Hasmukhlal Madhavlal Patel and Anr. v. Ambika Food Products Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 582; [2023] 8 S.C.R. 243
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice K.M. Joseph, Justice B.V. Nagarathna Companies Act, Justice 1956 – S. 2(32), Justice 81(1a), Justice 81(3), Justice 397, Justice 398 – Companies Act
- Decided
- 15 Jun 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8194/2018
- Sections
- 2(32), 105, 397, 81, 421, 81(3), 50, 81(1), 85, 81(2), 291
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL AND ANR.
v.
AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. AND ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 8194 of 2018)
JUNE 15, 2023
[K. M. JOSEPH AND B. V. NAGARATHNA, JJ.] Companies Act, 1956 – s. 2(32), 81, 81(1A), 81(3), 397, 398 – Companies Act, 1913 – s. 105-C – First respondent is a private limited company having authorised capital of Rs.1 crore – There are three groups i.e. HMP, S and VPP – Appellant nos. 1 and 2 described as the ‘HMP’ Group had 30.80% of the paid up share capital – ‘S’ Group represented by respondent nos. 4 & 5 had 45 per cent share and ‘VPP’ Group represented by respondent nos. 2 & 3 had 24.20 percentage in the paid-up capital – In response to the proposal for a term-loan made by the appellants, Bank advised them to increase Share Capital for minimum level of Rs. 2 Crore – First respondent company send a Notice to its Directors, four in number, viz., the appellants and Respondents 2 & 3 – Meeting was convened on 18.12.2009 – Directors of ‘S’ group resigned earlier and directors of ‘VPP’ Group were granted leave of absence – In the said meeting, the company proposed to issue further shares to its existing members in the ratio of 1:1 – S and VPP group sought to treat the first respondent company as disputed company – Thereafter, in minutes of Extraordinary General meeting of shareholders (27.01.2010), the authorised share capital of the company was increased to 2 crores – VPP Group and the S Group, purported to project a case of mismanagement and oppression by the appellants in the petitions u/s. 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 – NCLT found that the increase in the share capital and the allotment of shares itself, was not an act of oppression of the rights – NCLAT found that the allotment in the ratio of 1:1 was not oppressive – However, the manner in which allotment is done, may be illegal and, thus, oppressive – The act of increase in the share capital was upheld – The distribution of shares was ‘defective’ – On appeal, held: The authorised capital of a company, which is also known as nominal capital of the company, represents the maximum number of shares that can be issued – It must be indicated in the Memorandum [2023] 8 S.C.R. 243 A B C D E F G H 244 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
of Association – It can be increased only by the company by passing a resolution in a General Body Meeting – By the Resolution dated 18.12.2009, the Board of Directors had not actually purported to increase the Authorised Capital – The contents of the last paragraph of the Resolution, makes it abundantly clear that the Board of Directors was aware that the power lay with the General Body of shareholders to bring about an increase in the authorised capital – It has, no doubt, undertaken to resolve to issue further capital, even though it could be said that as on 18.12.2009, there was ‘no further capital’ subsisting in terms of the limit of Rs. 1 crore, which constituted the Authorised Capital as on 18.12.2009 – What is more shares have been offered on a ratio of 1:1 to the existing shareholders – They were given the choice of refusal or to apply for more or lesser number of shares – This is not a case where the Resolution was to allot the further shares to the Directors or Members of their Group alone – There is a concurrent finding that the decision to go in for increase in capital, viz., Authorised Capital, was not vulnerable to attack – The decision was based on the advice given by the Bank – The purpose of the Board of Directors to increase the capital has been admittedly found to be bona fide – An incidental gain, namely the change in the shareholding pattern is entirely the inevitable result of the refusal of the respondent’s groups to apply – On the whole, in the facts, the appellants cannot be described as having acted in a defective or in an unfair manner, in the matter of allotment of further shares particularly when the contention of the respondents about the bona fides of the decision to increase the authorised capital has been found in favour of the appellants.
