Abhishek Sharma v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 924; [2023] 14 S.C.R. 890
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice 1860 – S. 302 – Evidence Act, Justice 1872 – Multiple Prosecution Case That Appellant and Victim Had A Quarrel, Justice Set Her On Fi Re – Victim Died – Victim Had Given Four Dying
- Decided
- 18 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1473/2011
- Sections
- 302, 32, 307, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 14 S.C.R. 890 : 2023 INSC 924
CASE DETAILS
ABHISHEK SHARMA
v.
STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
(Criminal Appeal No. 1473 of 2011)
OCTOBER 18, 2023
[ABHAY S. OKA AND SANJAY KAROL, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: The victim-deceased gave four dying declarations. High Court confirmed the appellant’s conviction and sentence of life imprisonment u/s. 302 IPC as awarded by the trial Court. Penal Code, 1860 – s. 302 – Evidence Act, 1872 – Multiple dying declarations – Prosecution case that appellant and victim had a quarrel, as the victim had affection for their boss and not for appellant – Appellant took victim to an open site near a school and in the midst of an argument, set her on fire – Victim died – Victim had given four dying declarations – Appellant convicted by the Courts below – Propriety: Held: The DD-I shows that it was recorded in the third person, as PW-16-ASI had reported incident – The statement before the court is that the operator came into ‘DO room’ and reported that PW-16 had found a girl burning, and it is to him that she stated that appellant, had done this to her – Had the statement of the deceased, as told to PW-16, been before the court as it is, the same could have been considered a dying declaration within the meaning of s.32 IEA – DD-II is, in fact, an entry in the Medico-Legal Inquiry Register made by PW-8-doctor – It is true that a dying declaration is not to be discarded on account of brevity, but it is equally true that it must contain the proximate cause of the deceased’s condition and the reason therefor – Here, it states the presence of burn injuries and says that the same was caused by appellant, which, arguably, is insufficient – There is no particular identification of the convict-appellant, nor is there a mention of the means through which the injuries were inflicted (petrol) – DD-III was made to PW-17-SI – Despite this being the third statement given, no attempt was made to have the same made before a doctor or magistrate, which, as a rule of prudence, lends support to the prosecution – It reflects from the record that at the time when the third statement was recorded, the deceased had been administered treatment for her injuries – However, it has not come forth as to the nature of treatment and what kind of medicines were given to her – In the absence of a positive statement by the medical team responsible for her treatment, it cannot be stated, with certainty, that the medicines administered had no effect of impairing the mental fitness of the deceased – Therefore, doubts surrounds DD-III – DD- IV is the statement of the deceased to her mother – When making the declaration, there is nothing on record to indicate a) further deterioration in condition and b) non-availability of a third party, such as a doctor before whom such a statement could be recorded – The lack of independent corroboration, particularly when the person making the statement is the mother of the deceased, the court cannot rule out, to a positive degree, the role played by a sense of loss and possibly even anger, to rely on such statement – Besides the alleged dying declarations, there is no evidence to point to the guilt of the convict-appellant – On perusal of the records, there are inconsistencies throughout – There are gaps unexplained in the prosecution case. [Paras 15, 16, 17, 19, 26] Dying Declaration – Multiple dying declarations – The Court to consider the following principles, when dealing with a case involving multiple dying declarations:
Held: 1. The primary requirement for all dying declarations is that they should be voluntary and reliable and that such statements should be in a fit state of mind; 2. All dying declarations should be consistent – In other words, inconsistencies between such statements should be ‘material’ for its credibility to be shaken; 3. When inconsistencies are found between various dying declarations, other evidence available on record may be considered for the purposes of corroboration of the contents of dying declarations; 4. The statement treated as a dying declaration must be interpreted in light of surrounding facts and circumstances; 5. Each declaration must be scrutinized on its own merits – The court has to examine upon which of the statements reliance can be placed in order for the case to proceed further; 6. When there ABHISHEK SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
892 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
are inconsistencies, the statement that has been recorded by a Magistrate or like higher officer can be relied on, subject to the indispensable qualities of truthfulness and being free of suspicion; 7. In the presence of inconsistencies, the medical fitness of the person making such declaration, at the relevant time, assumes importance along with other factors such as the possibility of tutoring by relatives, etc. [Para 9]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Kamla v. State of Punjab (1993) 1 SCC 1; State of Punjab v. Parveen Kumar (2005) 9 SCC 769: [2005] 9 SCC 769; Amol Singh v. State of M.P. (2008) 5 SCC 468: [2008] 8 SCR 956; Lakhan v. State of M.P (2010) 8 SCC 514: [2010] 9 SCR 705; Makhan Singh v. State of Haryana (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1019; Ashabai v. State of Maharashtra (2013) 2 SCC 224: [2013] 1 SCR 115; Jagbir Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2019) 8 SCC 779: [2019] 11 SCR 1137; Uttam v. State of Maharashtra (2022) 8 SCC 576 – relied on.
