Madan v. State of Uttar Pradesh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 990; [2023] 16 S.C.R. 765
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice B.V. Nagarathna
- Decided
- 9 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1381/2017
- Sections
- 302, 149, 307, 323, 25, 313, 148, 449, 161, 174, 43, 37
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 16 S.C.R. 765 : 2023 INSC 990
CASE DETAILS
MADAN
v.
STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 1381-1382 of 2017)
NOVEMBER 09, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI, B.V. NAGARATHNA AND PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Six deaths were caused on account of brutal firing by the appellants and other accused persons. The trial court imposed sentence of capital punishment to the appellants (‘M’ and ‘S’) herein for the offence punishable u/s. 302 r/w. s.149 of IPC, while it sentenced accused ‘I’ to imprisonment for life for the same. (i) Whether the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt the case for conviction u/s. 302 of IPC;
(ii) Whether the present case falls in the category of rarest of rare cases; (ii) Whether on the facts of the present case, the capital punishment imposed on appellant- deserves to be maintained or not.
Penal Code, 1860 – s. 302 r/w. s.149 – The High Court, by the impugned judgment, while commuting the sentence of appellant ‘S’ from capital punishment to imprisonment for life, dismissed the appeals filed by appellant ‘M’ and accused ‘I’ and confirmed their conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court – The High Court further confirmed the Death Reference of the appellant ‘M’ – Propriety:
Held: The incident has taken place in two parts: The first place is near the house of ‘R’ – Appellant ‘M’ along with ‘I’ and other accused armed with licensed guns, rifles and country-made pistols came from behind and started firing indiscriminately – As a result of which, two fell down on the Khadanja and died on the spot – When ‘MA’, after hearing the sound of gunfire, came out of his house, the accused persons also fired shots at him – As a result of which, he also fell down – The second place is the house of Up-Pradhan- 766 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
‘RN’ – After indiscriminate firing by the accused persons, deceased ‘RK’ and PW-2 ran away to save their lives and RK entered the house of ‘RN’ – The accused persons followed them and entered into the house of ‘RN’ and fired shots at RK and two other persons – As a result of which, all three died – The prosecution has duly proved its case beyond reasonable doubt in view of the testimony of PW-1 being duly corroborated by the testimonies of PW-10 and PW-11 – This Court is of the considered view that the testimonies of these witnesses duly establish that these witnesses have witnessed the firing on three persons, who died on the spot – These witnesses have also seen the accused persons assaulting RK and PW-2 who had received the firearm injuries, who ran to the house of to take shelter – This Court is further of the considered view that though PW-7 is a sole witness insofar as the firing on deceased three persons is concerned, his testimony is cogent, reliable and trustworthy and can be made basis for coming to a conclusion that it is the present appellants along with other accused who have caused the death of deceased – In any case, his testimony is duly corroborated by the evidence of PW-1 who had immediately come to the second spot after the occurrence of the incident when PW-7 informed PW-1 about the incident occurring in his house – In the instant case, both the High Court and the trial court have meticulously scrutinized the evidence and found the testimony of the eye witnesses trustworthy and reliable – This Court after scrutinizing the evidence again find that merely because there are certain inconsistencies in the evidence of the witnesses, their evidence cannot be discarded – In totality of the circumstances, the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt the case for conviction u/s. 302 of IPC and the appeals in that regard are liable to be rejected. [Paras 27, 39, 42, 43, 49] Penal Code, 1860 – Whether the present case falls in the category of rarest of rare cases:
Held: Six deaths were caused on account of brutal firing by the appellants and other accused persons – The entire village and the people residing in the surrounding areas must have been shocked by such heinous and gruesome act – Not only that, one of the eye witnesses was also murdered during the pendency of the trial – The terror of the appellants and other accused persons was of such a high magnitude that even the witnesses who had received grievous injuries did not support the prosecution case and were required to be declared hostile – As such, four innocent persons were shot from behind – Therefore, the act of the appellants and the other accused would certainly be the one which shocked the collective conscience of the society and fall in the category of rarest of rare cases. [Para 57] Penal Code, 1860 – Whether on the facts of the present case, the capital punishment imposed on appellants deserves to be maintained or not.
Held: As per the Prison Conduct Report submitted by the Superintendent, District Jail, appellant ‘M’ is currently 64 years old – He has been in prison for 18 years 3 months – During this entire duration, he has no history of any kind of prison offence – The Report further shows that he has not been involved in any form of quarrels or fights in prison – The Report shows that he has cordial relations with other prisoners in his barrack and follows the prison rules – Taking into consideration all these factors, this Court finds that the present case is not a case wherein it can be held that imposition of death penalty is the only alternative – Another reason that weighs is that from the evidence of the witnesses, it is clear that the role attributed to all the accused persons has been similar – The evidence of witnesses would show that the role attributed is that all the accused persons including both the appellants herein had fired shots and indiscriminately indulged in the said firing – The role attributed in the evidence of the eye witnesses is identical to all the accused – In that view of the matter, the High Court was not justified in imposing death penalty on appellant ‘M’ while converting the death penalty imposed upon ‘S’ to life imprisonment – If the judgment of the High Court is maintained, it would lead to an anomalous situation – Whereas appellant ‘S’ would be entitled for consideration of his case for remission and pre-mature release on completion of a particular number of years in accordance with the relevant rules, appellant ‘M’ will have to face death penalty – Therefore, the interest of justice would be met by converting death penalty into life imprisonment i.e. actual imprisonment for a period of 20 years without remission – Appeal filed by ‘S’ dismissed and the appeal filed by appellant- ‘M’partly allowed by converting his death penalty into imprisonment for a fix term of 20 years.[Paras 69, 76-78] MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH 768 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684 – followed. Piara Singh and Others v. State of Punjab [1978] 1 SCR 597 : (1977) 4 SCC 452; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Krishna Master and Others [2010] 9 SCR 563 : (2010)12 SCC 324; State of Andhra Pradesh v. Bogam Chandraiah and Another (1986) 3 SCC 637; Darbara Singh v. State of Punjab [2012] 7 SCR 541 : (2012) 10 SCC 476; Subodh Nath and Another v. State of Tripura [2013] 4 SCR 581 : (2013) 4 SCC 122; Karnel Singh v. State of M.P. [1995] 2 Suppl. SCR 629 : (1995) 5 SCC 518; Machhi Singh and Others v. State of Punjab [1983] 3 SCR 413 : (1983) 3 SCC 470; Ramnaresh and Others v. State of Chhattisgarh [2012] 3 SCR 630 : (2012) 4 SCC 257; Swamy Shraddananda (2) alias Murali Manohar Mishra v. State of Karnataka [2008] 11 SCR 93 : (2008) 13 SCC 767; Mohinder Singh v. State of Punjab [2013] 3 SCR 90 : (2013) 3 SCC 294 – relied on.
