Balu Sudam Khalde & Anr v. The State of Maharashtra
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 314; [2023] 6 S.C.R. 851
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice J.B. Pardiwala Penal Code, Justice Imprisonment, Justice However
- Decided
- 29 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1910/2010
- Sections
- 302, 300, 6, 34, 323, 324, 504, 313, 27, 304, 8, 365
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 851[2023] 6 S.C.R. 851
BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR.
v.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
(Criminal Appeal No. 1910 of 2010)
MARCH 29, 2023
[SUDHANSHU DHULIA AND J.B. PARDIWALA, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860:
ss. 302 r/w 34 – Prosecution case that verbal altercation between the parties resulting in a fight wherein first informant assaulted on the head and the deceased suffered severe assault and succumbed to his injuries – Appellants convicted u/s 302 r/w 34, and sentenced to life imprisonment, however, acquittal of A-2 and A-4 – High Court upheld the order – Interference with – Held: Not called for – Oral evidence of all the three eyewitnesses is consistent and no good reason for the court to disbelieve the ocular version as narrated by the three eyewitnesses – Courts below recorded a concurrent finding that they are reliable witnesses – Suggestions put by the defence counsel in the cross-examination of the eyewitnesses establishes the presence of first informant at the scene of offence and the factum of assault could also be said to have been admitted – PW 3 could be termed as a res gestae witness – ss. 6 and 7 of the 1872 Act, in so far as, the admissibility of a statement of the PW-3 is concerned, would be attracted – Having regard to the nature of the injuries, they were caused by dangerous weapons which, were applied on the vital part of the body, it is a case of s. 302 – Case would not fall within the exception 4 to s. 300 – Assuming that the incident had occurred in the heat of the moment and fight was also sudden, the fact that the appellants inflicted as many as nine blows with a dangerous weapon on the deceased who was unarmed and was helpless should not be overlooked – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.6 and 7.
Exception 4 to Section 300 – Applicability of – Held: To bring a case within Exception 4 all the ingredients mentioned in it must be found.
A B C D E F G H 852 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
Evidence:
Oral Evidence – Evidentiary value of – Held: Appreciation of ocular evidence is a hard task – There is no fixed or straightjacket formula for appreciation of the ocular evidence – In assessing the value of the evidence of the eyewitnesses, two principal considerations are whether, in the circumstances of the case, it is possible to believe their presence at the scene of occurrence or in such situations as would make it possible for them to witness the facts deposed to by them and secondly, whether there is anything inherently improbable or unreliable in their evidence.
Cross-examination – Concession or admission of fact by defence counsel – Nature – of – Held: Any concession or admission of a fact by a defence counsel would definitely be binding on his client, except the concession on the point of law – Thus, the suggestion made by the defence counsel to a witness in the crossexamination if found to be incriminating in nature in any manner would definitely bind the accused – Accused cannot get away on the plea that his counsel had no implied authority to make suggestions in the nature of admissions against his client.
Doctrines/Principles: Principle of Res Gestae – Rule of – Held: Rule embodied in s. 6 is usually known as the rule of res gestae – It means that a fact which, though not in issue, is so connected with the fact in issue “as to form part of the same transaction” becomes relevant by itself – Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.6 and 7.
Dismissing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 The appreciation of ocular evidence is a hard task. There is no fixed or straight-jacket formula for appreciation of the ocular evidence. [Para 25][865-E] 1.2 In assessing the value of the evidence of the eyewitnesses, two principal considerations are whether, in the circumstances of the case, it is possible to believe their presence at the scene of occurrence or in such situations as would make it possible for them to witness the facts deposed to by them and secondly, whether there is anything inherently improbable or unreliable in their evidence. In respect of both these A B C D E F G H considerations, circumstances either elicited from those witnesses themselves or established by other evidence tending to improbabilise their presence or to discredit the veracity of their statements, will have a bearing upon the value which a Court would attach to their evidence. Although in cases where the plea of the accused is a mere denial, the evidence of the prosecution witnesses has to be examined on its own merits, where the accused raise a definite plea or put forward a positive case which is inconsistent with that of the prosecution, the nature of such plea or case and the probabilities in respect of it will also have to be taken into account while assessing the value of the prosecution evidence. [Para 27][868-C-E] 1.3 The oral evidence of all the three eyewitnesses PW 1, 2, 3 is consistent and there is no good reason for the Court to disbelieve the ocular version as narrated by the three eyewitnesses. The trial court as well as the High Court looked into the oral evidence of all the three eyewitnesses