Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 893; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1543
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 25 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3177/2025
- Sections
- 174, 194, 304, 302, 193(2), 173(2), 18, 115
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1543 : 2025 INSC 893 Sukdeb Saha v.
The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No. 3177 of 2025)
25 July 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue of growing crisis of student suicides in educational institutions; need for a preventive, remedial, and supportive framework for mental health protection and prevention of suicides by students; whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the High Court erred in rejecting the appellant’s prayer for transfer of the investigation to the CBI in the suspicious death of his 17-year-old daughter, who was undergoing coaching for NEET examination.
Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art.21 – Right to Mental Health – Growing crisis of student suicides – Mental health crisis afflicting students in educational institutions inter alia, including schools, coaching institutes, colleges and training centres – Comprehensive binding interim guidelines issued:
Held: 1.1 All educational institutions to adopt and implement a uniform mental health policy, drawing cues from the UMMEED (Understand, Motivate, Manage, Empathise, Empower, and Develop) Draft Guidelines, the MANODARPAN initiative, and the National Suicide Prevention Strategy – This policy shall be reviewed and updated annually and made publicly accessible on institutional websites and notice boards of the institutes. [Para 35] 1.2 All educational institutions with 100 or more enrolled students to appoint/engage at least one qualified counsellor, psychologist, or social worker with training in child and adolescent mental health – Institutions with fewer students to establish formal referral linkages with external mental health professionals. [Para 35] * Author 1544 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1.3 Dedicated mentors or counsellors to be assigned to smaller batches of students, during examination periods and academic transitions, to provide consistent, informal, and confidential support. [Para 35] 1.4 All educational institutions to establish written protocols for immediate referral to mental health services, local hospitals and suicide prevention helplines – Suicide helpline numbers, including Tele-MANAS and other national services, shall be prominently displayed in hostels, classrooms, common areas, and on websites – All teaching and non-teaching staff to undergo mandatory training by certified mental health professionals on psychological firstaid, identification of warning signs, response to self-harm, and referral mechanisms, at least twice a year – Further guidelines enumerated – Coaching hubs, including but not limited to Jaipur, Kota, Sikar, Chennai, Hyderabad, Delhi, Mumbai, and other cities where students migrate in large numbers for competitive examination preparation, shall implement heightened mental health protections and preventive measures – The Department of Education, District Administration, and management of educational institutions, to ensure the provision of regular career counselling for students and parents, regulation of academic pressure planning, through structured academic availability of continuous psychological support, and the establishment of institutional mechanisms for monitoring and accountability to safeguard student mental wellbeing. [Para 35] 1.5 These guidelines shall apply to all educational institutions across India, including public and private schools, colleges, universities, training centres, coaching institutes, residential academies, and hostels, irrespective of their affiliation – These guidelines to remain in force and be binding until appropriate legislation or regulatory frameworks are enacted by the competent authority and are not in supersession but in parallel to the ongoing work of the National Task Force on Mental Health Concerns of Students and are being issued to provide an interim protective architecture in the interregnum – These guidelines shall be read as complementary to the ongoing work of the National Task Force and would inform and assist the National Task Force in the development of a more comprehensive and inclusive framework. [Paras 35, 36] 2.1 Directions by Supreme Court – All States and Union Territories to notify rules within two months from the date of this judgment [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1545Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. mandating registration, student protection norms, and grievance redressal mechanisms for all private coaching centres complying with the mental health safeguards prescribed. [Para 37] 2.2 A district-level monitoring committee to be constituted in each district under the chairpersonship of the District Magistrate or Collector – It may include representatives from the departments of education, health, and child protection, civil society and shall oversee implementation, conduct inspections, and receive complaints. [Para 38] 2.3 Union of India to file a compliance affidavit before the Supreme Court within 90 days from the date of the judgment detailing the steps taken to implement the guidelines, the coordination mechanisms established with State Governments, the status of regulatory rule making w.r.t coaching centres, and the monitoring systems put in place – The affidavit also to indicate the expected time line for the completion of the report and recommendations of the National Task Force on Mental Health Concerns of Students. [Para 39] Transfer of investigation to CBI – When warranted – Appellant filed writ petition seeking transfer of investigation to CBI following the suspicious death of his 17-year-old daughter, who was undergoing coaching for NEET examination at Aakash Byju’s Institute, Vishakhapatnam, after falling from the terrace of her hostel – Prayer rejected by High Court – Interference with:
Held: Power to transfer the investigation of a criminal case to the CBI is an extraordinary measure, which must be exercised with great caution, and only in rare and exceptional circumstances – This jurisdiction is not to be invoked lightly or in a routine manner, but only where the facts of the case disclose a compelling necessity to ensure fairness in investigation, preservation of public confidence in the administration of justice, and protection of fundamental rights of the parties involved – In examining the prayer made by an aggrieved person seeking transfer of investigation to the CBI, the Court must necessarily be guided by the strict parameters – In the present case, the ineffectiveness of the local police officials is clear and undeniable – The attempt of the respondents to paint the unfortunate incident as one of suicide, relying upon vague references to the deceased being “agitated” on the evening of the incident 1546 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports is wholly unsubstantiated – The original and consistent version disclosed to the appellant, both by Aakash Institute’s personnel and local police, was that the appellant’s daughter had fallen from the terrace – At no point was the suicide theory mentioned to the appellant – The belated and unsubstantiated narrative of suicide appears to be a post-facto justification aimed at diluting the gravity of the incident and shielding institutional lapses – On facts, including the glaring inconsistencies in the medical records, the autopsy report indicating suspicious contents of stomach despite the deceased allegedly being on ventilatory support, the unexplained lapses in seizure and preservation of critical forensic evidence, and the contradictory statements by authorities, collectively highlight a case of exceptional complexity and concern – In view of the rare and extraordinary circumstances, investigation into the unnatural death of the appellant’s daughter is transferred to CBI – Impugned order quashed and set aside. [Paras 19, 21, 21.1, 22-24] Constitution of India – Arts.21, 32, 141 – Growing crisis of student suicides – Right to Mental Health, an integral component of the right to life u/Art.21 – Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 – ss.18, 115 – 210th Report of Law Commission of India; statistics in the National Crime Records Bureau in its 2022 report titled “Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India”, enumerated – India’s obligations under international laws, discussed – Legislative and regulatory vacuum w.r.t a unified, enforceable framework for suicide prevention of students – Binding interim guidelines issued. [Paras 31-35] Transfer of investigation to CBI – Power to transfer the investigation of a criminal case to CBI – Parameters to be considered, stated. [Paras 19, 20] Case Law Cited Amit Kumar v. Union of India, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 631; Arnab Ranjan Goswami v. Union of India [2020] 8 SCR 222 : (2020) 14 SCC 12; State of West Bengal & Others v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, West Bengal (CPDR) & Others [2010] 2 SCR 979 : (2010) 3 SCC 571; Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India [2014] 1 SCR 609 : (2014) 3 SCC 1; Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India [2018] 7 SCR 379 : (2018) 10 SCC 1; Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan [1997] Supp. 3 SCR 404 : (1997) 6 SCC 241 – referred to.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1547Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. Books and Periodicals Cited Jean-Jacques Rousseau, “Emile, or Education”, (Ed. and Trans.) Allan Bloom (New York: Basic Books, 1979); Jiddu Krishnamurti, “Education and the Significance of Life”, San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row, 1953; National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) Chapter-2 Suicides in India Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India, 2022; Law Commission of India, Report No. 210 on the Humanisation and Decriminalisation of Attempt to Suicide, Para 1.5 (October 2008); Teasdale, G., & Jennett, B. (1974). Assessment of coma and impaired consciousness. A practical scale. Lancet (London, England), 2(7872), 81– 84; Golden, K., Bodien, Y. G., & Giacino, J. T. (2024). Disorders of Consciousness: Classification and Taxonomy. Physical medicine and rehabilitation clinics of North America, 35(1), 15–33; Modi JP and others, A Textbook of Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology (Lexis Nexis Butterworths Wadhwa Nagpur 2011). List of Websites https://ncrb.gov.in/uploads/files/AccidentalDeathsSuicides inIndia2022v2.pdf.
List of Acts Mental Healthcare Act, 2017; Penal Code, 1860; Constitution of India; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023; Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013.
