State of Madhya Pradesh v. Phoolchand Rathore
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 444; [2023] 5 S.C.R. 601
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice Manoj Misra, Justice Aravind Kumar Penal Code, Justice Inter-Alia, Justice During Day Time, Justice The Accused Quarrelled With the Deceased and Took Her With Him On A Bicycle, Justice While Extending Threats That He Would Kill Her; (D) Later, Justice That Evening, Justice The Deceased Was Found in A
- Decided
- 28 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1315/2023
- Sections
- 302, 201, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 601[2023] 5 S.C.R. 601
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
v.
PHOOLCHAND RATHORE
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 1315-1316 of 2023)
APRIL 28, 2023
[SANJAY KISHAN KAUL, MANOJ MISRA AND ARAVIND KUMAR, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302 and 201 – Acquittal under – Prosecution rested its case on the circumstances, inter-alia, (a) the accused bore a grudge against his wife for keeping jewellery with her sister (PW8); (b) on the fateful day, during day time, accused on that count, quarrelled with PW8 and threatened to kill the deceased and set the house on fire; (c) in the evening of that fateful day, the accused quarrelled with the deceased and took her with him on a bicycle, while extending threats that he would kill her; (d) later, that evening, the deceased was found in a seriously injured condition; (e) the deceased died on account of those injuries; and
(f) blood-stained clothes etc. were recovered at the instance of the accused thereby making the chain complete – Trial Court convicted the accused and death penalty was awarded to the accused – High Court gave accused benefit of doubt to the accused and acquitted him – On appeal, held: Reason of the quarrel that deceased had kept her jewellery with her sister (PW8) was not found proved – As prosecution evidence revealed that jewellery was returned back – Thus, prosecution failed to prove motive – There appears no reason for accused to carry stones from the spot and hide them in his hut and leaving blood-stained stones near railway line – As far as blood stained clothes are concerned, PW4 stated that her father (accused) on return had washed those clothes and spread them to dry – How could they be recovered from hut – So, the recovery of the bloodstained clothes etc. was doubtful – Police prepared two memorandums (disclosure statement, as per the memorandum (Ex.P- 9), at Seoni Trisection, witnessed by PW6 and the recovery memo (Ex.P-10), was prepared at accused’s hut near railway line at the same time also witnessed by PW-6) – Both memorandums were prepared at the same time and different places, meaning all papers were signed at one go rendering the entire exercise of disclosure A B C D E F G H 602 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
and consequential discovery/recovery doubtful – Alleged extra judicial confession made by the accused to PW4 was neither disclosed in the FIR nor in the previous statement of PW4 made during investigation – Extra judicial confession also not proved beyond reasonable doubt – Also, accused and the deceased were noticed quarrelling with each other at about 1630 hours and soon thereafter, the appellant took deceased on his cycle – As per prosecution deceased was found injured at around 2000 hours, there was quite a large time-gap for other intervening factors to operate – Therefore, motive, disclosure, recovery and extra judicial confession was not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Constitution of India – Art. 136 – When it appears that the High Court has on an absolutely wrong process of reasoning and a legally erroneous and perverse approach to the facts of the case and ignoring some of the most vital facts, acquitted the respondent and the order of acquittal passed by the High Court has resulted in a grave and substantial miscarriage of justice, extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India may rightfully be exercised.
