M.A Biviji v. Sunita & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 938; [2023] 15 S.C.R. 113
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hrishikesh Roy
- Decided
- 19 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3975/2018
- Sections
- 23
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 15 S.C.R. 113 : 2023 INSC 938
CASE DETAILS
M.A BIVIJI
v.
SUNITA & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 3975 of 2018)
OCTOBER 19, 2023
[HRISHIKESH ROY AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: The complainant alleged negligence on the part of a Hospital – The main claim of negligence that the complainant attributed was that the forced Nasotracheal Intubation (NI) procedure resulted in her developing Grade-IV Subglottic Stenosis (i.e., narrowing of upper airway between the vocal folds and lower border of cricoid cartilage) in the trachea – Subsequently, the same led to various severe complications.
Negligence – Medical Negligence – The NCDRC concluded that the negligence charge regarding the unjustifiable ‘NI’ procedure was proved – The act of replacing the existing Tracheostomy Tube (TT), with ‘NI’ was held to have been an avoidable course of action that was other than what should have ordinarily been done in that situation – The NCDRC awarded complainant a compensation of Rs. 6,11,638/- @ 9% p.a. for the medical expenses she incurred at Hospital – Propriety:
Held: (1) Taking into consideration the medical literature on record as well as the expert medical committee report presented by the RML Hospital, it is reasonable to conclude that subglottic stenosis & subsequent trauma in the trachea is not an uncommon phenomenon with respect to a patient that has suffered serious injuries in a road accident – In addition, there tends to be a higher risk element of developing an injury if intubation is done in an emergency situation or multiple times – It could also be a result of being subjected to intubation for a prolonged period; (2) In the instant case, the patient was treated and underwent different procedures 114 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
at multiple hospitals – Therefore, there is a possibility that these medical complications could have arisen at any of these hospitals or places where the patient underwent treatment; (3) The medical report available in this case i.e., the RML Hospital Committee Report did not attribute any negligence to Hospital in question or the doctors with respect to any of the charges levelled against them – If the ‘NI’ procedure had been conducted in a negligent manner or was a poor medical decision, it is likely that the RML Hospital Committee Report would have mentioned the same – However, no such observation was made either; (4) The medical team at Hospital in question was able to show that the ‘NI’ procedure was carried out only after due consideration – The existing ‘TT’ was removed after the bronchoscopy showed normalcy in the airways & trachea of the patient – It was expected that the patient would be able to breathe normally without any support after ‘TT’ decannulation – However, a stridor was observed in the airways of the patient, after the said decannulation took place – In light of the same, an alternative course of treatment in the form of an ‘NI’ procedure was opted for as a temporary measure – There is nothing to show that the procedure conducted was outdated or poor medical practice – Resultantly, there was no breach of duty of care at Hospital in question or on part of the doctors – The charge of negligence is, therefore, not proved – Impugned judgment set aside. [Paras 50, 51, 52, 53, 56] Negligence – Medical Negligence – Essential ingredients for determination:
Held: The three essential ingredients in determining an act of medical negligence are: (1) a duty of care extended to the complainant, (2) breach of that duty of care, and (3) resulting damage, injury or harm caused to the complainant attributable to the said breach of duty – However, a medical practitioner will be held liable for negligence only in circumstances when their conduct falls below the standards of a reasonably competent practitioner. [Para 36] Negligence – Medical Negligence – A line of treatment undertaken should not be of a discarded or obsolete category in any circumstance: Held: Due to the unique circumstances and complications that arise in different individual cases, coupled with the constant advancement in the medical field and its practices, it is natural that there shall always be different 115M.A BIVIJI v. SUNITA & ORS.
