C. Haridasan v. Anappath Parakkattu Vasudeva Kurup & Others
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 37; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 244
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.R. Shah, Justice B.V. Nagarathna Specific Relief Act, Justice 1963 : Ss. 10, Justice 16(C)
- Decided
- 13 Jan 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4072/2022
- Sections
- 20, 16, 10, 11, 14
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 244 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
C. HARIDASAN
v.
ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA KURUP & OTHERS
(Civil appeal no. 4072 of 2022)
JANUARY 13, 2023
[M. R. SHAH AND B. V. NAGARATHNA, JJ.] Specific Relief Act, 1963 : ss. 10, 16(c), 20 – Discretion as to decreeing specific performance – On facts execution of the agreement to sell land between the parties and receipt of consideration by the appellant-buyer – Balance amount to be paid within six months provided the respondent-seller made available the document of title and purchase certificate after measuring the property – Thereafter notice served by the appellant to the respondent to execute the sale deed – Refusal of the respondent to execute the sale deed and cancelled the agreement – Suit for specific performance of the agreement to sell by the appellant – Trial court allowed the suit and also directed the appellant to pay 25% more amount, over and above the agreed consideration – High Court while considering s. 20, set aside the decree for specific performance and directed the respondent to pay the consideration amount to the appellant – On appeal held: In view of difference of opinion, matter referred to the larger bench – Reference to larger Bench.
Referring *the matter to larger Bench, the Court
HELD :
PER M. R. SHAH, J.
1.1. It was never the case on behalf of the defendants in the written statement and/or even before the trial court that the agreement to sell was inequitable and/or was a forced agreement to sell. Even the trial court also did not frame the issue, “whether agreement to sell was a forced agreement to sell/contract or not”. [2023] 3 S.C.R. 244 Ed. Note : Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.R. Shah and Hon’ble Mrs. Justice B.V. Nagarathna pronounced separate reportable judgments of the Bench comprising Their Lordships. In view of difference of opinion in the matter it was directed to place the papers before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India for appropriate orders for constituting a larger Bench to decide the controversy.
A B C D E F G H On appreciation of entire evidence on record, the trial court after recording the findings on the execution of the agreement to sell by the defendants and receipt of part sale consideration and that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, decreed the suit for specific performance. The High Court, as such, has not commented upon and/or set aside any of the findings recorded by the trial court, recorded while passing a decree for specific performance. Straightway, the High Court considered Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act and observed and held that by enhancing the amount of sale consideration, the trial court has wrongly exercised the discretion in favour of the plaintiff. The High Court commented upon the order passed by the trial court enhancing the amount of sale consideration and directing the plaintiff to pay more amount than the sale consideration mentioned in the agreement to sell. [Para 6][257- A-E] 1.2 The trial court directed the plaintiff to pay some more amount than the amount mentioned in the agreement to sell, at the most, the plaintiff can be said to be aggrieved. Still, the High Court considered such an order passed by the trial court against the defendants. As such, the trial court was absolutely justified in compensating the defendants by paying some more amount while passing a decree for specific performance. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the case and more particularly when the trial court exercised the discretion in favour of the plaintiff after having observed and recorded the findings on the execution of the agreement to sell by the defendants and that the part sale consideration was paid by the plaintiff which was accepted by the defendants and thereafter the finding that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, the trial court was absolutely justified in passing the decree for specific performance. The High Court has erred in interfering with the judgment and decree passed by the trial court, without setting aside the findings recorded by the trial court recorded while passing the decree for specific performance. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is unsustainable, both, on law as well as on facts, and is quashed and set aside and the judgment and decree passed by the trial court for specific performance of agreement to sell is restored. However, to do C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA
KURUP
A B C D E F G H 246 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
complete justice and in exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, it is directed that over and above the sale consideration mentioned in the agreement to sell and the amount already deposited by the plaintiff, the plaintiff to pay a further sum of Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) to the original defendants, to be paid within the stipulated period. The amount which might have been deposited by the original defendants, deposited pursuant to the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court, i.e., Rs. 3,10,000/- be also returned/paid to the original defendants. [Para 7, 8][257-F-H; 258- A-E] Pratap Lakshman Muchandi v. Shamlal Uddavadas Wadhwa, (2008) 12 SCC 67 : [2008] 1 SCR 854 – relied on.