Sher Singh v. State of Punjab (2008) 4 SCC 265: [2008] 2 SCR 959; Chacko v. State of Kerala (2003) 1 SCC 112; P.V. Radhakrishna v. State of Karnataka (2003) 6 SCC 443: [2003] 1 Suppl. SCR 745; Surinder Kumar v. State of Haryana (2011) 10 SCC 173: [2011] 12 SCR 1205; Khushal Rao v. State of Bombay AIR 1958 SC 22: [1958] SCR 552; Hari Obula Reddy and others v. The State of Andhra Pradesh (1981) 3 SCC 675; Pulicherla Nagaraju alias Nagaraja Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2006) 11 SCC 444: [2006] 4 Suppl. SCR 633 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1473 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 31.05.2010 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRLA No.431 of 2009 Appearances:
Ms. Kamini Jaiswal, Anish Dhingra, Ms. Rani Mishra, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G., Ms. Kiran Suri, Ms. Sonia Mathur, Sr. Advs., Ms. Snidha Mehra, Ms. Rukhmini Bobde, Sanjay Kr. Tyagi, Adit Khorana, Shubranshu Padhi, Udai Khanna, Arun Kumar Yadav, Shreekant Neelappa Terdal, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SANJAY KAROL J.
1. This appeal impugns a judgment and order of conviction passed by the High Court of Delhi in Criminal Appeal No. 431 of 2009 dated 31 May 2010, confirming the Appellant- Abhishek Sharma’s sentence of life imprisonment under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 18601, as awarded by Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi, vide judgment dated 30 April 2009.
FACTS
2. The facts, as reflected in the judgments of the courts below, are: - 2.1 Abhishek Sharma2 and Mandeep Kaur3 were colleagues at M/s Sai Telecom at Saraswati Vihar, Delhi where the former was a customer care executive and the latter the team leader/operation manager. On the intervening night of 20th-21st September 2007, the deceased was found engulfed in flames near the Queen Mary School, Model Town, Delhi. Despite efforts to save her at two different hospitals, namely LNJP Hospital and Maharaja Agrasen Hospital, she passed away on 03 October 2007.
2.2 It is recorded that a friendship had developed between these two persons, and the convict-appellant would often drive her home after work, which would end at around midnight. Allegedly, due to a quarrel in regards to her affections being not for him but instead for their boss, he took her to an open site near a school and, in the midst of an argument, set her on fire.
1 For Short, IPC 2 Hereinafter referred to as “convict-appellant”
3 Hereinafter referred to as the “Deceased”
ABHISHEK SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
894 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
2.3 On the way to the hospital, the deceased told Anoop Singh (PW-16) that the convict-appellant had set her ablaze. SI Balwant Singh (PW-17), along with Constable Paramjit Singh, recorded her statement, based on which an FIR under Section 307 IPC, was registered. The convict-appellant was arrested on 21 September 2007. Upon completing the investigation, a challan was presented to the Trial Court for proceeding against him under Section 302 IPC on 06 February 2008.
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
3. In support of its case, the prosecution examined a total of 25 witnesses. Following is a tabular representation thereof:- Sr.
No.
