Raj Kumar @ Suman v. State (Nct of Delhi)
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 520; [2023] 5 S.C.R. 754
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Rajesh Bindal Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice This Was Not Put to Him
- Decided
- 11 May 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1471/2023
- Sections
- 313, 313(5), 302, 120, 307, 342, 537, 120B, 452
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 754 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.[2023] 5 S.C.R. 754 RAJ KUMAR @ SUMAN v.
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
(Criminal Appeal No. 1471 of 2023)
MAY 11, 2023
[ABHAY S. OKA AND RAJESH BINDAL, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.313 – Power to examine the accused – Law summarized.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.313 – Non-compliance of – Omission made while questioning the accused u/s.313, effect of – Appellant was convicted u/ss.302, 307 r/w 120-B, IPC and sentenced accordingly –Held: The only alleged incriminating circumstance against the appellant is in the evidence of PW5, who stated that the appellant was standing with a katta in his hand outside the premises where the offence took place–However, this was not put to him in his statement u/s.313– Therefore, he had no opportunity to explain the said circumstance which was the only basis of his conviction– Hence, serious prejudice was caused to him – Conviction of the appellant was vitiated – Impugned judgment of the High Court set aside – Conviction and sentence of the appellant set aside.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.313(5)– Benefit of – Assistance of Prosecutor and Defence Counsel in preparing relevant questions–Held: While recording the statement u/s.313, in cases involving large number of prosecution witnesses, Judicial Officers advised to take benefit of s.313(5) which will ensure that the chances of committing errors and omissions are minimized– However, scant attention is paid to this provision – The National and the State Judicial Academies to take a note of this situation. Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 The law consistently laid down by this Court can be summarized as: (i) It is the duty of the Trial Court to put each material circumstance appearing in the evidence against the accused specifically, distinctively and separately. The material circumstance means the circumstance or the material on the basis A B C D E F G H of which the prosecution is seeking his conviction; (ii) The object of examination of the accused under Section 313 is to enable the accused to explain any circumstance appearing against him in the evidence; (iii) The Court must ordinarily eschew material circumstances not put to the accused from consideration while dealing with the case of the particular accused; (iv) The failure to put material circumstances to the accused amounts to a serious irregularity. It will vitiate the trial if it is shown to have prejudiced the accused; (v) If any irregularity in putting the material circumstance to the accused does not result in failure of justice, it becomes a curable defect. However, while deciding whether the defect can be cured, one of the considerations will be the passage of time from the date of the incident; (vi) In case such irregularity is curable, even the appellate court can question the accused on the material circumstance which is not put to him; and (vii) In a given case, the case can be remanded to the Trial Court from the stage of recording the supplementary statement of the concerned accused under Section 313 of CrPC. (viii) While deciding the question whether prejudice has been caused to the accused because of the omission, the delay in raising the contention is only one of the several factors to be considered. [Para 16][767-D-G; 768-A-C] Tara Singh v. State 1951 SCC OnLine SC 49; Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra (1973) 2 SCC 793 : [1974] 1 SCR 489; S. Harnam Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1976) 2 SCC 819; Samsul Haque v. State of Assam (2019) 18 SCC 161 – relied on.