PER B. V. NAGARATHNA, J. (Dissenting) :
1.1 The High Court relied on Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, prior to the same being substituted by way of Act No. 18 of 2018, to deny the relief of specific performance to the plaintiff. Section 20 of the Act as it stood prior to the Amendment Act of 2018 provided that the jurisdiction to decree specific performance is discretionary. It said that the Court is not bound to grant such relief merely because it is lawful to do so. Such a discretion, however, was not to be exercised arbitrarily, but ought to have been based on sound and reasonable judicial principles. Even in the absence of discretionary power under Section 20 to deny the relief of specific performance, the plaintiff was not entitled to claim such relief as a matter of right. The position of law, even following the amendment of 2018 remains that the provisions of Section 16 of the Act have to be mandatorily complied with by the party seeking the relief of specific performance. The relief of specific performance cannot be granted in favour of a party who has not performed his obligations under the contract. It is therefore necessary to ascertain whether, the plaintiff had complied with the statutory prerequisites under Section 16 (c), before claiming the relief of specific performance. [Para 12,18][268-B-C; 270-H; 271-A-B] 1.2 Clause (c) of Section 16 of the Act, which is relevant in the instant case, though amended w.e.f. 01st October, 2018 clearly states that unless the plaintiff establishes his readiness and A B C D E F G H willingness to perform his part of the contract, he would not be entitled to a decree of specific performance. Prior to the amendment, the expression “who fails to aver and prove” was on the statute book and its substitution by the words “who fails to prove” does not bring about any drastic change to the object and intent of the clause. This is because failing to prove readiness and willingness to perform the essential terms of the contract would first require averments to that effect to be made in the plaint by the plaintiff. The absence of such averments regarding readiness and willingness to perform the essential terms of the contract by the plaintiff would not permit him to let in any evidence on that aspect. It is a settled principle of law that no evidence can be permitted to be let in in the absence of averments in the plaint / pleadings. [Para 19][271-G-H; 272-A-C] 1.3 Notwithstanding the amendment to Section 16 of the Act whereby the expression “who fails to aver and prove” has been substituted with the phrase “who fails to prove,” the law remains that no evidence can be let in on a plea that was never put forward in the plaint/pleadings. But, it is necessary to sound a caveat. Even the absence of the words “ready and willing to perform the contract” in the plaint would now not have an adverse impact on the plaintiff’s case, so long as plaintiff’s readiness and willingness to perform the essential terms of the contract could be gathered on a holistic reading of the plaint. In fact, even in relation to the earlier scheme of Section 16 of the Act which required a plaintiff seeking the remedy of specific performance to ‘aver and prove’ that he was ready and willing to perform his obligations under an agreement, it was sufficient if the averments in substance indicate continuous readiness and willingness on the part of the person suing, to perform his part of the contract language in Section 16 (c), as it stood prior to the Amendment Act of 2018, did not require any specific phraseology to be followed in relation to the averments as to readiness and willingness. That the compliance of requirements of readiness and willingness have to be in spirt and substance and not in letter and form. That is why the deletion of the words “who fails to aver” in Section 16
(c) of the Act does bring about any real change in the position of law as it stood prior to the amendment. [Para 20, 21][272-E-H; 273-A-B] C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA
KURUP
A B C D E F G H 248 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
1.4 Readiness and willingness cannot be considered in a straitjacket formula; it has to be inferred on a consideration of the entire facts and circumstances of each case and the intention and conduct of the parties concerned. Even if a party to the contract is ready and has the requisite funds he may not be willing to perform his part of the contract and vice versa. Thus, both readiness as well as willingness have to be established by the plaintiff on whom the burden is cast in a suit for specific performance of an agreement. [Para 22, 23][273-C-D; 274-B] 1.5 Nothing was brought on record by the plaintiff to demonstrate that positive steps were taken by him in pursuance of the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights. It is trite that the relief of specific performance cannot be granted in favour of a party who has not performed his obligations under the contract. The only exception to such rule is that a party is not required to perform those obligations, as are prevented or waived by the other party to the contract. [Para 26][275-G-H] 1.6 It is an admitted fact that the plaintiff had paid an amount, which constituted merely 4% of the consideration. The trial court itself recorded findings to the effect that neither party had initiated timely steps to perform their respective obligations under the contract. Although the defendants did not make available the title deeds of the schedule property to the plaintiff, it could not be said that the conduct of the defendants had prevented the plaintiff from tendering the balance sale consideration, within the stipulated date, or at any time before filing the suit for specific performance as the whole object of the