Dismissing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1. The prosecution relied on the following circumstances: (a) Motive; (b) Disclosure Statement and Recovery; (c) Extra Judicial Confession; and (d) Accused taking the deceased with him and soon thereafter the deceased was found in an injured state [Para 24][618-G]
2. (a) Motive According to the prosecution, the appellant and the deceased used to quarrel because the deceased had kept her jewellery with her sister. However, the above reason for the quarrel was not found proved because the prosecution evidence led revealed that the jewellery had already been returned back much before the date of the incident. Therefore, to prove motive, during trial, prosecution developed another story, which is, that the appellant desired his wife to claim a share in her ancestral property which resulted in quarrels. This motive neither appealed to the High Court nor to this Court. [Para 24 (i)][619-A-C] A B C D E F G H
(b) Disclosure Statement and Recovery The disclosure statement, as per the memorandum (Ex.P- 9), was prepared at Seoni Trisection and witnessed by PW6; the recovery memo (Ex.P-10), was prepared at accused’s hut near railway line in Model village at 1400 hours 02.02.2010 and the same was witnessed by PW6. Interestingly, PW6 is the only public witness of disclosure and recovery to be examined and he has not supported the prosecution case. What is even more interesting is that the other seizure memorandum prepared in respect of lifting blood-stained saree, gravel, slippers etc. from near the railway line, that is the spot from where the deceased was lifted, was prepared at 1400 hours on 02.02.2010. How could it be possible that the police prepared two memorandums at the same time at different places. The answer to it lies in the testimony of PW6, a witness to both, who stated that he was made to sign the papers at the police station. Meaning thereby that all papers were prepared at one go rendering the entire exercise of disclosure and consequential discovery/recovery doubtful. Not only that, there appears no cogent reason for the accused to carry stones from the spot and hide them in his hut while leaving several bloodstained stones near the railway line. In such circumstances, it appears to us that those stones were picked from the spot near the railway track to show recovery from the hut. Insofar as the recovery of blood-stained clothes is concerned, in addition to the above reasons, the same is doubtful also because of the statement of PW4 that her father on return had washed those clothes and had spread them to dry over the cattle shed in the house therefore, how could they be recovered from the hut. It be noted that the house is shown located in the village, whereas the hut is shown in the field at quite a distance from the house. For all the reasons above, the High Court was justified in doubting the recovery of blood-stained clothes etc. at the instance of the accused from the hut and on the basis of a disclosure statement made by him. [Para 24 (ii)][620-C-H; 621-A-B]
(c) Extra Judicial Confession to PW4 The alleged extra judicial confession made by the accused to PW4 was neither disclosed in the FIR nor in the previous statement of PW4 made during investigation. PW4 was confronted STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH v. PHOOLCHAND RATHORE A B C D E F G H 604 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
with that omission during her deposition in court. That apart, the testimony of PW4 with regard to the accused returning home, making extra judicial confession, changing clothes, washing bloodstained clothes and spreading them to dry has been found unreliable and shaky by the High Court for cogent reasons extracted above, which do not appear perverse as to warrant an interference. Thus, the circumstance of extra judicial confession is also not proved beyond doubt. [Para 24 (iii)][621-C-E]
(d) Accused taking the deceased from home on a bicycle When the court peruse the detailed reasons recorded by the High Court in its judgment to hold that the testimony of PW4 is not of a stellar quality as to merit conviction solely on its basis, this Court finds no perversity in the High Court’s conclusion as may warrant a reversal of acquittal into a conviction in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution. At what time the accused had taken the deceased on his bicycle is not clear from the testimony of PW4 though, from the first part of her testimony, it appears that the accused and the deceased were noticed quarrelling with each other at about 1630 hours and soon thereafter, the appellant took the deceased on his cycle. If, from that, the event of taking the deceased on bicycle at about 1630 hours there is still quite a large time-gap between 1630 hours and 2000 hours for other intervening factors to operate. In light thereof, considering that the place of occurrence was an open place and the other circumstances (i.e. motive, disclosure, recovery and extra judicial confession) were not proved beyond reasonable doubt, shifting the burden on the accused to explain the circumstances in which the deceased sustained injuries, or to demonstrate that he parted company of the deceased, would not be justified in the facts of the case. [Para 24 (iv)][621-H; 622- A-B; 623-A-D] State of U.P. v. Sahai & Others (1982) 1 SCC 352; State of M.P. & Others v. Paltan Mallah & Others (2005) 3 SCC 169 : [2005] 1 SCR 710; Basheera Begam v.
Mohd. Ibrahim & Others (2020) 11 SCC 174: [2020] 3 SCR 562 – referred to.
Case Law Reference (1982) 1 SCC 352 referred to para 20 A B C D E F G H [2005] 1 SCR 710 referred to para 21 [2020] 3 SCR 562 referred to para 22 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal Nos.1315-1316 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 11.12.2015 of the High Court of M.P. Principal Seat at Jabalpur in CRLR Nos.1292 and 02 of 2015. Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Mrs. Anuradha Mishra, Vikas Bansal, Advs. for the Appellant.
