Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd v. Additional Director of Income Tax
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 891; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1497
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 24 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9766/2025
- Sections
- 142(1), 143(3), 144C, 9(1), 260A, 3, 92F, 4, 1, 2, 7
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1497 : 2025 INSC 891 Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd.
v.
Additional Director of Income Tax (Civil Appeal No. 9766 of 2025)
24 July 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the appellant, a tax resident of the UAE, has a Permanent Establishment-PE in India u/Art.5(1) of the Indo-UAE Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement-DTAA, and consequently, whether its income derived under the Strategic Oversight Services Agreement-SOSA is taxable in India.
Headnotes† Income Tax Act, 1961 – ss. 92F(iii-a), 143(3) – Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (Indo-UAE) – Arts. 4, 5(1), 7 – Strategic Oversight Services Agreement-SOSA – Art. I to V – Permanent Establishment-PE – Appellant company incorporated in Dubai, a tax resident of UAE, engaged in rendering consultancy services in the hotel sector – Appellant entered into SOSAs with Indian company, one for Delhi Hotel and other for Mumbai hotel – Assessment orders by the assessing officer taxing the hotel related services rendered by the appellant, on the ground that the appellant has a Permanent Establishment in India in the form of a place of business u/Art.5(1) of the DTAA – Affirmed by the ITAT and High Court – Correctness: Held: High Court rightly held that the appellant has a fixed place Permanent Establishment-PE in India and income received under the SOSA is attributable to such PE and is thus, taxable in India – Taxability is based on business presence and not the global profitability of the enterprise – Under DTAAs, the taxing rights of the source State over the business profits of a foreign enterprise are contingent upon the existence of a PE in the source country – One of the sine qua non for a fixed place PE is that the place through which the business is carried on must be ‘at the disposal’ of the enterprise, the “disposal test” principle – High Court was correct in concluding that the appellant’s role was not confined to high-level * Author 1498 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports decision making, but extended to substantive operational control and implementation – Detailed review of the SOSA executed between the appellant and the Indian Company demonstrates that the appellant exercised pervasive and enforceable control over the hotel’s strategic, operational, and financial dimensions – Appellant’s ability to enforce compliance, oversee operations, and derive profit-linked fees from the hotel’s earnings demonstrates clear and continuous commercial nexus and control with the hotel’s core functions – This nexus satisfies the conditions necessary for the constitution of a Fixed Place Permanent Establishment u/Art.5(1) of the India-UAE DTAA – Appellant’s executives and employees made frequent and regular visits to India to oversee operations and implement the SOSA – Findings of the assessing officer, based on travel logs and job functions, establish continuous and coordinated engagement, even though no single individual exceeded the 9-month stay threshold – u/Art.5(2)(i), the relevant consideration is the continuity of business presence in aggregate, not the length of stay of each individual employee – Once it is found that there is continuity in the business operations, the intermittent presence or return of a particular employee becomes immaterial and insignificant in determining the existence of a permanent establishment. [Paras 15-24] Case Law Cited Formula One World Championship Limited v. Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-3, Delhi & Anr. [2017] 2 SCR 152 : (2017) 15 SCC 602 – relied on.
Assistant Director of Income Tax-1, New Delhi v. M/s. E-Funds IT Solutions Inc. [2017] 10 SCR 157 : (2018) 13 SCC 294 – distinguished.
Union of India & Anr. v. U.A.E Exchange Centre [2020] 4 SCR 719 : (2020) 9 SCC 329 – referred to.
List of Acts Income Tax Act, 1961.