intended sale was to garner funds for discharging a debt which was ultimately done by the defendants by selling family jewellery. Further, there was no delay on the part of the defendant in acting in pursuance of the agreement. The fact that the purchase certificate was granted by the concerned authority only on 31st May, 2007, was beyond the control of the defendants and such delay could not be attributed to the defendants. The defendants had duly initiated the process of obtaining a purchase certificate soon after entering into the agreement. [Para 27, 28][276-A-E] 1.7 While the counsel for the appellant-plaintiff has contended that since the transaction in question involved the A B C D E F G H transfer of rights in immovable property, a prudent purchaser would have to satisfy himself as to the genuineness and validity of the documents of title, and therefore, owing to the nonavailability of documents of title, the plaintiff was unable to proceed with his obligations, no explanation has been provided as to why ancillary steps such as measurement of the property was not proceeded with. Delay in securing relevant documents from the concerned authorities could not absolve the plaintiff of his obligations under the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights. Further, this aspect of the matter is to be appreciated in light of the fact that there is nothing on record which would demonstrate any step taken by the plaintiff to pursue the agreement, until, 2nd November, 2006, on which date, the legal notice was served on the defendants calling upon them to execute the sale deed in respect of the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property. No explanation has been provided as to why the legal notice was not served earlier, particularly when the six–month period stipulated under the agreement had expired on 7th February, 2006. Such conduct of the plaintiff is certainly not reflective of willingness, in terms of Section 16(c) of the Act. Further, the Court has to be mindful of circumstances which compelled the defendants to enter into the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights dated 7th February, 2006. The time limit stipulated in the agreement is of significance in the instant case when this aspect is viewed in light of the fact that the defendants were debt-ridden and sought to sell their Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over suit property with the sole intention of clearing off such debts which were incurred to support the cardiac treatment of defendant no. 1. It was therefore necessary that the plaintiff paid a significant portion of the consideration, if not the entire sale consideration, within the period of six months as stipulated in the agreement. But the plaintiff refused to do so even on being repeatedly requested by the defendants. [Para 29, 30][276-E-H; 277-A-C] 1.8 The period of six months which was stipulated in the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, in the present case, has to be accorded its due significance while deciding the suit for specific performance. Having regard to the urgency of the financial need of the defendants, which need had prompted C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA
KURUP
A B C D E F G H 250 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
them to sell their Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property, it must be held that time stipulated in the agreement was the essence of the contract. The plaintiff in the present case served a legal notice only on 02nd November, 2006 while the six month period stipulated in the agreement had elapsed on 07th February, 2006. There is no explanation as to what occasioned the delay in serving the legal notice on the defendants and why such steps were not adopted soon after the expiry of the six month period stipulated in the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights. Therefore, it is held that the plaintiff, having paid no more than 4% of the sale consideration, and having not done even as much as getting the property measured within the period of six months stipulated under the agreement, cannot, at a belated date, claim specific performance of the agreement dated 7th August, 2005 to the disadvantage and hardship of the defendants. [Para 32-34][279-B-F] 1.9 The Courts may grant additional amount of consideration, a relief to balance equities, such a decree would be warranted only in cases where the plaintiff satisfactorily establishes compliance with Section 16 of the Act. That the measure of enhancement of compensation may be awarded at the discretion of the Court only if insufficiency of compensation is the only impediment to ensuring equity and preventing undue gain to one party. In the absence of compliance with the elementary requirements of Section 16 of the Act, enhancement of compensation cannot be employed as a device to allow specific performance in cases where the plaintiff has not performed his obligations under the contract as in the instant case. [Para 35][280- A-C] 1.10 The appeal fails on the sole ground that the conduct of the plaintiff was not reflective of his readiness as well as willingness on his part to pursue the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, in terms of Section 16(c) of the Act. [Para 36][280-C-D] 1.11 The impugned judgment of the High Court whereby the High Court set-aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court, (by which the suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, filed by the plaintiff was decreed), is affirmed. [Para 38][280-H; 281-A] A B C D E F G H Pratap Lakshman Muchandi and Ors. vs. Shamlal Uddavadas Wadhwa and Ors., (2008) 1 SCC 67;
Shenbagam vs. K.K. Rathinavel, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 71; Mehboob-Ur-Rehman (Dead) through LRs vs.