List of Keywords Article 21 of the Constitution of India; Mental health; Right to Mental Health; Student mental health; Suicide; Student suicides; Interim guidelines; Binding guidelines; Transfer of investigation to CBI; Unnatural/ Suicide death of a student; Suspicious circumstances; Investigation into unnatural death; Article 32 of the Constitution of India; Article 141 of the Constitution of India; Coaching for the National Eligibility-cum Entrance Test (NEET) examination; Aakash Byju’s Institute, Vishakhapatnam; Suicide theory; Theory of suicide; Belated and unsubstantiated narrative of suicide; Framework for mental health protection; Prevention of suicides by students across all educational institutions; UMMEED (Understand, Motivate, Manage, Empathise, Empower, and Develop) Draft Guidelines for the Prevention of Student Suicide, 1548 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 2023; MANODARPAN; National Suicide Prevention Strategy; Child and adolescent mental health; Student-to-counsellor ratios; Educational institutions; Coaching institutes/centres; Residentialbased institutions; Tele-MANAS; Mandatory training; Mechanisms for the reporting, redressal, and prevention of incidents; Suicide prevention helplines; Suicide helpline numbers; Psycho-social support to victims; Sensitisation programmes on student mental health; Mental health literacy; Undue academic pressure; Signs of psychological distress; Extracurricular activities; National Crime Records Bureau; Reduce academic burden; Career counselling services; Student mental well-being; Student protection norms; Grievance redressal mechanisms; Beyond the jurisdiction of Court; Need for an impartial investigation; Inconsistencies in the medical records; Lapses in seizure and preservation of critical forensic evidence; Contradictory statements; Not mere procedural irregularities; Malaise in the investigational process; National Task Force on Mental Health Concerns of Students and the Prevention of Suicides in Higher Educational Institutions; Atma Nirbhar Bharat Abhiyaan Yojna; National Suicide Prevention Strategy; Ministry of Health and Family Welfare; International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; The United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006; World Health Organisation’s Mental Health Action Plan; Comprehensive Mental Health Action Plan 2013- 2020; Vishaka Guidelines.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
3177 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 14.02.2024 of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amravati in WP No. 25381 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Joydeb B. Saha, Ayush Mittal, Ms. Oshin Maggu, Zazib Siddiqui, Gurrick Jassar, Dr. Nb V Srinivasa Reddy, M/s. V. Maheshwari & Co. Advs. for the Respondents:
Rajkumar Bhaskar Thakare, A.S.G., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Vivek Gupta, Rohit Khare, Padmesh Mishra, Merusagar Samantaray, Tanmay Mehta, Ms. Prerna Singh, Guntur Pramod Kumar, Dhruv Yadav, P. Santhosh Kumar, Abhiram Bannur, Sravan Kumar [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1549Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. Karanam, Y. Raja Gopala Rao, Dhuli Gopi Krishna, Akshay Singh, Ms. Sanjana Jain, Pranav Proothi, Ms. Manasi Chatpalliwar, Pulkit Agarwal, M Srinivas R Rao, Abid Ali Beeran P, Saswat Adhyapak, Ms. Namita Kumari, Anand Varma, Ayush Gupta, Kunal Mimani, Abhinav Rana.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
Table of Contents* I. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 2 II. PART A: - ........................................................................................... 10 (i). Facts of the Case: - ................................................................ 10 (ii). Submissions on behalf of the Appellant: - ............................ 16 (iii). Submissions on behalf of the Respondents: - ..................... 23 (iv). Discussion & Analysis: - .......................................................... 27 (v). Conclusion: - .............................................................................. 42 III. PART B: ............................................................................................ 44
(i) Background: - ........................................................................... 44
(ii) Right to Mental Health ............................................................. 47
(iii) Guidelines: - ............................................................................. 50
(iv) Directions: - .............................................................................. 59
I. INTRODUCTION
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. The present appeal arises from the judgment and order dated 14 th February, 2024, passed by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
1550 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Amravati 1 in Writ Petition No. 25381 of 2023, whereby the High Court rejected the appellant’s prayer, seeking transfer of the investigation of FIR No. 148 of 2023 to the Central Bureau of Investigation. 2 The aforesaid FIR was registered following the tragic, unnatural death of the appellant’s 17-year-old daughter, Ms. X, who was undergoing coaching for the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) examination at Aakash Byju’s Institute, Vishakhapatnam. She was staying in a Hostel when the unfortunate incident occurred on 14 th July, 2023, leading to her untimely death.