List of Keywords Indo-UAE Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA); Permanent Establishment (PE); Income tax; Fixed place of business; Hotel consultancy; Fees for Technical Services (FTS); [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1499Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax Strategic Oversight Services Agreement (SOSA); Disposal test; Degree of control and supervision; UN Model Double Taxation Convention (2021); OECD Model Tax Convention (2017); Tax resident of UAE; Consultancy services in the hotel sector; Global profitability; Business profits of foreign enterprise. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9766 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.12.2023 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in ITA No. 216 of 2020 With Civil Appeal No(s). 9767, 9768, 9769, 9770, 9771, 9772 and 9773 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
S. Ganesh, Sr. Adv., Ujjwal A. Rana, Himanshu Mehta, for M/s. Gagrat And Co.
Advs. for the Respondent:
N Venkatraman, A.S.G., Arijit Prasad, Rupesh Kumar, Sr. Advs., Raj Bahadur Yadav, Shashank Bajpai, V Chandrashekhara Bharathi, Santosh Kumar, Diwakar Sharma.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment R. Mahadevan, J.
Leave granted.
2. All these appeals arise out of the common judgment and order dated 22.12.2023 passed by the High Court of Delhi 1 in the Income Tax Appeals preferred by the appellant / assessee, in respect of the Assessment Years 2009-10, 2010-11, 2011-12, 2012-13, 2013-14, 2014-15, 2016-17 and 2017-18. The details of the impugned orders 1 For short, “the High Court”
1500 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports before this Court, before the High Court and before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, along with the corresponding tax effect involved in each case, are tabulated below:
Case No. High Court ITAT AO Tax effect evolved SLP (C) No.
5710 of 2024
ITA
No.216/2020 Order dated 22.12.2023 579/Del/2013 Order dated 04.12.2019 21.11.2012 AY 2009-10 85,14,156/- SLP (C) No.
1 0 1 5 2 o f
ITA
No.219/2020 Order dated 22.12.2023 1762/Del/2015 Order dated 04.12.2019 28.01.2015 AY 2011-12 2,98,96,262/- SLP (C) No.
1 0 1 5 7 o f
ITA
No.217/2020 Order dated 22.12.2023 957/Del/2016 Order dated 04.12.2019 18.12.2015 AY 2012-13 2,85,75,313/- SLP (C) No.
1 0 7 9 6 o f
ITA
No.201/2023 Order dated 22.12.2023 6363/Del/2019 Order dated 20.12.2022 19.06.2019 AY 2016-17 4,05,14,966/- SLP (C) No.
1 0 7 9 7 o f
ITA
No.215/2023 Order dated 22.12.2023 712/Del/2021 Order dated 20.12.2022 13.04.2021 AY 2017-18 4,05,14,966/- SLP (C) No.
1 0 7 9 8 o f
ITA
No.140/2021 Order dated 22.12.2023 727/Del/2017 Order dated 12.03.2021 24.11.2016 AY 2013-14 2,91,07,664/- SLP (C) No.
1 0 8 0 0 o f ITA No.36/2022 Order dated 22.12.2023 6179/Del/2017 Order dated 27.07.2021 28.07.2017 AY 2014-15 3,05,12,883/- S L P ( C )
D i a r y N o .
1 4 9 7 2 o f
ITA
No.218/2020 Order dated 22.12.2023 779/Del/2014 Order dated 04.12.2019 28.11.2013 AY 2010-11 2,98,96,262/- [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1501Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax
3. The necessary facts leading to the filing of the present appeals, as culled out from the impugned orders, are as follows:
3.1. The appellant is a company incorporated under the Companies Law, Dubai International Financial Centre Law No.3 of 2006, in the United Arab Emirates2 . It is a tax resident of the UAE under Article 4 of the Agreement between the Government of India and the UAE for the avoidance of Double Taxation 3 .
3.2. On 04.09.2008, the appellant entered into two Strategic Oversight Services Agreements 4 with Asian Hotels Limited 5 , India – one for AHL, Delhi and another for AHL, Mumbai. Under the SOSA, the appellant agreed to provide strategic planning services and “know-how” to ensure that the hotel was developed and operated as an efficient and a high-quality international full-service hotel. Subsequently, AHL underwent reorganization and its name was changed to Asian Hotels (North) Limited, which continued to own the hotel. On 18.07.2010, the SOSA was partially amended.
