Premchand v. The State of Maharashtra
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 207; [2023] 2 S.C.R. 119
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Dipankar Datta Penal Code, Justice 1860 – Ss. 300
- Decided
- 3 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 211/2023
- Sections
- 313(5), 300, 304, 313, 302, 307, 27, 313(1), 1, 3
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
PREMCHAND
v.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
(Criminal Appeal No. 211 of 2023)
MARCH 03, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.] Penal Code,1860 – ss. 300,302 307 and 304 – The trial Court convicted the appellant for the offence of murder of the victimdeceased and attempt to murder three others – The judgment of the trial Court was challenged by the appellant by preferring appeal before the High Court – The High Court upheld the judgment of trial Court – On appeal, held: The trial court and the High Court did not consider written Statement (Ext. 96) of the appellant u/s 313(5) Cr.P.C. in its entirety, non-consideration of the same has made the conviction vulnerable to interference – Trial Court failed to appreciate the defence version as spelt out in the Ext.96, which appears plausible – There is a missing link in the prosecution case as to the motive of the appellant to inflict the blow on the victim – Reading of the contents of Ext.96 does evince an act of retaliation spurred by sudden provocation resulting in a quarrel as well as a scuffle which resulted into death of the victim and others injured – The circumstances clearly negate any suggestion of premeditation in mind – The trial court lacked in objectivity by not examining the facts and circumstances as to whether the situation was such as is likely to reasonably cause an apprehension in the mind of the appellant that there was imminent danger to his body, of either death or grievous hurt being caused to him, if he did not act in private defence – To impute intention to cause death or the intention to cause that particular injury, which proved fatal, in circumstances of the case considered as unreasonable – Thus, appellant is entitled to the benefit of Exception 4 to s. 300, IPC – Conviction for murder and sentence of life imprisonment set aside – Appellant convicted u/s. 304, Part II, IPC.
Code of Criminal Procedure,1973 – s.313 – Object and scope discussed.
[2023] 2 S.C.R. 119 A B C D E F G H 120 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD:1. This is a case where it does not appear from the records that the written statement (Ext. 96) engaged the attention of both the trial court as well as the High Court. Applying the principles of law, there can be no quarrel that non-consideration of Ext. 96, to a limited extent, in relation to recording of conviction and consequently imposition of sentence, has rendered it vulnerable to interference. [Para 18][129-C-D] 2.By not looking into Ext. 96 with the other evidence on record, what the trial court omitted to consider is, whether the prosecution was justified in claiming that the offensive act amounted to culpable homicide amounting to murder or whether the appellant being guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, deserved punishment under section 304, Part II, IPC. True it is, the trial court considered the arguments advanced on behalf of the appellant that (i) he had “exercised his right of private defence”, and though (ii) “he exceeded such right”, (iii) the present case at the most would fall under section 304, Part II, IPC; but, it proceeded to overrule such arguments by relying on the oral testimony of P.W.s 2 to 4. In the process, the trial court failed to appreciate the defence version as spelt out in Ext.96, which appears to us to be plausible. Reading Ext.96 as it is, this Court found it probable that there could have been provocation at the instance of the victim, who allegedly indulged in spitting on the appellant coupled with verbal abuse, whereafter P.W.2 and later P.W.s 3 and 4 sprang into action, resulting in a scuffle where both parties indulged in inflicting injuries on each other resulting in an unwanted loss of life. Regrettably, pointed attention of the High Court does not appear to have been drawn to Ext.96 by counsel on behalf of the appellant. [Paras 20 and 21][129-H; 130- A-E]
3. Though there is no specific admission by the appellant that he had stabbed the victim or the other injured witnesses, reading of the contents of Ext.96 does evince an act of retaliation spurred by sudden provocation resulting in a quarrel as well as a scuffle which ultimately, most unfortunately, cost the victim his life and left some others injured. The appellant too sustained A B C D E F G H injuries in the scuffle and there is evidence on record that one of the injuries was grievous, yet, the criminal law was surprisingly not set in motion to bring to book those responsible for inflicting such injury. It was in a sudden quarrel, which could have been provoked by the victim and P.W.2, that blows followed from each side. Most importantly, the circumstances in which the incident occurred does clearly negate any suggestion of premeditation in mind. That apart, it cannot be overlooked that while the victim was middle-aged, the appellant was in his late fifties. At the time of the alleged incident, apart from P.W.s 2 and 3, other three persons who were present at the spot were not examined, as per the version of P.W.2. It is indeed improbable that in the presence of such persons, the appellant wielding a weapon like a knife would come to the spot with an intention to commit the offence of murder overpowering all of them without any sufficient reason or provocation. In this Court’s opinion, the trial court lacked in objectivity by not examining the facts and circumstances as to whether the situation was such as is likely to reasonably cause an apprehension in the mind of the appellant that there was imminent danger to his body, of either death or grievous hurt being caused to him, if he did not act in private defence. To impute intention to cause death or the intention to cause that particular injury, which proved fatal, in these circumstances seems to be unreasonable. [Para 23][131-E-H; 132-A-C]
4. The appellant was entitled to the benefit of Exception 4 to section 300, IPC. The appellant could not be convicted for murder of the victim. His conviction for murder and sentence of life imprisonment are liable to be set aside. It is ordered accordingly. However, this Court found it proper to convict the appellant under section 304, Part II, IPC. [Paras 25, 26 and 27][132-E-F] State of U.P. v. Lakhmi (1998) 4 SCC 336 : [1998] 1 SCR 850; Sanatan Naskar v. State of West Bengal (2010)
