Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (Cesc) v. Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1034; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1493
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kumar, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 25 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6888/2018
- Sections
- 109
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1493 : 2025 INSC 1034 Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (CESC)
v.
Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 6888 of 2018)
25 August 2025 [Sanjay Kumar and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The following questions arise for determination: (i) the effect of respondent no.2/KPTCL’s delay in commissioning the 220 kV evacuation system upon the timelines stipulated for fulfilment of the CPs and achievement of COD under the PPA; (ii) the entitlement of appellant to invoke and encash the performance bank guarantee in the facts of the present case; (iii) the sustainability of the finding of Force Majeure recorded by the State Commission in the absence of the contractual notice contemplated under Article 14.5 of the PPA; (iv) the character of the PPA as a contingent contract; and
(v) the competence of the State Commission and the APTEL to direct restoration of the bank guarantee, extension of timelines, and renegotiation of tariff.
Headnotes† Electricity Act, 2003 – APTEL affirmed the order dated 28.01.2015 of the Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commission (State Commission/KERC), whereby the State Commission directed Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Corporation Limited, the appellant herein, to restore to the Developer i.e. respondent no.1 herein, the amount realised from the encashment of the performance bank guarantee; extend the timelines for fulfilment of contractual obligations; and to undertake renegotiation of the tariff under the Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) for a solar power project:
Held: 1. Appellant’s invocation and encashment of the performance security was in full conformity with the contractual framework under the PPA – The non-fulfilment of the respondent no.1/Developer’s obligations within the stipulated time, non-seeking of extension under Article 5.7 or valid Force Majeure claim under Article 14, necessarily attracted Article 4.4 of the PPA – The impugned * Author 1494 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports judgment dated 21.03.2018 of the APTEL passed in Appeal No.176 of 2015, and the order dated 28.01.2015 of the State Commission in O.P. No.24 of 2014 are set aside. [Paras 44-45]
2. The record discloses beyond dispute that the evacuation system, integral for delivery of power, was to be executed by respondent no.2/KPTCL through the construction of two 220 kV double-circuit lines – By its communication dated 19.08.2014, respondent no.2/ KPTCL itself acknowledged that the lines would be commissioned only in August 2015, well beyond the contractual timelines – The respondent no.1/Developer submission that such delay, being beyond its control, automatically extended the contractual schedule, cannot be accepted – The contractual framework does not operate on automaticity – Contractual rights and remedies must be asserted within the framework of the agreement, not dehors it. [Paras 37-38]
3. Turning then to the invocation of the performance bank guarantee, in the present case, supply did not commence within the agreed period; no formal extension was obtained under Article 5.7 of the PPA; and no notice of Force Majeure was issued under Article 14.5 of the PPA – The preconditions for invocation of Article 4.4 of the PPA thus stood satisfied – Appellant’s invocation of the bank guarantee was, therefore, an exercise of a remedy specifically conferred by the contract, and to deny it would be to disregard the allocation of risk embodied in the PPA. [Para 39]
4. The finding of Force Majeure by the State Commission cannot be sustained for the reason that Article 14.5 of the PPA stipulates that the affected party “shall” issue notice within seven days of knowledge of the event – This requirement is not merely directory; it is a condition precedent for invoking the clause – Even if the delay in completion of the evacuation system was beyond the respondent no.1/Developer’s control, the appropriate provision for relief was Article 5.7, not Article 14 of the PPA – Significantly, Article 14.3.1 of the PPA details the events and circumstances which constitute Force Majeure and delay in the readiness of the evacuation system, even if attributable to Respondent No.2/KPTCL, does not constitute a Force Majeure. [Para 40]
5. The completion of the evacuation system by respondent no.2/ KPTCL was indeed an uncertain event outside the respondent no.1/Developer’s control, and in a practical sense, supply of power was dependent upon it – Yet, the PPA does not treat such [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1495Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (CESC) v. Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