Partly allowing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 The Authorised Capital of a company, which is also known as nominal capital of the company, represents the maximum number of shares that can be issued. It must be indicated in the Memorandum of Association. It can be increased only by the company by passing a resolution in a General Body Meeting. In other words, the Authorised Capital cannot be increased by the Board of Directors. It is out of the Authorised Capital that a company issues shares. It then becomes the Issued Capital. Whatever is issued, need not be subscribed to. Whatever A B C D E F G H is subscribed to, would become the Subscribed Capital. Paid-up Capital is defined in Section 2(32) of the Companies Act, 1956 as including capital credited as paid-up. The Subscribed Capital may be wholly or partly paid-up. [Paras 67, 68][279-D-G] 1.2 The position under the Companies Act, 1956, under Section 81, remained the same in that it is only the company, in its General Body Meeting, which could increase the Authorised Capital. The position still continued that call it increase in Subscribed Capital, it must be within the limits of the Authorised Capital. By the Resolution dated 18.12.2009, the Board of Directors had not actually purported to increase the Authorised Capital. The contents of the last paragraph of the Resolution, makes it abundantly clear that the Board of Directors was aware that the power lay with the General Body of shareholders to bring about an increase in the Authorised Capital. It has, no doubt, undertaken to resolve to issue further capital, even though it could be said that as on 18.12.2009, there was ‘no further capital’ subsisting in terms of the limit of Rs.1 crore, which constituted the Authorised Capital as on 18.12.2009. The Resolution to allot the shares in 1:1 ratio and the indication that shares, which are not applied for, could be the subject matter of allotment to other shareholders, were all to become operative upon the applications being considered. The Minutes further reveal that the consideration of the application was to await the increase in the Authorised Capital in a duly constituted meeting of the General Body of shareholders. It is, no doubt, true that the proper way of doing it could have been to pass a Resolution after the shareholders resolved to increase the Authorised Capital. It is equally true that such a Resolution was passed on 27.01.2010. The question is, as to whether the act of the Board of Directors attracted the opprobrium of it being an act of oppression. We would think that the decisions of the Board of Directors on 18.12.2009, understood as a whole, only means that the Resolution to issue further capital was to become effective only after the Authorised Capital was duly increased. This is not a case where the Board of Directors had resolved to allot the shares otherwise disregarding the mandate of Section 81 of the Act. What is more shares have been offered on a ratio of 1:1 to the existing HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD
PRODUCTS PVT. LTD.
A B C D E F G H 246 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
shareholders. They were given the choice of refusal or to apply for more or lesser number of shares. This is not a case where the Resolution was to allot the further shares to the Directors or Members of their Group alone. There is a concurrent finding that the decision to go in for increase in capital, viz., Authorised Capital, was not vulnerable to attack. The decision was based on the advice given by the Bank. The purpose of the Board of Directors to increase the capital has been admittedly found to be bona fide. An incidental gain, namely the change in the shareholding pattern is entirely the inevitable result of the refusal of the respondent’s groups to apply. This Court cannot proceed on the basis that the appellants foresaw and deliberately planned the whole affair. If only the respondents had applied, the situation would not have happened. [Paras 71, 72][280-E-H; 281-A-E] 1.3 As far as the aspect that, the purported object was shown as generating fresh funds but in place of Rs.90 lakhs only Rs.21 lakhs was brought in goes, the fact that the paid-up capital was apparently shown as credited by cancelling loans due by the company to the appellants group, should not prevent this Court from overlooking the fact that the debt-equity ratio has undoubtedly been improved. It must be borne in mind that the whole idea was to get funds from the Bank for the expansion of the company. The case of the respondents that there were loans due to them also may not advance their case. It would have been different if the respondents had applied and sought adjustment of the consideration by cancelling loans given by them to the company and it was rejected. On the whole, in the facts, the appellants cannot be described as having acted in a defective or in an unfair manner, in the matter of allotment of further shares particularly when the contention of the respondents about the bona fides of the decision to increase the authorised capital has been found in favour of the appellants. The appeals are partly allowed. The direction to allot shares in the impugned order is set aside. The order for conducting audit will remain undisturbed. There will be no order as to costs. [Para 73][281-F-H; 282-A] Nanalal Zaver and another v. Bombay Life Assurance Company Limited and another AIR 1950 SC 172 :
[1950] SCR 391 – followed.
A B C D E F G H Dale & Carrington Invt. (P) Ltd. And another v. P.K.
Prathapan and others (2005) 1 SCC 212 : [2004] 4 Suppl. SCR 334 – distinguished.
Needle Industries (India) Ltd. and others v. Needle Industries Newey (India) Holding Ltd. And others (1981)
3 SCC 333 : [1981] 3 SCR 698 – referred to Case Law Reference [1950] SCR 391 followed Para 6 [2004] 4 Suppl. SCR 334 distinguished Para 21 [1981] 3 SCR 698 referred to Para 26 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.8194 of 2018.
From the Judgment and Order dated 02.04.2018 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi in Company Appeal (AT) No.273 of 2017.
With Civil Appeal No.8195 of 2018.
Ms. Meenakshi Arora, Sr. Adv., Mohit D. Ram, Ms. Monisha Handa, Rajul Shrivastav, Anubhav Sharma, Advs. for the Appellants. Ritin Rai, Sr. Adv., S. S. Shroff, Malak Manish Bhatt, Siddharth, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
K. M. JOSEPH, J.
1. The first respondent is a private limited company. It can also be described as a closely held private limited company. The authorised capital of the first respondent was Rs.1 crore. It consisted of ten lakh equity shares of Rs.10/- each. The paid-up capital was also the same. There are three groups. Appellants 1 and 2, together and relatives can be described as the H.M. Patel Group. They had 30.80 percentage of the paid-up share capital. The next Group to be noticed is the Sheth Groupwhich is represented by Respondents 4 and 5, viz., Kirti Kumar Ochachhavlal Sheth and Ashwinikumar Kirtikumar Ochachhavlal Sheth (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the Sheth Group’, for short). The Sheth HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD
PRODUCTS PVT. LTD.