4. Before delving into the factual background and issues of the present case, this Court deems it appropriate to reflect upon the broader underlying generational societal issue, namely, the growing crisis of student suicides in the context of contemporary education. As articulated by numerous philosophers across history, the purpose of education was never confined to mere academic success or professional advancement. Rather, education was envisioned as a means for holistic development, intellectual, emotional, ethical, and spiritual. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in his prominent treatise “Émile, or On Education”3, emphasised that education must be adapted to the developmental needs of the child and should cultivate reason, autonomy, and emotional well-being. He warned against an educational system that neglects the individuality of the learner in pursuit of rigid societal expectations.
5. Jiddu Krishnamurti, in his book “Education and the Significance of Life,” 4 noted that the function of education is to create human beings who are integrated and therefore intelligent. Krishnamurti cautioned against turning education into a system of conformity and performance, warning that the mind of a child must not be conditioned by fear, competition, or compulsion. These philosophical foundations remind us that education is meant to liberate, not burden the learner, and that its true success lies not in grades or rankings but in the holistic growth of a human being capable of living with dignity, confidence, and purpose.
1 Hereinafter being referred to as ‘Andhra Pradesh High Court’. 2 Hereinafter being referred to as “CBI.”
3 Jean-Jacques Rousseau, “Emile, or Education”, (Ed. and Trans.) Allan Bloom (New York: Basic Books, 1979).
4 Jiddu Krishnamurti, “Education and the Significance of Life”, San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row, 1953. [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1551Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors.
6. Contrary to these ideals, the contemporary academic framework, particularly in the context of competitive examination systems, often subjects students to relentless psychological pressure. The very soul of education appears to have been distorted. Increasingly, education is perceived as a high-stakes race, a pressure-laden path toward narrowly defined goals of achievement, status, and economic security. The joy of learning has been replaced by anxiety over rankings, results, and relentless performance metrics. Students, especially those preparing for competitive examinations, are often caught in a web that rewards conformity over curiosity, output over understanding, and endurance over well-being.
7. In this paradigm, life becomes a series of tests, and failure is seen not as a part of growth but as a devastating end. In a system driven by performance metrics, competition, and institutional rigidity, students are often subjected to immense psychological strain, particularly in environments geared towards high-stakes competitive examinations.
8. In the recent past, multiple reports have emerged of student suicides in premier educational institutions and, more particularly, coaching centres, pointing to a pattern of despair that demands collective introspection. These young individuals, often far away from home, isolated in demanding academic environments, find themselves without adequate emotional or institutional support. The culture of silence around mental health, coupled with insufficient safeguards in educational institutions, exacerbates their vulnerability. The gravity of this crisis cannot be overstated, and any incident involving the death of a student under such circumstances warrants the utmost seriousness, not just as an isolated tragedy, but as part of a larger systemic malaise that threatens the future of the young generation.
9. The statistics published by the National Crime Records Bureau (‘NCRB’) in its 2022 report titled “Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India”5 paint a deeply distressing picture. India recorded 1,70,924 reported suicide cases in the year 2022 (an increase from 2021 data, i.e., 1,64,033 reported suicide cases), of which 7.6%, approximately 13,044, were student suicides. Notably, 2,248 of these deaths were 5 National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) Chapter-2 Suicides in India Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India, 2022. Available here. <https://ncrb.gov.in/uploads/files/AccidentalDeathsSuicidesinIndia2022v2. pdf>.
