Central Bureau of Investigation v. Narottam Dhakad & Anr.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 770; [2023] 14 S.C.R. 306
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice 1973
- Decided
- 25 Aug 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2592/2023
- Sections
- 173, 272, 465, 207, 208, 167, 464, 6, 125, 170, 376E, 158
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 14 S.C.R. 306 : 2023 INSC 770
CASE DETAILS
CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
v.
NAROTTAM DHAKAD & ANR.
(Criminal Appeal No.2592 of 2023)
AUGUST 25, 2023
[ABHAY S. OKA AND RAJESH BINDAL, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: In cases relating to offences arising out of the Vyapam Scam, respondents-accused filed applications seeking direction to supply a Hindi translation of the charge sheet filed by the appellant in English language. Rejected by Magistrate and Sessions Court. High Court whether justified in interfering and inter alia holding that Hindi was the only language of the Criminal Courts in the State of MP and therefore, the respondents were entitled to seek translation of the charge sheet into the language of the Court.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.173 – Language of the final report/charge sheet, if to be in the language of the Court determined in accordance with s.272, CrPC:
Held: There is no specific provision in CrPC which requires the investigating agency/officer to file it in the language of the Court determined in accordance with s.272 – Even if such a requirement is read into s.173, per se, the proceedings will not be vitiated if the report is not in the language of the Court – The test of failure of justice will have to be applied in such a case as laid down in s.465, CrPC – When a copy of the report and the documents are supplied to the accused u/s.207 and/or s.208, an opportunity is available for the accused to contend that he does not understand the language in which the final report or the statements or documents are written – But he must raise this objection at the earliest – In such a case, if the accused is appearing in person and wants to defend himself without opting for legal aid, there may be a requirement of supplying a translated version of the charge sheet and documents or the relevant part thereof concerning the said accused to him – It is, however, subject to the accused satisfying the Court that he is unable to understand the language in which the charge sheet is submitted – On facts, it cannot be said that non-supply of translation of the charge sheet and other documents to the accused in both appeals will occasion failure of justice – Impugned orders set aside. [Paras 18, 19 and 22] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Charge sheet filed in a language other than the language of the Court or the language which the accused does not understand, if illegal:
Held: No – A charge sheet filed within the period provided either u/s.167, CrPC or any other relevant statute in a language other than the language of the Court or the language which the accused does not understand, is not illegal and no one can claim a default bail on that ground. [Para 19] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.272 – Power under:
Held: s.272 deals with only the language of the Courts under CrPC – The power of the State Government is to determine for the purposes of CrPC what shall be the language of the Courts within the State other than the High Court – Power u/s.272 is not a power to decide which language shall be used by the investigating agencies or the police for the purposes of maintaining the record of the investigation – Wherever the legislature intended, there is a specific provision incorporated requiring the Court to mandatorily use the language of the Court in the proceedings – There is no such requirement laid down in respect of the report/charge sheet u/s.173. [Paras 12 and 15] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.465 – Test of the failure of justice – Error, omission, or irregularity in the trial:
Held: s.465 incorporates the same test of the failure of justice as s.464 while dealing with any error, omission, or irregularity in the proceedings – While deciding whether there is a failure of justice occasioned due to error, omission, or irregularity in the trial, the Court is required to consider the fact whether the objection could and should have been raised at an earlier stage in the proceedings – There is a specific provision to that effect under sub-section (2) of s.465 – Thus, in a given case, if something which CrPC specifically requires to be done in the language of the Court is done in any other language, per se, the proceedings will not be vitiated unless it is established that the omission has resulted in failure of justice – While CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION v. NAROTTAM
DHAKAD & ANR.
308 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
deciding the issue of whether there is a failure of justice, the Court will have to consider whether the objection was raised at the earliest available opportunity. [Paras 16 and 17] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss.211(6), 215, 228(2), 240, 272, 265, 277(b), 279, 281, 354, 353 – Language of the Court – Relevant provisions of CrPC having bearing on the issue of – Summarised. [Para 14]
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
2592 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 20.11.2017 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Gwalior in MCRC No.20941 of 2017.