opinions, including contesting views regarding the chosen line of treatment, or the course of action to be undertaken – In such circumstances, just because a doctor opts for a particular line of treatment but does not achieve the desired result, they cannot be held liable for negligence, provided that the said course of action undertaken was recognized as sound and relevant medical practice – This may include a procedure entailing a higher risk element as well, which was opted for after due consideration and deliberation by the doctor – Therefore, a line of treatment undertaken should not be of a discarded or obsolete category in any circumstance. [Para 37] Negligence – Medical Negligence – A higher threshold limit must be met to hold a medical practitioner liable for negligence:
Held: To hold a medical practitioner liable for negligence, a higher threshold limit must be met – This is to ensure that these doctors are focused on deciding the best course of treatment as per their assessment rather than being concerned about possible persecution or harassment that they may be subjected to in high-risk medical situations – Therefore, to safeguard these medical practitioners and to ensure that they are able to freely discharge their medical duty, a higher proof of burden must be fulfilled by the complainant – The complainant should be able to prove a breach of duty and the subsequent injury being attributable to the aforesaid breach as well, in order to hold a doctor liable for medical negligence – On the other hand, doctors need to establish that they had followed reasonable standards of medical practice. [Para 38]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Jacob Mathew vs. State of Punjab (2005) 6 SCC 1 : [2005] 2 Suppl. SCR 307; Kusum Sharma vs. Batra Hospital (2010) 3 SCC 480 : [2010] 2 SCR 685; Savita Garg v. Director, National Heart Institute (2004) 8 SCC 56 : [2004] 5 Suppl. SCR 359 – relied on.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No.3975 of 2018.
From the Judgment and Order dated 16.02.2018 of the National Consumer Disputes Resolution Commission, New Delhi in Consumer Case No.48 of 2005.
116 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
With C.A. No.4847 of 2018 and 6917 of 2023.
Appearances:
Fanish Kumar Rai, Gaurav Sahdev, Shantanu Sagar, Vinod Kumar, Rajesh Kumar, Keshav Sharma, Shakul R. Ghatole, Sudhanshu S. Choudhari, Advs. for the appearing parties.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
HRISHIKESH ROY, J.
Delay condoned.
2. The Civil Appeals have been filed under Section 23 of The Consumer Protection Act, 1986, (hereinafter referred to as the, ‘Act, 1986’) assailing the impugned decision passed on 16.02.2018 by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (hereinafter, ‘NCDRC’) in Consumer Case No. 48 of 2005 filed by Mrs. Sunita Parvate. The NCDRC directed Suretech Hospital and Research Centre Private Limited, a Hospital in Nagpur, Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, Chief Consultant and Intensive Care Unit In-charge, at Suretech Hospital, Dr. Madhusudan Shendre, ENT Surgeon at Suretech Hospital, and Dr. M. A. Biviji, Radiologist at Suretech Hospital to jointly and severally pay Rs. 6,11,638/- as compensation for medical negligence to Mrs. Sunita (Complainant) with 9 % simple interest from the date of filing of the complaint till the date of actual payment, within six weeks. Additionally, the NCDRC directed that Rs. 50,000/- to be paid to Mrs. Sunita as cost towards litigation expenses. The medical negligence was proved on account of the unjustifiable and forceful performance of Nasotracheal Intubation (hereinafter, ‘NI’) procedure on Mrs. Sunita on 13.05.2004, at Suretech Hospital. The ‘NI’ procedure entails inserting an endotracheal tube through the patient’s nose, to assist in breathing.
3. The Civil Appeal No. 3975 of 2018 has been filed by Dr. M.A. Biviji denying any role in the alleged medical negligence during treatment of Mrs. Sunita at Suretech Hospital. The Civil Appeal (Diary No.21513 of 2018) has been filed by Suretech Hospital, Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, and Dr. Madhusudan Shendre completely denying that any negligence was committed during Mrs. Sunita’s treatment in Suretech Hospital. Whereas Mrs. Sunita filed Civil Appeal 4847 of 2018 seeking enhancement of compensation ordered for medical negligence during her treatment. She further prayed for enhancement of 9% interest p.a. to 18% interest p.a. The claimant, Mrs. Sunita filed Consumer Case 48 of 2005 before the NCDRC seeking Rs. 3,58,85,249/- i.e., Rs. 3.58 crores. However, the NCDRC only awarded her Rs. 6,11,638/- @ 9% simple interest as compensation for the medical expenses she incurred. She was further entitled to Rs. 50,000/- as cost for her litigation expenses.
