Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 697; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2062
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 15 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6847/2025
- Sections
- 79(1), 178, 79, 111, 38, 125, 62, 61, 64, 3, 127, 14
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2062 : 2025 INSC 697 Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v.
Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 6847 of 2025)
15 May 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(i) Whether the CERC, while exercising its functions u/s.79(1) of the Electricity Act, 2003, is circumscribed by statutory regulations enacted u/s.178 of the Act, 2003; (ii) Whether the CERC exercises regulatory or adjudicatory functions u/s.79 of the Act, 2003. In other words, what is the scope of the CERC’s power to regulate inter-state transmission of electricity and determine tariff for the same under clauses (c) and (d) of s.79(1); (iii) Whether the grant of compensation by the CERC for the delay vide the orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively, is a regulatory or adjudicatory function and to what extent are the principles of natural justice applicable to the exercise of such functions;
(iv) Whether the High Court was justified in admitting the writ petition filed by the respondent no. 1 herein challenging the order dated 21.01.2020 of the CERC when there existed an alternative remedy u/s.111 of the Act, 2003.
Headnotes† Electricity Act, 2003 – ss.79, 178 – Relationship between ss.79 and 178 of the Act, 2003:
Held: A perusal of the provisions laying down the functions of the CERC indicates that the statutory authority is enjoined with the task of regulation as well as adjudication of several aspects of the generation, transmission and distribution of electricity – S.79 of the Act, 2003 enumerates the functions of the CERC which includes the dual functions of regulation and adjudication – S.178, on the other hand, empowers the CERC to enact regulations by notification thereby delegating to the body, the power of legislating statutory regulations under the Act, 2003 – The aforesaid two provisions * Author [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2063Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
indicate that the CERC functions as both, decision-making and regulation-making authority u/ss.79 and 178 respectively – However, while the authority exercising both these functions is one and the same, it is a settled position of law that the functions by themselves are separate and distinct – The functions u/s.79 are administrative or adjudicatory whereas those u/s.178 are legislative – A regulation u/s.178 is of general application to the entirety of a particular subject matter as opposed to regulation on a case-to-case basis which may be done by the CERC u/s.79 – Therefore, making of a regulation u/s.178 has the effect of interfering with and overriding existing contractual relationships between the regulated entities – On the other hand, the orders u/s.79 have to be confined to the existing statutory regulations and do not have the effect of altering the terms of contract between the specific parties before the CERC. [Paras 37, 38, 40] Electricity Act, 2003 – ss.79, 178 – The CERC vide its orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively imposed the liability of payment of compensation for delay onto the respondent no. 1 – Correctness:
Held: It is the case of the respondent no. 1 that by doing so, the CERC did not act in conformity with the 2014 Tariff Regulations which do not provide for payment of transmission charges by a party to whom the delay is attributable – In considered view of this Court, the said argument does not hold any water – This Court’s dictum in PTC and Energy Watchdog respectively settles the law in this regard and the absence of a regulation u/s.178 does not preclude the CERC from exercising its powers u/s.79(1) to make specific regulations or pass orders between the parties before it.[Para 43] Electricity Act, 2003 – s.79 – Regulatory and adjudicatory functions of the CERC:
Held: The regulatory powers provided to the CERC u/s.79 are of ad hoc nature and are required to be exercised by the CERC in context of the specific circumstances of the parties before it – The rationale for provision of such ad hoc powers by the Act, 2003 is to ensure that regulatory gaps, if any, that may be discovered on a case-to-case basis, are filled or removed – Therefore, there is no doubt that the CERC is enabled to exercise its regulatory powers by way of orders u/s. 79 and the purview of s.79 is not limited to 2064 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports only adjudicatory orders but includes within its scope administrative functions as well. [Para 48] Electricity Act, 2003 – Whether the grant of compensation by the CERC was a decision taken by the authority in its regulatory or adjudicatory capacity and whether it goes a step beyond the function of determination of tariff:
Held: A reading of the Act, 2003 would indicate that it makes no distinction between the regulatory and adjudicatory functions vested in and conferred upon the CERC, which is a quasi-judicial body enjoined to regulate and administer the subject of electricity generation, transmission and distribution – In such a situation, it becomes necessary to undertake a harmonious reading of ss.61 and 79 respectively to determine whether the CERC granted the liberty to claim compensation in exercise of its regulatory or adjudicatory function – The CERC granted liberty to the appellant herein to claim compensation from the respondent no. 1 to deal with a situation caused due to an unprecedented event not covered by any guidelines, regulations or contractual provisions between the parties – The dictum of this Court in Energy Watchdog, indicates that in such a situation where there is an absence of regulations and guidelines, the Act, 2003 mandates the CERC to strike a judicious balance between the parties keeping in mind commercial principles and consumers’ interest, in exercise of its general regulatory powers u/s.79(1) – The aforesaid leaves no manner of doubt that though the CERC’s orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively were for determination of tariff, yet the order granting liberty to the aggrieved appellant to claim compensation from the defaulting party is a consequence of a regulatory lacuna in the 2014 Tariff Regulations and therefore, is an instance of regulation of tariff between the parties. [Paras 53, 59, 60] Electricity Act, 2003 – Whether there was a contravention of the principles of natural justice by the CERC:
