial remand; Additional evidence; Search and seizure operation; Recovery of contraband-Ganja weighing 39 kgs; Corroborate the substantive evidence; Video-recording not converted into admissible evidence; Chemical examiner/analyst not produced as witness; Non-production of remnant samples; Non-production of representative samples; Legally admissible evidence.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
4041 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.10.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Nagpur in CRLA No. 449 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Anil Mardikar, Sr. Adv., Sachin Shanmukham Pujari.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Aditya Krishna, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Shrirang B. Varma.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Manoj Misra, J.
1. Leave granted.
938 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. This appeal arises from a judgment and order of the High Court 1 , dated 25.10.2024, in Criminal Appeal Nos. 449 of 2023 and 457 of 2024, whereby the appeals filed by the appellant and another, against the order of conviction and sentence dated 29.04.2023 of the Trial Court 2 in Special Sessions Trial No. 34 of 2020, were partly allowed, the order of conviction was set aside and the case was remanded to the Trial Court for a re-trial coupled with a direction that the accused shall stand remanded to judicial custody.
Facts
3. Appellant and three others were tried for offences punishable under Section 8(c) read with Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 3 . Prosecution case is based on a search and seizure operation leading to recovery of contraband (i.e., Ganja). It is alleged that on receipt of information that accused No. 1 - Kailas (the appellant) and accused No. 2 – Raju Motiram Solanke have stocked Ganja for sale in a hut, after entering the information in the Diary, sending information to senior officer vide written letter (Exh. No.69) and seeking permission (Exh. No.70), a raid was organized after arranging two panch witnesses, a photographer, a gazetted officer and a weighing scale. The hut was located. Two persons, namely, accused nos.1 and 2, were found sitting there. After necessary formalities, the hut was searched. Upon search, in the presence of panchas, 18 plastic packets, kept in a sack, containing Ganja, weighing 39 kilograms, were recovered; from which samples were drawn and sealed. On disclosure by the aforesaid two accused, complicity of accused No.3 came to light. Thereafter, raid was conducted at the residence of accused No. 3, who was not found present. However, during house search, five sacks with packets containing Ganja, weighing 107.90 kilogram, were recovered. When accused No. 3 was arrested, complicity of accused No. 4 came to light as the person who transported the contraband.
4. After investigation all four were charge-sheeted and tried. During trial, prosecution examined seven witnesses, namely, S.W. No. 1 – Vinayak 1 The High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Nagpur Bench, Nagpur 2 Additional Sessions Judge Akot, District Akola 3 NDPS Act [2025] 9 S.C.R. 939Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra Rajabhau Shinde i.e., witness of spot and seizure panchnama; S.W. No. 2 – Santosh Ashok Solanke i.e., photographer who took video as well as photographs of the raid proceedings; S.W. No. 3 – Sajid Khan Rajulla Khan i.e., person who weighed the contraband; S.W. No. 4 – Gopal Ukhardu Patil i.e., one of the members of the raiding party; S.W. No. 5 – Mohammed Umar Anisoddin i.e., panch witness of seizure panchnama of accused no.4’s vehicle, who was declared hostile; S.W. No. 6 – Gopalsingh Narsingh Daberao i.e., driver-cum- Police Constable, who took Ganja samples to forensic laboratory, Amravati for chemical analysis; and S.W. No. 7 – Sagar Ashokrao Hatwar i.e., Chief of the raiding party.
5. Trial Court convicted accused Nos.1 and 2 and acquitted the other two accused.
6. In its judgment, the Trial Court, inter alia, relied on the video recording of the raid to corroborate the substantive evidence led during trial. Relevant observations qua appreciation of evidence including the video recording are found in paragraphs 40 to 48 of the judgment, which are reproduced below:
“40. Santosh (SW No.2) has stated in his examination in chief that, he himself videographed the entire procedure and he himself made the compact disc of the said video film. He also personally gave the necessary certificate to the police in that behalf. He has included all the technical details in the said certificate. It is the same certificate as Exh. No.32.
