M/S Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 696; [2025] 6 S.C.R. 431
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 14 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6846/2025
- Sections
- 12A, 80(2), 35A, 30, 30(4), 3(2), 12, 80, 69, 80(1), 14
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 431 : 2025 INSC 696 M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v.
Union of India & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 6846 of 2025)
15 May 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether, due to non-compliance with s.12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, a suit should be dismissed u/Ord. VII r.11 CPC, or whether it should be kept in abeyance, directing the parties to first explore the possibility of settlement by instituting mediation; and whether the High Court erred in passing the impugned order, keeping the suit in abeyance and sending the parties to mediation as per the PIMS Rules and the 2020 SOP. Headnotes† Commercial Courts Act, 2015 – s.12A – Pre-institution mediation and settlement – Pre-institution mediation, if mandatory – Prospective effect to declaration in Patil Automation’s case – Money suit by respondent Union of India in commercial court for recovery of certain sum from appellant – No urgent interim relief prayed for – Preliminary objection by appellant as regards maintainability of the suit without availing the remedy of pre-institution mediation u/s.12A – Interim application by appellant u/Ord.VII r.11 seeking rejection of plaint – Commercial court declining to reject the plaint, directed post-institution mediation – In revision application, the High Court directed the suit be kept in abeyance and parties to attend mediation – Correctness:
Held: Approach adopted by High Court in keeping the suit in abeyance and referring the parties to mediation, strikes a perfect balance between the mandatory nature of s.12A as well as the prospective applicability of the consequence of non-compliance with s.12A as held in Patil Automation’s case – Decision of this Court in Patil Automation’s case lays down the correct position of law as regards s.12A by holding it to be mandatory in nature, which * Author 432 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports relates back to the date of the Amending Act; and that any suit which is instituted under the 2015 Act without complying with s.12A is liable to be rejected u/Ord.VII r.11, however, this declaration applies prospectively to suits instituted on or after the date of the decision in Patil Automation’s case, i.e., 20.08.2022 – Suits instituted without complying with s.12A of the 2015 Act prior to 20.08.2022 cannot be rejected u/Ord.VII r.11 on the ground of non-compliance with s.12A unless they fall within the exceptions stipulated in Patil Automation’s case – In suits instituted without complying with s.12A prior to 20.08.2022 which are pending adjudication before the trial court, the court shall keep the suit in abeyance and refer the parties to time-bound mediation in accordance with s.12A if an objection is raised by the defendant by filing an application u/Ord.VII r.11, or where any of the parties expresses an intent to resolve the dispute by mediation – Respondent does not fall under any of the exceptions and it cannot be said that bar of s.12A would continue to apply to the money suit filed by respondents despite there being a prospective declaration in Patil Automation’s case – Money suit was filed by the respondents much prior to the decision in Patil Automation’s case and it is squarely protected by the prospective ruling – Harmoniously construing observations in Patil Automation’s case, it is clear that while s.12A is held to be mandatory from the date of inception of the provision itself, the consequence of rejection for non-compliance is only made applicable prospectively – Trial court and High Court did not commit any error in refusing to reject the plaint – Mediation proceedings to be completed within the time frame stipulated by s.12A and the PIMS Rules – Pre-Institution Mediation and Settlement Rules, 2018 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Ord.VII r.11. [Paras 46, 47, 58, 59, 62, 64] Commercial Courts Act, 2015 – s.12A – Expression “urgent interim relief” – Construction of:
Held: Suit which contemplates an urgent interim relief may be filed under the 2015 Act without first resorting to mediation – Unlike s.80(2) CPC, leave of the court not required to be obtained before filing a suit without complying with s.12A – Test for “urgent interim relief” is if on an examination of the nature and the subject-matter of the suit and the cause of action, the prayer of urgent interim relief by the plaintiff could be said to be contemplable when the matter is seen from the standpoint of the plaintiff – Courts must also be wary of the fact that the urgent interim relief must not be merely [2025] 6 S.C.R. 433M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. an unfounded excuse by the plaintiff to bypass the mandatory requirement of s.12A. [Para 62] Commercial Courts Act, 2015 – s.12A – Equitable maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia – Meaning:
Held: Law does not compel an impossible performance – After the establishment of Commercial Court at relevant place, the statutory framework and corresponding rules were progressively implemented until December 2020 – Thus, during this intervening period, referring the matter to pre-suit mediation u/s.12A was impossible due to a persisting vacuum created by lack of appointment of necessary authorities and delineation of the procedural framework – Awaiting the establishment of the requisite infrastructure would unduly impede the recovery process in a money suit involving public funds, thereby defeating the very purpose and legislative intent of the 2015 Act, which aims to ensure the expeditious resolution of commercial disputes – Declaration of the mandatory nature of s.12A was given prospective effect in Patil Automation’s case keeping in mind the fact that s. 12A, being in its stages of infancy, had given rise to conflicting views by different High Courts and consequently an overall lack of clarity on the nature of the provision. [Paras 49, 51, 52, 53] Case Law Cited Patil Automation Private Limited and Others v. Rakheja Engineers Private Limited [2022] 11 SCR 808 : (2022) 10 SCC 1 – relied on. I.C. Golaknath and others v. State of Panjab and Others [1967] SCR 762 : AIR 1967 SC 1643; Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey [1988] 1 SCR 118 : (1987) 4 SCC 398; Madanuri Sri Rama Chandra Murthy v. Syed Jalal [2017] 5 SCR 294 : (2017) 13 SCC 174; Popat and Kotecha Property v. State Bank of India Staff Assn. [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 1030 : (2005) 7 SCC 510; Yamini Manohar v. T.K.D. Keerthi (2024) 5 SCC 815; U.P. SRTC v. Imtiaz Hussain [2005] Supp. 5 SCR 725 : (2006) 1 SCC 380 – referred to.
Spectrum Plus Ltd., In re: (2005) 3 WLR 58 – referred to. List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Commercial Courts Act, 2015; Pre-Institution Mediation and Settlement Rules, 2018; Limitation Act, 434 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1963; Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts (Amendment) Act, 2018; Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
List of Keywords Rejection of plaint; Pre-institution mediation; Post-institution mediation; Money suit; Recovery process in a money suit; Prospective applicability; Lex non cogit ad impossibilia; Urgent interim relief; Harmonious construction; Persisting vacuum created by lack of appointment of necessary authorities; Expeditious resolution of commercial disputes; Suit kept in abeyance; Explore possibility of settlement by instituting mediation; Sending the parties to mediation; Pre-institution mediation and settlement; Pre-institution mediation, if mandatory; Prospective effect to declaration in Patil Automation’s case; Remedy of pre-institution mediation; Time-bound mediation. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6846 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.02.2021 of the High Court at Calcutta in CO No. 1678 of 2020 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Vikas Singh, Pradip K.tarafder, Sr. Adv., Ms. Deepeika Kalia, Ms. V. Singh, Sudeep Chandra, Shambudha Dutta, Mrs. Anjani Aiyagari.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, A.S.G., Ms. Harshita Choubey, Sudarshan Lamba, Aaditya Dixit, Ms. Mili Baxi, Bhuvan Kapoor.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts:
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 435M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX .............................................................. 2
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT ......... 9
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE UNION OF INDIA ... 13
D. ANALYSIS ............................................................................ 19 i. Legislative intent behind the enactment of Section 12A of the 2015 Act ............................................................. 20 ii. Section 12A of the 2015 Act is mandatory in nature .... 26 iii. How the expression “urgent interim relief” is to be construed ....................................................................... 35 iv. The effect of according prospectivity to the declaration in Patil Automation (supra) on cases like the one at hand ............................................................................... 39 v. The equitable maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia ......... 41 E. CONCLUSION ...................................................................... 49
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court at Calcutta on its appellate side dated 22.02.2021 in C.O. No. 1678 of 2020 by which the High Court disposed of the revision application filed by the appellant herein by directing that the suit instituted by the respondent herein, i.e., Union of India, on 09.08.2019, shall be kept in abeyance for seven months from the date of the order or until the receipt of the report of the mediator, whichever is earlier. In other words, the High Court proceeded to pass an order keeping in mind Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (for short, “the 2015 Act”), as amended in 2018.
* Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
436 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarised as under: a. The respondent Union of India instituted Money Suit No. 28 of 2019 on 09.08.2019 in the Commercial Court, Alipore against the appellant herein for the recovery of a sum of Rs. 8,73,36,976/- (Rupees Eight Crore, Seventy-Three Lakh, Thirty-Six Thousand, Nine Hundred and Seventy-Six only) towards differential freight and penalty. Indisputably, no urgent interim relief was prayed for in the said suit.
b. No sooner the suit referred to above came to be instituted than the appellant herein, as defendant, raised a preliminary objection in its written statement dated 20.12.2019 as regards the maintainability of the suit without availing the remedy of pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the 2015 Act read with Pre-Institution Mediation and Settlement Rules, 2018 (in short, “the PIMS Rules”) which came into force with effect from 03.07.2018.
c. On 30.09.2020, the appellant herein preferred Interim Application No. 190 of 2020 under Order VII Rule 11(d) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (for shot, the “CPC”) read with Section 12A of the 2015 Act seeking rejection of the plaint, inter alia, on the ground that the Money Suit No. 28 of 2019 suffered from institutional defects and was violative of the mandatory provisions of preinstitution mediation.
d. The Order VII Rule 11(d) application, referred to above, came to be rejected by the Commercial Court vide order dated 21.12.2020. While rejecting the I.A. No. 190 of 2020 the Commercial Court observed thus:
“13. Since the case has been filed on 09.08.2019 and the present application has been filed at a belated stage, I find there is no requirement to reject the suit even for noncompliance of the mandatory provision of Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, otherwise, instead of aid in justice, the justice will be more delayed.
14. Once the plaint has been accepted by this Court, it would be presumed that the Court has no reason [2025] 6 S.C.R. 437M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. whatsoever to reject the plaint and obviously, the Defendant can raise this issue even at the time of filing W/S but admittedly, the Defendant no. 1 filed W/S even without taking the plea as now he has taken and in that case, it would be presumed that they are not also interested in the mediation proceedings.
15. This Court has been established on 05.07.2019 and within a month or more, the instant suit has been filed and at this stage, there is no proper infrastructure for conducting pre-litigation mediation and standard operating procedure has also not been framed by the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta.
16. In the above circumstances, the plea as taken by the Defendant no. 1/Petitioner is liable to be rejected as filed at a belated stage.
17. It appears from the instant application that the Defendant no. 1 is interested to proceed with the mediation proceedings and accordingly, let the dispute be referred to mediation and in such case also, the interest of the Defendant no.1/Petitioner will not be prejudiced.
18. Let the dispute be referred for mediation and Mr. Jayanta Mukherjee, Ld. Member of the Bar is appointed as the Mediator.
19. Both sides are directed to attend the mediation proceedings on 04.01.2021 at 2 p.m., and thereafter, the Ld. Mediator will fix further dates of proceedings and for doing so, the Ld. Mediator can obtain proposals for settlement from both sides.
20. The Ld. Mediator is further directed to complete his proceedings within 11.01.2021 and to submit the report alongwith the proposal if any, as submitted by both parties in a separate sealed envelope for consideration of this Court while awarding cost under Section 35A of the CPC.
