Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 920; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1289
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 26 Nov 2024
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 10169/2008
- Sections
- 16, 55, 22, 10, 55(1), 20, 17, 28
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1289 : 2024 INSC 920 Rohit Kochhar v.
Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors.
(Special Leave Petition(Civil) No(s). 10169-10171 of 2008) 26 November 2024 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the relief sought by the plaintiff in respect to the suit property can be entirely obtained through the personal obedience of the defendants warranting the application of the proviso to Section 16 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
Headnotes† Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Proviso to s.16 – When not applicable – Suit for specific performance of the contract in respect of the suit property situated in Gurugram, filed in the Delhi High Court – Single Judge held that the suit was maintainable in view of proviso to s.16 – Appeals filed by the defendants were allowed by Division Bench, plaint was directed to be returned to the plaintiff to present it before the appropriate court having territorial jurisdiction to try the suit for specific performance – Correctness:
Held: No error committed by High Court in passing the impugned orders – s.16 deals with territorial jurisdiction of the courts and inter alia provides that suits for recovery, partition, foreclosure, for determination of any other right or interest in immovable property are to be instituted in the court within whose jurisdiction the property is situate – The proviso to s.16 however, provides that a suit to obtain relief respecting, or compensation for wrong to, immovable property held by or on behalf of the defendant, may where the relief sought can be entirely obtained through his personal obedience be instituted either in the Court within whose jurisdiction the property is situate, or in the Court within whose jurisdiction the defendant resides, or carries on business, or personally works for gain – A suit for specific performance and delivery of possession is covered under clause
(d) to s.16 and thus the parties, even by agreement, cannot confer territorial jurisdiction on a court within whose territory the subject 1290 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports matter is not situated – Proviso to s.16 would be applicable to a case where the relief sought by the plaintiff can be obtained through the personal obedience of the defendant, that is, the defendant has not to go out of the jurisdiction of the court at all for the purpose of the grant of relief – However, since the present case would require the defendants to go to Gurugram for the purpose of execution of the sale deed, hence the proviso to s.16 will not be applicable – Further, it is clear from the terms of the alleged contract between the parties that the transfer of possession of the suit property is implicit in the said contract and absence of a specific prayer seeking transfer of possession would not have any bearing on the character of the suit, which is one covered by s.16(d) – Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – s.55. [Paras 13, 18, 21, 33] Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.22 – Import of – Discussed. [Paras 22-30] Case Law Cited Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd. v. Daulat and Another [2001] Supp. 3 SCR 29 : (2001) 7 SCC 698; Babu Lal v. Hazari Lal Kishori Lal and Others [1982] 3 SCR 94 : (1982) 3 SCR 94; Harshad Chiman Lal Modi v. DLF Universal Ltd. [2005] Supp. 3 SCR 495 : (2005) 7 SCC 791; Babasaheb Dhondiba Kute v. Radhu Vithoba Barde, 2024 INSC 122; Excel Dealcomm (P) Ltd. v. Asset Reconstruction Co. (India) Ltd. [2015] 4 SCR 948 : (2015) 8 SCC 219 – referred to. P.M.A. Velliappa Chettiar v. Saha Govinda Doss AIR 1929 Mad 721 – referred to.
Messrs. Moolji Jaitha and Co. v. Khandesh Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. AIR 1950 FC 83 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1980; Specific Relief Act, 1963 List of Keywords Suit for specific performance; Suit property situated in Gurgaon/ Gurugram, Suit filed in Delhi High Court; Territorial jurisdiction; To try the suit; Local limits; Court within whose jurisdiction the property is situate, Court within whose jurisdiction the defendant actually and voluntarily resides, carries on business, or personally [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1291Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors. works for gain; Personal obedience of the defendants; Delivery of possession; Court within whose territory the subject matter is not situated; Transfer of possession of the suit property; Absence of specific prayer seeking transfer of possession; Character of the suit; Plaint returned to be presented before the court of competent jurisdiction; willingness and readiness; Flat Buyers Agreement; Immovable property; in rem; in personam; Maxim “equity acts in personam.”
Case Arising From EXTRAORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No(s). 10169-10171 of 2008 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.03.2008 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in FAO Nos. 196, 197 and 205 of 2005 Appearances for Parties Kunal Verma, Somiron Borkataky, Ms. Yugandhara Pawar Jha, Ishvaaku Marwah, Saurav Kumar, Ms. Lavanya Dhawan, Ms. Yasha Goyal, Advs. for the Petitioner.
Ankit Virmani, Ajit Pudussery, Krishen Tewary, Ms. Ruchika Agarwala, Ashutosh Bamezai, Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Manish Sharma, Vyom Raghuvanshi, Ninad Dogra, Adya Rao, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. These petitions arise from a common order passed by a Division Bench of the High Court of Delhi dated 11.03.2008 in FAO(OS) Nos.196-197/2005 and FAO(OS) No.205/2005 respectively, by which the appeals filed by the respondents herein came to be allowed and the plaint was ordered to be returned to the petitioner herein for presenting it before the appropriate court having territorial jurisdiction to try the suit for specific performance.
