Prakash Nayi @ Sen v. State of Goa
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 24; [2023] 1 S.C.R. 823
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice M.M. Sundresh Penal Code, Justice With An Iron of Trial
- Decided
- 12 Jan 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2010/2010
- Sections
- 84, 302, 105, 8, 300, 329, 330, 334
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H PRAKASH NAYI @ SEN v.
STATE OF GOA
(Criminal Appeal No. 2010 of 2010)
JANUARY 12, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI AND M. M. SUNDRESH, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302 and s.84 – Plea of Insanity – “Schizophrenia” – Accused-appellant was convicted and sentenced u/s. 302 IPC for having caused the death of the victim-deceased by attacking him at a store in which the deceased was working, with an iron locking plate without any provocation and premeditation – In the course of trial, the defence pleaded insanity – At one of the hospitals where the accused was undergoing the treatment before the date of incident, it was recorded that the accused was suffering from anxiety neurosis with reactive depression and has symptoms of acid peptic disease and mild hypertension and the treatment was akin to one meant for schizophrenia – Two doctors were examined before the Sessions Court wherein they deposed positively pointing towards schizophrenia – On trial, the Trial Court convicted the accused of the said offence, and the Conviction was upheld by the High Court – Aggrieved by the decision, the accused approached Supreme Court – Held: The courts below erred in not accepting the reports of the doctors, more so when one of them withstood crossexamination and hence the conviction could not be said to be well founded – Further, the mere fact that the accused subsequently became fit to face the trial is sufficient enough to render an order of acquittal as it is indicative of his prior insanity – Also that both the Trial Court and the High Court were influenced by the nature of the act while ignoring the condition of the appellant and the fact that the burden on the accused is one of preponderance of probability.
Penal Code, 1860 – s. 84 – Plea of Insanity – S.84 of the Code recognized only the ‘acts’ which could not be termed as an offence – For the said section to apply such an act must emanate from an unsound mind – Existence of an unsound mind is a sine qua non to the applicability of the provision – A mere medical insanity cannot be said to mean unsoundness of mind – There may be a case where a person suffering from medical insanity would have committed an act, however, the test is one of legal insanity to attract the mandate of Section 84 of the IPC – There must be an [2023] 1 S.C.R. 823 A B C D E F G H 824 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 1 S.C.R.
inability of a person in knowing the nature of the act or to understand it to be either wrong or contrary to the law. Maxims – Actus non reum facit nisi mens sit rea – Unsound mind – A person of an unsound mind, who is incapable of knowing the consequence of an act, does not know that such an act is right or wrong. He may not even know that he has committed that act – When such is the position, he cannot be made to suffer punishment. Evidence Act, 1872 – ss. 8, 105 – Section 105 of the Indian Evidence Act, which places the burden of proving, has its exceptions – Though, as a general principle, the onus is upon the person accused to bring his case under the exception, dealing with the case u/s. 84 of the IPC, one has to apply the concept of preponderance of probabilities – The aforesaid provision has to be read along with Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Chapter XXV – ss. 329- 339 – Object and Purpose – The idea under the provisions to facilitate a person of unsound mind to stand trial, not only because of his reasoning capacity, but also to treat him as the one who is having a disability – The role of the Court is to find the remedial measures and do complete justice.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD : 1. Section 84 of the IPC recognizes only an act which could not be termed as an offence. It starts with the words “nothing is an offence”. The said words are a clear indication of the intendment behind this laudable provision. Such an act shall emanate from an unsound mind. Therefore, the existence of an unsound mind is a sine qua non to the applicability of the provision. A mere unsound mind per se would not suffice, and it should be to the extent of not knowing the nature of the act. Such a person is incapable of knowing the nature of the said act. Similarly, he does not stand to reason as to whether an act committed is either wrong or contrary to law. Needless to state, the element of incapacity emerging from an unsound mind shall be present at the time of commission. [Para 4][828-A-C]