3.3. For the Assessment Year 2009-10, the appellant filed its return of income declaring ‘Nil’ income and claiming a refund of Rs.87,99,091/-. After scrutiny, the Assessing Officer issued a notice dated 20.08.2010 under Section 142(1) read with Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 6 . In response, the appellant submitted a reply dated 25.08.2011, asserting that its income was not taxable under the Act as there was no specific Article under the DTAA for taxing Fees for Technical Services. It further stated that it did not have any fixed place of business, office, or branch in India, and that the presence of its employees in India during the relevant previous year did not exceed the nine-month threshold under Article 5(2) of the DTAA. Therefore, the appellant claimed that it did not have a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India and that its business income was not taxable under Article 7 of the DTAA.
2 For short, “UAE”
3 For short, “DTAA”
4 For short, “SOSA”
5 For short, “AHL”
6 For short, “the Act”
1502 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3.4. On 28.12.2011, the Assessing Officer passed a draft assessment order under Section 143(3) read with Section 144C of the Act, holding inter alia that the appellant’s activities constituted
(i) a business connection under Section 9(1)(i) of the Act;
(ii) a PE under Article 5 of the DTAA;
(iii) royalties and fees for technical services under Section 9(1)(vi)/(vii) of the Act; and
(iv) royalties under Article 12 of the DTAA.
3.5. The appellant filed its objections dated 22.01.2012 before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), which rejected the objections and upheld the Assessing Officer’s findings. Consequently, the Assessing Officer passed a final assessment order dated 21.11.2012, for the assessment year 2009-10. Similar assessment orders were passed for the Assessment Years 2010-11, 2011-12 and 2012-13.
3.6. Challenging the above assessment orders, the appellant filed four appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). By a common order dated 04.12.2019, the ITAT rejected the appellant’s contention that it did not have a PE in India and dismissed the appeals. In doing so, the ITAT relied on the decision of this Court in Formula One World Championship Limited v. Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-3, Delhi & Anr.7 and held that the appellant had a fixed place of business in India, thereby constituting a PE under Article 5(1) of the DTAA. Aggrieved by the said order, the appellant filed further appeals under Section 260A of the Act before the High Court.
3.7. In the meanwhile, the Assessing Officer passed a similar assessment order dated 24.11.2016 for the Assessment Year 2013-14, which the appellant challenged by filing ITA No.727/ Del/2017 before the ITAT. By order dated 12.03.2021, the ITAT dismissed the appeal, following its earlier order dated 04.12.2019. Aggrieved, the appellant preferred ITA No.140 of 2021 before the High Court.
7 (2017) 15 SCC 602
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1503Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax
3.8. Similarly, the appellant challenged the assessment orders for the Assessment Years 2014-15, 2016-17, and 2017-18 by filing appeals before the ITAT. By separate orders dated 27.07.2021 and 20.12.2022, the ITAT dismissed the appeals again, following its earlier order dated 04.12.2019. Aggrieved by these orders, the appellant filed ITA Nos.36 of 2022, 201 of 2023, and 215 of 2023 before the High Court.
3.9. The High Court heard all eight appeals together and framed the following substantial questions of law for consideration: (i)Whether the Tribunal misdirected itself both in law and on facts in holding that service charges received by the appellant under the various SOSA agreement were taxable as royalty?
(ii)Whether the appellant has Permanent Establishment in India within the meaning of the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement?
(iii)Whether the findings recorded by the Tribunal, in paragraphs 56, 57 and 59 are perverse and contrary to the terms of the Strategic Oversight Services Agreement (SOSA)?
(iv)Is article 7(1) of the DTAA at all applicable to the appellant, having regard to the fact that it has incurred losses in the relevant financial years?
