Rajesh & Anr. v. The State of Madhya Pradesh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 839; [2023] 15 S.C.R. 1
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice 1872 – Ss.26, Justice 27 – Being
- Decided
- 21 Sept 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 793/2022
- Sections
- 27, 26, 364A, 120B, 302, 201, 157, 100(4), 100(8), 100, 165, 162
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 15 S.C.R. 1 : 2023 INSC 839
CASE DETAILS
RAJESH & ANR.
v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 793-794 of 2022)
SEPTEMBER 21, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI, J. B PARDIWALA AND SANJAY KUMAR, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: In a case based on circumstantial evidence as there was no eyewitness to the kidnapping and murder, and where the prosecution’s case essentially turned upon the ‘recoveries’ made at the behest of the appellants-convicts, purportedly u/s.27, Evidence Act, whether their conviction on different counts and death sentence imposed on two out of the three appellants was justified, when the confessions were made before their arrest and prior to being ‘accused of any offence’.
Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.26, 27 – Being in ‘the custody of a police officer’ and being ‘accused of an offence’ – Pre-requisites to render a confession made to the police admissible to a limited extent by bringing into play the exception postulated u/s.27:
Held: s.26 provides that no confession made by any person whilst he is in the custody of a police officer shall be proved against such person, unless made in the immediate presence of a Magistrate – s.27 is in the nature of an exception to s.26 – It is essential u/s.27 that the person concerned must be ‘accused of an offence’ and being in the ‘custody of a police officer’, he or she must give information leading to the discovery of a fact and so much of that information, whether it amounts to a confession or not, that relates distinctly to the fact discovered, may be proved against him – Both aspects, viz, being in ‘the custody of a police officer’ and being ‘accused of an offence’, are indispensable pre-requisites to render a confession made to the police admissible to a limited extent, by bringing into play the exception postulated u/s. 27 – In the present case, though one of the appellant was taken to the police station, be it on 2 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
29.03.2013 or even earlier, he could not be said to be in ‘police custody’ till he was arrested at 18:30 hours on 29.03.2013, as he did not figure as an ‘accused’ in the FIR and was not ‘accused of any offence’ till his arrest – Therefore, it was his arrest which resulted in actual ‘police custody’, and the confession made by him, before such arrest and prior to his being ‘accused of any offence’, would be directly hit by s.26 and there is no possibility of applying the exception u/s.27 to any information given by him in the course of such confession, even if it may have led to the discovery of any fact – Thus, the purported discovery of the dead body, the murder weapon and the other material objects, even if it was at his behest, cannot be proved against him, as he was not ‘accused of any offence’ and was not in ‘police custody’ at the point of time he allegedly made a confession – Similarly, the other two appellants were also not named as the ‘accused’ in the FIR and were not ‘accused of any offence’ till they were arrested and taken into ‘police custody’, well after the recording of their confessions and the alleged seizures based thereon – This lapse on the part of the police is fatal – There are yawning infirmities and gaps in the chain of circumstantial evidence – The degree of proof required to hold appellants guilty beyond reasonable doubt, on the strength of circumstantial evidence, not established – No valid reasons were put forth by the Trial Court and the High Court as to why this case qualified as the ‘rarest of rare cases’, for imposing and sustaining capital punishment – Conviction and sentences of all the appellants on all counts set aside and they are acquitted by giving them the benefit of doubt – Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302, 364A, 120B, 201. [Paras 22, 27 and 39] Criminal Law – Investigation – Panchnamas and memos:
Held: In the present case, the manner and method in which the panchnamas and memos were prepared leave the prosecution high and dry – The witnesses to the panchnamas and the seizures acted as mere attestors to the documents and did not disclose in their own words as to how these objects were discovered, i.e., at whose instance and how – No lawful validity attaches to these proceedings recorded by the police in the context of collection of all this evidence – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. [Para 31, 32] Evidence – DNA evidence- hair, source and origin suspected – Non-reliance upon:
Held: In the present case, DNA evidence was also relied upon by the prosecution, by projecting a scenario that the deceased had struggled with his assailant and in the course of that scuffle, he managed to pull out some hair from the head of his assailant and they remained in his hand till the discovery of his body – DNA analysis of that hair proved that they were those of one of the appellant, ‘RY’ – However, on facts, this story is found to be bereft of logic – Further, as there is a doubt as to when ‘RY’ was taken by the police and as to whether his hair could have been pulled out by the police while he was in their control, the possibility of such evidence being introduced by the police themselves cannot be ruled out – Thus, as the source and origin of the DNA evidence, viz., the hair, is rendered suspect, the end result of that DNA analysis serves no real purpose in establishing the prosecution’s case. [Para 33] Criminal Law – Police investigation – Disappointing standards, noted with concern – Dr. Justice V.S. Malimath’s ‘Committee on Reforms of Criminal Justice System’; Law Commission of India Report No.239 – Discussed.
