Maghavendra Pratap Singh @ Pankaj Singh v. State of Chhattisgarh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 415; [2023] 4 S.C.R. 829
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sanjay Karol Penal Code, Justice 1860: Ss. 302, Justice 201, Justice The High Court Acquitted All the Accused Except the Appellant – On Appeal, Justice Held: Prosecution Case Rests Solely On Circumstantial Evidence
- Decided
- 24 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 915/2016
- Sections
- 25(1), 120B, 302, 120, 201, 79, 10, 156, 157, 160, 161, 172
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 829[2023] 4 S.C.R. 829 MAGHAVENDRA PRATAP SINGH @ PANKAJ SINGH v.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH
(Criminal Appeal No. 915 of 2016)
APRIL 24, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI AND SANJAY KAROL, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860: ss. 302 , 201, 120-B – Circumstantial Evidence – Criminal Conspiracy – Businessman-victim threatened for money and shot dead by two motorcyclists – Appellant and several others chargesheeted – Trial court convicted and sentenced all the accused persons except one – However, the High Court acquitted all the accused except the appellant – On appeal, held: Prosecution case rests solely on circumstantial evidence, as none was found present at the scene of the incident – Neither of the independent witness supported the prosecution case – Veracity of the Investigating Officer’s testimony does not inspire confidence on account of various lapses – Nothing on record suggests that the appellant had conspired to commit offence – Also all other accused were acquitted by the courts below and a single person cannot hatch a conspiracy – Thus, the High Court without appreciating the testimonies of the witnesses in their true import and meaning, and without having any discussion concerning the complicity of the appellant, in a perfunctory manner held the prosecution to have established the case, which is entirely circumstantial in nature, against the appellant – High Court erred in holding that the evidence reveals that in all human probability the act must have been done by the appellant – Principle of determining the guilt of the appellant in a case involving circumstantial evidence is not that of probability but certainty and that all the evidence present should conclusively point towards only a singular hypothesis, which is the guilt of the appellant – Thus, the order of the High Court is set aside – Arms Act, 1959 – s. 25(1)(1-b)(a) – Evidence Act, 1872 – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1974 – Chapter XII.
Penal Code, 1860:120-B – Charge of criminal conspiracy under – Basic requirement of – Held: For the charge of criminal conspiracy u/s. 120B, to be established, an agreement between the A B C D E F G H 830 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
parties to do an unlawful act must exist – In case of lack of direct evidence, it is not safe to hold a person guilty u/s. 120B – To prove the offence of criminal conspiracy, it is imperative to show a meeting of the minds between the conspirators for the intended common object – On facts, appellant cannot be convicted of criminal conspiracy solely for having concealed the location of the incriminating materials / articles and, in the absence of any evidence establishing meeting of the minds – Given that all the other coaccused have been acquitted by the courts below, meaning they were innocent of the crime, the fundamental requirement of a criminal conspiracy is not met.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 : Chapter XII – Duties and responsibilities of the Investigating Officer – Compliance of – Held: Investigating Officer is the person tasked with determining a direction, the pace, manner and method of the investigation – It is his statutory duty under the CrPC and is also a constitutional obligation to ensure the maintenance of peace and the uphold of rule of law – On facts, Investigating Officer miserably failed to investigate as is expected and required of a police officer to investigate a crime of murder, especially when not even a single eyewitness exists, and the entire case rests entirely on circumstantial evidence – Investigating Officer did not meet the obligations he was under – Numerous infirmities affected the conduct of the Investigation Officer calling into question, credibly, the investigation conducted by him or upon his directions.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 The prosecution’s case rests solely on circumstantial evidence, as none was found present at the scene of the incident. Further, it is also not the case of the prosecution that the present appellant had either used or shot the deceased with the gun allegedly recovered based on his statement, which was purportedly made before the police officer-PW-23 in the presence of independent witnesses PW-6 and PW-7. [Paras 10 and 11][837-G-H]
1.2. Neither of the independent witness PW 6 and PW 7 supported the prosecution case. Despite extensive cross examination conducted by the Public Prosecutor, nothing A B C D E F G H substantial could be elicited from their testimonies indicating any guilt of the accused. PW-1, nephew of the deceased, has not made out any person to be responsible for the offence, nor has he expressed any doubt or pointed fingers against any of the accused, much less the present appellant. Close examination of the testimony of the Investigating Officer-PW-23 reveals that the witness miserably failed to investigate as is expected and required of a police officer to investigate a crime of murder, especially when not even a single eyewitness exists, and the entire case rests entirely on circumstantial evidence. [Paras 14, 18 and 19][838-F; 839-C-D]