A B C D E F G H 248 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
Group had 45 per cent share in the paid-up capital. The third Group is represented by Respondents 2 and 3, viz., Manish Vipinchandra Patel and Krunal Vipinchandra Patel. They had 24.20 percentage of the paidup share capital. They are referred to hereinafter as the ‘V.P. Patel Group’.
2. The V.P. Patel Group filed T.P. 197 of 2016 (C.A. 16 of 2012) whereas the Sheth Group filed T.P. 10 of 2016 (C.P. 86 of 2010). The first respondent is the company. Respondents 2 and 3, in both the petitions, are the appellants before us. The V.P. Patel Group and the Sheth Group, through the aforesaid Petitions, purported to project a case of mismanagement and oppression by the appellants in the Petitions styled under Sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’, for short). By Order dated 17.05.2017, the NCLT, Ahmedabad Bench disposed of the petitions with the following directions:
“92. In this set of facts, it is not just and equitable to order winding up of the company. If the company Is to be wound up it is not in the interest of the company or and it is not in the interest of the three groups of shareholders. Therefore, this Tribunal is of the view that it is just and expedient to give following directions/ orders in this matter: -
(a) In view of the findings on point No. 3 it is held that increase in the authorised share capital of company from rupees one crore to two crores is valid and binding on all the shareholders. However, the allotment of shares in respect of increased share capital shall be made to all the existing shareholders of the Company as on 18.12.2009 in proportion to their shareholding. In case if any shareholder is not willing to subscribe for additional shares, then those shares shall be allotted to other shareholders taking their options again proportionate to their shareholding.
(b) In view of findings on point No. 4, the removal of respondents 2 and 3 as directors of the company is not valid.
(c) In view of finding on point No. S, this Tribunal direct that there shall be audit of accounts of the company from the financial year 2009-20l0 and determine what are the amounts siphoned by each petitioners and respondents 2to 5 and place the report before the General Body of the company duly convening Extra Ordinary A B C D E F G H General Meeting. The company is directed to take steps for recovery of such amounts from the concerned persons.
(d) Mis. A.R. Sulakhe& Co., 515, Loha Bhavan, Opp. Old High Court, Near Income Tax Circle, Ashram Road, Ahmedabad 380009 is appointed as auditors for the purpose auditing accounts of the company as directed above. The Auditors shall file report before this Tribunal within two months from the date of this order serving copy to the company and its directors. Fee of the auditorsis tentatively fixed at Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees fifty thou sand only). The auditors are at liberty to ask for further remuneration depending on work load.
(e) This Tribunal direct the Independent Valuer to determine the fair value of the shares of the first respondent company as on the date of filing (CP 85/2010) TP 10/2016.
(f) A.S. Gupta & Co., 203/1 New Cloth Market, 1st Floor, Outside Raiput Gate, Ahmedabad 380 002 is appointed as independent valuer to assess the fair value of the shares of the first respondent company as on the date of filing of this petition taking into consideration report of the auditors also. Independent valuer shall file his report fixing fair market value of the shares of the first respondent company before this Tribunal. Valuer shall take up the work of assessing valuation of the shares of the company after report of the auditor is filed. Independent valuer shall file report before this Tribunal within two months from the date of filing auditor’s report. Any one of the shareholders is at liberty to file an application before this Tribunal seeking directions/orders regarding the manner and mode in which the shares of company shall be sold and who has to purchase and at what value the shares are to be sold.
(g) Fee of the independent valuer is tentatively fixed at Rs.50,000/ - (Rupees fifty thousand only). The independent valuer is at liberty to ask for further remuneration depending upon the work load.
(h) Pending completion of the entire process as per this order there shall not be any alienation of properties both movable and immovable of the respondent no. 1 company by any of the parties.
(i) Pending completion of the entire process as per this order there shall not be any allotment of shares or transfer or sale of shares HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 250 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
except as indicated in this order.
(j) The company shall bear the fee of independent valuer and auditors.
(k) Both Petitions are disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs.”
3. The appellants thereupon filed Company Appeals under Section 421 of the Companies Act, 2013, viz., Company Appeals (AT)272 and 273 of 2017 against the Common Order in the aforesaid Petitions. The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, New Delhi (NCLAT) has affirmed substantially the Order passed by the NCLT. The modification was only in regard to paragraph-92C (supra) of the Order of the NCLT. The NCLAT substituted the words ‘financial year 2008-2009’ in place of ‘2009-2010’. Affirming the rest of the directions, the Appeals were disposed of. It is this Order, which is impugned in the Appeals before this Court.