1552 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports attributed directly to failure in examinations. As per NCRB data, the number of suicides among students in the last two decades has increased from 5,425 in 2001 to 13,044 in 2022. In the decade beginning from 2012, male student suicides surged to 99% and female student suicides jumped to 92%. Because of the non-recognition of transgender/non-binary students in the previous NCRB Reports, the data of the third gender is totally lacking from the statistics. However, their underrepresentation should not be disregarded, as it reflects a systemic failure to acknowledge and address the challenges faced by transgender and non-binary students within educational institutions. Needless to say, the abovementioned figures are not just statistical data, but precious lives lost, young minds prematurely silenced by pressures they were unable to bear. These figures, taken in conjunction with emerging patterns of distress in educational institutions, coaching centres, and residential educational institutions, point to a systemic failure in addressing students’ emotional and mental health needs. It must be acknowledged that student suicides, particularly those related to exam failure, are rarely the result of a single cause. Multiple factors, both individual and systemic, direct and indirect, contribute to such outcomes. These include low self-esteem, unrealistic academic expectations (both self-imposed and externally driven), impulsivity, social isolation, learning and cognitive disabilities, and, in some tragic cases, past trauma such as physical or sexual abuse. Equally concerning are suicides of students precipitated by experiences of sexual assault, harassment, ragging, bullying, or discrimination on the basis of caste, gender, sexual orientation, or disability, which continue to remain underreported and inadequately addressed. Each of these vulnerabilities may be exacerbated in high-pressure environments that lack adequate emotional support and psychological safeguards.
10. The Law Commission of India, in its 210th Report, has recognised suicide as one of the most tragic and preventable forms of death in our society.6 This Court has taken judicial notice of the disturbing trend of suicides among students enrolled in educational institutions, where intense academic competition often combines with emotional isolation, 6 Law Commission of India, Report No. 210 on the Humanisation and Decriminalisation of Attempt to Suicide, Para 1.5 (October 2008).
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1553Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. caste-based discrimination, financial stress, sexual harassment, and systemic indifference. In Amit Kumar v. Union of India7 , this Court addressed the issue of student suicides across the country and employed the phrase “suicide epidemic” to describe the alarming rise of students’ suicide incidents in educational institutions. The Court observed that a majority of these deaths were attributed to failure in examinations and the unbearable pressure imposed upon students by institutional and societal expectations.
11. This Court is therefore of the view that the present case must not be viewed in isolation, but rather in the context of this deepening crisis. While the legal and factual question before us concerns the unnatural/suicide death of a student, the broader social context in which such cases of suicide occur cannot be ignored.
12. It is in this light that the matter assumes not just legal but also moral, societal and institutional significance. Accordingly, this judgment is structured in two parts to address the issues in their entirety. Part A sets out the factual circumstances of the present case and adjudicates on the merits of the case. Part B sets out immediate interim guidelines, aimed at laying down a preventive, remedial, and supportive framework for mental health protection and prevention of suicides by students across all educational institutions.
II. PART A: -
(i). Facts of the Case: -
13. The background facts essential for disposal of the instant appeal are:
13.1. The appellant resides in West Bengal with his family. In May 2022, the appellant’s 17-year-old daughter, Ms. X, took admission at a coaching institute, namely, Aakash Byju’s Class/ Respondent no. 6 8 in Vishakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, to prepare for the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (‘NEET’) examination. She got a rented residential accommodation in Sadhana Ladies Hostel/Respondent No. 4 9 on the 7 2025 SCC OnLine SC 631.
8 Hereinafter being referred to as “Aakash Institute.”
9 Hereinafter being referred to as “Sadhana Hostel.”
1554 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports recommendation of Aakash Institute and took admission into Achiever’s Junior College for Class XII studies, concurrently pursuing her NEET preparation.