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
C. Chenga Reddy and others vs. State of A.P [1996] 3 Suppl. SCR 479 : (1996) 10 SCC 193; Ramreddy Rajesh Khanna Reddy vs. State of A.P. [2006] 3 SCR 348 : (2006) 10 SCC 172; Majenderan Langeswaran vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and another [2013] 10 SCR 907 : (2013) 7 SCC 192; Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; Hanumant vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (1952) 2 SCC 71; Padala Veera Reddy vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and others 1989 Supp (2) SCC 706; Bodhraj alias Bodha and others vs. State of Jammu & Kashmir [2002] 2 Suppl. SCR 67 : (2002) 8 SCC 45; State of Karnataka vs. David Rozario and another [2002] 2 Suppl. SCR 419 : (2002) 7 SCC 728; Ashish Jain vs. Makrand Singh and others [2019] 1 SCR 345 : (2019) 3 SCC 770; Boby vs. State of Kerala Criminal Appeal No. 1439 of 2009, decided on 12.01.2023; Yakub Abdul Razak Memon vs. State of Maharashtra through CBI, Bombay [2013] 15 SCR 1 : (2013) 13 SCC 1; Ramanand @ RAJESH & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH 4 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
Nandlal Bharti vs. State of Uttar Pradesh Criminal Appeal Nos. 64-65 of 2022, decided on 13.10.2022:2022 SCC OnLine SC 1396; Khet Singh vs. Union of India [2002] 2 SCR 598 : (2002) 4 SCC 380; Manoj and others vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2023) 2 SCC 353 – relied on.
Pulukuri Kotayya vs. King Emperor AIR 1947 Privy Council 67 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
793-794 of 2022.
From the Judgment and Order dated 10.08.2017 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Principal Seat at Jabalpur in Cr.RFC No.1 of 2017 and Crl.A. No.84 of 2017.
With Criminal Appeal No.795 of 2022.
Appearances:
Sidharth Luthra, Sr. Adv., Ms. Supriya Juneja, Aditya Singla, Bhavesh Seth, Shakti Singh, Ayush Aggarwal, Ayush Agarwal, Udbhav Sinha, Advs. for the Appellants.
Shreeyash Uday Lalit, Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Abhinav Aggarwal, Krishnagopal Abhay, Ms. Runjhun Garg, Ms. Maitreyee Jagat Joshi, Astik Gupta, Ms. Ayushi Mittal, Kuldeep Kumar Shukla, Vipul Abhishek, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SANJAY KUMAR, J.