Complaint before NCDRC:
4. At around 04:30 PM on 05.05.2004, Mrs. Sunita was taken to Gondia hospital within 15 minutes of meeting with a serious car accident near Gondia, resulting in multiple injuries. She suffered from a mandibular (lower jaw) fracture on the left side, and a clavicle (collar bone) fracture on the right side. As an emergency measure, Dr. Vimlesh Agarwal conducted a tracheostomy procedure i.e., creating an opening in the front part of the neck to insert a tube into Mrs. Sunita’s windpipe (trachea) to assist breathing. On 06.05.2004 at around 12:30 AM, the complainant/patient was shifted from Gondia Hospital to the ICU in Suretech Hospital, Nagpur under Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal’s (ICU In-charge) supervision. Mrs. Sunita was put on a ventilator through her Tracheostomy Tube (hereinafter, ‘TT’), which was weaned off on 08.05.2004. On 11.05.2004, Dr. Vinay Saoji, Plastic Surgeon, at Suretech Hospital performed ‘Mandibular Bracing Surgery’ to correctly set Mrs. Sunita’s left-side mandibular fracture in place. The surgery was performed through ‘TT’, horizontally and vertically wiring both the upper and lower jaws.
5. The complainant/patient alleged that on 13.05.2004, Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, Dr. Madhusudan Shendre, Dr. M.A Biviji performed Bronchoscopy to check Mrs. Sunita’s airways and for evaluating her Larynx and Trachea. The complainant further claimed that even though the Bronchoscopy showed a normal air-passageway, indicating her ability to breathe normally through the existing ‘TT’, Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, and Dr. Madhusudan Shendre, removed the ‘TT’ and forcefully performed ‘Nasotracheal Intubation’ (hereinafter ‘NI’) i.e., inserting an Endotracheal tube through the nose to facilitate breathing.
M.A BIVIJI v. SUNITA & ORS.
[HRISHIKESH ROY, J.] 118 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
6. According to the patient, until the ‘NI’ procedure was conducted, she was being fed through a Ryle’s Tube i.e., a tube inserted through the nose to the stomach. However, to accommodate the ‘Nasotracheal Tube’ (Hereinafter, ‘NT’), the Ryle’s Tube (Tube inserted through the nose to feed the patient) had to be removed. Subsequently, she was given liquid oral feed through her mouth. The liquid feed started passing into her respiratory tract, and got collected in her lungs leading to Frank pus and severe infection, ultimately causing ‘Severe Septicemia’. As per the patient, the food entered the respiratory tract only due to the inflated cuff of the ‘NT’. The pus started leaking through the stitched ‘tracheostomy’ wound. As a result of the injuries sustained in the subglottic region, the vocal cords of the patient were also paralysed.
7. On 25.05.2004, Dr. Nirmal ordered a ‘Barium Swallow Test’ i.e., a test conducted to check for any abnormalities in the digestive tract of the patient. It was alleged that even though the said test was resisted by the family of the complainant (in particular, a relative of the complainant – Dr. Kalidas Parshuramkar) due to a possible danger of developing asphyxia, the ‘Barium Swallow Test’ was done forcefully without the presence of any doctor, specifically the radiologist i.e., Dr. M. A. Biviji. Mrs. Sunita claimed to have been forcefully administered two glasses of Barium Sulphate i.e., the solution used to conduct the aforesaid test. It was alleged that upon consumption of the solution, she experienced extreme breathlessness and almost died. She was saved due to the efforts of her relative – Dr. Kalidas Parshuramkar, who took her to the suction room to remove the aspirated solution from her tracheostomy wound and lower trachea.