4. We have heard Smt. Meenakshi Arora, learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the appellants. We have heard, on the other hand, Shri Nitin Rai, learned Senior Counsel, on behalf of the V.P. Patel Group and Shri Malak Manish Bhat, learned Counsel on behalf of the Sheth Group.
5. The bone of contention between the parties has narrowed down to one issue. The appellants take exception to the Order of the NCLAT, affirming the direction of the NCLT, by which, allotment of shares in respect of the increased share capital, was to be made to all the existing shareholders of the company as on 18.12.2009, in proportion to their shareholding. It was the further direction in paragraph-92A (supra) of the NCLT, that in case, if any of the shareholders is not willing to subscribe for additional shares, then, those shares shall be allotted to other shareholders, taking their options again, proportionate to their shareholdings. Smt. Meenakshi Arora, after taking us through the sequence of facts, would point out that after finding that there was no mismanagement or oppression, as alleged andthe NCLT and the NCLAT have clearly erred in regard to the above matter. She would submit that first respondent is a private limited company. Section 81 of the Act did not, as such, apply to the company. Nevertheless, this is a case where the appellants have made an offer to all the existing shareholders and, what is more, in the ratio of 1:1. All that happened was since the company was advised that the authorised capital must be increased so that its A B C D E F G H capital requirements could be considered, the appellants decided to go in for increase in the authorised capital. The authorised capital was increased from Rs.1 crore to Rs.2 crores. She reminds us that this is a case where the Sheth Group quit in April, 2009 by resigning from the Board of Directors. They took away nearly 90 lakhs. On account of their activities, the company had run into rough weather. It was, in such circumstances, the need for increase in the authorised capital was felt. It is further pointed out that though the Sheth Group and the V.P. Patel Group attempted to impugn the decision to increase the authorised capital as an act of mismanagement and oppression, significantly, the NCLT and NCLAT have found no merit in the same. Therefore, once the increase in the capital was not found illegal or malafide, it is inexplicable, it is submitted, as to how the actual allotment of the shares could be found tainted. The rationale in the reasoning, viz., that the allotment was ‘defective’, was insupportable, it is contended. All the shareholders were given an equal opportunity to apply for shares in proportion to their existing shareholdings (1:1). They could apply for lesser number of shares. They could also apply for more number of shares. Lastly, they could exercise the choice to not apply for any shares at all. This choice was made available to all the shareholders across the Board falling in the three Groups. The fact of the matter is the Sheth group and the V.P. Patel Group did not apply. Without finding any illegality otherwise, the NCLT and NCLAT, it is contended, clearly erred.
6. Per contra, Shri Nitin Rai, learned Senior Counsel, would point out that the Court must bear in mind that the first respondent is a closely held company. It is more or less a quasi-partnership and it ran on trust. The authorised capital of the company was Rs.1 crore. Without the company, in the General Body Meeting, resolving to increase the authorised capital, there were no shares, which could have been allotted by the Board of Directors. In this regard, he sought support from Judgment of this Court reported in Nanalal Zaver and another v. Bombay Life Assurance Company Limited and another1. In other words, the authorised capital was increased by the decision of the General Body, only on 27.01.2010. However, the Board of Directors decided to allot shares, which were non-existent, prior to 27.01.2010. The action of the Board of Directors was unauthorised and impermissible in law. He further pointed out that even the V.P. Patel Group and also the Sheth
1 AIR 1950 SC 172
HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 252 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
Group had evinced and manifested their dispute in a formal manner with the Registrar of Companies. On account of the dealings of the appellants, the parties were at loggerheads. Though, the contents of the notice sent, was disputed, however, the matter was not pressed. It is further contended that the NCLT has found the allotment flawed. This is for the reason that under law, when allotment of further shares is made by the Board of Directors, the question of allotment of shares, which are not taken up by the shareholders, must be taken up only after the shareholders, in the first place, decline the allotment. In other words, in this case, the appellants have rolled-up the initial allotment, as also the issue relating to further allotment of shares in a single decision and notice. The NCLT has frowned upon the matter and rightly so. No prejudice will be caused, if impugned direction is upheld. He did take up the contention that the shares of the company were not got valued and it was issued on par, viz., at face value of Rs.10/-. The value did not do justice to the actual valuation of the company, which would have been on the higher side. But fairly, Shri Nitin Rai acknowledged that this aspect was not, as such, canvassed before the Tribunal. There is no offer made after 27.01.2010 he points out. He next complained that even proceeding on the basis that the decision to increase the authorised capital was well advised, it is noteworthy that only Rs.21 lakhs came in by way of the allotment of the additional capital. In other words, though the authorised capital was increased from Rs.1 crore to Rs.2 crores and the whole effort was purportedly to infuse fresh capital, in substance, only Rs.21 lakhs came into the coffers of the first respondent company. The additional capital offered was subscribed only in a sum of Rs.90 lakhs. Besides Rs.21 lakhs, which was brought in, the balance of Rs.69 lakhs was shown accounted by way of cancelling the loan due from the first respondent company to the appellants. This would nail the lie of the appellants that they had acted bonafide and in the best interest of the company. It is contended that the object of the appellants was to wrest control of a closely held company and it is this impermissible object, which alone will be frustrated by this Court upholding the concurrent directions of the NCLT and NCLAT.