Yashraj Singh Deora (Amicus Curiae), Abhishek Singh, Adv. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. These appeals are by the State of Madhya Pradesh against the judgement and order of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur (for short “the High Court”) dated 11.12.2015 in Criminal Appeal No.1292 of 2015 connected with Criminal Reference No.2 of 2015 whereby, the order of conviction and sentence including death penalty awarded to the respondent by the Court of District and Sessions Judge, Anuppur in Sessions Trial No.72 of 2010, under sections 302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) has been set aside and the respondent has been acquitted.
3. To have a clear understanding of the issues raised in these appeals a brief description of the prosecution case and the evidence led by the prosecution would be apposite.
Introductory Facts
4. The prosecution story narrated in the first information report (FIR), lodged by deceased’s brother Kamla (PW2), is that the accusedrespondent was unhappy that his wife Sundariya (the deceased) had kept her jewellery with her sister Jaimatiya Bai (PW-8); on the fateful day i.e. 01.02.2010, at around 1400 hours, the accused came to the house of PW2, while PW8 was there, fought with PW8 and told her that he would kill Sundariya and set the house on fire; when PW2 returned from his shop at around 1900 hours, on getting the above information, he STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH v. PHOOLCHAND RATHORE A B C D E F G H 606 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
telephoned Madhuri (PW4), daughter of Sundariya, who informed PW2 that her father had taken her mother on a bicycle towards the field while making utterances that he would kill her. On receipt of information from PW4, PW2 came to the village where Sundariya resided and went to search her out with the help of Manoj (not examined) and PW2’s brotherin-law Mathura (PW3). During the course of search, they found the deceased lying seriously injured between the railway tracks. They, therefore, rushed her to Jaithari Hospital but, on way, she succumbed to her injuries. The FIR was promptly lodged at P.S. Jaithari on 01.02.2010 at 2130 hours expressing suspicion against the respondent (i.e. the accused) of having killed his wife.
5. As per arrest memo (Ex. P-11), the accused was arrested on 02.02.2010, at about 1240 hours, from Seoni Tri-section. Vide Ex. P-9, on the same day i.e. 02.02.2010, at 1300 hours, a disclosure statement of the accused was recorded wherein, he assured recovery of stones (gitti) and blood-stained pant and shirt kept in his hut. Pursuant thereto, vide seizure memo (Ex. P-10), on 02.02.2010, at 1400 hours, a moss coloured full shirt and dark brown full pant with blood stains on them, three blood-stained stones with hair stuck on it and one old hero jet cycle were recovered from that hut.
6. Interestingly, on the same day, at the same time i.e. 1400 hours, vide Ex. P-12, another seizure was made from near the railway line of 5 blood-stained gravel (gitti - stone), 5 plain gravel (gitti - stone), blood stained red coloured saree and chappals.
7. On completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet was laid against the appellant and, after taking cognizance thereon, the case was committed to the Court of Session. The Sessions Court charged the appellant for committing murder of his wife on 01.02.2010 at 2000 hours, punishable under section 302 IPC, and of concealing blood-stained stones/ shirt/pant and cycle used in the offence with a view to remove evidence thereof, punishable under Section 201 IPC. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
Prosecution Evidence
8. As there existed no eyewitness account of the murder, the prosecution rested its case on circumstances, inter alia, (a) the accused bore a grudge against his wife for keeping jewellery with her sister (PW8);
(b) on the fateful day, during day time, accused on that count, quarrelled A B C D E F G H with PW8 and threatened to kill the deceased and set the house on fire;
(c) in the evening of that fateful day, the accused quarrelled with the deceased and took her with him on a bicycle, while extending threats that he would kill her; (d) later, that evening, the deceased was found in a seriously injured condition; (e) the deceased died on account of those injuries; and (f) blood-stained clothes etc. were recovered at the instance of the accused thereby making the chain complete. To prove these circumstances, the prosecution examined 12 witnesses. Gist of their testimony is noticed below:
(i) PW-1 - Ganga Bai She is the aunt of the accused. She did not support the prosecution case and was accordingly declared hostile.
Nothing much turns on her testimony.