closely and have recorded a concurrent finding that they are reliable witnesses. [Para 28][868-F-G] 1.4 In the exercise of the power under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, this Court, normally would not interfere with the concurrent findings of fact, except in very special circumstances or in the case of a gross error committed by the courts below. Only where the High Court ignores or overlooks “crying circumstances” and “proven facts” or “violates and misapplies well established principles of criminal jurisprudence” or refuses to give benefit of doubt to the accused persons, etc., would this Court step in to correct the legally erroneous decisions. Interferance is not only for the reason that this Court may arrive at a different conclusion, unless, there are compelling circumstances to tinker with conclusions drawn and that the accused were innocent/guilty. There are limitations in interfering with the findings of conviction, concurrent in nature. [Para 30][871-C-E] 1.5 The suggestion made by the defence counsel to a witness in the cross-examination if found to be incriminating in nature in any manner would definitely bind the accused and the accused cannot get away on the plea that his counsel had no implied BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA
A B C D E F G H 854 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
authority to make suggestions in the nature of admissions against his client. Any concession or admission of a fact by a defence counsel would definitely be binding on his client, except the concession on the point of law. The submission that an answer by a witness to a suggestion made by the defence counsel in the cross-examination does not deserve any value or utility if it incriminates the accused in any manner cannot be accepted. [Para 38, 39][873-B-D] 1.6 It is a cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence that the initial burden to establish the case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt rests on the prosecution. It is also an elementary principle of law that the prosecution has to prove its case on its own legs and cannot derive advantage or benefit from the weakness of the defence. This Court is not suggesting for a moment that if prosecution is unable to prove its case on its own legs then the Court can still convict an accused on the strength of the evidence in the form of reply to the suggestions made by the defence counsel to a witness. In the instant case, the conclusion is reached that the evidence of the three eyewitnesses inspires confidence and there is nothing in their evidence on the basis of which it could be said that they are unreliable witnesses. Having reached to such a conclusion, to fortify the view the suggestions made by the defence counsel to the eyewitnesses can be looked into, the reply to those establishing the presence of the accused persons as well as the eyewitnesses in the night hours. To put it in other words, suggestions by itself are not sufficient to hold the accused guilty if they are incriminating in any manner or are in the form of admission in the absence of any other reliable evidence on record. It is true that a suggestion has no evidentiary value but this proposition of law would not hold good at all times and in a given case during the course of cross-examination the defence counsel may put such a suggestion the answer to which may directly go against the accused and this is exactly what happened in the instant case. [Para 40][873-E-H; 874-A] 1.7 The principle of law that in a criminal case, a lawyer has no implied authority to make admissions against his client during the progress of the trial would hold good only in cases where A B C D E F G H dispensation of proof by the prosecution is not permissible in law. It is obligatory on the part of the prosecution to prove the post mortem report by examining the doctor. The accused cannot admit the contents of the post mortem report thereby absolving the prosecution from its duty to prove the contents of the same in accordance with law by examining the doctor. This is so because if the evidence per se is inadmissible in law then a defence counsel has no authority to make it admissible with his consent. Therefore, the suggestions made to the witness by the defence counsel and the reply to such suggestions would definitely form part of the evidence and can be relied upon by the Court along with other evidence on record to determine the guilt of the accused. [Para 41, 42][874-B-D] 1.8 The main object of cross-examination is to find out the truth on record and to help the Court in knowing the truth of the case. It is a matter of common experience that many a times the defence lawyers themselves get the discrepancies clarified arising during the cross-examination in one paragraph and getting themselves contradicted in the other paragraph. The line of crossexamination is always on the basis of the defence which the counsel would keep in mind to defend the accused. [Para 43][874- E] 1.9 During the course of cross-examination with a view to discredit the witness or to establish the defence on preponderance of probabilities suggestions are hurled on the witness but if such suggestions, the answer to those incriminate the accused in any manner then the same would definitely be binding and could be taken into consideration along with other evidence on record in support of the same. However, it would all depend upon the nature of the suggestions and with what idea in mind such suggestions are made to the witness. [Para 44, 45][875- F-G] 1.10 In the cross-examination of the PW-3 a suggestion was put to him that he had inquired with PW-1 as to what had happened and PW-1 in turn narrated the incident to PW-3. This suggestion put by the defence counsel to the PW-3 was answered in the affirmative. This part of the evidence of the PW-3 is corroborated by the evidence of the PW-1. The reason for BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA
A B C D E F G H 856 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
referring to the said a piece of evidence is that the PW 3 could be termed as a res gestae witness. This principle of res gestae is embodied in Section 6 of the Act 1872. What it means is that a fact which, though not in issue, is so connected with the fact in issue “as to form part of the same transaction” becomes relevant by itself. To form particular statement as part of the same transaction utterances must be simultaneous with the incident or substantial contemporaneous that is made either during or immediately before or after its occurrence. Sections 6 and 7 of the Act 1872 in the facts and circumstances of the case, in so far as, the admissibility of a statement of the PW-3 coming to know about incident, immediately from the PW-1 that AB had been seriously assaulted and that PW-1 had also suffered injuries and admitted by the PW-1 in his evidence would be attracted with all its rigour. [Paras 46, 47, 49 and 50][876-E-G; 877-A; 878-D-F] 1.11 There is no dispute that the death of the deceased occurred due to culpable homicide and not due to accident or suicide. The sine qua non for the application of an Exception to Section 300 always is that it is a case of murder but the accused claims the benefit of the Exception to bring it out of that Section and to make it a case of culpable homicide not amounting to murder. Therefore, it is assumed that this would be a case of murder and it is for the accused to show the applicability of the Exception. [Para 57][890-E] 1.12 The extent of injuries suffered by the deceased is noticed, as it appears from the deposition of the PW 7 who carried out the post mortem. Having regard to the nature of the injuries caused by dangerous weapons like sickle and sword which, were applied on the vital part of the body, there is no escape from the conclusion that it is a case of Section 302 IPC.[Para 60][891-B- C] 1.13 The submission that the case would fall within the Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC and such benefit be extended to the accused cannot be accepted. Assuming for the moment that the incident had occurred in the heat of the moment and fight was also sudden, the fact that the appellants inflicted as many as nine blows with a dangerous weapon on the deceased who was A B C D E F G H unarmed and was helpless should not be overlooked. For cases to fall within clause (3) of Section 300 IPC, it is not necessary that the offender intended to cause death, so long as the death ensues from the intentional bodily injury or injuries sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Thus, no case is made out by the appellants to interfere with the impugned judgment and order of the High Court. [Para 61, 62][891-C-F] Bharwada Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai v. State of Gujarat AIR 1983 SC 753 : [1983] 3 SCR 280; Leela Ram v. State of Haryana AIR 1995 SC 3717; Tahsildar Singh v. State of UP AIR 1959 SC 1012 : [1959] Suppl. SCR 875 – relied on.
Rakesh Kumar alias Babli v. State of Haryana (1987) 2 SCC 34; Tarun Bora alias Alok Hazarika v. State of Assam 2002 Cri. LJ 4076; Rajwant Singh v. State of Kerala AIR 1966 SC 1874 : [1966] Suppl. SCR 230;
State of Andhra Pradesh v. Rayavarapu Punnayya and Another (1976) 4 SCC 382 : [1977] 1 SCR 601; Sukhar v. State of U.P. (1999) 9 SCC 507 : [1999] 3 Suppl.
SCR 314; Govind s/o Soneram v. State of M.P. (DB)
2005 Cri.LJ 1244; Parkash Chand v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2004) 11 SCC 381 : [2004] 3 Suppl. SCR 389 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1983] 3 SCR 280 relied on Para 25 AIR 1995 SC 3717 relied on Para 25 [1959] Suppl. SCR 875 relied on Para 25 (1987) 2 SCC 34 referred to Para 37 [1999] 3 Suppl. SCR 314 referred to Para 48 [1977] 1 SCR 601 referred to Para 54 [2004] 3 Suppl. SCR 389 referred to Para 56 [1966] Suppl. SCR 230 referred to Para 61 BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA
A B C D E F G H 858 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
1910 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 02.03.2009 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in CRLA No. 637 of 2003.
K. L. Janjani, Pankaj Kumar Singh, Dr. Vinod Kumar Tewari, Kailash J. Kashyap, Advs. for the Appellants.
Abhikalp Pratap Singh, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Ms. Shreya Saxena, Ms. Yamini Singh, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
J. B. PARDIWALA, J.
1. This appeal by special leave is at the instance of two convict persons and is directed against the judgment and order dated 02.03.2009 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Criminal Appeal No. 637 of 2003 by which the High Court dismissed the criminal appeal referred to above, and thereby affirmed the order of conviction and the consequence sentence dated 12.03.2003 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Pune dated 12.03.2003 in Sessions Case No. 323 of 2001, by convicting both the appellants herein for the offence under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, ‘the IPC’) and sentencing them to suffer life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1000/- each with the stipulation that in default of payment of the fine they would undergo rigorous imprisonment for further six months.