1. Ajit Pal @ Bobby, a 15-year-old lad, was killed brutally in the last week of July, 2013. A neighbour, Om Prakash Yadav, along with his brother, Raja Yadav, and son, Rajesh @ Rakesh Yadav, stood trial in Sessions Case No. 560 of 2013 for Ajit Pal’s murder and connected offences. By judgment dated 29.12.2016 passed therein, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Jabalpur, Madhya Pradesh, convicted all three of them on different counts. Om Prakash Yadav was held guilty under Section 364A read with Section 120B IPC while Raja Yadav and Rajesh Yadav were held guilty of offences under Section 302 IPC read with Section 120B IPC; Section 364A read with Section 120B IPC; and Section 201 IPC. Sentences were passed against the three of them on the same day. Om Prakash Yadav was sentenced to life imprisonment along with default imprisonment of two months, if he failed to pay a fine of ₹2,000/-. Raja Yadav and Rajesh Yadav were sentenced to death for the offences under Sections 302 and 364A IPC and to two months default imprisonment each, if they individually failed to pay the fine amounts of ₹1,000/- and ₹1,000/- respectively. Both of them were also sentenced to five years rigorous imprisonment and payment of fine of ₹500/- each in relation to the offence under Section 201 IPC coupled with one month’s default imprisonment.
2. Aggrieved thereby, all three convicts appealed to the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. Their appeals were clubbed with ‘In reference (CRRFC-1 of 2017)’ received from the Sessions Court in the light of the death sentences. By judgment dated 10.08.2017 delivered in Criminal Appeal No. 83 of 2017, filed by Om Prakash Yadav, and Criminal Appeal No. 84 of 2017, filed by Rajesh Yadav and Raja Yadav, along with ‘In reference (CRRFC-1 of 2017)’, a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court confirmed their conviction and sentences, including the death penalty visited upon Raja Yadav and Rajesh Yadav.
3. Assailing this verdict, the three convicts are before this Court by way of these appeals by special leave. Criminal Appeal No. 793 of 2022 was filed by Rajesh Yadav and Raja Yadav in the context of Criminal Appeal No. 84 of 2017, while Criminal Appeal No. 794 of 2022 was filed by them in relation to ‘In reference (CRRFC-1 of 2017)’. Criminal Appeal No. 795 of 2017 was filed by Om Prakash Yadav against the dismissal of Criminal Appeal No. 83 of 2017.
4. To establish its case, the prosecution had examined 17 witnesses before the Trial Court and marked 45 exhibits. The defence examined 3 witnesses and adduced 14 exhibits in evidence.
5. In brief, the prosecution’s case is as follows: Rajwant Kaur (PW- 1), Ajit Pal’s mother, received a substantial sum of money upon sale of RAJESH & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 6 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
some property by her father. This sale was effected on 22.03.2013 but prior to that, a sum of ₹10 lakhs was received by her in cash. On the date of registration of the sale deed, a sum of ₹27.5 lakhs was received by cheque, in the name of her father. The balance amount was also received in cash on the same day. Out of the ₹10 lakhs received by her, PW-1 created a fixed deposit for ₹9 lakhs and ₹1 lakh was kept in her account. This information was in the knowledge of Om Prakash Yadav, a neighbour, and his entire family. While so, on 26.03.2013, PW-1’s son, Ajit Pal, left the house at 9 o’clock in the night to see the ‘Holika’ and did not return. PW-1 lodged a ‘missing person’ report (Ex. P1) at Gorakhpur Police Station on 27.03.2013 at 16:15 hours. On 28.03.2013, PW-1’s brother, Amarjeet Singh @ Mitthu (PW-2), and Om Prakash Yadav went to the Gurudwara in Gwarighat to search for the boy. They did not find him there but while they were returning, PW-2 received a call on his mobile phone from mobile number 8305620342. The caller said - “I am Khan speaking, Bobby is with me. Send me 50 lakh rupees.” PW-2 went to PW-1 to tell her about this and at that time, another call came on his mobile phone from the same number. PW-2 gave the phone to PW-1 and the caller said “I am Khan speaking. Your Bobby is with me. Send 50 lakh rupees and if you tell the police or any other person then I will cut Bobby’s throat and kill him.” PW-1 told him not to do that and asked to speak to her child. She then heard a voice saying: “Mummy, save me, Mummy, save me, I am Bobby”. PW1 stated that, on hearing Bobby’s voice, she fell down and the mobile fell from her hand. Om Prakash Yadav took the phone and started speaking to the caller. He said “Tell us quickly where to get the money and I am getting the money with (sic) Didi”. Then, Monu Gujral (PW-10), another neighbour, took the phone but it was cut. PW-10 then used his own phone to call the kidnapper on the same number and asked to speak to Bobby. When the kidnapper let him do so, PW-10 told PW-1 that it was not Bobby’s voice. Then, the caller said to PW-10 that Bobby had told him that his mother had ₹3 lakh; to send the same right away and the balance ₹20 lakh could be given in 1 month.
