Omprakash Sahni v. Jai Shankar Chaudhary & Anr. Etc.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 478; [2023] 5 S.C.R. 141
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.R. Shah, Justice J.B. Pardiwala Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice Held: the Endeavour On The
- Decided
- 2 May 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1331/2023
- Sections
- 389, 302, 34, 27, 389(1), 3
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
OMPRAKASH SAHNI
v.
JAI SHANKAR CHAUDHARY & ANR. ETC.
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 1331-1332 of 2023)
MAY 02, 2023
[M. R. SHAH AND J. B. PARDIWALA, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 389 – The three respondents were convicted for the murder of the appellant’s brother by the Trial Court and sentenced to life imprisonment – The order of conviction and sentence passed by Trial Court was challenged in appeal by the respondents before the High Court – Respondents prayed before the High Court that they be released on bail pending the final disposal of their appeals by suspending the substantive order of sentence of life imprisonment – High Court suspended sentence and ordered their release on bail – On appeal, held: The endeavour on the part of the Court should be to see as to whether the case presented by the prosecution and accepted by the Trial Court can be said to be a case in which, ultimately the convict stands for fair chances of acquittal – While undertaking the exercise to ascertain whether the convict has fair chances of acquittal, what is to be looked into is something palpable – Something which is very apparent or gross on the face of the record, on the basis of which, the Court can arrive at a prima facie satisfaction that the conviction may not be sustainable – The Appellate Court should not reappreciate the evidence at the stage of s.389 and try to pick up few lacunas or loopholes here or there in the case of the prosecution, it is not correct approach – In the instant case, High Court has gone into the issues like political rivalry, delay in lodging the FIR, some over-writings in the First Information Report etc. – All these aspects, will have to be looked into at the time of the final hearing of the appeals filed by the convicts – High Court committed a serious error in suspending the substantive order of sentence of the convicts and their release on bail pending the final disposal of their criminal appeals – Order of High Court set aside – Convicts ordered to surrender. [2023] 5 S.C.R. 141 A B C D E F G H 142 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD:1. In Vijay Kumar, it was held that in considering the prayer for bail in a case involving a serious offence like murder punishable under Section 302 of the IPC, the court should consider the relevant factors like the nature of accusation made against the accused, the manner in which the crime is alleged to have been committed, the gravity of the offence, and the desirability of releasing the accused on bail after they have been convicted for committing the serious offence of murder. [Para 31][162-G]
2. The endeavour on the part of the Court, therefore, should be to see as to whether the case presented by the prosecution and accepted by the Trial Court can be said to be a case in which, ultimately the convict stands for fair chances of acquittal. If the answer to the above said question is to be in the affirmative, as a necessary corollary, if ultimately the convict appears to be entitled to have an acquittal at the hands of this Court, he should not be kept behind the bars for a pretty long time till the conclusion of the appeal, which usually take very long for decision and disposal. However, while undertaking the exercise to ascertain whether the convict has fair chances of acquittal, what is to be looked into is something palpable. To put it in other words, something which is very apparent or gross on the face of the record, on the basis of which, the Court can arrive at a prima facie satisfaction that the conviction may not be sustainable. The Appellate Court should not reappreciate the evidence at the stage of Section 389 of the CrPC and try to pick up few lacunas or loopholes here or there in the case of the prosecution. Such would not be a correct approach. [Para 33][163-B-D]
3. In the case on hand, what the High Court has done is something impermissible. High Court has gone into the issues like political rivalry, delay in lodging the FIR, some over-writings in the First Information Report etc. All these aspects, will have to be looked into at the time of the final hearing of the appeals filed by the convicts. Upon cursory scanning of the evidence on record, this court is unable to agree with the contentions coming from the Senior Counsel for the convicts that, either there is A B C D E F G H absolutely no case against the convicts or that the evidence against them is so weak and feeble in nature, that, ultimately in all probabilities the proceedings would terminate in their favour. For the very same reason this court was unable to accept the contention coming from the convicts through their Senior Counsel that, it would be meaningless, improper and unjust to keep them behind the bars for a pretty long time till they are found not to be guilty of the charges. [Para 34][163-E-G]
4. In the overall view of the matter, this Court is convinced that the High Court committed a serious error in suspending the substantive order of sentence of the convicts and their release on bail pending the final disposal of their criminal appeals. [Para 35][163-H] Rajesh Ranjan Yadav Alias Pappu Yadav v. CBI (2007)
1 SCC 70 : [2006] 9 Suppl. SCR 40; Ash Mohammad v. Shiv Raj Singh Alias Lalla Babu and Another (2012) 9 SCC 446 : [2012] 7 SCR 584; Bhagwan Rama Shinde Gosai and Others v. State of Gujarat (1999) 4 SCC 421 : [1999] 3 SCR 545; Sidhartha Vashisht Alias Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2008) 5 SCC 230 :
[2008] 8 SCR 220; Atul Tripathi v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others (2014) 9 SCC 177 : [2014] 14 SCR 1188 – relied on.
