Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1097; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 585
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 10 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3955/2025
- Sections
- 212, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 66C, 376A, 363, 201, 120B
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 585 : 2025 INSC 1097 Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v.
State of Uttarakhand (Criminal Appeal No(s). 3955-3956 of 2025)
10 September 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the conviction of the appellants, as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court, deserves to be upheld or whether they are entitled to acquittal.
Headnotes† Circumstantial evidence – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – ss.3 r/w 4, 5 r/w 6, 7 r/w 8 – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.376A, 363, 212, 120-B and 201 – Case of the prosecution that the deceased-minor girl was raped and sodomised and the accused-appellants were seen in close proximity to her shortly before she went missing from a wedding function and was later found dead – Prosecution relied upon motive of lust; the last seen theory and the alleged scientific evidence – Appellant No.1 was convicted u/ss.376A, IPC and ss.16, 17 3 r/w 4-7, POCSO Act and ss.363, and 201, IPC and was awarded death sentence – While, the appellant No.2 was convicted additionally u/s.212, IPC also and was sentenced accordingly – Guilt of the appellants, if was proved beyond reasonable doubt:
Held: 1.1 No – The prosecution failed to prove the guilt of the appellants beyond a reasonable doubt – In cases resting on circumstantial evidence, every link in the chain must be firmly and conclusively established, leaving no room for doubt – Where two views are possible, the one favourable to the accused must be adopted. [Paras 53, 56] 1.2 As regards ‘motive’, the prosecution has merely alleged that the appellants were driven by lust – However, no independent or credible evidence has been adduced to substantiate such a motive – A bald assertion without corroboration cannot by itself form a safe basis for conviction. [Para 52] * Author 586 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1.3 The ‘last seen theory’ relied upon by the prosecution suffers from serious infirmities – The prosecution has failed to prove the proximity of time and place so as to shift the burden onto the accused – The entire prosecution case linking the accused-appellants to the crime through the ‘last seen theory’ rests upon the belated introduction of interested witnesses after the body was recovered, upon the information given by ‘NC’ (deceased victim’s cousin) – Despite being a close relative who first disclosed the situs of the victim girl’s dead body, he was never examined or interrogated by the investigating officers – This omission is of grave significance. [Paras 31, 32, 52] 1.4 The utter failure of the Investigating Officer to question him so as to find out the source of his knowledge about the dead body of the victim girl depicts gravely tainted and suspicious actions of the Investigating agencies – The Investigating Officer’s failure to record a statement of ‘NC’ during the investigation and the omission of the prosecution to present him for deposition at the trial deprived the Court of the most vital link in the chain of circumstances – This intentional and calculated omission not only undermines the ‘last seen theory’ but also causes serious prejudice, as it deprives the Court and the defence of the opportunity to test whether the knowledge of ‘NC’ was innocent or otherwise – In the absence of this crucial testimony, the last seen circumstance collapses completely – Non-examination of ‘NC’ compels the Court to draw an adverse inference against the prosecution. [Para 32] 1.5 Furthermore, the scientific evidence also is itself riddled with deficiencies – The alleged theory of DNA found on the body of the victim girl matching with the DNA of appellant No. 1, is ex facie doubtful and unworthy of credence – Also, the prosecution’s claim that the appellant No.1’s location was traced through mobile surveillance is falsified by its own record, as the call detail records were procured much later and no evidence exists to link the appellant No.1 with the sim numbers in question – Likewise, the omission to examine crucial witnesses, including the subscribers of the relevant mobile numbers and most importantly ‘NC’ further weakens the case of the prosecution. [Para 52] 2.1 Thus, the prosecution has failed to prove motive, the last seen theory stands contradicted, and the alleged scientific evidence is marred by inconsistencies and serious loopholes – It is wholly unsafe to uphold a conviction, much less the extreme penalty of death – Since the prosecution failed to establish the chain of circumstances against appellant No.1, the very foundation of the case against [2025] 9 S.C.R. 587Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand appellant No. 2 is also destroyed as the same rests primarily on the alleged extra-judicial confession of accused-appellant No.1 inter alia stating that upon seeing the victim girl coming out of the wedding Pandal, he and his companions (appellant No.2 and the other accused) minds got vitiated by lust and thus decided to engage in carnal acts – Thus, the prosecution has failed to prove the charges against appellant No. 2 also, beyond a reasonable doubt and his conviction also cannot be sustained. [Paras 38, 53, 55] 2.2 Impugned common judgment passed by the Division Bench of the High Court and the judgment of the Trial Court are set aside – Appellants acquitted. [Paras 57, 58] Criminal Law – Award of death penalty – Duty of courts: Held: Trial Courts, as well as High Courts, are required to exercise the highest degree of circumspection