41. The certificate on Exh. No.32 is given by Santosh (SW No.2). That is, of course as per section 65 B (4) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. In the said certificate Santosh (SW No.2) has mentioned the entire details such as the business of photography the witness is involved in, the camera he uses for that purpose, its particulars such as Sony company camera model number 450 H.D. camera etc and he has proven the certificate that he has issued personally (Exh. 32) on all the legal and technical criteria.
42. The video film of the proceedings of the raid conducted by the police and its compact disc made by Santosh (S.W. No. 2) is produced in the court and it was seen in the 940 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports court on the laptop by the court (myself), the concerned clerk, the learned counsels for the accused, the learned counsels for the prosecution and all the accused. The said compact disc is assigned property No.27. There is no dispute regarding the video film in the said compact disc raised by the defense. This important fact is to be taken into consideration and kept in our collective conscious (sic).
43. All of us saw when the said CD was played in this court that the panch witnesses, police officers, staff members, the weighing scale operator, sub-divisional officer, both the accused No.1, Kailas, No. 2 Raju could be seen in the video film (i.e., in the video shooting in the CD) in the compact disc marked as property No.27.
44. There is no reason whatsoever to take any doubt regarding the veracity of the video film in the said property No.27. There is no place whatsoever to raise any doubt regarding the reliability of Santosh No.2 doing the video shooting. There is also no reason whatsoever to raise any doubts regarding this certificate exhibit No.32 issued as per section 65-B (4) of the Indian Evidence Act 1872. No one has raised any dispute whatsoever in the recognition or identification of the panch witnesses, police officials, staff members, accused seen in the said video hence all these facts stand proven.
45. In this way the originally reliable contentions made in the oral statements and examination in chief by all the witnesses such as Vinayak (SW No.1), Santosh (SW No.2), Sajid Khan (SW No.3), Gopal (SW No.4) and Shri Hatkar (SW No.7) that, on the date, time and place of occurrence the accused No.1, Kailas, and accused No.2, Raju, were found in possession of Ganja weighing 39 kilograms are strongly and undisputedly supported by the video film and photographs in the compact disc of property No.27 on record of the court. There is no reason whatsoever to refute the said proofs. As mentioned earlier the said video film in the said CD has also not been contested on behalf of the accused No.1 and 2.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 941Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra
46. In the said video film and in some still photographs (i.e., in the photographs in exhibit No.36, 37, 38 on record of this court) an unknown person in yellow T-shirt and who has dyed his color can be seen. The learned counsel Shri Sharma for the accused No.1 and 2 attempted to create a big controversy during the cross examination of the witnesses in that behalf.
47. All the witnesses have clearly dismissed the suggestions made by the learned counsel for the accused number 1 and 2 to the witnesses in their cross examination that the Hut behind the Mari Mata temple at Adgaon is owned by the unknown person in those photographs and the Ganja also belongs to him. Shri Hatwar (S.W. No.7) has clearly stated in his cross examination (Exh. No.61), page No.14, Para No.67) that the person wearing the yellow T-shirt is the associate of the weighing scale operator Sajid Khan (SW No.3).
48. It is quite possible that some bystanders, overzealous persons then enter as intruders while any such proceedings are in progress. Just because he was seen in one of such photographs and in some part of the video film, the cogent, reliable and undisputed proof of all the remaining witnesses, public prosecution does not and should not get nullified. The identification of the unknown person seen in the said photograph and the video film is not the point of contention in this case. It is unnecessary and irrelevant, and it is not sufficient at all to nullify all the other reliable evidence produced by the prosecution.”
(Emphasis supplied)
7. Aggrieved by Trial Court’s judgment and order, the two convicts filed criminal appeals before the High Court. Criminal Appeal No. 449 of 2023 was by the appellant whereas the other i.e., Criminal Appeal No. 457 of 2024, was by Raju Motiram Solanke.
8. The High Court partly allowed the appeals, set aside the conviction and sentence, however, remanded the matter for a re-trial with a direction that the accused shall stand remanded to judicial custody. Aggrieved by the direction for a re-trial with judicial remand, this appeal has been filed.