13.2. On 14 th July 2023, at around 11:54 pm, the appellant received a phone call from Ravikanth, Assistant Branch Manager (Operations) of Aakash Institute, informing the appellant that his daughter had fallen from the 3 rd floor of the building of Sadhana Hostel at about 10:20 pm and had sustained severe injuries and that she had been taken to Venkataramana Hospital/Respondent No. 5 10 for medical treatment. The appellant immediately called his daughter’s friend, who informed him that all the students had been locked inside a room and that she couldn’t tell what exactly happened. The appellant’s friend, Bapandas, who hails from Vishakhapatnam, visited the Venkataramana Hospital on 15 th July, 2024, around 1:15 am and found the child, Ms. X, conscious and talking. The appellant immediately took the first available flight to Vishakhapatnam (Andhra Pradesh) and reached the Venkataramana Hospital on 15 th July, 2023, at 1:50 pm, where he found his daughter unconscious and on ventilator support. The management of Venkataramana Hospital told the appellant that his daughter had suffered a heart attack around 4:00 am on 15 th July, 2023, but couldn’t receive proper treatment due to the unavailability of a specialist medical faculty, and thus, she was placed on a ventilator. Being dissatisfied with the care and medical treatment being provided to his daughter at Venkataramana Hospital, the appellant shifted her to Care Hospital/Respondent No. 7 11 for better treatment. On 16 th July, 2023, approximately 12:00 (noon), the appellant’s daughter, while undergoing medical treatment, passed away. On the same day, the statement of the appellant was recorded, and thereafter, an FIR 12 was registered by IV Town Police Station under Section 174 13 of 10 Hereinafter referred to as “Venkatramana Hospital.”
11 Hereinafter being referred to as “Care Hospital.”
12 FIR No. 177 of 2023.
13 Corresponding Section 194 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1555Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. the Code of Criminal Procedure. 14 Subsequently, an Inquest Report was prepared on 17 th July 2023, and the body of the deceased was sent for postmortem examination.
13.3. Aggrieved by the suspicious circumstances surrounding the medical treatment provided to his daughter and dissatisfied with the authorities’ apparent reluctance to properly investigate the matter, the appellant approached the Andhra Pradesh High Court, by way of Writ Petition No. 20387 of 2023 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking a Writ of Mandamus, questioning the inaction of the Commissioner of Police and the SHO in collecting CCTV footage and other material evidence from Sadhana Hostel, Venkataramana Hospital, and Care Hospital in relation to the suspicious death of his daughter. Further, the appellant sought consequential directions for the appointment of a Court Commissioner to collect the CCTV footage. The Andhra Pradesh High Court vide Order dated 10 th August 2023, appointed Ms. K. Priyanka Lakshmi as Advocate Commissioner to collect and verify the CCTV footage for the period from 1st July, 2023 to 31st July, 2023 in the presence of the appellant. The above-mentioned Writ Petition was disposed of by the High Court vide Order dated 12th February, 2024.
13.4. On 20th August 2023, the appellant lodged a formal FIR15 under Sections 302 and 120 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 16 , at Police Station Netaji Nagar, Kolkata, West Bengal, against Aakash Institute, Sadhana Hostel, and Venkataramana Hospital and others.
13.5. The Assistant Commissioner of Police 17 (East Sub-Division) Andhra Pradesh, on 27th August 2023, took up the investigation and, after concluding the same, he filed an Alteration Memo on 29 th August 2023, before the Magistrate for applying Section 304 Part-II of the IPC to the case. In this memo, the following individuals were arrayed as accused persons:- 14 Hereinafter being referred to as “CrPC.”
15 FIR No. 148 of 2023.
16 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘IPC.’ 17 For Short, ‘ACP.’ 1556 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports S. No. Name of the Accused Position Accused No. 1 M.s Gannu Kumari Hostel Warden Accused No. 2 Yecheral Surya Kumar Owner of the Hostel Accused No. 3 Gangumalla Naga Venkata Durga Ravikanth Assistant Branch Manager (Operations)
of Aakash Byju’s Vishakapatnam Accused No. 4 Gundu Rajeshwari Rao Branch Manager of Aakash Byju’s Vishakapatnam
13.6. On 25 th September, 2023, the appellant filed a second Writ Petition No. 25381 of 2023 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, before the Andhra Pradesh High Court, seeking directions to transfer the investigation of the case to the CBI.
13.7. On 10th November 2023, the appellant filed third Writ Petition No. 29622 of 2023 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, before the Andhra Pradesh High Court, seeking a Writ of Mandamus, with a declaration that the authorities’ failure to properly evaluate forensic samples from the deceased’s body and their classification of the suspicious death as suicide was illegal, arbitrary, and totally unjustified.
13.8. The Andhra Pradesh High Court, vide Order dated 14 th February 2024, disposed of the third writ petition by directing the concerned SHO to send preserved forensic samples of the deceased, along with samples collected from the appellant to AIIMS, New Delhi, for DNA testing and determination of the cause of death, with the entire exercise to be completed within two months.