before awarding the death penalty – The irreversible nature of capital punishment demands that it be imposed only in the “rarest of rare” cases and only when the prosecution has led unimpeachable, cogent, and convincing evidence that excludes every hypothesis of innocence – Even the slightest doubt or infirmity in the prosecution’s case must weigh against the imposition of such a sentence – Any hasty or mechanical application of the death penalty, without ensuring the highest standards of proof and procedural fairness, not only undermines the rule of law but risks the gravest miscarriage of justice by extinguishing a human life irretrievably – It is the duty of courts to consider mitigating circumstances and conduct a detailed sentence hearing before awarding the death penalty – Therefore, unless the prosecution’s evidence forms an unbroken and reliable chain of circumstances pointing only to the guilt of the accused, the extreme penalty cannot be justified. [Para 54] Evidence – Scientific/forensic evidence – DNA evidence – Reliance upon, when not justified – Circumstances surrounding the arrest of appellant No. 1 also examined, as the credibility of the DNA samples collected by the IOs was directly dependent upon the legality and authenticity of the arrest and subsequent seizure proceedings:
Held: On facts, in view of the various contradictions, omissions, and investigative lapses, the entire procedure of arrest and search of the person of the appellant No. 1 by PW-10 is gravely doubtful – The story projected in the evidence of the witness is something 588 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports out of fiction and is ex facie unbelievable – Thus, there are many suspicious circumstances surrounding the theory of apprehension and arrest of the appellant No.1 – The very theory advanced by the prosecution, that accused was traced based on his mobile location, is false and without foundation – The manner in which the arrest of the appellant No.2 was projected by the prosecution is also seriously dubious – Thus, the very foundation on which the DNA evidence is sought to be projected is gravely compromised, for if the arrest itself was illegal and stage-managed, the process of drawing samples from the accused-appellants cannot be regarded as either voluntary or reliable. [Paras 35, 40, 41, 44, 45] 1.2 Various circumstances, starting from the so-called arrest of the appellant No. 1 from Ludhiana (Punjab) taken cumulatively, give rise to a strong inference of tampering with the forensic samples and planting of semen of the appellant No.1 on the samples, i.e., cervical swab, undershirt, and underwear of the victim girl, so as to establish his involvement in the crime – The entire process of collection and examination of samples and the consequent matching of the DNA is suspicious and wholly unreliable – The DNA report cannot be treated as a reliable piece of evidence – In absence thereof, there is no evidence on record to connect the appellant No.1 with the crime – Also, credentials and qualifications of the Doctor (PW-34), who conducted the DNA examination and issued the DNA Report are also highly doubtful to place him in the category of a DNA expert. [Paras 48, 49] Circumstantial evidence – Conviction based purely on circumstantial evidence – Golden principles laid down in Sharad Birdhichand Sharda, stated. [Para 10] Case Law Cited Manoj & Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2022] 9 SCR 452 : (2022) SCC OnLine SC 677; Sharad Birdhichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; Mukesh & Anr. v. State for NCT of Delhi & Ors. [2017] 6 SCR 1 : (2017) 6 SCC 1; Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 684; Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab [1983] 3 SCR 413 : (1983) 3 SCC 470 – relied on.
List of Acts Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012; Penal Code, 1860; Information Technology Act, 2000.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 589Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand List of Keywords Rape; Circumstantial evidence; Motive, Last seen theory; Alleged scientific evidence; Tampering with forensic samples; Semen of accused planted; Semen planted on the samples; Cervical swab; Undershirt; Underwear; Chain of circumstances not established; Process of collection and examination of samples suspicious; Matching of the DNA is suspicious; DNA report not reliable; Mobile location; Alleged extra-judicial confession; Theory of apprehension and arrest; Suspicious circumstances; Arrest illegal; Arrest stagemanaged, Procedure of arrest and search; Procedure of arrest and search doubtful; Forensic evidence; Forensic samples; Process of drawing samples not reliable; DNA examination; DNA Report; Credentials of the Doctor doubtful; Not a DNA expert; No bloodstains; Jacket; Death penalty; Capital punishment; “Rarest of rare” cases; Highest degree of circumspection; Mitigating circumstances; Pithoragarh; Haldwani; Victim girl; Missing; Wedding function; Wedding Pandal; Lust; Sodomised; Victim girl’s hairband; Authenticity of the recovery proceedings doubtful; Alleged recovery manipulated; Guilt not proved beyond reasonable doubt; Acquittal. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 3955-3956 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 18.10.2019 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CRLR Nos. 1 and 104 of 2016 With Criminal Appeal No. 3957 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. Manisha Bhandari, Omkar Shrivastava, Divyadeep Chaturvedi, Ayush Jain, Shashwat Sidhant, Ayush Kumar Dubey, Ms. Ishita Dhaila, Pritish Arya, Saurabh Pandey, Dhruv Chandra, Ms. Manisha Bhandari, Omkar Shrivastava, Divyadeep Chaturvedi, Shashwat Sidhant, Ms. Ishita Dhaila, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Ms. Vanshaja Shukla, Ms. Ankeeta Appanna, Siddhant Yadav, Ajay Bahuguna.