8. The complainant, being unsatisfied with her treatment at Suretech hospital sought a discharge. On 27.05.2004, she flew to Mumbai, to meet Dr. Sultan Pradhan in Prince Aly Khan Hospital who advised her to first treat life-threatening conditions like difficult respiration, ‘Severe Septicemia’, and ‘Severe Thrombocytopenia’. Dr. Pradhan reinserted the ‘TT’ without a cuff through the pre-existing tracheostomy wound to aid respiration. The complainant alleged that even Dr. Pradhan questioned the ‘NI’ procedure, opining that all subsequent complications that arose were iatrogenic in nature.
119M.A BIVIJI v. SUNITA & ORS.
[HRISHIKESH ROY, J.]
9. Upon being advised rest, Mrs. Sunita flew back to Nagpur, and got herself admitted to Shanti Prabha Nursing Home. On 03.06.2004, Dr. Swarankar performed a Fiber Optic Bronchoscopy, which revealed two openings in Mrs. Sunita’s Trachea at the subglottic level. A false passage was created, which caused the food to pass into her trachea. Mrs. Sunita claimed that the unnecessary and forced ‘NI’ procedure was the only reason why her subglottic region was injured leading to multiple serious medical complications. On 04.06.2004, Mrs. Sunita was discharged from Shanti Prabha Nursing Home, Nagpur. Subsequently, she stayed at her home in a special medically-equipped room until 02.07.2004 when she flew to Mumbai. On 03.07.2004, Dr. Pradhan conducted a laryngoscopy and pharyngoscopy revealing complete laryngostenosis i.e., narrowing of the airway. Upon Dr. Pradhan expressing his inability to perform surgical intervention, Mrs. Sunita underwent a 3D CT Scan for her larynx on 05.07.2004 at Jaslok Hospital in Mumbai. The scan indicated a 3.5 cm subglottic stenosis. On 07.07.2004, Mrs. Sunita went to Dr. Krishnakant B. Bharagava and Dr. Samir K. Bhargava, ENT specialists, who conducted Flexible Fiberoptic Bronchoscopy to observe signs of injuries in the subglottic region. Subsequently, the patient was referred to Dr. Ashutosh G. Pusalkar, ENT at Leelavati Hospital in Mumbai. Dr. Pusalkar expressed his inability to perform any immediate surgical intervention due to the severity of injury in the subglottic region. He advised Mrs. Sunita to maintain the ‘TT’ and undergo proper care for the stoma wound for around 6 months. Eventually, on 30.01.2005, Dr. Pusalkar performed tracheoplasty i.e., tracheal reconstruction surgery. A 3.5 cm long subglottic stenotic segment was excised in the surgery. Resultantly, the complainant had to live with a shortened windpipe. On 14.03.2005, the ‘TT’ was removed after which the doctors realised that Mrs. Sunita’s speech could never be restored.
10. Thereafter, Mrs. Sunita filed Consumer Case No. 48 of 2005 under Sections 12 and 21 of Act, 1986 before the NCDRC on 16.05.2005 alleging medical negligence in her treatment at Suretech Hospital, resulting in permanent damage to her respiratory tract and permanent voice-loss, altering her life forever. Through the complaint, she sought Rs. 3,58,85,249/- @ 18% interest p.a. as compensation against loss and injury suffered by her and her family. The complainant claimed that due to Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, 120 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
Dr. Madhusudan Shendre, and Dr. M.A Biviji’s negligence she suffered from ‘Severe Septicemia’, i.e., a blood stream infection resulting from bacterial infection in her respiratory tract. She claimed that the infection was caused due to oral aspiration i.e., food and liquid entering her airways, and getting deposited in her lungs, leading to Frank pus. She further alleged that the negligent treatment at Suretech Hospital, resulted in her developing ‘Hemorrhagic Peteche’ all over her body due to ‘Severe Thrombocytopenia’ i.e., her platelet count falling to dangerously low levels. The complainant alleged negligence on the part of Suretech Hospital to not conduct regular blood tests to identify significant fall in her platelet count at an appropriate time and waited for her platelet levels to fall to a dangerously low level, i.e., 26,000 on 20.05.2004, before taking any action. Mrs. Sunita also claimed her repeated complaints of blurred vision were ignored, thereby resulting in vision loss. The main claim of negligence that the complainant attributed in the Consumer Case No. 48 of 2005 is that the forced ‘NI’ procedure resulted in her developing Grade-IV Subglottic Stenosis (i.e., narrowing of upper airway between the vocal folds and lower border of cricoid cartilage) in the trachea. Subsequently, the same led to various severe complications. As per the complainant, the unnecessitated and forcefully-conducted ‘NI’ procedure was the only reason she suffered from voice-loss and permanent deformity in her respiratory tract. The ‘NI’ procedure was carried out, despite multiple failures in decannulating the ‘TT’.
