Gwalior Development Authority and Another v. Bhanu Pratap Singh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 393; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 498
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Ajay Rastogi
- Decided
- 19 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8549/2014
- Sections
- 17
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 498 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.[2023] 3 S.C.R. 498
GWALIOR DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND ANOTHER
v.
BHANU PRATAP SINGH
(Civil Appeal No. 8549 of 2014)
APRIL 19, 2023
[AJAY RASTOGI AND BELA M. TRIVEDI, JJ.] Constitution of India – Article 226 – Registered lease deed – Alteration/amendment u/Article 226 – Impermissibility of – Appellants invited bids in 1997 for grant of leases of different plots under the transport city scheme – Respondent’s offer for 27887.50 sq. meters @ Rs.725/- per sq. meter was accepted and the aforesaid plot area was leased out in his favour for Rs.2,06,67,966/- to be paid in four instalments after making the advance payment of Rs.15 lakhs as earnest money – Instalments were to be deposited by October 1999 – However, respondent deposited the final instalment in August 2005 – After negotiations, lease deed was finally executed in March 2006 but for the reduced land of 18262.89 sq.meters rather than the total land of 27887.50 sq. meters – Respondent filed writ petition seeking mandamus against the appellants to execute the lease deed for the remaining area of land i.e.9625.50 sq. meters – Allowed – Correctness of – Held: Parties got the lease deed executed for 18262.89 sq. meters without demur in March 2006 and the transaction which was initiated pursuant to the tender floated by the appellant in 1997 stood concluded after execution of the lease deed – Thus, after the transaction was concluded and the instrument was registered u/s.17 of the Registration Act, it was not open to be altered or amended even by the High Court in exercise of its jurisdiction u/Article 226 – Mandamus issued by the High Court to execute the lease deed for the remainder of the area is beyond jurisdiction and contrary to law – Impugned judgment set aside– Registration Act, 1908 – s.17.
Constitution of India – Article 14 – Violation of – Undue indulgence granted by appellant-Authority – Held: There is no justification as to what was the reason for the Authority to grant undue indulgence to the respondent in depositing the instalments which ought to have been deposited by 31.10.1999 but were A B C D E F G H deposited upto 25.08.2005 – In the ordinary course of business, the auction was supposed to be cancelled and the earnest money deserved to be forfeited – Such exercise of power by the Authority is a clear abuse of discretion which is not only violative of Art.14, but also smacks of an undue favour which is always to be avoided – Whenever there is such a business/commercial transaction, it is always to be examined on the commercial principles where equity has no role to play.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 8549 of 2014.
From the Judgment and Order dated 21.04.2011 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh Bench at Gwalior in WP No. 2792 of 2009.
Sanjay Hegde, Sr. Adv., Rajesh Kandari, Vikrant Singh Bais, Advs. for the Appellants.
Varun K. Chopra, Rohin Oza, Mehul Sharma, Dipu Jha, Harsh Khabar, M/s VKC Law Offices, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
RASTOGI, J.
1. The instant appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 21st April, 2011 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Gwalior with the following directions: i) The Respondents are directed to execute the lease deed in favour of the petitioner of remaining area of the land i.e. 9625.50 sq. mtr. in accordance with the acceptance of his offer of total plot area 27887.50 sq. mtr.
ii) The petitioner shall be liable to make payment of interest from 17.8.2001 upto 29.3.2006 when the lease deed was executed in favour of the petitioner excluding the period of 27.5.2004 to 29.3.2005.
iii) The Respondents are at liberty to calculate the amount of interest accordingly after verification of the amount which has been paid by the petitioner.
iv) The order be complied with within a period of three months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order.
GWALIOR DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND ANR. v.
BHANU PRATAP SINGH
A B C D E F G H 500 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
2. The facts of the case culled out from the record are that the appellants, according to the land disposal rules, issued an advertisement and invited bids for grant of leases of different plots under the transport city scheme. The respondent was also one of the bidders for MC-2 (Market Complex-2) plot area 27887.50 sq. meters. The offer of the respondent @Rs.725/- per sq. meter being the highest bid was finally accepted. Consequently, a letter of allotment dated 29th September, 1997 was issued in favour of the respondent whereby it was informed that the bid of the respondent was found to be the highest and it had been decided to lease out the plot area of 27887.50 sq. meters in his favour for a consideration of Rs.2,06,67,966/- and the auction bidder/respondent was directed to deposit a sum of Rs.1,91,67,966/- upto the period of 31st October, 1999 in addition to the earnest money of Rs.15 lakhs in four instalments in the following manner:
(i) Rs.51,66,922/- by 31.10.1997 (for 25% amount)
(ii) Rs.51,66,922/- by 30.06.1998 (for first instalment)
(iii) Rs.51,66,922/- by 28.10.1999 (for second instalment)
(iv) Rs.36,36,990/- by 31.10.1999 (for third instalment)
3. The letter of allotment contained a rider that the market complex has to be constructed in accordance with the sanctioned plan by the Gwalior Development Authority (hereinafter being referred to as the “Authority”) and construction work has to be completed within the period of two years with a further stipulation that failure to deposit the instalments in terms of the conditions of the bid document, the security amount shall be forfeited.
