Chowdamma (D) By Lr and Another v. Venkatappa (D) By LRs and Another
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1038; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1532
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 25 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11330/2011
- Sections
- 50, 114, 101, 102
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1532 : 2025 INSC 1038 Chowdamma (D) by LR and Another v.
Venkatappa (D) by LRs and Another (Civil Appeal No. 11330 of 2011)
25 August 2025 [Sanjay Karol and Prashant Kumar Mishra,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the respondents succeeded in establishing a valid marital relationship between their mother and the deceased primarily on the basis of the oral testimony of P.W.2; and whether the relationship between the deceased and the respondents’ mother can be presumed to be a valid marital union, in the absence of formal documentary proof.
Headnotes† Evidence Act, 1872 – s.50 – Proof of relationship – Presumption of marriage – Appellant no.1-second wife of deceased, exerted her influence, and got the names of herself and her children entered in the revenue records – On basis thereof, the appellants-second wife and her son declined to acknowledge the respondents-children of first wife of the deceased as being in joint possession of the suit schedule properties – Respondents sought partition of suit property – Appellant’s case that the appellant no.1 is the only wife of the deceased, and thus, the respondents have no right, title, or interest over the suit schedule properties; that they denied the marriage of the deceased with the respondent’s mother and claimed that they inherited the properties pursuant to a partition effected between the deceased and his brother – Trial Court dismissed the suit – High Court decreed the suit in favour of the respondents relying on the evidence of P.W.2 which established the relationship of the respondents’ mother with the deceased – Correctness:
Held: Testimony of P.W.2 being that of a person residing in the same village and having a long-standing familiarity with both the respondents and the appellants, coupled with his awareness of the events pertaining to the relationship between the deceased and the * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1533Chowdamma (D) by LR and Another v.
Venkatappa (D) by LRs and Another respondents’ mother, cannot be dismissed as mere hearsay – On the contrary, it reflects a narration of events personally witnessed or known to him directly – Such evidence, being rooted in personal knowledge, falls within the ambit of s.50 – Thus, in the absence of contemporaneous documentary evidence, the evidence of P.W.2 assumes evidentiary significance in establishing the nature of the relationship between the deceased and the respondents’ mother – His evidence is consistent with s.50 and is being rooted in personal knowledge and long-standing acquaintance with both the respondents and appellants – P.W.2’s testimony was unimpeached in the cross-examination and warrants an inference in favour of the subsistence of a valid marital relationship between the deceased and the respondent’s mother – Though genealogical tree, by itself, does not constitute conclusive proof, it operates as corroborative evidence and, when read along with the oral testimony of P.W.2, it supports the inference of a valid marital relation between the deceased and the respondents’ mother – As regards the presumption of marriage, plaintiffs have discharged the burden of proof placed upon them – They have sufficiently established that the deceased lived with their mother, as husband and wife – Appellants failed to discharge their onus to disprove the factum of a valid marriage between the respondents’ mother and the deceased – Furthermore, reliance on the revenue records is of no avail, as such records only hold presumptive value and don’t confer title – Appellant no.1, though physically present in the court during the trial, abstained from stepping into the witness box to rebut the respondents’ assertions as also wilfully bypassed the statutory remedy available to those pleading physical incapacity – In the absence of cogent medical evidence to support her alleged incapacity, her abstention from the witness box constitutes deliberate circumvention of the evidentiary burden resting upon her – Adverse presumption u/s.114(g) of the Evidence Act is inevitable – Court of law cannot offer refuge to studied silence where a duty to disclose exists – Respondents anchored their claim in measured and unwavering testimony of P.W.2, an account rooted in personal knowledge and long-standing familiarity, which withstood the rigours of cross-examination – His evidence, unshaken and consistent, found further corroboration in the genealogical chart presented by the respondents – It, thus, stands established that the respondents have discharged the evidentiary burden imposed upon them by law – In contrast, the appellants, bereft of probative material or candour, resorted solely to denials – When measured 1534 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports against the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities, the scales unambiguously tilt in favour of the respondents – Impugned judgment does not suffer from any infirmity to warrant interference. [Paras 25, 30-32, 42, 48, 49, 55-57, 59, 60] Case Law Cited Dolgobinda Paricha v. Nimai Charan Misra and Ors. [1959] Supp. 1 SCR 814 : AIR 1959 SC 914; State of Bihar v. Radha Krishna Singh and Ors. [1983] 2 SCR 808 : (1983) 3 SCC 118; Badri Prasad v. Dy. Director of Consolidation and Ors. [1979] 1 SCR 1 : (1978) 3 SCC 527; Anil Rishi v. Gurbaksh Singh [2006] Supp. 1 SCR 659 : (2006) 5 SCC 558; Addagada Raghavamma and Anr. v. Addagada Chenchamma and Anr. [1964] 2 SCR 933 : 1963 SCC OnLine SC 37; Suraj Bhan and Ors. v. Financial Commissioner and Ors. [2007] 5 SCR 155 : (2007) 6 SCC 186; Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao and Anr. [1999] 1 SCR 1168 : (1999) 3 SCC 573 – referred to. Andrahennedige Dinohamy and Anr. v. Wijetunge Liyanapatabendige Balahamy and Ors., 1927 SCC OnLine PC 51; Mohabbat Ali Khan (Plaintiff) v. Mahomed Ibrahim Khan and Ors. (Defendants), 1929 SCC OnLine PC 21 – referred to.