Jaikam Khan v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2021) 13 SCC 716; Khema @ Khem Chandra v. State of Uttar Pradesh 2022 SCC OnLine SC 991; Acharaparambath Pradeepan and Another v. State of Kerala [2006] 10 Suppl. SCR 1101 : (2006) 13 SCC 643; Harjinder Singh alias Bhola v. State of Punjab (2004) 11 SCC 253; Waman and Others v. State of Maharashtra [2011] 6 SCR 1072 : (2011) 7 SCC 295; Shera Singh v. State of Punjab (1996) 10 SCC 330; Shankar Kisanrao Khade v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 6 SCR 949 : (2013) 5 SCC 546; Gandi Doddabasappa alias Gandhi Basavaraj v. State of Karnataka (2017) 5 SCC 415 : [2017] 2 SCR 62; Prakash Dhawal Khairnar (Patil) v. State of Maharashtra (2002) 2 SCC 35 : [2001] 5 Suppl. SCR 612; Sundar @ Sundarrajan v. State by Inspector of Police 2023 SCC OnLine SC 310; Rajendra Pralhadrao Wasnik v. State of Maharashtra [2018] 14 SCR 585 : (2019) 12 SCC 460; Santosh Kumar Satishbhushan Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (2009) 6 SCC 498 : [2009] 9 SCR 90; Chhannu Lal Verma v. State of Chhattisgarh [2018] 14 SCR 355 : (2019) 12 SCC 438; Manoj and Others v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2023) 2 SCC 353; Babasaheb Maruti Kamble v. State of Maharashtra (2019) 13 SCC 640; Irappa Siddappa Murgannavar v. State of Karnataka (2022) 2 SCC 801 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
1381-1382 of 2017.
From the Judgment and Order dated 22.02.2017 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CCN No. 3520 of 2015 and RN No. 09 of 2015. With Criminal Appeal No. 1790 of 2017.
Appearances:
Anand Grover, Sr. Adv., Aarif Ali, Mohd. Irshad Hanif, Ms. Shreya Rastogi, Mujahid Ahmed, Mohd. Ehatsham Rao, Kailesh U. More, Khalid Azeez, Bhavesh Seth, Aditya P. Rath, Ms. Harini Raghupathy, Manish Kumar Vikkey, Ms. Sunita Sharma, Himanshu Mehra, Ms. Kanchan Jha, Advs. for the Appellant.
Brijender Chahar, Sr. Adv., Vishwa Pal Singh, Dr. Vijendra Singh Mahndiyan, Mukesh Kumar, Bharpur Singh, Sandeep Kumar, Ashutosh Bhardwaj, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
B. R. GAVAI, J.
1. These appeals challenge the judgment and order dated 22nd February 2017, passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Capital Case Nos. 3359 and 3520 of 2015 with Reference No. 9 of 2015 and Criminal Appeal No. 3519 of 2015, thereby dismissing the appeals filed by appellant Madan and another accused Ishwar; whereas, it allowed in part, the appeal filed by appellant Sudesh Pal. By the said judgment, the High Court confirmed the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 31st July 2015 passed by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 3, Muzzaffarnagar (hereinafter referred to as “trial court”) in Sessions Case No. 09/2005 with Sessions Case No. 838 of 2005 and 10/2005, in respect of appellant – Madan, while MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH 770 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
commuting the sentence of capital punishment to life imprisonment in respect of appellant – Sudesh Pal.
2. Shorn of details, the facts leading to the present appeals are as under: 2.1 The First Information Report (“FIR” for short) was lodged on a written report given by informant Lokendra (PW-1), on 14th October 2003 at P.S. Babri, District Muzzafarnagar, which was registered as Crime No. 197 of 2003, for offences punishable under Sections 147, 148, 149, 302, 307, 323 and 452 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”). The incident took place at 5.30 PM and the FIR came to be registered on the same day at 7.40 PM.
2.2 The report was recorded by one, Naresh Pal s/o Vijay Pal r/o village Barwala, District Baghpat on the oral report of Lokendra (PW- 1). According to the FIR, Smt. Vimla Devi, who was the mother of Ram Kishan, cousin of Lokendra (PW-1), was a candidate in the election for Gram Pradhan; whereas the wife of one Arshad was the opposing candidate. On the one hand, Lokendra (PW-1) supported the candidature of Vimla Devi; whereas, the family of appellant Madan and Ram Bhajan supported the candidature of the wife of Arshad. When Vimla Devi came to be elected as Gram Pradhan along with Lokendra (PW-1), who also came to be elected as a member of the Gram Panchayat, appellant Madan and his family members bore a grudge with Lokendra (PW-1) and others on account of the feeling of jealousy.