21. Accordingly, the instant I.A. is disposed of as being rejected on contest.”
438 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports e. Thus, the Commercial Court while declining to reject the plaint directed post-institution mediation by asking the parties to name and appoint an advocate as a mediator.
f. The appellant herein, being dissatisfied with the order passed by the Commercial Court rejecting the application filed under Order VII Rule 11(d) of the CPC, challenged the same before the High Court by filing a civil revision application.
g. The High Court disposed of the revision application, inter alia, holding as under:
“15. In this case, the defendant filed the application under Order VII Rule 11(d) of the Code of Civil Procedure for rejection of the plaint as being barred by law, the plaintiff having failed to initiate the process of mediation under Section 12A of the said Act. However, assuming that the plaint is rejected on this ground, Order VII rule 13 would allow the plaintiff to file another suit on the self same cause of action. Thus, in my opinion, rejecting the plaint at this stage, would not be in consonance with the objectives of the said Act and Rules. The plaintiffs may face a non-starter or a non-settlement and would have to come back and file a suit once again. This will cause unnecessary delay and shall not be cost effective even for the defendant. Thus, considering the ultimate object of the provision of law, this Court is of the opinion that the suit which is at its early stage, be kept in abeyance and the plaintiff be directed to comply with the provisions of Section 12A. This order is further passed keeping in mind the time and the situation when the plaint was filed, that is, within a month after the commercial division at Alipore had been made operative. It is also true that until December, 2020, the SOP and the meditation rules to be followed by the Legal Services Authority Act, 1987 in West Bengal, for conducting commercial mediations had not been notified. The panel of trained mediators for commercial suit was also prepared and published thereafter. Thus the plaintiffs had sufficient reasons not to go for an effective mediation as envisaged under the said Rules [2025] 6 S.C.R. 439M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. in the absence of proper infrastructure. The situation would have been otherwise, had there been proper infrastructure in place.
16. The decision of the Calcutta High Court will not apply as the decision was on the point of leave to file the suit without exhausting the mediation process.
This Court is not dispensing with the requirement of Section 12A but directing the plaintiff to comply with the provision of law by keeping the suit in abeyance.
17. Mediation in India is still in its nascent stage and requires more awareness. Prior to the publication of the panel of trained mediators for settlement of commercial disputes, there was no complete machinery which could be availed. Settlement of commercial disputes require special technical and commercial knowledge.
18. Mandatory training for mediation of commercial disputes is the minimum requirement for any mediator to be appointed in terms of the said Rules. Commercial disputes are very often technical in nature and may involve knowledge in commercial law and business.
If such was not the case, a separate panel of such mediators would not have been prepared. The Act and the Rules have been framed with an object of improving the “ease of doing business”.
19. Section 12A of the Pre-Institution Mediation, is a mere tool for reduction of pendency of commercial litigation in India. However, the purpose of the said Section 12A and the Rules cannot not be to nonsuit a party but only to encourage the party seeking to file a suit to first explore the possibility of settlement of the dispute through mediation. Section 12A provides the parties with an alternative mechanism to resolve their disputes by negotiation in the presence of a mediator.
Such mediation has been made time bound and the parties also have the liberty to move the commercial court for adjudication of the dispute, if a mediation results in a non-starter or the talks of settlement fail. 440 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
20. Thus the plaint should not be rejected at this stage on the ground of non-compliance with Section 12A of the said Act when the plaintiff can still be directed to comply with the provisions of law by keeping the suit in abeyance.
