Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 755; [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1313
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice Sanjay Kumar, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 3 Oct 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2623/2014
- Sections
- 34, 27, 302, 307, 161, 157, 428
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 1313 : 2024 INSC 755 Rama Devi v.
The State of Bihar and Others (Criminal Appeal No(s). 2623-2631 of 2014)
03 October 2024 [Sanjiv Khanna,* Sanjay Kumar and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the judgment of the trial court and acquitting the respondents of the charges punishable under Sections 302, 307, 333, 355 and 379, all read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860, and Section 27 of the Arms Act, 1959.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 307, read with s.34 – Murder of an MLA and his bodyguard – Respondents convicted by Trial Court – Conviction reversed by High Court – Challenge to: Held: In view of the evidence and materials on record, charges against A-4 and A-8 under Section 302 read with Section 34 and Section 307 r/w Section 34 proved and established beyond reasonable doubt – Conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court affirmed and restored – However, benefit of doubt given to other accused persons as there is no direct ocular evidence implicating them and the charge of conspiracy is not substantiated, their acquittal upheld – Impugned judgment set aside. [Paras 42-45] FIR – Delay in forwarding the copy to magistrate – When not fatal:
Held: The incident took place in the night of 13.06.1998 – 14.06.1998 being a Sunday, the FIR was forwarded to the jurisdictional magistrate on 15.06.1998 – Thus, the delay in forwarding the copy of the FIR to the jurisdictional magistrate was explained – Mere delay by itself is not sufficient to discard and disbelieve the case of the prosecution unless the accused demonstrate how this delay has prejudiced their case – If the investigation starts in right earnest and there is sufficient material on record to show that the accused were named and pinpointed, *Author 1314 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the prosecution case can be accepted when evidence implicates the accused – The requirement to dispatch and serve a copy of the FIR to the jurisdictional magistrate is an external check against ante dating or ante timing of the FIR to ensure that there is no manipulation or interpolation in the FIR – Further, if the court finds the witnesses to be truthful and credible, the lack of a cogent explanation for the delay may not be regarded as detrimental. [Para 30] Evidence – Non-recovery of vehicles and weapons used in the offence – Effect on credibility of eyewitnesses, if any: Held: The ocular version of the witnesses should not be disregarded solely because the weapon used in the crime and the vehicles allegedly used by the accused were not located or seized by the police – On facts, the failure of the police to recover the vehicles and the weapons is not sufficient to undermine the credibility of the eyewitness accounts or the corroborative evidence regarding the cause of the homicidal deaths of both the deceased. [Para 27] Evidence – Witness with criminal background – Courts to exercise caution but, evidence cannot be discarded merely on the ground of criminal background:
Held: Criminal background of a witness necessitates that the courts approach their evidence with caution – The testimony of a witness with a chequered past cannot be dismissed as untruthful or uncreditworthy without considering the surrounding facts and circumstances of the case, including their presence at the scene of the offence – In cases involving conflicts between rival gangs or groups, the testimony of members from either side is admissible and relevant – If the court is convinced of the veracity and truthfulness of such testimony, it may be considered – Courts assess the broader context to determine if there is sufficient corroboration, as long as there are no valid reasons to discredit the evidence – The crucial test is whether the witness is truly an eyewitness and whether their testimony is credible – If their presence at the scene is established beyond doubt, their account of the incident can be relied upon – Such evidence cannot be discarded merely on the grounds of criminal background. [Para 20] Evidence – Presence of eyewitness (PW-1) at the place of occurrence (hospital) proven, however there was [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1315Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others non- compliance with hospital and prison protocols – Reliance on testimony of PW-1, if proper – MLA and his bodyguard were murdered in the hospital where the former was admitted for treatment while in judicial custody – PW-1 did not seek prior permission from the court or jail authorities nor did he make any entry in the hospital register while visiting the deceased MLA in the hospital:
Held: Fardbeyan (Exhibit-50) and the ocular evidence of PW-24 and PW25, establish the presence of PW-1 and other visitors in the hospital – Once the presence of a witness at the place of occurrence is proven, their testimony, if credible and truthful, should not be dismissed solely based on non-compliance with hospital and prison protocols – Further, the reasoning given by the High Court to disregard and doubt the eyewitness account of PW-1, on the premise that he ought to have been the informant because he is the brother-in-law of the deceased MLA and was present at the hospital at the time of occurrence, is conjectural and unfounded – Any person can be an informant of a case, and the police may also register a case on their own – The rationale of the High Court for dismissing the testimony of PW-1 is fundamentally flawed. [Para 15] Evidence – Testimony of hostile witness – Maxims – falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus – Inapplicability:
Held: Maxim falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus is not a sound rule to apply in the conditions of this country – This maxim does not occupy the status of rule of law – It is merely a rule of caution which involves the question of the weight of evidence that a court may apply in the given set of circumstances – Evidence of a hostile witness is not to be completely rejected, so as to exclude versions that support the prosecution – Rather, the testimony of the hostile witness is to be subjected to close scrutiny, enabling the court to separate truth from falsehood, exaggerations and improvements – Only reliable evidence should be taken into consideration – The court is not denuded of its power to make an appropriate assessment – The entire testimony of a hostile witness is discarded only when the judge, as a matter of prudence, finds the witness wholly discredited, warranting the exclusion of the evidence in toto – The creditworthy portions of the testimony should be considered for the purpose of evidence in the case. [Paras 16, 22] 1316 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Deep Chand and Others v. State of Haryana (1969) 3 SCC 890; State of Rajasthan v. Daud Khan (2016) 2 SCC 607; Ponnam Chandraiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh [2008] 11 SCR 561 : (2008) 11 SCC 640; State of U.P. v. Farid Khan and Others (2005) 9 SCC 103; C. Muniappan and Others v. State of Tamil Nadu [2010] 10 SCR 262 : (2010) 9 SCC 567; Yogesh Singh v. Mahabeer Singh and Others [2016] 7 SCR 713 : (2017) 11 SCC 195; State of Rajasthan v. Arjun Singh and Others [2011] 10 SCR 823 : (2011) 9 SCC 115 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Arms Act, 1959.
List of Keywords Murder; Member of the Legislative Assembly; MLA; Bodyguard; Political leader; Benefit of doubt; Acquittal; Conspiracy not proved/ substantiated; Motive; Charges proved beyond reasonable doubt; Hospital; Prison protocols; Hospital register; Visitors; Delay in forwarding FIR to magistrate; Not fatal; Ante dating; ante timing; Manipulation or interpolation in FIR; Superficial issues; Memory test; Witness with criminal background; Non-recovery of vehicles, weapons used in the offence; Ocular evidence; Informant; Hostile witness; Maxims; falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus; Fardbeyan; Eyewitness; Efflux of time.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
2623-2631 of 2014 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.07.2014 of the High Court of Patna in CRLAP No. 778, 898, 825, 859, 865, 899, 871, 874 and 878 of 2009 With Criminal Appeal Nos. 2632-2640 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, K M Nataraj, A.S.G., Siddharth Aggarwal, Ms. Sonia Mathur, Mrs. Ruchi Kohli, Mrs. Archana [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1317Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others Pathak Dave, Surendra Singh, Sr. Advs., Arvind Kumar Sharma, Aditya Singia, Vishwajeet Bhati, Harsh Yadav, Ritwik Saha, Sharad Kumar Puri, Ms. Parul Sharma, Mrs. Pinki Aggarwal, Mrs. Priya Puri, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Ms. Sairica S Raju, Rajesh Kumar Singh, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, P V Yogeswaran, Ms. Ronika Tater, Ms. Surbhi Bhardwaj, Ms. Dipanshu Krishnan, Ms. Madhumita Kesavan, Nikhil Chandra Jaiswal, Tripurari Ray, D. S. Parmar, Ms. Sujeeta Srivastava, Abhishek Priyadarshi, Ms. Mrinal Elker Mazumdar, Saurabh Singh, Anirudh Ray, Ashutosh Ghade, Sunil Kumar, Nimit Bhimjiyani, Rahul Raman, Ms. Sneha Balapure, Raj Kamal, Aseem Atwal, Kartavya Batra, Anurag Chandra, Ms. Nupur Kaushik, Ms. Stuti, Ms. Aprajita Tyagi, Ms. Muskan Sidana, Harneet Singh, Ms. Prerna Singh, Shantanu Sagar, Raj Kumar, Prabhat Ranjan Raj, Anil Kumar, Gunjesh Ranjan, Mrs. Divya Mishra, Shashank Kumar Saurav, Sanjay Jain, Manu Shanker Mishra, Laxmi Narayan Sharma, Vivekanand Singh, Nishant Kumar, Nithyananda Murthy P, Ms. Bhanu Prabha, Vaibha Kumar, Advs. for the appearing parties.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjiv Khanna, J.