(ii) PW-2 – Kamla Singh Rathore (the informant)
He deposed about — receipt of information, at 1900 hours, of the quarrel that took place on the fateful day during day time; search operation; discovering the deceased, at around 2000 hours, in an injured condition near railway track; rushing her to the hospital; the deceased succumbing to her injuries on way to the hospital; and lodging of the FIR. During cross-examination, PW2 admitted that no quarrel/fight took place in his presence. On being questioned as to how PW2 communicated with PW4 on that fateful day, PW2 stated that PW4 had used mobile of some third person but could not disclose his name or number.
(iii) PW-3 – Mathura Prasad Rathore He corroborated PW2’s statement that the deceased was found lying near the railway tracks and from there she was rushed to Hospital though she succumbed to her injuries on way.
(iv) PW-4 – Madhuri Singh Rathore (Daughter of the deceased)
She is the star witness. She deposed about — fights between her father (the accused) and mother (the deceased); her returning from maternal uncle’s home at 1630 hours and noticing her father and mother fighting/ STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH v. PHOOLCHAND RATHORE [MANOJ MISRA, J.] A B C D E F G H 608 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
quarrelling and, later, her father forcibly taking her mother on his cycle to the fields. PW4 also stated that she followed them up to the village pond but, on being scolded, she came back and that near the pond, she met Sushila (PW-12), her paternal aunt, to whom she narrated the incident.
Whereafter, on coming back, she made a phone call to her maternal uncle (PW2). Then her maternal uncle called back to know the whereabouts of her mother. When she told him that her father had taken her mother and had asked her to remain in the house, her maternal uncle came to the village in search of her mother. PW4, during her deposition, added that in between her father had returned alone and had told her that he had killed her mother.
During cross-examination, PW4 admitted that the ornaments that were kept by her mother with her aunt (i.e. mother’s sister) were returned by her aunt eight days before the incident. She also admitted that on the fateful day she gave her examination from 1100 hours till 1500 hours and that, at present, she is living with her maternal uncle. PW4 was also confronted with her previous statement wherein there was an omission regarding confession made by her father.
(v) PW-5 – Dr. Sunil Khanna (Autopsy Surgeon)
He proved the autopsy report (Ex.P-8) wherein he recited eight lacerated wounds, ante mortem in nature, caused by hard and blunt object within 24 hours of examination conducted on 02.02.2010 at 1100 hours According to his opinion, deceased died within 24 hours of the examination, on account of head injuries leading to haemorrhage, resultant shock and cardio respiratory failure. During cross examination, he stated that if train is moving and any person, walking on foot, gets dashed by the train then such injuries may occur.
This witness was re-examined and questioned by Court.
At that stage, the witness stated that if injuries were sustained during a train accident then it might reflect fracture on face. He accepted the possibility of injuries being caused as a result of assault with Gitti (Gravel - small stones). A B C D E F G H
(vi) PW-6 – Shivkumar Rathore He is a witness to the disclosure statement and seizure of blood-stained clothes etc. He, however, did not support the prosecution case and was therefore declared hostile. During cross-examination he admitted his signature on the memorandum(s) but claimed that his signatures were obtained by the police at the police station without informing him about the contents of the documents.
(vii) PW-7 – Kiran @ Rambai She is another daughter of the deceased. She stated that at the time of the incident, she was in the house of her maternal uncle namely, Kamla Rathore, at Jaithari. During cross examination, she stated that disputes between her father and mother used to take place but they use to get resolved.
(viii) PW-8 – Jaimatiya Bai Rathore She is sister of the deceased Sundariya. She deposed that the dispute between the deceased and her husband was on account of ancestral properties coming from deceased’s mother side. She stated that she does not have any other information about the incident. At this stage, the witness was declared hostile and was allowed to be crossexamined by the prosecution.
During cross-examination, at the instance of prosecution, she stated that there was theft at Sundariya’s place therefore, for security reasons, Sundariya had kept her gold and silver at her house which, a week before the incident, were sent by her to the house of Sundariya. She also stated that the accused had come to her house and had threatened to kill Sundariya and set the house on fire.