Ahsanul Ghani (2019) 19 SCC 415; Sughar Singh vs.
Hari Singh (Dead) through LRs and Ors., A.I.R. 2021 SC 5581; B. Santoshamma vs. D. Sarala and Anr., (2020) 19 SCC 80; Bachhaj Nahar vs. Nilima Mandal and Ors., (2008) 17 SCC 491; Motilal Jain vs. Ramdasi Devi, A.I.R. 2000 SC 2408 : [2000] 1 Suppl. SCR 615;
Syed Dastagir vs. T.R. Gopalakrishna Shetty, (1999) 6 SCC 337 : [1999] 1 Suppl. SCR 351; His Holiness Acharya Swami Ganesh Dassji vs. Sita Ram Thapar, (1996) 4 SCC 526 : [1996] 2 Suppl. SCR 111; J.P.
Builders vs. A. Ramdas Rao, (2011) 1 SCC 429 : [2010] 15 SCR 538; Saradamani Kandappan vs. S.
Rajalakshmi, (2011) 12 SCC 18 : [2011] 8 SCR 874;
K.S. Vidyanadam vs. Vairavan (1997) 3 SCC 1 : [1997] 1 SCR 993 – referred to.
Case Law Reference In the Judgment of M. R. SHAH, J.
[2008] 1 SCR 854 relied on Para 7 In the Judgment of B. V. NAGARATHNA, J.
(2008) 1 SCC 67 referred to Para 9.4, 35 (2019) 19 SCC 415 referred to Para 15 A.I.R. 2021 SC 5581 referred to Para 16 (2020) 19 SCC 80 referred to Para 17 (2008) 17 SCC 491 referred to Para 19 [2000] 1 Suppl. SCR 615 referred to Para 21 [1999] 1 Suppl. SCR 351 referred to Para 21 [1996] 2 Suppl. SCR 111 referred to Para 23 [2010] 15 SCR 538 referred to Para 24 [2011] 8 SCR 874 referred to Para 31 [1997] 1 SCR 993 referred to Para 32 C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA
KURUP
A B C D E F G H 252 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.4072 of 2022.
From the Judgment and Order dated 03.11.2021 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in RFA No.63 of 2009.
M. K. S. Menon, Ms. Usha Nandini V., Biju P. Raman, M. S.
Vishnu Sankar, Ravi, Advs. for the Appellant.
Raghenth Basant, Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Ms. Roopali Lakhotia, Shankar Narayanan, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgments of the Court were delivered by
M. R. SHAH, J.
1. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order dated 03.11.2021 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in Regular First Appeal No. 63 of 2009, by which the High Court has allowed the said appeal preferred by the original defendants and has set aside the judgment and decree dated 18.08.2008 passed by the learned trial Court in Original Suit No. 205/2006, decreeing the suit for specific performance, the original plaintiff has preferred the present appeal.
2. That the plaintiff and the defendants entered into an agreement to sell dated 07.08.2005 under which the defendants agreed to sell the land in question for a consideration of Rs. 8,750/- per cent. The plaintiff paid an amount of Rs. 10,000/- as advance towards the part sale consideration amount. The balance consideration was agreed to be paid by the plaintiff within six months from the date after measuring the property provided the defendants make available the documents of title including the purchase certificate under the Kerala Land Reforms Act. 2.1 That thereafter, the plaintiff served a legal notice dated 02.11.2006 upon the defendants to execute the sale deed to which the defendants sent reply and refused to execute the sale deed and cancelled the agreement to sell. Therefore, the appellant herein – original plaintiff instituted a Suit being Original Suit No. 205/2006 before the learned trial Court for specific performance of agreement to sell and in the alternative return of the plaintiff’s amount with interest.