2. The petitioner herein, who is the original plaintiff, instituted Civil Suit No.1138/2004 in the Delhi High Court on its original side for permanent injunction and specific performance of the contract dated 1292 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 16/20.01.2004 entered into with the respondents herein, the original defendants, in connection with a commercial property admeasuring 10,747 sq. ft. situated on the second floor of the Fortune Global Hotel & Commercial Complex in Gurgaon (“suit property”).
3. It is the case of the plaintiff that sometime in September 2003, the original defendant no. 2 offered to sell to it commercial space of approximately 10,000 sq. ft. on the second floor of the commercial complex of the Fortune Hotel and Commercial Complex project which was being developed by the defendants. After discussions and negotiations regarding the same, a written communication was received by the plaintiff on 16.01.2004 containing the aforesaid offer in relation to the suit property and the terms and conditions for the transaction.
4. The offer was accepted by the plaintiff vide letter dated 20.01.2004 and a cheque dated 20.01.2004 for Rs 20,000,00/- was issued by the plaintiff in favour of original defendant no. 3 in furtherance of the said acceptance. Further payment of Rs 20,000,00/- was made by the plaintiff on 06.02.2004.
5. Thereafter, disputes cropped up between the parties regarding certain terms contained in the “Flat Buyers Agreement”. It is the case of the plaintiff that despite several attempts on its part to negotiate the terms of the said agreement so as to arrive at a settlement, the defendants insisted upon unreasonable, arbitrary and unconscionable terms with a view to wriggle out of their liability arising out of the binding contract dated 16/20.01.2004.
6. Aggrieved by the defendant’s alleged refusal to honour the binding contract despite the expression of willingness and readiness by the plaintiff on multiple occasions, the plaintiff instituted the aforesaid suit for specific performance and permanent injunction.
7. The defendants in their written statements, inter alia, raised a preliminary objection as regards the territorial jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court to entertain the suit instituted by the plaintiff. The defendants submitted that there was no concluded and binding contract between the parties and the letters dated 16.01.2004 and 20.01.2004 respectively were only a part of the ongoing discussion and negotiations between the parties in relation to the suit property. The letter dated 16.01.2004 was only a letter of intent and was to be followed by a property buyer agreement to be signed by the plaintiff [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1293Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors. which would contain detailed terms and conditions regarding the sale of the suit property. Further, in the alternative, the defendants submitted that the plaintiff failed to show his readiness and willingness to pay the balance amount at any point in time and thus cannot seek specific performance of the contract.
8. The learned Single Judge vide its order dated 25.04.2005 overruled the objection raised by the defendants as regards the territorial jurisdiction and took the view that it had the jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The Court took the view that as the plaintiff was seeking the relief of specific performance simpliciter and had not prayed for a decree to put him in possession of the suit property, such a relief could be granted and enforced by the personal obedience of the vendor and thus the Court in whose territorial jurisdiction the vendor resides or carries on business or works for gain would have the jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
9. Placing reliance on the decision of this Court in Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd. v. Daulat and Another reported in (2001) 7 SCC 698, the Single Judge drew a distinction between a suit relating to specific performance of a contract for sale of immovable property simpliciter and a suit where additional claim for delivery is prayed for, and observed that a suit of the former category, that is, one for the enforcement of contract of sale and for execution of a conveyance, cannot be said to be a suit for determination of title to land or that the decree in it would operate on the land. The Court further observed that Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act has been specifically held to be an enabling provision by the decision in Adcon Electronics (supra) and thus the observations made by this Court in Babu Lal v. Hazari Lal Kishori Lal and Others reported in (1982) 3 SCR 94 would not be applicable to the facts of the present case as the issue has been directly answered by the decision in Adcon Electronics (supra). The relevant observations made by the Single Judge are extracted hereinbelow:
“28. I need not, therefore, deal with the various decisions of this Court and other High Courts relied upon by Counsel for the defendants for the reason that the decision of the Supreme Court in Adcon Electronic’s case (supra) holds the field. The said decision has taken into account Section 22 1294 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of the Specific Relief Act. Decision categorically holds that a suit seeking specific performance of an agreement to sell simplicitor even if it relates to immovable property is not a suit in which the relief claimed relates to title or to land. The suit is for enforcement of terms of contract. Decision categorically holds that it is at the option of the plaintiff to seek delivery of possession. Decision categorically holds that unless possession of immovable property is specifically prayed for, suit could be instituted within the local limits of the Court having jurisdiction where the defendant resides, carries on business or personally works for gain.