Rebuttalto the Consumer Complaint:
11. Dr. M.A Biviji claimed that being a radiologist, he did not have any role in conducting Mrs. Sunita’s Bronchoscopy or ‘NI’ on 13.05.2004. Relying on Mrs. Sunita’s discharge bill dated 26.05.2004, he averred that Dr. Rajesh Swarnakar as the pulmonologist and bronchoscopist at Suretech Hospital, conducted the aforesaid Bronchoscopy and ‘NI’ procedure.
12. Dr. M.A Biviji, Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, and Dr. Madhusudan Pradhan claimed that the complaint is not maintainable as the complainant has not impleaded necessary parties i.e., Dr. Swarnakar, who conducted both the Bronchoscopy, indicating normalcy in Mrs. Sunita’s airways and the ‘NI’ procedure, as well as Dr. Ambade and Dr. Arti Wanare, Ophthalmologists, and Dr. Vinay Saoji, Plastic Surgeon who conducted the ‘Mandibular Bracing Surgery’.
13. According to Dr. Biviji, performing the ‘Barium Swallow Test’ was essential in order to understand why the liquid feed was coming out of Mrs. Sunita’s tracheostomy wound. He elucidated how the test was a routine procedure conducted even in newborn babies to enquire about any abnormality in the passage between the windpipe and the food-pipe. He stated that the solution used for the said test i.e., the Barium Sulphate solution is a non-toxic, and harmless substance, not posing any danger even in case of it being aspirated. He stated that he was present during the test, as it cannot be conducted without a radiologist’s presence. Their presence is needed for the multiple X-rays that need to be taken during the test. Further, the test cannot be conducted without the patient’s cooperation, as they are instructed to swallow the Barium solution. After the test, as a part of the routine procedure, appropriate steps were taken to remove the Barium Swallow Solution that was aspirated by the patient, using a suction machine.
14. Dr. Biviji along with Dr. Nirmal Jaiswal, Dr Madhusudan Shendre, and Suretech Hospital claimed that the complaint had been filed at the behest of Dr. Kalidas Parshuramkar (Mrs. Sunita’s relative) who is a third party apart from being a PG diploma student in Gynecology. It was stated that Dr. Parshuramkar lacked the expertise to understand the treatment, yet constantly interfered, and misinformed the patient about the ‘Barium Swallow Test’, and other treatments being carried out, thereby creating unnecessary panic. The doctors prayed for the complaint to be referred to a panel of medical experts in order to determine whether any negligence was committed or not.