942 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports High Court’s observations
9. The reasons for which High Court directed a re-trial can be found in paragraphs 12 to 19 of its judgment, reproduced below: “12. It is to be noted that the entire process of raid at the hut as well as at the house of Shatrughna was video recorded with the help of the photographer. The photographer has been examined. Panch witness has supported the case of the prosecution. PW-1 Vinayak Shinde, the panch witness, has deposed in great detail about the raid, search, seizure and sampling. He has stated that, in his presence, the entire process was video recorded by the photographer. PW-2 Santosh Solanke is the photographer. He has deposed about the video recording of the entire process of search, seizure, sampling and apprehension of the appellant. PW-7 Sagar Hatwar, the investigating officer, has deposed in his evidence that the entire process of the raid was videographed. The CD of the video recording is at Exh. 27. In this context, it would be necessary to consider the evidence of the photographer (PW-2). At Para No. 7, he has stated that on last date the CD was played on the computer of the Court by the clerk. The APP and the Advocates for the appellants had seen the recording. Perusal of the evidence of all the witnesses does not show that the learned Judge, while recording their evidence, had played the CD in the Court and personally saw it.”
13. In this background, it is necessary to consider the observations made by the learned Judge in his judgment. Para No. 42 would be relevant. Learned Judge has noted that he had personally seen the video recording. Similarly, it was seen by the concerned clerk, APP and the advocates for the appellants. Learned Judge has noted that the advocates for the appellants had no dispute about the contents of the CD. In my view, this observation is against the appellants. It is to be noted that the CD has been admitted in the evidence. It is marked as Exh. 27. The question is whether the evidence adduced before the Court is sufficient to prove the contents of the CD or not. If the Court comes to the conclusion that this evidence is [2025] 9 S.C.R. 943Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra not sufficient to prove the contents, then the question is as to how the same could be used against the appellant.”
14. It is to be noted that we are in the era of technology. The technology is now being used for the purpose of investigation. This is a good sign for the criminal justice administration. Electronic evidence collected with the assistance of the technology, which may be audio recording, video recording, photography or the data from the memory card, cannot be admitted in the evidence as it is. Before such material is admitted as an evidence, proper care and procedure is required to be followed. Such material has to be converted into a legally admissible evidence. The law prescribes the procedure. The prosecutor, the presiding officer and the advocates must be well versed with the procedure, while recording the evidence of the witness with regard to the contents of the video recording or CCTV footage. If there is a lack of procedural knowledge to convert such material into legally admissible evidence collected during the course of investigation, then the very purpose of the video recording or collection of the CCTV footage capturing the incident will be frustrated. The video recording or CCTV footage without proper evidence to prove the contents of the video recording cannot be made use of against the accused. It needs to be stated that with the advent of technology and use of the technology during the investigation, all concerned are required to keep themselves abreast with the law and procedure. A great care is required to be taken while recording the evidence when such electronic evidence is produced before the court. It is the duty of the court and other stakeholders to see that it is converted into legally admissible evidence. If there is a failure on the part of the prosecutor and the presiding officer, on account of some misconception related to the subject, then it can cause miscarriage of justice. It needs to be stated that in this case on account of procedural error, apparent lacuna has crept in, and which has resulted in miscarriage of justice. It has caused prejudice not only to the appellant but to the prosecution as well. It needs to be mentioned that in 944 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports this case, on this count, there is an imminent flaw, which has caused prejudice not only to the appellants but to the prosecution as well.