2. It may not be out of place to state at this stage that in all four persons were put to trial including the two appellants herein in the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Pune for the offence punishable under Sections 302 and 323 read with Section 34 of the IPC. The appellants herein are original accused Nos. 1 and 3 resply. The original accused No. 2 and 4 resply were acquitted by the Trial Court.
CASE OF THE PROSECUTION
3. The case of the prosecution as unfolded in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses and also detailed in the first information report is that on the fateful day of the incident i.e., on 01.04.2001 at about 11.15 p.m., the first informant PW 1, namely, Asgar Shaikh (Ex. 7) was chit chatting with his friend Abbas Baig (deceased). At that time, while the A B C D E F G H appellant No. 2 herein accompanied by few other individuals was passing by the side, he was accosted by the deceased Abbas. There was some verbal altercation between the two. After sometime the appellant No. 2 herein accompanied by the appellant No. 1 herein and the other two coaccused who came to be acquitted by the Trial Court reached at the spot. A fight ensued in which, the first informant PW 1 Asgar Shaikh was assaulted on his head by means of weapons like sickle and sword. This assault on the head of the first informant PW 1 is alleged to have been laid by the appellant No. 1 herein. The first informant suffered a bleeding injury on his head. Thereafter, a severe assault was laid on the deceased Abbas Baig by means of a sickle and sword. It is the case of the prosecution that the appellants herein had dangerous weapons in their hands in the form of a sword and sickle. The deceased Abbas Baig suffered serious injuries on his body and ultimately succumbed to such injuries.
4. A first information report was lodged on 2.04.2002 by the PW 1 at around 2 a.m. i.e., just within three hours from the time of the incident. The deceased Abbas Baig having suffered serious bleeding injuries was taken to the hospital in a rickshaw owned by the PW 3, namely, Nasir Khan. The deceased upon reaching the hospital was declared dead.
5. The FIR Exh. 8 lodged by the PW 1 viz. Asgar Shaikh reads thus:- “I Ajgar Ibrahim Shaikh aged 22 years, Occupation Turner, residing at 54 BP/251 Lohia Nagar, slum area, Pune. I hereby lodge my complaint as under:
I am residing at the aforementioned address with my mother, father and sister. I have been working as a turner past three years in the workshop owned by Abdul Wahab Shaikh situated at Guruwar Peth, Pune in the name of New Quality Instruments. Yesterday, i.e., on 1.4.2001, I left my house at 9.00 AM for reporting at the workshop. I worked out at the workshop for whole day and came back at 7.00 PM. I had my dinner at 11.15 PM in the night and thereafter went outside as I wanted to have paanmasala. When I reached somewhere near the shop by name Shri Sai Car Auto Consultant, I met my friend Abbas Baig (deceased) also a resident of BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 860 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
Lohianagar, slum area, Pune. I started cheating with my friend Abbas. At that point of time, Santosh Khalde and one another boy were passing through the place where, we were talking. My friend Abbas saw Santosh and told me that “Itni Raat Ko Maa Chudane Ke Liye Kaha Ja Raha Hai? Tumhara plan kya hai”. Santosh replied that he had no plan and was proceeding to answer nature’s call. At around 11.45 PM, four persons, namely, Balu Khalde, Ramesh Mohite, Raju Mohite and Santosh Khalde assembled and started talking with us. At that time, Balu khale told him “Bajula Haat”. Abbas Baig told Balu Khalde that “Usse kya baat kar raha hai?” talk to me. At that time, I told them “Kaiko Lafda Kar Rahe Ho?” Balu Khalde took out a weapon like Koita which he had hidden in his waist and hit me on my head. Ramesh Mohite caught hold of Abbas Baig and Balu Khalde stabbed him with a small bladed sword. We started shouting. One Firoz Babumian Shaikh residing in the neighbourhood came out of his house and told Raju Mohite “What are you fighting about?” Santosh Khalde abused Firoz Babumian. When people started assembling at the place of the occurrence, all the four assailants ran away. Abbas Baig was seriously injured and he fell down. He had suffered injuries on his left paw, wrist, right hand and right shoulder. He was bleeding profusely. I picked up Abbas in an injured condition and took him nearby chokadi. At that point of time, one Nasir a rickshaw driver known to us also living in the same slum came over there. I requested Nasir to keep a watch on Abbas Baig as he would reach and call the police. Accordingly, I alongwith Firoz Shaikh went to Lohianagar Police Station and informed about the incidence to the police. The police arrived and immediately shifted Abbas Baig to the nearby Sassoon Hospital. However, Abbas Baig was declared dead by the doctor at the hospital.”
