Cardinal Mar George Alencherry v. State of Kerala & Anr.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 250; [2023] 2 S.C.R. 1014
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dinesh Maheshwari, Justice Bela M. Trivedi Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice 406, Justice 409, Justice 418, Justice 420, Justice 423, Justice 465, Justice 467
- Decided
- 17 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 836/2023
- Sections
- 120B, 203, 34, 482, 202, 156(3), 200, 190, 204, 87, 202(1), 156
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 1014 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY
v.
STATE OF KERALA & ANR.
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 836-41 of 2023)
MARCH 17, 2023
[DINESH MAHESHWARI AND BELA M. TRIVEDI, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Issuance of summons – Legality of – A complaint was made against the appellant-archbishop and other accused persons for having committed an offense u/s 120B, 406, 409, 418, 420, 423, 465, 467, 468 r/w 34 of IPC alleging that the appellant along with other accused persons had fraudulently disposed of certain immovable property belonging to the church – The first complaint filed by the complainant was dismissed by the court at Maradu on 30.09.2021 without taking cognizance of the complaint as the counsel for complainant did not appear – On 02.04.2019, in another complaint on same set of facts, the trial court (at Kakkanad) dismissed the complaint u/s. 203 of Cr.P.C. with respect to offences u/ss. 409, 418, 420, 465, 467 and 468 of the IPC, however issued summons to the appellants and other accused persons for the offfences u/ss. 120-B, 406, 423 r/w s.34 IPC – The appellant filed the revision application before the Sessions Court but the same was dismissed and the petition u/s 482 Cr.P.C. before the High Court was also dismissed – Before the Supreme Court, appellant contended that the instant complaint after dismissal of the earlier complaint on same facts was not maintainable – Held: Trial Court at Kakkanad in the instant complaint cases, before the dismissal of the previous complaint, had already taken cognizance by issuing summons to the appellant and others – It is true that the complainant, in the instant complaint, should have disclosed the full and correct facts more particularly with regard to the previous complaint filed by him against the appellant and other accused but mere non-disclosure of such facts, would not be a ground to set aside the summons issued by the trial Court which after applying its mind and having been prima facie satisfied about the commission of the alleged offences u/ss. 120B, 406 and 423 r/w. 34 of IPC had issued summons – All the three Courts below have discussed in detail about the prima facie involvement of the appellant in the alleged [2023] 2 S.C.R. 1014 A B C D E F G H offences, and having carefully examined the record of the complaints in question, there is no illegality or infirmity in the orders passed by the trial Court issuing summons against the appellant.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 482 – Restraint on exercise of powers under Judicial Review – Held: Judicial restraint is a virtue, and the predilections of individual judges, howsoever well intentioned, cannot be permitted to be operated in utter disregard of the well-recognized judicial principles governing uniform application of law – Unwarranted judicial activism may cause uncertainty or confusion not only in the mind of the authorities but also in the mind of the litigants.
Disposing of the matters, the Court HELD: 1. In case of Pramatha Nath Talukdar Vs. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar, it was held with regard to filing of the second complaint that a fresh complaint could be entertained after the dismissal of previous complaint under Section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code when there was manifest error or manifest miscarriage of justice or when fresh evidence was forthcoming. It was further held that an order of dismissal under Section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code is no bar to the entertainment of a second complaint on the same facts, but it will be entertained only in exceptional circumstances, e.g. that the previous order was passed on an incomplete record or on a misunderstanding of nature of complaint or it was manifestly absurd, unjust or foolish or where new facts which could not, with reasonable diligence, have been brought on record in the previous proceedings have been adduced. Having regard to the said legal position and various decisions of the Supreme Court, it could not be said that the trial court had committed any error in entertaining the complaints filed by the respondent complainant, when the previous complaint filed by him was pending before the other court, and more particularly when the said court had dismissed the said previous complaint for non- prosecution, without taking cognizance of the alleged offences therein. [Paras 14 and 15][1028-D-F; 1030-D-E]
2. The Sessions Court in the Revision petitions filed by the appellant had also upheld the said orders passed by the trial CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY v. STATE OF
KERALA & ANR.
