Sayunkta Sangarsh Samiti & Anr v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 1080; [2023] 16 S.C.R. 724
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Aniruddha Bose, Justice Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, Justice The Project Was Stalled By A
- Decided
- 15 Dec 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1359/2023
- Sections
- 11, 3, 2, 4, 26, 42, 22
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 16 S.C.R. 724 : 2023 INSC 1080
CASE DETAILS
SAYUNKTA SANGARSH SAMITI & ANR
v.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 1359 of 2023)
DECEMBER 15, 2023
[ANIRUDDHA BOSE AND SUDHANSHU DHULIA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: An entirely private arrangement was arrived at between the Developer on the one hand and some of the hutment dwellers on the other. Slum Rehabilitation Authority had no role to play in it. Is private agreement as such enforceable against the statutory mandate of the Slum Rehabilitation Authority.
Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) issued a Letter of Intent in favour of Developer for residential tenements – In 2007, the project was stalled by a minority section of the slum dwellers (appellant society) – The Developer filed a civil suit seeking injunction against obstructers – During the pendency of the suit an MoU was signed between them, whereby the appellant society undertook to enforce selfdevelopment rehabilitation with cooperation of the developer – Towers which the appellant-society undertook to construct or supervise their construction were towers D, E and F, which were then to be occupied exclusively by the members of the appellant society – Pursuant to MOU, the appellant-society approached SRA to do allotment as per the settlement – Propriety:
Held: The Civil Suit was at the behest of the developers against individual society and SRA was not made party to these proceedings – Private agreements cannot be enforced in Slum Rehabilitation Schemes as against the statutory mandate of the SRA – The claim of the appellant was based entirely on terms of consent arrived between the Developer and them, which has no basis in law – SRA has to act in terms of its own policies and circulars without allowing private or contractual interests to prevail over public policy especially a policy which is welfare based – It is also Circular No.162 dated 23.10.2015, that allotment will be done by draw of lots for all the hutment dwellers and same was sought to be followed by the SRA – The appellant society though has filed two Writ Petitions subsequently in connection with the procedure for allotment undertaken by the SRA, yet it has not challenged the validity of Circular No. 162, instead it has sought to impose its private contractual rights over and above the statutory provisions which is not permissible – SRA directed to carry out the allotment of flats in accordance with law. [Paras 20, 21,22,23, 25,26]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Ram Chandra Mahadev Jagpat and Ors. vs Chief Executive Officer and Others, [2006] 8 Suppl. SCR 658 : (2006) 11 SCC 661; Pramila Singh Suman vs State of Maharashtra and Others, [2008] 17 SCR 1517 : (2009) 2 SCC 729; Balasaheb Arjun Torbole and Others vs Administrator and Divisional Commissioner and Others, [2015] 6 SCR 750 : (2015) 6 SCC 534 – referred to.
Lokhandwala Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. and Another v. State of Maharashtra and others, 2011 SCC OnLine Bom 118; Susme Builders Private Limited v. Chief Executive Officer, Slum Rehabilitation Authority, 2014 SCC OnLine Bom 4822; New Janta SRA CHS Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, 2019 SCC OnLine Bom 3896; Smt. Usha Dhondiram Khairnar and Others v. State of Maharashtra and Others, 2016 SCC OnLine Bom 11505 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.1359 of 2023. From the Judgment and Order dated 22.10.2021 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WPL No.8391 of 2020.
Appearances:
Jayant Bhushan, Sr. Adv., Rahul Kripalani, Ankit Yadav, Ms. Suhasini Sen, Ms. Prakriti Rastogi, Aditya Pratap Singh Chauhan, Ms. Supraja V., SAYUNKTA SANGARSH SAMITI & ANR v. THE STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA
726 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Ms. Mahalakshmi Ganapathy, Amartya Bhushan, Yojit Mehra, Prashant Gawali, Advs. for the Appellants.
Arunabh Chowdhury, Sr. Adv., Shrirang B. Varma, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aniruddha Joshi, Shashibhushan P. Adgaonkar, Omkar Jayant Deshpande, Mrs. Pradnya S Adgaonkar, Anil Rao, Mubarakka Mohammed Lokhandwala, Mrs. Pragya Baghel, Dechen W. Lachungpa, Anirudha M. Sethi, Sagar Ghogre, Vaibhav Ghogre, Amrendra Kumar Mehta, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.