Held: The CERC was not adjudicating the issue of delay between the parties but was only regulating the consequences of the delay to the commissioning of the transmission elements – There was also no occasion for the respondent no. 1 to be afforded an opportunity to be heard at that stage – In considered view of this Court, any dispute pertaining to the levy of transmission charges incurred before the concerned transmission assets were put to use, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2065Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
would arise only upon the appellant raising bills to the respondent no. 1 in this regard – In such a scenario, it cannot be said that there was a contravention of the principles of natural justice by the CERC. [Para 61] Electricity Act, 2003 – Whether the CERC is empowered to order for imposition of transmission charges on the party to whom delay is attributable.
Held: The CERC is empowered to order for imposition of transmission charges on the party to whom delay is attributable – This Court has, however, have not considered the question whether such liability of payment of transmission charges could be imposed on the respondent no. 1 in the specific facts of the case on hand – This Court is of the opinion that APTEL is the appropriate authority to look into the merits of the matter should the respondent no. 1 choose to prefer an appeal before APTEL u/s.111 of the Act, 2003. [Para 66] Electricity Act, 2003 – Writ Petition – Maintainability of a writ petition before the High Court in the presence of the alternative remedy – Conditions of:
Held: This Court’s dictum in Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trademarks wherein it has been held that despite the availability of an alternative remedy, a writ petition can be entertained in the following cases: a) Where principles of natural justice are breached; b) Where fundamental rights are sought to be enforced or breach thereof is complained of; c) Where the impugned order is passed by an authority without jurisdiction; d) Where the constitutionality of any provision is called in question – However, this Court’s observations in Whirlpool are of no avail to the respondent no. 1 as the present matter falls in none of the cases enumerated therein – Therefore, there was no occasion for the High Court to admit the writ petition of the respondent no. 1. [Paras 11, 64] Case Law Cited PTC India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission [2010] 3 SCR 609 : (2010) 4 SCC 603; Airports Economic Regulatory Authority of India v. Delhi International Airport Ltd. [2024] 10 SCR 1404 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2923; Energy Watchdog v. CERC [2017] 3 SCR 153 : (2017) 14 SCC 80 – relied on.
2066 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trademarks [1998] Supp. 2 SCR 359 : (1998) 8 SCC 1: Power Grid Corpn. of India Ltd. v. Punjab State Power Corpn. Ltd. [2016] 2 SCR 116 : (2016) 4 SCC 797; Sitaram Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Union of India [1990] 1 SCR 909 : (1990) 3 SCC 223 – referred to.
Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors., 2019 SCC OnLine APTEL 83 – referred to.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003; Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014.
List of Keywords Section 79 of the Electricity Act, 2003; Section 178 of the Electricity Act, 2003; Determination of tariff; Regulatory and adjudicatory functions; Tariff Regulations; Commercial Operation Date; Compensatory transmission charges; Principles of natural justice; Alternative remedy; Inter-state transmission; Intra-state transmission; Time-overrun/Delay; Quasi-judicial body; Delegated legislation; Ad hoc power.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6847 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.02.2021 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Indore in WP No. 10845 of 2020 With Civil Appeal No. 6848 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
M.G. Ramachandran, Sr. Adv., Shubham Arya, Ms. Poorva Saigal, Pramod Dayal, Nikunj Dayal, Ms. Reeha Singh, Ms. Pallavi Saigal, Ms. Shirin Gupta, Aneesh Bajaj, Ms. Srishti Khindaria. Advs. for the Respondents:
Prashant Singh. A.G. (MP), Amit Seth, Arjun Garg, Ms. Kriti Gupta, Ms. Sagun Srivastava, Brahma Prakash Soni, Anup Jain, Udit [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2067Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
Gupta, Vyom Chaturvedi, Ms. Pragya Gupta, Amrnath Sahoo, Ms. Nishtha Goel, Ms. Deep Shikha Kumar (for M/s. Udit Kishan And Associates), Shirish K. Deshpande, Ms. Rucha Pravin Mandlik, Mohit Gautam, Apoorv Sharma, Sudhanshu S. Choudhari.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts:
INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ............................................................. 2 B. IMPUGNED ORDER ........................................................... 8
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT ........ 12
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS ... 16
E. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION ........................................ 20 F. ANALYSIS ........................................................................... 21 i. Relevant Provisions of the Act, 2003 ........................ 21 ii. Relationship between Sections 79 and 178 of the Act, 2003 respectively ................................................. iii. Regulatory and adjudicatory functions of the CERC under Section 79 ......................................................... iv. Grant of compensation for delay on the part of a party is a regulatory function ..................................... G. CONCLUSION ...................................................................... 55 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