2. The provision speaks about the act of a person of unsound mind. It is very broad provision relatable to the incapacity, as aforesaid. The test is from the point of view of a prudent man. Therefore, a mere medical insanity cannot be said to mean unsoundness of mind. There may be a case where a person suffering from medical insanity would have committed an act, however, the test is one of legal insanity to attract the mandate A B C D E F G H of Section 84 of the IPC. There must be an inability of a person in knowing the nature of the act or to understand it to be either wrong or contrary to the law. The aforesaid provision is founded on the maxim, actus non reum facit nisi mens sit rea, i.e., an act does not constitute guilt unless done with a guilty intention. It is a fundamental principle of criminal law that there has to be an element of mens rea in forming guilt with intention. A person of an unsound mind, who is incapable of knowing the consequence of an act, does not know that such an act is right or wrong. He may not even know that he has committed that act. When such is the position, he cannot be made to suffer punishment. This act cannot be termed as a mental rebellion constituting a deviant behaviour leading to a crime against society. He stands as a victim in need of help, and therefore, cannot be charged and tried for an offence. His position is that of a child not knowing either his action or the consequence of it. [Paras 5 and 6][828-C-G]
2. The burden of proof does lie on the accused to prove to the satisfaction of the Court that one is insane while doing the act prohibited by law. Such a burden gets discharged based on a prima facie case and reasonable materials produced on his behalf. The extent of probability is one of preponderance. This is for the reason that a person of unsound mind is not expected to prove his insanity beyond a reasonable doubt. Secondly, it is the collective responsibility of the person concerned, the Court and the prosecution to decipher the proof qua insanity by not treating it as adversarial. Though a person is presumed to be sane, once there are adequate materials available before the Court, the presumption gets discharged. Section 105 of the Indian Evidence Act, which places the burden of proving, has its exceptions. Though, as a general principle, the onus is upon the person accused to bring his case under the exception, dealing with the case under Section 84 of the IPC, one has to apply the concept of preponderance of probabilities. The aforesaid provision has to be read along with Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act. The better way to reconcile the aforesaid provision would be to have a look into the behaviour and conduct before, during and after the occurrence. [Paras 8 and 9][831-A-D]
3. As Section 84 of the IPC has its laudable objective behind it, the prosecution and the Court have their distinct roles to play. The agency has to take up the investigation from the materials produced on behalf of the person claiming unsoundness. It has to satisfy itself that the case would not come within the purview PRAKASH NAYI @ SEN v. STATE OF GOA A B C D E F G H 826 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 1 S.C.R.
of Section 84 of the IPC. The Court on its part has to satisfy itself as to whether the act was done by a person with an unsound mind within the rigour of Section 84 of the IPC. [Paras 10 and 11][831- E-F]
4. Having noted the scope and ambit of Chapter XXV of Cr.P.C., including the provisions incorporated by way of amendments in the year 2009, one has to take into account the fact that the Court has a larger role to play while considering the case under Section 84 of the IPC. If a friendly approach is required to be followed during the trial, when adequate powers have been conferred upon the Court to even discharge an accused on the ground of an unsound mind, the same reasoning will have to be applied with much force when it comes to Section 84 of the IPC. The whole idea under the provisions discussed is to facilitate a person of unsound mind to stand trial, not only because of his reasoning capacity, but also to treat him as the one who is having a disability. The role of the Court is to find the remedial measures and do complete justice. [Paras 17 and 16][835-B-D] Surendra Mishra v. State of Jharkhand (2011) 11 SCC 495 : [2011] 1 SCR 133; Hari Singh Gond v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2008) 16 SCC 109 : [2008] 12 SCR 949; Bapu @ Gajraj Singh v. State of Rajasthan 2007 8 SCC 66 : [2007] 7 SCR 917; Dahyabhai Chhaganbhai Thakkar v. State of Gujarat AIR 1964 SC 1563 : [1964] 7 SCR 361; Devidas Loka Rathod v.
State of Maharashtra (2018) 7 SCC 718 : [2018] 7 SCR 767 – relied on.
Case Law Reference [2011] 1 SCR 133 relied on Para 7 [2008] 12 SCR 949 relied on Para 7 [2007] 7 SCR 917 relied on Para 7 [1964] 7 SCR 361 relied on Para 12 [2018] 7 SCR 767 relied on Para 14 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.2010 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 02.06.2008 of the High Court of Bombay Bench at Goa in CRLA No.63 of 2006.
Aftab Ali Khan, (SCLSC), M. Z. Chaudhary, Shahbaz, Arvind Kr. Kanva, Sayyed Imtiyaz Ali, Ms. Amna Darakshan, Ali Safeer Farooqi, Advs. for the Appellant.