2.2 The said suit was resisted by the defendants by filing written statement. It was denied that the plaintiff was ever ready and willing to A B C D E F G H perform his part of the contract. It was also submitted that the suit was filed after one year from the date of expiry of the agreement. It was the case on behalf of the defendants that defendant No.1 was a heart patient and he had undergone the surgery on which huge amount was spent which was borrowed from others and therefore to clear off the said liability, the defendants agreed to sell the property in question. It was also the case of the defendants that even though the defendants had approached the plaintiff to pay some more money, he was not prepared for the same, thereby defendants had been compelled to sell the gold ornaments and clear the liabilities. It was submitted that the defendants were always ready and willing to perform their part of the agreement. 2.3 The learned trial Court framed the following issues:
“1. Whether plaintiff had performed his part of the contract, thereby entitling him for specific performance of the agreement?
2. Whether plaintiff has got any cause of action against defendants?
3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs sought?
4. Relief and costs?”
2.4 On appreciation of the entire evidence on record, the learned trial Court decreed the suit for specific performance of agreement to sell dated 07.08.2005. However, at the same time and to do complete justice between the parties, the learned trial Court directed the plaintiff to pay 25% more amount, over and above the agreed consideration i.e., sale consideration at the rate of Rs. 11,000/- per cent (Rs. 8750/- per cent + 25% = 10,037/-, rounded off to Rs. 11,000/-). The learned trial Court also directed the plaintiff to deposit the balance sale consideration, i.e., Rs. 3,97,000/-, within a period of two months.
2.5 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Court decreeing the suit for specific performance of agreement to sell dated 7.8.2005, the defendants preferred an appeal before the High Court. Without upsetting the findings recorded by the learned trial Court on execution of agreement to sell dated 7.8.2005; payment of part sale consideration and the other issues held in favour of the plaintiff, straightway the High Court considered Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act and opined that the trial Court was not justified in enhancing the sale consideration and ought not to have exercised the discretion in favour of the plaintiff. By the impugned C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA KURUP [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 254 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
judgment and order, the High Court, while relying upon and/or considering Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, has partly allowed the appeal and has set aside the judgment and decree for specific performance and has directed the defendants to pay Rs. 3,10,000/- to the plaintiff. 2.6 Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court, setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Court for specific performance of agreement to sell, the original plaintiff has preferred the present appeal.
3. It is vehemently submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant that in the facts and circumstances of the case, the High Court has committed an error in reversing the decree of specific performance.
3.1 It is submitted that the execution of the agreement to sell and receipt of part sale consideration have not been disputed by the defendants.
3.2 It is submitted that as per the conditions mentioned in the agreement to sell, the balance sale consideration was required to be paid within a period of six months from the date after measuring the property provided the defendants make available the documents of title including the purchase certificate under Kerala Land Reforms Act, which was yet to be obtained.
3.3 It is submitted that even the purchase certificate was issued by the Government during the pendency of the suit. It is submitted that therefore once the execution of agreement to sell is admitted and the part sale consideration is received and it was found that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, the learned trial Court was justified in decreeing the suit for specific performance. 3.4 It is then submitted that even, though not required, the learned trial Court enhanced the sale consideration to do complete justice, which the plaintiff agreed. It is submitted that enhancement of the sale consideration by the learned trial Court could not have been gone against the plaintiff.
3.5 It is further submitted that even otherwise when while exercising the discretion in favour of the plaintiff to pass a decree for specific performance, the learned trial Court enhanced the amount of sale consideration and directed the plaintiff to pay some more amount A B C D E F G H than the sale consideration mentioned in the agreement to sell, the same was not required to be interfered with by the High Court.
3.6 It is submitted that as such the High Court has straightway gone and considered Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, without adverting to the findings recorded by the learned trial Court on execution of the agreement to sell; payment of part sale consideration and that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. 3.7 Making the above submissions, it is prayed to allow the present appeal.
4. The present appeal is opposed by Shri Raghenth Basant, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the original defendants.
4.1 It is vehemently submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the original defendants that as such the agreement to sell was a forced agreement to sell as at the relevant time, defendant no.1 suffered a heart attack and he was in need of money and therefore he was compelled to sell the property in question. It is therefore submitted and as rightly observed by the High Court, the learned trial Court ought not to have exercised the discretion in favour of the plaintiff, rather ought to have exercised the discretion in favour of the defendants on the ground of equity.