3.10. By a common judgment and order dated 22.12.2023, the High Court answered the first question in favour of the appellant / assessee, and referred the fourth question to a larger Bench. However, it answered questions (ii) and (iii) against the appellant holding that the appellant, being a company incorporated in Dubai and a tax resident of the UAE, had a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India in the form of a fixed place of business. Aggrieved by this part of the High Court’s judgment, the appellant has preferred the present appeals.
4. Challenging the findings of the High Court regarding the existence of a Permanent Establishment (PE) in the form of a fixed place of business in India under the Indo-UAE DTAA, the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant / assessee vehemently contended that 1504 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the appellant is a Dubai based company engaged in rendering hotel consultancy and advisory services from Dubai to hotels in the Hyatt Group of Hotels, including several located in India. These services are rendered under a SOSA entered into with each hotel owner individually. The SOSA explicitly stipulates that the appellant shall render its services from Dubai and is not obligated to send or station any employee in India. However, the agreement permits at the appellant’s sole discretion, occasional and temporary visits by its employees to India.
4.1. It was further submitted that the income of the appellant is not taxable in India under the provisions of the Act, as there is no specific Article in the DTAA enabling taxation of Fees for Technical Services (FTS). Furthermore, the appellant does not maintain a fixed place of business, office, or branch in India. The limited and occasional presence of its employees in India, did not exceed the threshold of nine months under Article 5(2)
(i) of the DTAA, thereby excluding the existence of a PE.
4.2. The learned Senior Counsel argued that the High Court erroneously disregarded the two essential conditions laid down in Formula One (supra) and Assistant Director of Income Tax- 1, New Delhi vs. M/s. E-Funds IT Solutions Inc..8 , which are essential for the existence of a fixed place of business PE viz.,
(a) There must be a specific, fixed, and identifiable physical location in India; and
(b) Such location must be at the disposal of the foreign enterprise for use in carrying out its own business activities.
4.3. It was further submitted that there was no designated space or office at the hotel premises in Delhi or Mumbai that was either specifically reserved for or placed at the disposal of the appellant. The appellant exercised no control or dominion over any part of the premises. Mere involvement in policy decisions or enforcement of brand standards does not amount to a fixed place of business PE. Ownership and operational control of the hotel remained entirely with the Indian entity, as reaffirmed by Article 1, Section 3 of the SOSA.
8 (2018) 13 SCC 294
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1505Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax
4.4. The learned Senior Counsel further contended that the role of the appellant under the SOSA, was limited to strategic guidance, brand compliance, and long-term planning. The day-to-day operations of the hotel were carried out by Hyatt India Pvt. Ltd, under a separate Hotel Operating Services Agreement (HOSA) entered into with the hotel owner. The appellant had no involvement in such daily management. However, the High Court erred in conflating the two separate legal agreements – the SOSA entered into by the appellant and the HOSA entered into by Hyatt India Pvt. Ltd. – and mistakenly attributed the dayto-day control of hotel operations to the appellant. According to the learned Senior Counsel, Hyatt India Pvt. Ltd. is a distinct legal entity, taxable independently under Indian law, and its operational activities cannot be attributed to the appellant for the purpose of determining PE under the DTAA.
4.5. It was also submitted that the High Court laid undue emphasis on the fact that six employees of the appellant visited India and stayed at the hotel premises during the relevant years. These visits, however, were brief and routine in nature and the same executives visited other Hyatt hotels across India including those in Goa, Bengaluru, Kochi, and Chennai. These oversight visits were intended to ensure brand uniformity and quality compliance. The short duration spread across multiple locations, and lack of exclusive use or control over any space do not satisfy the legal requirement of a fixed place of business PE. Furthermore, the Department failed to produce documentary evidence to establish that any such designated space was ever placed at the disposal of the appellant.
4.6. It was submitted that the High Court incorrectly inferred that the absence of an express prohibition in the SOSA on decisionmaking by appellant’s employees during their stay at the hotel implies a right of disposal. In law, a fixed place of business PE cannot be presumed from the mere absence of a restriction; there must be an affirmative grant of a right to use a specific physical location to carry on the enterprise’s own business.