Kishori Lal v. Rupa and Others (2004) 7 SCC 638 :
[2004] 4 Suppl. SCR 628; Vijay Kumar v. Narendra and Others (2002) 9 SCC 364; Ramji Prasad v. Rattan Kumar Jaiswal and Another (2002) 9 SCC 366; Vasant Tukaram Pawar v. State of Maharashtra (2005) 5 SCC 281 : [2005] 3 SCR 630; Gomti v. Thakurdas and Others (2007) 11 SCC 160 : [2007] 5 SCR 90 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2006] 9 Suppl. SCR 40 relied on Para 25 [2012] 7 SCR 584 relied on Para 26 [1999] 3 SCR 545 relied on Para 27 [2008] 8 SCR 220 relied on Para 28 OMPRAKASH SAHNI v. JAI SHANKAR CHAUDHARY &
ANR. ETC.
A B C D E F G H 144 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
[2014] 14 SCR 1188 relied on Para 29 [2004] 4 Suppl. SCR 628 referred to Para 30 [2005] 3 SCR 630 referred to Para 32 [2007] 5 SCR 90 referred to Para 32 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 1331-1332 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 16.09.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Patna in CRADB Nos. 322 and 411 of 2021. R. Chandrachud, Ms. Fauzia Shakil, Agastya Sen, Advs. for the Appellant.
V. K. Shukla, Sr. Adv., Rakesh Kumar, Shailendra Mani Tripathi, Chand Qureshi, C. Thangaraja, S. Krishnamoorthy, K. Kumaravadivel, Manish Kumar, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
J. B. PARDIWALA, J.
1. These appeals are at the instance of the original first informant (brother of the deceased) and are directed against a common order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 322 of 2021 and Criminal Appeal (DB) No.411 of 2021 respectively by which, the High Court suspended the substantive order of sentence of life imprisonment imposed by the Trial Court on the respondent Nos. 1, 3 and 4respectively herein (convicts) and ordered their release on bail pending the final disposal of the two criminal appeals referred to above.
FACTUAL MATRIX
2. It appears from the materials on record that the respondents Nos. 1, 3 and 4 respectively herein alongwith six other co-accused were put to trial in the Court of Additional Sessions Judge-VII, Vaishali, Hajipur, District: Vaishali at Hajipur (Bihar) in Sessions Trial No. 280/2019 for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 120-B, 506 respectively read with Section34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, ‘the IPC’) and Section 27 of the Arms Act, 1959 (for short, ‘the 1959 Act’)
3. The three respondents herein, namely, Jai Shankar Chaudhary, Abhay Kumar and Ram Babu respectively were held guilty by the Trial A B C D E F G H Court, of the offence of murder of the brother of the appellant herein, namely, Manish Kumar. The other co-accused were ordered to be acquitted.
4. The respondents Nos. 1, 3 and 4 respectively herein went in appeal before the High Court of Judicature at Patna, challenging the order of conviction and sentence passed by the Trial Court.