2.3 The FIR states that on 14th October 2003, at about 5.30 PM, when Satendra, the real brother of Lokendra (PW-1), his nephew Sunil s/o Chandrapal, cousin Ram Kishan s/o Narain Singh @ Lala, Sukhpal Singh (PW-2) s/o Lotan Singh and his father Jai Singh (PW-8) s/o Ganga Ram were going to the house of Up-Pradhan Rizwan s/o Irshad Khan (PW-7) for discussing problems of the village, and had reached the house of Rashid s/o Mustafa, appellant Madan along with Rajveer, Ram Bhajan, Ramveer, and Kanwar Pal who were the sons of Ishwar along with Ishwar himself, who was the brother-in-law (sala) of appellant Madan, also known as Pahalwan, appellant Sudesh Pal, who was the real brother-in-law (sadu) of appellant Madan along with Neetu, who was the nephew of appellant Madan, armed with licensed guns, rifles and country-made pistols came from behind and started firing indiscriminately. As a result of the said firing, Satendra and Sunil fell down on ‘Khadanja’. When Masooq Ali s/o Abdul Gaffur came out of his house upon hearing the sound of gunfire, the accused persons shot fire at him due to which he also fell down. Following which, Ram Kishan and Sukhpal Singh (PW-2) ran away to save their lives. Ram Kishan thereafter entered into the house of the Up-Pradhan Rizwan.
2.4 It is further stated in the FIR that the accused persons thereafter entered the house of Up-Pradhan Rizwan and fired shots at Ram Kishan, Rizwan and Rihan. They also fired shots at Sukhpal Singh (PW-2). Ram Kishan, Sunil and Satendra died on the spot. When Mumtaz Khan (PW- 5) s/o Imtyaz reached at the place of incident, the accused persons fired shots at him as well. The accused persons further assaulted Jai Singh (PW-8), father of Lokendra (PW-1) with the ‘butt’ of the gun who then ran away to save his life. Following which, when the villagers were taking Rizwan, Rihan, Masooq Ali, Sukhpal Singh (PW-2) and Mumtaz Khan (PW-5) to the hospital; Rizwan, Rihan and Masooq Ali succumbed to their injuries and died on the way and their bodies were accordingly kept in their houses. When the accused persons were firing at the place of the incident, Ram Pal s/o Salet, Sudhir (PW-11) s/o Mahendra, Anil (PW-3) s/o Chandrapal, Mahesh Pal (PW-4) s/o Prahlad, Harpal Singh (PW-10) s/o Dhara, Mahipal s/o Atal Singh along with other villagers reached and saw the said incident. Lokendra (PW-1) also reached the place of the incident and witnessed the incident with his own eyes and requested to register the report and take legal action.
2.5 The FIR was registered and the investigation was subsequently taken over on 14th October 2003 by Mr. Raghunandan Singh Bhadauria (PW- 24), who was the then Station House Officer (for short ‘SHO’). He recorded the statement of Lokendra (PW-1) and proceeded to the place of the incident in front of the house of Rashid s/o Mustafa where he found the dead bodies of Satendra, Jai Singh (PW-8) and Sunil in a pool of blood. The dead body of Masooq Ali s/o Abdul Gafoor was on the cot in his house. When he reached the house of Rizwan, where he found the dead bodies of Rizwan and Rihan s/o Irshad Khan (PW-7) lying on the cot, whereas the body of Ram Kishan s/o Narain Singh was found lying in a pool of blood in the veranda of the said house. Upon inspection of the place of the incident, Raghunandan Singh MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 772 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Bhadauria (PW-24) found empty cartridges near the dead body which were taken into possession. Three empty cartridges of 12 bore 9 mm were found and taken into possession in the presence of witnesses Anil Kumar (PW-3) s/o Chandrapal Jat and Sri Dheer Singh s/o Prahlad Singh. The recovery memo (Ext. Ka – 2) was accordingly prepared and signed. He then took plain and blood-stained mud from the spot in the presence of the said witnesses. The recovery memo for the same was prepared and kept sealed in two separate containers (Ext. Ka-3). He also collected plain and blood-stained mud from where the bodies of Rizwan, Rihan and Ram Kishan were lying and a recovery memo (Ext. Ka – 6) was prepared to that effect. Further, empty cartridges of 12 bore 9 mm, 5 bullets along with another such bullet were recovered and taken into custody which were then sealed in the presence of the witnesses. However, Raghunandan Singh Bhadauria (PW-24) could not recover the blood-stained mud from the place where Masooq Ali, Rizwan and Rihan fell down and were subsequently taken to the hospital due to the movement of persons at the place of occurrence.
2.6 The Investigating Officer then recorded the statement of other witnesses after which he inspected the place of the incident and prepared the site plan. After panchayatnama of the dead bodies, the same were sent for post-mortem examination through Head Constable Surendra Singh, Head Constable Ram Kumar, Constable Yashpal and Constable Satya Prakash. After Raghunandan Singh Bhadauria (PW-24) was transferred, the investigation was taken over by Surajpal Singh (PW-23), SHO on 18th October 2003. He took steps to execute non-bailable warrants issued against the accused persons and also took steps to initiate proceedings under Sections 82-83 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “Cr.P.C.”). After the copies of the post-mortem report were obtained, the same were noted and enclosed with the C.D. of the deceased Ram Kishan, Masooq Ali, Rizwan, Rihan, Satendra and Sunil. Statements of witnesses Sudhir (PW-11), Harpal Singh (PW-10), Mahesh Pal (PW-4), and Mahipal were recorded at village Butrada. Surajpal Singh (PW-23) also recorded the statements of Rashid Sachdev and Ram Mehar, who were the witnesses of the panchayatnama. During investigation, Surajpal Singh (PW-23) received information that one co-accused, who was involved along with the accused persons named in the FIR had died in the same incident and his body was taken away by the accused persons and the same was found and recovered from the jungle (agricultural field) of village Pinana regarding which, Case Crime No. 799 of 2003 was registered at P.S. Kotwali, for offences punishable under Sections 302 and 201 of IPC. Surajpal Singh (PW-23) thereafter recorded the statements of other witnesses and also raided the house of the accused persons.