With Criminal Appeal No. 2593 of 2023 Appearances:
Vikramjeet Banerjee, ASG, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Padmesh Mishra, Navanjay Mahapatra, Kartik Dey, Suraj Mishra, Abhishek Singh, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant.
Saurabh Mishra, AAG, Piyush Lakhanpal, Avinash Kr. Lakhanpal, Yashraj Singh Bundela, Pawan, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
ABHAY S. OKA, J.
1. Leave granted.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
2. Under Section 272 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short ‘CrPC’), the State Government has the power to determine what shall be, for the purposes of CrPC, the language of each Court within a particular State other than the High Court. As provided in Section 6 of CrPC, there are various Courts in a State. The said Courts are the Courts of the Session, Judicial Magistrates of the First Class, Metropolitan Magistrates, Judicial Magistrates of the Second Class, and Executive Magistrates.
3. In these two appeals, we are dealing with charge sheets filed by the appellant - Central Bureau of Investigation, in relation to offences arising out of the VYAPAM Scam in the State of Madhya Pradesh. Charge sheets have been filed for various offences under Sections 419, 420, 468, 467 and 471 of IPC and under Sections 3 and 4 of the Madhya Pradesh Examinations Act, 1937. The first respondent in Criminal Appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 5525 of 2018 filed an application before the learned Judicial Magistrate seeking a direction to supply a Hindi translation of the charge sheet filed by the appellant in English language. The contention of the first respondent accused was that he was unable to understand the charge sheet filed in English language. The learned Judicial Magistrate held that the first respondent was an educated person, having knowledge of English. Learned Judge pointed out that the offence related to fraud in the examination. The allegation is that after the first respondent received admit card, some other person took the examination by impersonating him. The learned Magistrate observed that the vakalatnama filed by the first respondent was in English and the first respondent has also signed in English. It was further held that the Advocate representing the first respondent had sound knowledge of the English language. Therefore, the learned Magistrate proceeded to reject the prayer made by the first respondent. The order of the learned Magistrate has been confirmed by the Sessions Court in revision. However, the High Court interfered by holding that Hindi was the only language of the Criminal Courts in the State and therefore, the first respondent was entitled to seek a translation of the charge sheet into the language of the Court.
4. The first respondent in Criminal Appeal, arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 10680 of 2022, is also an accused in the same case. He also made a similar application before the learned Magistrate which was rejected. The first respondent challenged the said order before the High Court. A Division Bench of the High Court by the impugned judgment held that when a charge sheet was filed in the language unknown to the accused, he was entitled to translation of the charge sheet in the language which he understands. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION v. NAROTTAM DHAKAD & ANR. [ABHAY S. OKA, J.] 310 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
5. The appellant - the Central Bureau of Investigation has challenged both the impugned orders.
SUBMISSIONS
6. The submission of the appellant in both cases is that the accused were highly educated and had knowledge of the English language. Therefore, there is no prejudice to the accused if the charge sheet was in English language. It was also pointed out by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant that the charge sheets in VYAPAM Scam cases are very bulky and translation of the charge sheets into Hindi is a very time-consuming and costly process.
7. The submission of the learned counsel appearing for the accused is that in the exercise of powers under Section 272 of CrPC, the State Government has declared Hindi as the only language of the Criminal Courts in the State. Their submission is that the language Hindi is for the purposes of the Code and therefore, charge sheets filed under Section 173 of CrPC ought to be filed in the language of the Court. Therefore, both the accused supported the view taken by the High Court. The learned counsel appearing for the accused also submitted that in a given case if the accused is not conversant with the language in which the charge sheet has been filed, he will not be able to defend himself properly as he will not be in a position to understand the statements recorded by the police and other documents collected during investigation.