FORMAL
WITNESSES
MATERIAL
WITNESSES
MEDICAL
WITNESSES
1. PW1- HC Rajiv Kumar a duty officer PW16- ASI Anoop Singh In charge PCR Van Commander 63 PW7- Dr. Lata Sr.
Resident prepared the death summary of the deceased
2. PW2- Ct. Dalbir Singh photographer PW15- Ct. Subodh Kumar has accompanied PW16 in the PCR Van PW8- Dr. S.N. Basna working as CMO in LNJP Hospital
3. PW4- SI Manohar La draftsman PW17- SI Balwant Singh he obtained the MLC of the injured PW12- Dr. K. Goyal conducted the postmortem of the deceased
4. PW9- Ct. Mukesh took sealed parcels to deposit the same at CFSI PW13- Ct. Paramjit Singh did the investigation, along with SI Balwant Singh PW18- Dr. Raj examined the deceased
5. PW10- HC Pramod Kumar posted at MHC(M)
PW5- Smt. Jasmer Kaur mother of the deceased PW19- Dr. Sanjay S.R.
Surgery examined the accused, Abhishek Sharma
6. PW11- HC Naresh Kumar accompanied SI Balwant Singh to Maharaja Agarsen Hospital PW6- Sh. Yashin Nagpal partner of M/S Sai Telecom, where the deceased and accused were working PW20- Dr. Geeta Ramakrisan Micro Biologist who examined the blood sample of the deceased
7. PW14- ASI Suresh Chand he went to the spot for an inspection PW3- Hemant Aneja brother-in-law of the deceased PW22- Dr. Ashish Sharma proved the MLC
8. PW21- Sh. K.K.
Sharma record clerk from Maharaja Agarsen Hospital PW24- Shri Pradeep Kumar Misra Junior Scientific Officer, CFSL, Calcutta, examined the blood and hair samples.
9. PW23- Inspector Harish Chander got the site plan prepared by SI;
recorded the statement of MHC(M);
PW25- Shri Bijayantra Mukhopadhyay Junior Scientific Officer, CFSL, Calcutta, examined the plastic bottle with burnt material.
4. Testimonies of PW18, PW8, and PW12 (Doctors) have established that the deceased died due to burn injuries, ante mortem in nature which facts further stand corroborated by PW16, PW17, PW5, and PW6. 4.1 The deceased gave four dying declarations. The First4 was given to a police officer PW16 i.e., the person who, in the 4 For ease, DD-I ABHISHEK SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
[SANJAY KAROL, J.] 896 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
PCR van, reached the spot of the crime and took the deceased to the LNJP Hospital. Even though the defense on the ground questioned the veracity of this declaration that PW15, who was with PW16 while the deceased was taken to the hospital, had not heard the statement being made, the Trial Court found the same to have been established since there was nothing to show that she had been tutored to state thus or that there was no possibility of her having made such a statement.
4.2 The second5 was given to Dr. Raj (PW-18), who had examined the deceased and prepared the MLC. She deposed that the deceased was fit to give a statement and that “by Abhishek”
was not written subsequently. PW8 corroborated her statement. The doctors’ testimonies remained unchallenged, and therefore, the defense’s attempts to term the testimonies as unreliable were not found to be correct by the Trial Court.
4.3 The third6 dying declaration was given to PW17, based on which the FIR was registered. The defense questioned this declaration on the ground that the police had obtained the signatures of the deceased on a blank paper, and the same was manipulated into an FIR. The argument of the defense that a doctor did not attest the same did not find favor with the court, which stated that as per “Sher Singh Vs State of Punjab”7, the endorsement of the doctor is only a matter of prudence.
The court held that the deceased had clearly shown the motive and intention of the convict-appellant to kill her.
4.4 The fourth8 dying declaration was given to PW 5 (mother of the deceased). In her deposition, examination-in-chief and cross-examination, it is clearly shown that the deceased was in a fit state of mind to give a statement. It has come forth that this statement was made on 22 September 2007, which was 5 For ease, DD-II 6 For ease, DD-III
7 (2008) 4 SCC 265
8 For ease, DD-IV much prior to the deterioration of her condition, because of which she was put on ventilator support six days before her death on 03 October 2007.