2.1 The only circumstance brought on record against the present appellant is in the evidence of PW5, who stated that the appellant was standing outside near the gate of the gallery with a katta in his hand. No overt act was attributed to him. There is a long statement of the appellant under Section 313 of CrPC in which as many as 42 questions were put to the appellant. Question no.13 is about what PW5 deposed. Admittedly, it was not put to the appellant that it is brought on record that he was standing outside near the gate of the gallery with a katta in his hand. It is true that the answer given by him to every question is “I don’t RAJ KUMAR @ SUMAN v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
A B C D E F G H 756 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
know”. If all the circumstances put to the appellant in his statement under Section 313 CrPC are carefully perused, any person of ordinary intelligence will get the impression that none of the prosecution witnesses has stated anything against him. That is why one cannot find fault with the appellant when he gave standard answers to every question as nothing adverse against him was put to him. In paragraph 13 of the written submissions by the appellant before the High Court, a specific contention was raised that the only circumstance appearing against the appellant was not put to him in the statement under Section 313 of CrPC. It is not in dispute that this part of the argument is not considered by the High Court. The Trial Court has not reproduced the submissions made by the counsel appearing for the accused. [Para 10][760-F-H; 761-A-B] 2.2 The only alleged incriminating circumstance appearing against the appellant in the evidence produced by the prosecution has not been put to him in his statement under Section 313 of CrPC and, therefore, he had no opportunity to explain the said circumstance. Moreover, his conviction is based only on this circumstance. [Para 11][761-C] 2.3 Only based on the version of PW5 regarding the appellant’s presence with a weapon outside the premises where the offence took place, the involvement of the appellant has been held as proved. There is absolutely no other evidence against him. This is not a case where there are several incriminating circumstances appearing against the appellant in the evidence adduced by the prosecution. This is a case where there is only a solitary circumstance appearing in the evidence against the appellant. The prosecution examined 37 witnesses. The material against the appellant is in the form of one sentence in the evidence of PW5. The appellant was not confronted during his examination under section 313 of CrPC with the only allegation of the prosecution against him. A serious prejudice was caused to the appellant. The incident is of 1995. It is not clear whether this aspect was argued before the Trial Court as the Trial Court has not reproduced the submissions of the counsel for the appellant. However, before the High Court, it was certainly canvassed as it forms a part of the written submissions. Even assuming that the A B C D E F G H defect or irregularity was curable, the question is whether today, the appellant--accused can be called upon to explain the said circumstance. More than 27 years have passed since the date of the incident. Considering the passage of time, it will be unjust now at this stage to remit the case to the Trial Court for recording further statement of the appellant under Section 313 of CrPC. In the facts of the case, the appellant cannot be called upon to answer something which has transpired 27 years back. The appellant has already undergone incarceration for a period of 10 years and 4 months. The conviction of the appellant stands vitiated. In the facts of the case, the option of remand will be unjust. The conviction and sentence of the appellant is set aside.The impugned judgment of the High Court is also set aside. [Paras 18-20, 23][769-C-H; 770-A-B; 771-B] Vahitha v. State of Tamil Nadu 2023 SCC OnLine SC 174 – distinguished.
Ranvir Yadav v. State of Bihar (2009) 6 SCC 595 :
[2009] 7 SCR 653; Sukhjit Singh v. State of Punjab (2014) 10 SCC 270 : [2014] 10 SCR 608; Maheshwar Tigga v. State of Jharkhand (2020) 10 SCC 108;
Satyavir Singh Rathi, Assistant Commissioner of Police & Ors. v. State through Central Bureau of Investigation (2011) 6 SCC 1 : [2011] 6 SCR 138 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2009] 7 SCR 653 referred to Para 5 [2014] 10 SCR 608 referred to Para 5 [2011] 6 SCR 138 referred to Para 6 [1974] 1 SCR 489 relied on Para 12 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1471 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 01.11.2018 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRLA No.32 of 2004.
Sumeet Verma, Sumit Kumar, Mahinder Pratap Singh, Vinay Kumar, Advs. for the Appellant.
Chirag M. Shroff, Adv. for the Respondent.
RAJ KUMAR @ SUMAN v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
A B C D E F G H 758 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
ABHAY S. OKA, J.
1. Leave granted.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
2. Appellant (accused no.2) was convicted by the Sessions Court by the Judgment dated 27th August 2003 for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code (for short, ‘IPC’). For the offence under Section 302, the appellant was sentenced to undergo life imprisonment. He was also convicted for the offence punishable under Section 307 read with Section 120-B of IPC, for which he was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 7 years.