2068 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
1. Leave granted.
2. Since the issues raised in both the captioned appeals are the same, those were taken up for hearing analogously and are being disposed by this common judgment and order.
3. These appeals arise from the Judgment and Order passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Indore Bench dated 25.02.2021, in Writ Petition No. 10845 of 2020 and Writ Petition No. 9136 of 2020 respectively, by which the High Court admitted the writ petitions filed by the Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited (“MPPTCL”) on the ground that the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (the “CERC”) had exercised powers beyond those vested in it as per the regulations under the Electricity Act, 2003 (the “Act, 2003”) in passing the orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 in Petition No. 311/TT/2018 and Petition No. 266/TT/2018 respectively.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
4. The appellant herein is a Government of India Undertaking constituted for the purpose of undertaking inter-state transmission of electricity. In other words, the scope of work of the appellant includes inter alia, establishing and operating transmission lines, sub-stations and other transmission assets associated with inter-State transmission of power. These include ‘bays’ and inter-connecting ‘transformers’ at sub-stations to provide inter-connection facilities. By virtue of being a central transmission utility, the appellant is a deemed transmission licensee in terms of Section 38 of the Act, 2003. The respondent no. 1 herein is the State Transmission Utility and intra-state transmission licensee in the State of Madhya Pradesh.
5. The case on hand pertains to a dispute between the appellant and respondent no. 1 in respect of the implementation of the “Western Region System Strengthening Scheme XIV (WRSS-XIV) and Western Region Strengthening Scheme XVI (WRSS-XVI)” respectively by the appellant. The transmission assets were implemented by the appellant at the Indore sub-station upon the specific request of the respondent no. 1. In this regard, the parties planned and approved the WRSS-XIV in its 37th Standing Committee Meeting on Power System Planning of Western Region held on 05.09.2014 and WRSS- XVI in the 38th Standing Committee Meeting for the Western Region on 17.07.2015.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2069Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
6. According to the agreement between the parties, the respondent no. 1 was required to construct and commission the intra-state transmission line from Indore sub-station coinciding with the timeline of completion of works which were within the scope of the appellant. However, the construction and commissioning of the intra-state transmission line by respondent no. 1 was delayed. Such delay constrained the appellant to file Petition No. 311/TT/2018 and Petition No. 266/TT/2018 corresponding to WRSS-XIV and WRSS-XVI respectively, before the CERC for (i) approval of the Commercial Operation Date (the “COD”) of its transmission system, under Regulation 4(3) of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014 (the “2014 Tariff Regulations”), and (ii) determination of transmission charges and billing of the tariff for the transmission facilities established by it at the Indore sub-station.
7. The CERC vide its order dated 21.01.2020, observed, inter alia, that as per the investment approval accorded to the transmission scheme on 27.01.2016, the assets were scheduled to be commissioned within 30 months from the date of investment approval. Accordingly, the scheduled COD came to be 27.07.2018. However, the commissioning of such assets was delayed thereby compelling the appellant to file a petition for approval of COD under Regulation 4(3) of the 2014 Tariff Regulations. The details of the transmission assets are as follow:
Asset Description Scheduled
COD
Proposed
COD
as per Regulation 4(3)(ii)
Date of active power flow Timeoverrun/ Delay Asset-1 1 x 500 MVA, 400/220 kV ICT-2 along with associated transformer bays and 2 no.
220kV line bays at 400/220 kV Indore substation.
27.07.2018 02.09.2018 10.12.2018 37 days 2070 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Asset-2 2 no. 220 kV line bays at 400/220 kV Indore substation.