4.5 Consequent to the above discussion, the Trial Court found all four dying declarations to be consistent, voluntarily made, and in a fit mental condition. Further, concerning the testimonies of PW6, namely Yasin Nagpal, it is established that the deceased was last seen in the convict-appellant’s company when they left the office at around 12:30 AM. The convict-appellant’s statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,1973 stated that he left the office at 12:00 AM and the deceased was still in office.
4.6 The Court found that the statement of the convict-appellant was not credible, and the statement of PW6 was unblemished and unchallenged.
4.7 In view thereof, the convict-appellant was found guilty and convicted under Section 302, IPC.
FINDINGS OF THE HIGH COURT
5. It was observed that the homicidal nature of the death is undisputed. In respect of each of the dying declarations, the High Court agreed with the conclusions arrived at by the Trial Court and observed that the appeal was devoid of merits. The High Court’s reasoning per each such declaration is referred to below:- 5.1 DD-I given to PW16 was sought to be challenged on the ground that PW15 had not heard the statement being made. The court noted that in his cross-examination, PW15 had stated that the deceased “might have told the fact that convict-appellant was responsible for the incident”. It was further observed that the driver of such a vehicle, when is focused on taking a patient with serious injuries to the hospital with the siren blaring, it is no surprise that he did not hear what the deceased stated to PW16.
ABHISHEK SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
[SANJAY KAROL, J.] 898 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
5.2 DD-II was made to PW18, which, it has been observed, was entirely in tune with DD-I made to PW16. The concerned doctor has also deposed regarding the deceased’s fitness when making such a statement. The addition of “by Abhishek” was not found credible by the High Court as PW18 has denied the same, and no reason was found to disbelieve doctors.
5.3 DD-III was made at 3.30 AM to PW17. This statement also names the convict-appellant. It was observed that between 1.40 AM and 3.30 AM, three consecutive statements were given by the deceased, and the time from when she was found in a burnt condition to the registration of an FIR is barely two hours.
5.4 DD-IV was sought to be discredited on the ground that PW5 was an interested witness. This argument has been termed “hardly any argument,” and therefore, in view of the High Court, DD-IV also stood proven.
6. An additional ground taken before the High Court was that a person with 25 % burn injuries could not have given detailed statements. This was disregarded by the court, considering that a doctor had specifically deposed to her fit mental condition. Additionally, the submission in respect of Chapter 13 of Punjab and Haryana High Court Rules, which prescribe the procedure for recording of dying declarations, was held not to be of any aid to the convict-appellant as it was observed that simply because the rules were not complied with, the dying declarations could not be discarded if they had withstood strict scrutiny after applying all cautions.
7. For the aforesaid reasons, the judgment of the Additional Sessions Judge, Tis Hazari, West Delhi, was affirmed.
OUR VIEW
8. Before proceeding to the merits of this matter, it would be appropriate to appreciate the various principles of law laid down by this court in regard to cases involving multiple dying declarations.
8.1 This Court in Kamla v. State of Punjab9 has held:
“5. It is well settled that dying declaration can form the sole basis of conviction provided that it is free from infirmities and satisfies various tests (vide Khushal Rao v. State of Bombay [AIR 1958 SC 22 : 1958 SCR 552 : 1958 Cri LJ 106] ). The ratio laid down in this case has been referred to in a number of subsequent cases with approval. It is also settled in all those cases that the statement should be consistent throughout if the deceased had several opportunities of making such dying declarations, that is to say, if there are more than one dying declaration, they should be consistent. If a dying declaration is found to be voluntary, reliable and made in fit mental condition, it can be relied upon without even any corroboration. In a case where there are more than one dying declaration if some inconsistencies are noticed between one and the other, the court has to examine the nature of the inconsistencies namely whether they are material or not. In scrutinising the contents of various dying declarations, in such a situation, the court has to examine the same in the light of the various surrounding facts and circumstances.”
