H. J. Baker and Bros. Inc v. The Minerals and Metals Trade Corporation Ltd. (Mmtc)
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 747; [2023] 11 S.C.R. 287
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Aravind Kumar Headnotes Issue for Consideration : in the Instant Appeals, Justice The Order Passed By the Division Bench of the High Court, Justice But Set Aside the Award for the Balance Period, Justice However, Justice The
- Decided
- 18 Aug 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2437/2010
- Sections
- 73
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 11 S.C.R. 287 : 2023 INSC 747
CASE DETAILS
H. J. BAKER AND BROS. INC.
v.
THE MINERALS AND METALS TRADE
CORPORATION LTD. (MMTC)
(Civil Appeal No(s). 2437 of 2010)
AUGUST 18, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND ARAVIND KUMAR, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration : In the instant appeals, the order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court, which partly interfered with an arbitration award by upholding the findings of the Single Judge of the High Court to the extent the award granting damages for certain period, but set aside the award for the balance period, is challenged.
Arbitration – Award of damages – Interference with – Award of damages for breach of contract for certain periods – Upheld by the Single Judge of the High Court, however, the Division Bench upheld the findings, to the extent the award granted damages for certain period, but set it aside for the balance period – Correctness:
Held : As regards first period, conclusions of courts below upheld and does not call for interference – As regards the second period, the respondent made no attempt to produce a copy of the canalisation order before the tribunal nor intimated the claimant its inability to continue with the arrangement – Nothing was shown to prevent the respondent from communicating the said aspect at the earliest point of time – Thus, no interference called for – Furthermore, the measure of damages has to be in accord with s. 73, i.e. the market price of goods on the date of the breach, less the contract price – As regards, the award for the balance period, the Division Bench held that the failure to produce the best evidence that the claimant possessed in the form of contracts for the balance quantity and the payments received as proof of damage suffered and the shipping arrangements as well as the shipments as billed from time to time with full 288 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
particulars, disentitled it to any compensation for the later period, which is in accordance with law – Impugned judgment applied the correct principles of law, in partly setting aside the award – As regards, the rate of interest, there have been concurrent findings – Contract Act, 1873 – s. 73. [Paras 14-16, 18-21]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
M/S. Murlidhar Chiranjilal vs M/S. Harishchandra Dwarkadas & Anr [1962] 1 SCR 653; Arosan Enterprises Ltd v Union of India [1999] Supp 2 SCR 621: (1999) 9 SCC 449; Vedanta Ltd. v. Shenzhen Shandong Nuclear Power Construction Co. Ltd. [2018] (12) S.C.R 829 – referred to. Foley vs. Classique Coaches Ltd. (1934) 2 K.B. 1 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.2437 of 2010.
From the Judgment and Order dated 27.07.2009 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in FAO No.477 of 2001.
With Civil Appeal No.5286-5287 of 2023.
Appearances:
Ramesh Singh, Ms. Kiran Suri, Sr. Advs., Gautam Khaitan, Ms. Bharti Badesra, Mrs. Bina Gupta, Ms. Ranjana Roy Gawai, Ms. Vasudha Sen, Vineet Wadhwa, Ms. Divya Roy, Advs. for the appearing parties. JUDGMENT/ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.
1. Leave granted in SLP (Civil) No(s). 12870-12871 of 2011.
289H. J. BAKER AND BROS. INC. v. THE MINERALS AND METALS TRADE CORP. LTD. (MMTC) [S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.]
2. These appeals are directed against a common judgment of the Delhi High Court1, which partly interfered with an arbitration award. One appeal has been preferred by the respondent – MMTC Limited in arbitration (hereafter “MMTC”) to the extent that the impugned judgment did not set aside the award, and the other appeal by the arbitration claimant – M/s H.J Baker & Bros. INC (hereafter “Baker”) to the extent it did.
Essential facts
3. MMTC entered into an agreement dated 14-01-1986 with Baker for the purchase of US-origin sulphur. In terms of the agreement, MMTC was to purchase on an annual basis 60,000 metric tons of sulphur (+/- 5% for shipping convenience). The agreement was to be operative for three years from 01-06-1986 and thereafter was to be extended annually on ever green basis unless terminated by either party through six month’s written notice. Under the contract, MMTC purchased the material till 1991. On 20-12-1991, MMTC telexed Baker, confirming supply-price for the period from January to June 1992. As no vessel was nominated for this purpose, by a fax dated 27-01-1992, Baker requested nomination of a vessel. On 31-01- 1992, MMTC communicated that it would be nominating its vessel in March 1992 for 25,000 metric tons of sulphur in May-June 1992. Thereafter some correspondence was exchanged between the parties over the nomination of the vessel.