A B C D E F G H 1016 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
court issuing summons against the appellant and others after dealing with each and every aspect of the matter including the ingredients of alleged offences for which the summons were issued against the appellant. The High Court in the impugned order has also discussed in detail the submissions made by the counsels for the parties in the petitions filed by the appellant under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. and upheld the order passed by the Sessions Court. In view of the said observations made and prima facie findings recorded by the three courts below as regards the alleged involvement of the appellant in the alleged offences, this Court is not inclined to interfere with the same. [Para 17][1031-A-C]
3. No doubt, summoning of an accused is a serious matter and therefore the Magistrate before issuing the summons to the accused is obliged to scrutinize carefully the allegations made in the complaint with a view to prevent a person named therein as accused from being called upon to face any frivolous complaint, nonetheless one of the objects of Section 202 Cr.P.C. is also to enable the Magistrate to prosecute a person or persons against whom grave allegations are made. Just as it is necessary to curtail vexatious and frivolous complaints against innocent persons, it is equally essential to punish the guilty after conducting a fair trial. In the instant cases, all the three courts below have discussed in detail about the prima facie involvement of the appellant in the alleged offences, and therefore it is not necessary for this Court to reiterate the same. Suffice it to say that having carefully examined the record of the complaints in question, there is no illegality or infirmity in the orders passed by the trial court issuing summons against the appellant-Archbishop for the alleged offences. [Para 18][1031-C-F]
4. The High Court in its overzealous approach had travelled not only beyond the scope and ambit of Section 482 Cr.P.C and of Article 226 of the Constitution of India, but had crossed all the boundaries of judicial activism and judicial restraint by passing such orders under the guise of doing real and substantial justice. The jurisprudential enthusiasm and wisdom for doing the substantial justice has to be applied by the courts within the A B C D E F G H permissible limits. The belief of self-righteousness or smugness of the High Court in exercise of its powers of judicial review should not overawe the other authorities discharging their statutory functions. The court may not have to remind the High Courts that judicial restraint is a virtue, and the predilections of individual judges, howsoever well intentioned, cannot be permitted to be operated in utter disregard of the well-recognized judicial principles governing uniform application of law. Unwarranted judicial activism may cause uncertainty or confusion not only in the mind of the authorities but also in the mind of the litigants. [Paras 28 and 29][1036-A-D] S. K. Sinha, Chief Enforcement Officer v. Videocon International Ltd. and Others (2008) 2 SCC 492 :
[2008] 2 SCR 36; Ramdev Food Products Private v.
State of Gujarat (2015) 6 SCC 439 : [2015] 5 SCR 283; Pramatha Nath Talukdar v. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar AIR 1962 SC 876 : [1962] Suppl. SCR 297 – relied on.
Jatinder Singh and Others v. Ranjit Kaur (2001) 2 SCC 570 : [2001] 1 SCR 707; Ranvir Singh v. State of Haryana and Another (2009) 9 SCC 642; Poonam Chand Jain and Another v. Fazru (2010) 2 SCC 631 :
[2010] 2 SCR 109; Samta Naidu and Another v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Another (2020) 5 SCC 378 :
[2020] 2 SCR 1127– referred to.
Case Law Reference [2008] 2 SCR 36 relied on Para 10 [2015] 5 SCR 283 relied on Para 11 [1962] Suppl. SCR 297 relied on Para 14 [2001] 1 SCR 707 referred to Para 15 [2010] 2 SCR 109 referred to Para 15 [2020] 2 SCR 1127 referred to Para 15 CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY v. STATE OF
KERALA & ANR.
A B C D E F G H 1018 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 836-841 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 12.08.2021 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in CRLMC Nos.8936 of 2019, 205, 1414, 1409, 2138, 2136 of 2020 and 9115 of 2019.
With Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 1487-1493 of 2022 and 3580- 3586 of 2023.
Chander Uday Singh, Siddharth Luthra, Sr. Advs., Romy Chacko, Robin V.S., Sudesh Kumar, Gyanant Singh, Pratap Shanker, Asif Ahmed, Kunal Sinha, Sarthak Shanker, Swetank Shantanu, Advs. for the Appellant.
Jaideep Gupta, Jayanth Muth Raj, Sr. Advs., Nishe Rajen Shonker, Alim Anvar, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Abdulla Naseeh V.T., Ms. Meena K. Poulose, P. S. Sudheer, Ms. Miranda Solaman, Rishi Maheshwari, Ms. Anne Mathew, Bharat Sood, Ms. Shruti Jose, Ashok Basoya, Kuriakose Varghese, V. Shyamohan, Ms. Aishwarya Hariharan, Akshat Gogna, Advs. for the Respondents.