This judgment decides two sets of appeals, one by the State of Bihar, through the Central Bureau of Investigation, 1 and the other by Rama Devi, wife of one of the deceased – Brij Bihari Prasad, a member of the Bihar Legislative Assembly. The second deceased – Lakshmeshwar Sahu – was the bodyguard of Brij Bihari Prasad and a member of the Bihar police.
2. The impugned judgment of the High Court of Judicature at Patna dated 24.07.2014 reverses the judgment of the trial court and acquits the nine accused 2 of the charges punishable under Sections 302, 307, 333, 355 and 379, all read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, 3 and Section 27 of the Arms Act, 1959.4 1 For short, “CBI.”
2 Suraj Bhan Singh @ Suraj Singh @ Suraj, Mukesh Singh, Lallan Singh, Mantu Tiwari, Captain Sunil Singh (since deceased), Ram Niranjan Chaudhary, Shashi Kumar Rai (since deceased), Vijay Kumar Shukla @ Munna Shukla, Rajan Tiwari.
3 For short, “IPC”.
4 For short, “1959 Act”.
1318 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
3. The incident in question took place on 13.06.1998 at around 08:15 p.m. at the Indira Gandhi Institute of Medical Science, Patna.5 On the basis of the fardbeyan (Exhibit 50) of Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10) recorded by S.S.P. Yadav, Inspector-cum-Officer-in-Charge, Shastri Nagar Police Station, 6 on 13.06.1998 at 9:00 p.m., First Information Report 7 No. 336/1998, (Exhibit 51 and 51/1) was lodged under Sections 302, 307, 34, 120B, 379 of the IPC and Section 27 of the 1959 Act at 12:15 a.m. on 14.06.1998.
The Prosecution Case
4. The prosecution case is as follows:
(i) On 13.06.1998 at around 6:30 p.m., Brij Bihari Prasad, who was in judicial custody and admitted for treatment at IGIMS hospital, was taking a walk outside the wardroom along with – Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), Arbind Singh (PW-13), Ram Nandan Singh (PW-12), Mahant Ashwani Das (PW-25), Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Onkar Singh and 2-4 others.
(ii) Brij Bihari Prasad was also accompanied by his bodyguard – Lakshmeshwar Sahu, who was armed with a carbine, and other sepoys.
(iii) Two vehicles, a Sumo car, with registration number, BR-1P-1818, followed by an Ambassador car, registration number of which could not be ascertained, entered the IGIMS hospital from the southern main gate, Bailey Road side and stopped near Brij Bihari Prasad.
(iv) Occupants of the said cars, namely – Mantu Tiwari (A-4), Vijay Kumar Shukla @ Munna Shukla (A-8), Rajan Tiwari (A-9), and Shri Prakash Shukla @ Shiv Prakash Shukla (since deceased), Satish Pandey (since deceased) and Bhupendra Nath Dubey (since deceased) came out of the vehicles.
(v) Mantu Tiwari(A-4) was armed with a sten gun and all others were armed with pistols. Bhupendra Nath Dubey (since deceased) 5 For short, “IGIMS Hospital”.
6 S.S.P. Yadav subsequently expired and did not depose. 7 For short, “FIR”.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 1319Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others abusively exhorted others to shoot at Brij Bihari Prasad while he himself also fired at Brij Bihari Prasad with his pistol.
(vi) Mantu Tiwari (A-4) and Shri Prakash Shukla @ Shiv Prakash Shukla (since deceased) fired at Brij Bihari Prasad from their sten gun and pistol respectively.