27.07.2018 02.09.2018 12.12.2018 37 days Asset-3 1 x 500 MVA, 400/220 kV ICT-1 along with associated transformer bays at 400/220 kV Indore substation.
27.07.2018 14.10.2018 10.12.2018 79 days Asset-4 1 no. 220 kV line bays at 400/220 kV Indore substation.
27.07.2018 14.10.2018 - 79 days Asset-5 1 no. 220 kV line bay at 400/220 kV Indore substation.
27.07.2018 05.12.2018 - 131 days
8. As regards the specific issue of time-overrun, the order dated 21.01.2020 passed by the CERC noted that the appellant herein had attributed the entire time-overrun in case of the instant assets to the respondent no. 1 who delayed the commissioning of the downstream intra-state assets that were supposed to be operational at the same time as the transmission assets to be commissioned by the appellant. Even though the CERC approved the COD proposed by the appellant under Regulation 4(3)(ii), yet it did not condone the time-overrun on account of matching the commissioning of the inter-state transmission assets in question with the downstream network of respondent no. 1, on the ground that it was the decision of the appellant to coordinate and match the commissioning dates of both categories of assets. However, the CERC allowed the appellant to claim compensation for the period prior to the COD as determined under Regulation 4(3)(ii), by way of liquidated damages, interest during construction and incidental expenses incurred during construction. It was held that the transmission charges in case of all the assets as enumerated above would be borne by the respondent no. 1 from the COD determined under Regulation 4(3)(ii) upto one day before actual charging of downstream system. It is pertinent to [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2071Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
note that the CERC did not allow compensation from the Scheduled COD upto the newly determined COD as the delay in that case was not condoned.
9. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order of the CERC, the respondent no. 1 challenged the same by way of a writ petition before the High Court on the following grounds:
(i) There is no provision in the 2014 Tariff Regulations under which compensatory transmission charges could be levied on the respondent no. 1 by the CERC and therefore, the CERC fell into grave jurisdictional error by holding that the appellant could claim compensation from the respondent no. 1.
(ii) Further, the agreement between the parties was recorded in the minutes of the 37 th and 38 th meetings of the Standing Committee held on 05.09.2014 and 17.07.2015 respectively. Such agreement contains no terms and conditions as regards the recovery of compensation from the respondent no. 1. Therefore, the CERC, by granting liberty to the appellant to claim compensation from the respondent no. 1 has effectively re-written the terms and conditions of the agreement between the parties.
(iii) The bill dated 08.06.2020 raised by the appellant for the payment of Rs. 6.18 crore, in consequence of the order of the CERC dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively, is illegal and not in accordance with either the 2014 Tariff Regulations or the terms of agreement between the parties.
10. On the other hand, the appellant claimed before the High Court that the issue raised by the respondent no. 1 by way of the writ petition was not that the CERC did not have jurisdiction at all. The challenge was to the exercise of jurisdiction by the CERC which was not permissible in light of the alternative remedy available to the respondent no. 1 in terms of Section 111 of the Act, 2003.
B. IMPUGNED ORDER
11. The High Court vide its judgment and order dated 25.02.2021, recorded the following submissions of the respondent no. 1: i. The respondent no. 1 herein relied on this Court’s decision in PTC India Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory 2072 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Commission reported in (2010) 4 SCC 603 to submit that the decision of the CERC must be in conformity with the Regulations enacted under Section 178 of the Act, 2003 wherever such regulations are applicable. Therefore, the measures taken by the CERC under Section 79(1) are required to be in conformity with the Regulations under Section 178.
ii. It was further submitted that a regulation under Section 178 is made under the authority of delegated legislation and consequently, its validity can be tested only in judicial review proceedings before the courts and not by way of appeal before the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (the “APTEL”) under Section 111 of the Act, 2003.
iii. It was submitted that the order of the CERC levying compensatory transmission charges on the respondent no. 1 was not in conformity with the 2014 Tariff Regulations enacted under Section 178 of the Act, 2003 and was beyond the scope of the said Regulations. Therefore, the said order was passed without any jurisdiction and hence, was being assailed before the High Court without availing the statutory alternative remedy. iv. Further, the APTEL had already addressed a similar question in Nuclear Power Corporation of India Limited. v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors. reported in 2019 SCC OnLine APTEL 83 wherein it was held as under:
“10.5 Accordingly, in absence of specific provisions in the Sharing Regulations/Tariff Regulations, 2014 to deal with the situation under question the Central Commission through exercise of its regulatory powers has prescribed a principle for sharing of transmission charges of the Transmission System of the Respondent No.2 in the Impugned Order. Thus, it is observed that by way of exercising its regulatory power by a way of judicial order(s) the Central Commission has laid down the principles of payment of transmission charges in such an eventuality.
