Manoj Kumar Soni v. The State of Madhya Pradesh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 705; [2023] 11 S.C.R. 246
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Unaccompanied By Supporting Evidence, Justice If Justifi ED Evidence – Disclosure Any Supporting Evidence, Justice To Convict U/S.411 and S.120-B
- Decided
- 11 Aug 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1030/2023
- Sections
- 411, 120, 27, 313, 114, 374(2), 394, 25, 26
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 11 S.C.R. 246 : 2023 INSC 705
CASE DETAILS
MANOJ KUMAR SONI
v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
(Criminal Appeal No.1030 of 2023)
AUGUST 11, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration : Conviction of both the appellants-accused respectively u/s.411 and s.120-B, IPC was based largely upon disclosure statements made by them and the co-accused, unaccompanied by supporting evidence, if justified Evidence – Disclosure statements relied upon, without any supporting evidence, to convict u/s.411 and s.120-B, IPC – If adequate: Held : No – Although disclosure statements hold significance as a contributing factor in unriddling a case, they are not so strong a piece of evidence sufficient on its own and without anything more to bring home the charges beyond reasonable doubt – Sole connecting evidence against both the appellants-accused (‘M’ and ‘K’) was the recovery based on their disclosure statements, along with those of the other co-accused but this evidence is not sufficient to qualify as “fact … discovered” within the meaning of s.27, Evidence Act, 1872 and thus, untrustworthy – Appellants’ conviction respectively for offence punishable u/s.411 and s.120-B, IPC set aside, acquitted. [Paras 21, 30 and 44] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.27 – Disclosure statements u/s.27 made by the accused – Evidentiary value:
Held : The provided information must be directly relevant to the discovered fact, including details about the physical object, its place of origin, and the accused person’s awareness of these aspects – Further, as regards the disclosure statements of co-accused, Courts have hesitated to place reliance solely on them and used them merely to support the conviction. [Paras 22 and 23] 247MANOJ KUMAR SONI v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
Evidence – Property seizure memos – Reliability:
Held : Could have been a reliable piece of evidence but the seizure witnesses turned hostile – No scope to rely on a part of their depositions – Thus, the seizure lost credibility.[Para 26] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Examination u/s.313 – Duty of Trial Courts:
Held : Trial courts have been cautioned against recording statements in a casual and cursory manner – Mere quantity of questions posed to the accused is not important but rather the content and manner in which they are framed – In the present case, irrelevant and abstract questions about the main incident of robbery were asked to the appellant-accused ‘M’, even though his alleged involvement occurred much later when the robbed items were allegedly sold to him by the co-accused – Prosecution’s entire case is premised on the disclosure statements made by the co-accused, but ‘M’ was never given the opportunity to explain the circumstances. [Paras 31 and 32] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.114(a) – Presumption – Appellants were not present at the complainant’s house during the incident and were apprehended later when it was discovered that ‘M’ had purchased the stolen articles and ‘K’ was involved in hatching the conspiracy: Held : A presumption of fact u/s.114(a) must be drawn considering other evidence on record and without corroboration from other cogent evidence, it must not be drawn in isolation – Trial Court convicted one of the appellant-accused (‘M’) based on a presumption u/s.114(a) asserting that his possession of stolen articles shortly after the theft, with knowledge of its stolen nature, was adequate enough to hold him guilty u/s.411, IPC – It erred in drawing such a presumption of fact without considering other factors. [Paras 34-36] Penal Code, 1860 – s.120-B – Among all five accused persons, only one of the accused-appellant (‘K’) was convicted for criminal conspiracy u/s.120-B – Legality:
Held : One person alone can never be held guilty of criminal conspiracy because one cannot conspire with oneself – Conviction of ‘K’ u/s.120-B vitiated. [Paras 38 and 41] 248 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Words and phrases – “Conspiracy” – Meaning – Discussed – Penal Code, 1860 – s.120-A. [Para 38]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Haricharan Kurmi vs. State of Bihar AIR 1964 SC 1184 : [1964] SCR 623 – followed.
