Phulel Singh v. State of Harayana
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 863; [2023] 12 S.C.R. 793
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha
- Decided
- 27 Sept 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 396/2010
- Sections
- 304, 307, 498, 309, 302, 34, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
CASE DETAILS
PHULEL SINGH
v.
STATE OF HARAYANA
(Criminal Appeal No. 396 of 2010)
SEPTEMBER 27, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI, PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA AND PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether in the totality of the circumstances, it can be said that the dying declaration (Ex. P.L.) is free from doubt; whether evidence prove beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was harassed on account of non-fulfillment of demand of dowry.
Evidence Act, 1872 – Dying Declaration – Dying declartion free from doubt or not – Doubt whether the dying declaration recorded was voluntary or it was tutored – Doubt regarding fitness of victim – Variation in statement made by victim:
Held: The present case mainly rests on the dying declaration of the deceased – In the present case, the dying declaration is recorded by PW-5, Executive Magistrate – It is relevant to note that the deceased received burn injuries on 05.11.1991 but the dying declaration came to be recorded on 08.11.1991 after an application was made by the relatives of the deceased to the SDM – PW-5, Executive Magistrate, in his evidence, admitted that the boys (related to deceased), who had brought the application containing the order of the SDM had told him that the statement of the deceased should be recorded and that she was in a position to make the statement – He further admitted that those boys had told him that whatever they had to tell the deceased, they had told her and that he should accompany them to record her statement – There is a grave doubt as to whether the dying declaration recorded by PW-5, Executive Magistrate was a voluntary one or tutored at the instance of respondent No.5 – It is also doubtful as to whether PW-8 had really examined the deceased with regard to her fitness prior to her statement [2023] 12 S.C.R. 793 : 2023 INSC 863 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.794 being recorded by PW-5, Executive Magistrate – PW-8-doctor had further stated that the deceased had also narrated that her husband had extinguished fire by pouring water on her – In the totality of the circumstances, it cannot be said that the dying declaration (Ex. P.L.) is free from doubt. [Paras 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14] Penal Code, 1860 – Dowry death – High Court partly allowed the appeal filed by the accused persons; accused no.1, father of the appellant herein was acquitted of the charge u/s. 304-B of the IPC, however, the conviction and sentence qua appellant was upheld – Propriety: Held: Dying declaration of deceased was not free from doubt – The most glaring aspect that is required to be considered is that the High Court itself has disbelieved the dying declaration insofar as father-in-law of the deceased is concerned – It is difficult to understand that how the same dying declaration could have been made basis for conviction of the appellant when the same was disbelieved insofar as another accused is concerned – PW-9-investigating officer had stated in his deposition that he had come to the conclusion that the present case was not a case u/s. 307 of IPC or s.498-A of IPC but a case u/s. 309 of IPC – He had further stated that during investigation, it was revealed that the deceased was short-tempered and that accused no.1 (father of appellant) was not there in the village on the fateful day – Insofar as harassment with regard to non-fulfillment of demand of dowry is concerned, except the vague allegation, there is nothing in their evidence to support the prosecution case – PW-6-Sarpanch of the village stated that he was informed by PW-4, father of the deceased that in-laws of the deceased were harassing her and therefore they should go to village, however, nothing was said regarding any harassment on account of non-fulfillment of demand of dowry – There is no evidence to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was harassed on account of non-fulfillment of demand of dowry – Therefore, no case u/s. 304-B of IPC is made out by the prosecution. [Paras 15, 16 and 17]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Makhan Singh v. State of Haryana 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1019 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
396 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 24.07.2009 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRLA No.909 of 1999.
Appearances:
Rajul Bhargav, Sr. Adv., Rajiv K. Garg, Ashish Garg, Lalit Nagar, T. L. Garg, Advs. for the Appellant.
Samar Vijay Singh, Raj Singh Rana, Keshav Mittal, Ms. Sabarni Som, Aman Dev Sharma, Pankaj Kumar Singh, Advs. for the Respondent. JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
B. R. GAVAI, J.
1. This appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 24th July 2009 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court for the States of Punjab and Haryana in Criminal Appeal Nos. 413-DBA of 2001 and 909-SB of 1999 along with Criminal Revision No. 134 of 2000, wherein the Division Bench partly allowed the appeal filed by the accused persons; whereby Jora Singh (Accused No. 1), father of the appellant herein was acquitted of the charge under Section 304-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (“IPC” for short) and the conviction and sentence qua the appellant herein rendered by the learned court of Mrs. Nirmal Yadav, Sessions Judge, Sirsa (hereinafter referred to as “the trial court”) in Sessions Trial No. 122 of 1994 vide judgment and order dated 14th September 1999 for the offence punishable under Section 304-B of IPC and sentence to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of seven years was upheld. Whereas, Criminal Appeal No. 413-DBA of 2001 filed by the State of Haryana and Criminal Revision No. 134 of 2000 filed by Pavitar Singh (PW-3), brother of Kiran Kaur (hereinafter referred to as “deceased”) challenging the acquittal of the accused persons for the charge under Section 302 of IPC were dismissed.