8 SCC 249 : [2010] 7 SCR 1023; Reena Hazarika v.
State of Assam (2019) 13 SCC 289 : [2018] 13 SCR 1108; Parminder Kaur v. State of Punjab (2020)
8 SCC 811 : [2020] 6 SCR 508 - referred to.
PREMCHAND v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA A B C D E F G H 122 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Case Law Reference [1998] 1 SCR 850 referred to Para 14 [2010] 7 SCR 1023 referred to Para 14 [2018] 13 SCR 1108 referred to Para 14 [2020] 6 SCR 508 referred to Para 14 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
211 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 06.08.2019 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Nagpur in CRA No. 211 of 2016.
Ravindra Bana, Sudheer Voditel, Advs. for the Appellant.
Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya A. Pande, Bharat Bagla, Ms. Kirti Dadheech, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1. This appeal, by special leave, calls in question the judgment and order dated 06th August, 2019 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Nagpur, whereby Criminal Appeal No 211 of 2016 carried by the appellant assailing his conviction under section 302, Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for brevity ‘IPC’) and sentence of life imprisonment with a fine of Rs.6,000.00 and a default sentence of one year as well as sentence of seven years of rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs.4,000.00 for the offence punishable under section 307, IPC was dismissed.
2. The prosecution case was that Nandkishor Korde (for brevity ‘the victim’) was murdered on 26th September, 2013 at around 5:00 pm by the appellant. The other three victims, namely Namdeo Korde (P.W.2), Vilas Charde (P.W.3), and Kunal Babhulkar (P.W.4) received stab injuries caused by a knife, also inflicted by the appellant. A report was lodged soon thereafter by the mother of the victim Rekhabai Korde, (P.W.1), leading to registration of an F.I.R. under sections 302 and 307, IPC. The post-mortem report dated 27th September, 2013 (Ext.35) recorded “stab injury to neck” of the victim as the probable cause of death.
3. Consequent to the registration of the F.I.R., Police Inspector Bharat Thakre (P.W.8) took up the investigation, visited the spot of the A B C D E F G H incident and prepared spot panchnama. He found the spot of the incident stained with blood and recovered a blood-stained knife, a wooden stick stained with blood, three pairs of chappals, two spectacles, and a blue dot pen. P.W.8 arrested the appellant and since he too had received injuries, he was referred to the Rural Hospital, Katol for his medical examination.
4. Upon completion of the investigation, a charge sheet under sections 302 and 307, IPC was filed before the concerned court against the appellant. Upon committal, charges for the above-said offences were framed to which the appellant pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
5. The prosecution examined 8 (eight) witnesses to support of its case. None was examined on behalf of the defence. However, the appellant filed a written statement, which we propose to refer to at a later part of this judgment. The Additional Sessions Judge largely relied on the statements of P.W.2, P.W.3, and P.W.4 to convict the appellant. The Court concluded that the appellant committed the murder of the victim with the knife (Art.1) and also attempted to commit the murder of P.W.2, P.W.3 and P.W.4. The defence of the appellant appeared to the Court to be false and the prosecution was held to have proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. This was followed by the convictions and sentences, noted above.