During cross-examination at the instance of the accused, upon a suggestion that a family dispute was going on, PW8 stated the accused was pressurising the deceased to take a share in her ancestral property from her brother and since she was not agreeing to it, the accused had a dispute with her.
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH v. PHOOLCHAND RATHORE [MANOJ MISRA, J.] A B C D E F G H 610 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
(ix) PW-9 – Rajiv Singh He was the Halqa Patwari (Revenue Circle Inspector/ Lekhpal) who inspected the crime scene under orders of the Tehsildar and prepared the spot panchnama (Ex. P- 13) as also site plan (Ex. P-14) of the place from where the deceased was taken in an injured condition to the hospital.
(x) PW-10 – Ashok Kumar Rathore He is son of PW2 who brought his vehicle to take the deceased along with PW2 to the hospital. He corroborated the evidence that the deceased succumbed to her injuries on way to the hospital.
(xi) PW-11 – Satish Dwivedi - Investigating Officer He proved the various stages of investigation including registration of the FIR on 01.02.2010 at 2130 hours.
Interestingly, as per his deposition, he visited the site on 02.02.2010 and vide seizure memo (Ex.P-12) lifted bloodstained gravel, plain gravel, blood-stained saree and two slippers from the spot. He deposed about — arresting the accused vide memo Ex.P-11; recording his disclosure vide Ex.P-9; and effecting recovery vide memo (Ex.P-10). He stated that sealed articles were sent for forensic examination. He also produced the recovered articles as material exhibits.
During cross-examination, though PW11 admitted knowing PW2 (informant) from before but denied the suggestion that he conspired with PW2 to falsely implicate the accused. In paragraph 25 he stated that saree was not found on the body of the deceased. He also admitted that a new railway track was being laid there and in that connection machines were there. However, he denied the suggestion that in connection with laying new track hundreds of workers (labourers) were there. In paragraph 32 he denied the suggestion that the accused had reached the police station on 01.02.2010 itself. He also denied the suggestion that the alleged arrest, disclosure and recovery at the instance of the accused are bogus.
A B C D E F G H In respect of the distance between Seoni Trisection and Seoni village, PW11 denied the suggestion that the distance between the two is of 6 km. Rather, claimed it to be 600 meters. He also admitted that the witnesses of the memorandum were not residents of Seoni Trisection.
(xii) PW-12 – Sushila (Sister-in-Law of the Deceased)
PW-12 disclosed no knowledge about the prosecution case and was therefore declared hostile.
Forensic Reports
9. In addition to the oral testimony of the witnesses, forensic reports confirmed presence of human blood on saree, shawl, petticoat, blouse, shirt and stone. Likewise, blood was found on the gravel recovered from the place of occurrence though its origin could not be determined as it had disintegrated. Similarly, the classification of the blood could not be made as it had disintegrated.
Statement under section 313 Cr.P.C.
10. The incriminating circumstances appearing in the prosecution evidence were put to the accused while recording his statement under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C.”) The accused denied the incriminating circumstances and claimed that he has been falsely implicated.
Findings of the Trial Court
11. The Trial Court found the following incriminating circumstances proved — (a) the deceased was assaulted, abused and forcibly taken by the accused on a bicycle and she did not return thereafter rather, two hours later, was found in badly injured condition; (b) the accused made extra judicial confession of his guilt to his daughter (PW4); (c) human blood was found on the clothes recovered; and (d) except bald denial no explanation was offered by the accused. According to the trial court, the said circumstances constituted a chain so far complete that it established beyond doubt that it was the accused and no one else who committed the crime. To conclude as above, the Trial Court placed reliance on the testimony of PW-4. Upon finding the accused guilty, the trial court convicted the accused and awarded death penalty to him under section 302 IPC and 7 years RI under section 201 IPC. For confirmation of death penalty, a reference was made to the High Court under section STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH v. PHOOLCHAND RATHORE [MANOJ MISRA, J.] A B C D E F G H 612 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
366 Cr.P.C., which was registered as Reference No.2 of 2015. In the meantime, the accused filed criminal appeal against the order of conviction and sentence, which gave rise to Criminal Appeal No.1292 of 2015 before the High Court. The appeal and the reference were connected and decided together by the High Court vide impugned judgment and order dated 11.12.2015.
High Court Findings
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.