21. The instant case is a suit for recovery of money filed by the Union of India for an amount over Rs.8 Crores. The alleged claim is for recovery of public money. The allegation is illegal claim of concessional rate of freight under Rate Circular No.24/2008, 30/2008 and 36/2009. The suit was filed, summons were issued, the written statement was filed, case management hearing was held. The defendant did not show any inclination towards settlement of the dispute by way of mediation. An application under Order VII Rule 11 (a) of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed by the defendant for rejection of the plaint against the defendant No. 2 to 4. Noncompliance with Section 12A was not raised by the defendant in the said application. Thereafter, once the earlier application was rejected, a subsequent application under Order VII Rule 11(d) for rejection of the plaint on the ground of noncompliance with Section 12A of the said Act was again filed. The application was filed on September 30, 2020, that is, more than a year since the institution of the suit. Thus, the learned court held that the suit should not fail for non-compliance of Section 12A of the said Act. Rejection of the plaint would result in delay in dispensation of justice, instead of the court acting in aid of justice. In my opinion, this was a correct approach, keeping in mind the objects and reasons for establishing Commercial Courts, that is, quick and easy resolution of disputes either by settlement or in court. Yet, the obligation under the law must be complied with. The learned court below rightly directed the suit to be kept in abeyance. In my opinion, the defendants will not suffer any prejudice.
The suit has not progressed beyond filing of the written statement. Thereafter two consecutive applications were filed by the defendant for rejection of the plaint. [2025] 6 S.C.R. 441M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. It is also not the case of the defendant that they are interested in settlement through mediation.
22. The decisions cited by Mr. Mitra are not applicable in the facts of this case. The court can make an order adjusting equities for satisfying the ends of justice as it may deem fit while interpreting a procedural law even if the same is couched with a negative covenant.
23. However, the learned court below erred in naming the mediator himself, instead of directing the plaintiffs to approach the State Legal Services Authority, West Bengal, in terms of the 2018 Rules and the SOP notified by the State of West Bengal in this regard.
24. The order impugned is set aside to the extent of appointment of Mr. Jayanta Mukharjee learned member of the bar as a mediator, and the direction upon the parties to attend the mediation on the date fixed by the learned court below and also further directing the learned mediator to complete the proceeding within January 11, 2021 and submit a report before the learned court.
25. Hence, it is ordered that the suit be kept in abeyance for seven months from date or until receipt of the report of the learned mediator, whichever is earlier. The plaintiffs are directed to approach the District Legal Services Authority, West Bengal in accordance with the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) dated December 11, 2020, mandatorily, within two weeks from date. In case of default, the learned court below shall be at liberty to pass such orders in the suit for non-compliance of the order of court.
The Authority shall act in accordance with the said Rules of 2018 and the SOP. The process is to be completed within the period as prescribed by the Rule 3(8) of the Rules of 2018. The Mediator shall file the report in such Form and manner as prescribed by the Rules, before the learned court below within the aforesaid period. The remuneration/fees etc. of the learned Mediator will be fixed as per the SOP.
442 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
26. Upon receipt of the report from the Mediator, the learned Commercial court will proceed according to law. This revisional application is disposed of and there shall be no order as to costs.”
4. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant-original defendant has come up before us with the present appeal.
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
5. Mr. Vikas Singh, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant, vehemently submitted that the High Court committed an egregious error in declining to reject the plaint having regard to the mandatory provision of Section 12A of the 2015 Act. According to the learned counsel, the issue is squarely covered by the decision of this Court in Patil Automation Private Limited and Others v. Rakheja Engineers Private Limited reported in (2022) 10 SCC 1, wherein this Court has said in so many words that Section 12A of the 2015 Act is mandatory and any suit instituted violating the mandate of Section 12A must be visited with rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11.
6. The learned counsel laid much emphasis on the observations made by this Court in Patil Automation (supra) as contained in paragraphs 103 and 114 of the judgment respectively. He would argue that in Patil Automation (supra) this Court while holding on one hand that it is crystal clear that the procedure provided under Section 12A of the 2015 Act is mandatory, said on the other hand that in view of the facts of Patil Automation (supra), where the trial had progressed substantially, directed the parties to appear before the Secretary District Legal Services Authority, Faridabad for mediation keeping the suit alive and in abeyance. Taking a clue from the observations made by this Court in paragraphs 103 and 114 of Patil Automation (supra) respectively, the learned counsel submitted that the suit in question is still at the initial stage and the same has been kept in abeyance and has not progressed beyond filing of the written statement. This, according to the learned counsel, would take the suit in question out of the purview of the category where there has been substantial progress in the suit. In other words, according to the learned counsel, since there has been no progress worth the name in the suit in question, the mandate of Section 12A will apply with all force and the plaint ought to meet with the fate of rejection. [2025] 6 S.C.R. 443M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr.
