Nisar Ahmad & Ors. v. Sami Ullah (Dead) Through LRs. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 820; [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1855
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 24 Oct 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9739/2011
- Sections
- 9(2), 11(1), 9, 48, 3, 3(2), 4, 3(5), 3(11), 1, 5(2), 7
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 1855 : 2024 INSC 820 Nisar Ahmad & Ors.
v.
Sami Ullah (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 9739-40 of 2011)
24 October 2024 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue as regards the shares of the parties in the disputed land. High Court whether justified in upholding the order passed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation in revision and holding that the appellants had 1/12 share jointly in the plots comprised in Khata Nos. 98 and 99 excluding plot Nos. 35, 37, 111 and 112 which exclusively belonged to the respondents. Consolidation authorities whether erred in alloting 1/2 share to the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants. Headnotes† Uttar Pradesh Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953 – ss.9(2), 11(1) – High Court held that the appellants had 1/12 share jointly in the plots comprised in Khata Nos. 98 and 99 excluding plot Nos. 35, 37, 111 and 112 exclusively belonging to the respondents – It also held that the consolidation authorities erroneously alloted 1/2 share to the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants on the premise that the land was a joint family property:
Held: No error or perversity in the view taken by the High Court – The concept of joint family property which is prevalent amongst the Hindus is not known amongst the Muslims – Authorities were not justified in importing principles of Hindu law while determining the share of the parties who were admittedly Mohammedans – High Court duly considered the claim of the appellants as well as of the respondents and held that in so far claim of the appellants to plot Nos. 35, 57, 111 and 112 of Khata No. 99 and plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100 were concerned, predecessor-in-interest of the appellants himself had relinquished those lands in favour of the respondents – Relinquishment deed was registered and was never questioned by the predecessor-in-interest of the appellants during his lifetime – Further, validity of the lease in question cannot be disputed by the appellants – High Court concurred with the finding * Author 1856 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports recorded by the revisional authority and rightly dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellants – Appellants entitled to 1/12 share in the land comprised in the lease deed and not 1/2 as was wrongly held by consolidation authorities. [Paras 22-24] Uttar Pradesh Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953 – Scheme of the Act – Stated.
Case Law Cited Attar Singh v. State of U.P [1959] Supp. 1 SCR 928 : AIR 1959 SC 564; Chandra v. Deputy Director of Consolidation, 2007 SCC OnLine All 2196 – referred to.
List of Acts Uttar Pradesh Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953; U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950.
List of Keywords Co-tenancy; Consolidation Officer; Deputy Director of Consolidation; Consolidation authorities; Assistant Settlement Officer; Revisional authority Shares of the parties; Common ancestor; Disputed land; Disputed khatas; Agricultural holdings; Consolidation of Holdings; Concept of joint family property not known amongst the Muslims; Hindu law; Mohammedans; Predecessor-in-interest; Relinquishment deed; Lease deed; Revision application/petitions; No error apparent on the face of record.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 9739-40 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.01.2009 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in WP No. 6635 of 1974 and CMWP No. 18 of 1975 With Contempt Petition (C) No. 194 of 2022 Appearances for Parties M.Z. Chaudhary, Shariq Zaidi, Aftab Ali Khan, Sayyad Mansoor, Ms. Mansi Chahal, Tabarak Hussain, Rahat Ali Chaudhary, Shoaid [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1857Nisar Ahmad & Ors. v. Sami Ullah (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. Ahmad Khan, Kapil Sagar, Aftab Ali Khan, Syed Mehdi Imam, Atif Shuhrawardy, Tabrez Ahmad, Pankaj Kumar, S.S. Chauhan, Atif Suhrawardy, Mrs. Shamama Anis, Pankaj Kumar, Sharad Chauhan, Advs. for the appearing parties.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. The two appeals by special leave are directed against the judgment and order dated 05.01.2009 passed by a Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 6635 of 1974 (Nisar Ahmad and Ors. Vs. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Sultanpur and Ors.) and in Writ Petition No.18 of 1975 (Sami Ullah and Anr. Vs. Nisar Ahmed and Ors.). By the aforesaid judgment and order dated 05.01.2009, Civil Misc. Writ Petition No.6635 of 1974 was dismissed and Writ Petition No.18 of 1975 has been allowed.