6. Om Prakash Yadav pressed upon PW-1 to arrange ₹1 lakh and to withdraw the rest of the ₹20 lakhs from the bank. However, PW-1 could not give ₹1 lakh to Om Prakash Yadav as there were relatives in her house. PW-10 wrote down the mobile number from which the kidnapper had called, viz., 8305620342, on a piece of paper and gave it to PW-1. She gave the said number to the police. When she came back from the police station, Om Prakash Yadav came to her and asked her not to tell the police anything and that Bobby would be freed by midnight. Later, Raja Yadav came to PW-1’s house at about 11 o’clock in the night and told her that her brother, PW-2, and her other brother, Major Singh, had kidnapped her son in their greed for money. Raja Yadav had a sword in his hand and told PW-1 that he would cut the throats of her brothers if she asked him to. PW-1 told him not to do any such thing as her brothers would not do something like that.
7. On 28.03.2013 at about 3:30 pm, basing on the ransom calls received, PW-2filed a report with the Gorakhpur Police Station. On that basis, FIR No. 273/13 (Ex. P35) was registered at 18:20 hours against unknown persons under Sections 364A and 365 IPC. Call details and IMEI data were obtained by the Investigating Officer (PW-16) from the Cyber Cell for mobile number 8305620342 from which the ransom calls had been made. PW-16 was informed by the Cyber Cell that the mobile phone handset with IMEI No. 358327028551270 was used to make the ransom calls and the handset with this IMEI number was also used with mobile number 9993135127, which was issued to Om Prakash Yadav. On receiving this information, PW-16 went to the house of Om Prakash Yadav in Narmada Nagar, Gwarighat, on 29.03.2013. PW-16 took Rajesh Yadav to the police station and questioned him at 13:45 hours, whereupon he confessed to having killed Ajit Pal, along with Raja Yadav. PW-16 recorded a Memorandum (Ex. P8) containing the confession of Rajesh Yadav, wherein he also stated that he would help recover Ajit Pal’s body and the murder weapon. Rajesh Yadav and PW-16, along with witnesses, then went to Narmada Nagar. Rajesh Yadav led them to a well near Khandari Canal. Ajit Pal’s body was found in the well. It was stuffed in a white plastic sack. The body was identified as that of Ajit Pal by the witnesses present. Ajit Pal’s throat was cut and there was hair entangled in his right-hand fingers. The police prepared a Panchayatnama (Ex. P2). It bears the signature of PW-2. The Naksha Panchayatnama (Ex. P3) was also signed by PW-2. Rajesh Yadav pointed out an empty liquor bottle lying at some distance. The same was seized under a Property Seizure Memo (Ex. P10). An iron knife was also seized at the behest of Rajesh Yadav RAJESH & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 8 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
from the canal. There were blood-like stains on the knife. The seizure was effected in the presence of witnesses under a Property Seizure Memo (Ex. P11). Rajesh Yadav was then arrested on 29.03.2013 at 18:30 hours under an Arrest Memo (Ex. P36).
8. PW-16 again went to the house of Rajesh Yadav on 30.03.2013 to search for the SIM cardof mobile number 8305620342, but it was not found. Ex. P37 is the House Search Panchnama in that regard. On 31.03.2013, Rajesh Yadav was again questioned in Gorakhpur Police Station in the presence of witnesses and his statement was recorded in a Memorandum (Ex. P15). He stated that the mobile phone from which the ransom calls were made was with his brother, Brijesh Yadav, and that he would help recover it. On 31.03.2013, Brijesh Yadav was taken to Gorakhpur Police Station and questioned in the presence of witnesses. He made a statement, recorded in a Memorandum (Ex. P17), that he had hidden the mobile phones given by his brother, Rajesh Yadav, in a suitcase in his room. Brijesh took the police and witnesses to the house and a double-SIM mobile phone handset, with IMEI Nos. 358327028551278 and 358327028653272, was seized. Another mobile phone of Micromax company with SIM No. 9993135127 and IMEI Nos. 910549001346373 and 910549001754378 was also seized. The Seizure Memo is Ex. P19.