2.7 Thereafter, investigation was transferred and taken over on 21st December 2003 by Inspector Adesh Kumar Sharma (PW-20), EOW, Meerut. Accused persons Ishwar and Kunwar Pal were taken in police remand. He then proceeded to the place of the incident along with police personnel for the recovery of weapon; whereupon, a country-made pistol and the gun used in the incident were recovered at the instance of accused persons Ishwar and Kanwar Pal. Further, one empty cartridge was found in the gun whereas one empty cartridge of 9 mm was found in the country-made pistol. Both the fire-arms were in operating condition and the Recovery Memo for the gun and the country-made pistol were prepared and sealed in two separate clothes. Following which, panchayatnama was prepared by Sub-Inspector Surendra Singh (PW-16) with regards to the three deceased, namely, Masooq Ali, Rihan and Rizwan. Additionally, panchayatnama and inquest reports with regards to the deceased, namely, Ram Kishan, Satendra and Sunil were prepared by another Sub-Inspector.
2.8 Subsequently, the investigation was transferred and handed over to Bahadur Singh Chauhan, the then C.B.C.I.D. (PW-17) on 13th January 2004 by the orders of higher authority. Bahadur Singh Chauhan (PW-17) recorded the statement of Lokendra (PW-1), inspected the place of the incident and accordingly prepared a site plan. The statements of other witnesses were also recorded. Bahadur Singh Chauhan (PW-17) thereafter recorded the statements of earlier investigating officers in C.D.
2.9 Subsequently, the investigation was again transferred from C.B.C.I.D. to the civil police. After the chargesheet was submitted by Bahadur Singh Chauhan (PW-17) against appellant Madan along with other accused persons, namely, Kanwar Pal and Ishwar; the investigation was taken over by the then S.H.O. P.S. Babri, Siddh Narayan Yadav on 18th October 2004 who was examined as PW-19. Siddh Narayan Yadav (PW-19) submitted the chargesheet against appellant Sudesh Pal and another accused person who was absconding at the time. Siddh Narayan Yadav (PW-19) was MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 774 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
the fifth IO of this case and he also submitted a chargesheet against accused Rajvir along with other accused persons.
2.10 The post-mortem of deceased Ram Kishan was conducted by Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) on 15th October 2013 at 12.50 PM. The injuries sustained by deceased Ram Kishan are thus:
1. Wound of firearm 4 cm X 1.5 cm in depth of the muscle in the right side off ace and aside of the nose. Around the wound there were tattooing in the area of 20 cm x 7 cm.
2. Wound of entering of 8 firearms 20 cm X 19 cm towards left side of chest which was in deep ranging from ½ cm X ½ cm from the surface of the chest. Around the wound no blacking and tattooing were present. One metal pellet was taken out from the cavity of the chest.
3. Wound of entering of firearm ½ cm X ½ cm X till the cavity of abdomen, towards left of abdomen and 1 cm above of tunica crest.
4. Wound of entering of firearms towards right side of the chest, 5 m away from the right side nipple. As per position of 2 hrs. 1.5 cm X 1 cm in deep in the cavity of the chest.
5. Wound of entering of firearm ½ cm X ½ cm in deep of cavity of the abdomen, around 5 cm away from the right side navel, in the position of 8 hrs.
6. Mark of bruises towards the opposite of chest in the area of 1.4 cm X 7 cm in right side of the chest.
7. Wound of exit of firearm in the area of 33 cm X 21 cm, towards back side of the chest and was in deep from 2 cm X 1.5 cm to 1cm X 1 cm in the cavity of the chest.
8. Wound of entering of firearm 1.5 cm X 1 cm in depth of the muscle, beneath knee on right forearm.
9. Wound of exit of firearm 3.5 cm to 3 cm in depth of the muscle in the mid of right side arm in the correspondence of injury No. 8 which is wound of entering of firearm.
10. Wound of entering of firearm in depth of muscle from 1 cm X ½ cm, in the inner portion of left upper side arm but 5 cm beneath from armpit. Around the wound the tattooing was present.
11. Wound of exit of firearm in depth of the muscle 1 cm X 1.5 cm, corresponding the injury No. 10.
12. Brusted wound in the area of 1.5 cm X 6 cm to 2.5 cm X 1 cm deep in the muscle.
2.11 The post-mortem of deceased Masooq Ali was conducted by Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) on 15th October 2013 at 1.30 PM. The injuries sustained by deceased Masooq Ali are thus:
1. Wound of entering of firearm measuring ½ cm X ½ cm deep in the cavity of the chest and 8 cm away from left side nipple in the position of 11.00 hrs.
2. Wound of exit of firearm measuring 2 cm X 1.5 cm in deep in the cavity of chest, towards right side of chest beneath 11 cm of armpit and 14 cm away from the nipple in the position of 9 hrs. 2.12 The post-mortem of deceased Rizwan was conducted by Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) on 15th October 2013 at 1.45 PM. The injuries sustained by deceased Rizwan are thus:
1. Wound of entering of firearm in deep of cavity of chest measuring ½ cm X ½ cm towards left side of chest, 2 cm beneath the outer portion of clavicle.
