Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited v. Ratnagiri Gas and Power Private Limited & Ors
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 993; [2023] 14 S.C.R. 761
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala
- Decided
- 9 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1922/2023
- Sections
- 79
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 14 S.C.R. 761 : 2023 INSC 993
CASE DETAILS
MAHARASHTRA STATE ELECTRICITY DISTRIBUTION
COMPANY LIMITED
v.
RATNAGIRI GAS AND POWER PRIVATE LIMITED & ORS
(Civil Appeal No. 1922 of 2023)
NOVEMBER 09, 2023.
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI , JB PARDIWALA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission-CERC and Appellate Tribunal for Electricity-APTEL were justified in affixing liability to pay fixed charges on the appellant. Electricity Act, 2003 – s. 79 – Payment of fixed capacity charges – Fixation of liability – Power Purchase Agreement between the appellant and first respondent whereby the appellant would purchase power from the first respondent – First respondent was supposed to receive the contracted quantity of gas supply from RIL, however after there was a decline in the supply – In order to make up for the shortfall, the first respondent entered into a Gas Supply Agreement-GSA with GAIL for the supply of Recycled Liquid Natural Gas, and conveyed the same to the appellant and requested the appellant to schedule its energy requirements – Appellant refused to schedule power at the rates stipulated and stated that it stood absolved of the liability to pay capacity charges in accordance with the PPA – Petition u/s. 79 by the first respondent for non-payment of fixed charges – CERC held the appellant liable to pay fixed capacity charges under the PPA – APTEL upheld the order – Correctness:
Held: Commercial document cannot be interpreted in a manner that is at odds with the original purpose and intendment of the parties to the document – Deviation from the plain terms of the contract is warranted 762 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
only when it serves business efficacy better – According to the principles governing the interpretation of contracts, the PPA is required to be read as a whole – Primary fuels include LNG/Natural gas and/or RLNG, and the appellant’s agreement is required in case liquid fuels are to be employed – A bare reading of the clause indicates that the requirement to seek such an agreement does not attach to the first part of the clause which envisages RLNG as a primary fuel – An arrangement involving a transition from one primary fuel to another primary fuel is permissible by the clause, even without the appellant’s agreement – Requirement of an agreement, mandated for an arrangement involving liquid fuel cannot be read into the plain text of the former part of Clause 4.3 – Capacity declaration based on RLNG could be done unilaterally, unencumbered by the requirement of the appellant’s consent in the latter half or the prior approval requirement under Clause 5.9 of the PPA – Thus, the CERC and APTEL correctly held that the GSA/GTA with GAIL is permissible by the terms of the contract and the consent or approval of the appellant is irrelevant. [Para 28-29, 32, 35-36]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Ltd v. GMR Vemagiri Power Generation Limited (2018) 3 SCC 716 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.1922 of 2023. From the Judgment and Order dated 22.04.2015 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi in AN No.261 of 2013.
Appearances:
Vikas Singh, Sr. Adv., Samir Malik, Ms. Nikita Choukse, Akash Lamba, Krishan Kumar, M/s. D.S.K. Legal, Advs. for the Appellant. C. Aryaman Sundaram, Sr. Adv., Mrs. Swapna Sheshadri, Anand K Ganesan, Nitin Saluja, Ms. Ritu Apurva, Ms. Archita Kashyap, Advs. for the Respondents.
763MSEDCL. v. RATNAGIRI GAS AND POWER PVT. LTD.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI
Contents Factual Background .......................................................................4* CERC Order dated 30 July 2023 and APTEL Judgement and Final Order dated 22 April 2015..............................................................6* Submissions....................................................................................9* Analysis and Conclusion ..............................................................13* Terms of the PPA .................................................................13* Factual Context and the Intention of parties to the contract 17*
1. This appeal arises from the judgment of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity1 at New Delhi. APTEL dismissed an appeal against an order of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission2 dated 30 July 2013.3
2. The first respondent, an electricity transmission company called Ratnagiri Gas And Power Private Limited4, filed a petition under Section 79 of the Electricity Act, 2003 against the appellant, Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Co. Ltd.5, seeking the resolution of issues arising out of the non-availability of domestic gas; beneficiaries’ reservations to allow the first respondent to enter into contracts for alternate fuel, the revision of the Normative Annual Plant Availability Factor6 and directions to the beneficiaries to pay fixed charges due to the first respondent.
3. CERC, by its order dated 30 July 2013 held the appellant liable to pay fixed charges to the first respondent. CERC’s decision was upheld by * Ed Note: Pagination is as per the original judgment.