3. By order dated 27.04.2009, this Court had issued notice on the special leave petition as well as on the prayer for interim relief. Subsequently, by order dated 15.01.2010, both the parties were directed to maintain status quo prevailing as on 15.01.2010. Thereafter, by order dated 03.11.2011, leave was granted directing the status quo order to be continued in the meantime.
4. At the outset, it may be useful to make a brief reference to the relevant facts. Zahoor Ahmed, son of Abdul Shakoor, father of the appellants, had moved the Consolidation Officer, Sultanpur under Section 9(2) of the Uttar Pradesh Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953 (briefly ‘the 1953 Act’ hereinafter) raising a dispute as to Khata Nos. 99 and 100 of village Bhati Jarouli of Miranpur, District Sultanpur, U.P., recorded in the name of respondent Sami Ullah and others. Zahoor Ahmed claimed co-tenancy in both the Khatas to the extent of half share. Since the dispute could not be reconciled, he approached the Consolidation Officer. After notice and hearing, the Consolidation Officer passed an order dated 06.12.1972 directing that the name of Zahoor Ahmed be entered as a co-tenant in Khata No. 99 and accordingly partition be made. The shares of Sami Ullah and another (respondents herein) were determined to the extent of 1858 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 1/4 each. However, the claim of Zahoor Ahmed of co-tenancy qua Khata No. 100 was rejected. Accordingly, direction was issued to intimate the parties and to correct the areas of the land in respect of the parties so determined by the Consolidation Officer.
5. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order dated 06.12.1972, respondents Sami Ullah and others filed appeals before the Assistant Settlement Officer under Section 11(1) of the 1953 Act. Similarly, Zahoor Ahmed also filed an appeal under Section 11(1) of the 1953 Act against the said order dated 06.12.1972 rejecting his claim qua Khata No. 100. By order dated 25.04.1973, the appellate authority i.e. the Assistant Settlement Officer, Sultanpur dismissed all the appeals. In other words, order of the Consolidation Officer dated 06.12.1972 was upheld.
6. Thereafter, respondents Sami Ullah and others filed a revision application before the Deputy Director of Consolidation, Gorakhpur (‘Deputy Director’, hereinafter). Likewise, the legal heirs of Zahoor Ahmed, Nisar Ahmed and others (‘appellants’ herein) also filed revision before the Deputy Director against rejection of their appeal. By the order dated 20.09.1974, the Deputy Director opined that Zahoor Ahmed was not entitled to get share in the above Khatas and accordingly the order of the Consolidation Officer as affirmed by the Assistant Settlement Officer i.e. the appellate authority was modified. Deputy Director while dismissing the revision of Zahoor Ahmed, Nisar Ahmed and others allowed the revision of the respondent Sami Ullah and others.
7. Appellants thereafter preferred Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 6635 of 1974 before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (briefly ‘the High Court’ hereinafter). By the judgment and order dated 05.01.2009, the High Court held that Deputy Director was not justified in importing principles of Hindu law while determining the share of the parties who were admittedly Mohammedans. Accordingly, the High Court held that the appellants have 1/12 share jointly in the plots comprised in Khata Nos. 98 and 99 excluding plot Nos. 35, 37, 111 and 112 which exclusively belongs to the respondents Sami Ullah and his brother Badlu, sons of Abdul Ghafoor. Accordingly, Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 6635 of 1974 was dismissed and Writ Petition No. 18 of 1975 was allowed.
8. It is this judgment and order dated 05.01.2009 which came to be assailed in the related special leave petitions and upon leave being [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1859Nisar Ahmad & Ors. v. Sami Ullah (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. granted, the present civil appeals came to be registered.
9. While learned counsel for the appellants has contended that the High Court was not justified in upholding the order passed by the Deputy Director in revision thereby adversely affecting the rights of the parties, learned counsel for the respondents on the other hand supports the impugned order. He submits that the order of the High Court is a wellreasoned and balanced order and therefore should not be disturbed.
10. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
11. Zahoor Ahmed, the predecessor in interest of the appellants, had approached the Consolidation Officer under Section 9(2) of the 1953 Act raising a dispute regarding Khata Nos. 99 and 100. It may be mentioned that the Khata No. 99 was recorded in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu (the respondents) whereas Khata No. 100 was recorded in the name of Sami Ullah alone. Zahoor Ahmed claimed co-tenancy in both the Khatas to the extent of 1/2 share. He also claimed half share in Khata No. 100. Since the dispute could not be reconciled, the same was raised before the Consolidation Officer.
11.1. According to Zahoor Ahmed, the land in question were acquired by Mohammad and Abdul Ghafoor, father of Allah Bux, jointly for the benefit of the entire family. Thus, they were in joint occupation of the land. At the time of death of Allah Bux, Ghafoor was the ‘karta’ of the family and all the sons of Allah Bux remained in joint occupation. Zahoor Ahmed claimed that he was in joint occupation of the land in question, paying land revenue to the extent of his share. Thus, he claimed half share in the land in question by way of pedigree.
11.2. According to the respondents, their father had acquired the lands covered by Khata No. 98 through lease; their father had five shares in the said land and one share belonged to Mohammad who died in 1942. Though he was survived by his daughter, as per family custom, she did not have any share in the lands in question. Respondents claimed one share in this land as well. Thus, according to the respondents, they had 11/12 share in Khata No. 98 and 1/12 share belonged to Zahoor.
11.3. In so far Khata No. 99 is concerned, according to the respondents, these lands were acquired by their father 1860 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and devolved upon them on the death of their father. They challenged the claim of Zahoor to such land on the ground that Zahoor had made a dastbardari in their favour in the year 1948. Plot Nos. 45, 57, 111 and 112 were claimed by the respondents as having been acquired by their father Ghafoor. They, however, admitted half share claim of Zahoor Ahmed in respect of Khata No. 99 while denying the claim to the remaining extent of half. Plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100 was wholly claimed by the respondents denying the claim of Zahoor to the extent of half share in the said land.
11.4. Consolidation Officer upon consideration of the pleadings of the parties in dispute had framed the following issues:
(i) Whether respondents were entitled to 11/12 share of Khata No. 98?
(ii) Whether Zahoor Ahmed was entitled to half share of Khata No. 98?
(iii) What was the share of the parties in respect of Khata No. 98?
(iv) Whether Zahoor Ahmed was co-tenant of Khata No. 99 as claimed?
(v) Whether the respondents were recorded as the sole owner of the land covered by Khata No. 99?
(vi) Whether Sami Ullah and Badlu i.e. the respondents were entitled to 11/12 share in respect of plot Nos. 31, 94, 95, 96, 97 and 99 etc. as claimed?
(vii) Whether plot Nos. 35, 57, 111 and 112 were the sole sirdari of the respondents as claimed?
(viii) What were the share of the parties qua Khata No. 99?
(ix) Whether Zahoor was co-tenant of plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100 as claimed?
(x) Whether the respondents were the sole owner of the land of Khata No. 100?
(xi) What were the shares of the parties qua Khata No. 100?
11.5. After noting that it was an admitted position that neither the daughter in the family nor their sons got any share in the lands [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1861Nisar Ahmad & Ors. v. Sami Ullah (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. belonging to the family, Consolidation Officer observed that the appellants and the respondents were recorded as co-tenant of the land in Khata No. 98. Respondents also admitted the share of the appellants in plot Nos. 94, 95, 96, 99, 100 etc. to the extent of 1/12. Thus, according to the Consolidation Officer, in view of the admission made by the respondents, Zahoor Ahmed was the co-tenant and that the dispute was only regarding his share. Further, the Consolidation Officer remarked that the onus was on the respondent to prove that they were entitled to 11/12 share of the land. Consolidation Officer also noticed that there was a lease deed of 1922 but what was to be seen was whether the lands were acquired jointly.