1.3. The homicidal death of the victim is not in dispute. It has come in the testimony of the Investigating Officer that on 27.9.2009, after registration of the complaint, he visited the spot; carried out the preliminary investigation; sent the dead body for post-mortem and collected several incriminating articles. His testimony reveals that the prime accused was SP, who stands acquitted on all charges by the Court below, and this Court is not called upon examine the complicity of the other accused. It further emanates from the testimony of PW 23 that the present appellant was not present at the spot of the crime. In fact, not even one person has disclosed his complicity in the crime. His testimony further reads the complicity of the appellant in the crime, to be suspected only based on the disclosure statements of co-accused SP to the effect that the former could get recovered pistol/bullets/ live cartridges from the house of co-accused AS. The courts below disbelieved this part of the version of the deponent qua the other accused. Hence, the High Court’s reasoning in arriving at appellant’s guilt is illogical if not self-contradictory. [Paras 20- 22][839-E-H; 840-A] 1.4 Nothing on the record suggests that the instant appellant had conspired to commit the offence. At best, as shown from the testimony of this deponent, the present appellant has only concealed the relevant incriminating evidence/articles. The materials on record in no way establish that before the commission of the offence, the accused had any common purpose, object or intention of committing the crime, without the same being borne out of the records, the charge of criminal conspiracy MAGHAVENDRA PRATAP SINGH @ PANKAJ SINGH v.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH
A B C D E F G H 832 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
and of common intention which is to be read with Section 302 of the Penal Code, fails. For the charge of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B to be established, an agreement between the parties to do an unlawful act must exist. In some cases, direct evidence to establish conspiracy may be absent, but when the lack of evidence is apparent, it is not safe to hold a person guilty under this section. To prove the offence of criminal conspiracy, it is imperative to show a meeting of the minds between the conspirators for the intended common object. Thus, the present appellant cannot be convicted of criminal conspiracy under Section 120B, solely for having concealed the location of the incriminating materials/ articles and, in the absence of any evidence establishing meeting of the minds. Given that all the other co-accused have been acquitted by the courts below, meaning they were innocent of the crime, the fundamental requirement of a criminal conspiracy is not met. The charge of criminal conspiracy also fails on the ground that a single person cannot hatch a conspiracy. [Paras 30- 33][841-E-H; 842-A,B-D] 1.5 Even about the search, the veracity of the Investigating Officer’s testimony is not found to be inspiring in confidence on account of various lapses. For he did not examine the owner of the house; did not enter his movement in the case diary; did not record that he took the accused for effecting the recovery; was not able to describe clearly the area from where the recovery was effected; admits both the independent witnesses, who do not belong to the area from where the recoveries were effected; does not associate any of the residents of the area for conducting the search; does not examine any of the residents for carrying out any further investigation and most importantly admits that both the memo of arrest as also the recovery not to have been prepared by him or bearing his signature and the same too, have many corrections and over-writing, thus reducing the correctness and authenticity of this document. Furthermore, he is not clear about the description of the articles recovered. [Paras 35 and 36][843-A-C] 1.6 The Investigating Officer is the person tasked with determining a direction, the pace, manner and method of the investigation. It is a statutory duty under the Cr.P.C. and is also A B C D E F G H a constitutional obligation ensuring the maintenance of peace and the upholding of rule of law. The Magistrate concerned is not empowered to interfere with the investigation being carried out up until the submission of the report by the said officer. Needless to state then that the role of the Investigating Officer is essential and crucial. Chapter XII Cr.P.C. titled as “information to the police and their powers to investigate”, lays down the procedure and course of action to be taken by the police upon receipt of the commission of an offence cognizable in nature. [Paras 38, 40][843- F, H; 844-C-D] 1.7 The Investigating Officer did not meet the obligations he was under. Numerous infirmities affected the conduct of the Investigation Officer calling into question, credibly, the investigation conducted by him or upon his directions. [Para 44][846-D] 1.8 The High Court, without appreciating the testimonies of the witnesses in their true import and meaning, and without having any discussion concerning the complicity of the accused, in a perfunctory manner held the prosecution to have established the case, which is entirely circumstantial in nature, against the instant appellant. Significantly, the High Court holds that the evidence reveals that “in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused”. Inter alia, it is this finding which is found to be erroneous, for the principle of determining the guilt of the accused in a case involving circumstantial evidence is not that of probability but certainty and that all the evidence present should conclusively point towards only a singular hypothesis, which is the guilt of the accused. The judgment passed by the High Court is set aside.[Paras 45-46][846-E-H] Vijay Shankar v. State of Haryana (2015) 12 SCC 644 : [2015] 9 SCR 977; D.K Basu v. State of WB (1997) 1 SCC 416 : [1996] 10 Suppl. SCR 284; Parveen v. State of Haryana, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 1184; Geeta Devi Vs. State of U.P. & Ors. 2022 SCC OnLine 57;
Amarnath Chaubey v. Union of India (2021) 11 SCC 80; Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union of India (2014) 2 SCC 532 : [2013] 17 SCR 1099; Common Cause v.