1. The appellants before this Court have challenged the order dated 22.10.2021 passed by the High Court of Judicature, Bombay, which has dismissed the Writ Petition of the appellants. The petition was for quashing of the order dated 26.10.2020 passed by respondent No. 2 i.e. Slum Rehabilitation Authority, Maharashtra (hereinafter referred to as ‘SRA’).
2. SRA had proposed a Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for the slum at CS No. 1(pt) of Lower Parel Division at J.R. Boricha Marg. The project was for construction of a total built up area of 75854.716 sq. m., where 1765 slum dwellers were to be rehabilitated. Nine towers i.e. tower nos. A to I, 69 commercial tenements, 24 recreational tenements, 6 existing amenities, 19 balwadis, 19 welfare centres and 19 society offices, were in the construction plan. The construction of all the above towers has been completed as of now, and 473 slum dwellers have already been given possession of their tenements in Towers A, B and C. All the same, the allotment for the remaining towers has been stalled due to the present dispute and the ongoing litigation between various stake holders of the project. Hopefully it should end now.
3. Slums of Mumbai are symbolic of the existing inequalities in our society. The growth of industries and urban centres invariably result in migration of rural population to urban industrial areas areas, in search of employment. The migrants, displaced poor and the marginalised are forced by circumstances to form a living space for themselves, which are called slums. Slums have also been described as a crowded settlement of temporary household with inadequate facilities and very poor hygienic conditions. Although, many of the slums in Mumbai such as ‘Dharavi’, ‘Byculla’ and ‘Khar’ were initially villages, but they too have mushroomed into slums in the lopsided urban development.
4. The city of Mumbai has a maximum number of recorded slums in the country and as per the 2011 census, 42 percent of its population stays in slums. Very little attention was paid to the slum dwellers in their initial period during the late 19th century and early 20th century, during colonial Rule. After the 1896 bubonic plague the Government recognised the need for improvement in the housing and sanitary conditions, in the city. This resulted in the formation of Bombay Improvement Trust (for short ‘BIT’) in 1898, and later Bombay Development Department (for short ‘BDD’) in the year 1920. BDD in particular, inter alia, had a mandate to construct low-cost houses for the workers who were manning the factories and the mills in the city; and for the workers in ports and railway station as well. All the same, not much was done by these bodies as far as improvement of living conditions of the workers in these areas or for providing them with a decent housing or sanitary conditions.
5. With independence, initially the approach of the authorities towards slums was also largely focused on clearing the slum areas, rather than improving their conditions. The Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956 was enacted by the Parliament for declaring the areas as slum area, and clearing it. The competent authority could declare an area as a slum area and would thereafter pass demolition or clearance orders. There was no purposeful welfare, socially sensitive, provision in the Act for redevelopment of the area after its clearance and this was left to the satisfaction of the competent authority, which may redevelop an area, subject to his or her satisfaction (see Section 11 of the Act).
6. This approach of the executive and the legislature subsequently changed with the concept of welfare state taking hold and the growth of awareness of the inhabitants towards their rights under the Constitution. The Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1971 Act’) was enacted which had SAYUNKTA SANGARSH SAMITI & ANR v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 728 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
provisions for redevelopment of area and other benefits for the inhabitants. In 1971 Act the purpose of the Act was “improvement and clearance of slums areas in the State and for their redevelopment and for the protection or occupiers from eviction, distress and warrants; and for matters enacted with the purposes aforesaid; …………………”. The main authorities in the 1971 Act are the competent authority to be appointed under Section 3 of the Act and more importantly the Slum Rehabilitation Authority for implementing slum rehabilitation scheme. The Slum Rehabilitation Authority or SRA is a creature of the statute of “1971 Act” and as a body corporate consisting of following:
“3-A…………….
(1)……………..
(2) Every Slum Rehabilitation Authority shall consist of a Chairman, a Chief Executive Officer and fourteen other members, all of whom shall be appointed by the State Government.”