However, it is felt that the Central Commission in the impugned Order has abruptly concluded the payment liability on the Appellant just by referring [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2073Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
to its earlier orders and not establishing the linkage with the present case explicitly. This Tribunal would like to clarify the same.”
The respondent no. 1 submitted that the APTEL had taken a peculiar view of the matter. Although the CERC exercises twin powers of adjudication and regulation, yet the fact remains that the regulatory power cannot be exercised by way of a judicial order. Since APTEL took a contrary view on the issues at hand, the respondent no. 1 was of the view that no useful purpose would be served by filing an appeal under Section 111. v. Since the orders of the CERC were in the nature of regulations as per the averments of the appellant, the vires of the same could only be questioned before the High Court and not before the APTEL in terms of this Court’s dictum in Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trademarks reported in (1998) 8 SCC 1 wherein it has been held that despite the availability of an alternative remedy, a writ petition can be entertained in the following cases:
(a) Where principles of natural justice are breached,
(b) Where fundamental rights are sought to be enforced or breach thereof is complained of,
(c) Where the impugned order is passed by an authority without jurisdiction,
(d) Where the constitutionality of any provision is called in question.
12. Having heard the parties, the High Court affirmed that despite the availability of an alternative remedy, a writ petition can be entertained if any of the factors mentioned in Whirlpool (supra) are satisfied. Since the respondent no. 1 had challenged the constitutionality of the orders of the CERC dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively, on the grounds that the power exercised by the CERC was beyond the powers vested in it as per the relevant regulation and that the relief granted to the appellant was beyond the reliefs prayed for, the High Court was of the opinion that the principles of natural justice were breached. Therefore, despite the availability of an alternative remedy, the writ petition deserved to 2074 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports be entertained. Having held so, the High Court admitted the writ petition for hearing on merits. The relevant portion of the impugned order is reproduced below:
“[13] This is trite that despite availability of alternative remedy, a writ petition can be entertained if any of the factors mentioned in the judgment of Whirlpool (supra) are satisfied. In the instant case, the petitioner has challenged the constitutionality of the orders. Even if it is challenged by way of amendment, once amendment is allowed it will relate back to the original date of filing of writ petitions. Petitioner has also challenged the orders by contending that power exercised by the Commission was beyond the powers vested in it as per relevant regulation. The relief granted was beyond the relief prayed for. Hence, principles of natural justice were breached. In our view, in a case of this nature despite availability of alternative remedy, the writ petition can be entertained.
[14] Resultantly, the objection regarding alternative remedy is over ruled. The petition is admitted for hearing.”
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
13. Mr. M.G. Ramachandran, the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, submitted that the orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively were passed by the CERC under Sections 62 and 79 of the Act, 2003 respectively. Section 111 of the Act, 2003 provides for regular first appeal on both questions of fact and law to the APTEL which is an expert body specially constituted as per the recommendations of this Court in West Bengal Electricity Regulatory Commission v. CESC Limited reported in (2002) 8 SCC 715. A second appeal to this Court is allowed under Section 125 of the Act, 2003 for the purpose of adjudication of substantial questions of law.
14. He submitted that the Act, 2003 is an exhaustive and self-contained complete code on all matters concerning electricity including generation, distribution, trading and transmission of electricity. The Act, 2003 provides for tariff fixation by the CERC under Section 62. Since determination of tariff is a quasi-judicial function, the same has been made appealable to the APTEL. The learned counsel [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2075Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
relied upon this Court’s decision in PTC India (supra) to submit that the only exclusion to the scope of the appellate remedies provided under the Act, 2003 is that the statutory regulations notified by the CERC under Section 178 cannot be challenged in appeal before the APTEL. The APTEL, therefore, cannot rule on the vires of a regulation formulated by the CERC but there is no bar on it to interpret such regulations.
15. Therefore, a writ petition before the High Court cannot be maintained when an efficacious alternative remedy was available to the respondent. The learned counsel relied on this Court’s judgment in Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited v. MB Power (Madhya Pradesh) Limited reported in (2024) 8 SCC 513 and GRIDCO v. Western Electricity Supply Co. of Orissa Ltd. reported in (2024) 2 SCC 500 to fortify his submission in this regard. He also contended that as per this Court’s dictum in Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Orissa reported in (1983) 2 SCC 433, Nivedita Sharma v. Cellular Operators Association of India reported in (2011) 14 SCC 337 and U.P. Jal Nigam & Anr. v. Nareshwar Sahai Mathur & Anr. reported in (1995) 1 SCC 21, where statutory tribunal or statutory remedies are in place, a writ petition should not ordinarily be entertained at other fora.