completion as a condition precedent in law to the Respondent No.1/ Developer’s obligations – It instead provides specific contractual mechanism(s)-Article 5.7 for delays attributable to the appellant and Article 14 for events of Force Majeure – Unless relief is sought and secured under those provisions, the time-bound obligations under the PPA remain enforceable and the Appellant’s remedies for default intact. [Para 41]
6. Finally, as to the competence of the regulatory fora, appellant and respondent no. 2/KPTCL, though both State instrumentalities, are parties to a commercial contract concluded through competitive bidding – Their relationship is governed not by overarching notions of equity but by the terms of the PPA – The jurisdiction of the regulatory bodies is to ensure compliance with law and to adjudicate disputes within the four corners of the contract. [Para 43] Law of Contract – Explicit terms of contract – Intention of parties:
Held: It is settled that the explicit terms of a contract are always the final word with regard to the intention of the parties – This Court has, in a consistent line of judgements, reiterated that regulatory or adjudicatory fora cannot, under the guise of equity or fairness, rewrite the contractual framework or superimpose obligations alien to the agreement – The PPA, being the product of a competitive bidding process and having received regulatory approval, must be construed and enforced strictly in accordance with its express stipulations – To permit otherwise would be to allow the State Commission or the APTEL to override the parties own allocation of risk under the contract. [Para 42] Case Law Cited Venkataraman Krishnamurthy & Anr. v. Lodha Crown Buildmart Pvt. Ltd. (2024) 4 SCC 230 – referred to.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003.
List of Keywords Delay in commissioning the 220 kV evacuation system; Encashing the performance bank guarantee; Force Majeure; Contingent 1496 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports contract; Restoration of the bank guarantee; Power Purchase Agreement; Law of Contract; Explicit terms of contract; Intention of parties; Jurisdiction of the regulatory bodies.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6888 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.03.2018 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi in A No. 176 of 2015 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Dhruv Mehta, Sr. Adv., Ms. Garima Jain, Tushar Kanti Mahindroo, Arnav Khanna.
Advs. for the Respondents:
C. Mohan Rao, Sr. Adv., Gowtham Polanki, Snehasish Mukherjee. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Satish Chandra Sharma, J.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
1. This appeal is arising from the judgment dated 21.03.2018 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, New Delhi (the “APTEL”), whereby the APTEL has affirmed the order dated 28.01.2015 of the Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commission (the “State Commission”/“KERC”), whereby the State Commission directed Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Corporation Limited, the Appellant herein, to restore to the Developer i.e. Respondent No. 1 herein, the amount realised from the encashment of the performance bank guarantee; extend the timelines for fulfilment of contractual obligations; and to undertake renegotiation of the tariff under the Power Purchase Agreement (the “PPA”) for a solar power project.
2. The Appellant, Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Limited (“Chamundeshwari”/“CESC”), is a distribution licensee wholly owned by the State of Karnataka. The Respondent No. 2, Karnataka [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1497Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (CESC) v. Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
Power Transmission Corporation Limited (“KPTCL”), is the State transmission utility and a statutory corporation. Both entities are State instrumentalities engaged in discharging public functions under the Electricity Act, 2003. The Respondent No. 1, M/s Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. (the “Developer”) a special purpose vehicle promoted and incorporated by M/s Saisudhir Energy Limited, a private generating company selected pursuant to a competitive bidding process for the establishment of a 10 MW solar power project in Chitradurga District.
3. The lis traces its origin to a request for proposal issued by the Karnataka Renewable Energy Development Limited (the “KREDL”) inviting bids for selection of Solar Power Developers (the “SPDs”) to establish grid-connected solar power plants in the State of Karnataka. The bidding process was conducted under the aegis of the State’s solar policy to promote renewable energy capacity. Pursuant to the competitive bidding process, the Respondent No. 1/Developer was selected for development of a 10 MW solar photovoltaic power project at Thallaku Village, Challakere Taluk, Chitradurga District, Karnataka.
4. On 30.08.2012, Appellant and the Respondent No. 1/Developer executed a PPA for procurement of 10 MW solar power at a tariff of Rs. 8.49/kWh, approved by KERC. The PPA envisaged achievement of Commercial Operation Date (the “COD”) within 12 months from the Effective Date, preceded by satisfaction of “Conditions Precedent” (the “CPs”) under Article 4 of the PPA, within 240 days.