3. The allegation against this accused, along with one Vimal (since deceased) and five others, was that on 01st October 1995, around 03:30 pm, they conspired to criminally intimidate and commit the murder of Jawahar Lal (PW-3) and his relatives. The allegation is that PW-3 was running his own cable TV network, and the accused wanted him to stop the said cable TV network. The allegation of the prosecution is that on 01st October 1995 at about 03:30 pm, the accused entered the house of PW-3 Jawahar Lal where he, along with his family members, were residing. Accused nos.4 and 5 fired bullets from their revolvers at Omi Devi, mother of PW-3 and Chander Shekhar (deceased – brother of PW-3). Accused no.3 and deceased Vimal attacked Chander Shekhar (deceased) and Omi with daggers and knives. PW-3 and PW-7 suffered serious injuries. As noted earlier, Chander Shekhar died. We may note that admittedly the only allegation against the present appellant (accused no.2) is that while 6 other accused entered the house of PW-3, the appellant was standing near the gate of the gallery with katta (countrymade handgun) in his hand. By the impugned judgment, the High Court has confirmed the conviction of the appellant.
SUBMISSIONS
4. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant pointed out that only PW-5 Ved Prakash deposed that the appellant was standing near the gate of the gallery with katta in his hand. However, PW-3, in the cross-examination, accepted that he had not seen the present appellant on the day of the incident and his name was told to him by PW-5. Learned A B C D E F G H counsel submitted that though the High Court, in paragraph 84 of the impugned judgment, has recorded a finding that even PW-13 had seen the appellant, in fact, PW-13 has not deposed anything about the appellant.
5. He submitted that the only circumstance appearing in the evidence against the appellant that he was standing outside near the gate of the gallery with a katta was not put to him in his statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘CrPC’). He submitted that this argument was specifically canvassed before the High Court, which finds a place in the written submissions filed on behalf of the appellants, but the High Court did not consider it. He relied upon decisions of this Court in the case of Ranvir Yadav v. State of Bihar1; Sukhjit Singh v. State of Punjab2; Maheshwar Tigga v. State of Jharkhand3; and Samsul Haque v. State of Assam4. He submitted that as a result of the failure of the Trial Court to put the only circumstance appearing against the appellant during his examination under Section 313 of CrPC, grave prejudice has been caused to the appellant resulting in failure of justice.
6. Learned counsel representing the respondent-State submitted that the appellant did not cross-examine PW-5. He relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Satyavir Singh Rathi, Assistant Commissioner of Police & Ors. v. State through Central Bureau of Investigation5. He submitted that in this decision, this Court held that the objection regarding the omission or defect in recording the statement under Section 313, CrPC must be raised at the earliest so that the defect can be cured. He submitted that the said contention was raised 16 years after the passing of the judgment by the Trial Court. He would, therefore, submit that, at this stage, this objection cannot be sustained. He submitted that the very fact that the said objection was not raised at any time earlier shows that there is no prejudice caused to the appellant due to the failure of the Court to put the only circumstance against the appellant to him while recording his statement under Section 313, CrPC.
OUR VIEW
7. We have considered the submissions. There is no dispute that the only allegation against the appellant was that while six accused entered
1 (2009) 6 SCC 595
2 (2014) 10 SCC 270
3 (2020) 10 SCC 108
4 (2019) 18 SCC 161
5 (2011) 6 SCC 1.
RAJ KUMAR @ SUMAN v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
[ABHAY S. OKA, J.] A B C D E F G H 760 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
the house of PW-3, the appellant was standing outside with a katta in his hand. In paragraph 84 of the impugned judgment, the High Court has observed that the evidence of PW-3, as regards the appellant, creates some doubt. However, it was held that the evidence of PW-5 and PW- 13 is clear and consistent as regards his involvement. We have, therefore, perused the evidence of the said three prosecution witnesses. PW-3 Jawahar Lal deposed about the entry of 6 other accused into his house at about 03:30 pm on 01st October 1995. He did not depose that the appellant was standing outside with a katta in his hand. In further examination-in-chief, he stated that in his statement recorded by the police, he has wrongly mentioned that the accused-Rajinder Kumar was guarding the spot. He stated that it was the appellant who was guarding the spot. The High Court has expressed doubt about the version of PW- 3 concerning the involvement of the present appellant. The reason given by the High Court is that PW-3 also stated that on the day of the incident, he did not see the appellant, but his name was told to him by PW-5 Ved Prakash. Therefore, the testimony of PW-3 cannot be relied upon to implicate the appellant.