9. On 31.03.2015 at 15:00 hours, PW-16 questioned Raja Yadav in Gorakhpur Police Station in the presence of witnesses. He stated that he had hidden the blood-stained clothes worn by him at the time of the incident and would help recover the same. On the basis of this statement, recorded in a Memorandum (Ex. P16), Raja Yadav took the police and witnesses to his Dairy in Narmada Nagar, where his clothes, with blood-like stains, were seized under a Seizure Memo (Ex. P18). Raja Yadav was arrested on 31.03.2013 under an Arrest Memo (Ex. P20) at 17:40 hours.
10. Om Prakash Yadav was taken to Gorakhpur Police Station on 05.04.2013 and questioned in the presence of witnesses. He stated that the blood-stained clothes worn by Rajesh Yadav at the time of the incident were hidden by him in a plastic bag under some hay in a room of his house. This statement was recorded in a Memorandum (Ex. P22) and on that basis, one black T-shirt, one black full lower and one light green Bermuda were found under the hay in a room of his house. The clothes were seized at 15:15 hours on 05.04.2013 under a Seizure Memo (Ex. P23). Om Prakash Yadav was arrested on 05.04.2013 at 15:30 hours under an Arrest Memo (Ex. P24).
11. The hair seized from the right fist of the deceased was sent for DNA analysis and for comparison with the blood samples of Rajesh Yadav and Raja Yadav. The DNA Test Report revealed that the said hair belonged to Rajesh Yadav. The autopsy of the body was done by Dr. Vivek Shrivastav (PW-7). His postmortem report (Ex. P7) indicated that the death had occurred 3 to 5 days prior to the examination and the cause of death was haemorrhagic shock which occurred due to the throat being cut prior to death. The postmortem examination was conducted by him at 10:15 hours on 30.03.2013.
12. According to the prosecution, the ransom calls were made by Raja Yadav by inserting the SIM card with mobile number 8305620342 into Om Prakash Yadav’s mobile phone handset bearing IMEI No. 358327028551270. Thereafter, the said SIM card was destroyed and Om Prakash Yadav’s SIM card with mobile number 9993135127 was inserted into the handset. As per the prosecution, though the ransom calls were made during the morning hours on 28.03.2013, Ajit Pal was killed on the night of 26.03.2013 itself by Rajesh Yadav and Raja Yadav. They lured him by offering him alcohol, whereupon Raja Yadav and Ajit Pal drank whisky. Raja Yadav then caught hold of Ajit Pal and Rajesh Yadav cut his throat. Rajesh Yadav then got a white plastic sack and they hid the body in the well. This, in sum and substance, was the prosecution’s case.
13. Before parting with the factual narrative, we may note that the prosecution tried to project Puran Singh (PW-3) as a witness to buttress a ‘last seen’ theory so as to build up a stronger case. This witness stated that his daughter was married to PW-2. He stated that he knew the accused also. He claimed that on 26.03.2013 at 6 pm, he had gone to Narmada Nagar to give a box of sweets to his daughter for Holi. He further stated that, after leaving her house, he reached the railway crossing and met Raja Yadav, Rajesh Yadav and Ajit Pal. Ajit Pal greeted him and he asked Ajit Pal why he was not at home as it was past 9 pm. Ajit Pal told him that he was going to see the ‘Holika’ and left with the others. PW-3 stated that he then went home and was informed by his daughter on 28.03.2013 that Ajit Pal had been RAJESH & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 10 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
kidnapped and ransom calls had been made. On 29.03.2013, his daughter informed him that Ajit Pal’s dead body was found inside a well and that Raja Yadav, Rajesh Yadav, Brijesh Yadav and Om Prakash Yadav had helped recover it. PW-3 stated that he went for Ajay Pal’s last rites on 30.03.2013 and when he met the TownInspectorat the crossing, he told him that he had met Ajit Pal along with Raja Yadav and Rajesh Yadav on 26.03.2013. This version of PW-3 was accepted by the Trial Court but was disbelieved by the High Court. The ‘last seen’ theory sought to be built up by the prosecution, therefore, fell to the ground.