5. On 28.05.2013, the parties executed a supplementary PPA, inter alia, aligning the commissioning schedule and other contractual timelines with the State Commission’s tariff order and clarifying the delivery point and interconnection facilities. It reaffirmed that CPs were to be fulfilled within 240 days and COD achieved within 12 months thereafter. The CPs obliged the Respondent No. 1/Developer to acquire land, secure statutory approvals, achieve financial closure, enter into connectivity agreements, and ensure readiness of the evacuation system in coordination with Respondent No. 2/KPTCL.
6. The project site was finalised at Village Thallaku, Challakere Taluk, Chitradurga. The Respondent No. 1/Developer obtained permission under Section 109 of the Karnataka Land Reforms Act for acquisition 1498 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of 49.36 acres by the order of the Deputy Commissioner dated 19.02.2014.
7. The evacuation scheme prepared by Respondent No. 2/KPTCL envisaged connection of the project to the State grid through the commissioning of two specific 220 kV double-circuit transmission lines: one between Birenhalli and Thallak; and another between Hiriyur and Gowribidnur. The readiness of these lines was, in effect, a technical and operational precondition for the grant of synchronisation approval as outlined in letter dated 06.02.2014.
8. On 05.04.2014, the Respondent No. 1/Developer sought Appellant’s assistance for securing approvals and requested extension of the COD, citing delay in Respondent No. 2/KPTCL’s commissioning of the 220 kV lines. Vide letter dated 17.05.2014, Appellant stated that extension could be considered only on condition of a reduced tariff from Rs. 8.49/kWh to Rs. 2.39/kWh. The Respondent No. 1/Developer contested this reduction and approached the State Commission by way of O.P. No. 24 of 2014, seeking inter-alia; i) restoration of the performance bank guarantee; ii) extension of timelines; and iii) consequential direction for tariff renegotiation, thereby retaining the original tariff. Pertinently, vide an interim order dated 14.11.2014, the State Commission directed Appellant herein not to encash the performance security/bank guarantee.
9. During pendency, the Respondent No. 1/Developer addressed further letters seeking extension of time for CPs fulfilment, pointing to the dependency on Respondent No. 2/KPTCL’s works. In response to a Right to Information application, Respondent No. 2/KPTCL confirmed that the 220 kV lines were likely to be commissioned only in August 2015, well beyond the original CP and COD timelines.
10. Due to the inability to evacuate the contracted power, Appellant claims to have procured power from alternate sources at higher rates, incurring losses to the tune of Rs. 48.65 crores. The Respondent No. 1/Developer, on the other hand, faced encashment of the performance bank guarantee to the tune of Rs. 24.9 crores despite COD being rendered impossible due to Respondent No. 2/KPTCL’s admitted delay.
11. Vide final order dated 28.01.2015, the State Commission held that the delay in completion of the evacuation system constituted [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1499Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (CESC) v. Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
a Force Majeure event under the PPA and accordingly ordered:
(i) restoration of the encashed performance security to the Respondent No. 1/Developer; (ii) extension of the contractual timelines and
(iii) renegotiation of the project tariff in the light of the revised commissioning schedule.
12. Aggrieved by the orders passed by the State Commission, Appellant filed Appeal No. 176 of 2015 before the APTEL and APTEL vide the impugned order dismissed the appeal filed by the Appellant thereby affirming the findings and directions of the State Commission. It is against this concurrent view of the fora below that Appellant has approached this Court in the present appeal.
SUBMISSIONS BY THE APPELLANT
13. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for Appellant submits at the outset that the dispute cannot be adjudicated without first appreciating the essential character of the agreement between the parties. It is urged that the PPA, executed on 30.08.2012 and supplementary PPA on 28.05.2013, is in its essence a contingent contract within the meaning of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (the “Contract Act”). The PPA is a self-contained commercial arrangement concluded through competitive bidding. Its terms allocate risk and provide specific remedies.