15. It is to be noted that the video recording of the entire process was the best evidence in the possession of the prosecution. The question that was required to be addressed by the learned Judge while recording such evidence was as to how it has to be converted into legally admissible evidence. The learned Judge and the learned prosecutor have committed a procedural error. The proper procedure has not been followed. In this case, the main witnesses are the panch witnesses, the photographer, other members of the raiding party and the investigating officer. If the evidence consists of a video recording of the particular incident or part of the incident, the recorded incident must be proved through the concerned witness. As far as the video recording or recorded CCTV footage is concerned, the witness who is an eyewitness to the incident or acted as a panch witness or in the other capacity, must describe the incident on oath before the Court. In such a case, at the time of recording the evidence of the concerned witness, the video recording, either recorded in the CD or pen drive or any other electronic gadget, must be played on the screen. The witness, after playing the CD, must describe or translate the video recording or the contents of the recording in his own words on oath before the Court. If it is an audio recording, then the part of the audible conversation must be transcribed and placed on record under the signature of the investigating officer. Unless and until the recorded video or CCTV footage is played at the stage of evidence of the witness, the witness would not be able to describe or narrate the incident in his or her own words on oath before the Court. In this way, at the stage of recording of evidence, each and every witness concerned with the video recording of the incident or any part of the incident must describe or narrate the incident in his or her own words on oath before the Court. If it is not so done, then it would be very difficult to understand or read that video recording by the [2025] 9 S.C.R. 945Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra presiding officer, prosecutor or Advocate. This procedure has to be scrupulously followed. This has not happened in this case. The CD was not played while recording the evidence of the panch witnesses, the photographer, the other members of the raiding party and the investigating officer. It is therefore apparent that the legally admissible evidence as to the contents of the recording/CD has not at all been recorded.
16. The CD is a part of the record. At the stage of the arguments in these appeals, the CD was played in the Court. It is evident that the video recording commenced with the apprehension of the appellant. The CD contains the recording of the inspection of hut, recovery of the substance, the description of the substance and further part of the proceedings. The CD further contains the recording of the raid and recovery at the house of Shatrughna. The learned Judge was required to play the CD at the time of recording evidence of each witness and record the contents appearing on the screen with the help of the concerned witness. If this procedure had been followed, then the contents of the CD would have become legally admissible evidence. This procedure had not been followed. This has caused prejudice to the appellants as well as to the prosecution. The important evidence collected in the form of the video recording has not been converted into legally admissible evidence. In order to verify the correct factual position, at the stage of the argument of the appeals, the video recording was played. It was very difficult to understand the contents of the CD. If the evidence of the witnesses had been recorded on playing the video recording at the time of the evidence, then the oral testimony of the witnesses on oath, as to the contents of the CD would have been part of the record.
17. It is evident that in this case the detailed description of the Ganja has not been recorded in the panchnama.
Similarly, the detailed description of the Ganja has not been stated by the witnesses. The substance seized from the possession of the appellant can be seen from the video recording. It was necessary to show this part of the 946 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports recording to the witnesses and record the description of the substance in detail through each and every witness. In my view, this is a fundamental flaw in this case. The appellants could not be held responsible for this mistake or rather a mess. It was the responsibility of the learned prosecutor to insist before the learned Judge to play the CD when the witnesses were in the witness box. It was not done by the learned Prosecutor/In-charge of the case. Similarly, the learned Judge did not follow this procedure scrupulously. It seems that the learned Judge did not act diligently while recording the evidence of the witnesses with regard to the incident or a part of the incident videographed by the investigating officer. Learned Judge has observed in his judgment that there was no objection as such on the part of the appellants to this CD. In my view, this observation is totally perverse. This observation is not only against the appellants, but it is also against the prosecution. In this case, the required evidence as to the contents of the video recording or CD has not been properly recorded. There is a procedural error. It was the duty of the Court to give justice to the hard work put in by the police officer, while conducting the raid and ensuring the video recording of the entire proceedings. The video recording is the most important and vital evidence in this case. It can reflect upon the credibility and authenticity of the raid. Similarly, the description of the substance, which can be seen from the video recording, would be of immense importance. It cannot be excluded from consideration, if it is proved properly. This is one flaw in this case. It has caused prejudice to the appellants as well as to the prosecution.
18. The next important flaw which can be seen is the failure of the prosecution to examine the CA. It is noticed that in the Vidarbha region, in the trials under the NDPS Act, the CA is not examined. In my view, this is a serious mistake on the part of the prosecution. It needs to be placed on record that in Greater Mumbai, in every case under the NDPS Act, the CA is examined. In Vidarbha region, while deciding the appeals against the conviction and sentence in NDPS cases, it is noticed that this aspect is taken for [2025] 9 S.C.R. 947Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra granted by the prosecution. It needs to be stated that in Vidarbha region, the majority of the cases under the NDPS Act are with regard to the seizure of the Ganja.