PHULEL SINGH v. STATE OF HARAYANA SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.796
2. Shorn of details, the facts leading to the present appeal, are as under: 2.1 The marriage between the deceased and the appellant was solemnized in March, 1987, and they were blessed with a girl and a boy. It is the prosecution case that the appellant used to harass the deceased on account of insufficiency of dowry. It is further the prosecution case that, succumbing to the demands of the appellant, the parents of the deceased paid Rs.20,000/- to the appellant in cash and in 1990, they gave a scooter and gold ornaments weighing 2.5-3 tolas to the appellant. Further, the deceased would tell her parents and her brother about the harassment and ill-treatment meted out to her at the hands of the appellant whenever she visited her parental house and eventually refused to reside in the house of the appellant. However, on account of the assurance and responsibility undertaken by Mohan Singh, the son-in-law of Jora Singh, father-in-law of the deceased, she was brought back to her matrimonial house. Even then, the deceased was not treated properly by the appellant. According to the prosecution allegations, Pavitar Singh (PW- 3), brother of the deceased had come to see the deceased at her matrimonial home in village Chatha about 3 to 4 days prior to the Diwali of 1991 when the deceased had informed him about the demand for dowry being made by the appellant and his family. When Pavitar Singh (PW-3) returned home and informed his parents about the said harassment being meted out to the deceased in lieu of demand for dowry, Randhir Singh (PW-4), father of the deceased, went to Major Singh (PW-6), Sarpanch of his village, who assured him that they would go to the house of the appellant for counselling them after Diwali. Following which, on 5th November 1991, i.e., on the festive day of Diwali, Dr. Sharma of Bhagwangarh had come to Rama Mandi. On his return, he informed Pavitar Singh (PW-3) and other family members that the deceased had been burnt and that she was being taken to Ludhiana. Thereupon, Pavitar Singh (PW-3), Randhir Singh (PW-4) and cousin Gur Raj Singh reached the Daya Nand Medical College and Hospital, Ludhiana (hereinafter referred to as “DMC, Ludhiana”) where the deceased was admitted and lay unconscious. On 5th November 1991, Dr. Jasmeet Singh Dhir (PW-7), the Medical Officer at DMC, Ludhiana, who had medico-legally examined the deceased, opined that she had 91% burns on her body and accordingly sent ruqa (Ex.-P.J) to the Station House Officer (SHO), Police Station Sarabha Nagar, Ludhiana on the same day at about 05.10 p.m. regarding admission of the deceased in the hospital.
2.2 On 7th November 1991, when the deceased regained consciousness, she told Pavitar Singh (PW-3) and others that it was the appellant who had burnt her. Following which, Randhir Singh (PW-4) made an application (Ex. P.D./1) to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM), Ludhiana, for recording of the statement of the deceased. On the following day, i.e., 8th November 1991, Mr. Sadhu Singh (PW-5), the then Executive Magistrate, Ludhiana received the said application along with endorsements of the SDM, Ludhiana (Ex. P.D/2 and P.D/3). Upon receiving the same, the Executive Magistrate, Ludhiana reached the DMC, Ludhiana and moved another application (Ex. P.S.) before the Medical Officer at about 04.15 p.m. thereby seeking his opinion with regards to the fitness of the deceased. When Dr. Jatinder Pal Singh (PW-8) gave his opinion (Ex. P.S/1) that the deceased was fit to make a statement, Mr. Sadhu Singh (PW-5) proceeded to record the statement of the deceased (Ex. P.L.) on the same day at about 04.40 p.m. The statement was read over and explained to the deceased, who had put her thumb impression on the same after admitting to its contents to be correct. A First Information Report (“FIR” for short) (Ex. P.E./1) was recorded based on the said statement of the deceased against Jora Singh, father-in-law of the deceased, appellant herein and Dhan Kaur, mother-in-law of the deceased, for the offences punishable under Sections 498-A, 307, 406 and 34 of IPC. On 18th November 1991, at about 06.00 p.m., Dr. Jatinder Pal Singh (PW- 8) sent ruqa (Ex. P.M.) to the Police Station Sarabha Nagar, Ludhiana, regarding the death of the deceased. Following which, the Assistant Sub Inspector (ASI), Sri Bhagwan (PW-9) prepared an inquest report at the DMC, Ludhiana on 19th November 1991 with regards to the dead body of the deceased and made an application for conducting of post-mortem examination as well (Ex. P.R./1).
2.3 Upon completion of investigation, a charge-sheet came to be filed in the court of jurisdictional Magistrate. Since the case was exclusively triable by the learned Sessions Judge, it came to be committed to the learned Sessions Court. Charges were framed for the offences punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of IPC and Section 304-B of IPC. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.