(vii) Satish Pandey, Vijay Kumar Shukla @ Munna Shukla (A-8) and Rajan Tiwari (A-9) fired at Lakshmeshwar Sahu.
(viii) Both Brij Bihari Prasad and Lakshmeshwar Sahu collapsed and died.
(ix) Rabindra Bhagat (PW-14) suffered a gunshot wound in the cross-fire.
5. The post-mortem reports dated 14.06.1998 (Exhibits 9 & 9/1), proved by Dr. Arvind Kumar Singh (PW-7), establish the homicidal death of Brij Bihari Prasad and Lakshmeshwar Sahu due to multiple gunshot injuries resulting in haemorrhage and shock. The multiple gunshot wound entries are consistent with successive firing from firearms/ pistol. To this extent the prosecution version is unchallenged.
6. As per the prosecution case, there were eleven eye-witnesses, namely, Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), Amod Kumar (PW-11), Ram Nandan Singh (PW-12), Arbind Singh (PW-13), Rabindra Bhagat (PW-14), Kamakhya Narain Singh (PW-15), Bhola Prasad Premi (PW-16), Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) and Binod Kumar Singh (PW-19). However, Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42), and to some extent, Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10) had supported the prosecution case. Others were hostile or partly hostile as they did not support the prosecution case or did not name/identify the perpetrators.
7. Primarily relying on the testimonies of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Mahant Ashwani Das (PW-25), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) and Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), the trial court convicted the respondents Suraj Bhan Singh (A-1), Mukesh Singh (A-2), Lallan Singh (A-3), Mantu Tiwari (A-4), Captain Sunil Singh (A-5) (since deceased),8 Ram Niranjan Chaudhary (A-6), Vijay Kumar 8 It is an accepted and admitted position that Captain Sunil Singh (A-5) has passed away. The appeal qua him shall stand abated.
1320 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Shukla @ Munna Shukla (A-8), Rajan Tiwari (A-9) and Shashi Kumar Rai (A-7) (since deceased). 9 Reasoning of the High Court
8. The judgment of the High Court refers to the evidence in detail, with the acquittal of the respondents grounded in the following findings:
(i) FIR No. 336/1998, marked Exhibit 51, is ante-timed.
(ii) Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) is not an eye-witness, but rather a planted witness, as his name was not mentioned in the fardbeyan (Exhibit 50). His antecedents are questionable.
(iii) The testimony of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) implicating the respondents-accused is unreliable because:
(a) he is Brij Bihari Prasad’s brother-in-law;
(b) he should have been the informant but was not, which raises doubts about his presence at the IGIMS hospital;
(c) he contradicted the prosecution’s case by accepting that Rajan Tiwari (A-9), whom he knew beforehand, was not present during the incident. However, in his statement under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973,10 he claimed that Rajan Tiwari (A-9) was one of the assailants of Lakshmeshwar Sahu; and
(d) he deposed under the pressure of his sister, Rama Devi (PW-24), who was present in the court during the recording of his evidence on all (three) days.
(iv) The deposition of Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) is unreliable on the following grounds:
(a) he is a convict in a murder case registered in the year 1979;
(b) he did not surrender after the dismissal of his appeal by the High Court and was accordingly declared an absconder;
(c) he was arrested on 04.05.2006 while deposing before the trial court in the present case;
9 The appeal qua Shashi Kumari Rai (A-7) stood abated on account of his demise vide order dated 28.02.2020.
10 For short, “CrPC”.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 1321Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others
(d) he was under the patronage and protection of Brij Bihari Prasad and his wife, Rama Devi (PW-24);
(e) there is a contradiction between the versions of Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) and Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) regarding their presence in the hospital room of Brij Bihari Prasad at IGIMS hospital. While Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) claims that Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25)
was in the hospital room when he arrived there, Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) states that Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) was already present in the hospital room of Brij Bihari Prasad when he (Mahanth Ashwani Das) reached the hospital.