16. It is the case of the appellant that the respondent has not challenged any regulation or provision of the Act, 2003 and has only challenged the orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively passed by the CERC which in ordinary circumstances may be appealed under Section 111 of the Act, 2003.
17. In the case on hand, no issue of constitutionality of the order arises as the conditions prescribed in this Court’s judgment in Whirlpool (supra), for exercise of writ jurisdiction are fulfilled. The learned counsel submitted that there is no violation of principles of natural justice as the respondent was duly served. Further, no issue as regards the defect in jurisdiction of the CERC was raised before that forum in the first instance.
18. Mr. Ramachandran submitted that it was not the case of the respondent that the CERC had acted wholly without jurisdiction. The respondent has admitted that in terms of Section 62 and Section 79(1)(c) and (d) of the Act, 2003, the CERC undoubtedly and undisputedly has the function and the jurisdiction to deal with 2076 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports inter-state transmission, determination of transmission charges and the sharing thereof. The orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively passed by the CERC had been challenged by the respondent only on one consideration that is, the correctness of the decision holding the respondent liable for transmission charges. It is the case of the appellant that the APTEL is competent to decide such issues.
19. The learned counsel further submitted that the respondent had intentionally not approached the APTEL with a view to escape the decision rendered by it in a similar set of facts wherein the liability of payment of transmission charges was imposed on the generating company in the event of delay in commissioning of downstream assets by it. It was submitted that the writ petition was filed by the respondent to avoid the binding decision of the APTEL in Nuclear Power Corporation (supra).
20. Mr. Ramachandran also highlighted the consequences of entertaining writ petitions against the orders of the CERC. He submitted that there are multiple beneficiaries in an inter-state transmission system. Owing to the nature of electricity transmission systems that span across states, it is possible that an identical issue relating to the same transmission system may be challenged before multiple High Courts resulting in multiplicity of decisions as well as a higher chance of conflict between different decisions for the same transmission assets. He brought to our notice that the respondent no. 4 herein that is, Maharashtra State Electricity Transmission Corporation Limited (“MSETCL”), who is one another beneficiary of the transmission system established by the appellant, has filed an appeal under Section 111 of the Act, 2003 before the APTEL bearing DFR No. 414 of 2024 challenging the order dated 27.01.2020 passed by the CERC, which is the very same order that has been challenged by the respondent no. 1 herein before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh by way of a writ petition.
21. The learned counsel submitted that the delay on the part of the respondent no. 1 in bringing up the intra-state system cannot lead to deprive the appellant of the charges for its inter-state system. We were informed that as on 23.11.2024, the principal amount due and outstanding was approximately Rs. 16.86 crore along with the late payment surcharge.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2077Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
22. Mr. Prashant Singh, the learned Advocate General of the State of Madhya Pradesh appearing on behalf of the respondent no. 1, submitted that the present appeal is directed against an interim order of admission of the writ petition passed by the High Court and the same does not warrant any interference by this Court.
23. The learned counsel submitted that the orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively passed by the CERC, wherein the liability of payment of transmission charges from 11.01.2019 till the downstream transmission assets achieve their Commercial Operation Date, are beyond its jurisdiction and violative of the rights of the respondents. It was submitted that no statutory authority or tribunal can assume jurisdiction in respect of a subject matter which the statute does not confer on such authority/tribunal. In the circumstance that a tribunal erroneously decides a fact in which the question of the jurisdiction depends, then in that case, the order passed thereby stands vitiated.
24. Mr. Singh further submitted that the powers of the High Court are wide and unlimited, therefore, the availability of an alternate remedy is not an absolute bar under Article 226. It is the case of the respondents that as per the dictum of this Court in Southern Electricity Supply Co. of Orissa Ltd. v. Sri Seetaram Rice Mill reported in (2012) 2 SCC 108, if the exercise of jurisdiction by a tribunal ex facie appears to be in futility, then the High Court would be justified to interfere with the order of the tribunal under Article 226. He also relied upon this Court’s decision in Maharashtra Chess Assn. v. Union of India reported in (2020) 13 SCC 285, to submit that the availability of an alternative remedy does not alter the discretionary nature of the High Court under its writ jurisdiction.