590 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. The present appeals by special leave are preferred on behalf of appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali alias Ali Akhtar alias Shamim alias Raja Ustad1 and appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma 2 , assailing the common judgment dated 18 th October 2019, passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital3 in Criminal Appeals4 , partially upholding the conviction and sentence awarded to the appellants by the Special Judge (POCSO)/ Fast Track Court/ Additional District & Sessions Judge, Haldwani, District Nainital 5 vide judgment and order of sentence dated 11 th March, 2016 in Session Trial Case 6 , whereby accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali was convicted for the offences punishable under Sections 376A, 363, and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 7 ; under Section 3 read with Section 4, Section 5 read with Section 6 and Section 7 read with Section 8 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 8 ; and Section 66C of the Information Technology Act, 2000 9 . Accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma was convicted under Sections 212 of the IPC and Section 66C of the IT Act; however, he was acquitted of the charges under Sections 363, 201, 120-B, 376A of the IPC and Sections 16/17 read with Sections 4, 5, 6, 7 of the POCSO Act. The accused-appellants were sentenced as under:
1 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali’; appellant in Criminal Appeals @ SLP(Crl.) No(s). 14-15 of 2020.
2 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘accused-appellant No.2-Prem Pal Verma’; appellant in Criminal Appeal @ SLP(Crl.) No(s). 6573 of 2020.
3 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘High Court’.
4 Criminal Appeal No. 104 of 2016 along with Criminal Reference No.1. of 2016 and others. 5 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘the trial Court’.
6 Session Trial No. 09 of 2015.
7 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘the IPC.’ 8 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘the POCSO Act.’ 9 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘IT Act’.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 591Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand Accused/ appellant Provision under which convicted Sentence awarded by the trial Court The High Court Accused- Appellant No. 1 - Akhtar Ali Section 376A of the IPC; and Sections 16 and 17 read with Sections 4, 5, 6, and 7 of the POCSO Act.
Death Sentence Affirmed Section 363 of the
IPC
Rigorous imprisonment for seven years and a fine of Rs.5000/and in default of payment of fine, simple imprisonment for a further period of one month.
Affirmed Section 201 of the
IPC
Rigorous imprisonment for seven years and a fine of Rs.5000/and in default of payment of fine, simple imprisonment for a further period of one month.
Affirmed.
Section 66C of the IT Act Rigorous imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs.20,000/and in default of payment of fine, simple imprisonment for a further period of two months.
Acquitted Section 120B of the
IPC
Acquitted. Acquitted Accused- Appellant No. 2 Prem Pal Verma Section 212 of the
IPC
Rigorous imprisonment for seven years and a fine of Rs.10,000/and in default of payment of fine, simple imprisonment for a further period of one month.
Affirmed Section 66C of the IT Act Rigorous imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs.20,000/and in default of payment of fine, simple imprisonment for a further period of two months.
Acquitted Sections 363, 201, 120-B, 376A of the IPC; and Sections 16, 17 read with Sections 4, 5, 6, and 7 of the POCSO Act.
Acquitted. Affirmed Accused- Junior Masih alias Foxy Section 212 of the IPC; Section 66 of the IT Act; and Sections 16, 17 read with Sections 4, 5, 6, and 7 of the POCSO Act.
Acquitted Affirmed.
592 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. Briefly stated, the case of the prosecution, giving rise to the present appeals, is as under:
4.1 On 21st November, 2014, at 11:30 am, the victim’s father (PW-1) lodged a report 10 under Section 365 of the IPC, at Kathgodam Police Station, alleging inter alia that he and his family had travelled from Pithoragarh to Haldwani to attend the wedding of a relative which was to be solemnized at Sheeshmahal in Ramlila Maidan, Kathgodam, on 20 th November, 2014. During the said ceremony at around 07:45 pm, his daughter, Ms. K, along with other children, was playing in the pandal (venue). When Ms. K was called for a group photograph, she could not be found and appeared to have gone missing. Ishwar Singh Sah (PW-36), an attendee at the function, telephonically registered a missing complaint with Constable Subodh Sharma (PW-4) about Ms. K’s disappearance. Subodh Sharma (PW-4) recorded the information in the Police Station’s General Diary Report No. 5111 and alerted on-duty officers to try and locate the informant’s daughter, Ms. K. The Police officials questioned the people who attended the wedding and the individuals in nearby vehicles and searched the area, but the child, Ms. K, was nowhere to be found.
4.2 Four days later, i.e., on 25 th November, 2014, Rajesh Kumar Yadav (PW-6), Station House Officer, received a phone call from an individual, named Nikhil Chand (cousin of the informant’s daughter, Ms. K), who informed that the dead body of the victim girl was lying near Gaula River in the Forest in front of Sheeshmahal. Based on the said information, Sub-Inspector Shanti Kumar Gangwar (PW-5), along with Constables Mamta Arya, Devki Bisht, Subodh Sharma (PW-4) and Suresh Chandra, proceeded to the said location and found the dead body of a small girl, which was identified and confirmed to be that of the informant’s daughter, Ms. K, by the public present at the location, as well as by her relatives. Sub-Inspector Suman Pant (PW-3) prepared the panchayatnama12 of the body, which was then sent 10 Case Crime No. 73 of 2014. The same is Exhibited as Exhibit Ka-1. 11 Exhibit Ka-17.