OUR VIEW
8. The Government of Madhya Pradesh in exercise of power under Section 272 of CrPC issued a notification dated 28th March 1974, declared Hindi to be the language of each Court in the State except the High Court. If we consider the scheme of CrPC, it regulates not only the procedure before the Criminal Courts but also the procedure to be followed by the police and other investigating agencies. Chapter V deals with the arrest of persons. Chapter VI deals with processes to be issued for compelling the appearance of the accused before the Court. Chapter VII deals with processes to be issued to compel the production of things before the Court. Chapter VIII contains provisions regarding security for keeping the peace and for good behaviour. The powers under the said Chapter are to be exercised by the Courts under the CrPC or an Executive Magistrate, as the case may be. Chapter X contains the steps to be taken for the maintenance of public order and tranquillity. Chapter IX contains Section 125 which confers powers on the Courts of the Judicial Magistrate, First Class to order payment of maintenance to wives, children and parents. Chapter XI deals with the preventive action of the police. Chapter XII contains elaborate provisions regarding the registration of First Information Reports, and the investigation of offences in cognizable or non-cognizable cases.
9. Section 173 forms part of Chapter XII which contains provisions regarding a police report which is popularly known as a charge sheet. We are, therefore, reproducing Section 173 of CrPC which reads thus: “173. Report of police officer on completion of investigation.—
(1) Every investigation under this Chapter shall be completed without unnecessary delay.
(1A) The investigation in relation to an offence under sections 376, 376A, 376AB, 376B, 376C, 376D, 376DA, 376DB or 376E of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860) shall be completed within two months from the date on which the information was recorded by the officer in charge of the police station.
(2) (i) As soon as it is completed, the officer in charge of the police station shall forward to a Magistrate empowered to take cognizance of the offence on a police report, a report in the form prescribed by the State Government, stating—
(a) the names of the parties;
(b) the nature of the information;
(c) the names of the persons who appear to be acquainted with the circumstances of the case;
(d) whether any offence appears to have been committed and, if so, by whom;
(e) whether the accused has been arrested;
(f) whether he has been released on his bond and, if so, whether with or without sureties;
(g) whether he has been forwarded in custody under section 170. CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION v. NAROTTAM DHAKAD & ANR. [ABHAY S. OKA, J.] 312 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
(h) whether the report of medical examination of the woman has been attached where investigation relates to an offence under sections 376, 376A, 376AB, 376B, 376C, 376D, 376DA, 376DB] or section 376E of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860).
(ii) The officer shall also communicate, in such manner as may be prescribed by the State Government, the action taken by him, to the person, if any, by whom the information relating to the commission of the offence was first given.
(3) Where a superior officer of police has been appointed under section 158, the report shall, in any case in which the State Government by general or special order so directs, be submitted through that officer, and he may, pending the orders of the Magistrate, direct the officer in charge of the police station to make further investigation.
(4) Whenever it appears from a report forwarded under this section that the accused has been released on his bond, the Magistrate shall make such order for the discharge of such bond or otherwise as he thinks fit.
(5) When such report is in respect of a case to which section 170 applies, the police officer shall forward to the Magistrate along with the report—
(a) all documents or relevant extracts thereof on which the prosecution proposes to rely other than those already sent to the Magistrate during investigation;
(b) the statements recorded under section 161 of all the persons whom the prosecution proposes to examine as its witnesses.
(6) If the police officer is of opinion that any part of any such statement is not relevant to the subject-matter of the proceedings or that its disclosure to the accused is not essential in the interests of justice and is inexpedient in the public interest, he shall indicate that part of the statement and append a note requesting the Magistrate to exclude that part from the copies to be granted to the accused and stating his reasons for making such request.
(7) Where the police officer investigating the case finds it convenient so to do, he may furnish to the accused copies of all or any of the documents referred to in sub-section (5).
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.