1 “APTEL”.
2 “CERC”.
3 Appeal No. 261 of 2013 4 “RGPPL”/first respondent.
5 “MSEDCL”/appellant.
6 “NAPAF”.
764 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
APTEL by the impugned order. The civil appeal against the APTEL order was disposed of by this Court by an order dated 13 May 2015, whereby the appellant was granted liberty to move the court when it became necessary. This Court directed as follows:
“The question raised in the present appeal before this Court at this stage appears to be academic in the absence of any coercive steps against the appellant for recovery. We, therefore, decline to entertain this appeal at this stage. However, we give liberty to the appellant to move this Court once again in the event it becomes so necessary.”
4. Consequently, there was correspondence between the appellant and the first respondent regarding the liability towards fixed charges. The appellant disclaimed any liability under the Power Purchase Agreement7 stating that it stood absolved of the fixed charges since the capacity declaration was made by the first respondent based on RLNG, without the appellant’s consent. The first respondent filed an execution petition before APTEL seeking the payment of Rs 5287.76 crores together with an amount of Rs 1826 crores in accordance with the APTEL order dated 22 May 2013. Notice was issued on the execution petition by an order dated 25 November 2022.
5. Thus, in light of the subsequent events and the liberty granted by this Court, the present appeal has been filed.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
6. The first respondent, RGPPL is a joint venture of NTPC Ltd., Gas Authority of India Ltd8, MSEB Holding Company, ICICI, IDBI, SBI, and Canara Bank. It was established as a Special Purpose Vehicle to take over the assets of Dabhol Power Company Limited whose operations had to be closed down. The first respondent is a transmission company that owns a gas-based generating station at Ratnagiri, Maharashtra. 95% of its capacity has been allocated by the Ministry of Power to the State of Maharashtra and the rest to the State of Goa, and UTs of Daman and Diu, and Dadra and Nagar Haveli. The share allocated to the State of Maharashtra is supplied 7 “PPA”.
8 “GAIL”
765MSEDCL. v. RATNAGIRI GAS AND POWER PVT. LTD.
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI] to the distribution licensee MSEDCL, the appellant. The appellant and the first respondent entered into a Power Purchase Agreement on 10 April 2007 for 25 years whereby the appellant would purchase power from the first respondent. The tariffs for the three blocks of the generating station were determined by CERC in accordance with the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2004 having regard to the capital cost and plant capacity of the generating station.
7. The first respondent was supposed to receive the contracted quantity of gas supply from RIL. It is stated on behalf of the first respondent that the supply was received accordingly until September 2011, after which, there was a progressive decline in the gas supply. The shortfall was attributed to the low-yielding KG-D6 gas fields. The issue of short supply was taken up with the Central Government and was placed before the Empowered Group of Ministers in its meeting held on 24 December 2012.
8. On account of the steady decline in the supply of domestic gas since September 2011, and in order to make up for the shortfall in the generation of power during 2011-2012, the first respondent entered into a Gas Supply Agreement/Gas Transportation Agreement9 with GAIL for the supply of Recycled Liquid Natural Gas10 under spot cargo on a take-and-pay-contract basis. The first respondent conveyed this to the appellant by a letter dated 16 December 2011. In this letter, the first respondent stated that due to the shortfall in the supply of domestic gas, the first respondent was unable to achieve the target availability stipulated in the tariff order. According to the first respondent, this, in turn, was impacting their ability to make full fixed cost recovery and hampering the viability of the project. The appellant was requested to schedule its energy requirements accordingly based on capacity declarations made by the first respondent.
9. The appellant refused to schedule power at the rates stipulated in the above letter. The appellant stated that in accordance with Clause 5.9 of the PPA, the first respondent failed to obtain the appellant’s approval before entering into the GSA/GTA with GAIL. As such, the declaration of capacity on RLNG was stated to be unilateral and arbitrary and in violation 9 “GSA”/”GTA”.
10 “RLNG”
766 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
of the terms of Clause 5.9 of the PPA which mandated prior approval from the appellant. Therefore, the appellant stated, that it stood absolved of the liability to pay capacity charges in accordance with the PPA. Letters were exchanged between the appellant and the first respondent from 17 December 2011 to 01 March 2012.
10. In order to resolve the above issue of non-payment of fixed charges, the first respondent filed a petition under Section 79 of the Electricity Act 2003 seeking the resolution of the issue of shortfall of domestic gas, the reservations of the beneficiaries to allow it to enter into alternate contractual arrangements for fuel i.e. RLNG. The petition additionally sought the revision of the NAPAF and directions to the beneficiaries to pay outstanding fixed charges.