A B C D E F G H The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
M. M. SUNDRESH, J.
“Was’t Hamlet wronged Laertes? Never Hamlet. If Hamlet from himself be ta’en away, And when he’s not himself does wrong Laertes, Then Hamlet does it not; Hamlet denies it. Who does it, then? His madness. if’t be so, Hamlet is of the faction that is wronged; His madness is poor Hamlet’s enemy.”
-William Shakespeare (Source : Hamlet, W.S. (Play) Act-5 Scene-2 Line-245)
1. While acknowledging the hurt that he has caused to Laertes for causing the death of his father, whom he murdered by way of a mistaken identity, Hamlet pleads temporary madness. While pleading so, he disassociates himself from the act as if it was done by a third person and he was made to suffer the consequence. He thus pleads to treat him as a victim rather than an offender. Though the act of Hamlet does constitute a culpable homicide coming within the definition of Section 300 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 an act of unsound mind would not attract the same. Through these lines, Shakespeare brings out the agony of a man having to justify his act of madness.
2. Raising the plea of insanity on the mandate of Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter ‘the IPC’), the appellant seeks reversal of the order of conviction passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Bombay at Goa, confirming the order of the Additional Sessions Judge, S.G. Margao-II. As we are dealing with the seminal issue of applicability of Section 84 of the IPC and in the light of the focus made by the counsel for the appellant, we do not propose to go into the merits.
3. We have heard Shri Aftab Ali Khan, the counsel appointed from the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
SECTION 84 of The Indian Penal Code, 1860 “84. Act of a person of unsound mind. - Nothing is an offence which is done by a person who, at the time of doing it, by reason of unsoundness of mind, is incapable of knowing the nature of the act, or that he is doing what is either wrong or contrary to law.” PRAKASH NAYI @ SEN v. STATE OF GOA A B C D E F G H 828 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 1 S.C.R.
4. Section 84 of the IPC recognizes only an act which could not be termed as an offence. It starts with the words “nothing is an offence”. The said words are a clear indication of the intendment behind this laudable provision. Such an act shall emanate from an unsound mind. Therefore, the existence of an unsound mind is a sine qua non to the applicability of the provision. A mere unsound mind per se would not suffice, and it should be to the extent of not knowing the nature of the act. Such a person is incapable of knowing the nature of the said act. Similarly, he does not stand to reason as to whether an act committed is either wrong or contrary to law. Needless to state, the element of incapacity emerging from an unsound mind shall be present at the time of commission.
5. The provision speaks about the act of a person of unsound mind. It is a very broad provision relatable to the incapacity, as aforesaid. The test is from the point of view of a prudent man. Therefore, a mere medical insanity cannot be said to mean unsoundness of mind. There may be a case where a person suffering from medical insanity would have committed an act, however, the test is one of legal insanity to attract the mandate of Section 84 of the IPC. There must be an inability of a person in knowing the nature of the act or to understand it to be either wrong or contrary to the law.
6. The aforesaid provision is founded on the maxim, actus non reum facit nisi mens sit rea, i.e., an act does not constitute guilt unless done with a guilty intention. It is a fundamental principle of criminal law that there has to be an element of mens rea in forming guilt with intention. A person of an unsound mind, who is incapable of knowing the consequence of an act, does not know that such an act is right or wrong. He may not even know that he has committed that act. When such is the position, he cannot be made to suffer punishment. This act cannot be termed as a mental rebellion constituting a deviant behaviour leading to a crime against society. He stands as a victim in need of help, and therefore, cannot be charged and tried for an offence. His position is that of a child not knowing either his action or the consequence of it.
7. We wish to place reliance on the following decisions of this Court:
• Surendra Mishra v. State of Jharkhand (2011) 11
SCC 495
A B C D E F G H “11. In our opinion, an accused who seeks exoneration from liability of an act under Section 84 of the Penal Code is to prove legal insanity and not medical insanity. Expression “unsoundness of mind” has not been defined in the Penal Code and it has mainly been treated as equivalent to insanity. But the term “insanity” carries different meaning in different contexts and describes varying degrees of mental disorder. Every person who is suffering from mental disease is not ipso facto exempted from criminal liability. The mere fact that the accused is conceited, odd, irascible and his brain is not quite all right, or that the physical and mental ailments from which he suffered had rendered his intellect weak and affected his emotions or indulges in certain unusual acts, or had fits of insanity at short intervals or that he was subject to epileptic fits and there was abnormal behaviour or the behaviour is queer are not sufficient to attract the application of Section 84 of the Penal Code.”