6. The inquest panchnama of the dead body of the deceased was drawn at the hospital itself. As a part of the investigation, the scene of offence panchnama was drawn. The clothes of the deceased stained with blood were collected and sent to the forensic science laboratory for chemical analysis. All the four accused were arrested by the police. The clothes of all the accused were collected and sent to the FSL. The dead body of the deceased was sent for post mortem. While the appellants A B C D E F G H herein were in police custody, they are said to have made statements on their own free will and volition that they would show the place where they had concealed the weapons of offence i.e. the sickle and the sword. Ultimately, the discovery panchnamas were drawn in presence of the panch witnesses. The statements of various other witnesses were recorded by the police.
7. At the end of the investigation chargesheet was filed for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC, in the Court of the learned Magistrate. The learned Magistrate committed the case to the Court of Sessions as the offence was exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions.
8. The Trial Court framed the following charge vide Exh.8. The translated version of the charges framed against the appellants are quoted below:
“1. That you accused Nos. 1 to 4, on 01.04.2001, at about 11.45 P.M. or thereabout, at Plot No. 54/BP, Lohiyanagar, Pune, in front of shop named as Shri Sai Car Auto Consultant, either individually or in furtherance of your common intention, did commit murder, by intentionally or knowingly causing the death of Abbas Sanaulla Beg, and thereby committed an offence punishable either under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code simpliciter or Section 302 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code, and within my cognizance.
AND
2) That you accused Nos. 1 to 4, on the aforesaid day, date, time and place and during the course of the same transaction, either individually or in furtherance of your common intention, voluntarily caused hurt to complainant Ajgar Ibrahim Shaikh, and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code simplicetor or Section 323 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, and within my cognizance. “
AND
3) That you accused Nos. 1 to 4, on the aforesaid day, date, time and place and during the course of the same transaction, either individually or in furtherance of your common BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 862 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
intention, voluntarily caused hurt to complainant Ajgar Ibrahim Shaikh, by means of sickle and sword, which if used as a weapon of offence, would likely to cause death of said complainant, and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 324 of the Indian Penal Code simplicetor or Section 324 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, and within my cognizance.
AND
4) That you accused Nos. 1 to 4, on the aforesaid day, date, time and place and during the course of the same transaction, either individually or in furtherance of your common intention, intentionally insulted and thereby gave protection to the complainant Ajgar Ibrahim Shaikh, intending or knowing it to be likely that such provocation will cause the said complainant to commit breach of public peace, and thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 504 of the Indian Penal Code simplicetor or Section 504 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and within my cognizance.
AND I hereby direct that you be tried by me on the aforesaid charges.”
9. The prosecution adduced the following oral evidence in support of its case:
(1) PW 1 Asgar Shaikh - Ex. 7
(2) PW 2 Firoj Shaikh- Ex. 9
(3) PW 3 Nasir Khan - Ex. 10
(4) PW 4 Aslam Khan- Ex. 11
(5) PW 5 Mahesh Kumar Jain- Ex. 14
(6) PW 6 Suhas Kalase- Ex. 15
(7) PW 7 Dr. Shrikant Chandekar- Ex. 18
(8) PW 8 Mubarak Baig- Ex. 21
(9) PW 9 Mahendr Arokade- Ex. 22
(10) PW 10 Baba Shaikh- Ex. 38 A B C D E F G H
10. The following pieces of documentary evidence were adduced by the prosecution:
(i) Inquest Panchnama
(ii) Post mortem report
(iii) Spot Panchnama (scene of offence panchnama)
(iv) Arrest and Personal search
(v) Seizure of clothes of complainant
(vi) Seizure of clothes of deceased
11. After completion of the oral as well as the documentary evidence of the prosecution, the statements of the appellants herein under Section 313 of the Code, of Criminal Procedure (for short, ‘the CrPC’) were recorded in which the appellants herein stated that the complaint was a false one. They further stated in their written statement under Section 313 of the CrPC that they were workers of one Hindi Ekta Mandal. On 09.03.2001, tension mounted between the Hindus and the Muslims as some people from the minority community damaged the idol of Ganesh. A report with the police was lodged in that regard. In such circumstances, the witnesses deposed falsely against them.
12. At the conclusion of the trial, the learned Trial Judge convicted the appellants herein for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and sentenced both as stated hereinbefore. The original accused Nos. 2 and 4 were ordered to be acquitted of all the charges.
13. In such circumstances referred to above, the two appellants are here before this Court with the present appeal.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF FOF THE APPELLANTS
14. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants vehemently submitted that the High Court committed a serious error in dismissing the appeal filed by the two appellants herein against the judgment and order of conviction passed by the Trial Court. According to the learned counsel, the High Court failed to appreciate that no reliance could have been placed on the evidence of the so called eyewitnesses. According to the learned counsel, the ocular version on record does not inspire any confidence and deserves to be discarded.
BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 864 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
15. The learned counsel further submitted that the very presence of the first informant PW 1 Asgar Shaikh is doubtful because although he claims to have suffered an injury on his head during the assault yet no medical treatment was taken by him and there is no medical certificate on record that he had suffered any injury on his head. In such circumstances, according to the learned counsel, the entire first information report, at the instance of the PW 1 is unreliable.
16. The learned counsel further submitted that the discovery of the weapons under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (for short, ‘the Act 1872’) could also not have been relied upon as the panch witnesses failed to support the case of the prosecution or rather failed to prove the contents of the panchnama.
17. In the last, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants vehemently submitted that even if the entire case of the prosecution is believed to be true, the case at the most would be one of culpable homicide not amounting to murder. According to the learned counsel, the case falls within the purview of Exception 4 to Section 300 of the IPC.
18. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel prays that there being merit in his appeal, the same may be allowed and the appellants be acquitted of all the charges. In the alternative, he prayed that the conviction may be altered from one under Section 302 of the IPC to Section 304 Part 1 of the IPC by giving benefit of Exception 4 to the Section 300 of the IPC.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
19. Mr. Abhikalp Pratap Singh, the learned counsel appearing for the State of Maharashtra, on the other hand has vehemently opposed this appeal submitting that no error not to speak of any error of law can be said to have been committed by the High Court in dismissing the appeal thereby affirming the order of conviction and the consequence sentence passed by the Trial Court.
20. He would submit that there is no good reason to doubt the ocular version of the eyewitnesses, which has come on record. He further submitted that was no good reason for the eyewitnesses to falsely implicate the appellants herein in the alleged crime.
21. The learned counsel submitted that no case is made out to bring the case within the ambit of Exception 4 to Section 300 of the IPC. A B C D E F G H He vehemently submitted that as many as nine injuries were inflicted on the body of the deceased by dangerous weapons like sickle and sword. The appellants herein can be said to have taken undue advantage and acted in a cruel manner.
22. In the last, the learned counsel appearing for the State submitted that the discovery of the weapons points towards the conduct of the accused persons and such conduct is a relevant fact under Section 8 of the Act 1872 which taken together with the ocular version supports the case of the prosecution in toto.
23.In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel appearing for the State prayed that there being no merit in the present appeal, the same may be dismissed.
ANALYSIS
24. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment and order.
APPRECIATION OF ORAL EVIDENCE
25. The appreciation of ocular evidence is a hard task. There is no fixed or straight-jacket formula for appreciation of the ocular evidence. The judicially evolved principles for appreciation of ocular evidence in a criminal case can be enumerated as under:
“I. While appreciating the evidence of a witness, the approach must be whether the evidence of the witness read as a whole appears to have a ring of truth. Once that impression is formed, it is undoubtedly necessary for the Court to scrutinize the evidence more particularly keeping in view the deficiencies, drawbacks and infirmities pointed out in the evidence as a whole and evaluate them to find out whether it is against the general tenor of the evidence given by the witness and whether the earlier evaluation of the evidence is shaken as to render it unworthy of belief. II. If the Court before whom the witness gives evidence had the opportunity to form the opinion about the general tenor of evidence given by the witness, the appellate court which had not this benefit will have to attach due weight to the appreciation of evidence by the trial court and unless there are reasons weighty and formidable BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 866 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
it would not be proper to reject the evidence on the ground of minor variations or infirmities in the matter of trivial details. III. When eye-witness is examined at length it is quite possible for him to make some discrepancies. But courts should bear in mind that it is only when discrepancies in the evidence of a witness are so incompatible with the credibility of his version that the court is justified in jettisoning his evidence.
IV. Minor discrepancies on trivial matters not touching the core of the case, hyper technical approach by taking sentences torn out of context here or there from the evidence, attaching importance to some technical error committed by the investigating officer not going to the root of the matter would not ordinarily permit rejection of the evidence as a whole.
V. Too serious a view to be adopted on mere variations falling in the narration of an incident (either as between the evidence of two witnesses or as between two statements of the same witness) is an unrealistic approach for judicial scrutiny.
VI. By and large a witness cannot be expected to possess a photographic memory and to recall the details of an incident. It is not as if a video tape is replayed on the mental screen. VII. Ordinarily it so happens that a witness is overtaken by events. The witness could not have anticipated the occurrence which so often has an element of surprise. The mental faculties therefore cannot be expected to be attuned to absorb the details. VIII. The powers of observation differ from person to person. What one may notice, another may not. An object or movement might emboss its image on one person’s mind whereas it might go unnoticed on the part of another.