Union of India (2015) 6 SCC 332 : [2015] 6 SCR 731;
Pooja Pal v. Union of India (2016) 3 SCC 135 : [2016] 11 SCR 560; Bhagwant Singh v. Commission of Police MAGHAVENDRA PRATAP SINGH @ PANKAJ SINGH v.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH
A B C D E F G H 834 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
(1983) 3 SCC 344 : [1983] 3 SCR 109; Mohd. Imran Khan v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), (2011) 10 SCC 192 : [2011] 15 SCR 1030 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2015] 9 SCR 977 referred to Para 12 [1996] 10 Suppl. SCR 284 referred to Para 27 (2021) 11 SCC 80 referred to Para 38 [2013] 17 SCR 1099 referred to Para 38 [2015] 6 SCR 731 referred to Para 39 [2016] 11 SCR 560 referred to Para 41 [1983] 3 SCR 109 referred to Para 42 [2011] 15 SCR 1030 referred to Para 43 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.915 of 2016.
From the Judgment and Order dated 14.01.2016 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in CRA No.468 of 2013.
Shivaji M. Jadhav, Brij Kishor Sah, Adarsh Kumar Pandey, Apurva, Balraj Virha, Rehman Ali, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. Ashmita Singh, Gautam Narayan, Advs. for the Respondent. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
SANJAY KAROL, J.
1. The following three questions arise for consideration :
1. Whether the Investigating Officer in the present case had complied with the duties and responsibilities cast upon him by virtue of Chapter XII of Code of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973?
2. Whether the court below, while acquitting all the other co-accused in connection with the same crime, erred in not returning a finding qua the instant appellant – a co-accused - in respect of a charged framed under Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860?
A B C D E F G H
3. Whether the impugned judgments convicting the appellant are sustainable in law or not?
2. Maghavendra Pratap Singh @ Pankaj Singh (referred to as Pankaj Singh) has preferred the present appeal against the Judgment dated 14.1.2016 passed by the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in Criminal Appeal No.468 of 2013. He alone stands convicted for having committed an offence punishable under Section 302, Indian Penal Code, 1860, with life imprisonment and a fine of Rs.1000/- with further imprisonment of 6 months in default; under Section 201 of the IPC, punishable with 7 years RI with a fine of Rs.1000/- and 6 months RI for default; under Section 25(1)(1-b)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959 3 years RI with fine of Rs.1000/- and 6 months RI for default. The sentences were awarded to run concurrently.
3. The incident which led to the present case was that a businessman by the name of Goverdhan Aggarwal (hereinafter, the deceased) and certain others were threatened, and a demand of rupees ten lakhs was made from each of them. On 26.9.2009 the deceased left his office at about 7:00 PM for his home when two motorcyclists shot him. He was taken to the District Hospital, Ambikapur, in the car of PW-24, namely Prabodh Minz, where he died. That night, an FIR was registered at the P.S. Gandhi Nagar (Ex.P-37). The body was sent for a post-mortem vide Memo under Ex.P-39. After due investigation, a chargesheet was filed, stating that all the accused persons, including Sunil Paswan, Pankaj Singh, and Pappu Tiwari, came together and, in agreement, committed or caused to be committed the murder of Gowardhan Aggarwal. In pursuance of the said agreement, Pappu Tiwari made available the motorcycle, Pankaj Singh conveyed the information of the deceased having departed from his office, Abhishek Singh carried Sunil Paswan and the weapons as pillion rider on the said motorcycle on the evening of 26.9.2009 at about 7:00 PM, where Sunil Paswan then shot the deceased.
4. The Learned Additional District Judge, in Session Trial No. 76/ 2010, seized of the trial against Sunil Paswan, Maghavendra Pratap Singh @ Pankaj Singh, Akhileshwar Pratap Singh @ Lalit Singh, and Sidkant Tiwari @ Pappu Tiwari; and in Sessions Case 166/2010, Mannu Singh @ Gyanendra Singh @ Manvendra Singh @ Abhishek Singh, Satish Tripathi, and Ganeshdutt Mishra.