12 Exhibit Ka-9.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 593Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand for autopsy. Dr. C.P. Bhaisora (PW-7) conducted post-mortem examination and found that all the organs of the victim girl were pale with early signs of putrefaction. He opined that the cause of death was shock and haemorrhage resulting from injuries to the vaginal and perianal region caused by sexual assault and blunt force trauma, which were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Consequently, offences under Sections 363, 376, 302, and 201 of the IPC and Section 4 of the POCSO Act were added to Case Crime No. 73 of 2014.
4.3 On 25 th November, 2014, the investigation of the case was assigned 13 to Vipin Chandra Pant (PW-40), the Investigating Officer. During the investigation, it was found that on the evening of 20 th November, 2014, the nearby shopkeeper, i.e., Kishan Singh Bora (PW-16), Bal Krishan (PW-19), and Shahadat Ali (PW-20) saw the accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma, who is a driver by profession, drinking liquor with another person. Both were seen buying chocolates and toffees from a nearby shop. Further inquiries revealed that Shankar Dutt Padalia (PW- 18), owner of a Dumper, which operated in the Gaula River, had employed a man from Bihar on the recommendation of the accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma. The investigating agency obtained the mobile phone number of this unidentified person from Shankar Dutt Padalia (PW-18) and placed it under surveillance. Similarly, the accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma’s mobile number was retrieved from his employer, Manish Gaur @ Mannu Gaur (PW-39) and was also placed under surveillance.
4.4 Two teams from the Special Task Force (STF) were formed to uncover the details of the crime. One team, led by Sub-Inspector Yogesh Kumar Chand (PW-10), proceeded to Ludhiana (Punjab), based on call detail records of the suspected numbers, while another team, led by Sub-Inspector Naresh Chauhan, headed to Champaran (Bihar) and Delhi. On 27 th November, 2014, at around 11:00 am, the team led by Sub-Inspector Yogesh Kumar Chand (PW-10) traced the location of one suspected mobile number to Guru Amardas Colony in Ludhiana (Punjab). They 13 Vide Order No. 03 of 2014.
594 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports then began searching for the user of the mobile phone and eventually detained the suspect at Sethi Market, who identified himself as Akhtar Ali, i.e., accused-appellant No. 1. During a personal search, the police recovered a railway ticket from Haldwani to Delhi, an identity card, and a mobile phone from the possession of accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali. The team also claimed to have recovered the blanket used in the alleged crime from the possession of accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, who was formally arrested and then was taken to the Police Station, Kathgodam, Haldwani on 28th November, 2014. Upon arrival, the Investigating Officer, Vipin Chandra Pant (PW-10), interrogated accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, who confessed that accused-appellant No.2-Prem Pal Verma and a Junior Masih alias Foxy14 , were his accomplices and were also involved in the crime. He admitted that his friend, accused-appellant No.2-Prem Pal Verma, had helped him secure a job as a dumper driver with Shankar Datt Padalia (PW-18) of Sheeshmahal, Kathgodam. On 20 th November, 2014, accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, accused-appellant No.2-Prem Pal Verma, and Junior Masih alias Foxy, consumed whisky (alcohol) together. Around 07:30 pm, a young girl came out of the wedding Pandal (venue). All three threatened the victim girl with a Tamancha (a country-made pistol), took her to a nearby forest, wrapped her in a blanket, and committed sexual assault on her. When the girl became unconscious, they abandoned her body, after covering it with leaves, and left the scene. The accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, purportedly led the police to the crime scene and recovered the victim girl’s hairband. A seizure memo15 was prepared as proof of the same.
4.5 On 28th November, 2014, Sub-Inspector Shanti Kumar Gangwar (PW-5) and his team arrested the accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma, and accused No. 3-Junior Masih alias Foxy.
4.6 After recording the statements of witnesses and concluding the investigation, the Officer-in-charge of the police station proceeded to file a charge sheet against all three accused 14 Accused No. 3 in Session Trial No. 09 of 2015.
15 Exhibit Ka-16.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 595Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand persons. The accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali was chargesheeted under Sections 363, 376, 302, 201, and 120-B of the IPC, along with Sections 4, 5, and 6 of the POCSO Act, and Section 66(C) of the IT Act. The accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma was charge-sheeted under Sections 363, 376, 302, 201, 120-B, and 212 of the IPC, along with Sections 4, 5, and 6 of the POCSO Act and Section 66(C) of the IT Act. Junior Masih alias Foxy was charge-sheeted under Section 212 of the IPC and Section 66(C) of the IT Act. On 27 th January, 2015, the trial Court took cognizance of the offences and provided the accused persons copies of the documents relied upon by the prosecution in compliance with the provisions of Section 207 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. 16 4.7 The trial Court then proceeded to frame charges against all the charge-sheeted accused persons for the above offences, who abjured their guilt and claimed trial. The prosecution examined 40 witnesses, exhibited 87 documents, and 27 material objects to prove its case and establish the guilt of the accused persons. The accused persons were questioned under Section 313 of the CrPC and were confronted with the circumstances appearing against them in the prosecution case, which they denied and claimed to be innocent.