15. According to Dr. Jaiswal, Mrs. Sunita met with a serious accident after which a ‘TT’ was done in the Gondia Hospital, only after an unsuccessful Endotracheal Intubation attempt. The patient was hospitalized in a semi-comatose state, and then immediately put on a ventilator by Dr. Jaiswal. He stated that due care was taken towards Mrs. Sunita’s treatment. A neuro-surgeon treated her for head-injuries, and a plastic surgeon treated her for mandibular fractures and oesopharyngeal trauma. Dr. Jaiswal claimed he was not responsible for removing the Ryle’s Tube or forcefully performing the ‘NI’ procedure either. It was propounded that it is common for road accident patients to develop sepsis due to contamination of their wounds. Mrs. Sunita’s complete blood count report WBC-16700 on 06.05.2004 indicated neutrophilia-84% i.e., showing signs of infection at the time of M.A BIVIJI v. SUNITA & ORS.
[HRISHIKESH ROY, J.] 122 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
her admission to Suretech Hospital. With respect to thrombocytopenia, immediate action was taken and Mrs. Sunita was given platelet concentrates on an everyday basis. Additionally, a bone-marrow examination was done to rule out any other possibility of damage to the platelets. On 27.05.2004, Mrs. Sunita’s platelets started rising gradually and reached up to 73,000 levels. Dr. Jaiswal claimed that it is possible for a tracheal stenosis to be discovered in the future, arising out of serious injuries sustained in a road accident. The doctors contented that the subsequent medical complications suffered by Mrs. Sunita could have also come to effect between 04.06.2004 to 03.07.2004 when she was being treated in her own house under Dr. Kalidas Parshuramkar’s supervision.
16. Dr. Madhusudan Shendre claimed that on Dr. Jaiswal’s instructions, he attempted ‘TT’ decannulation (i.e., Removing ‘TT’) on 11.05.2004 since ‘TT’ removal had become necessary. As the crisis resulted from Mrs. Sunita being involved in a vehicular accident, she was put on a ventilator, which was weaned off on 08.05.2004. Removing the ‘TT’ would enable a normal respiratory passage. He further reasoned that long-term intubation posed a risk of infections and complications like stenosis. The Mandibular surgery was successfully done to fix Mrs. Sunita’s lower jaw. Early in the morning, Dr. Shendre removed the ‘TT’ and covered Mrs. Sunita’s stoma wound, when she was in sustained bandage. He claimed that Mrs. Sunita started experiencing breathing difficulty at night. Therefore, the ‘TT’ was reinserted to support her airway. A re-examination of the Tracheostomy wound indicated that the trauma to the tracheal wall extended posteriorly and superiorly, resulting in the anterior flap of the tracheal wall getting sucked during inspiration, thereby, obstructing tracheal lumen. A need to conduct tracheoplasty in the future was suggested, in order to avoid stenosis. However, as it could not be conducted immediately, an ‘NI’ procedure was suggested as an alternative involving ‘NT’ as a temporary stent. The ‘NT’ stent was expected to serve the purpose of holding the anterior flap and supporting the weakened anterior tracheal wall, preventing a collapse in the lumen, which was causing a problem in decannulation of the ‘TT’. Upon the flap and tracheal wall healing completely, the ‘NT’ would have been removed restoring normal airway. Therefore, Dr. Rajesh Swarnakar conducted the requisite ‘NI’ procedure.
NCDRC Judgment
17. In relation to the main allegation in the complaint regarding the ‘TT’ unnecessarily being replaced by ‘NI’, even though the 1st Bronchoscopy conducted on 13.05.2004, revealed normalcy in Mrs. Sunita’s airways, the NCDRC held that negligence was proved. It was found that given the patient was breathing normally through the ‘TT’, there was no basis to consider replacing it with ‘NI’. It was observed that the ‘TT’ is resorted to when there is a need to provide longer respiration assistance as opposed to ‘NI’, which is more of a temporary measure. Mrs. Sunita was already receiving breathing assistance through the ‘TT’ having already been performed at Gondia hospital on 05.05.2004. After which, she was shifted to Suretech Hospital in a semi-comatose state at around 12:30 AM on 06.05.2004. She was put on a ventilator as an urgent measure, which was weaned off on 08.05.2004. Even the Bronchoscopy conducted on 13.05.2004 indicated a normal larynx and trachea. Thus, it is established that Mrs. Sunita was recovering well, breathing through the ‘TT’ without any issue. Thus, ‘NI’ was performed without any basis or justification, especially as a short-term measure, even though the patient was responding well to her existing treatment. It was further reasoned that even though there is a need to take necessary long-term steps to ensure the patient’s respiration is restored to its earlier normal levels, but the same cannot be done unreasonably, in a tearing hurry, especially without any impending need. Thereby, the NCDRC concluded that the negligence charge regarding the unjustifiable ‘NI’ procedure was proved. The act of replacing the existing ‘TT’, with ‘NI’ was held to have been an avoidable course of action that was other than what should have ordinarily been done in that situation.