7. Shri Malak Manish Bhat would echo the contentions addressed by Shri Nitin Rai. The fact that the company is closely held family and Group Unit, is stressed.
A B C D E F G H
ANALYSIS
8. On 24.11.2009, in response to the proposal for a term-loan made by the appellants, the Bank of Baroda, undoubtedly, communicated the following:
“1. We advise you to increase Share Capital for minimum level of Rs.2Crs.
2. We advise you to expand the board of directors so personal guarantee of additional eligible can be available to the bank for increase of bank’s exposure.
3. We request you to let us know the full details of Reserve and Surplus mentioned in your Balance Sheet as of 31.03.2009.”
9. On 08.12.2009, the first respondent company send a Notice to its Directors, four in number, viz., the appellants and Respondents 2 and 3 (the V.P. Patel Group). It must be remembered that the Directors representing the Sheth Group had resigned earlier in the year. The meeting was convened to take place on 18.12.2009. In the Agenda for the Meeting, we find the following, inter alia:
“2. To take note of letter dated 24th November 2009 received from Bank of Baroda, instructing Company to infuse additional funds by way of equity for proposal submitted for Term Loan.
3. To decide on the methology to increase the equity.
4. To consider increase in Authorised Share Capital of Company from Rs.1,00,00,000/- to Rs.2,00,00,000/-.”
10. The Meeting did take place on 18.12.2009. The Directors of the V.P. Patel Group, viz., Manish Patel and Krunal Patel were granted leave of absence. The first appellant Chaired the Meeting. The second appellant was the other participant as Director. The following is the Minutes of the Meeting:
“MINUTES OF MEETING OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
OF AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCT PRIVATE LIMITED HELD
ON 18TH DECEMBER, 2009 AT REGISTERED OFFICE OF
THE COMPANY AT RAJODA PO. BAVLA - 382 220
AHMEDABAD AT 11.00 A.M.
The following Directors were present:
HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 254 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
1. Mr. Hasmukhbhai Madhavlal Patel.
2. Mr. Dilipkumar M. Patel
1. CHAIRMAN OF THE MEETING
Mr. Hasmukhlal Patel, with the consent of the Directors present, chaired the meeting.
2. LEAVE OF ABSENCE
Leave of absence was granted to Mr. Manish Patel, Director and Mr. Krunal Patel, Director.
3. TAKE NOTE OF THE LETTER RECEIVED FROM
BANKOF BARODA:
It was informed to the Board that Company is in receipt of letter dated 24th November, 2009, advising Company to bring in additional equity of Rs. 100 Lacs in order meet its requirement for proposed Term Loan application. Copy of the letter received from the Bank duly initiated by the Chairman of the purpose of identification was put before the Board. The Board took note of the same.
4. TO DECIDE MEHODOLOGY TO INCREASE THE
EQUITY.
It was informed to the Board that in order to raise the equity it would be appropriate that initially offer is made to the existing shareholders. The Board discussed in detail and was of the opinion that the considering the present equity offer be made to exiting shareholders of Company to apply for one equity shares for every share held. It was then resolved as under:
RESOLVED that pursuant to the requirement of the fresh funds for expanding the business activity of the Company, Company be and is hereby authorized to issue 10,00,000 (Ten Lakh) equity shares of Rs. 10/- each at per to the existing shareholders in the ratio of one share for every share held.
RESOVLVED FURTHER that shareholders shall have right to apply for and in case of shares not being subscribed by any other shareholder be allotted to the shareholder who is willing to take additional shares.
A B C D E F G H RESOLVED FURTHER that a notice inviting the shareholders to subscribe for an get allotted their entitlement be forwarded to the shareholders in this regards and the same shall be considered for allotment upon authorized capital for the Company having been increased.”
11. Following this decision, Notice of Extraordinary General Meeting to be held on 27.01.2010, was given. The shareholders were informed that as decided in the Meeting on 18.12.2009, the company proposed to issue further shares to its existing members in the ratio of 1:1. Interested members were required to exercise their rights on or before the 05.02.2010. Next, it was indicated as follows:
“Please note that this is advance intimation and eligibility to apply for shares would be subject to approval of the increase in authorised capital by the shareholders in the EGM to be held on 27th January, 2010.