14. Obligation to achieve the COD within the stipulated period is, by the very structure of the PPA, inextricably linked to the readiness of the evacuation system - a responsibility that rests squarely on Respondent No. 2/KPTCL, the State transmission utility. In the absence of such readiness, Respondent No. 1 was aware that synchronisation and injection of power into the grid is technically impossible.
15. Inviting our attention to Article(s) 4 and 5 of the PPA, learned Senior Counsel submits that while Article 4 sets out the CPs to be duly complied with by the Respondent No. 1/Developer within the stipulated timelines, Article 5 enumerates the substantive obligations to be discharged in furtherance of the contractual scheme. It is urged that the framework of these provisions does not contemplate any dilution of responsibility on the premise that certain elements may require coordination with other agencies, or may otherwise lie beyond the control of the Respondent No. 1/Developer. The said Article(s), in material part, provide as follows:
1500 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “ARTICLE 4: CONDITION PRECEDENT 4.1 Condition Precedent Save and except as expressly provided in Articles 4, 14, 18, 20 or unless the context otherwise requires, the respective rights and obligations of the Parties under this Agreement shall be subject to the satisfaction in full of the conditions precedent specified in this Clause 4 (the “Conditions Precedent”) by the Developer within 240 (two hundred and forty) days from the Effective Date, unless such completion is affected by any Force Majeure event, or if any of the activities is specifically waived in writing by CESC Mysore.
4.2 Conditions Precedent for the Developer The Conditions Precedent are required to be satisfied by the Developer shall be deemed to have been fulfilled when the Developer shall have:
a) obtained all Consents, Clearances and Permits required for supply of power to CESC Mysore as per the terms of this Agreement;
b) not Applicable c) achieved Financial Closure and provided a certificate to CESC Mysore from the lead banker to this effect;
d) made adequate arrangements to connect the Power Project switchyard with the Interconnection Facilities at the Delivery Point;
e) obtained power evacuation approval from [Karnataka Power Transmission Company Limited (“KPTCL”)/CESC Mysore, as the case may be];
f) produced as per the requirements set out in Schedule 1, the documentary evidence of having the clear title and possession of the land required for the Project in the name of Developer;
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1501Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (CESC) v. Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
g) fulfilled Technical Requirements for Solar PV Project as per the format provided in Schedule 2 and also provides the documentary evidence for the same;
h) delivered to CESC Mysore from confirmation, in original, of compliance with the equity lock-in condition as set out in 5.2; and i) delivered to CESC Mysore a legal opinion from the legal counsel of the Developer with respect to the authority of the Developer to enter into this Agreement and the enforceability of the provisions thereof.
4.2.1 Developer shall make all reasonable endeavours to satisfy the Conditions Precedent within the time stipulated and CESC Mysore shall provide to the Developer all the reasonable cooperation as may be required to the Developer for satisfying the Conditions Precedent.
4.2.2 The Developer shall notify CESC Mysore in writing at least once a month on the progress made in satisfying the Conditions Precedent. Developer shall promptly inform the CESC Mysore when any Conditions Precedent is satisfied by it.
4.3 Damages for delay by the Developer In the event that the Developer does not procure fulfillment of any or all of the Conditions Precedent set forth in Clause 4.2 within the period of 240 days and the delay has not occurred for any reasons attributable to CESC Mysore or due to Force Majeure, the Developer shall pay to CESC Mysore Damages in an amount calculated at the rate of 0.2% (zero point two per cent) of the Performance Security for each day’s delay until the fulfillment of such Conditions Precedent, subject to a maximum period of 30 (thirty) days. On expiry of the said 30 (thirty) days, CESC Mysore at its discretion may terminate this Agreement.