Slum areas are defined under Section 2(ga) of the 1971 Act as follows: “Slum area means any area declared as such by the Competent Authority under sub-section (1) of Section 4 [and includes any area deemed to be a slum area under Section 4-A”
Section 4 and 4A of the 1971 Act is regarding declaration of slum areas, which are as follows:
“4. Declaration of slum areas.— [(1) Where the Competent Authority is satisfied that—
(a) any area is or may be a source of danger to the health, safety or convenience of the public of that area or of its neighbourhood, by reason of the area having inadequate or no basic amenities, or being insanitary, squalid, overcrowded or otherwise; or
(b) the building in any area, used or intended to be used for human habitation are—
(i) in any respect, unfit for human habitation; or
(ii) by reasons of dilapidation, overcrowding, faulty arrangement and design of such buildings, narrowness or faulty arrangement of streets, lack of ventilation, light or sanitation facilities or any combination of these factors, detrimental to the health, safety or convenience of the public of that area, the Competent Authority may, by notification in the Official Gazette, declare such area to be a slum area. Such declaration shall also be published in such other manner (as will give due publicity to the declaration in the area) as may be prescribed.]
(2) In determining whether buildings are unfit for human habitation for the purposes of this Act, regard shall be had to the condition thereof in respect of the following matters, that is to say, —
(a) repairs;
(b) stability;
(c) freedom from damp;
(d) natural light and air;
(e) provision for water-supply;
(f) provision for drainage and sanitary conveniences;
(g) facilities for the disposal of waste water;
and the building shall be deemed to be unfit as aforesaid, if, and only if, it is so far defective in one or more of the said matters that it is not reasonably suitable for occupation in that condition.
(3) Any person aggrieved by a declaration made under sub-section (1) may, within thirty days after the date of such declaration in the Official Gazette, appeal to the Tribunal. [No such appeal filed after the expiry of thirty days as aforesaid shall be entertained.]
(4) When an appeal is presented under sub-section (3), the Tribunal shall, by a public notice published in a newspaper in the Marathi language circulating in the local area in which the slum area is situated and also displayed at some conspicuous place in the slum area, call upon the residents of the slum area to file their objections, if any, to the appeal within a period of fifteen days from the date of publication of such public notice in the newspaper as aforesaid, either by themselves or through any association of residents in the slum area of which they are members. SAYUNKTA SANGARSH SAMITI & ANR v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 730 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(5) On expiry of the period of fifteen days as aforesaid the Tribunal shall fix a day for hearing the appeal and inform the appellant about the same by letter under certificate of posting and the residents of the slum area by displaying the notice of hearing at some conspicuous place in the slum area and upon hearing the appellant, and the residents or representative of their association in the slum area, if present, or on considering the written objections, if any, made by such residents or association, if absent, the Tribunal may, subject to the provisions of sub-section (6), make an order either confirming, modifying or rescinding the declaration: and the decision of the Tribunal shall be final.
Explanation.—For the purposes of sub-section (4) and this sub-section, the, expression “any association of residents in the slum area” means a society, if any, of such residents registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 (21 of 1860) or under the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 (Mah. XXIV of 1961).
(6) While deciding the appeal the Tribunal shall ignore the works of improvement executed in such slum area by any agency of the Government or any local authority after the declaration thereof as such slum area by the Competent Authority under sub-section (1).] [4-A. Certain slum improvement areas deemed to be slum areas.—(1) Any declaration made under Section 26 of the Maharashtra Slum Improvement Board Act, 1973 (Mah. XXIII of 1973), declaring any area to be slum improvement area, and in force immediately before the date of commencement of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) (Amendment)Act, 1976 (Mah. XX of 1970), (herinafter in this section referred to as “the said date”) shall, on and from the said date, be deemed to be a declaration made under Section 4 of this Act declaring the same area to be a slum area for the purposes of this Act.
(2) Any person aggrieved by the provisions of sub-section (1) may, within thirty days from the said date, appeal to the Tribunal function under this Act.
(3) on such appeal, the Tribunal may make an order either confirming, modifying or rescinding the declaration: and the decision of Tribunal shall be final].”
7. The Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (hereinafter referred to as ‘MRTP Act, 1966’) is again an important piece of legislation with which we are presently concerned. The MRTP Act, 1966 was enacted in order to have a planned development in the State of Maharashtra. An amendment was brought in the MRTP Act, 1966, in the year 1995 whereby SRA was given the status of Planning Authority so far as slums were concerned. The State Government under the 1966 Act has got powers to frame what is called Development Control Regulations (DCR) for the purposes of implementation of any scheme, project, etc which would include development of a slum. The DCR Regulation under which the present rehabilitation of slum was to be undertaken was Regulation 33(10) of DCR, 1991.