4.7. Ultimately, the learned senior counsel submitted that the High Court’s findings are legally untenable and factually erroneous. The essential legal requirements for the constitution of a fixed place of business PE were not satisfied in the present case. 1506 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4.8. Accordingly, it was prayed that the findings of the High Court regarding the existence of a fixed place of business PE be set aside and a declaration be made to the effect that the appellant does not have a PE in India under Article 5 of the Indo-UAE DTAA, and that its income is not taxable in India under Article 7 of the said DTAA.
5. Per contra, the learned Additional Solicitor General of India appearing for the respondents submitted that on 04.09.2008, the appellant entered into SOSA with AHL, an Indian company and the owner of the Hyatt Regency Delhi, for providing oversight services in relation to the hotel for a period of 20 years. Under the SOSA, they had more than mere access to the hotel premises – the premises were at the appellant’s full and unconditional disposal.
5.1. According to the learned Senior Counsel, the appellant’s business was carried on through the employees stationed at the hotel, thereby satisfying the criteria of a fixed place of business Permanent Establishment (PE) under Article 5 of the Indo-UAE DTAA.
5.2. It was further submitted that Article 5(1) of the DTAA defines a PE as a “fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on”. This definition is echoed in Section 92F(iii-a) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Article 7(1) of the DTAA provides that profits of an enterprise are taxable only in the State of residence unless the enterprise carries on business through a PE in the other State. If a PE exists, then the profits attributable to the PE are taxable in the source country.
5.3. Referring to the various Clauses of the SOSA, it was submitted that the appellant’s role extended beyond high-level policy formulation and into the domain of actual implementation. The appellant was involved in the appointment and training of staff, monitoring daily operations, exercising financial oversight, and influencing procurement and operational decisions – all of which demonstrate managerial and functional control, particularly through the General Manager, who reported to the appellant.
5.4. The learned Senior Counsel pointed out the documentary evidence mentioned in the impugned orders, which include records of names, roles, and durations of stay of the appellant’s [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1507Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax employees posted at the hotel. Some individuals remained in India for up to nine months and were involved in substantive hotel operations, clearly indicating operational presence in line with the terms of the SOSA. In view of the same, it was submitted that the appellant had full and effective control over the hotel premises and that the premises were indeed at its disposal for conducting its business. Therefore, the hotel satisfies the definition of a fixed place of business PE under Article 5(1) of the DTAA. Consequently, in terms of Article 7(1) of the DTAA, the profits attributable to such PE are liable to be taxed in India and the appellant be taxed in India on the income derived from such activities.
5.5. To substantiate his contention, the learned Senior Counsel placed reliance on the decision of this Court in Formula One (supra). In that case, the assessee (FOWC) incorporated in the UK, entered into a Race Promotion Contract (RPC) with Jaypee Sports International Ltd. to host the Formula One Grand Prix in India. The Court had to determine whether Jaypee constituted a fixed place PE of FOWC in India under the terms of the RPC. The Court held in paragraphs 74 and 76.5 of the judgment that for a fixed place PE to exist, two conditions must be met: (a) there must be a fixed place of business, and (b) through that place, the business of the enterprise must be wholly or partly carried on. Although FOWC’s claimed, it only had access to the race circuit for three days a year, the Court noted that the contract term extended to five years (renewable to ten), and FOWC had full control during the race period. Therefore, the premises were held to constitute a PE. The Court also referred to the OECD Commentary [paragraph 40(c) and 40(d)] to clarify that the duration of access is not determinative in itself – the right of disposal and conduct of business through the premises are the core tests. It further emphasized three key features of a PE: stability, productivity, and dependence.