4.8 After hearing the parties and evaluating the evidence, the trial Court, vide its judgment dated 11 th March, 2016, held that the prosecution had successfully established its case beyond a reasonable doubt and, therefore, convicted the accusedappellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, and accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma, as noted above. 17 The trial Court acquitted the accused No. 3-Junior Masih alias Foxy, on the ground of insufficient evidence against him. Vide an order, passed on the same day, the accused-appellants were sentenced in the terms indicated above. 18 4.9 Aggrieved by their conviction and sentences, accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, and accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma, 16 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘CrPC’.
17 Supra, Para No.3.
18 Ibid.
596 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports preferred an appeal 19 under Section 374(2) CrPC to the High Court. The informant/father (PW-1) of the victim girl also filed a criminal appeal 20 against the acquittal of Junior Masih alias Foxy, as well as against the acquittal of Prem Pal Verma and Akhtar Ali for certain offences.21 The State also filed two identical appeals22 against the acquittal of Junior Masih alias Foxy, as well as against the acquittal of accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali and accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma, for certain offences.23 A Criminal Reference 24 was forwarded by the trial Court to the High Court under Section 366 of CrPC, for confirmation of the death sentence awarded to accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali. The High Court, vide the common impugned judgment dated 18 th October, 2019, upheld the conviction and sentences awarded to accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, and accusedappellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma for the offences punishable under the IPC and POCSO Act. However, both were acquitted of the charge under Section 66C of the IT Act. Consequently, the High Court dismissed the appeals filed by the father of the victim girl (PW-1) and the State and upheld the acquittal of the accused-Junior Masih alias Foxy and the partial acquittal of the accused-appellants. In Criminal Reference, the High Court also upheld the death sentence awarded to the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali. 25 The impugned common judgment of the High Court dated 18 th October 2019, is subjected to challenge by the accused-appellants in these appeals by special leave.
Submissions on behalf of the appellants: -
5. Ms. Manisha Bhandari, learned counsel for the accused-appellants, submitted that the entire prosecution case is based on circumstantial evidence, the chain of which remains incomplete and shattered as 19 Criminal Appeal No. 104 of 2016.
20 Criminal Appeal No. 318 of 2016.
21 Supra, Para No. 3.
22 Government Appeals No. 7 and 8 of 2017.
23 Supra, Para No. 3.
24 Criminal Reference No. 1 of 2016.
25 Supra, Para No. 3.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 597Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand the material evidence has been fabricated, and gotten up witnesses were deliberately introduced by the prosecution, to bolster its case. Learned counsel for the accused-appellants advanced the following pertinent submissions to urge that the conviction of the accusedappellants as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court is unsustainable on the face of the record: -
5.1. That the prosecution’s case has, from the very beginning, been inconsistent and self-contradictory. The original version of the prosecution alleged that the victim girl, Ms. K, was kidnapped at gunpoint by the accused-appellants on the evening of 20th November 2014, and was taken to a secluded forest area, where she was subjected to brutal sexual assault. However, during the course of the investigation, the Investigating Officer, Vipin Chandra Pant (PW-40) admitted that no firearm was ever recovered and even conceded that the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, himself, in his extra-judicial confession, denied the use of any weapon. The prosecution, in order to fill this glaring lacuna, abruptly substituted its earlier story with a new version that the victim girl, Ms. K, was lured away by the accusedappellant with sweets and toffees. Such a fundamental and unexplained departure from the original prosecution narrative cannot be brushed aside, and it goes to the root of the case, demonstrating that the evidence has been tailored to suit the needs of the prosecution.
5.2. That the prosecution failed to examine one of the most material witnesses, namely, the cousin of the victim girl, Nikhil Chand. It is borne out from the record that Nikhil Chand was the first person who telephonically informed the Superintendent of Police, Rajesh Kumar (PW-6) about the location of the dead body of the victim girl in the Gaula River forest. It is also reflected in the case diary that Nikhil Chand had claimed to have seen the victim near a dumper on the date of the incident. In such circumstances, Nikhil was the only person who had knowledge both of the victim, Ms. K’s, last known movements and of the exact location of her dead body, which could not be found despite the fervent efforts of the other relatives and a number of police teams. Despite this, he was neither interrogated during the investigation nor examined during the trial. The prosecution offered no explanation for this grave omission. 598 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports The deliberate exclusion to examine such a pivotal witness, whose testimony could have either confirmed or demolished the prosecution’s version, casts a deep shadow over the fairness of the investigation and trial, warranting raising of an adverse inference against the prosecution.