List of Acts Evidence Act, 1872; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Partition; Valid marital relationship; Oral testimony; Presumed to be a valid marital union; Absence of formal documentary proof; Revenue records; Joint possession of the suit schedule properties; Long-standing familiarity; Community-level proximity; Acquaintance with the familial relations; Special means of knowledge; Prolonged cohabitation; Presumption in favour of a valid wedlock; Burden of proof; Revenue records hold presumptive value; Abstention from the witness box; Personal knowledge; Legitimacy of the relationship; Conclusive proof; Corroborative evidence; Interested witness; Exerted influence; Change in revenue entries.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11330 of 2011 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.10.2010 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in RFA No. 935 of 2005 [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1535Chowdamma (D) by LR and Another v.
Venkatappa (D) by LRs and Another Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Ms. Kiran Suri, Sr. Adv., S.J. Amith, Ms. Aishwarya Kumar, Dr. Mrs. Vipin Gupta.
Advs. for the Respondents:
G V Chandrashekar, Sr. Adv., N K Verma, Ms. Apeksha D, Ms. Anjana Chandrashekar.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
1. This Appeal calls in question the impugned order dated 28.10.2010 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in Regular First Appeal No.935 of 2005, whereby the High Court allowed the said appeal filed by the plaintiffs and set aside the judgment of the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division) Holalkere, dated 24.03.2005 in O.S No.102/2001, consequently decreed the suit for partition filed by the plaintiffs.
2. The defendants in O.S.No.102/2001 are the appellants herein, and the plaintiffs are respondents. The parties shall be referred to as per their position before the Trial Court for convenience.
The genealogical chart germane to the present dispute is as under: DASABOVI @ DASAPPA (Elder Son)
VENKATAPPA
(Younger Son)
THIMMABOVI VELLAPPA
BHEEMAKKA @ SATHYAKKA (First Wife)
CHOWDAMMA
(Second Wife)
Defendant No.1/ Appellant No.1
BALACHANDRAPPA
Defendant No.2/ Appellant No.2
VENKATAPPA
Palintiff No.1/ Respondent No.1
SIDAMMA
Palintiff No.2/ Respondent No.2 1536 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The case of the plaintiffs is that their grandfather, namely Thimmabovi Vellappa, had two sons: Dasabovi @ Dasappa and Venkatappa. Dasabovi had two wives. The first wife, Bheemakka @ Sathyakka, is the mother of the plaintiffs. The second wife, Chowdamma, is defendant No.1, and their son is defendant No.2. Dasabovi died about five years prior to the filing of the suit, leaving behind plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 and defendant Nos.1 and 2. The suit schedule lands bearing Survey Nos.39/1B, 149, 41/lP, 37/1, 37/lA, and 29/9, and the house bearing No.38, situated in Devigere and Kallahally village, Hosadurga Taluk.
4. About five years prior to the filing of the suit, during the lifetime of Dasabovi’s father, the properties were divided between the father of the plaintiffs and his brother, Venkatappa. As a consequence, the suit schedule lands and the house property fell into the share of Dasabovi. After the partition, the plaintiffs became the manager of the joint family properties, and both the plaintiffs and the defendants were cultivating the suit schedule properties.