2. Wound of entering of firearm in deep of cavity of chest measuring 1 cm X 1 cm in front of the left side of chest 4 cm away from left nipple in the position of 7.00 hrs.
3. Wound of exit of firearm 2 cm X 1.5 cm in deep of the cavity of the chest towards back side of the chest 3 cm away from the middle line in right side and 7 cm beneath the neck corresponding the injury No. 2.
2.13 The post-mortem of deceased Rihan was conducted by Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) on 15th October 2013 at 2.10 PM. The injuries sustained by deceased Rihan are thus:
MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 776 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
1. Wound of entering of firearm 1.2 cm X 1.2 cm in deep of the bone, on upper side of the left shoulder. Around the wound tattooing was present. The bone beneath the injury was fractured.
2. Wound of exit of firearm 1 cm X 1 cm in deep of the cavity of the chest towards right side of the chest, 12 cm beneath of imprear angle of Scapula and 15 cm away from the middle line.
2.14 The post-mortem of deceased Satendra was conducted by Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) on 15th October 2013 at 2.30 PM. The injuries sustained by deceased Satendra are thus:
1. Wound of entering of firearm ½ cm X ½ cm in deep of the bone towards the back side of the right shoulder and 7 cm beneath the upper portion. The bone beneath the injury was fractured.
2. Wound of exit of firearm 1.5 cm X 1 cm corresponding the injury No. 1 and on outer portion of right side collarbone.
3. Wound of exit of firearm ½ cm X ½ cm in deep of cavity of chest, towards left side of chest and 7 cm beneath the left nipple in the position of 7.00 hrs.
4. Wound of exit of firearm 2 cm X 1 cm in deep of cavity of the chest towards back side of left side chest, 16 cm beneath the scapula corresponding the injury.
2.15 The post-mortem of deceased Sunil was conducted by Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) on 15th October 2013 at 3.00 PM. The injuries sustained by deceased Sunil are thus:
1. Wound of entering of firearm 4 cm x 3 cm in the deep of the cavity of the chest towards left side of the chest and 11 cm away from nipple in the position of 11.00 hrs.
2. Second and third rib beneath the injury were fractured.
3. The small four metal pellet and a bending piece of plastic in cylindrical shape was taken out from the cavity of the chest. 2.16 After completing the investigation, chargesheet came to be submitted against the arrested accused persons along with absconding ones in the court of jurisdictional Magistrate. Since the case was exclusively triable by the Sessions Court, the same came to be committed to the Sessions Judge, Muzaffarnagar. Following which, charges were framed against appellants Madan and Sudesh Pal and other accused persons, namely, Kunwar Pal and Ishwar for offences punishable under Sections 148 and 449, Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 307 read with Section 149, Section 323 read with Section 149 of IPC by the trial court; whereas, an additional charge for offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act, 1959 was framed against accused Ishwar.
2.17 Subsequently, accused Kunwar Pal absconded and the trial commenced against appellant Madan and co-accused Ishwar in Sessions Trial No. 09 of 2005, against appellant Sudesh Pal in Sessions Trial No. 838 of 2005 and against accused Ishwar in Sessions Trial No. 10 of 2005 for the charge under Section 25 of the Arms Act, 1959 arising out of Case Crime No. 204 of 2003. The accused persons denied the charges and pleaded to be tried.
2.18 The prosecution examined as many as 25 witnesses to prove the guilt of the accused persons. In the present case, three out of the six deceased persons, namely, Ram Kishan, Satendra and Sunil were related with Lokendra (PW-1) as his cousin, real brother, and nephew respectively. They were also related with Jai Singh (PW-8) and Anil (PW-3). The statements of the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. wherein they denied the allegations against them and stated that they were not involved in the incident and were thus innocent. However, due to village election rivalry, they were being falsely implicated in this case but did not examine any witness in defence.
2.19 At the conclusion of trial, the trial court vide judgment dated 31st July 2015 held the accused persons guilty of committing the murder of six persons and accordingly convicted the appellants herein along with accused Ishwar for offences punishable under Sections 148 and 449, Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 307 read with Section 149, Section 323 read with Section 149 of IPC, while accused Ishwar was also additionally convicted for the offence punishable under Section 25 of the Arms Act, 1959. The trial court, observing the offences committed by the appellants herein to have been falling in the ambit of the rarest of the rare case, imposed sentence of capital punishment to the appellants herein for the offence punishable under MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 778 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Section 302 read with Section 149 of IPC, while it sentenced accused Ishwar to imprisonment for life for the same. The trial court sentenced each of the three accused persons 3 years rigorous imprisonment under Section 148 of IPC; life imprisonment under Section 449 and Section 307 read with Section 149 of IPC and one year rigorous imprisonment under Section 323 read with Section 149 of IPC. The trial court further sentenced accused Ishwar to five years rigorous imprisonment under Section 25 of the Arms Act. 2.20 Being aggrieved thereby, the accused persons preferred their respective appeals before the High Court with regards to the conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court. The High Court, by the impugned judgment, while commuting the sentence of appellant Sudesh Pal from capital punishment to imprisonment for life, dismissed the appeals filed by appellant Madan and accused Ishwar and confirmed their conviction and sentence awarded by the trial court. The High Court further confirmed the Death Reference insofar as appellant Madan is concerned; whereas insofar as appellant Sudesh Pal is concerned, his appeal was partly allowed and the sentence of capital punishment imposed on him was converted to life imprisonment.