(f) there is a discrepancy as to when the police recorded the statement of Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) and his version of events on 13.06.1998 and 14.06.1998. Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) claims that after the occurrence he and Rama Devi (PW-24) had proceeded to the official residence of Brij Bihari Prasad from IGIMS hospital at about 9:00-9:30 p.m. Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) had left for Muzzaffarpur Math in the night at about 12:30 a.m. on 14.06.1998. Thus, the police could not have recorded the statement of Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) in the IGIMS hospital at 12:30 a.m. on 14.06.1998. Further, if Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) was present at the time of occurrence, as deposed by him, police should have recorded his statement before he left the IGIMS hospital campus around 9:30 p.m.
(v) Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) was not an eye-witness, as his presence is not mentioned in the fardbeyan (Exhibit 50) or the FIR (Exhibits 51 and 51/1). His statement under Section 161 of the CrPC was recorded belatedly, five days after the incident.
(vi) Rama Devi (PW-24) is not an eye-witness, as she had left the place of occurrence prior to the incident. The police did not produce Rama Devi’s statement under Section 161 of the CrPC recorded on 13.06.1998 by the second investigating officer 11 – 11 For short, “IO”.
1322 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Shashi Bhushan Sharma (PW-54), who had taken charge of the investigation in compliance with the instructions of Senior Superintendent of Police, Patna. The version of Rama Devi (PW-24) that she learnt names and details of the assailants from the visitors she had met earlier in the day in the hospital room is not mentioned in the Section 161 CrPC statements dated 18.10.1999 and 28.03.2001 given by her to Rai Singh Khatri (PW-62), IO of CBI. This is corroborated by the statement of Rai Singh Khatri (PW-62), IO of CBI, who testified that Rama Devi (PW-24) did not name the assailants. Since the initial statement of Rama Devi (PW-24) under Section 161 CrPC recorded by Shashi Bhushan Sharma (PW-54) was not on record and she later failed to disclose the name of the assailants in her Section 161 CrPC statements to Rai Singh Khatri (PW-62), IO of CBI, her deposition in court, stating that Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Ram Niranjan Chaudhary (A-6), Kamakhya Narain Singh (PW-15), Arbind Singh (PW-13), Amarendra Kumar Sinha (Informant/PW-10), Onkar Singh, Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) and others were present with the deceased, should not be relied on.
(vii) The eye-witnesses did not testify about the retaliatory firing by the security personnel of Brij Bihari Prasad who were present at the scene of the occurrence. The recovery of empty cartridges and the firearms examination report (Exhibit-17) indicate that shots were fired from two of the four rifles which had been issued to the security guards.
Court depositions and analysis of evidence
9. We will now examine in some detail the court depositions of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25), Amarendra Kumar Singh (PW-10) and Rama Devi (PW-24), before scrutinising the reasons given by the High Court to discredit their versions. Our discussion will also address the arguments raised by both sides, with particular focus on the contention of the respondents that the court depositions of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25), Amarendra Kumar Singh (PW-10) and Rama Devi (PW-24) should not be accepted.
10. At the outset, we express our agreement with the reasoning given by the High Court for disbelieving the presence of Shashi Bhushan [2024] 10 S.C.R. 1323Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others Singh (PW-42) at the spot, and consequently, his deposition as an eye-witness for the following reasons:
(i) Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) is not mentioned as one of the persons present at the place of occurrence in the fardbeyan (Exhibit-50), as also in the FIR (Exhibits 51 and 51/1). These documents name the eyewitnesses. Therefore, the absence of the name of Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) is significant.
(ii) His statement under Section 161 CrPC was recorded on 18.06.1998, i.e., 5 days after the date of occurrence;
(iii) Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) has deposed about taking the dead body of Brij Bihari Prasad on 14.06.1998 from Patna to Behihari village, the native place of Brij Bihari Prasad. Therefore, the delay in his Section 161 CrPC statement impairs his assertion of being an eyewitness, making it unworthy of acceptance;
(iv) Although Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), Mahant Ashwani Das (PW-25), and Rama Devi (PW-24) have testified to the presence of Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) as an eyewitness, this assertion should not be accepted. The fardbeyan (Exhibit P-50), being the first written account made immediately after the incident, is unexceptionable. Furthermore, the unexplained delay of five days in recording the statement of Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) as an eyewitness dents the credibility of his account.