18. The NCDRC further observed that the expert medical committee report formulated by RML Hospital was silent about the baseless and forced ‘NI’ procedure that was carried out, even though the Bronchoscopy report indicated that the patient had a normal airway. The expert committee report mentioned that the ‘TT’ was only removed on 13.05.2004, after the said Bronchoscopy report. Thereafter, Mrs. Sunita was able to breath, but a minimal stridor was observed.
19. The NCDRC held that the submissions made by Dr. Madhusudan Shendre are inconsistent in relation to removal of the ‘TT’, and covering the M.A BIVIJI v. SUNITA & ORS.
[HRISHIKESH ROY, J.] 124 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
stoma wound, and observing normalcy in the morning, whereas he averred observing the patient having breathing difficulty at night. Resultantly, Dr Madhusudan Shendre felt that a re-examination was necessitated. He stated that the re-examination revealed damage to the tracheal wall, necessitating Tracheoplasty in the future. The NCDRC rejected the doctor’s suggestion of proceeding with ‘NI’ as a temporary measure on account of a lack of clear timeline. It was held that there was absolutely no justification for opting for ‘NI’, especially when the patient was recovering well.
20. The NCDRC however concluded that Mrs. Sunita’s claim with respect to negligence leading to Thrombocytopenia, was not proved. The complainant’s platelet count on 06.05.2004 was 1,73,000, well within the normal range. It significantly dropped down to 26,000 on 20.05.2004. The NCDRC observed that usually decisive interference starts when the levels drop down to 20,000, however, in Mrs. Sunita’s case, intervention was done even when her platelet levels dropped down to 26,000. The NCDRC further observed that additionally, a bone-marrow examination was done. The intravenous immunoglobulin was planned in advanced for the next 5 days. Eventually, Mrs. Sunita’s platelet count was observed to have started increasing, rising to 73,000 on 27.05.2004. The same was said to have been corroborated with her discharge slip. The NCDRC relying on the expert committee report held that no negligence was proved in handling the Septicemia and thrombocytopenia.
21. The NCDRC also rejected the charges of negligence with respect to the ‘Barium Swallow Test’. The decision of conducting the ‘Barium Test’ was held to be a clinical one. As food was leaking from Mrs. Sunita’s trachea stoma wound, an investigation to understand the underlying cause was necessitated. It was held that Barium Sulphate is a non-toxic solution, posing no serious danger to the complainant. Mrs. Sunita failed to prove the charge regarding the test being conducted without a radiologist’s presence.
22. The NCDRC held that the negligence charge with respect to vision loss and the hospital ignoring Mrs. Sunita’s complaints about blurred vision, is not proved. When she was admitted to Suretech Hospital, she was in a critical condition, requiring ICU care and ventilator support. So, the NCDRC rejected the suggestion that she was in a position to complain about blurred vision. Further, tests conducted by two different Ophthalmologists at Suretech Hospital revealed normal retina. Vision became an issue only after two months, in July 2004, when Mrs. Sunita was diagnosed with left homonyms, quadrantanopia. The expert committee report held that such issues relating to vision-loss are commonly observed after serious road accidents.