2.21 Being aggrieved thereby, the present appeals.
3. We have heard Shri Anand Grover, learned Senior Counsel appearing for appellant Madan in Criminal Appeal Nos. 1381-82 of 2017, Shri Manish Kumar Vikkey, learned counsel appearing for appellant Sudesh Pal in Criminal Appeal No. 1790 of 2017 and Shri Brijender Chahar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent-State of Uttar Pradesh.
4. Shri Grover, learned Senior Counsel appearing for appellant Madan firstly, addressed us on merits of the matter. He submitted that the order of conviction as passed by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court is not at all sustainable. He submitted that initially 11 witnesses were cited as eye witnesses. However, 7 of them have turned hostile. The prosecution case is therefore left with only 4 alleged eye witnesses i.e. Lokendra (PW- 1), Irshad Khan (PW-7), Harpal Singh (PW-10) and Sudhir (PW-11).
5. Shri Grover submitted that, from the testimony of Lokendra (PW- 1) itself, it can be seen that his presence at the scene of crime is doubtful. It is submitted that the evidence of this witness is contradictory to his original statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. There are substantial improvements in his evidence. Though in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., he stated that he was with a group of people, but in cross-examination he admitted that he was not walking along with the group, but was behind them by around 10 yards from the cross roads (towards the north) when the group of people reached Rashid’s house. He submitted that Lokendra (PW-1) admitted that he could not clearly see the place of incident or the group of people from where he was standing. He further submitted that the said witness has admitted that on hearing the sound of firing, he ran further northwards from the cross-roads from Rashid’s house and could not see the site.
6. Shri Grover submitted that there are also substantial contradictions in the testimony of Lokendra (PW-1) which casts doubt with regard to his presence at Rizwan’s house. He submitted that, in the chief-examination, this witness has stated that on witnessing the shooting at Rashid’s house, he ran towards Rizwan and Rihan’s house and took cover there and witnessed the incident at Rizwan’s house. However, in cross-examination, he contrarily stated that on hearing the sounds of firing, he ran further northwards from the cross-roads and stayed there for 15-20 minutes. From the evidence of Jai Singh (PW-8) and Sukhpal Singh (PW-2), father and uncle of Lokendra (PW-1) respectively, it is clear that Lokendra (PW-1) was not present at the place of incident. Even in the case registered by Lokendra (PW-1), he does not show himself to be an eye witness. It is submitted that there are contradictions in his testimony about the authorship of Tehrir.
7. Shri Grover submitted that if Lokendra (PW-1) had really accompanied the group, then certainly he would also have received some injuries. The learned Senior Counsel, relying on the judgments of this Court in the cases of Jaikam Khan v. State of Uttar Pradesh1 and Khema @ Khem Chandra v. State of Uttar Pradesh2, submitted that the testimony of this witness, being totally contradictory, cannot be relied upon for convicting the appellant Madan.
1 (2021) 13 SCC 716
2 2022 SCC OnLine SC 991 MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 780 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
8. Shri Grover further submitted that Irshad Khan (PW-7) is the father of deceased Rizwan and Rihan, who were allegedly shot at their own house. He submitted that there are material contradictions in the evidence of Irshad Khan (PW-7) also. It is submitted that, in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., Irshad Khan (PW-7) stated that he was present on the roof of the adjoining house and not inside the room in his house and hence, could not have witnessed the incident at his house. It is submitted that these contradictions have been put to him in cross-examination. It is submitted that non-examination of Mehmoona Begum, mother of deceased Rizwan and Rihan, who was present at the place of incident, also casts doubt about the presence of Irshad Khan (PW-7) at the place of incident. He submitted that if Irshad Khan (PW-7) was really present at the place of incident, then there was no reason as to why he did not receive any injury. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that the presence of this witness is not supported from his deposition given in Tehrir. It is submitted that the conduct of Irshad Khan (PW-7) in not informing the police about the incident also casts doubt about his presence.
9. Shri Grover submitted that the presence of Harpal Singh (PW- 10) at the place of incident is also doubtful. In his deposition, Harpal Singh (PW-10) has stated that he was at the village main road, 4-5 steps ahead of the victims at Rashid’s house. On hearing the sound of firing, he allegedly hid near Amanullah’s house at the time of incident. However, in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., he has stated that at the time of incident, he was near the private school rickshaw stand which was about 600 metres away from the place of incident. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that a perusal of the spot map would show that the private school is not near the place of incident. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that further the evidence of this witness is not corroborated by the injured witness or other eye witnesses including Sudhir (PW-11). It is further submitted that there are material contradictions with regard to time of incident in the deposition of the said witness and as such, the testimony of this witness is not credible.
10. Insofar as Lokendra (PW-1) is concerned, Shri Grover submitted that the testimony of the said witness suffers from material omissions with regard to involvement of appellant Madan in the incident. In his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., Lokendra (PW-1) had stated that there were 2-3 unknown people involved in the crime. Further in his testimony, there were material omissions in this regard. In his testimony, Lokendra (PW-1) vaguely mentioned that the appellant Madan and his family members were involved in the crime. However, he has not given any details with regard to the same.
11. Shri Grover further submitted that there is improvement in the evidence of Sudhir (PW-11) with regard to the cause of his presence at the place of incident. In his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., Sudhir (PW-11) did not give any reason for his presence at the place of incident. It was for the first time in court that he deposed about being in the locality in search of labourers to work in his field. He submitted that there are serious lapses in the prosecution case inasmuch as though Sudhir (PW-11) is alleged to have accompanied Lokendra (PW-1) to Police Station Babri to register the Tehrir, he did not permit Sudhir (PW-11) to go inside the police station while registering the Tehrir. He submitted that such a conduct is not consistent with human nature. The learned Senior counsel therefore submitted that Sudhir (PW-11) would fall in the category of a chance witness and the testimony of such a witness cannot be relied upon without there being corroboration from any independent testimony. The learned Senior Counsel relies on the judgments of this Court in the cases of Acharaparambath Pradeepan and Another v. State of Kerala3 and Harjinder Singh alias Bhola v. State of Punjab4.