C E R C O R D E R D AT E D 30 J U LY 2023 A N D A P T E L
JUDGEMENT AND FINAL ORDER DATED 22 APRIL 2015.
11. CERC allowed the above petition and held the appellant liable to pay fixed capacity charges under the PPA. It held that (i) Clause 4.3 of the PPA permits the use of LNG/Natural gas or RLNG as a ‘primary fuel’; (ii) the first respondent is permitted to use even liquid gas, albeit with the consent of the appellant; (iii) the terms of the PPA do not injunct the first respondent from declaring capacity based on RLNG; (iv) the beneficiaries have the option to dispatch or refuse to dispatch the capacity on natural gas, RLNG, or liquid fuel; (v) in the event they choose to refuse the dispatch, they cannot repudiate the liability to pay fixed charges citing the transmission company’s failure to obtain approval; (vi) such consent or approval is not necessary for declaring capacity based on the contractually designated primary fuels, including RLNG; (vii) the requirement of seeking the appellant’s approval under Clause 5.9 is not a mandatory pre-requisite for making capacity declarations under Clause 4.3; (viii) the fixed tariffs are payable on declared capacity; (ix) since the first respondent was unable to obtain domestic gas due to a country-wide shortage, they made arrangements for RLNG; (x) the appellant’s decision to not schedule the supply based on RLNG has a bearing on variable charges and not on the fixed charges; and (xi) the appellant was thus liable to pay the fixed charges based on capacity declarations made on RLNG by the first respondent.
767MSEDCL. v. RATNAGIRI GAS AND POWER PVT. LTD.
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI]
12. APTEL upheld the above order in the following terms:
a. The need to obtain the consent of the distribution licensee arises only when the power generation company makes arrangements based on liquid gas. In the present case, the only change in question is being made from one primary fuel to another primary fuel i.e. from natural gas to RLNG. Both of these are “primary fuel for RGPPL” in accordance with Article 4.3 of the PPA. This change, unlike the change from primary fuel sources to liquid gas, does not require the consent of the distribution company; b. The PPA did not require the power generation company to obtain the consent of the distribution licensee for entering into the GSA/ GTA with GAIL. The plant was set up after significant efforts from the central and state governments. The first respondent was left with no choice but to enter into the GSA/GTA with GAIL in order to overcome the domestic gas shortage. The appellant had refused to schedule power for the declared availability based on RLNG to be supplied under the GSA/GTA;
c. The first respondent has declared the necessary availability of electricity when the appellant has chosen not to schedule the quantum of electricity on the declared availability. As long as the first respondent has the declared available capacity and irrespective of whether the appellant has scheduled the capacity offered by the first respondent, the appellant is liable to pay the fixed capacity charges; and d. The first respondent has invested in establishing, operating, and maintaining the generating station. The annual fixed charges are determined with reference to specific tariff requirements stemming from the Tariff Regulations of 2009. The capital costs invested in the station need to be serviced by way of the annual fixed charges.
Thus, APTEL directed that if the appellant wishes to not pay for the electricity from RLNG, it must pay compensation to the first respondent, since it is liable, under Article 5.2 of the PPA, to pay the capacity charges. No prior consent, as envisaged in Article 5.9, is required, in order for such liability to arise.
768 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
13. APTEL thus held that the appellant has been rightly ordered to pay the capacity charges notwithstanding the fact that they have not consented to the GSA/GTA with GAIL. The appeal was thus dismissed.
14. The Civil Appeal against APTEL’s decision was initially disposed of by this Court. Since the appellant was not facing any punitive action for recovery, the appeal was dismissed and the appellant was granted the liberty to approach the Court when necessary.
15. In view of the above liberty, the present appeal is before us.
16. Following the issue of notice, the first respondent has entered appearance and filed a counter affidavit.
17. We have heard Senior Counsel for the appellants and respondents.
SUBMISSIONS
18. The appellant urged the following submissions in its challenge to APTEL’s judgment and final order:
a. CERC has put Clause 4.3 and Clause 5.9 of the PPA in two separate buckets. According to the PPA (clauses 4.3, and 5.9 read conjointly), the first respondent was obligated to obtain prior approval from the appellant before entering into the GSA/GTA with GAIL. Failing this requirement, the first respondent has absolved the appellant of the obligation to pay for the declared capacity to the extent that such declared capacity is attributable to the RLNG which though, a primary source of fuel, could have been obtained by the first respondent only after prior consent of the appellant;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.