5.6. Applying these principles to the present case, the learned Senior Counsel contended that the appellant – Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd – has entered into a long-term agreement (20 years) under which it enjoys broad and continued control over the hotel’s key functions, including staffing, operations, strategic policy, and financial oversight. This arrangement 1508 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports reflects the three core characteristics of a PE: stability (20year term), productivity (fee linked to business outcomes), and dependence (reliance on hotel infrastructure and staff to carry out its business).
5.7. It was further submitted that the decision in E-Funds (supra), is factually distinguishable and therefore, not applicable to the present case.
5.8. In view of the foregoing submissions, particularly the principles laid down in Formula One (supra), the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the appellant’s operation satisfies all conditions for the existence of a fixed place of business PE under Article 5(1) of the Indo-UAE DTAA. The appellant’s plea of lacking day to-day control is untenable given the pervasive control and continuous nature of its involvement.
5.9. Accordingly, it was submitted that the hotel premises constitutes a fixed place of business of the appellant in India, and in terms of Article 7(1) of the DTAA, the profits attributable to such PE are liable to tax in India. Therefore, the present appeals are liable to be dismissed.
6. We have heard the learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant and the learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the respondents and also perused the materials available on record.
7. On 16.05.2024, when these matters were taken up for consideration, this Court passed the following interim order:
“We have heard learned senior counsel for the petitioner and learned Additional Solicitor General for the respondentdepartment.
It is stated at the Bar that the tax demand has been fully met by the petitioners (under protest). However, the apprehension is with regard to the initiation of penalty proceedings pending consideration of the matter before this Court.
It was submitted that the petitioner has a good case on merits and therefore, initiation of penalty proceedings and the demand made thereon would ultimately be prejudicial to the petitioner herein.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1509Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax Per contra, learned Additional Solicitor General submitted that having regard to the fact that three authorities, including the High Court, having held against the petitioner herein on the basis of the judgments of this Court, there is no reason as to why the penalty proceedings should be stayed or frustrated at this stage.
However, we find that since notices have been issued in these matters pending consideration of these special leave petitions and bearing in mind the fact that the tax demand has been made by the petitioners herein, the penalty proceedings shall remain stayed till the next date of hearing.
List the matters on 23.09.2024.”
7.1 On 23.09.2024, the aforesaid interim order was directed to be continued until further orders of this Court.
8. It is not in dispute that the appellant is a company incorporated in Dubai, and is a tax resident of the UAE within the meaning of Article 4 of the Agreement between the Government of India and the UAE for the Avoidance of Double Taxation. The appellant is engaged in rendering consultancy services in the hotel sector. It entered into two SOSAs both dated 04.09.2008 with ASL, India – one in respect of the Delhi hotel and the other, for the Mumbai hotel. For the relevant assessment years, the Assessing Officer passed assessment orders taxing the hotel related services rendered by the appellant, inter alia, on the ground that the appellant has a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India in the form of a place of business under Article 5(1) of the DTAA. These findings were affirmed by the ITAT.
9. As noted earlier, the High Court, at the time of final hearing of the appeals, framed four substantial questions of law, whereby it answered three of them, and referred the fourth question to a Larger Bench. Aggrieved by the finding of the High Court that the appellant has a Permanent Establishment in the form of a place of business in India as contemplated under Article 5(1) of the DTAA, the present appeals have been filed before this Court.
10. The principal issue that arises for determination herein is whether the appellant – Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd., a tax resident of the UAE, has a Permanent Establishment (PE) in India under 1510 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Article 5(1) of the Indo – UAE Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA), and consequently, whether its income derived under the Strategic Oversight Services Agreement (SOSA) is taxable in India.
11. At the outset, it is necessary to analyse the relevant clauses of the DTAA and the SOSA for effective adjudication. The concept of ‘Permanent Establishment’ is well defined under Article 5 of the DTAA, and similar provisions are found in international models such as the UN Model Double Taxation Convention (2021) and the OECD Model Tax Convention (2017). These model conventions provide an inclusive yet exhaustive definitions of PE, with the precise scope depending upon the terms of the bilateral DTAA. Article 5(1) of the India – UAE DTAA defines a PE as “a fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on”. This is consistent with the definition provided in Section 92F(iii-a) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. For better appreciation, Article 5 of the India – UAE DTAA is extracted below:
“PERMANENT ESTABLISHMENT
1. For the purposes of this Agreement, the term “permanent establishment” means a fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on.