12. Shri Grover further submitted that there are material contradictions regarding the place where deceased Masooq Ali was shot. According to Lokendra (PW-1) and Harpal Singh (PW-10), Masooq Ali was shot and killed in front of his own house. However, this version is not supported by the testimony of Irshad Khan (PW-7).
13. Shri Grover submitted that all the aforesaid witnesses are related to the deceased and they or their relatives held posts in the village panchayat. He submitted that Lokendra (PW-1) is the brother of deceased Satendra, son of injured Jai Singh (PW-8) and cousin of deceased Ram Kishan. Sudhir
3 (2006) 13 SCC 643
4 (2004) 11 SCC 253
MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 782 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(PW-11) is an immediate cousin of Ram Kishan and related to Lokendra (PW-1). Irshad Khan (PW-7) is the father of deceased Rizwan and Rihan. It is submitted that these witnesses also supported Vimla Devi, the then sarpanch and Ram Kishan’s mother. Lokendra (PW-1) and Sudhir (PW-11) are related witnesses of deceased Ram Kishan and Satendra. It is submitted that all these witnesses have falsely implicated appellant Madan so as to ensure the conviction of appellant Madan and his family members.
14. Shri Grover submitted that the injured eye witnesses Sukhpal Singh (PW-2), Mumtaz Khan (PW-5) and Jai Singh (PW-8) have not supported the prosecution story alleging the involvement of the present accused. It is submitted that though Mumtaz Khan (PW-5) has stated in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. that the appellant Madan along with other accused was involved in the shooting, in his examinationin-chief, he has stated that when he came out on hearing the sound of firing, he saw 3-4 persons who had covered their faces with masks and these persons were involved in shooting. Mumtaz Khan (PW-5) does not specifically name the appellant Madan. He submitted that even there are contradictions in the evidence of Sukhpal Singh (PW-2). It is submitted that even Jai Singh (PW-8), father of Lokendra (PW-1) has not supported the prosecution case and was declared hostile. It is therefore submitted that in the absence of the independent witnesses supporting the prosecution case, the conviction could not have been based on the basis of testimony of interested witnesses. He further submitted that the deposition of Bahadur Singh Chauhan (PW-17) would show that 2-3 unknown persons from outside the village were also involved in the crime. However, the police has failed to investigate the matter with regard to involvement of persons from other villages. It is submitted that only on account of political rivalry, appellant Madan has been implicated in the present crime. The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the recoveries of the weapons alleged to have been used in the crime are farcical and in any case not supported by the Ballistic Report.
15. Shri Grover submitted that there are serious lacunae in the investigation. It is submitted that as per the evidence of Lokendra (PW-1), Irshad Khan (PW-7) and Harpal Singh (PW-10), the police were present at the scene prior to the report being lodged at the police station i.e. before 07.40 P.M. However, Raghunandan Singh Bhadauria (PW-24) stated that he arrived at the location at around 08.30 P.M. i.e. after the report was lodged at 07.40 P.M. It is submitted that there is no certainty as to when the Special Report under Section 174 Cr.P.C. was sent to the Magistrate. He submitted that the timing of investigation becomes particularly important in view of the opinion of Dr. Arvind Kumar Aggarwal (PW-14) who conducted the post-mortem stating that the death of the deceased could have been between 8-9 P.M. i.e. after the investigation had started. He submitted that the lapses in the investigation are further apparent from the fact that there are inconsistencies with regard to the presence of bodies of the deceased and the place of inquest. It is submitted that from the evidence of some of the witnesses, it appears that the bodies were moved from the site of shooting prior to the starting of inquest. However, the inquest report records the presence of bodies at the site of shooting i.e., at the village main road, Masooq Ali’s house and Deputy Pradhan’s house. It is submitted that all these factors will cumulatively raise substantial doubt on the fairness of investigation and reporting.
16. Shri Grover submitted that, though independent witnesses were available, for the reasons best known to the prosecution, they have not been examined. It is submitted that uptill now, Mehmoona Begum, wife of Irshad Khan (PW-7), who was present inside the kitchen during the killing of Rizwan, Rihan and Ram Kishan, was not presented as a witness. It is submitted that if this witness could have been examined, the real genesis of the incident would come forth. It is further submitted that since the occurrence has taken place on the main street, many independent witnesses must have witnessed the incident. They have also not been examined. Even Rashid, in front of whose house, one of the shootings occurred, was not produced as a witness. It is further submitted that Amanullah, in whose house Harpal Singh (PW-10) allegedly hid during the shooting, was not examined as a witness.
17. Shri Grover therefore submitted that the prosecution has failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt and as such, the judgment and order of conviction as recorded by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court is liable to be set aside.
MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 784 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
18. Shri Grover, in the alternative, submitted that even if this Court does not interfere with the conviction, the capital punishment awarded to appellant Madan is not sustainable. He submitted that the trial court and the High Court have failed to draw a balance-sheet of mitigating and aggravating circumstances. It is submitted that the prosecution has to discharge the burden to place the material on record to establish that there is no possibility of reforming a convict before capital sentence could be awarded. Shri Grover submitted that in the present case, the State was directed to produce three Reports i.e. Probation Officers Report, Prison Conduct Report and Psychological Assessment Report. He submitted that, from the conduct of appellant Madan in jail, it is evident that appellant Madan has shown positive signs of reformation and poses no continuing threat to society. Appellant Madan is currently 64 years old and he has been in prison for 18 years and 3 months. It is submitted that during the entire duration, he has had no history of any kind of offence in prison.