23. The NCDRC concluded that just based on a single act of negligence, wherein, unjustifiably, ‘NI’ was forcefully performed, replacing the existing ‘TT’, it is not possible to conclude that subsequent resultant medical complications, including permanent respiratory tract deformity and voiceloss suffered by Mrs. Sunita were a consequence of that very single act of negligence. The NCDRC observed that the risk of complications could not have been pin-pointed. The subsequent medical complications could have occurred anywhere, as the complainant was treated at various hospitals by multiple doctors, and also lived in her own house from 04.06.2004 to 03.07.2004. The complainant was a victim of a serious road accident, wherein, it is common for various serious infections and complications to occur. The Complainant failed to produce any evidence proving that Dr. Pradhan opined that the complications were only a result of the forced ‘NI’. Relying on the expert committee, it was held that subsequent medical complications, and infections are common after serious road accidents.
24. The NCDRC awarded Mrs. Sunita a compensation of Rs.
6,11,638/- @ 9% p.a. for the medical expenses she incurred at Suretech Hospital. Reasoning, that as only a single act of negligence is proved, that too not attributable to all subsequent medical complications, it is only fair to announce compensation against the medical expenses incurred at Suretech Hospital. The NCDRC further directed that Rs. 50,000/- be paid to Mrs. Sunita as cost towards her litigation expenses.
PLEADINGS ASSAILING THE IMPUGNED NCDRC
JUDGMENT:
25. Assailing the NCDRC Judgment dated 16.02.2018, Mrs. Sunita filed Civil Appeal 4847 of 2018, seeking enhancement of Rs. 6,11,638/compensation. She also claimed a higher rate of interest at 18% instead of the awarded 9% interest p.a. The patient claims that though the NCDRC was correct in attributing medical negligence with respect to the unjustified forced ‘NI’ procedure, replacing the existing ‘TT’, the NCDRC erred in holding M.A BIVIJI v. SUNITA & ORS.
[HRISHIKESH ROY, J.] 126 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.
that there is no direct link attributable to the said act of negligence leading to subsequent prolonged medical complications, permanent respiratory damage, and voice-loss. Mrs. Sunita claims that the sole reason why she lost her voice and suffered from tracheal stenosis, is the forced ‘NI’. Though the Bronchoscopy report on 13.05.2004 indicated that she has a normal airway enabling normal breathing through the existing ‘TT’, the ‘NI’ was yet conducted forcefully, resulting in a tracheal injury. Furthermore, the ‘NI’ procedure was undertaken despite multiple failed attempts to decannulate the ‘TT’. Resultantly, the patient developed Frank Pus. She also further suffered from ‘Severe Septicemia’, directly attributing it to her tracheal injury. Moreover, Mrs. Sunita averred that Suretech Hospital’s discharge summary does not mention any details about the ‘NI’ procedure, indicating an attempt to hide the commission of the aforesaid negligent act.
26. On 30.01.2005, Dr. A.G. Pusalkar performed tracheoplasty on Mrs. Sunita, wherein, a 3.5cm Grade-IV subglottic stenotic segment was excised. As a result, she now has to live permanently with a shortened windpipe. It is further claimed that as per medical science, 95% subglotticstenosis cases are acquired, and out of those about 90% cases result from traumatic ‘NI’. Resultantly, it is claimed that she has to live with a life-long respiratory problem, with a danger of aspiration, causing a potential life-threatening situation like asphyxia. As a result, Mrs. Sunita claimed Rs. 75,00,000/- for the deformity of her respiratory tract, and another Rs. 75,00,000/- for losing her voice. She seeks another Rs. 5,00,000/- for permanent disfiguration of her neck. She further sought Rs. 50,00,000/- as compensation towards the mental and physical suffering she had to undergo due to her prolonged treatment. Rs. 15,00,000/- was sought for the impact her disability had on her husband. Rs. 25,00,000/- was claimed for the mental stress and agony caused to her husband. Rs. 20,00,000/- was claimed collectively for the suffering undergone by the patient’s children due to her disability.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.