Application Form for applying shares is attached with this letter.”
12. The Special Business, viz., increasing the authorised capital was specified. The first appellant, as Chairman, was also authorised to give effect to the Resolutions.
13. The Application Form for applying and getting the equity shares in the first respondent company, pursuant to the decision dated 18.12.2009, may be noticed:
“APPLICATION FORM
AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCT PRIVATE LIMITED
NH-8, VILL. RAIODA: TALUKA: BAVLA: DIST:
AHMEDABAD
PIN:382220
Application for applying and getting equity shares allotted in Ambika Food product Private Limited pursuant to the decision taken by the Board of Directors in their meeting held on 18th December, 2009.
Name of the Share Holder:
HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 256 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
Address:
Folio No.:
Number of Share Held: equity share ofRs.10/- each at Par Number of Shares eligible for application: ___ equity shares Note for option to be exercised:
- Please tick on the appropriate option below - Only one option can be exercised - In correct and more than one selection shall invalidate the form and it shall be presumed that last option is exercised.
- In case of non-selection of any option, it shall be presumed, that last option is exercised.
1. I/We wish to apply for the full number of shares for which I/ We am/are eligible.
a. I/We enclose herewith an amount of Rs. _____ /- towards our subscription money by way of DD/PO/Cheque No. ___ dated ____ I I 2010.
b. We hereby authorized the company to convert the amount of unsecured deposit of Rs. _____ /- standing to our credit in the books of the Company.
2. We wish toapply for lesser no. __ Equity Shares from which I/ We am/are eligible.
a. I/We enclose herewith an amount of Rs. ——/- towards our subscription money by way of DD/PO/Cheque No .. ___ dated I / 2010.
b. We hereby authorize the company to convert the amount of unsecured deposit of Rs. _____ /- sanding to our credit in the books of the Company.
3. We wish to apply for higher no. __ Equity Shares from which I/We am/are eligible.
a. I/We enclose herewith an amount of Rs. ____/- towards our subscription money by way of DD/PO/Cheque No. ___ dated I 12010.
A B C D E F G H b. We hereby authorize the company to convert the amount of unsecured deposit of Rs. _____ /- sanding to our credit in the books of the Company.
4. We do not wish to apply for any shares of the company. I/We hereby agree to accept the Equity Shares applied for on such smaller number as may be allotted to me/us subject to the terms of Application Form and Articles of Association of the Company.
I/We undertake that I/We will sign all such other documents and do all such other acts. necessary on my/our part to enable me/us to be registered as the holder(s) of the Equity Shares which may be allotted to me/us. I/We authorized you to place my/our name(s) on the Register of Members of the Company as the holder(s) of the equity shares and to register and address(es) as given below. I/We note. that the Board of Directors are entitled in their absolute discretion to accept or reject this application in whole or in part without assigning any reason whatsoever.
I/We agree to the allotment of shares subject to the Rules, Regulations and Conditions laid down by Financial Institutions, Securities Exchange Board of India if any and Board of Directors of the Company.
I am/we are Indian National(s) resident in India and 1 am/we are not applying for Equity Shares as nominee(s) of any person resident abroad or a foreign national.
(Signature of First Holder) (Signature of Second Holder)
(Signature of Third Holder)
Date:
Place:
Note:
Above signatures should tally with the signatures on record.”
14. On 18.12.2009, the second respondent, viz., Manish Kumar V. Patel, wrote to the Registrar of Companies, Gujarat, requesting that the first respondent company be marked as a disputed company and not to take any documents, papers, forms, including e-forms, on record, as HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 258 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
per decision of majority, are not considered. It is stated in the letter that they would be deprived of their basic rights. It is stated that the appellants may increase the authorised capital and allot shares to them and fraudulently take the control of the company. It is further stated that they were in the process of convening Extraordinary General Meeting, to be held shortly, to inform the shareholders and resolve to remove the appellants from the MCA-21 Portal and Record of ROC.We find along with the same, a communication signed by shareholders, which combined the Sheth Group and the V.P. Patel Group and consisted of 68.98 per cent of the shares, supporting the letter seeking to treat the first respondent company as disputed company.
15. Next, we must notice the Minutes of the Extraordinary General Meeting of shareholders held on 27.01.2010. The appellants were the Members, who were present. There was no one from the Sheth Group or the V.P. Patel Group. The authorised share capital of the company was increased to Rs.2 crores. On the very same day, a Meeting took place of the Board of Directors. The appellants participated in the Meeting. Respondents 2 and 3 were given leave of absence. We find the following from the Minutes of the said Meeting:
“MINUTES OF MEETING OF THEBOARD OF DIRECTORS
OF AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTPRIVATE. LIMITED HELD
ON 27, JANUARY, 2010 ATREGISTERED OFFICE OF THE
COMPANY AT RA.JODA PO.BA VLA - 382 220
AHMEDABAD AT 03.00 P.M.