11.6. After discussing the evidence and the materials on record, the Consolidation Officer vide the order dated 06.12.1972 held that Zahoor Ahmed was in occupation of the plots of land bearing Nos. 95, 96, 97, 99, 100 and 107 and as many as five plots being 99, 100, 107 etc. were being cultivated by Zahoor. The Khasra for the relevant years indicated that Zahoor was all along in occupation of the above lands; his name was recorded over an area of 3 bighas 10 biswas of lands and he also paid land revenue in respect of which large number of revenue receipts were on record. Thus, the Consolidation Officer concluded that the lands were acquired jointly when Zahoor Ahmed was a minor and his share would be half of the land. Therefore, he was entitled to half share in Khata Nos. 98 and 99. In so far plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100 is concerned, it was held that the same remained the exclusive property of the respondents. The Consolidation Officer declared that Zahoor Ahmed being the co-tenant of Khata No. 99 was entitled to half share thereof. Accordingly, it was ordered that the name of Zahoor Ahmed be entered as a co-tenant in Khata No. 99 and partition be made in Khata Nos. 98 and 99 in the following manner:
(i) Zahoor - 1/2
(ii) Sami Ullah - 1/4
(iii) Badlu - 1/4
12. Against the aforesaid order dated 06.12.1972, altogether three appeals were filed before the appellate authority i.e. Assistant Settlement Officer- one by Zahoor Ahmed and the other two by 1862 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the respondents. The appeals were filed under Section 11(1) of the 1953 Act.
12.1. By the common judgment and order dated 25.4.1973, the appellate authority i.e. Assistant Settlement Officer, Sultanpur dismissed all the three appeals. While dismissing the appeals, the appellate authority noted that in the basic year, Khata No.98 was recorded in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu and also in the name of Zahoor Ahmed. Khata Nos.99 and 100 were recorded in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu. Zahoor Ahmed filed objection under Section 9 of the 1953 Act contending that in Khata No.99 his name should be recorded. He claimed 1/2 share in Khata Nos.98 and 99 contending that Satai was the common ancestor of both the parties and that he had acquired the disputed land from the joint family. According to him, Allah Bux and Mohammad were the sons of Satai. Abdul Ghafoor was the elder son of Allah Bux and became the ‘karta’ of the joint family. After the death of Allah Bux, Abdul Ghafoor, Abdul Shakoor and Mohd. Ismail, being sons of Allah Bux, came into possession of the disputed land jointly. Mohd. Ismail died issueless. The disputed land was recorded in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu being the sons of Abdul Ghafoor as ‘karta’ of joint family.
12.2. Zahoor stated that at the time of death of his father, he was a minor and lived with Abdul Ghafoor. Abdul Ghafoor and Abdul Shakoor had 1/2 share in the disputed land. Accordingly, both the parties were in possession of the disputed land.
12.3. Sami Ullah and Badlu objected to the claim of Zahoor and contended that the land in Khata No.99 was acquired by Abdul Ghafoor. Sami Ullah and Badlu admitted 1/12 share in the disputed land and denied share of Zahoor in plot No.115 of Khata No.100.
12.4. The primary authority i.e. the Consolidation Officer on the basis of the materials of record and the evidence adduced decided the share of Zahoor in Khata Nos. 98 and 99 at 1/2 and dismissed the objection of Zahoor qua plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100. Therefore, Zahoor filed Appeal No. 43 in respect of plot No. 115 of Khata No.100. Sami Ullah and Badlu filed Appeal Nos. 50 and 51 against the decision of the Consolidation Officer [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1863Nisar Ahmad & Ors. v. Sami Ullah (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. declaring 1/2 share in the disputed land of Khata Nos. 98 and 99 as belonging to Zahoor.
12.5. The appellate authority was of the view that plot No.35 was recorded only in the name of Allah Bux. Zahoor had relinquished in favour of Sami Ullah on 30.06.1948. Zahoor also relinquished the share of Ismail. Sami Ullah had filed the patta for the first time before the Consolidation Officer on 07.05.1992. In the settlement exercise, some disputed land was acquired by Allah Bux and Mohammed jointly. Plot Nos.111 and 112 were recorded in the name of Abdul Ghafoor. The appellate authority noted the submission made on behalf of Zahoor that he was in possession of the disputed land in Khata Nos.98 and 99 and paying land revenue and took the view that the disputed land was in possession of the joint family. When Shakoor, father of Zahoor, had died Zahoor was a minor. Thereafter, father of Sami Ullah brought up Ghafoor and Ghafoor lived as a member of the joint family. Though the name of Ghafoor was not recorded, Sami Ullah admitted 11/12 share of Zahoor. According to the appellate authority, Zahoor was in continuous possession over the disputed land. The revenue receipts indicated that he was in possession of 1/2 share thereof and paying the revenue in respect of the said land. As regards plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100, the appellate authority concurred with the view of the primary authority. Therefore, the appellate authority i.e. the Assistant Settlement Officer upheld the order of the Consolidation Officer and dismissed all the appeals.