29.Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act is also an enabling provision and need not be enforced by the buyer.
30. In respect of the submission made by Counsel for the defendants Pertaining to the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the point that the rule is directed to secure the exhaustion of the reliefs in respect of a cause of action and not to the inclusion in one and the same action, different causes of action, even though they arise from the same transaction (see decision of Privy Counsel reported as 26 IC 228, Payana v. Panna Lal) has been lost sight of by Counsel.
31. Order 2 Rule 2 is aimed against multiplicity of the suits in respect of same cause of action. Complete identity of cause of action and various reliefs flowing therefrom has not to be confused with various causes of action which may accrue under same transaction.
32. A vendee may be happy to gain title to immovable property at the pains of the vendor having lost title and since possession was pursuant to title, being labelled as an unauthorised occupant if after execution of sale deed and possession being required to the delivered refuses to do so. In such eventuality, the vendor would be liable to pay damages/mesne profits for unauthorised occupation.
This would be an entirely separate cause of action postexecution of the sale deed.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1295Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors.
33. I accordingly decide the objection raised by the defendants against them. It is held that this Court has jurisdiction to entertain the suit.”
10. The defendants, being aggrieved by the order passed by the learned Single Judge, preferred three appeals before a Division Bench of the High Court under Section 10 of the Delhi High Court Act, 1966.
11. The Division Bench of the High Court allowed the appeals and ordered the plaint to be returned to the plaintiff in accordance with law so as to be presented before the court of competent jurisdiction.
12. The Division Bench of the High Court in its impugned order took into consideration the provisions of Section 16 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 as also Section 55 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and recorded the following findings:- “18. In the present case, it is an admitted position that the appellant had entered into the aforesaid alleged contract at its Corporate office at Delhi. It is the specific stand of the appellant that they were initially residents of Delhi and that they had moved to Gurgaon and their corporate office is now also located at Gurgaon. It is the contention of the counsel appearing for the respondents that the proviso to Section 16 of Code of Civil Procedure is applicable which is sought to be invoked, for, the relief which is sought for could be entirely enforced through the personal obedience of the defendants in Delhi. There is however not only a prayer in the plaint for declaration of the right and title, but also to transfer the right, title and interest in the suit premises situate at Gurgaon. As, in our opinion, the suit can be decreed in favour of the plaintiff only when the Court can get the sale deed executed and registered in favour of the plaintiff which would confer the title of the suit premises on the plaintiff, and the execution and the registration of the sale document would have to take place at Gurgaon and, for this the Court will also have to pass a decree directing the defendant to get the sale deed executed and registered at Gurgaon, implication of the same will be that a direction will have to be given to the defendant 1296 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports that he shall have to move out of Delhi and go to Gurgaon and get the same registered. No sale deed is sought to be registered at Delhi and, therefore, in our considered opinion such a relief cannot be entirely obtained through the personal obedience of the defendant, who in this case has to go to the jurisdiction of another court to get the decree executed and the sale deed registered.
19. Accordingly, we are of the considered opinion that the submissions of the learned counsel for the respondent and the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge that the present case is covered by the proviso of Section 16 of the Code of Civil Procedure are misplaced. In the facts and circumstances of the case as delineated, the relief in the present suit cannot be entirely obtained through the personal obedience of the defendants. The proviso to Section 16 of the Code of Civil Procedure would be applicable to a case where the relief sought for by the plaintiff was entirely obtainable through the personal obedience of the defendant, i.e., the defendant has not at all to go out of the jurisdiction of the Court for the aforesaid purpose. The present case is not a case of the aforesaid nature. In the present case for execution of the sale deed the defendants will have to go out of the jurisdiction of this Court and get the same executed and registered in Gurgaon.
20. In the present case also it is an admitted position that possession of the said property was with the seller and, therefore, in terms of the provisions of Section 55(1) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the relief of possession is inherent in the relief of specific performance of the contract. In our considered opinion the ratio of the decision of the Supreme Court in Babu Lal(supra) and the principles laid down in the case of Harshad Chiman Lal Modi (supra) are applicable to the facts of the present case. In Harshad Chiman Lal Modi (supra) it was found that in addition to passing decree, the court was also required to deliver possession of the property. It was held that such a relief can be granted only by sending the concerned person [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1297Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors. responsible for delivery of possession to Gurgaon and the court at Delhi does not have the jurisdiction to get the aforesaid decree enforced for the property situate outside territorial jurisdiction of Delhi High Court. The Court while referring to the provisions of Section 16 of the CPC held that the location of institution of a suit would be guided by the location of the property in respect of which and for determination of any right or interest whereof the suit is instituted. The proviso to Section 16 CPC is also not applicable to the case, as the relief sought for cannot be entirely granted or obtained through the personal obedience of the respondent.