5.3. That the manner of recovery of the victim girl’s body itself is shrouded in serious doubt. The record shows that immediately after the disappearance of the girl child on the evening of 20th November 2014, an extensive search was conducted by the police and local residents in and around the wedding venue, the Gas Godam area, and the banks of the Gaula River. The efforts to search continued for several days without yielding any results. Yet, on 25 th November 2014, the body was suddenly discovered mere 800 steps away from the venue by none other than the victim’s cousin, Nikhil Chand. This circumstance is highly suspicious, for it is inconceivable that despite repeated searches, the police could not locate the body which was lying in such close proximity, only for it to be fortuitously found by the very relative whose own conduct remains under grave doubt compounded by the medical evidence demonstrating that injuries on the dead body of the victim girl were concentrated on the left side of the body suggestive of dragging, which gives rise to a grave doubt that the situs of the crime was shifted, and that the body was planted at the spot later shown. The shifting of the situs irretrievably demolishes the chain of incriminating circumstances.
5.4. That the condition of the crime scene was wholly inconsistent with the prosecution’s allegation of repeated sexual assault on the victim girl by three fully grown men. According to the prosecution, the victim was raped and sodomised and then left in the bushes after being covered with leaves. However, the police did not find any bloodstains or signs of struggle at the alleged crime scene, although the post-mortem clearly records that the death was due to excessive bleeding, which occurred within minutes of the assault. The total absence of blood stains on the ground at or around the site renders the prosecution’s version implausible. Equally unexplained is the forensic finding that blood was detected only on the red jacket found on the dead body, but not on the blanket or the ground. Such discrepancies [2025] 9 S.C.R. 599Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand belie the story that the crime was committed there and suggest that the crime scene was staged.
5.5. That the alleged recovery of a hair-band at the instance of the accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, is another circumstance that cannot be believed. The FIR itself mentions that the victim girl had a boy-cut hairstyle, and no reference to any hairband was ever made at the initial stage. The recovery memo is riddled with irregularities. It bears overwriting of the time of recovery, does not mention the date, and has no independent witnesses. Even the trial Court and the High Court expressed doubt regarding this recovery. The improbability of the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, recalling the precise spot where such a trivial item was discarded days earlier, in a dense jungle, adds to the suspicion of the so-called recovery, which is thus nothing but planted evidence.
5.6. That the arrest of the accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, from Ludhiana on 27 th November 2014, is also surrounded by grave doubt. The prosecution relies upon a “secret source” who, without any prior familiarity with the accused’s appearance, is alleged to have identified him in a crowded city. No Ravanagi or Aamad entry of the arresting team was made at the local police station at Ludhiana. The only local officer, Inspector K.R. Pandey, who could have corroborated the arrest and prepared the site map of the arrest, was withheld from the witness box. The Naksha Najri of the place of arrest was curiously prepared much later, on 6 th January, 2015, by the Investigating Officer himself, who was not even part of the team that allegedly apprehended the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali. To make matters worse, the photograph of the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, was published in the newspapers on 28 th November, 2014, even though the prosecution claims he was produced at Haldwani, only that very morning. These circumstances leave no room for doubt that the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali had, in fact, been picked up earlier from Haldwani (Uttarakhand) and falsely shown as arrested in Ludhiana (Punjab). The purpose of this fabricated exercise was clearly to justify the collection of samples and to facilitate the planting of DNA material of the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali, on the forensic samples collected from the victim girl’s body.
600 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5.7. That the DNA report, on which the conviction of the accusedappellant No.1-Akhtar Ali primarily rests, is neither consistent nor reliable. The prosecution claims that the semen of the accusedappellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali matched the cervical swab, undershirt, and underwear of the deceased. However, the same semen was conspicuously absent in the cervical smear prepared from the very same source, as well as in the vaginal swab, vaginal wash, and the shirt worn by the victim girl. Such selective presence of semen of the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali is inexplicable unless the samples were tampered with and the fluids/blood of the accused-appellants were planted onto the same. The defence case that semen was forcibly obtained from the accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali after his illegal detention much before 27 th November, 2014, and planted on certain exhibits, is fully supported and corroborated by these anomalies. Further, although the prosecution’s case was of gang rape by three individuals, the semen of the other two alleged perpetrators was not detected on any forensic exhibit, which wholly demolishes the allegation of collective assault. The chain of custody of the exhibits is equally suspect: there is no record of where the samples were kept between 26 th November 2014 and 27 th November 2014, discrepancies exist in the forwarding letters, and several key documents bear no specimen seals at the time of seizure and sampling. Such glaring lapses make the scientific/forensic evidence inadmissible and incapable of sustaining a conviction, much less the imposition of the death penalty.