Topandas vs. State of Bombay (1955) 2 SCR 881; Shiv Kumar vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2022) 9 SCC 676; Sanjeet Kumar Singh vs. State of Chhattisgarh 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1117; A Devendran vs. State of Tamil Nadu (1997) 11 SCC 720 : [1997] 4 Suppl. SCR 591 – relied on. Suresh Chandra Bahri vs. State of Bihar (1995) Supp (1) SCC 80 : [1994] 1 Suppl. SCR 483; Ram Sharan Chaturvedi vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1080 – referred to.
Pulukuri Kotayya and others vs. King-Emperor 1946 SCC OnLine PC 47; AIR 1947 PC 67; Emperor vs. Lalit Mohan Chuckerburty (1911) ILR 38 Cal 559; The King vs. Plummer (1902) 2 KB 339; I.G. Singleton v. King-Emperor (1924-25) 29 CWN 260 : AIR 1925 Cal 501 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1030 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 12.10.2022 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Principal Seat at Jabalpur in CRLA No.10549 of 2019. With Criminal Appeal No.1458 of 2023.
Appearances:
Harmeet Singh Ruprah, Amankant Mishra, Advs. for the Appellant. Sunny Choudhary, Adv. for the Respondent.
249MANOJ KUMAR SONI v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
JUDGMENT/ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1. These criminal appeals, by special leave, assail the common judgment and order dated 12th October, 2022 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Jabalpur (“High Court”, hereafter) whereby Criminal Appeal No. 10474 of 2019 and Criminal Appeal No. 10549 of 2019 [appeals under Section 374(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code (“Cr. PC”, hereafter)] carried by Manoj Kumar Soni (“Manoj”, hereafter) and Kallu @ Habib (“Kallu”, hereafter), respectively, were dismissed. While Manoj assailed his conviction for the offence punishable under Section 411 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (“IPC”, hereafter) and sentence of rigorous imprisonment of three years with a fine of Rs. 5,000.00 and a default sentence of three months, Kallu assailed his conviction for the offence punishable under Section 120- B, IPC and sentence of rigorous imprisonment of ten years with a fine of Rs. 5,000.00 and a default sentence of three months.
2. In all, five accused persons were convicted and sentenced for different offences punishable under the IPC vide the common judgment of the Additional Sessions Judge (“Trial Court”, hereafter) dated 28th November, 2019. The aforesaid judgment having been confirmed by the High Court, all the accused persons preferred Special Leave Petitions (“SLPs”, hereafter) before this Court challenging the common judgment dated 12th October, 2022. The SLPs of the three accused, namely, Suleman, Arif and Jaihind, were dismissed and the judgment and order of the High Court affirming their conviction and sentence left undisturbed. However, notice was issued on the SLPs preferred by the remaining two accused, Manoj and Kallu, on 06th April, 2023 and 11th April, 2023, respectively.
3. These two appeals were heard on different dates. However, a common judgment being under assail, this Court proposes to dispose of both these appeals vide this common judgment.
4. The case of the prosecution, in a nutshell, is that a complaint was registered by PW-18 (“complainant”, hereafter) to the effect that on 14th April, 2010, at around 1:30 pm, while the complainant was in her house, four persons rang the doorbell. When her servant, PW-8, answered the door, all four persons armed with a pistol forcefully entered the house. They tied up 250 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
the hands and legs of the complainant and her servant, threatened to kill them, and proceeded to rob the complainant of silver and gold jewellery, cash, and other valuables by taking the keys to the locker. The accused persons remained at the complainant’s residence till 2:30 pm before fleeing. Based on the complaint, an F.I.R. was registered at around 4:30 pm against four unknown persons under Section 394, IPC and all of them were subsequently arrested.
5. Investigation of the F.I.R. was carried out by the Investigating Officer (“I.O.”, hereafter). The specific allegations against Manoj are that the stolen jewellery (“articles”, hereafter) had allegedly been sold to him and, despite being aware that the co-accused had sold him stolen goods, he still chose to receive and possess the same dishonestly. Consequently, he was arrested on 9th May, 2010. Thereafter, these articles were recovered by the I.O. on two different days — 9th May, 2010 and 21st May, 2010. While the Seizure Memo dated 9th May, 2010 bears the signature of seizure witnesses PW-16 and PW-5, the Seizure Memo dated 21st May, 2010 bears the signature of seizure witnesses PW-11 and PW-6. The process of identification was conducted by PW-19, the Tehsildar, on 15th July, 2010. The specific allegations against Kallu, former driver of the complainant, pertain to his involvement in a conspiracy with other co-accused persons.The allegation against him is that he shared information with them, disclosing that the complainant had a substantial amount of money and valuable jewellery in her residence, coupled with the knowledge that she lived alone; this, allegedly led to the subsequent planning and execution of the robbery at the complainant’s house.