5. The case of the prosecution narrated by the Trial Court in its judgment dated 12.03.2021 is as under:
“The F.I.R in the instant case had been registered on 14.08.2018, on the basis of written application of informant Om Prakash Sahni, alleging therein that the informant Om Prakash Sahni on 13-08-2018 at about 01:00 P.M. alongwith his younger brother Manish Kumar, the Block Pramukh, Jandaha reached the Office of Block Pramukh, situated at block Jandaha by their alto car. Informant’s brother went in his chamber. The driver of the B.D.O. came in his car and told thePramukh that B.D.O. has called him and on such information the Block Pramukh Manish Kumar went to the residence of B.D.O. in the B.D.O’s car. After sometime the Pramukh came back in the same vehicle and as he was heading towards his chamber at about 03:00 P.M., the accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar came and opened fire on informant’s brother,the Block Pramukh upon the exhortation by accused Ram Babu Sahni to kill him. The informant’s brother fell on the ground and both the accused waving their pistols, fled away on a motorcycle towards Mahua road. The other two accused Ram Babu Sahni and Binod Chaudhary also fled away from the place of occurrence on one another motorcycle, towards the same direction. The F.I.R. further states that the informant and the Pramukh’s driver namely Anil Kumar alongwith certain others were present at the time of occurrence. They took him to the clinic of doctor Bindu Jha and on his reference, they took the injured to the Ganpati Hospital, Hajipur, where he was declared dead. Thereafter they took the deceased to Hajipur Sadar Hospital, where the postmortem examination was carried out and the police also reached there and carried out further proceeding. The F.I.R. also states that the election of block pramukh was OMPRAKASH SAHNI v. JAI SHANKAR CHAUDHARY & ANR. ETC. [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 146 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
held on 02-08-2018 and the Pramukh won the election. The informant in the F.I.R. also states that Umesh Singh Kushwaha, M.L.A., Mahnar, Binod Chaudhary s/o Ram Lakhan Chaudhary, Ajeet Kumar s/o Ram Babu Sahni Village Dulaur P.S. Jandaha, Kundan Sahni (Prakhand Shikshak) s/o Ram Nandan Sahni Vill Narharpur, Randhir Kumar S/o Late Masudan Prasad Singh Vill Narharpur, Ranjeet Kumar S/o Ram Briksh Singh Viii Narharpur, all from P.S. Jandaha and Ajay Thakur (Teacher) Sankul Sadhan Sevi, Jandaha Vill Nari Khurd P.S. Patepur Dist Vaishali had earlier threatened the informant at Bindi Chowk Road (north from Suresh Chowk) that they would not allow informant’s brother to win the election and in the event, he wins, they would not let him live. The informant also states that these persons threatened him many times and he informed his brother of such fact. The present Prakhand Siksha Padadhikri, Jandaha also threatened that he should communicate to the Pramukh for not getting involved in the recruitment of Prakhand Shikshak, otherwise he may face dire consequences. The informant is under the belief that all the abovereferred persons in conspiracy, have committed the murder of informant’s brother Manish Kumar.”
6. In the course of the trial, the prosecution examined ten witnesses as under:
P.W. 1 Raj Kumar Sahni, P.W. 2 Anil Kumar Sahni, P.W 3 Rup Kala Devi, P.W. 4 Dr. Shashidhar Kumar, P.W. 5 Lal Babu Sahni, P.W. 6 Laldeo Sahni, P. W. 7 Om Prakash Sahni/ informant, P. W. 8 Saroj Kumar Singh, P.W. 9 Shobhakant Paswan (Investigating Officer) and P.W. 10 Sunil Kumar Singh (Investigating Officer).
A B C D E F G H
7. The Trial Court, upon evaluation of the oral as well as documentary evidence on record, in the final analysis observed in paras 40 and 41 respectively as under:
“40. On considering the submissions made by learned counsel of parties and the conjoint perusal of prosecution evidence including the cross-examination done by learned counsels for defence this court finds that the prosecution has led credible evidence that on 13-08-2018, at about 03:00 PM at Jandaha block, the accused Ram Babu Sahni and Binod Chaudhary exhorted Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar Sahni to kill Manish Sahni. On such provocation, Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar Sahni shot the bullet over Manish Sahni. He was then taken to doctor Bindu Jha in Jandaha and was referred from there to Hajipur. He was taken to Hajipur Ganpati Hospital by an ambulance, where the doctor declared him dead. As per the evidence of PW-7/ informant, the Manish Sahni alongwith him and the driver P.W. 2 reached the block Jandaha at about 01:00 P.M., they were sitting in his chamber, when the B.D.O. called him through his driver and he went to meet the B.D.O. to his resident from the B.D.O’s vehicle. When he arrived back at about 03:00 P.M., as he was heading towards his chamber, the accused Ram Babu Sahni and Binod Chaudhary exhorted Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar Sahni to kill Manish Sahni. On such provocation, Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar Sahni shot the bullet over Manish Sahni and he fell on the ground. All the four accused fled away from northern gate towards Mahua road. Manish Sahni was then taken to doctor Bindu Jha in Jandaha and was referred from there to Hajipur. He was taken to Hajipur Ganpati Hospital by an ambulance, where the doctor declared him dead. His autopsy was performed at Sadar Hospital, Hajipur. The reason behind the occurrence in question is that the accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary was earlier elected the block Pramukh, but was defeated by Manish Sahni in no confidence motion. The Manish Sahni then became Block Pramukh. All the accused persons are said to conspire for commission of the alleged offence. The P.W. 1 Raj Kumar Sahni in his evidence has proved that the Pramukh Manish Sahni came from B.D.O’s OMPRAKASH SAHNI v. JAI SHANKAR CHAUDHARY & ANR. ETC. [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 148 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