25. The learned counsel submitted that the grounds set out in the writ petition before the High Court clearly meet the parameters laid down by this Court in Whirlpool (supra) and The Asssistant Commissioner of State Tax and Ors. v. M/s Commercial Steel Limited reported in (2022) 16 SCC 447, which are as follow:
(i) An excess of jurisdiction,
(ii) A breach of fundamental rights,
(iii) A violation of the principles of natural justice, and
(iv) A challenge to the vires of the statute or delegated legislation. 2078 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports It is the case of the respondent that no statutory authority or tribunal can assume jurisdiction in respect of subject matter which the statute does not confer on it and an error of jurisdictional facts renders the order erroneous in law.
26. Mr. Singh submitted that the CERC exceeded its jurisdiction while ordering for recovery of transmission charges as the provisions for determination of tariff under the Act, 2003 do not confer power on the CERC to act arbitrarily and levy unilateral charges. He vehemently submitted that doing so is violative of the principles of natural justice. He argued that there is no provision either in the agreement between the parties or in the 2014 Tariff Regulations for claiming compensation or damages. He further submitted that the conditions governing the commissioning of the transmission assets in question were approved in the 38th Standing Committee meeting held on 17.07.2015 and the same include no provision as regards claiming of compensation or damages from the respondent.
27. The learned counsel brought to our notice the order dated 18.01.2019 passed by APTEL in Nuclear Power Corporation (supra) wherein, in a similar set of facts, the liability to pay compensation or damages was imposed on the generating entity for delaying the commissioning of transmission assets. It is the case of the respondent that since the APTEL has already passed an adverse order previously, the concerns of the respondent may not be addressed by filing an appeal under Section 111 of the Act, 2003.
28. Mr. Singh informed us that the transmission line is now functional and fully charged. The dispute regarding payment of compensation or damages is with respect to a limited period of time in which there was admittedly, a delay in commissioning the line due to force majeure.
29. It was submitted that no error or illegality could be said to have been committed by the High Court while exercising its discretion to entertain the writ petition and the impugned orders passed thereby are neither perverse nor contrary to law.
E. ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
30. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the following questions fall for our consideration:
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2079Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
i. Whether the CERC, while exercising its functions under Section 79(1) of the Act, 2003, is circumscribed by statutory regulations enacted under Section 178 of the Act, 2003?
ii. Whether the CERC exercises regulatory or adjudicatory functions under Section 79 of the Act, 2003? In other words, what is the scope of the CERC’s power to regulate inter-state transmission of electricity and determine tariff for the same under clauses (c) and (d) of Section 79(1)?
iii. Whether the grant of compensation by the CERC for the delay vide the orders dated 21.01.2020 and 27.01.2020 respectively, is a regulatory or adjudicatory function and to what extent are the principles of natural justice applicable to the exercise of such functions?
iv. Whether the High Court was justified in admitting the writ petition filed by the respondent no. 1 herein challenging the order dated 21.01.2020 of the CERC when there existed an alternative remedy under Section 111 of the Act, 2003?
F. ANALYSIS
i. Relevant Provisions of the Act, 2003
31. Section 61 reads thus:
“61. Tariff regulations.
The Appropriate Commission shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, specify the terms and conditions for the determination of tariff, and in doing so, shall be guided by the following, namely:--
(a) the principles and methodologies specified by the Central Commission for determination of the tariff applicable to generating companies and transmission licensees;
(b) the generation, transmission, distribution and supply of electricity are conducted on commercial principles;
(c) the factors which would encourage competition, efficiency, economical use of the resources, good performance and optimum investments;
2080 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(d) safeguarding of consumers’ interest and at the same time, recovery of the cost of electricity in a reasonable manner;
(e) the principles rewarding efficiency in performance;
(f) multi year tariff principles;
(g) that the tariff progressively reflects the cost of supply of electricity and also, reduces cross-subsidies in the manner specified by the Appropriate Commission;
(h) the promotion of co-generation and generation of electricity from renewable sources of energy;
(i) the National Electricity Policy and tariff policy: Provided that the terms and conditions for determination of tariff under the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 (54 of 1948), the Electricity Regulatory Commission Act, 1998 (14 of 1998) and the enactments specified in the Schedule as they stood immediately before the appointed date, shall continue to apply for a period of one year or until the terms and conditions for tariff are specified under this section, whichever is earlier.”
32. Section 62 reads thus:
“62. Determination of tariff.