5.8. That the trial Court erred in sentencing the accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, and passing the conviction order, awarding the death penalty, on the very same date. It was urged that the trial Court made no effort whatsoever to consider the aggravating and mitigating circumstances before awarding the death penalty. Reliance was placed on the case of Manoj & Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh 26, wherein it has been categorically held that before imposing a sentence of death, the Court is duty-bound to conduct a careful and meaningful evaluation of both aggravating and mitigating factors, including the possibility of reform and 26 2022 SCC OnLine SC 677.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 601Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand rehabilitation of the accused. The omission of the trial Court to undertake this exercise vitiates the sentencing process and renders the award of the death penalty unsustainable in law. On these grounds, learned counsel appearing for the accusedappellants implored the Court to accept the appeals, set aside the impugned judgments, and acquit the accused-appellants of the charges levelled against them.
Submission on behalf of the Respondent/State: -
6. Per contra, Ms. Vanshaja Shukla, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-State, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced on behalf of the accused-appellants and advanced the following pertinent submissions imploring this Court to dismiss the appeals: -
6.1. That the arrest of accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali was based on meticulous mobile surveillance and investigative findings, as evidenced by multiple prosecution witnesses. Yogesh Kumar Chand (PW-10), head of the Special Task Force, testified that accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali had been missing from the crime scene since the date of the incident, prompting the investigation officer to place his mobile number (75xxxxxx90) under surveillance. The Call Details Records (‘CDR’) confirmed that on 20 th November, 2014, and 21 st November, 2014, his cellphone was active within the tower range of the crime scene. Furthermore, another number operating from the same device (both numbers having IMEI Nos. 911352501735790 and 911352501735780) traced his location to Ludhiana, where he was apprehended by Yogesh Kumar Chand (PW-10) and his team. The testimony of Amar Chand Sharma (PW-11), Radhey Shyam Shukla (PW-26), and Arun Kumar (PW-27) corroborates the same, affirming the accuracy of the mobile location tracking. Additionally, Ravindra Kumar Yadav (PW-35), in charge of the Special Operations Group, confirmed that the accusedappellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, was identified through surveillance. These findings unequivocally establish that the arrest of the accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, was lawful and based on concrete evidence, which is corroborated by the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses.
602 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
6.2. That the recovery of the victim-girl’s dead body and subsequent observations made in post-mortem examination provide irrefutable evidence of a brutal sexual assault and murder. Sabir Ali (PW-29), who was tending to his horses in the forest, was the first to locate the deceased’s body and immediately informed the local residents near Ram Leela Ground, Sheeshmahal, establishing the discovery as spontaneous and untainted. Moreover, Suman Pant (PW-3), Sub-Inspector, identified the dead body and conducted the inquest proceedings, noting visible injuries to the vaginal region, indicating that the victim girl was subjected to sexual violence before being done to death. The post-mortem examination further corroborates this conclusion, which was proved by Dr. C.P. Bhaisora (PW-7), i.e., the Medical jurist, who conducted an autopsy upon the victim girl’s dead body. The post-mortem examination conclusively notes that the cause of death was shock and haemorrhage due to injuries inflicted on the vaginal and perianal region associated with grave sexual assault, caused by blunt force impact, and that these injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. This medical evidence not only confirms the horrific nature of the crime but also aligns with the prosecution’s case that the victim girl was subjected to forcible sexual assault and brutal violence, thereby directly implicating the accused-appellants for the heinous and premeditated crime.
6.3. That the scientific and DNA evidence conclusively establishes the involvement of accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, in the crime, leaving no room for doubt. Dr. Sanjeev Kharkwal (PW-13), a Senior Medical Officer at District Hospital, Nainital, collected the blood samples of all the accused persons on 30 th November, 2014 and ensured that the said samples were properly sealed and documented before being handed over to Constable Ashutosh Kumar (PW-15), who deposited them at the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL), Dehradun, on 2 nd December, 2014. The forensic analysis conducted by Dr. Manoj Kumar Agarwal (PW-34) at FSL Dehradun resulted in a DNA profiling report 27 that unequivocally confirmed the presence of human semen on 27 DNA Report dated 12th December, 2014 (Exhibit Ka-75) and DNA Report dated 15th December, 2014 (Exhibit Ka-76)
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 603Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand the cervical swab, undershirt, and underwear of the victim girl. Crucially, the profile of the DNA extracted from these exhibits was an exact match with the DNA profile obtained from the blood sample of accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, conclusively proving his physical involvement in the crime. This scientific evidence, which is objective and beyond human manipulation, serves as the strongest link connecting the accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali to the sexual assault and murder of the victim girl, Ms. K. The DNA report28 provides irrefutable affirmation of accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali’s role in this heinous crime, strengthening the prosecution’s case beyond the pale of doubt.