4.2 Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the original defendants has submitted that at the time of execution of agreement to sell, the plaintiff paid a meagre amount of Rs. 10,000/- only as advance towards the consideration amount. It is submitted that as the defendants were hard pressed and were in need of immediate money as defendant no.1 suffered a heart attack, it was agreed that the balance consideration to be paid within six months from the date of agreement to sell. It is submitted that thereafter as the plaintiff did not pay the balance sale consideration within six months, the defendants cleared their liabilities by selling gold ornaments of their family members and therefore thereafter the defendants were not in need of money and therefore there was no cause and/or reason to sell the property in question and thereafter the agreement to sell was cancelled. It is submitted that considering the aforesaid circumstances, the High Court has rightly set aside the decree for specific performance, considering Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act and has rightly exercised the discretion in favour of the defendants, rather than in favour of the plaintiff.
C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA KURUP [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 256 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
4.3 It is further submitted by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the defendants that as on today the price of the property in question has gone very high and therefore it is prayed not to interfere with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court.
5. I have heard the learned counsel for the respective parties at length.
At the outset, it is required to be noted that the execution of agreement to sell and receipt of part sale consideration paid under the agreement to sell has not been disputed by the defendants. It is not in dispute that the defendants as such agreed to sell the property in question. The relevant terms of agreement to sell, as agreed between the parties, are as follows:
“(a) the balance consideration was to be paid by the Petitioner to the Respondents within six months from the date of sale agreement.
(b) The Petitioner was obligated to measure the property at his own expense, arrange the balance consideration amount and prepare the deeds with respect to the plaint schedule property in favour of himself or in favour of its nominees.
(c) Respondents were to handover the abovementioned deeds as also the anterior documents, possession certification, tax receipt and encumbrance certificate for the last 13 years, purchase certificate, either in their originals or certified copies within the stipulated six months to the Petitioner.
(d) After the fulfilment of the above terms and conditions, the Respondent No.1 and his wife were obligated to execute the sale deed prepared by the Petitioner and register the same after obtaining the balance consideration amount and then accordingly, the Respondents were to hand over actual possession of the plaint schedule property to the Petitioner.”
6. It is contended on behalf of the defendants that the agreement to sell was a forced agreement to sell. On the contrary, the defendants stated in the written statement in para 4 that the defendants were always ready and willing to perform their part of the contract. It may be true that at the relevant time the defendants may be in need of money. However, the fact remains that they agreed to sell the property in question A B C D E F G H for sale consideration mentioned in the agreement to sell and as observed hereinabove, it was the case on behalf of the defendants that they were always ready and willing to perform their part of the contract. Therefore, as observed hereinabove, it was never the case on behalf of the defendants in the written statement and/or even before the learned trial Court that the agreement to sell was inequitable and/or was a forced agreement to sell. Even the learned trial Court also did not frame the issue, “whether agreement to sell was a forced agreement to sell/contract or not”. On appreciation of entire evidence on record, the learned trial Court after recording the findings on the execution of the agreement to sell by the defendants and receipt of part sale consideration and that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, decreed the suit for specific performance. By the impugned judgment and order, the High Court, as such, has not commented upon and/or set aside any of the findings recorded by the learned trial Court, recorded while passing a decree for specific performance. Straightway, the High Court has considered Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act and has observed and held that by enhancing the amount of sale consideration, the learned trial Court has wrongly exercised the discretion in favour of the plaintiff. The High Court has commented upon the order passed by the learned trial Court enhancing the amount of sale consideration and directing the plaintiff to pay more amount than the sale consideration mentioned in the agreement to sell.
7. When to do the complete justice and relying upon and/or considering the decision of this Court in the case of Pratap Lakshman Muchandi v. Shamlal Uddavadas Wadhwa, (2008) 12 SCC 67, the learned trial Court directed the plaintiff to pay some more amount than the amount mentioned in the agreement to sell, at the most, the plaintiff can be said to be aggrieved. Still, the High Court has considered such an order passed by the learned trial Court against the defendants. As such, the learned trial Court was absolutely justified in compensating the defendants by paying some more amount while passing a decree for specific performance. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the case and more particularly when the learned trial Court exercised the discretion in favour of the plaintiff after having observed and recorded the findings on the execution of the agreement to sell by the defendants and that the part sale consideration was paid by the plaintiff which was accepted by the defendants and thereafter the finding that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract, the C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA KURUP [M. R. SHAH, J.] A B C D E F G H 258 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
learned trial Court was absolutely justified in passing the decree for specific performance. The High Court has erred in interfering with the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Court, without setting aside the findings recorded by the learned trial Court recorded while passing the decree for specific performance. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is unsustainable, both, on law as well as on facts.