V Giri, Sr. Adv., Raghenth Basant, Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Ms. Roopali Lakhotia, Shreerang Verma, Ajay Krishna, P.V. Dinesh, Jaimon Andrews, Rahul Raj Mishra, Bineesh K., Naresh Kumar, Advs. For the Impleader.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.
1. Leave granted in SLP (Crl.) Nos. 2849-2854 of 2022.
2. All these matters are arising out of the impugned common judgment and order dated 12.08.2021 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in Crl. MC No. 8936 of 2019, Crl. MC No. 205 of 2020, Crl. MC No. 1414 of 2020, Crl. MC No. 1409 of 2020, Crl. MC No. 2138 of 2020, Crl. MC No. 2136 of 2020 and Crl. MC No. 9115 of 2019.
3. In the batch of six appeals arising out of SLP (Crl.) Nos. 2849- 2854/2022, filed by the appellant Cardinal Mar George Alencherry (original accused) the impugned common order dated 12.08.2021 in its entirety has been assailed, however, in the SLP (Crl.) No. 1487-1493/2022 filed A B C D E F G H by Eparchy of Bathery (not a party before the High Court), and in the SLP Diary No. 7364/2022 filed by the Catholic Diocese of Thamarassery (not a party before the High Court), this Court vide the order dated 14.02.2022 had granted permission to file the SLPs to the said petitioners to a limited extent in respect of the petitioners’ grievances pertaining to paragraphs 17 to 39 of the impugned order. Under the circumstances, the facts of the appeals filed by the appellant- Cardinal Mar George Alencherry are considered for the sake of convenience.
4. The facts in nutshell, as discernible from the record, giving rise to the present appeals are that: -
(i) The Syro Malabar Church, an Episcopal Institution is headed by the Bishop of Archdiocese, i.e., the appellant – Cardinal Mar George Alencherry (hereinafter referred to as ‘the appellant- Archbishop’). The said Archbishop claiming to have an authority over all the spiritual and temporal affairs concerning Syro Malabar Church alienated certain immoveable properties of the Church. The present respondent no. 2 – Mr. Joshy Varghese (original complainant) claiming to be a member and believer of a Roman Catholic Church has filed a complaint under Sections 190 and 200 of Cr.P.C. being Crl. M.P.No. 5003/2018 in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Ist Class, Kakkanad (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Trial Court’) on 16th July, 2018, against three accused i.e. (1) the appellant- Archbishop, (2) Rev Fr. Joshy Puthuva and (3) Saju Varghese alleging commission of the offences punishable under Sections 120B, 406, 409, 418, 420, 423, 465, 467, 468 r/w 34 of IPC.
(ii) It has been alleged in the complaint, inter alia that the complainant is the member of the St. Mary’s Church, Perumbavoor, one of the churches administered by the Archdiocese of Ernakulam- Angamaly. The appellant took charge of the Archdiocese as its Major Archbishop on 29.05.2011 and he was subsequently ordained as a Cardinal of Syro Malabar Church on 06.01.2012. The said Archdiocese has been administering various educational institutions, orphanages, old age homes, convents, monasteries and hospitals, in addition to 338 churches under CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY v. STATE OF KERALA & ANR. [BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1020 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
it. The said Archdiocese owned assets both movable and immovable worth crores of rupees. The bylaws of Archdiocese which prescribed the procedures for the administration and management of the assets of the Archdiocese were modified on 29.07.2009.
(iii) It has been further alleged that the appellant- Archbishop entered into a criminal conspiracy with accused no. 2 – Rev Fr. Joshy Puthuva, who was the financial officer of the said Archdiocese, during the period from 2012 to 2017 to fraudulently dispose of some of the immovable properties of the Archdiocese, and in furtherance thereof, they alienated certain properties worth crores of rupees to the accused no. 3 - Saju Varghese, as described in the complaint.
(iv) In the said complaint, a sworn statement of the complainant was recorded in view of Section 202 of Cr.P.C. as the appellant and the other two accused in the said complaint were residing beyond the jurisdiction of the Trial Court. One more witness was also summoned and examined in support of the complaint. The complainant also had produced few documents in support of the said complaint.
(v) The Trial Court vide the order dated 2nd April, 2019 took the complaint on file and dismissed the complaint under Section 203 of Cr.P.C. so far as the offences under Sections 409, 418, 420, 465, 467 and 468 of IPC were concerned, however issued summons against the accused for the offences under Sections 120-B, 406, 423 read with 34 of
IPC.