19. Shri Grover submitted that even from the Psychological Evaluation Report conducted by Institute of Human Behaviour & Allied Sciences (IHBAS), Dilshad Garden, Delhi, it could be seen that the said Report shows that the socio-occupational functioning is unaffected. It further shows that appellant Madan has voluntarily taken up tasks in prison to keep himself occupied and also taken up responsibilities to help younger prisoners to lead a better life in prison. It is submitted that, taking into consideration all these factors, the capital punishment needs to be commuted to life imprisonment.
20. Shri Grover submitted that even the alleged motive is far-fetched. He submitted that the political rivalry which is attributed as motive is remote inasmuch as the elections were held for the period prior to more than two and half years of the incident. The learned Senior Counsel therefore requested for allowing the appeals.
21. Shri Grover further submitted that the present case does not fall in the category of rarest of rare cases to warrant capital punishment. He submitted that the finding recorded by the trial court and the High Court with regard to the present case being rarest of rare cases is without basis and as such, even if the conviction is confirmed, capital punishment would not be sustainable.
22. Shri Grover fairly submitted that though there are certain criminal antecedents against the appellant, the same cannot be a ground to deny his commutation. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that in the event this Court does not interfere with the order of conviction, the capital punishment deserves to be commuted to life imprisonment.
23. Shri Manish Kumar Vikkey, learned counsel appearing for appellant Sudesh Pal has adopted the arguments as advanced by Shri Grover.
24. Shri Chahar, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the State submitted that no interference would be warranted with the concurrent orders of trial court and the High Court.
25. Shri Chahar submitted that the appellants have brutally killed six innocent persons only on account of political rivalry. It is submitted that the appellants who have committed such a heinous and gruesome crime, are not entitled to any leniency. It is submitted that appellant Madan was already a hardened criminal. He submitted that he was also awarded life imprisonment in another case and under his leadership, the accused persons killed six persons. It is submitted that the incident was such which caused terror in the society and the High Court and the trial court have rightly held the present case to be the rarest of rare cases so as to award death penalty to the accused. He therefore submitted that no interference would be warranted in the present case.
26. With the assistance of the learned counsel for both the parties, we have examined the entire evidence and perused the material placed on record.
27. The incident has taken place in two parts as under:
(i) The first place is near the house of Rashid son of Mustafa. Appellant Madan along with Rajveer, Ram Bhajan, Ramveer, Kanwar Pal and Ishwar armed with licensed guns, rifles and country-made pistols came from behind and started firing indiscriminately. As a result of which, Satendra and Sunil fell down on the Khadanja and died on the spot. When Masooq Ali, after hearing the sound of gunfire, came out of his house, the accused persons also fired shots at him. As a result of which, he also fell down.
MADAN v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [B. R. GAVAI, J.] 786 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(ii) The second place is the house of Up-Pradhan Rizwan. After indiscriminate firing by the accused persons, Ram Kishan and Sukhpal Singh (PW-2) ran away to save their lives and Ram Kishan entered the house of Rizwan. The accused persons followed them and entered into the house of Rizwan and fired shots at Ram Kishan, Rizwan and Rihan. As a result of which, Ram Kishan died on the spot. Masooq Ali, Rizwan and Rihan were taken to the hospital by the villagers. However, on the way to hospital, they succumbed to their injuries.
28. Though the prosecution has examined 11 witnesses, only 4 of them supported the prosecution case. PW-1 is Lokendra. He has deposed in his evidence that, on 14th October 2003 at around 05.30 in the evening, he and his brother Satendra, Sukhpal Singh (PW-2), Ram Kishan, his father Jai Singh (PW-8) and Sunil were going to the Deputy Pradhan Rizwan’s house for discussing the problems of the village. He has stated that when they reached near the house of Rashid son of Mustafa, the accused persons including the present appellants carrying rifles, guns etc. in their hands, came behind them. They shouted that they would kill these people today. After saying this, all the people started firing indiscriminately with their weapons. Due to those injuries, Satendra and Sunil fell down on the spot. He stated that Ram Kishan and Sukhpal Singh (PW-2) were also shot but they fled away to save their lives. He further stated that in the meantime, Masooq Ali came out of his house near the spot. The accused persons also shot him and he also fell down.
29. Lokendra (PW-1) further stated that Ram Kishan entered into Rizwan’s house to save his life and the accused persons also entered Rizwan’s house after him. When Rizwan and Rihan were trying to stop them from entering their house, they also fired shots at both of them. The said witness cannot be said to be an eye witness as to what has happened inside the house of Rizwan. However, insofar as the first incident is concerned, he is an eye witness to the same.
30. In his examination-in-chief, Lokendra (PW-1) has stated about Vimla Devi, mother of deceased Ram Kishan contesting the election of village Pradhan in the previous election. Lokendra (PW-1) was also a member of the Gram Panchayat and he supported Vimla Devi. He stated that because of this, appellant Madan and others started keeping internal enmity with them.
31. Lokendra (PW-1) also deposed that Mahipal, a witness to this incident, was also murdered about two and half months ago in the vicinity of the Jwalapur Police Station, Haridwar, in which, Rajveer, Ramvir, Rambhajan, sons of Ishwar and Ishwar were made the accused persons. He further stated that because Rambhajan, Rajveer, Ramveer, Ompal and Devendra alias Neetu were absconding from their homes since the incident, they could not be caught. In his cross-examination, it was put to him that in his Tehrir, it was not mentioned that he was going with the other persons to the place of Rizwan. However, the FIR is not an encyclopaedia of the entire incident. There are certain omissions in his evidence but they are not material.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.