4. The quantity of 50,000 metric tons of sulphur for January-July 1992 was not lifted by MMTC. Instead, MMTC by fax, on 08-04-1992 informed Baker that the import of sulphur was de-canalised by the Union Government on 20-02-1992 and consequently, it could not nominate any vessel against the balance quantity in the contract. Baker did not accept MMTC’s reason for not nominating the vessel and lifting the balance quantity of sulphur. Baker kept insisting upon lifting the desired quantity and also stated that because of MMTC’s inaction, it was incurring storage expenses as well. MMTC, by its letter dated 21/22-05-1992 stated that import of sulphur directly from the Gulf was at lower landed costs and because of the changed situation, namely, decanalising of sulphur import by the Union Government, its import from the USA or Canada ceased to be competitive. MMTC requested for cost and freight prices (hereafter, “C & F prices”) mentioning that it was eager to continue relations with Baker. The latter maintained that de-canalisation would not affect the contract 1 By final order dated 27-07-2009 in F.A.O. (OS) No. 477 of 2001. 290 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
between the parties and MMTC had to purchase the quantity at agreed prices. Ultimately, Baker sent a legal notice to MMTC claiming damages for the past three half-yearly semesters i.e. January-June 1992, July- December 1992 and January-June 1993. This was followed by another legal notice dated 19-07-1993. By this legal notice, arbitration was invoked by Baker.
5. A three-member tribunal was constituted, which adjudicated the claims. Eventually, under the award2, MMTC was held liable to pay US $ 5,10,215/- to Baker, for two distinct periods. The award was challenged by MMTC through objections. The objections were rejected by the learned single judge and the award was made the rule of court.3 MMTC appealed the affirmation of the award by the learned single judge. On appeal, the Division Bench, by the impugned order upheld the single judge’s findings, to the extent the award granted damages for the period January-June, 1992, but set it aside for the balance period.
6. Some of the relevant clauses of the agreement dated 14.01.1986 which are material for this case are extracted below:
“Clause 6:- The price will be settled half yearly and shall be in line with Canadian producers prices to their long terms contract customers. Both parties will make utmost efforts to settle the prices for supplies during January - June by 15th January and for supplies during July -December by 15th July of that year. In case no settlement on price for deliveries during a semester is possible, the quantity allocated for that period may stand lapse or reduced and both parties shall meet again to negotiate prices for subsequent period.”
Clause 5:- The agreement shall be operative for three years from 1st January, 1986 and will be extended annually on ever green basis unless cancelled by either party on six months written notice.”
7. In arbitration, Baker contended that MMTC had committed a breach of the contract dated 20.12.1991 for the purchase of 50,000 metric tons of sulphur during the period January-June 1992 (first half of 1992). Baker claimed damages for MMTC’s failure to lift sulphur of the same quantity during the second half of 1992 and two half yearly semesters 2 Award dated 07.02.1996 3 By order dated 05.09.2001 in Suit No 1038-A of 1996& IA No 6093 of 1996. each of 1993 and 1994. The three-member tribunal held that MMTC had committed a breach of the contract and its commitments and responsibility to lift 50,000 metric tons of sulphur during the first half of 1992 remained intact. The single judge found that this plea was justified, and upheld the tribunal’s findings for award of damages for the period January-June, 1992 at US$ 200,000/- and for the balance period (June-December 1992) at US$ 300,000/-. Damages for the latter period were held to be unwarranted by the impugned judgment.
Contentions of parties
8. Appearing for Baker, Mr. Ramesh Singh, learned senior counsel and Ms. Bina Gupta, learned counsel, argued that the basis on which the impugned order proceeded to interfere with the award, i.e., it did not take into account the principles underlying the award of damages is incorrect. It was urged that the circumstance that a party had not gone to the market or did not make attempts to mitigate its losses, disentitled it to damages, is an incorrect premise. On the other hand, whether a party goes to the marketplace is immaterial and the court can award damages, keeping in mind the difference between the contract price and the market price. Reliance was placed on a decision of the court in M/S. Murlidhar Chiranjilal vs M/S. Harishchandra Dwarkadas & Anr (hereafter, “Murlidhar Chiranjilal”)4 that even if a party does not purchase the goods in the market “on the date of breach it would be entitled to damages on proof of rate for similar canvas prevalent” at the relevant place “on the date of breach, if that rate was above the contracted rate resulted in loss to it.”. The decision in Foley vs. Classique Coaches Ltd.5 too was relied on to support the above view.
9. Baker argued that the assumption by the Division Bench, that the price of the goods, on the date of the breach, was not proved is unwarranted. Counsel relied on the award, to show that the prices for the relevant period, formed part of the consideration, which weighed with the tribunal, in ultimately fixing the market price, on a reasonable basis, i.e., at US$ 300,000/. It was urged that the price lists for the period, on the contractual goods, published by the standard “Fertecon” reports, which the parties agreed, reflected the sale position of sulphur in the international market. The reports spoke about a large number of sales at prevalent market prices of sulphur during 1992. It was argued that the view in the award regarding the measure of damages,
4 1962 SCR (1) 653
5 (1934) 2 K.B. 1 H. J. BAKER AND BROS. INC. v. THE MINERALS AND METALS TRADE CORP. LTD. (MMTC) [S. RAVINDRA BHAT, J.] 292 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.