The examination of the CA, in the case of the analysis of Ganja, is very important because, in the report of the CA the description of the substance in detail is recorded invariably. The description of the substance, seized as Ganja, is required to be proved to bring it within the ambit of the definition of Ganja under Section 2(iii)(b) of the NDPS Act. In this case, the prosecution has failed to examine the CA. In this case, the learned prosecutor did not produce remnant samples received from the office of CA. Similarly, the prosecutor did not produce the representative samples drawn at the time of the seizure on the spot as well as drawn in presence of the learned Magistrate at the time of the inventory. The remnant samples are required to be shown to the CA to bring on record the nature of the narcotic drug and the description of the drugs. Similarly, the representative samples are required to be opened before the Court at the time of the evidence of the concerned witness. The presiding officer is required to note down the description of the narcotic drug/substance found in the sample packets. It is further pertinent to mention that if the seized drug is not destroyed, then the same shall also be produced before the Court while recording the evidence of the witness. The description of the substance found in the packets/sacks shall also be recorded. The learned presiding officer is required to record this part of the evidence very meticulously and note down the description of substance.
19. I am conscious of the fact that under Section 293 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the reports of certain Government scientific experts may be used as evidence in an inquiry, trial or other proceedings. The record shows that no specific order was passed by the learned Judge, while admitting the CA report. It is to be noted that, in cases under the NDPS Act, as and when a CA report is tendered, the Court shall insist the prosecutor to examine 948 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the CA. If the CA is available, then the learned Judge shall not exhibit the report without examining the CA. The trial of the offences under the NDPS Act cannot be taken lightly. The trial for the offences under the NDPS Act has to be conducted very carefully. It needs to be mentioned that in such a trial, the Court has to deal with so many technical aspects and issues. The NDPS Act provides for checks and balances while conducting the investigation in the crime so as to avoid false implication of innocent persons. The act provides for stringent punishment for a proved offence. Therefore, the Court has to be very careful while recording the evidence. In this case, the required care was not taken.”
10. After the above discussion, the High Court proceeded to consider whether a re-trial of the case would be necessary and, in Paragraph 26, the High Court opined that re-trial is necessary. Paragraph 26 of the impugned judgment is extracted below:
“26. It is to be noted that in this case, for the purpose of proving the contents of the CD, the recall of all the witnesses would be necessary. The witnesses were the members of the raiding party. Each and every witness would be required to describe /translate the contents of the CD/video recording. Similarly, the prosecution would be required to examine the CA. Therefore, in this case, the option of recording additional evidence may not be appropriate. Even after recording the additional evidence, the further procedure with regard to the recording of 313 statement of the accused would be required to be gone into. In this case, in my view, the re-trial would be the best option in the interest of the appellants as well as the prosecution. In the facts and circumstances, in this case, I am opting to order a re-trial.”
11. Having held that re-trial is necessary the High Court set aside the Trial Court judgment and ordered re-trial of accused nos.1 and 2. However, since there was no appeal against acquittal of accused nos.3 and 4, the High Court observed that accused nos. 3 and 4 shall not have to face re-trial.
12. Aggrieved by the direction for holding a re-trial, one of the accused, namely, Kailas, is in appeal before us.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 949Kailas S/o Bajirao Pawar v. The State of Maharashtra Submissions on behalf of the Appellant
13. On behalf of the appellant, it is submitted that a re-trial can be directed in exceptional circumstances as laid down by a Constitution Bench of this Court in Ukha Kolhe versus State of Maharashtra4 , which has been consistently followed, and recently followed by a three Judge Bench of this Court in Nasib Singh versus State of Punjab and Another 5. Relying on the aforesaid decisions, it was urged that re-trial is not to be ordered just to enable the prosecution to lead evidence which it could but did not care to lead either on account of insufficient appreciation of the nature of the case or for other reasons. It was urged that if the High Court was not satisfied with the prosecution’s evidence on record, the appropriate course for the High Court was to order acquittal of the appellant. Accordingly, it is urged that the order of the High Court directing for a re-trial be set aside and the appellant be acquitted.
Submissions on behalf of Respondent-State
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.