13.9. The Andhra Pradesh High Court vide Impugned Order dated 14 th February, 2024, disposed of the second Writ Petition No. 25381 of 2023 and held that since there are two FIRs registered in two different States i.e., State of Andhra Pradesh [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1557Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. and State of West Bengal, the prayer seeking transfer of the case to CBI, was beyond the jurisdiction of the Court.
13.10. The aforesaid order dated 14 th February, 2024, of the Andhra Pradesh High Court is assailed by the appellant in this appeal with special leave.
(ii). Submissions on behalf of the Appellant: -
14. Learned counsel representing the appellant, vehemently and fervently urged that the High Court gravely erred in rejecting the prayer of the appellant, seeking transfer of the case to the CBI. In this regard, he has advanced the following pertinent submissions:
14.1. The investigation into the unnatural and suspicious death of the appellant’s daughter, Ms. X, was conducted in a manifestly arbitrary and perfunctory manner by the local police authorities. Despite repeated oral and written representations made by the appellant to the Station House Officer, IV Town Police Station, Visakhapatnam, seeking registration of an FIR and fair investigation, the police authorities willfully neglected their statutory duties. Further, it was submitted that after the statement of the appellant was recorded on 16 th July, 2023, and inquest proceedings were registered under Section 174 of the CrPC, without conducting proper investigation and inquiry, the SHO/respondent No. 3 hastily concluded that the appellant’s daughter had committed suicide. This conclusion was drawn despite the fact that the appellant was repeatedly and categorically asserting that his daughter’s death was a case of unnatural death, warranting investigation under Section 302 of the IPC. The appellant even disclosed the names of potential accused persons in his statement, yet these leads were deliberately ignored by the investigating authorities, who were determined to classify the case as suicide from the outset, foreclosing any possibility of a proper and fair investigation.
14.2. The doctors and management of Venkataramana Hospital acted in gross dereliction of their duty by initiating treatment without informing either the police or the family members, and by placing the deceased on ventilation without obtaining the consent of the parents. When the appellant’s daughter, Ms. X, was admitted to Venkataramana Hospital on 15th July, 2023 at 1558 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 10:30 pm, she was conscious and even asked for water, as witnessed at approximately 1:15 am on 16 th July, 2023, by the appellant’s friend namely, Bapandas. Despite her precarious condition, the doctors and other staff at Venkataramana Hospital failed to provide proper medical treatment that could have saved her life. The deceased was in a condition fit for communication. However, no effort was made by police authorities to get the statement of Ms. X, which manifests total apathy on the part of the local authorities.
14.3. The directions issued by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Writ Petition No. 20387 of 2023, whereby an Advocate Commissioner was appointed to secure CCTV footage and relevant records, were not complied with in the true letter and spirit. The Advocate Commissioner, appointed by the Andhra Pradesh High Court, attempted to collect CCTV footage and documents as directed by the Court vide order dated 10 th August, 2023, but the police officials failed to cooperate fully. They neither seized the hard disk of the CCTV footage from the adjacent shop, i.e., Sanghvi Lamination Shop, near which the incident occurred, nor marked the spot of the incident, nor collected forensic samples from the said place. The appellant submits that these material omissions indicate a deliberate attempt to protect the interests of the respondents, particularly Aakash Institute, Sadhana Hostel, and Venkataramana Hospital thereby casting a grave doubt on the bona fides and fairness of the local police officers.
14.4. The CCTV footage, from Sadhana Hostel shows a girl in salwar/trousers going upstairs toward the terrace at approximately 10:25 pm on 14 th July, 2023, whereas the footage from Sanghvi Lamination Shop from 14 th July, 2023, at 10:46 pm, shows a girl in blue half pants and a T-shirt lying down on the floor. This glaring discrepancy in apparel indicates that the girl going upstairs in the hostel footage may not have been the appellant’s daughter, Ms. X. The police failed to properly scrutinise and verify the CCTV footage to confirm the identity of the said girl, yet they have hastily concluded the case to be one of suicide. These serious lapses establish beyond doubt that the investigation is neither fair nor effective.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1559Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors.