• Hari Singh Gond v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2008)
16 SCC 109
“10. “7 . Section 84 lays down the legal test of responsibility in cases of alleged unsoundness of mind. There, is no definition of “unsoundness of mind” in the IPC. The courts have, however, mainly treated this expression as equivalent to insanity. But the term ‘insanity’ itself has no precise definition. It is a term used to describe varying degrees of mental disorder. So, every person, who is mentally diseased, is not ipso facto exempted from criminal responsibility. A distinction is to be made between legal insanity and medical insanity. A court is concerned with legal insanity, and not with medical insanity...”
• Bapu @ Gajraj Singh v. State of Rajasthan 2007 8
SCC 66
“10. Section 84 embodies the fundamental maxim of criminal law i.e. actus non reum facit nisi mens sit rea (an act does not constitute guilt unless done with a guilty intention). In order to constitute an offence, the intent and act must concur; but in the case of insane persons, no culpability is PRAKASH NAYI @ SEN v. STATE OF GOA [M. M. SUNDRESH, J.] A B C D E F G H 830 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 1 S.C.R.
fastened on them as they have no free will (furios is nulla voluntas est).
11. The section itself provides that the benefit is available only after it is proved that at the time of committing the act, the accused was labouring under such a defect of reason, from disease of the mind, as not to know the nature and quality of the act he was doing, or that even if he did not know it, it was either wrong or contrary to law then this section must be applied. The crucial point of time for deciding whether the benefit of this section should be given or not, is the material time when the offence takes place. In coming to that conclusion, the relevant circumstances are to be taken into consideration, it would be dangerous to admit the defence of insanity upon arguments derived merely from the character of the crime. It is only unsoundness of mind which naturally impairs the cognitive faculties of the mind that can form a ground of exemption from criminal responsibility. Stephen in History of the Criminal Law of England, Vol. II, p. 166 has observed that if a person cut off the head of a sleeping man because it would be great fun to see him looking for it when he woke up, would obviously be a case where the perpetrator of the act would be incapable of knowing the physical effects of his act. The law recognizes nothing but incapacity to realise the nature of the act and presumes that where a man’s mind or his faculties of ratiocination are sufficiently dim to apprehend what he is doing, he must always be presumed to intend the consequence of the action he takes…”
Section 105 of the Indian Evidence Act 1872 “105. Burden of proving that case of accused comes within exceptions. —When a person is accused of any offence, the burden of proving the existence of circumstances bringing the case within any of the General Exceptions in the Indian Penal Code, (45 of 1860), or within any special exception or proviso contained in any other part of the same Code, or in any law defining the offence, is upon him, and the Court shall presume the absence of such circumstances.”
A B C D E F G H
8. The burden of proof does lie on the accused to prove to the satisfaction of the Court that one is insane while doing the act prohibited by law. Such a burden gets discharged based on a prima facie case and reasonable materials produced on his behalf. The extent of probability is one of preponderance. This is for the reason that a person of unsound mind is not expected to prove his insanity beyond a reasonable doubt. Secondly, it is the collective responsibility of the person concerned, the Court and the prosecution to decipher the proof qua insanity by not treating it as adversarial. Though a person is presumed to be sane, once there are adequate materials available before the Court, the presumption gets discharged.
9. Section 105 of the Indian Evidence Act, which places the burden of proving, has its exceptions. Though, as a general principle, the onus is upon the person accused to bring his case under the exception, dealing with the case under Section 84 of the IPC, one has to apply the concept of preponderance of probabilities. The aforesaid provision has to be read along with Section 8 of the Indian Evidence Act. The better way to reconcile the aforesaid provision would be to have a look into the behaviour and conduct before, during and after the occurrence.
10. As Section 84 of the IPC has its laudable objective behind it, the prosecution and the Court have their distinct roles to play. The agency has to take up the investigation from the materials produced on behalf of the person claiming unsoundness. It has to satisfy itself that the case would not come within the purview of Section 84 of the IPC.
11. The Court on its part has to satisfy itself as to whether the act was done by a person with an unsound mind within the rigour of Section 84 of the IPC.
12. We wish to place reliance on the classical decision of this Court in Dahyabhai Chhaganbhai Thakkar v. State of Gujarat (AIR 1964 SC 1563), wherein the Court held that:
“(7) The doctrine of burden of proof in the context of the plea of insanity may be stated in the following propositions:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.