21. The decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Adcon Electronics Pvt. Ltd. v. Daulat and Another (2001) 7 SCC 698, relied upon by the respondents, would also not be applicable to the facts of the present case. The said decision was rendered in the context of the expression “suit for land”. The Supreme Court in the said decision held that suit for specific performance of an agreement for sale of the suit property, without a claim for delivery of possession, cannot be treated as a “suit for land” and is, therefore, triable under clause 12 if the other conditions thereunder are fulfilled. The facts of the said case are, therefore, distinguishable and are not applicable to the case in hand. The said decision was rendered due to specific provision therein and it is also apparent from the fact that the case of Babu Lal(supra) was not even referred to in that case.
22. Another decision of the Supreme Court which needs reference at this stage is the case of Begum Sabiha Sultan v. Nawab Mohd. Mansur Ali Khan and others (2007) 4 SCC 343. In para 12 of the said judgment it was held by the Supreme Court that reading the plaint as a whole in this case, there cannot be much doubt that the suit is essentially in relation to the relief of partition and declaration in respect of the properties situate in Village Pataudi, Gurgaon, outside the jurisdiction of court at Delhi. In that view of the matter it was also held that the Delhi Court will have no jurisdiction to try and decide the aforesaid 1298 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports suit. It was also held in the said decision by following the decision of Harshad Chiman Lal Modi (supra) that the relief of partition, accounting and declaration of invalidity of the sale executed in respect of immovable propertied situated situate in village Pataudi, Gurgaon could not entirely be obtained by personal obedience to the decree by the defendants in the suit. It was further held that applying the test laid down therein, it is clear that the present suit could not be brought within the purview of the Section 16 of the Code or entertained relying on Section 20 of the Code on the basis that three out of the five defendants are residing within the jurisdiction of the court at Delhi.
23. In view of the above facts and circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that the Delhi court would not have the territorial jurisdiction to entertain and decide the aforesaid suits. Consequently, we hold that the decision rendered by the learned Single judge cannot be upheld.
The same is accordingly set aside and quashed.
24. The appeals are allowed accordingly, the plaint be returned to the plaintiff in accordance with law.”
13. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, we are of the view that no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned orders.
14. Section 16 of the CPC deals with territorial jurisdiction of the courts and provides that suits for recovery or partition of immovable property or for foreclosure, sale or redemption in the case of a mortgage of or charge upon immovable property or for determination of any other right to or interest in immovable property, or for compensation for wrong to immovable property, or for recovery of movable property actually under distraint or attachment, shall be instituted in the court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the property is situate. Further, the proviso provides that a suit to obtain relief respecting, or compensation for wrong to, immovable property held by or on behalf of the defendant, may where the relief sought can be entirely obtained through his personal obedience be instituted either in the Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the property is situate, or in the Court within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1299Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. & Ors. defendant actually and voluntarily resides, or carries on business, or personally works for gain.
15. Thus, the pivotal question before us is whether the relief being sought by the plaintiff in respect to the suit property can be entirely obtained through the personal obedience of the defendants. If yes, then the facts of the present case would warrant the application of the proviso to Section 16 of the CPC and the High Court on its original side would be competent to entertain the suit instituted by the plaintiff.
16. This Court in Harshad Chiman Lal Modi v. DLF Universal Ltd. reported in (2005) 7 SCC 791 observed that Section 16 of the CPC recognises a well-established principle that actions against res or property should be brought in the forum where such res is situate. A court within whose territorial jurisdiction the property is not situate has no power to deal with and decide the rights or interests in such property. In other words, this Court held that a court has no jurisdiction over a dispute in which it cannot give an effective judgment.
17. On the proviso to Section 16, the Court observed that the proviso, no doubt, states that though the court cannot, in case of immovable property situate beyond jurisdiction, grant a relief in rem still it can entertain a suit where relief sought can be obtained through the personal obedience of the defendant. The proviso is based on a wellknown maxim “equity acts in personam”, recognised by the Chancery Courts in England. The Equity Courts had jurisdiction to entertain certain suits relating to immovable properties situated abroad through personal obedience of the defendant. The Court observed that the principle on which the maxim was based was that the courts could grant relief in suits relating to immovable property situated abroad by enforcing their judgments by process in personam i.e., by arrest of the defendant or by attachment of his property.
18. The Court held that a suit for specific performance and delivery of possession was covered under clause (d) to Section 16 of the CPC and thus the parties, even by agreement, cannot confer territorial jurisdiction on a court within whose territory the subject matter is not situated.
19. Recently, this Court in Babasaheb Dhondiba Kute v. Radhu Vithoba Barde reported in 2024 INSC 122 held that the conveyance by way of sale would take place only at the time of registration of a sale 1300 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports deed in accordance with Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908. Till the time of such registration, no conveyance could be said to have taken place.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.