(v) For the same reasons, the reliance of the prosecution on the court testimony of Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), averring the presence of Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) at the place of occurrence, contrary to his fardbeyan, is erratic and untrustworthy. Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), did not entirely support the prosecution case, yet being conscious of the fact that he was the informant of the fardbeyan, he could not completely resile. His dock version about the presence of Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) has been rightly disbelieved. Testimony of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1)
11. Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) is categoric about his presence in the hospital at about 6:40–7:00 p.m. on 13.06.1998 to visit Brij Bihari Prasad. He named the persons who were present with him in the 1324 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports hospital room, which includes Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25). The testimony captures the following:
(i) Brij Bihari Prasad went for a walk along with the people of his constituency and supporters who had come to see him. The police personnel assigned for his protection also accompanied him.
(ii) After some time, two vehicles – a white Sumo car (Registration No. BR-1P-1818) and a white Ambassador car – came into the hospital and stopped at a distance of about 20 steps in front of Brij Bihari Prasad.
(iii) Bhupendra Nath Dubey (since deceased) alighted from the Sumo car, which was also carrying 2-3 more persons. 2-3 other people also alighted from the Ambassador car.
(iv) Bhupendra Nath Dubey (since deceased) pointed towards Brij Bihari Prasad and ordered that he be killed, while he himself also started firing shots. Others joined him in the firing.
(v) Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) specifically identified Satish Pandey (since deceased) as an occupant of the Ambassador car.
(vi) Vijay Kumar Shukla @ Munna Shukla (A-8), who was a legislator from Lal Ganj, got down from the Ambassador car, while Mantu Tiwari (A-4), along with 1-2 more people, alighted from the Sumo.
(vii) Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) saw Mantu Tiwari (A-4) but did not know his name. He came to know about the name subsequently from Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10) and Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42).
(viii) Mantu Tiwari (A-4) was carrying a big firearm while Bhupendra Nath Dubey (since deceased) was carrying a small firearm. The other assailants were carrying either a revolver or a small firearm.
(ix) Bodyguard Lakshmeshwar Sahu who was carrying a carbine, was also fired upon.
(x) As a result of the firing, both Lakshmeshwar Sahu and Brij Bihari Prasad collapsed.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 1325Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others
(xi) While leaving, Bhupendra Nath Dubey (since deceased) took the carbine that belonged to Lakshmeshwar Sahu and raised the slogan “Jai Bajrang Bali”.
(xii) After the assailants left, Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) and other visitors went near the dead bodies of Brij Bihari Prasad and Lakshmeshwar Sahu.
(xiii) Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) identified both Mantu Tiwari (A-4) and Vijay Kumar Shukla @ Munna Shukla (A-8) in the court.
(xiv) While Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) identified Rajan Tiwari (A-9) in the court, he testified that Rajan Tiwari (A-9) was not present at the place of occurrence. Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) had not seen Suraj Bhan Singh (A-1) and Shashi Kumar Rai (A-7) at the place of occurrence.
(xv) Paras Nath Chaudhary (PW-1) establishes the presence of Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), Arbind Singh (PW- 13), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42), Ram Nandan Singh (PW-12), Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25), Rabindra Bhagat (PW-14), one Kanti, resident of Jamui, Kamakhya Narain Singh (PW-15), Ram Niranjan Chaudhary (A-6), Vijay Jha (PW-51) and 2-3 other persons at the IGIMS hospital.
12. The cross-examination of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) brings the following aspects to light:
(i) He accepted that Rama Devi (PW-24) was his sister and that she was present in the court on the day of the hearing but left while his evidence was being recorded.
(ii) He affirmed that Brij Bihari Prasad was admitted to the hospital 10-12 days before the occurrence.
(iii) Before the date of occurrence, he met Brij Bihari Prasad in the hospital on 4-5 occasions.
(iv) Brij Bihari Prasad, being in judicial custody, was admitted to IGIMS hospital by the jail administration.
(v) He accepted that his sister, Rama Devi (PW-24), had contested Lok Sabha elections in the past. Rama Devi (PW-24) contested Vidhan Sabha elections after the death of Brij Bihari Prasad. 1326 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(vi) He states that he had also taken part in the election campaign of Rama Devi (PW-24).