8. We have carefully perused the evidence of PW-13. Though the High Court has observed that PW-13 has ascribed a role to the appellant of standing outside with a katta in his hand, we find that PW- 13 has made no such statement in his evidence.
9. Thus, what remains is the evidence of PW-5. All that he stated in his examination-in-chief was that he saw Raj Kumar standing at the gate of the gallery with a katta in his hand. He identified the appellant in the Court.
10. Hence, the only circumstance brought on record against the present appellant is in the evidence of PW-5, who stated that the appellant was standing outside near the gate of the gallery with a katta in his hand. No overt act was attributed to him. There is a long statement of the appellant under Section 313 of CrPC in which as many as 42 questions were put to the appellant. Question no.13 is about what PW-5 deposed. Admittedly, it was not put to the appellant that it is brought on record that he was standing outside near the gate of the gallery with a katta in his hand. It is true that the answer given by him to every question is “I don’t know”. If all the circumstances put to the appellant in his statement under Section 313 CrPC are carefully perused, any person of ordinary intelligence will get the impression that none of the prosecution witnesses A B C D E F G H has stated anything against him. That is why one cannot find fault with the appellant when he gave standard answers to every question as nothing adverse against him was put to him. We may note here that in paragraph 13 of the written submissions by the appellant before the High Court, a specific contention was raised that the only circumstance appearing against the appellant was not put to him in the statement under Section 313 of CrPC. It is not in dispute that this part of the argument is not considered by the High Court. We may also note that the Trial Court has not reproduced the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing for the accused.
11. Thus, we will have to proceed on the footing that the only alleged incriminating circumstance appearing against the appellant in the evidence produced by the prosecution has not been put to him in his statement under Section 313 of CrPC and, therefore, he had no opportunity to explain the said circumstance. Moreover, his conviction is based only on this circumstance.
12. Therefore, we will have to consider the effect of the aforesaid omission on the part of the Trial Court. The law on this aspect is no longer res integra. Apart from the decisions relied upon by the learned counsel representing the parties, there are other important decisions on this aspect. The first relevant judgment is of a Bench of four Hon’ble Judges of this Court in the case of Tara Singh v. State6. The Court considered the provision of Section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (for short, ‘CrPC of 1898’). Section 313 of CrPC and Section 342 of CrPC of 1898 are in pari materia. In paragraph 18, this Court held thus :
“18. It is important therefore that an accused should be properly examined under Section 342 and, as their Lordships of the Privy Council indicated in Dwarkanath Varma v.
Emperor [Dwarkanath Varma v. Emperor, AIR 1933 PC 124 at p. 130 : 1933 SCC OnLine PC 11] , if a point in the evidence is considered important against the accused and the conviction is intended to be based upon it, then it is right and proper that the accused should be questioned about the matter and be given an opportunity of explaining it if he so desires. This is an important and salutary provision and I cannot 6 1951 SCC OnLine SC 49 RAJ KUMAR @ SUMAN v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
[ABHAY S. OKA, J.] A B C D E F G H 762 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
permit it to be slurred over. I regret to find that in many cases scant attention is paid to it, particularly in the Sessions Courts. But whether the matter arises in the Sessions Court or in that of the Committing Magistrate, it is important that the provisions of Section 342 should be fairly and faithfully observed.”
(emphasis added)
Again in paragraph 23, this Court held thus:
“23. Section 342 requires the accused to be examined for the purpose of enabling him “to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against him”. Now it is evident that when the Sessions Court is required to make the examination under this section, the evidence referred to is the evidence in the Sessions Court and the circumstances which appear against the accused in that court. It is not therefore enough to read over the questions and answers put in the Committing Magistrate’s Court and ask the accused whether he has anything to say about them. In the present case, there was not even that. The appellant was not asked to explain the circumstances appearing in the evidence against him but was asked whether the statements made before the Committing Magistrate and his answers given there were correctly recorded. That does not comply with the requirements of the section.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.