The following Directors were present:
1. Mr. HasmukhbhaiMadhavlal Patel.
2. Mr. Dilipkumar M. Patel
I. CHAIRMAN OF THE MEETING
Mr. Hasmukhlal Patel, with the consent of the Directors present,chaired the meeting.
2. LEAVEOF ABSENCE
Leave of absence was granted to Mr. Manish Patel, Director and Mr.Krunal Patel, Director.
3. OUT COME OF EXTRA ORDINARY GENERAL
MEETING:
A B C D E F G H It was informed to the Board that Share Holders of the Company haspassed Ordinary Resolution for increase in Authorized Share Capitalof theCompany from Rs. 1 ,00,00,000/- to Rs. 2,00,00,000/ -. TheBoard has took note of the same. Any one of the director of theCompany was then authorized to file the necessary Form 5 with theoffice of Registrar of Companies.
4.BOARD MEETING FOR ALLOTMENT OF SHARES:PROP
It was informed to the Board that as mentioned Shares Holders of theCompany has passed resolution for increase of Authorised ShareCapital and therefore, and as per the application and notice alreadycirculated the last date of receipt of application is 5th February, 2010.It is therefore. proposed to convene meeting of the Board of Directorsis proposed. to be held on 9th February, 20 l 0, for considering allotment of further issue of Equity Shares. The Board disuccsed the matter and decided to hold Board Meeting on 9th February, 2010. It was also informed to the Board that the Company is taking steps to inform the shareholders about the outcome of the meeting so that they can take immediate steps to subscribe to the equity.
5. VOTE OF THANKS:
There being no other business, the meeting ended with vote of thanks to the chair.
Date: 27.01.2010
DIRECTOR
(HASMUKHBHAI PA TEL)
CHAIRMAN”
(Emphasis supplied)
16. Pursuant to the same, it is the specific case of the appellants that the shareholders were sent Notices by Registered Post about the decision of the Extraordinary General Body Meeting so that they could take steps to subscribe to the additional capital sought to be raised. There is, indeed, evidence of the Notices. It is true that the respondents still dispute the receipt of the same.
17. On 09.02.2010, we find the following Minutes of the Meeting of the Board of Directors, of the said date:
HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 260 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
“MINUTES OF MEETING OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
OF AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCT PRIVATE LIMITED HELD
ON 9TH FEBRUARY, 2010 AT REGISTERED OFFICE OF THE
COMPANY AT RAJODA PO. BA VLA - 382 220
AHMEDABAD AT 11.00 A.M.
The following Directors were present:
l. Mr. Hasmukii’bhaiMadhavlal Patel.
2. Mr. Dilipkumar M. Patel
1 . CHAIRMAN OF THE MEETING
Mr. Hasmukhlal Patel, with the consent of the Directors present, chaired the meeting.
2. LEAVE OF ABSENCE
Leave of absence was granted to Mr. Manish Patel, Director and Mr. Krunal Patel, Director.
3. ALLOTMENT OF SAHRES:
It was informed to the Board that Company has received 7 Applications from Share Holders, who have shown their interest in further issue of Company. Some of the Share Holders has made application for higher number of shares then what were offered to.
The Board then considered the all application received and having found the same in order passed the following resolutions: RESOLVED THAT 9,00,000 Equity shares of Rs. 10/- (Ten Only)@ per be and are hereby allotted to the applicants as under:- Sr. No. Name of Allottee Name of Share Allotted
1. Himanshu Madhavlal Patel 165000
2. Varshaben Hasmukhlal Patel 140000
3. Dilipkukar Madhavlal Patel 149000
4. Jyotsna Dilipkumar Patel 185000
5. Nisatgkumar Hasmukhlal Patel 92000 A B C D E F G H
6. Bankimkumar Dilipkumar Patel 71000
7. Dishaben Hasmukhlal Patel 98000 Total 900000 RESOLVED FURTHER THAT company do issue necessary share certificates for the above shares within the stipulated period and Mr. Hasmukhlala Patel ad Mr. Dilipkumar Patel be and are authorised to sign the said certificates under the Common Seal of the Company.
RESOLVED FURTHER THAT the necessary Return of Allotment in Form 2 be filed with the Registrar of Companies, Gujarat.