(1) The Appropriate Commission shall determine the tariff in accordance with the provisions of this Act for--
(a) supply of electricity by a generating company to a distribution licensee:
Provided that the Appropriate Commission may, in case of shortage of supply of electricity, fix the minimum and maximum ceiling of tariff for sale or purchase of electricity in pursuance of an agreement, entered into between a generating company and a licensee or between licensees, for a period not exceeding one year to ensure reasonable prices of electricity;
(b) transmission of electricity;
(c) wheeling of electricity;
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2081Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
(d) retail sale of electricity:
Provided that in case of distribution of electricity in the same area by two or more distribution licensees, the Appropriate Commission may, for promoting competition among distribution licensees, fix only maximum ceiling of tariff for retail sale of electricity.
(2) The Appropriate Commission may require a licensee or a generating company to furnish separate details, as may be specified in respect of generation, transmission and distribution for determination of tariff.
(3) The Appropriate Commission shall not, while determining the tariff under this Act, show undue preference to any consumer of electricity but may differentiate according to the consumer’s load factor, power factor, voltage, total consumption of electricity during any specified period or the time at which the supply is required or the geographical position of any area, the nature of supply and the purpose for which the supply is required.
(4) No tariff or part of any tariff may ordinarily be amended, more frequently than once in any financial year, except in respect of any changes expressly permitted under the terms of any fuel surcharge formula as may be specified.
(5) The Commission may require a licensee or a generating company to comply with such procedures as may be specified for calculating the expected revenues from the tariff and charges which he or it is permitted to recover.
(6) If any licensee or a generating company recovers a price or charge exceeding the tariff determined under this section, the excess amount shall be recoverable by the person who has paid such price or charge along with interest equivalent to the bank rate without prejudice to any other liability incurred by the licensee.”
33. Section 64 reads thus:
“64. Procedure for tariff order.
(1) An application for determination of tariff under section 62 shall be made by a generating company or licensee in 2082 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports such manner and accompanied by such fee, as may be determined by regulations.
(2) Every applicant shall publish the application, in such abridged form and manner, as may be specified by the Appropriate Commission.
(3) The Appropriate Commission shall, within one hundred and twenty days from receipt of an application under sub-section (1) and after considering all suggestions and objections received from the public,--
(a) issue a tariff order accepting the application with such modifications or such conditions as may be specified in that order;
(b) reject the application for reasons to be recorded in writing if such application is not in accordance with the provisions of this Act and the rules and regulations made thereunder or the provisions of any other law for the time being in force:
Provided that an applicant shall be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard before rejecting his application.
(4) The Appropriate Commission shall, within seven days of making the order, send a copy of the order to the Appropriate Government, the Authority, and the concerned licensees and to the person concerned.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in Part X, the tariff for any inter-State supply, transmission or wheeling of electricity, as the case may be, involving the territories of two States may, upon application made to it by the parties intending to undertake such supply, transmission or wheeling, be determined under this section by the State Commission having jurisdiction in respect of the licensee who intends to distribute electricity and make payment therefor.
(6) A tariff order shall, unless amended or revoked, continue to be in force for such period as may be specified in the tariff order.”
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2083Power Grid Corporation of India Limited v. Madhya Pradesh Power Transmission Company Limited & O rs.
34. Section 79 reads thus:
“79. Functions of Central Commission.
(1) The Central Commission shall discharge the following functions, namely:-
(a) to regulate the tariff of generating companies owned or controlled by the Central Government;
(b) to regulate the tariff of generating companies other than those owned or controlled by the Central Government specified in clause (a), if such generating companies enter into or otherwise have a composite scheme for generation and sale of electricity in more than one State;
(c) to regulate the inter-State transmission of electricity;
(d) to determine tariff for inter-State transmission of electricity;
(e) to issue licences to persons to function as transmission licensee and electricity trader with respect to their inter- State operations;
(f) to adjudicate upon disputes involving generating companies or transmission licensee in regard to matters connected with clauses (a) to (d) above and to refer any dispute for arbitration;
(g) to levy fees for the purposes of this Act;
(h) to specify Grid Code having regard to Grid Standards;
(i) to specify and enforce the standards with respect to quality, continuity and reliability of service by licensees;
(j) to fix the trading margin in the inter-State trading of electricity, if considered, necessary;
(k) to discharge such other functions as may be assigned under this Act.
(2) The Central Commission shall advise the Central Government on all or any of the following matters, namely:-
(i) formulation of National electricity Policy and tariff policy; 2084 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.