14. A conspectus of the prosecution’s case clearly reveals that it is poised entirely on circumstantial evidence as there was no eyewitness to the kidnapping and murder of Ajit Pal. In a case resting on circumstantial evidence, the prosecution must establish a chain of unbroken events unerringly pointing to the guilt of the accused and none other [See C. Chenga Reddy and others vs. State of A.P1, Ramreddy Rajesh Khanna Reddy vs. State of A.P.2, Majenderan Langeswaran vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and another3and Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra4]. As long back as in the year 1952, in Hanumant vs. State of Madhya Pradesh5, a 3-Judge Bench of this Court observed as under:
‘It is well to remember that in cases where the evidence is of a circumstantial nature, the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should in the first instance be fully established, and all the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. Again, the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency and they should be such as to exclude every hypothesis but the one proposed to be proved. In other words, there must be a chain of evidence so far complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for a conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and it must be such as to show that within all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.’
1 (1996) 10 SCC 193
2 (2006) 10 SCC 172
3 (2013) 7 SCC 192
4 (1984) 4 SCC 116
5 (1952) 2 SCC 71
Again, in Padala Veera Reddy vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and others6, this Court affirmed that when a case rests solely upon circumstantial evidence, such evidence must satisfy the following tests:
‘1. The circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently and firmly established;
2. Those circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards guilt of the accused;
3. The circumstances, taken cumulatively, should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability the crime was committed by the accused and none else; and
4. The circumstantial evidence in order to sustain conviction must be complete and incapable of explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the guilt of the accused and such evidence should not only be consistent with the guilt of the accused but should be inconsistent with his innocence.’
15. Applying these standards presently, we find that the prosecution utterly failed to pass muster in establishing its case. There are cavernous gaps in the evidence that the prosecution would offer as an ‘unbroken chain unerringly pointing to the guilt of the appellants’. Discrepancies galore in the prosecution’s case tear asunder the fabric of its purported version as to how events unfolded. Oftentimes, Courts find that reckless overzealousness and unbridled fervour coupled with scant regard for due procedures and practices on the part of the police, in picking upon those whom they perceive to be the guilty party and then building up a case against them, accomplishes the direct opposite of what they seek to achieve, by exposing gaping holes and weak links in the chain of evidence that they ultimately offer, as is the situation now.
16. To begin with, there is no clarity as to the time at which Ajit Pal went missing. Ex. P1, being the ‘missing person’ report lodged by Rajwant Kaur (PW-1), recorded that Ajit Pal left the house on 26.03.2013 6 1989 Supp (2) SCC 706 RAJESH & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 12 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
at 9 o’clock and went somewhere and that he was searched for but was not found. Significantly, there is no mention therein of whether it was at 9 am or 9 pm that Ajit Pal had left the house or that it was to see the ‘Holika’. PW-6 is the Chief Constable at Gorakhpur Police Station who recorded Ex. P1 on 27.03.2013. He stated that PW-1 reported that her son, Ajit Pal, had left the house on 26.03.2013 at 9 o’clock without telling anyone and he had not been found despite their search. There is a mention of the time as 9 o’clock, without specifying whether it was in the morning or night and again, no mention of the ‘Holika’. However, FIR No.273/13 (Ex. P35), registered on 28.03.2013 at 18:20 hours, recorded that Ajit Pal had left the house on 26.03.2013 at ‘9 in the morning’ without telling anyone and that he was searched for everywhere but was not found. Again, there is no mention therein of his having gone to see the Holika, but there is now clear ambiguity whether Ajit Pal went missing on 26.03.2013 at 9 o’clock in the morning itself or at 9 o’clock at night. Further, the prosecution would have it that the kidnappers were not even certain as to the ransom amount that they wanted. Several varying figures find mention in the prosecution’s case. If the very motive for the offence was to collect ransom, it is doubtful whether the kidnappers would have been so equivocal about their demand.