7. The learned counsel submitted that this Court in Patil Automation (supra) applied the principle of prospective overruling more particularly for the purpose of issuing directions as contained in paragraph 113 and sub-paragraphs respectively thereof. Relying on the decision of the Constitution Bench in I.C. Golaknath and others v. State of Panjab and others reported in AIR 1967 SC 1643, more particularly the observations made in paragraph 45 therein, the learned counsel would submit that even while applying the doctrine of prospective overruling the law laid down could be said to have been always the same. If a subsequent decision changes the earlier one, the later decision would not change the law but would only discover and lay down the correct principle of law. According to the learned counsel, if the suit is allowed to proceed further the same would amount to a fresh litigation as it has not progressed beyond the initial stage and has been under subsisting orders of stay since 2021.
8. In such circumstances referred to above, according to the learned counsel there remains no material distinction between a fresh suit if filed today and the present suit sought to be revived from the state of inception.
9. The learned counsel laid much stress on his submission that the suit in question would be governed by the declaration made by this Court in Patil Automation (supra).
10. The learned counsel further submitted that while applying the doctrine of prospective overruling, the House of Lords in the case of Spectrum Plus Ltd., In re: reported in (2005) 3 WLR 58, has held that prospective overruling takes several different forms. In its simplest form prospective overruling involves a court giving a ruling of the character sought by the bank in that case. Overruling of this simple or “pure” type has the effect that the court’s ruling has an exclusively prospective effect. The ruling applies only to transactions or happenings occurring after the date of court’s decision. All transactions entered into, or events occurring, before that date continue to be governed by the law as it was conceived to be before the court gave its ruling.
11. It was also argued that even otherwise since the suit has not progressed beyond the initial stage the declaration made by this Court in paragraph 104 of Patil Automation (supra) would apply with all force. In paragraph 104 the Court observed, “They would have to bring a fresh suit, no doubt after complying with Section 12A, 444 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports as permitted under Order VII Rule 13. Moreover, the declaration of law by this Court would relate back to the date of the Amending Act of 2018”. The same would be applicable in the present facts and circumstances of the case.
12. In the last, the learned counsel submitted that if the suit is withdrawn today and filed afresh after exploring the avenue of pre-institution mediation, it would not, in any manner, give rise to the question of limitation having been exhausted, since the plaintiff is the Central Government, and the limitation to file the suit by Central Government is 30 years under Article 112 of the schedule of the Limitation Act, 1963 (for short, “the Limitation Act”).
13. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being merit in his appeal the same may be allowed and the plaint be ordered to be rejected.
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE UNION OF INDIA
14. Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, the learned Additional Solicitor General, submitted that no error, not to speak of any error of law, could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned order.
15. The learned ASG laid much emphasis on the fact that the suit instituted by the Union of India for recovery of money from the appellant herein should not fail in view of the purported non-compliance with Section 12A of the 2015 Act, more particularly, when the infrastructural requirement for the mediation process was not completed and the Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) came to be framed only on 11.02.2020.
16. The learned ASG submitted that there need not be any debate on the point that Section 12A of the 2015 Act is mandatory. In other words, Section 12A stipulates compulsory pre-suit mediation. She would submit that the issue is no longer res integra in view of the decision of this Court in Patil Automation (supra). However, according to the learned ASG the law laid down by this Court in Patil Automation (supra) should be applied prospectively with effect from 20.08.2022 as made clear in the decision itself.
17. The learned ASG provided us with a table to give a bird’s eye view of the timelines for insertion of Section 12A of the 2015 Act followed [2025] 6 S.C.R. 445M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. by creation of the necessary infrastructure for implementation of the provisions and the filing of the money suit by Union of India.