vehicle and was heading towards his chamber, when accused Jai Shankar alongwith another opened fire over Manish Sahni. He has stated that it was Jai Shankar, who shot Manish Sahni. P.W. 2, the driver of Block Pramukh namely Anil Kumar Sahni also proved that Manish Sahni arrived from B.D.O’s vehicle. The accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar Sahni were already present there. The other accused Ram Babu Sahni and Binod Chaudhary reached there and said “kya dekhte ho goli maaro”. Jai Shankar Chaudhary shot the bullet and thereafter Abhay Kumar shot the other bullet. The Pramukh fell on the ground and the informant and the witness P.W.2 are said to take him to hospital at Jandaha, from where he was referred to Hajipur Sadar Hospital, but he died on the way. P.W. 3 the wife of deceased is not an eye witness. However, she has testified the death of her husband by accused persons in the manner as stated by witnesses. In addition to these facts, she has also stated that when her husband won the election, he was given threat for life and she had advised her husband to remain alert. P.W. 5 in his statement-in-chief has proved the date and time of occurrence i.e., 13-08-2018 at 03:00 P.M. He, an eye witness also testifies the prosecution story that the accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar opened fire over Manish Sahni on the provocation and exhortation by Ram Babu Sahni and Binod Chaudhary. P.W. 6 in his statementin-chief also proves the date 13-08-2018 and time 03:00 P.M. of the alleged occurrence. He claims to be an eye witness of the occurrence and testifies that Binod Chaudhary and Ram Babu came by a bike and exhorted Jai Shankar Chaudhary and another person, whom he did not identify. On such exhortation and provocation, Jai Shankar Chaudhary and the other one opened fire over Manish Sahni. P.W. 8 Saroj Kumar Singh also claims to be an eye witness and testifies the fact that on the instigation of Binod Chaudhary, the accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary opened fire over Manish Sahni and he does not identify the other person, who also shot bullet over Manish Sahni. However, the date of occurrence has been contradicted by PW-8 to be 30.08.2018. The accused Binod Chaudhary whose name reflects in the A B C D E F G H evidence repeatedly is not facing the instant trial before court. The doctor has proved the postmortem report and the injuries thereon are the two entry wounds, one each over left upper chest and over epigastrium alongwith two exit wounds, one each on right sub costal region impugned posterior axillary line and the other over right lumbar region in posterior axillary line. The two investigating officers who carried out the investigation, have proved genuineness of the investigation process as has been discussed in the preceding paragraphs. The defence could not bring such material or contradictions or any other evidence on record to falsify the facts placed and proved by prosecution.
41. Hence, on the basis of material and the evidence both oral and documentary, as available on record, this court arrives at conclusion that the prosecution has proved its case against accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary, Abhay Kumar alias Abhay Sahni and Ram Babu Sahni, beyond reasonable doubts that on exhortation of Ram Babu Sahni, the other two accused Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar @ Abhay Sahni opened fire over Manish Sahni, causing his death and thereby committing his murder. This court finds them guilty of committing the murder of Manish Sahni in furtherance of their common intention.”
8. The three convicts before us i.e., the respondents Nos. 1, 3 and 4 respectively prayed before the High Court that they be released on bail pending the final disposal of their appeals by suspending the substantive order of sentence of life imprisonment.
9. The High Court suspended the substantive order of sentence of all the three convicts and ordered their release on bail vide the impugned order dated 16.09.2022. The High Court observed thus: “By the impugned judgment and order of conviction dated 12.03.2021 and order of sentence dated 15.03.2021 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-VII, Vaishali at Hajipur, in Sessions Trial No. 280/2019 arising out of Jandaha P.S. Case No. 202/2018, the appellant has been convicted and sentenced as under:
OMPRAKASH SAHNI v. JAI SHANKAR CHAUDHARY & ANR. ETC. [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 150 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
75 per cent of the fine amount has been ordered to be paid to the widow of deceased Manish Sahni, namely, Rup Kala Devi and 25 per cent of the amount has been ordered to be paid to the State of Bihar.