(vii) He denied knowing the fact that Devendra Nath Dubey, one of the candidates of Motihari constituency, was the main rival of Rama Devi (PW-24).
(viii) He further denied that Brij Bihari Prasad along with his brother, Shyam Bihari Prasad, murdered Devendra Nath Dubey.
(ix) He affirmed his presence at the place of occurrence and denied the claim that he did not witness the incident.
(x) He refuted the suggestion that being the brother-in-law of Brij Bihari Prasad, he is giving false evidence.
(xi) He also denied the claim that he was deposing at the behest of his sister Rama Devi (PW-24).
(xii) He reiterates that Mahanth Ashwani Das (PW-25) and others were present at the hospital.
(xiii) Two guards, which included Lakshmeshwar Sahu, were walking beside Brij Bihari Prasad.
(xiv) After the firing, the hospital staff and other people present started running in different directions.
(xv) Rama Devi (PW-24) came to the hospital after the incident. He testifies to seeing her cry beside the dead body of Brij Bihari Prasad.
(xvi) Police officers examined the dead body of Brij Bihari Prasad and prepared an Inquest Report. He denies signing the Inquest Report or any other document.
(xvii) He had gone to the hospital the next morning on 14.06.1998.
(xviii) He mentioned that his police statement was recorded about 10 -12 hours 12 after the incident but could not recall the exact date since it was taken seven years ago.
13. Though it was pointed out that Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), in his testimony, could not remember the number of the hospital room 12 See Trial Court Record, Vol. II, p.58.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 1327Rama Devi v. The State of Bihar and Others or whether it was south-facing or not, this aspect would not, in our opinion, dent his core testimony. It is apposite to note that Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) was aware that the hospital room was on the ground floor and there was a verandah after crossing 4-5 rooms on the west side. He further stated that there was a cycle stand, a vacant place for sitting, and a road which joins Bailey Road on the west side.
14. Paras Nath Chaudhury 13 (PW-1) accepts that he did not seek prior permission from the court or the jail authorities to visit Brij Bihari Prasad in the hospital, nor did he make any entry into the hospital register. This is also true for other visitors, a position accepted by the prosecution. The absence of a register entry or prior permission, a factor to be taken into consideration, is not sufficient reason to discard bounteous and credible evidence and material establishing that Brij Bihari Prasad, a political leader with influence, had numerous visitors and supporters meeting him at the hospital. The fardbeyan (Exhibit-50) and the ocular evidence of Rama Devi 14 (PW-24) and Mahanth Ashwani Das 15 (PW-25), establish the presence of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) and other visitors. Further, the following witness accounts establish the presence of visitors and eyewitnesses:
¾ Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10) has deposed and accepted the presence of Arbind Singh (PW-13), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42), Ram Niranjan Chaudhary (A-6) and 7-8 other persons. ¾ Arbind Singh (PW-13), who was declared hostile, accepted that Amarendra Kumar Sinha (PW-10), Shashi Bhushan Singh (PW-42) and 5-7 other persons had come to the hospital. ¾ Rabindra Bhagat (PW-14), the injured witness who also turned hostile, deposed to the presence of two other persons accompanying Brij Bihari Prasad.
Once the presence of a witness at the place of occurrence is proven, their testimony, if credible and truthful, should not be dismissed solely based on non-compliance with hospital and prison protocols. 13 See para 11(xv).
14 See para 23.
15 See para 17(ii).
1328 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
15. The reasoning given by the High Court to disregard and doubt the eyewitness account of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1), on the premise that he ought to have been the informant because he is the brother-in-law of Brij Bihari Prasad and was present at the hospital at the time of occurrence, is conjectural and unfounded. This fact cannot ipso facto lead to the disavowal of his testimony. Such a presumption imposes a rigid formula for determining who should be an informant, which the law does not envision. It is an accepted and admitted position that the name of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) has been mentioned in the fardbeyan and in the FIR as one of the persons present at the hospital. Any person can be an informant of a case, and the police may also register a case on their own. The rationale of the High Court for dismissing the testimony of Paras Nath Chaudhury (PW-1) is fundamentally flawed.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.