18. According to the learned ASG, the table would reveal that after the establishment of the first Commercial Court in Alipore, the statutory framework and corresponding rules were progressively implemented till December 2020. According to her, the money suit instituted in 2019 could not have been referred to pre-suit mediation under Section 12A due to persisting infrastructural vacuum created by lack of appointment of necessary authorities/mediators and delineation of the procedural framework for the same. The table provided by the learned ASG reads thus:
Date Insertion and subsequent implementation of S.12A Money Suit 03.05.2018 S. 12A was introduced by way of amendment to the 2015 Act mandating pre-suit mediation.
03.07.2018 Central Government notified the PIMS Rules. Rule 3 requires a party to make an application to the Authority for initiation of mediation p r o c e s s . T h e C e n t r a l Govt. further authorised the State Authority and District Authority constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 for the purposes of pre-institution mediation and settlement.
12.09.2018 The Central Govt. further authorised the authorities constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 such as the National and District Legal Services Authorities for the purposes of pre-institution mediation and settlement.
446 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 09.08.2019 Money Suit No. 28 of 2019 filed before the Commercial Court by the respondents seeking recovery of a sum of INR 8,73,36,976 against the appellant.
20.12.2019 The appellant filed its written statement in the suit.
27.01.2020 A panel of trained mediators for conducting pre-litigation mediation in commercial disputes was sent to the State Legal Services Authority, West Bengal.
30.09.2020 Appellant filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC seeking rejection of the plaint after more than one year of filing of the suit, evincing that the same was merely an afterthought with the purpose of negating the suit.
14.10.2020 The SOP was prepared by the State Legal Services Authority.
11.12.2020 The SOP was approved
19. The learned ASG submitted that although the first commercial court was established at Alipore on 05.07.2019, yet the institutional infrastructure for pre-suit mediation was not in place until much later. This is because the panel of trained mediators was prepared only on 27.01.2020 followed by approval of the SOP on 21.12.2020. As such, when the Union of India instituted the Money Suit on 09.08.2019, the requisite infrastructure for conducting pre-suit mediation was not yet established thereby making compliance with Section 12A impossible.
20. The learned ASG tried to fortify her submission by relying on the equitable maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia, i.e., law does not compel an impossible performance. In this regard, the learned ASG placed reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of Raj [2025] 6 S.C.R. 447M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey reported in (1987) 4 SCC 398, more particularly, the observations made in paragraph 6 therein.
21. The learned ASG submitted that taking advantage of this administrative vacuum, the appellant should not be allowed to defeat the money suit under the garb of non-compliance. Section 12A, at its nascent stage was not a feasible course. If settlement through mediation is truly the real objective and intention of the petitioner, the same may be fully achieved by the impugned order.
22. It was further submitted that had Union of India awaited the establishment of the requisite infrastructure, the same would have unduly impeded the recovery process in a money suit involving public funds, thereby defeating the very purpose and legislative intent of the 2015 Act, which aims to ensure expeditious resolution of commercial disputes.
23. In the last the learned ASG submitted that if the money suit instituted by the Union of India is dismissed on the ground of Section 12A of the 2015 Act, the Union of India would still have the opportunity to file another suit on the same cause of action under Order VII Rule 13 of the CPC and the process would have to start afresh. The court fees would also have to be deposited for the fresh suit. Such delay and protraction of the suit proceedings would be contrary to the very objective of the 2015 Act and the same may lead the public exchequer to suffer.
24. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned ASG prayed that there being no merit in this appeal, the same may be dismissed.
D. ANALYSIS
25. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, two questions fall for our consideration:
a. Whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned order; and b. Whether, due to non-compliance with Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, a suit should be dismissed under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, or whether it should be kept in abeyance, directing the parties to first explore the possibility of settlement by instituting mediation? 448 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports i. Legislative intent behind the enactment of Section 12A of the 2015 Act
26. Before adverting to the rival submissions canvassed on either side, we must look into few relevant provisions of law.