IX. By and large people cannot accurately recall a conversation and reproduce the very words used by them or heard by them. They can only recall the main purport of the conversation. It is unrealistic to expect a witness to be a human tape recorder. X. In regard to exact time of an incident, or the time duration of an occurrence, usually, people make their estimates by guess work on the spur of the moment at the time of interrogation. And one cannot expect people to make very precise or reliable estimates A B C D E F G H in such matters. Again, it depends on the time-sense of individuals which varies from person to person.
XI. Ordinarily a witness cannot be expected to recall accurately the sequence of events which take place in rapid succession or in a short time span. A witness is liable to get confused, or mixed up when interrogated later on.
XII. A witness, though wholly truthful, is liable to be overawed by the court atmosphere and the piercing cross examination by counsel and out of nervousness mix up facts, get confused regarding sequence of events, or fill up details from imagination on the spur of the moment. The sub-conscious mind of the witness sometimes so operates on account of the fear of looking foolish or being disbelieved though the witness is giving a truthful and honest account of the occurrence witnessed by him.
XIII. A former statement though seemingly inconsistent with the evidence need not necessarily be sufficient to amount to contradiction. Unless the former statement has the potency to discredit the later statement, even if the later statement is at variance with the former to some extent it would not be helpful to contradict that witness.”
[See Bharwada Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai v. State of Gujarat 1983 Cri LJ 1096 : (AIR 1983 SC 753) Leela Ram v. State of Haryana AIR 1995 SC 3717 and Tahsildar Singh v. State of UP (AIR 1959 SC 1012)]
26. When the evidence of an injured eye-witness is to be appreciated, the under-noted legal principles enunciated by the Courts are required to be kept in mind:
(a) The presence of an injured eye-witness at the time and place of the occurrence cannot be doubted unless there are material contradictions in his deposition.
(b) Unless, it is otherwise established by the evidence, it must be believed that an injured witness would not allow the real culprits to escape and falsely implicate the accused.
(c) The evidence of injured witness has greater evidentiary value and unless compelling reasons exist, their statements are not to be discarded lightly.
BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 868 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
(d) The evidence of injured witness cannot be doubted on account of some embellishment in natural conduct or minor contradictions.
(e) If there be any exaggeration or immaterial embellishments in the evidence of an injured witness, then such contradiction, exaggeration or embellishment should be discarded from the evidence of injured, but not the whole evidence.
(f) The broad substratum of the prosecution version must be taken into consideration and discrepancies which normally creep due to loss of memory with passage of time should be discarded.
27. In assessing the value of the evidence of the eyewitnesses, two principal considerations are whether, in the circumstances of the case, it is possible to believe their presence at the scene of occurrence or in such situations as would make it possible for them to witness the facts deposed to by them and secondly, whether there is anything inherently improbable or unreliable in their evidence. In respect of both these considerations, circumstances either elicited from those witnesses themselves or established by other evidence tending to improbabilise their presence or to discredit the veracity of their statements, will have a bearing upon the value which a Court would attach to their evidence. Although in cases where the plea of the accused is a mere denial, the evidence of the prosecution witnesses has to be examined on its own merits, where the accused raise a definite plea or put forward a positive case which is inconsistent with that of the prosecution, the nature of such plea or case and the probabilities in respect of it will also have to be taken into account while assessing the value of the prosecution evidence.
28. Keeping the aforesaid principles of law in mind, we looked into the oral evidence of all the three important witnesses i.e., PW 1 Asgar Shaikh (Exh. 7), PW 2 Firoz Babumiyan Shaikh (Exh. 9) and PW 3 Nasir Khan (Exh. 10). The oral evidence of all the three eyewitnesses is consistent and there is no good reason for us to disbelieve the ocular version as narrated by the three eyewitnesses. The Trial Court as well as the High Court looked into the oral evidence of all the three eyewitnesses referred to above closely and have recorded a concurrent finding that they are reliable witnesses.