13. Two revision petitions were filed under Section 48 of the 1953 Act, Revision No. 3302 was filed by the respondents and Revision No. 3312 was filed by the appellants, against the judgment and order dated 25.04.1973 passed by the Assistant Settlement Officer in appeal.
13.1. The revisional authority i.e. the Deputy Director of Consolidation noted that according to Zahoor, the disputed land was joint family property and as such, his share in it was 1/2. Khata No. 98 was recorded in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu on the one hand and Zahoor on the other hand whereas Khata No. 99 was recorded only in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu. Consolidation Officer had allowed the name of Zahoor Ahmed to be in half of Khata No. 98 and Khata No. 99; however, 1864 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports dismissed the claim of Zahoor Ahmed in respect of plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100. Against the aforesaid decision, appeal was filed but the same was dismissed. It was thereafter that the revision came to be filed by Zahoor Ahmed.
13.2. On the other hand, Sami Ullah claimed that Zahoor had 1/12 share in Khata No. 98 as well as in Khata No. 99 and none in respect of plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100. His objection was allowed in respect of plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100 but was dismissed in respect of the other two Khatas. Therefore, he also filed appeals before the Assistant Settlement Officer which were however dismissed. Thereafter, the related revision petition came to be filed claiming 5/6 th share in Khata No. 98 and exclusively claimed Khata No. 99 for himself and Badlu.
13.3. During the revision proceedings, Zahoor Ahmed died and he was substituted by his legal heirs (sons) Nisar Ahmed, Irshan Ahmed and Ishtiyag Ahmed. The revisional authority considered the claim of Sami Ullah. Zahoor Ahmed had disputed 1/12 th share in Khata No. 98 because in the year 1922, the disputed land was taken on lease by Abdul Ghafoor: 5/6th share from Mohammad Ismail and 1/6 th share from the zamindar. Mohammad Ismail died in the year 1942. After his death, his 1/6th share got devolved in 1/12 th share, viz, in plot Nos. 35, 57, 111 and 112. It was noted that Khata No. 99 was recorded in the name of Sami Ullah and Badlu. The revisional authority noted on the basis of the evidence adduced that Shakoor had expired in the year 1930. Thereafter, the name of Zahoor was recorded as a member of the joint family in Khata No. 98. From the materials on record, the revisional authority noticed that Zahoor was in possession and paying rent in respect of the disputed land. However, the revisional authority accepted the contention of Sami Ullah that Zahoor had relinquished his share in respect of plot Nos. 35, 57, 111 and 112 by way of relinquishment deed of the year 1948. Deputy Director i.e. the revisional authority noted that relinquishment was by way of a relinquishment deed and that Zahoor had admitted his signature on it. Therefore, there was no reason to disbelieve the contention of Sami Ullah because in the year 1948, Zahoor had relinquished his share in plot Nos. 35, 57, 111 and 112. Further, possession of Zahoor Ahmed was also not recorded. [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1865Nisar Ahmad & Ors. v. Sami Ullah (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. Thus Zahoor Ahmed was held to be not entitled to any share in so far the said plots were concerned. The lower authorities had ignored the relinquishment deed which vitiated their respective orders. On the basis of the relinquishment deed, the Deputy Director allowed the revision of Sami Ullah in respect of plot Nos. 35, 57, 111 and 112. As regards claim of Zahoor in respect of plot No. 115 of Khata No. 100, the Deputy Director was not convinced about the said claim. That being the position, the revisional authority upheld the view taken by the lower authorities and dismissed the revision of Zahoor Ahmed.
14. Assailing the above order of the revisional authority, appellants preferred Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 6635 of 1974 whereas respondents preferred Writ Petition No. 18 of 1975 before the High Court. High Court heard both the writ petitions together as the two writ petitions arose out of the same consolidation proceedings in respect of Khata Nos. 98, 99 and 100 in village Bhati Jarouli, Sultanpur.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.