In compliance of this Court’s order dated 03.08.2022, the State has filed a written objection in terms of the first proviso to Section 389(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code. We have heard Mr. Vasant Vikas, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant in Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 322 of 2021; Mr. Sanjay Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant in Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 411 of 2021 and learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants have submitted that for the occurrence said to have taken place at 03:00 pm, at a public place, on 13.08.2018, the First Information Report came to be registered on 14.08.2018, based on written report of the informant (P.W.-7) submitted at 01:00 pm. The informant has claimed to be an eye-witness of the occurrence. However, there is no explanation for the late submission of the written report, naming these appellants as A B C D E F G H the assailants. It has been argued that it is evident from the First Information Report that political rivalry between the deceased and these appellants has been disclosed as the reason why the deceased was killed by these appellants. They accordingly submit that disclosure of names of these appellants in the First Information Report, as the main assailants, is an afterthought and in that background, the late registration of First Information Report casts a serious doubt on the veracity of the prosecution’s case. It has, further, been argued that though (P.W.-7), the informant, has claimed to be an eyewitness to the occurrence, who had carried the deceased in the injured condition to a nearby hospital and thereafter to Sadar hospital, after the deceased was declared dead in a private hospital; his own deposition contradicts this version as asserted in the First Information Report inasmuch as in response to a question during the course of cross-examination, he admitted that he had not gone to the Sadar hospital with the deceased. It has further been argued that though the appellants were produced during the course of the trial through video conference from the jail, but there is no evidence that the prosecution’s witnesses identified these appellants during the course of the trial.
Learned Additional Public Prosecutor opposing appellants’ prayer for bail has submitted that since the appellants are the main assailants, as disclosed in the First Information Report, which has been substantiated by all the eye-witnesses during the course of the trial, who have been consistent in their depositions and political rivalry between the deceased and these appellants, being an admitted fact, such animosity adds credence to the deposition of the eyewitnesses.
We have perused the impugned judgment and order of the trial court. We have given our anxious consideration to rival submissions advanced on behalf of the parties. We have perused the original copy of the First Information Report available with the lower court records from which it is manifest that there have been over-writings as regards the date when the said written report of the informant (P.W.-7) was submitted in the police station.
OMPRAKASH SAHNI v. JAI SHANKAR CHAUDHARY & ANR. ETC. [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] A B C D E F G H 152 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
It is the prosecution’s case, as disclosed in the First Information Report as also set up at the trial, that the occurrence had taken place at 03:00 pm on 13.08.2018 in the Block office. The deceased was Pramukh of the said block. It has been asserted in the First Information Report that when the informant and the deceased were about to enter into his (deceased’s) chamber in the Block office, appellant Jai Shankar Chaudhary and Abhay Kumar opened fire on the instigation of accused Ram Babu Sahani. The informant and others are said to have taken the deceased, in injured condition, to a private hospital, where he was declared dead. The dead body of the deceased was thereafter taken to Sadar hospital, where the inquest report was prepared by the police officer and post-mortem was also carried out on the same date, i.e., 13.08.2018. In the aforesaid background, we find substance in the submission made on behalf of the appellants that there was no cogent explanation for the informant to have filed his written statement on the next day at 01 :00 pm, implicating these appellants as the main assailants. Further, the informant (P.W.-7) does not prima facie appear to be truthful, particularly in view of the evidence of the prosecution witnesses to the effect that the body of the deceased was taken by villagers to the hospital and not by the informant. In the abovementioned peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, in our view, inordinate delay in filing of the written report leading to registration of First Information Report appears to be a valid ground for doubting the case of the prosecution, for the purpose of exercise of discretion under Article 389(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code.
Considering the facts and circumstances as noted above, the prayer made on behalf of the appellants for their release on bail is allowed.
Let the appellants, namely, Jai Shankar Chaudhary [In Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 322 of 2021], Abhay Kumar @ Abhay Sahni and Ram Babu Sahni [In Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 411 of 2021] be released on bail during the pendency of appeal on furnishing bail bond of Rs. 10,000/- (Ten Thousand) with two sureties of the like amount each to the satisfaction A B C D E F G H of learned Additional Sessions Judge-VII, Vaishali at Hajipur, in Sessions Trial No. 280 of 2019 arising out of Jandaha P.S. Case No. 202of2018.
The sentence shall remain suspended in the meanwhile. Realisation of fine shall also remain stayed.”
(Emphasis supplied)
10. The original first informant (brother of the deceased) being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the aforesaid order passed by the High Court has come up in appeals before us.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.