29. The High Court in its impugned judgment observed in paras 9 and 10 resply as under:
A B C D E F G H “9. First, it is argued on behalf of the Appellants the learned Counsel that the substantive evidence of P.W. Nos. 1 and 2, alleged eyewitnesses cannot be taken as trustworthy, in as much as they are interested and related witnesses to the deceased Abbas Baig. Secondly, it is argued that there was no immediate disclosure of the names of the accused persons when the injured Abbas was brought to Lohiyanagar Police Chowki and when said Abbas and both the injured P.W. Nos. 1 and 2 were sent to Sasoon Hospital for medical treatment no history of assault was given. Thirdly, it is argued that P.W. 1, complainant had improved on his story by mentioning that Abbas had sustained injuries on his head and it was not so mentioned by him while giving his complaint. Fourthly, it is argued that the main vital injury was in the normal course of events, sufficient to cause the death of Abbas is injury No.9 as per the Post Mortem report was attributed to only accused No.3 i.e. Appellant No.2 as it was made by use of a sword and as such it was not the injury inflicted by Appellant No.1 accused. By canvassing such last argument, it emphasized on behalf of the Appellant that the death of Abbas was caused due to the injury at serial no. 9 in the Post Mortem report and as such the Appellant accused No.1 could not be held responsible for the death of Abbas, further argued.
10. While dealing with such arguments, on behalf of the Appellants as mentioned above, we have carefully gone through the substantive evidence of P.W.1 and 2 and also of the incidental witness, corroborating the major part of the events i.e. P.W.No.3 and it must be said that immediately after reaching Lohianagar Police Chowki a complaint was lodged by P.W.1 and by that time said Abbas was also brought to the Police Chowki and was subsequently referred to Sasoon Hospital for treatment, however, declared, dead on admission. It is also in the substantive evidence of P.W.1 that he and P.W.2 attended the Sasoon Hospital along with police yadi for getting treatment, it is a factual position that there is no medical certificate brought on record by the prosecution regarding injury sustained by P.W. Nos. 1 and 2 and as such factual position prompted the Sessions Court to hold that there was no charge established for the offence punishable under BALU SUDAM KHALDE & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 870 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
Section 324 read with Section 34 of Indian Penal Code for the assault on the witness No. 1, the complainant. It is also observed that the death of Abbas was due to multiple injuries though as opined by the Medical Officer, P.W. No.7, the main injury which could have in the normal course caused death of Abbas, is injury No.9 mentioned in the Post Mortem report. In other words, it must be said that all the injuries sustained by Abbas were the cause of his resultant death and that a role was attributed to the accused Appellants using the respective weapons i.e. Article No.16 sickle and Article No. 17 a sword.”
30. In the exercise of the power under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, this Court, normally would not interfere with the concurrent findings of fact, except in very special circumstances or in the case of a gross error committed by the courts below. Only where the High Court ignores or overlooks “crying circumstances” and “proven facts” or “violates and misapplies well established principles of criminal jurisprudence” or refuses to give benefit of doubt to the accused persons, etc., would this Court step in to correct the legally erroneous decisions. We are also not to interfere only for the reason that we may arrive at a different conclusion, unless, of course, there are compelling circumstances to tinker with conclusions drawn and that the accused were innocent/ guilty. Undoubtedly, there are limitations in interfering with the findings of conviction, concurrent in nature.
31. In the course of hearing of this appeal, we also noticed something very important, going to the root of the matter.
32. We noticed that in the cross-examination of the original first informant, PW 1 Asgar Shaikh (Exh.7), few suggestions were put to him by the defence counsel. We quote the relevant part of the crossexamination of the first informant:
“The attack on us was sudden. The first blow was hit on my head. I was assaulted severely on the head. Due to assault, I suffered a bleeding injury. It is not true that I felt giddy due to assault. Yes I however suffered pain. At that time, I did not feel that I should save my life. I did not feel that I should run away or I should try to hide myself. I went towards the side of Lohiya Nagar Police Chowkey. I did feel that I was being assaulted without any reason. Abbas was screaming while he was being assaulted. …”
A B C D E F G H
33. We are of the view from the aforesaid that the suggestions put by the defence counsel in the cross-examination of the eyewitnesses establishes the presence of PW 1 Asgar Shaikh at the scene of offence and the factum of assault could also be said to have been admitted. The reply to the suggestions answers the submission canvassed by the learned counsel for the appellants that PW1 Asgar Shaikh should not be believed or relied upon as there is nothing on record to indicate that he was an injured eyewitness. The defence could be said to have admitted the presence of PW Asgar Shaikh. When the aforesaid part of the crossexamination of PW1 Asgar Shaikh was brought to the notice of the defence counsel, he submitted that a suggestion put by defence counsel to a witness in his cross-examination has no evidentiary value and even if the same is incriminating in any manner would not bind the accused as the defence counsel has no implied authority to admit the guilt of the facts incriminating the accused.
34. According to the learned counsel such suggestions could be a part of the defence strategy to impeach the credibility of the witness. The proof of guilt required of the prosecution does not depend on the satisfaction made to a witness.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.