5. During the lifetime of Dasabovi, another property bearing No. 37/1 of Kallahally Village, Hosadurga, was purchased out of joint family funds and in the name of the joint family. However, the said property was registered in the name of defendant No.1 (Chowdamma).
6. After the birth of plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 to the first wife of Dasabovi, he fell in love with defendant No.1 (Chowdamma) and entered into a relationship with her. After some time, she was brought into his house and began living with him as his wife. In view of the second wife entering the house, the first wife and her children were driven out. Consequently, Bheemakka, the first wife, along with the plaintiffs, went to her paternal home at Antharagange Village.
7. Even though the first wife and her children left the house of Dasabovi, he continued to visit them on several occasions. After the death of Dasabovi, the plaintiffs also visited their father’s residence at Galirangaiahnahatti Village, as they were in joint possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties.
8. It is alleged that defendant No.1, who was a Panchayat member, exerted her influence, and got the names of herself and her children entered in the revenue records. Based on the change in the revenue [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1537Chowdamma (D) by LR and Another v.
Venkatappa (D) by LRs and Another entries, the defendants declined to acknowledge the plaintiffs as being in joint possession of the suit schedule properties. Hence, the plaintiffs were compelled to demand their share in the family properties. Having been denied the same, the plaintiffs have filed O.S.No.102/2001 seeking partition of the suit schedule property to the extent of half share, along with other consequential reliefs.
9. The defendants contended that the defendant No.1 is the only wife of the deceased Dasabovi, and hence, the plaintiffs have no right, title, or interest over the suit schedule properties. They denied the marriage of Dasabovi with the plaintiffs’ mother and claimed that they inherited the properties pursuant to a partition effected between the deceased Dasabovi and his brother Venkatappa.
10. The Trial Court, on framing six issues, dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs. Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiffs filed a Regular First Appeal being Regular First Appeal No.935/2005 before the High Court. The High Court, after relying on the evidence of P.W.2 (Hanumanthappa), which established the relationship of the plaintiffs’ mother with the deceased Dasabovi and observing that the defendants’ reliance was based solely on denial, further noted that defendant No.1 had deliberately chosen not to enter the witness box.
11. Considering the above, the High Court set aside the judgment of the Trial Court in O.S. No.102/2001 and decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs. Aggrieved thereby, the present Appeal has been preferred by the defendants.
SUBMISSIONS
12. The learned counsel for the defendants/appellants submitted that the High Court clearly erred in setting aside a well-reasoned judgment and decree rendered by the Trial Court. It is contended that the plaintiffs/ respondents were admittedly not residing in the village where the suit schedule property is situated. Hence, their claim that they were in joint possession of the suit schedule property is unsustainable. It is further contended that the plaintiffs/respondents have miserably failed to adduce cogent and reliable evidence to prove that the plaintiffs’ mother was married to Dasabovi. Mere submission of genealogical tree is not a proof of factum of marriage. It is strenuously urged that the High Court was wholly unjustified in drawing adverse inference for defendant no.1’s failure to depose as she was medically unfit 1538 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports due to arthritis. It is also argued that the plaintiffs failed to discharge the burden of proving existence of a valid marriage between their mother and Dasabovi. It is further argued that the High Court failed to appreciate that the revenue records are in the name of the defendants and despite challenge by the plaintiffs, the higher revenue authorities dismissed their claim holding that they have failed to prove that they are the legal heirs of deceased Dasabovi.
13. Per contra, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs/respondents has argued that the Trial Court recorded a perverse finding in respect of the marriage of plaintiffs’ mother with Dasabovi despite there being sufficient evidence on record. In such a view of the matter, the High Court has rightly set aside the judgment of the Trial Court which does not warrant interference in this Appeal. According to the learned counsel for the plaintiffs/respondents, a reading of plaintiffs’ evidence, particularly the evidence of P.W.2 (Hanumanthappa), would clearly prove that the plaintiffs’ mother was married to Dasabovi. Defendant No.1 has not entered the witness box to disapprove the said fact. The High Court has rightly concluded that the plaintiffs’ mother was married to Dasabovi. It is further argued that the revenue records are neither proof of title nor the said could be used to prove the factum of marriage. The plaintiffs having successfully discharged their burden of proof, the onus shifted on the defendants which was not discharged by them. Therefore, the finding regarding marriage is unimpeachable. The learned counsel for the respondents would pray for dismissal of this Appeal.