The present slum area with which we are concerned is at Lower Parel Division in J.R. Boricha Marg and is notified as a “slum” under the 1971 Act and had 1672 residential tenements. As per the scheme of SRA more than 70 percent of the eligible hutment dwellers were members of the federation, i.e., present respondent no.6 which were to choose its developer and take the scheme forward under the overall supervision of SRA.
8. In accordance with the procedure given under the DCR, 1991 the majority section of the slum dwellers, in the present case, who were earlier divided into different independent societies, got together and formed a society called “Shramik Ekta Co-Operative Housing Federation” (respondent No. 6, herein), which we here refer as the “Federation”. The Federation in turn appointed Lokhandwala Kataria Constructions (respondent No. 5) as its Developer. SRA consequently issued a Letter of Intent (LoI) on 16.04.2005, in favour of the Developer, approving the proposed Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, submitted before them.
9. The work for construction of the nine towers commenced but was stalled shortly afterwards in 2007. Since then, the project was moving only in fits and starts. This was due to the interference caused by a minority section of the slum dwellers. These slum dwellers are also members of the Federation though have formed a separate minority society for themselves, SAYUNKTA SANGARSH SAMITI & ANR v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 732 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
called “Sayunkta Sangharsh Samiti” (hereinafter referred to as ‘SSS’), which is the present appellant no. 1 before us, and to which we would refer in a while.
10. Based on the provisions of law regarding redevelopment of a slum, the procedure for the implementation of a Slum Rehabilitation Scheme has been summarised and published by SRA in form of “Guidelines for the Implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Schemes in Greater Mumbai” which was published in September, 1997. The procedure mandates that: “70% or more of the eligible hutment-dwellers in a slum or pavement in a viable stretch at one place have to show their willingness to join Slum Rehabilitation Scheme and come together to form a cooperative housing society of all eligible hutment-dwellers through a resolution to that effect.”
11. This Court has upheld this procedure in a catena of Judgments which include Ram Chandra Mahadev Jagpat and Ors. vs Chief Executive Officer and Others (2006) 11 SCC 6611; Pramila Singh Suman vs State of Maharashtra and Others (2009) 2 SCC 7292; Balasaheb Arjun Torbole and Others vs Administrator and Divisional Commissioner and Others
(2015) 6 SCC 5343
12. In 2007, the project being stalled by a minority section of the Federation, the Developer filed a civil suit before the City Civil Court, Bombay seeking injunction against the defendant nos.1 to 15 who were inhabitants of the slum, and as per the scheme had an entitlement for a flat each in the residential complex which was to be constructed by the developer i.e., the plaintiff, but these defendants were not letting the Developer make construction of the nine towers which had to be constructed within a stipulated time. Defendant no.16 was the federation and the recitals of the plaint clearly states that defendant no.16 is only a proforma party, it is actually defendant nos.1 to 15 who were creating obstructions in the construction of the towers, which the plaintiff was mandated to construct as per the scheme. To our mind, this Civil Suit was not even maintainable in view of Section 42 of the 1971 Act, which bars the jurisdiction of Civil 1 Para 28 2 Para 18 3 Paras 14 & 15 Courts in matters relating to slum development. Section 42 of the 1971 Act reads as under:
“42. Save as otherwise expressly provided in this Act, no Civil Court shall have jurisdiction in respect of any matter which the Administrator, Competent Authority or Tribunal is empowered by or under this Act, to determine, and no injunction shall be granted by any Court or other authority in respect of any action taken or to be taken in pursuance of any power conferred by or under this Act.”
13. Be that as it may, the SRA which was in any case a necessary party to the Civil Suit, was not made a defendant. The reasons are not difficult to locate. In the absence of SRA, there was no one to question the maintainability of the suit, as it ultimately ended in a compromise decree. It so happens that during the pendency of the suit an MoU was signed between the plaintiff and appellant-society, which had as its members, most of the contesting defendants, and the so called contesting parties agreed to resolve their differences as per the MOU.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.