14.5. The conduct of senior police officials, including the statement made by the Police Commissioner during the press conference on 24 th August, 2023, is contrary to the truth and demonstrates the authorities’ intent to shield the actual culprits. In the press release, the Commissioner stated that the inquest report was authored by the appellant’s blood relatives, whereas in reality, the Circle Inspector of IV Town Police Station dictated the report and pressured the appellant not to interfere. Furthermore, the Commissioner’s statement that there was no evidence related to Aakash Institute is in gross disregard to the fact that the appellant had enrolled his daughter in Aakash Institute for competitive exam preparation, and it was on the instruction and recommendation of the management people from Aakash Institute that she was accommodated in Sadhana Hostel. As such, Aakash Institute was the guardian and custodian of Ms. X and cannot abdicate its responsibility in this matter.
14.6. In the autopsy report dated 17 th July, 2023, under column D (Abdomen), there is explicit mention of a “suspicious smell” in the stomach contents of the deceased. Despite this finding, neither the chemical analysis report dated 4 th September, 2023, conducted by Andhra Pradesh Regional Forensic Science Laboratory 18 , Visakhapatnam, nor the final opinion on the cause of death by Autopsy Doctor P. Venkataramana Rao dated 21st September, 2023, has been procured and placed on record. The deliberate withholding of these vital forensic reports strongly suggest an attempt to conceal evidence that may contradict the theory of suicide hastily advanced by the investigating authorities.
14.7. The formation and functioning of the Medical Committee constituted to investigate potential medical negligence suffer from grave irregularities. While the Superintendent of King George Hospital, Visakhapatnam, formed a five-member committee of doctors, strangely enough, Dr. P. Venkataramana Rao, the autopsy doctor who had already been involved in the postmortem examination, was also included as a sixth member without proper notification. This triple role of the said doctor as 18 Hereinafter being referred to as ‘RFSL’.
1560 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports an autopsy surgeon, chemical analyst, and committee member represents an egregious conflict of interest and compromises the independence and integrity of the medical investigation. Moreover, the Medical Committee itself acknowledged its limitations, stating in its report that it “has only perused the documents submitted in the said matter without any interaction with the doctors who have treated the patient or the relatives of the deceased,” and that it lacked “knowledge about the medical facilities, qualifications of treating doctors and infrastructure of the hospitals where the deceased was treated.”
14.8. The appellant contends that the pathetic failure of the local police authorities in conducting proper investigation and the lackadaisical arraignment of certain individuals for criminal negligence is manifested in the conflicting narratives emerging from the CCTV footage, medical records, and eyewitness accounts. It is thus urged that a fair, impartial, and independent investigation can only be ensured by transferring the matter to the CBI. The appellant has made several representations to the State Government for the same, which have remained unacknowledged. Furthermore, the High Court at Calcutta in Criminal Revision No. 3541 of 2023 vide Order dated 9 th October 2023, had also stayed the second FIR filed at Police Station Netaji Nagar, Kolkata, West Bengal.
On these grounds, learned counsel appearing for the appellant implored the Court to accept this appeal, set aside the impugned judgment and direct the transfer of the investigation to the CBI, in the interest of justice and to uphold the rule of law. (iii). Submissions on behalf of the Respondents: -
15. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant and advanced the following pertinent submissions imploring this Court to dismiss the present appeal and reject the prayer to transfer the investigation to CBI:-
15.1. Investigation into the unfortunate death of the appellant’s daughter, Ms. X, has been conducted diligently and in accordance with the law by the local police authorities. Respondent No. 3, the Investigating Officer, acted promptly [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1561Sukdeb Saha v. The State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. upon receiving the medico-legal case report (MLC) from Venkataramana Hospital and recorded the same in the General Diary. Statements of the attending doctor were recorded, the scene of the occurrence was inspected, CCTV footage was reviewed, and over 40 witnesses were examined. Material evidence, including digital footage, was seized and sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL). An offence alteration memo was filed before the jurisdictional Magistrate based on emerging evidence to alter the charge to Section 304 Part-II of the IPC, reflecting the seriousness with which the investigation has been pursued.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.