6. Upon completion of investigation, a chargesheet was filed before the concerned court against the accused persons including Manoj and Kallu. The offences with which all the accused were charged are shown as under: Jaihind Sections 450, 394, 397, IPC and Section 25(1-B), Arms Act, 1959 (“Arms Act”, hereafter)
Arif Sections 450, 394, 397, IPC and Section 25(1-B), Arms Act Suleman Sections 450, 394, 397, IPC Kallu Section 120-B, IPC Manoj Section 411, IPC 251MANOJ KUMAR SONI v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] Upon committal, charges were framed and the accused including Manoj and Kallu pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
7. Based on the complainant’s testimony, it is established that among the four accused present at the scene during the incident, Suleman, Arif, and Jaihind were duly identified by the complainant, but the fourth accused remained unidentified. During the investigation, it was revealed that the fourth accused was a minor and the case was subsequently referred to the juvenile court for further proceedings. Insofar as Kallu and Manoj are concerned, they were not present at the complainant’s house during the incident and were apprehended at a later stage of the investigation when it was discovered that Manoj had purchased the stolen articles, and Kallu was involved in hatching the conspiracy.
8. After appreciating the oral and documentary evidence on record, the Trial Court convicted and sentenced all the five accused persons as follows: Jaihind and Arif Sections 450, 397, IPC and Section 25(1-B), Arms Act R.I. for 5 years with a fine of Rs 1,000 R.I. for 10 years with a fine of Rs 5,000 R.I. for 1 year with a fine of Rs 1,000 Default: 1 month, 3 months, and 1 month respectively Suleman Sections 450, 397, IPC. R.I. for 5 years with a fine of Rs 1,000 R.I. for 10 years with a fine of Rs 5,000 Default: 1 month and 3 months, respectively Kallu Section 120-B, IPC R.I. for 10 years with a fine of Rs 5,000 Default: 3 months Manoj Section 411, IPC R.I. for 3 years with a fine of Rs 5,000 Default: 3 months
9. In convicting Manoj, the Trial Court primarily relied on two pieces of evidence: the Seizure Memos, which were prepared upon recovery of the stolen articles from Manoj’s possession, and the Identification Memo, in which the complainant identified the articles stolen. The Trial Court drew presumption under Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (“Evidence Act”, hereafter), to the extent it provides that “a man who is in possession of stolen goods soon after the theft is either the thief or has received the goods knowing them to be stolen unless he can account for his possession”. According to the Trial Court, the crucial corroborative evidence in Manoj’s case was the fact that the articles found in his possession belonged to the complainant and were accurately identified by her. Additionally, Manoj failed to provide any explanation regarding how 252 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
the stolen articles came into his possession. These collective factors resulted in his conviction under Section 411, IPC.
10. Insofar as Kallu is concerned, the Trial Court primarily based his conviction for criminal conspiracy on two key factors: first, the information provided by co-accused Jaihind during interrogation in his memorandum statement dated 12th May, 2010, stating that he had given Rs.3,000.00 to Kallu from the stolen money and had kept one country-made pistol along with three cartridges at his (Kallu) house/tapra; and secondly, during interrogation, Kallu himself in his memorandum statement admitted to keeping Rs.3,000.00 in his room’s cupboard, which was subsequently seized upon his disclosure. Having held that Kallu had conspired with the other co-accused, the Trial Court convicted him of criminal conspiracy punishable under Section 120-B, IPC.
11. The aforesaid judgment having been challenged by Manoj and Kallu, a learned Single Judge of the High Court was of the view that the findings of the Trial Court did not warrant any interference and that the appeals were devoid of any merit; hence, the same were dismissed. In confirming Manoj’s conviction and sentence, the High Court relied on the finding that most of the stolen articles were recovered from his possession and some of them were melted by him. Considering that the articles were duly identified by the complainant, the High Court was of the view that Manoj, knowing that the articles were stolen property, dishonestly retained them. While affirming the conviction and sentence of Kallu, the learned Judge referred to the fact that the complainant was known to Kallu and he was working as her driver and that Rs.3,000.00 was recovered from his house based on the disclosure statement.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
12. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of Manoj submitted that the courts below erred in recording the conviction under Section 411, IPC. The main submissions advanced by him to have the conviction reversed are as follows:
a) All four independent witnesses (PW-5, PW-6, PW-11, and PW-16) who were shown to be present during the seizure/ recovery of the articles from Manoj’s house turned hostile and failed to support the prosecution’s case of seizure.