6. The aforesaid judgment having been challenged before the High Court, the relevant Division Bench was of the view that the findings did not warrant any interference and that the appeal was devoid of any merit; hence, it was dismissed.
7. The first limb of the arguments advanced by learned counsel for the appellant is that the courts below clearly erred in convicting the appellant. According to him, the following points deserve consideration: a. Firstly, the courts below failed to appreciate that none of the other persons present at the site of the occurrence, namely Shankarrao Fartode, Umrao Charde, and Ramesh Korde (as per the version of P.W.2) were examined as prosecution witnesses. The courts ought to have inferred that had they been produced they would not have supported the prosecution case and, thus, were deliberately withheld.
Non-examination of such independent witnesses, therefore, should be held to be fatal to the prosecution case.
PREMCHAND v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 124 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
b. Secondly, having regard to the age of the appellant (he was 58 years old on the date of the incident), it is quite improbable that he could freely inflict stab injuries on the victim and the others without anyone of the injured as well as the others present at the site (Shankarrao Fartode, Umrao Charde, and Ramesh Korde) even making an attempt to resist the appellant from inflicting injuries as also to save anyone of the others.
c. Thirdly, it was necessary to establish, by examining these independent witnesses, that it was the appellant who came with the knife and holding it was on a stabbing spree resulting in the death of the victim and injury to the others.
d. Fourthly, all eyewitnesses (P.W.2, P.W.3 and P.W.4) who deposed against the appellant were interested witnesses and, therefore, not credible and their testimony ought not to have been relied upon.
e. Fifthly, the courts below failed to take note that P.W.2 and P.W.3 were both interested witnesses and it was a clear case of false implication by suppressing the original story of the actual incident.
f. Sixthly, it is surprising that although P.W.4 claimed to have snatched the knife from the appellant, there is no injury on his hand; on the contrary, there is no explanation from the side of the prosecution with regard to the six injuries suffered by the appellant.
g. Seventhly, no motive could be established for the appellant to assault the victim and P.W.2 as the dispute between the parties arising out of unauthorized construction made by P.W.2 on the ground floor of the building of the appellant relates back to the year 2003.
h. Seventhly, the knife was not recovered at the instance of the appellant under section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 but seizure has been shown to have been made at the site. There being contradictory statements of P.W.2 and P.W.4, it is unclear as to who introduced the knife in the scuffle.
A B C D E F G H i. Finally, the appellant was a permanent resident of Nagpur whereas the place of the incident is Katol, a tehsil place situated about 50 kms. from Nagpur. There could hardly be any reason for the appellant to travel such distance and murder the victim, and that too with a knife in broad daylight and in the presence of a host of people.
8. The second limb of the arguments of learned counsel is that even if it be assumed that death of the victim occasioned at the hands of the appellant, as per the prosecution case the victim was initially away from the place of incident and was the last to join the scuffle. There was, thus, no premeditation on the part of the appellant as such and the victim seems to have got injured unintentionally in the scuffle between the appellant on the one side and the victim, P.W.s 2, 3 and 4 on the other. Therefore, clearly, the victim was not the target. He contended that conviction of the appellant under section 302, IPC was erroneous on facts and in the circumstances and that the evidence at best made out a case punishable under section 304, Part II, IPC. The appellant has been behind bars for nine years and it is only fair, just and proper that this Court upon consideration of the materials on record directs his release by converting the conviction from section 302, IPC to section 304, Part II, IPC and sentencing him to the period already spent in custody.
9. Learned counsel appearing for the State, on the other hand, supported the judgment of conviction and order of sentence of the Sessions Judge. He also submitted that the High Court took pains to reappraise the evidence and finally concurred with the Sessions Judge. No case having been set up by the appellant for interference, he urged this Court to dismiss the appeal.
10. We have heard the parties, considered the evidence led by them before the trial court and perused the judgment and order of the trial court and the High Court.
11. Any detailed discussion of the oral evidence of the prosecution witnesses is considered unnecessary in view of the “WRITTEN STATEMENT” dated 31st March, 2016 (Ext.96) of the appellant [Annexure ‘P-16’ to the paperbook], which was filed by him before the trial court in his defence, in terms of sub-section (5) of section 313 Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for brevity ‘Cr. P.C.). It is also noted that while replying to Q. No.79 in course of examination under section 313(1), the appellant had referred to such a statement.
PREMCHAND v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 126 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.