Date: 09.02.2010
DIRECTOR
(HASMUKHBHAI PATEL)
CHAIRMAN”
THE FINDINGS OF THE NCLT
18. Answering the question, as to whether increase in the paid-up capital from Rs.1 crore to Rs.2 crores in the Extraordinary General Body Meeting dated 27.01.2010 was an act of oppression or not, the NCLT finds that Notices for the Board Meeting on 18.12.2009 were sent to all the Directors by registered post. In the Board Meeting on 18.12.2009, decision was taken to convene the shareholders meeting on 27.01.2010 to increase Authorised Share Capital. On the date of the Board Meeting itself, it was found that the V.P. Patel Group wrote to the Registrar of Companies that the H.M. Patel Group (appellants) is going to increase the Authorised Capital.Thus, V.P. Patel Group was having knowledge, it was found, of the proposal to increase the Authorised Capital. After noting the contention of the Sheth Group and V.P. Patel Group that they were insisting on the appellants sending communication by registered post, acknowledgment due, the Notice dated 08.12.2009 to convene the Board Meeting and Notice of the Extraordinary General Meeting dated 24.12.2009, were sent by registered post. The Tribunal finds that the V.P. Patel Group shareholders were having knowledge of the proposal to increase the share capital. The Sheth Group also, with knowledge, did not chose to participate in the Board Meeting on HASMUKHLAL MADHAVLAL PATEL v. AMBIKA FOOD PRODUCTS PVT. LTD. [K. M. JOSEPH, J.] A B C D E F G H 262 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 8 S.C.R.
18.12.2009 and the Extraordinary General Body Meeting on 27.01.2010. The Tribunal, therefore, rejected the contention of the V.P. Patel Group and the Sheth Group that they had not received Notice or had no knowledge of the Board Meeting on 18.12.2009 or the Extraordinary General Body Meeting on 27.01.2010. Next, the Tribunal finds that the Minutes of the Board Meeting and the Extraordinary General Body Meeting clearly show that after complying with the provisions of the Companies Act and Articles of Association, Resolutions were passed to increase the Authorised Share Capital. Pursuant thereto, Resolutions were passed to invite applications from shareholders. Increase in share capital and the allotments had not been given effect since no returns were recorded with the Registrar of Companies because of the objections of the V.P. Patel Group. Therefore, ‘the increase in the share capital and the allotment of shares itself and allotment of shares itself, is not an act of oppression of the rights of the V.P. Patel Group and the Sheth Group’, is found by the NCLT. It is further found that the removal of the appellants, as directed, was not valid and could not be upheld. Under the point, ‘outcome of financial irregularities alleged by the three Groups’, it is found that three Groups were at loggerheads. There appeared to be no possibility of the three Groups coming together and conducting affairs of the first respondent company. It is next pointed that the findings of the Tribunal would show that there are no established acts of oppression and mismanagement except some financial irregularities, which require examination by the Board of Directors. Thereafter, we have noticed the directions in paragraph-92 (supra).
19. Next, is the finding in the impugned Order in regard to allotment. The NCLAT also finds that the contention of the Sheth Group and V.P. Patel Group that they did not get Notice of the Extraordinary General Body Meeting, could not be believed. The need to increase the share capital and the circumstances, which led to it, canvassed by the appellants, including the letter dated 24.11.2009 issued by the Bank of Baroda, was found reliable. Dealing with the point pertinent to the Appeals before us, viz, the actual allotment of shares on increase of share capital, it is, inter alia, found that there did not appear to be any discussion by the NCLT regarding allotment of shares.
20. Next, the NCLAT finds that the allotment in the ratio of 1:1 may not be oppressive, it is found. However, the manner in which allotment is done, may be illegal and, thus, oppressive. The direction of the NCLT was found to be not without basis in the records. Referring to the forms A B C D E F G H for applying for shares, it is noted that they are dated 04.02.2010 and they show that the applications were not in the ratio of 1:1 but much beyond that. For example, it is stated that the wife of the first appellant was having just 20 equity shares. She applied for 98000 equity shares. The contention of the V.P. Patel Group that the members of the appellant Group calculated in advance and applied so as to consume the whole of the increased share capital, anticipating in advance that they can get it, is noted. A reference was made to the Articles of Association and therein the following Article referring to General Authority is referred to as follows:
“General Authority Wherever in the Companies Act, 1956 it has been provided that the Company shall have any right, privilege or authority or that Company can not carry out any transaction unless the Company is so authorised by its Articles then in that case, Articles hereby authorise and empower the Company to have such rights, privilege or authority and to carry out such transaction as have been permitted by the Companies Act, 1956.”
21. The argument that in view of the Article, Section 81 of the Act would apply, is noted. It is further noted that even if the appellants had issued Notice in anticipation of the members to apply on increase of share capital, which was, till that point of time, not decided, the offer could not have been of more than 1:1 and the right procedure would have been that after the share capital was increased, claims of 1:1 should have been considered and only, thereafter, the unsubscribed portion, could be offered. The argument based on Dale & Carrington Invt. (P) Ltd. and another v. P.K. Prathapan and others2, was noted.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.