ANALYSIS
14. We have heard the learned counsel for both the parties and perused the material available on record.
15. The case of the defendants is that one Thimmabovi Vellappa had two sons, namely Dasabovi and Venkatappa. A partition was effected in the year 1962-1963 and Items Nos. 1 to 3 fell to the share of Dasabovi. It is further stated that Items Nos. 4 to 6 were subsequently purchased by Dasabovi through registered sale deeds. The defendants contend that the deceased Dasabovi never married the mother of the plaintiffs, and that defendant No.1, Chowdamma, is the only wife of the deceased Dasabovi. The defendants further submitted that the plaintiffs were never in possession of the suit [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1539Chowdamma (D) by LR and Another v.
Venkatappa (D) by LRs and Another schedule properties, and denied that the plaintiffs and defendants were residing together in Galirangaiahnahatti or Kallahalli jointly.
16. The plaintiffs, on the other hand, contend that their mother was the first wife of the deceased Dasabovi. They stated that, after he married a younger woman, their mother was forced to leave the matrimonial home and reside at her parental house. It is admitted by both parties that the properties standing in the name of the deceased Dasabovi were ancestral in nature.
17. The principal issue that arises for our consideration is whether the plaintiffs have succeeded in establishing a valid marital relationship between their mother, Bheemakka @ Sathyakka, and the deceased Dasabovi, primarily on the basis of the oral testimony of P.W.2 (Hanumanthappa).
18. The High Court, while considering the issue of valid marital relationship between the plaintiffs’ mother and the deceased Dasabovi, relied on the evidence of P.W.2 (Hanumanthappa). The witness stated in his evidence that he knows the families of both the plaintiffs and the defendants. He further stated in his evidence that deceased Dasabovi married the plaintiffs’ mother, Bheemakka, and through her, begot plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2. Later, the deceased Dasabovi married defendant no.1, which led to the plaintiffs’ mother being ousted from the matrimonial home. Thereafter, she resided in her parental home in Antharagange village. The witness further deposed that the deceased Dasabovi would regularly visit the plaintiffs and their mother at Antharagange village. P.W.2 also stated that even after the death of the deceased, the plaintiffs used to visit their father’s village to attend the agricultural operations regularly.
19. It is observed that, both P.W.1 (Venkatappa) and D.W.1 (Balachandrappa) being interested witnesses, their evidence cannot be relied upon to establish the relation between the deceased Dasabovi and the plaintiffs’ mother. Further, D.W.3 (Thimmappa), who is the son of the sister of the father of Dasabovi, supports the claim of the defendants. However, he has no knowledge of any marriage between the deceased Dasabovi and the plaintiffs’ mother. D.W.4 (V. Thimmappa), who is the son of Dasabovi’s brother, has also deposed on similar lines with D.W.3.
20. In the present case, there is a paucity of documentary and contemporaneous material to conclusively establish the marital 1540 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports relationship between the deceased Dasabovi and the mother of the plaintiffs. In such circumstances, the best possible evidence assumes crucial significance. The testimony of P.W.2 (Hanumanthappa) is the sole evidence adduced in support of the existence of such a relationship. Accordingly, the evidentiary value of the testimony of the P.W.2 must be examined in light of the principles laid down under Section 50 of the Indian Evidence Act 18721 .
PROOF OF RELATIONSHIP
21. Section 50 of the Evidence Act makes provision regarding “Opinion on relationship, when relevant”. The said provision is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
“50. Opinion on relationship, when relevant.––When the Court has to form an opinion as to the relationship of one person to another, the opinion, expressed by conduct, as to the existence of such relationship, or any person who, as a member of the family or otherwise, has special means of knowledge on the subject, is a relevant fact:
Provided that such opinion shall not be sufficient to prove a marriage in proceedings under the Indian Divorce Act, 1869 (4 of 1869), or in prosecution under sections 494, 495, 497 or 498 of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860).
Illustrations
(a) The question is, whether A and B, were married.
The fact that they were usually received and treated by their friends as husband and wife, is relevant.
(b) The question is, whether A was the legitimate son of B. The fact that A was always treated as such by members of the family, is relevant.”
22. The principle underlying Section 50 of the Evidence Act has been explained by this Court in Dolgobinda Paricha v. Nimai Charan Misra and Ors.2, wherein this Court observed thus:
1 For short, “the Evidence Act”
2 AIR 1959 SC 914.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1541Chowdamma (D) by LR and Another v.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.