17. Adding to the confusion, Rajwant Kaur (PW-1) stated during her cross-examination that the person on the phone who made the ransom call was a stranger and then went on to add that she had recognised the voicebut as her child’s life was in danger, she did not tell the police. She further stated that she did not say that she had recognized the voice until the end. She also admitted that she did not even mention in her examination-in-chief that she had recognised the voice. Compounding matters further, she stated that the police had used tracking dogs on 29.03.2013 but denied the suggestion that the dogs had detected the body in the well. According to her, the dogs were used in the evening after the body was taken out from the well in the afternoon. Thereafter, she said that the tracking dogs had gone to the well and washing area at 7-8 o’clock but she did not remember on which dateit was,but it was after the body was found. Similarly, Jitendra Singh (PW-8), a close relation of PW-1 and a key witness to the prosecution’s seizure memos, stated that he had heard of sniffer dogs being used between 28.03.2013 and 29.03.2013 but it was not in his presence. As to why sniffer/tracking dogs would be pressed into service after the police found the dead body, the murder weapon and other material objects is not comprehensible. Notably, the Investigating Officer (PW-16) did not even mention the use of sniffer/ tracking dogs during investigation. This suppression, be it for whatever reason, does not reflect well upon the prosecution.
18. These being glaring disparities in the very foundation of the case, things get progressively worse.Saidutt Bohare (PW-15), the Nodal Officer from Bharti Airtel Limited, who furnished the call data to the police, said that he sent those details by email to the Police Superintendent’s Office when he was asked. He produced a copy of the email, containing the call details sent to the Police Superintendent’s office (Ex. P31). He stated that the subscriber of mobile number 9993135127 was Om Prakash, son of Buletan Yadav, and furnished the call details and IMEI data. The call data statement (Ex. P31) reveals that it was made available to the police at 18:05 hours on 28.03.2013. It was only thereafter that the FIR was registered at 18:20 hours. However, though the call data statement was sufficient to link Om Prakash Yadav with the ransom calls, the police chose to mention in the FIR that the accused was ‘Unknown’. Further, if Ex. P31 statement pointed to the involvement of Om Prakash Yadav, as claimed by the Investigating Officer (PW-16), there is no explanation forthcoming as to why the police picked up Rajesh Yadav first.
19. Further, and most crucial of all, there is no clarity as to when the appellants were actually taken into ‘custody’ by the police. PW-2 stated in his examination-in-chief that the police caught Rajesh Yadav and took him to Gorakhpur Police Station during the afternoon hours of 28.03.2013 itself. During his cross-examination, PW-2 again asserted that the police did not take Om Prakash Yadav on 28.03.2013 but they took Rajesh Yadav and Raja Yadav. PW-2 categorically denied the suggestion that the police did not take Raja Yadav and Rajesh Yadav on 28.03.2013 and that they took them on 29.03.2013. Shiv Prakash (PW-4), a relation of the accused, also stated that the Gorakhpur police had taken him along with Raja Yadav, Brijesh Yadav, Om Prakash Yadav and Rajesh Yadav and held them in the police station on the night of 28.03.2013 itself, where they were beaten. He was declared hostile and cross-examined by the prosecution. He again claimed that the police had taken them on the night of 28.03.2013. He stated that he RAJESH & ANR. v. THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [SANJAY KUMAR, J.] 14 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
was released on the 5th from Gorakhpur Police Station but he did not make a complaint due to fear, as the police had beaten him a lot.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.