Surprisingly, the courts below completely ignored this aspect of the matter.
b) There were serious procedural lapses in conducting the identification process in respect of the articles. The prescribed procedure in respect of seizure of a property was not followed, and a procedural flaw is established from the testimonies of the complainant and PW 19. The recovery of the ornaments from the possession of Manoj does not establish them to be that of the complainant. Therefore, the presumption under Section 114, Evidence Act was erroneously drawn as the very identification process suffers from serious lapses.
c) The Trial Court recorded the statement of Manoj under Section 313, Cr. PC in a very casual manner, as if it were completing a formality in law. It miserably failed to put any adverse circumstance appearing in the evidence against Manoj for eliciting his explanation. This is one other procedural lapse, and a grave one, which has rendered the trial vitiated qua Manoj.
d) Manoj has been framed in the case due to the animosity between him and the police as the police used to “often harass [Manoj] for going here and there and getting the jewellery weighed, identification etc.”. This statement of Manoj, given at the end of his examination under Section 313, Cr. PC was brushed aside by the courts below without assigning any reason, far less cogent reason.
e) Significant contradictions exist between the testimonies of police witnesses and seizure witnesses. The Trial Court predominantly relied on the statements of the police witnesses, overlooking the presence of additional testimonies of independent seizure witnesses available in the records, who subsequently turned hostile.
13. Finally, it was submitted that there was absolutely no material to convict Manoj under Section 411, IPC. Hence, the conviction and sentence of Manoj ought to be set aside and consequently, the appeal be allowed. MANOJ KUMAR SONI v.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] 254 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
14. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent/State submitted that both the courts below delved deep into the materials on record and, upon meticulous consideration of evidence, did not find any material contradiction in the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses. The procedural flaws pointed out by his adversary did not result in any failure of justice and, therefore, there is no reason to interfere with the judgment and order passed by the Trial Court, which has since been affirmed by the High Court. Supporting the conviction and sentence of Manoj, the learned counsel urged this Court to dismiss the appeal.
15. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of Kallu challenged the correctness of the impugned judgment and advanced the following submissions: a) No evidence was presented to substantiate the alleged conspiracy on the part of Kallu to commit any crime as alleged by the complainant. In other words, the necessary elements of the offence under Section 120-A, IPC, punishable under Section 120-B, IPC were not established.
b) The Trial Court convicted the other accused persons primarily relying on the statements and information provided by the complainant. However, the complainant did not make any statement or allegation against Kallu. His conviction was based solely on two factual aspects: first, that Rs.3,000.00 was recovered from him during the investigation based on information provided by the accused Jaihind and, secondly, that Kallu used to be the complainant’s driver one year ago. Apart from these circumstances, the prosecution failed to present any additional evidence to substantiate the charge under Section 120-B, IPC; the conviction and sentence, therefore, cannot sustain merely on these grounds.
c) Suresh Chandra Bahri vs. State of Bihar1 was placed to support the contention that the essential elements of an agreement between Kallu and the other co-accused persons to commit the offence are lacking, which is a necessary component to bring home the charge of criminal conspiracy. Additionally, Ram Sharan Chaturvedi vs. State of Madhya Pradesh2 was relied upon to emphasize the requirement for some kind of physical manifestation of agreement 1 (1995) Supp (1) SCC 80 2 (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1080 in order to establish the offence of criminal conspiracy. Topandas vs. State of Bombay3 was placed for supporting the contention that one person alone can never be held guilty of criminal conspiracy for the simple reason that one cannot conspire with oneself. It was pointed out that in the present case, Kallu is the only person convicted under Section 120-B, IPC, while no other accused has been convicted under the same provision, inviting thereby serious doubts about the validity of Kallu’s conviction.
d) The courts below have overlooked significant material contradictions, improvements, and omissions in the statements of prosecution witnesses.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.