MAGHAVENDRA PRATAP SINGH @ PANKAJ SINGH v.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH [SANJAY KAROL, J.] A B C D E F G H 836 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
A total of twenty- eight witnesses were examined, and the Trial Court framed eight issues for consideration. Issues A, B and C concern the instant appellant. They are; A) whether the accused persons have in agreement with each other and, in pursuance of criminal conspiracy, murdered the deceased; B) whether the accused have in agreement with each other and with the intention to screen each other from punishment concealed particular articles such as the motorcycle, pistol, cartridges, scarf, etc. and C) whether Pankaj Singh has been found in possession of two 9mm pistols, their magazines and thirty-three live cartridges without possessing the requisite licence thereof.
5. The Learned Additional District Judge disposed of both the cases with a common judgement dated 25.03.2013. by which out of the seven persons named above, one, namely, Akhileshwar Pratap Singh, was acquitted, and others were convicted and sentenced under various provisions of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and in certain cases under provisions of the Arms Act, 1959.
6. A total of five appeals were filed before the High Court. The status of all accused persons is as under:
Accused Charge Trial Court High Court
7. The High Court, vide Impugned judgement dated 14.01.2016, acquitted all the accused save and except Maghavendra Pratap Singh @ Pankaj Singh, the present appellant.
8. This Court has therefore been called upon to examine the correctness of the conviction decision and sentence rendered by the A B C D E F G H learned First Additional Sessions Judge, Ambikapur, District Sarguja, Chhattisgarh, and as partly confirmed by the High Court. The Impugned Judgment
9. In the appeal preferred by the convicts (five in number) in terms of the impugned Judgment, the High Court, while acquitting all the other convicts, namely, Satish Tripathi, Ganesh Datt Mishra, Mannu Singh, and Sunil Paswan, has confirmed the conviction and sentence awarded to Pankaj Singh as reproduced above. In doing so, the Court found the testimonies of Ashish Agrawal (PW-1), Naresh Mandal (PW- 6), Avinash Tirki (PW-7) and Inspector J.S. Saggu (PW-23), Investigation Officer sufficient enough to prove the guilt of Pankaj Singh warranting conviction and sentence. In paragraph 49 of its Judgment, the High Court observed as under:
“49. On due consideration, the prosecution has proved entire circumstantial evidence against the appellant Madvendra. The circumstances are fully established consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and that is not explainable by any other circumstances except that appellant Madhvendra is guilty and evidence collected by the prosecution is of the conclusive nature and tendency. The chain of evidence is complete, it shows in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused. The Prosecution has duly proved that appellant Madhvendra had killed Gowardhan Agrawal and was also in possession of fire arm and cartridges in contravention of relevant provisions of Arms Act and had caused disappearance of evidence of offence committed by concealing the pistol, cartridges and other articles. The conviction awarded to accused Madhvendra does not call for any interference. The same is well founded.” Consideration of the Evidence on Record
10. It is pertinent to note that the prosecution’s case rests solely on circumstantial evidence, as none was found present at the scene of the incident.
11. Further, it is also not the case of the prosecution that the present appellant had either used or shot the deceased with the gun allegedly recovered based on his statement (Ex. P-15), which was purportedly made before the police officer (PW-23) in the presence of independent witnesses namely, Naresh Mandal (PW-6) and Avinash Tirki (PW-7). MAGHAVENDRA PRATAP SINGH @ PANKAJ SINGH v.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH [SANJAY KAROL, J.] A B C D E F G H 838 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
12. It will be helpful to refer to the general principle of cases revolving around circumstantial evidence as encapsulated by Vijay Shankar v. State of Haryana (2015) 12 SCC 644. The relevant portion is as follows:
“8. There is no eyewitness to the occurrence and the entire case is based upon circumstantial evidence. The normal principle is that in a case based on circumstantial evidence the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently and firmly established; that these circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused; that the circumstances taken cumulatively should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability the crime was committed by the accused and they should be incapable of explanation of any hypothesis other than that of the guilt of the accused and inconsistent with their innocence vide Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 : 1984 SCC (Cri) 487]. The same view was reiterated in Bablu v. State of Rajasthan [Bablu v. State of Rajasthan, (2006) 13 SCC 116 : (2007) 2 SCC (Cri) 590].”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.