5. The complainant - Joshy Varghese has also filed other five similar complaints against the appellant-Archbishop and others (Annexures A-4 to A-9 in SLP(Civil) Nos.2849-2854 of 2022) in which the trial court had issued the summons by passing separate orders, the details of which are as under:
A B C D E F G H
6. The appellant-Archbishop (accused no.1) and the said Saju Varghese (accused no. 3) being aggrieved by the order dated 02.04.2019 passed by the trial court in Cr.M.P.No. 5003/2018 preferred Criminal Revision Application Nos. 20/2019 and 21/2019 respectively before the Sessions Court, Ernakulam Division (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Sessions Court’). The Sessions Court dismissed the said Criminal Revision Petitions, vide the order dated 24.08.2019, against which the appellant- Archbishop preferred Crl.M.C. No.8936 of 2019 and other five petitions before the High Court under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. The original accused no. 3 - Saju Varghese also filed Crl.M.C. No.9115/2019 before the High Court. The High Court vide the impugned order dated 12th August, 2021 dismissed all the seven Crl.M.Cs. The High Court also gave certain directions to the respondent-State Government while dismissing the said petitions. The High Court thereafter posted the matters on 25.10.2021 for the compliance report, and then gave further directions by passing various orders from time to time. Being aggrieved by the same, the present sets of appeals have been filed by the appellants as stated hereinabove.
7. The learned senior advocate Mr. Sidharth Luthra appearing for the appellant-Archbishop submitted following chart, showing details of the properties involved in these appeals.
CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY v. STATE OF KERALA & ANR. [BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1022 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
DETAILS OF PROPERTY
8. According to the learned Senior Advocate Mr. Luthra, the respondent no. 2-Joshy Varghese and others had also filed similar complaints against the appellant and others. The details of the said complaints submitted by Mr. Luthra are as below:-
(i) 03.01.2018: The respondent no. 2 Joshy Varghese, the complainant, had filed a complaint being CMP No. 2/2018 A B C D E F G H in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, First Class. Maradu, against the appellant and others praying for investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., alleging criminal conspiracy to sell the plots of lands belonging to the Archdiocese. The Judicial Magistrate, Maradu, Ernakulam before issuing the process in the said complaint directed the respondent no. 2 to examine the witnesses. The respondent no. 2 challenged the said order before the Kerala High Court, which dismissed his petition vide the order dated 22.02.2018. The said complaint was thereafter dismissed by the Magistrate vide the order dated 30.09.2021.
(ii) 12.01.2018: One Paulachan Puthuppara, an Advocate filed a complaint being CMP No. 179/2018 in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ernakulam against the petitioner and two others alleging criminal conspiracy in respect of the sale of plots of land belonging to the Archdiocese. The Magistrate, Ernakulam vide the order dated 02.02.2018 dismissed the complaint observing that if complainant was aggrieved, he could resort to an appropriate civil action as may be available under the law.
(iii) 15.01.2018: One Shine Varghese filed a complaint before the P.S. Ernakulam Central, being FIR No. 719/2018, making similar allegations, in which the police filed a closure report, however the complainant Shine Varghese filed a Protest Petition, which is pending under consideration before the concerned court.
(iv) 18.03.2019: One complainant Pappachan filed a complaint being Cr.M.P.No. 820/2019 against the appellant- Archbishop and others in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Kakkanad. The said complainant had also filed a complaint before the Ernakulam P.S. on 12.01.2019, however no action was taken. Ultimately FIR No. 818/2019 was registered, however the investigating officer has submitted a closure report in the said complaint.