8. In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, the present appeal succeeds. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is hereby quashed and set aside and the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Court for specific performance of agreement to sell is hereby restored.
However, to do complete justice and in exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, I direct that over and above the sale consideration mentioned in the agreement to sell and the amount already deposited by the plaintiff, the plaintiff to pay a further sum of Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) to the original defendants, to be paid within a period of six weeks from today. The amount which might have been deposited by the original defendants, deposited pursuant to the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court, i.e., Rs. 3,10,000/- be also returned/paid to the original defendants.
9. The present appeal is accordingly allowed in the aforesaid terms. However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.
NAGARATHNA, J.
1. I have had the advantage of reading the judgment proposed by His Lordship M.R. Shah, J. However, I regret to agree with the reasoning as well as the conclusion arrived at by His Lordship. Hence, my separate judgment.
2. The plaintiff in Original Suit No. 205/2006 has assailed the judgment dated 03rd November, 2021, passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in Regular First Appeal No. 63 of 2009. By the impugned judgment, the High Court has set-aside the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court, i.e., the Court of the Subordinate Judge, Tirur in O.S. No. 205/2006, by which the suit for specific performance of an agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, filed by the plaintiff, was allowed. Hence, the appeal by the plaintiff in the suit.
A B C D E F G H
3. For the sake of convenience, the parties herein shall be referred to in terms of their rank and status before the Trial Court.
4. The case of the plaintiff in a nutshell is stated as under: 4.1 That the defendants who have Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property, measuring 37 cents since 1989, assigned such rights over the same in favour of the plaintiff for a consideration of Rs. 8750/- per cent. That an agreement of sale in respect of the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property was entered into between the defendants-sellers and the plaintiff-buyer on 7th August, 2005 in the presence of witnesses. An advance sale consideration of Rs. 10,000/was paid by the plaintiff. The remaining sale consideration was required as per the agreement to be paid within six months from the date on which agreement of sale was entered into, following which the sale deed was to be executed in favour of the plaintiff or his nominees, in respect of the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, which are valuable usufructuary rights and possession of the suit property was to be handed over to the plaintiff.
4.2 That before the expiry of six months, the defendants were to make available to the plaintiff documents pertaining to the suit property, such as tax receipts, non-encumbrance certificate, purchase certificate etc. That the plaintiff contacted the defendants repeatedly and expressed his willingness to comply with the terms of the agreement of sale dated 7th August, 2005. However, defendants sought to evade and delay compliance with the said agreement on the ground that anterior documents and certificates relating to the suit property could not be obtained. 4.3 That though the plaintiff had sent a legal notice dated 02nd November, 2006 calling upon the defendants to execute the deed assigning Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights after accepting the balance sale consideration from the plaintiff, the defendants took no positive steps in this regard.
4.4 That the plaintiff was ready and willing to tender the balance sale consideration and have the deed of assignment registered in his name within the period stipulated in the agreement. That the defendants were attempting to evade the agreement of sale in an attempt to obtain a better price for the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property as the market value thereof had increased manifold. Therefore, the plaintiff was constrained to file a suit for specific performance of the C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA KURUP [B.V. NAGARATHNA, J.] A B C D E F G H 260 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, dated 7th August, 2005.
4.5 With the aforesaid averments, it was prayed that the defendants be directed to receive the balance sale consideration from the plaintiff and execute the sale deed in respect of the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property in his favour. In the alternative, it was prayed that the defendants may be directed to return the advance amount of Rs. 10,000/- paid by the plaintiff, together with interest thereon.
5. In response to the plaint, the defendants filed a written statement, the contents of which are encapsulated as under:- 5.1 That the plaintiff was never ready and willing to perform his obligations under the agreement dated 7th August, 2005. That the suit for specific performance was filed on 13th December, 2006, which was nearly one year after the expiry of the deadline fixed in the agreement, for compliance of the terms thereof.