8.2. In State of Punjab v. Parveen Kumar10, this court further observed:
“10. …. The court must be satisfied that the dying declaration is truthful. If there are two dying declarations giving two different versions, a serious doubt is created about the truthfulness of the dying declarations. It may be that if there was any other reliable evidence on record, this court could have considered such corroborative evidence to test the truthfulness of the dying declarations...”
9 (1993) 1 SCC 1(2-Judge Bench)
10 (2005) 9 SCC 769 (2-Judge Bench)
ABHISHEK SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
[SANJAY KAROL, J.] 900 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
8.3. In Amol Singh v. State of M.P.11, “13. … However, if some inconsistencies are noticed between one dying declaration and the other, the court has to examine the nature of the inconsistencies, namely, whether they are material or not. While scrutinising the contents of various dying declarations, in such a situation, the court has to examine the same in the light of the various surrounding facts and circumstances.”
8.4. Faced with multiple dying declarations, this Court in Lakhan v. State of M.P12 observed- “21. … In case there are multiple dying declarations and there are inconsistencies between them, generally, the dying declaration recorded by the higher officer like a Magistrate can be relied upon, provided that there is no circumstance giving rise to any suspicion about its truthfulness. In case there are circumstances wherein the declaration had been made, not voluntarily and even otherwise, it is not supported by the other evidence, the court has to scrutinise the facts of an individual case very carefully and take a decision as to which of the declarations is worth reliance.”
This judgment was also referred to by this court recently in Makhan Singh v. State of Haryana13.
8.5. In Ashabai v. State of Maharashtra,14 the court observed:- “15. When there are multiple dying declarations, each dying declaration has to be separately assessed and evaluated and assessed independently on its own merit as to its evidentiary value and one cannot be rejected because of certain variations in the other.”
11 (2008) 5 SCC 468 ( 2-Judge Bench)
12 (2010) 8 SCC 514 (2-Judge Bench)
13 (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1019 (2-Judge Bench)
14 (2013) 2 SCC 224 (2-Judge Bench)
8.6. In Jagbir Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi),15 the following principles were observed:
31. A survey of the decisions would show that the principles of declarations can be culled out as follows:
….
31.6. However, there may be cases where there are more than one dying declaration. If there are more than one dying declaration, the dying declarations may entirely agree with one another. There may be dying declarations where inconsistencies between the declarations emerge.
The extent of the inconsistencies would then have to be considered by the court. The inconsistencies may turn out to be reconcilable.
31.7. In such cases, where the inconsistencies go to some matter of detail or description but is incriminatory in nature as far as the Accused is concerned, the court would look to the material on record to conclude as to which dying declaration is to be relied on unless it be shown that they are unreliable;
31.8. The third category of cases is that where there are more than one dying declaration and inconsistencies between the declarations are absolute and the dying declarations are irreconcilable being repugnant to one another. In a dying declaration, the Accused may not be blamed at all and the cause of death may be placed at the doorstep of an unfortunate accident. This may be followed up by another dying declaration which is diametrically opposed to the first dying declaration. In fact, in that scenario, it may not be a question of an inconsistent dying declaration buta dying declaration which is completely opposed to the dying declaration which is given earlier. There may be more than two.”
15 (2019) 8 SCC 779 (2-Judge Bench)
ABHISHEK SHARMA v. STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
[SANJAY KAROL, J.] 902 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
8.7. In Uttam v. State of Maharashtra,16 this court observed: “15. In cases involving multiple dying declarations made by the deceased, the question that arises for consideration is as to which of the said dying declarations ought to be believed by the court and what would be the guiding factors for arriving at a just and lawful conclusion. The problem becomes all the more knotty when the dying declarations made by the deceased are found to be contradictory. Faced with such a situation, the court would be expected to carefully scrutinise the evidence to find out as to which of the dying declarations can be corroborated by other material evidence produced by the prosecution. Of equal significance is the condition of the deceased at the relevant point in time, the medical evidence brought on record that would indicate the physical and mental fitness of the deceased, the scope of the close relatives/family members having influenced/tutored the deceased and all the other attendant circumstances that would help the court in exercise of its discretion.”
9. Having considered various pronouncements of this court, the following principles emerge, for a Court to consider when dealing with a case involving multiple dying declarations:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.