9. Adverting to the first and foremost submission made by the Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Luthra that the present complaint against the appellant after the dismissal of the earlier complaint by the Court of CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY v. STATE OF KERALA & ANR. [BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1024 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Maradu, on the same set of facts, filed by the respondent no.2complainant was not maintainable, it may be noted that the respondent no.2 had earlier filed a complaint being no.2/2018 on 03.01.2018 in the Court of JMFC, Maradu under Section 156(3) and Section 200 Cr.PC, making general allegations with regard to the fraudulent sale of the properties belonging to the Archdiocese by the appellant Archbishop, whereas the instant complaints six in number have been filed by the respondent no.2- complainant in the Trial Court giving specific details about the sale of the properties situated within the jurisdiction of Trial Court at Kakkanad. It is not disputed that the first complaint (C.C. No.2/ 2018) was dismissed on 30.09.2021 by the concerned court at Maradu without taking cognizance of the complaint as the counsel for the complainant did not appear, whereas in the instant complaints, the summons have been issued by the Trial Court, taking cognizance of the offences under Section 120B, 406, 423 read with Section 34 of IPC on 02.04.2019 and on other dates subsequent thereto, that is prior to the dismissal of the first complaint on 30.09.2021. The respondent no.2 in the counter filed by him has specifically stated that regarding the first item of property, the complaint was filed before the Court of Maradu (Ernakulam), as the cause of action had arisen within the jurisdiction of Maradu Police Station, whereas with regard to the other properties, seven complaints have been filed before the Court of JMFC, Kakkanad within whose jurisdiction the properties were situated. It is pertinent to note that there was no adverse order passed or cognizance taken by the Court at Maradu and on the contrary the same was dismissed after the Trial Court at Kakkanad issued summons against the appellant and others, taking cognizance of the alleged offences under Section 120B, 406, 423 read with Section 34 of IPC.
10. It cannot be gainsaid that the cognizance is taken of an offence and not of the offender. As such the phrase “taking cognizance” has nowhere been defined in the Cr.PC, however has been interpreted by this Court to mean “become aware of” or “to take notice of judicially”. In S.K. Sinha, Chief Enforcement Officer Vs. Videocon International Ltd. and Others1, this Court while explaining the scope of the enquiry under Section 202 Cr.PC, observed as under:- “19. The expression “cognizance” has not been defined in the Code. But the word (cognizance) is of indefinite import. It has no
1 (2008) 2 SCC 492
A B C D E F G H esoteric or mystic significance in criminal law. It merely means “become aware of” and when used with reference to a court or a Judge, it connotes “to take notice of judicially”. It indicates the point when a court or a Magistrate takes judicial notice of an offence with a view to initiating proceedings in respect of such offence said to have been committed by someone.
20. “Taking cognizance” does not involve any formal action of any kind. It occurs as soon as a Magistrate applies his mind to the suspected commission of an offence. Cognizance is taken prior to commencement of criminal proceedings. Taking of cognizance is thus a sine qua non or condition precedent for holding a valid trial. Cognizance is taken of an offence and not of an offender. Whether or not a Magistrate has taken cognizance of an offence depends on the facts and circumstances of each case and no rule of universal application can be laid down as to when a Magistrate can be said to have taken cognizance.
21. Chapter XIV (Sections 190-199) of the Code deals with “Conditions requisite for initiation of proceedings”. Section 190 empowers a Magistrate to take cognizance of an offence in certain circumstances. Sub-section (1) thereof is material and may be quoted in extenso:
“190. Cognizance of offences by Magistrates.—(1) Subject to the provisions of this Chapter, any Magistrate of the First Class, and any Magistrate of the Second Class specially empowered in this behalf under sub-section (2), may take cognizance of any offence—
(a) upon receiving a complaint of facts which constitute such offence;
(b) upon a police report of such facts;
(c) upon information received from any person other than a police officer, or upon his own knowledge, that such offence has been committed.”
22. …….
23. Then comes Chapter XVI (Commencement of proceedings before Magistrates). This Chapter will apply only after cognizance of an offence has been taken by a Magistrate under Chapter CARDINAL MAR GEORGE ALENCHERRY v. STATE OF KERALA & ANR. [BELA M. TRIVEDI, J.] A B C D E F G H 1026 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
XIV. Section 204, whereunder process can be issued, is another material provision which reads as under:
“204. Issue of process.—(1) If in the opinion of a Magistrate taking cognizance of an offence there is sufficient ground for proceeding, and the case appears to be—
(a) a summons case, he shall issue his summons for the attendance of the accused, or
(b) a warrant case, he may issue a warrant, or, if he thinks fit, a summons, for causing the accused to be brought or to appear at a certain time before such Magistrate or (if he has no jurisdiction himself) some other Magistrate having jurisdiction.
(2) No summons or warrant shall be issued against the accused under sub-section (1) until a list of the prosecution witnesses has been filed.
(3) In a proceeding instituted upon a complaint made in writing, every summons or warrant issued under sub-section
(1) shall be accompanied by a copy of such complaint.
(4) When by any law for the time being in force any processfees or other fees are payable, no process shall be issued until the fees are paid and, if such fees are not paid within a reasonable time, the Magistrate may dismiss the complaint.
(5) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to affect the provisions of Section 87.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.