5.2 That as per the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights, the plaintiff-purchaser was to measure the suit property and accordingly ascertain the sale consideration payable at the rate of Rs. 8750/- per cent. That no attempt was made by the plaintiff in this regard. Therefore, it could not be said that the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of the agreement, more so, when no attempt was made by the plaintiff to determine even as much as the exact purchase price for the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property. That the plaintiff had paid only Rs. 10,000/- which is a very negligible portion of the purchase price. That the defendants were in dire need for finances in order to bear the expenses for cardiac treatment of defendant no. 1. Therefore, the defendants had approached the plaintiff repeatedly, with requests to tender the balance sale consideration. However, the plaintiff did not pay heed to the requests of the defendants and therefore, the defendants were constrained to raise the requisite funds by selling their jewellery and ornaments.
5.3 That the defendants agreed to sell their Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property only with a view to urgently raise requisite finances to enable them to bear the medical expenses for the treatment of defendant no. 1. Therefore, it was additionally important for the plaintiff to have duly paid the balance consideration within six months from the date on which agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights was A B C D E F G H entered into. Since the plaintiff failed to do so, it could not be concluded that he was ready and willing to perform his obligations under the agreement dated 7th August, 2005.
5.4 That the plaintiff was by occupation, a real estate agent and frequently engaged in the practice of entering into agreements of sale in respect of properties and thereafter attempting to find buyers for smaller extents or portions of such properties. That since the plaintiff could not find prospective buyers, he did not pursue the agreement dated 7th August, 2005 for over one year and had been attempting to evade the same. However, since the value of the suit property considerably increased over time, the plaintiff sought to claim the same at a price significantly below the prevailing market rate by placing reliance on a stale agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights.
5.5 With the aforesaid averments, it was prayed before the Trial Court that the suit filed by the plaintiff for specific performance of the agreement of sale dated 7th August, 2005, be dismissed.
6. The Court of the Subordinate Judge, Tirur by its judgment and decree dated 18th August, 2008 allowed the suit filed by the plaintiff and passed a decree of specific performance of the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights dated 7th August, 2005. Sale consideration was enhanced by 25% and it was directed that a sale consideration of Rs. 11,000/- per cent, instead of Rs.8750/- per cent, be paid by the plaintiff. It was directed that on payment of the sale consideration, sale deed in respect of the Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property be executed in favour of the plaintiff within a period of three months from the date on which the decree was passed.
The salient findings of the Trial Court are as under:
i) That specifying the time for performance of an agreement is not sufficient to prove that time was indeed the essence of the contract. That if time was the essence of the agreement, either of the parties ought to have initiated due performance of the same within the specified period.
However, since neither of the parties to the agreement of sale had initiated timely steps in pursuance of the said agreement, it was held that time was not the essence of the contract.
C. HARIDASAN v. ANAPPATH PARAKKATTU VASUDEVA KURUP [B.V. NAGARATHNA, J.] A B C D E F G H 262 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
ii) That the purchase certificate and title deed of the property were not readily available with the defendants at the time of entering into the agreement of sale of Kanam and Kuzhikoor rights over the suit property. That this fact raised the probability that non-performance of the agreement within the stipulated time, was not attributable to the plaintiff. iii) That since the transaction in question involved sale of rights over immovable property, a prudent purchaser would have to satisfy himself as to the genuineness and validity of the documents of title. Therefore, the first step ought to have been taken by the defendants, by handing over the relevant documents to the plaintiff, which would have in turn enabled the plaintiff to measure the property and tender the balance sale consideration. That the delay in performance of the agreement of sale could be attributed to the non-availability and non-furnishing of the title deeds of the plaint schedule property.
iv) That the mere fact that the defendants had handed over the photostat copy of the title deed to the plaintiff, could not lead to the inference that the plaintiff could have proceeded to measure the property.
v) That although a direction of specific performance would cause some hardship to the defendants, because they could no longer pursue their intention of constructing a house on the suit property, that alone would not be a ground to deny specific performance of a valid agreement.
vi) That since the value of the suit property had increased manifold and had doubled within a short span of time, specific performance, if allowed by payment of the consideration agreed upon in the agreement, would confer an undue benefit on the plaintiff. Therefore, the sale consideration was enhanced by 25% vis-à-vis the consideration agreed upon in the agreement dated 7th August, 2005.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.