1502 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 4.4 Performance Security a) For due and punctual performance of its obligations under this Agreement, relating to the Project, the Developer has delivered to CESC Mysore, simultaneously with the execution of this Agreement, an irrevocable and revolving bank guarantees from a scheduled bank acceptable to CESC Mysore for an amount of Rs. 24,90,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Four Crores Ninety Lakhs only) (“Performance Security”). The Performance Security is furnished to CESC Mysore in the form of three bank guarantees in favour of Managing Director of the CESC Mysore as per the format provided in Schedule 3 and having validity up to 1 year from the Commercial Operation Date. The details of the bank guarantees furnished towards the Performance Security are given below;
(i) Bank Guarantee No. 2657BG3652012 dated 24 August, 2012 for an amount of Rs. 4,98,00,000/- (Rupees Four Crores Ninety Eight Lakhs only);
(ii) Bank Guarantee No. 2657BG3662012 dated 24 August, 2012 for an amount of Rs. 9,96,00,000/- (Rupees Nine Crores Ninety Six Lakhs only); and
(iii) Bank Guarantee No. 2657BG3672012 dated 24 August 2012 for an amount of Rs. 9,96,00,000/- (Rupees Nine Crores Ninety Six Lakhs only).
b) Appropriation of Performance Security Upon occurrence of a Developer Default or failure to meet the Conditions Precedent by the Developer, CESC Mysore shall, without prejudice to its other rights and remedies hereunder or in law, be entitled to encash and appropriate the relevant amounts from the Performance Security as Damages for such Developer Default or Conditions Precedent. Upon such encashment and appropriation from the Performance Security, the Developer shall, within 30 (thirty) days thereof, replenish, in case of partial appropriation, to its original level the Performance Security, and in case of appropriation of the entire Performance Security provide a fresh Performance [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1503Chamundeshwari Electricity Supply Company Ltd. (CESC) v. Saisudhir Energy (Chitradurga) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
Security, as the case may be, and the Developer shall, within the time so granted, replenish or furnish fresh Performance Security as aforesaid failing which CESC Mysore shall be entitled to terminate this Agreement in accordance with Article 16.
c) Release of Performance Security Subject to other provisions of this Agreement, CESC Mysore shall release the Performance Security, if any within 1 year from the Commercial Operation Date.
The release of the Performance Security shall be without prejudice to other rights of CESC Mysore under this Agreement.”
“ARTICLE 5: OBLIGATION OF THE DEVELOPER 5.1 Obligations of the Developer 5.1.1 Subject to and on the terms and conditions of this Agreement, the Developer shall at its own cost and expense;
a) procure finance for and undertake the designing, constructing, erecting, testing, commissioning and completing of the Power Project in accordance with the Applicable Law and Grid Code observe, fulfill, comply with and perform all its obligations set out in this Agreement or arising hereunder;
b) comply with all Applicable Laws and obtain applicable Consents, Clearances and Permits (including renewals as required) in the performance of its obligations under this Agreement and maintaining all Applicable Permits in full force and effect during the Term of this Agreement; c) commence supply of power up to the Contracted Capacity to CESC Mysore no later than the Scheduled Commissioning Date and continue the supply of power throughout the term of the Agreement;
d) connect the Power Project switchyard with the Interconnection Facilities at the Delivery Point;
1504 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports e) own the Power Project throughout the Term of Agreement and keep it free and clear of encumbrances, except those expressly permitted under Article 19; and f) comply with the equity lock-in conditions set out in Clause 5.2; and g) be responsible for all payments related to any taxes, cesses, duties or levies imposed by the Government Instrumentalities or competent statutory authority on land, equipment, material or works of the project to or on the electricity consumed by the Project or by itself or on the income or assets owned by it;
h) be responsible for the construction of additional bays in case required;
i) construct and carry out the maintenance of the transmission line up to the Delivery Point, during the Agreement Period and pay applicable supervision charges to the concerned Government Instrumentality;
j) make arrangements for auxiliary consumption and bear all the related costs for the same.
5.1.2 The Developer shall discharge its obligations in accordance with Good Industry Practice and as a reasonable and prudent person.
5.1.3 The Developer shall, at its own cost and expense, in addition to and not in derogation of its obligations elsewhere set out in this Agreement:
a) make, or cause to be made, necessary applications to the relevant government agencies with such particulars and details, as may be required for obtaining Applicable Permits and obtain and keep in force and effect such Applicable Permits in conformity with the Applicable Laws; b) procure, as required, the appropriate proprietary rights, licenses, agreements and permissions for materials, methods, processes and systems used or incorporated into the Power Project;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.