6.4. That the conduct of the accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali before and after the incident supports the prosecution’s case and conclusively establishes his involvement in the crime. Prior to the victim’s disappearance, multiple witnesses, including Kishan Singh Bora (PW-16), Balkrishna (PW-19), and Sahadat Ali Hasan (PW-20), saw accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali near the location of the crime, corroborating that he was in the vicinity at the relevant time. Vipin Chandra Pant (PW-40), the Investigating Officer (IO), further confirmed this through the site plan, which aligns with the testimony of these witnesses. Additionally, two minor girls who were with the victim girl at the time were offered toffees by accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali, and accused-appellant No.2-Prem Pal Verma, suggesting a deliberate attempt to lure away the victim; however, the families of these children did not allow them to testify due to societal ramifications. The accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali’s suspicious conduct in absconding following the crime further fortifies the prosecution’s case.
6.5. That the site plan prepared by Vipin Chandra Pant (PW-40) establishes that the victim girl was kidnapped from about 800 steps away from where her body was later found. Several witnesses, viz., Veer Bahadur Chand (PW-23, victim’s uncle), Deepak Sharma (PW-25), and Manoj Singh Dewri (PW-31), saw accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali near a dumper (No. 8711) 28 Ibid.
604 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports parked close to the crime scene. Shankar Dutt Padalia (PW-18), the dumper owner, confirmed that accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali was employed as a driver on 20 th November, 2014, but disappeared soon after the crime. His sudden disappearance, as testified by Hariom Sharma (PW-24) (a railway employee), who stated that accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali boarded a train from Haldwani on 21st November, 2014, and fled to Ludhiana, further points to accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali’s guilty state of mind. The CCTV footage handed over by Subhash Singh (PW-21), Assistant General Manager, IDBI Bank, was reviewed by the Investigating Officer, Vipin Chandra Pant (PW-40), confirming that accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali and accusedappellant No.2-Prem Pal Verma, entered the bank together on 21st November, 2014 at 02:04 pm, just after the crime. Thus, the chain of circumstances, as noted by the trial Court and High Court, is complete, leaving no room of doubt about the involvement of the accused-appellants in the crime. The ocular testimonies, scientific/forensic (i.e., DNA examination) evidence, findings of post-mortem examination, and the accused persons’ conduct before and after the incident collectively establish a consistent and unbroken sequence linking accused-appellant No. 1-Akhtar Ali and accused-appellant No. 2-Prem Pal Verma to the crime. Proximity of the accused-appellants to the victim girl during the wedding function, suspicious absconding, and corroborative forensic evidence decisively point to the guilt of accused-appellant No.1-Akhtar Ali.
On these grounds, the learned counsel for the respondent-State contended that the present appeals should be dismissed, as both Courts below have applied the law to the facts on record correctly and reached the only possible conclusion pointing towards the guilt of the accused-appellants.
Discussion: -
7. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at the bar and have carefully scanned the record with the assistance of learned counsel representing the accused-appellants and the learned counsel appearing for the respondent-State. We have also analysed and evaluated the evidence available on record. [2025] 9 S.C.R. 605Akhtar Ali @ Ali Akhtar @ Shamim @ Raja Ustad v. State of Uttarakhand
8. In order to appreciate whether the conviction of the accusedappellants, as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court, deserves to be upheld or whether the appeals merit acceptance, thereby entitling the accused-appellants to acquittal, it is necessary to examine the evidence in greater detail.
9. There is no dispute that the case of the prosecution is based purely on circumstantial evidence in the form of motive, the theory of last seen together, and scientific/forensic evidence, since no witness claims to have seen the alleged incident wherein the victim girl was subjected to sexual assault and violence. The fact that the death of the victim girl, Ms. K, was homicidal in nature was duly proved by the medical evidence on record. Dr. C.P. Bhaisora (PW-7), who conducted the examination, proved the post-mortem report29 wherein multiple injuries were noted on the dead body of the victim girl, particularly on the vaginal and perianal regions. He opined that the cause of death of the victim girl was shock and haemorrhage as a result of the injuries caused by sexual assault and blunt force trauma, which were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. Thus, there is no doubt on the aspect that the death of Ms. K was homicidal in nature.
10. It is a well-established principle of criminal jurisprudence that a conviction may be based purely on circumstantial evidence, provided that such evidence is deemed credible and trustworthy. In cases based purely on circumstantial evidence, it is imperative to ensure that the facts leading to the conclusion of guilt are fully established and that all the established facts point irrefutably to the accused person’s guilt. The chain of incriminating circumstances must be conclusive and should exclude any hypothesis other than the guilt of the accused. In other words, from the chain of incriminating circumstances, no reasonable doubt can be entertained about the accused person’s innocence, demonstrating that it was the accused and none other who committed the offence. The law with regard to conviction based on circumstantial evidence has been crystallised by this Court in the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra30, wherein the following golden principles, governing cases based on circumstantial evidence, were laid down:
29 Exhibit No. Ka24.
30 (1984) 4 SCC 116.
606 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “153. A close analysis of this decision would show that the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to be fully established:
(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances concerned “must or should” and not “may be” established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal distinction between “may be proved” and “must be or should be proved” as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC 793] where the observations were made: [SCC para 19, p. 807] “Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance between ‘may be’ and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.
(emphasis supplied)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.