4. It is not disputed that the respondent deposited a total sum of Rs.2,02,18,437/- from September, 1997 to the last instalment on 25th August, 2005. The amount deposited by the respondent on various dates be stated as under:
1 27.9.1997 Rs. 15,00,000.00 2 6.11.1997 Rs. 2,00,000.00 3 31.12.1997 Rs. 3,00,000.00 4 17.4.1998 Rs. 5,00,000.00 5 22.1.2003 Rs. 16,00,000.00 A B C D E F G H 6 30.1.2003 Rs. 3,00,000.00 7 30.1.2003 Rs. 2,00,000.00 8 31.12.2001 Rs. 5,00,000.00 9 19.12.2003 Rs. 5,00,000.00 10 12.4.2004 Rs. 10,00,000.00 11 27.2.2004 Rs. 10,00,000.00 12 5.1.2004 Rs. 10,00,000.00 13 25.8.2005 Rs. 1,16,18,437.00 Total Rs. 2,02,18,437.00
5. It reveals from the record that, in the meanwhile, the respondent requested for revising the layout plan in order to enable to deposit the requisite amount with the Authority and the layout plans were also revised, but finally the amended layout plan was accepted by the Authority on 17th August, 2001. It is also not disputed that despite the respondent failed to deposit the instalments in terms of conditions of the bid document by 31st October, 1999 and the final amount being deposited on 25th August, 2005, no action was taken by the appellants either for cancellation of the bid or for forfeiture of the amount deposited by the respondent and what transpires between the parties is not made available on record but the fact is that the lease deed was finally executed for 18262.89 sq. meters on 29th March, 2006 to the extent of principal amount of Rs.1,32,39,356/ - @Rs.725/- per sq. meter plus the component of interest for the said amount for the delay in deposit of Rs.69,97,087/- total Rs.2,02,18,437/and the lease deed was executed by the respondent without any demur. We do not find any justification as to what was the reason for the Authority to grant such undue indulgence to the respondent in depositing the instalments which ought to have been deposited by 31st October, 1999 but were deposited upto 25th August, 2005, be that as it may, it appears that after some round table negotiations to the extent of principal amount it was adjusted against the auction bid and balance to be adjusted towards interest, the total land which was put to public auction of 27887.50 sq. meters, was reduced to 18262.89 sq. meters and with the consent of parties and without any demur, the lease deed was executed on 29th March, 2006.
GWALIOR DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND ANR. v.
BHANU PRATAP SINGH [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 502 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
6. After more than a period of three and half years, the writ petition came to be filed by the respondent under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking a mandamus against the appellants to execute the lease deed for the remaining area of 9625.50 sq. meters in addition to the lease earlier executed in favour of the respondent and the Division Bench of the High Court while accepting the prayer made by the respondent, directed the appellants to execute the lease deed in favour of the respondent for the remaining area of 9625.50 sq. meterswithout any consideration with liability on the respondent to make payment of interest for the period 17th August, 2001 upto 29th March, 2006, the day when the lease deed was executed in favour of the respondent, excluding the period of 27th May, 2004 to 29th March, 2005. As a matter of fact, no additional consideration was required to be paid by the respondent except the interest for the interregnum period of which reference has been made under the impugned judgment and that became the subject matter of challenge at the instance of the Authority in the instant appeal.
7. Notices were issued by this Court on 4th January, 2012 and after hearing the parties, leave was granted on 5th September, 2014.
8. It reveals from the record that at one point of time, it was informed to this Court that there is a possibility of settlement of dispute between the parties, which reflects from the order of this Court dated 27th August, 2019, but later, it reveals from the order dated 4th May, 2022, that counsel for the respondent on instructions informed this Court that the circle rate fixed by the State Government in reference to the subject land in question is not viable and is much higher than the market value of the subject property as on that day for commercial use. As no settlement was arrived at between the parties, the matter was finally heard and arguments stood concluded on 13th April, 2023.
9. Learned counsel for the respondent informed this Court that on 16th March, 2023, although it was not reflected in the order, the respondent was called upon as to whether the prevalent circle rate in reference to the subject property in question is acceptable, the appellant Authority can be called upon to examine, but we find from the record that there was no such order as referred to by the respondent’s learned counsel, the fact is that whatever circle rate prevalent at the relevant point of time of which we have made a reference, was not considered to be viable by the respondent and once this amicable resolution has failed, the matter was being heard on merits.
A B C D E F G H
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.