2. The term “permanent establishment” includes especially:
(a) a place of management ;
(b) a branch;
(c) an office;
(d) a factory;
(e) a workshop;
(f) a mine, an oil or gas well, a quarry or any other place of extraction of natural resources;
(g) a farm or plantation;
(h) a building site or construction or assembly project or supervisory activities in connection therewith, but only where such site, project or activity continues for a period of more than 9 months;
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1511Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax
(i) the furnishing of services including consultancy services by an enterprise of a Contracting State through employees or other personnel in the other Contracting State, provided that such activities continue for the same project or connected project for a period or periods aggregating more than 9 months within any twelve-month period.
3. Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Article, the term “permanent establishment” shall be deemed not to include:
(a) the use of facilities solely for the purpose of storage, display or delivery of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise;
(b) the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purpose of storage, display or delivery;
(c) the maintenance of a stock of goods or merchandise belonging to the enterprise solely for the purpose of processing by another enterprise;
(d) the maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of purchasing goods or merchandise, or of collecting information, for the enterprise;
(e) the maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for the purpose of carrying on, for the enterprise, any other activity of a preparatory or auxiliary character.
4. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs (1) and (3), where a person - other than an agent of independent status to whom paragraph (5) applies - is acting on behalf of an enterprise and has, and habitually exercises in a Contracting State an authority to conclude contracts on behalf of the enterprise, that enterprise shall be deemed to have a permanent establishment in that State in respect of any activities which that person undertakes for the enterprise, unless the activities of such person are limited to the purchase of goods or merchandise for the enterprise. 5.An enterprise of a Contracting State shall not be deemed to have a permanent establishment in the other Contracting 1512 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports State merely because it carries on business in that other State through a broker, general commission agent or any other agent of an independent status, provided that such persons are acting in the ordinary course of their business. However, when the activities of such an agent are devoted wholly or almost wholly on behalf of that enterprise, he will not be considered an agent of independent status within the meaning of this paragraph.”
11.1. Article 7 of the DTAA governs the taxation of business profits. Article 7(1) provides that the profit of an enterprise shall be taxable only in the State of its residence, unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment (PE) situated therein. In such a case, only so much of the profits as is attributable to that PE may be taxed in the other State. The provision reads as follows: “Article 7 - Business profits
(1) The profits of an enterprise of a Contracting State shall be taxable only in that State unless the enterprise carries on business in the other Contracting State through a permanent establishment situated therein.
If the enterprise carries on business as aforesaid, the profits of the enterprise may be taxed in the other State but only so much of them as is attributable to that permanent establishment.”
12. Insofar as the SOSA is concerned, the relevant clauses have already been extracted by the High Court in the impugned order; hence, we do not consider it necessary to reproduce them here once again. However, for contextual clarity, it may be noted that Section 4 of Article I of the SOSA deals with the ‘title to the hotel’. It provides that if the hotel owner desires to obtain financial assistance for the construction or refinancing of the hotel – or if the hotel is to be used as collateral for any borrowing unrelated to the hotel business – the owner is required to obtain a non-disturbance and attornment agreement from the lender, which must be acceptable to the assessee. This provision ensures that the assessee can perform its obligation under the SOSA and realise its fees without interference but also.
12.1. Article II of the SOSA pertains to operating terms. As per Sections 1 and 2 of Article II, the SOSA is to remain in force [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1513Hyatt International Southwest Asia Ltd. v. Additional Director of Income Tax for a term of twenty years from the effective date, with a possibility of extension by ten years through mutual agreement.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.