27. Section 12A of the 2015 Act reads as follows:
“12-A. Pre-institution mediation and settlement.—(1)
A suit, which does not contemplate any urgent interim relief under this Act, shall not be instituted unless the plaintiff exhausts the remedy of pre-institution mediation in accordance with such manner and procedure as may be prescribed by rules made by the Central Government.
(2) The Central Government may, by notification, authorise the Authorities constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (39 of 1987), for the purposes of pre-institution mediation.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (39 of 1987), the Authority authorised by the Central Government under sub-section
(2) shall complete the process of mediation within a period of three months from the date of application made by the plaintiff under sub-section (1):
Provided that the period of mediation may be extended for a further period of two months with the consent of the parties:
Provided further that, the period during which the parties remained occupied with the pre-institution mediation, such period shall not be computed for the purpose of limitation under the Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963).
(4) If the parties to the commercial dispute arrive at a settlement, the same shall be reduced into writing and shall be signed by the parties to the dispute and the mediator.
(5) The settlement arrived at under this section shall have the same status and effect as if it is an arbitral award on agreed terms under sub-section (4) of Section 30 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996).”
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 449M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr.
28. At the time of enactment of the 2015 Act, the monetary limit for a suit liable to be tried by the Commercial Court was fixed at Rs 1 crore.
29. In the course of three years, noticing certain features, the legislature decided to amend the 2015 Act. Therefore, in the year 2018, the 2015 Act came to be amended by the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts (Amendment) Act, 2018 (Act 28 of 2018) (hereinafter referred to as “the Amending Act”).
30. It is apposite that we notice the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Amending Act:
“Statement of Objects and Reasons.—The Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 was enacted for the constitution of Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division in the High Courts for adjudicating commercial disputes of specified value and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.
2. The global economic environment has since become increasingly competitive and to attract business at international level, India needs to further improve its ranking in the World Bank “Doing Business Report” which, inter alia, considers the dispute resolution environment in the country as one of the parameters for doing business. Further, the tremendous economic development has ushered in enormous commercial activities in the country including foreign direct investments, public private partnership, etc. which has prompted initiating legislative measures for speedy settlement of commercial disputes, widen the scope of the courts to deal with commercial disputes and facilitate ease of doing business. Needless to say that early resolution of commercial disputes of even lesser value creates a positive image amongst the investors about the strong and responsive Indian legal system. It is, therefore, proposed to amend the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015.
3. As Parliament was not in session and immediate action was required to be taken to make necessary amendments 450 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015, to further improve India’s ranking in the “Doing Business Report”, the President promulgated the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018 on 3-5-2018.
4. It is proposed to introduce the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts (Amendment) Bill, 2018 to replace the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018, which inter alia, provides for the following namely—
(i) to reduce the specified value of commercial disputes from the existing one crore rupees to three lakh rupees, and to enable the parties to approach the lowest level of subordinate courts for speedy resolution of commercial disputes;
(ii) to enable the State Governments, with respect to the High Courts having ordinary original civil jurisdiction, to constitute commercial courts at District Judge level and to specify such pecuniary value of commercial disputes which shall not be less than three lakh rupees and not more than the pecuniary jurisdiction of the district courts;
(iii) to enable the State Governments, except the territories over which the High Courts have ordinary original civil jurisdiction, to designate such number of Commercial Appellate Courts at district judge level to exercise the appellate jurisdiction over the commercial courts below the district judge level;
(iv) to enable the State Governments to specify such pecuniary value of a commercial dispute which shall not be less than three lakh rupees or such higher value, for the whole or part of the State; and
(v) to provide for compulsory mediation before institution of a suit, where no urgent interim relief is contemplated and for this purpose, to introduce the pre-institution mediation and settlement mechanism and to enable the Central [2025] 6 S.C.R. 451M/s Dhanbad Fuels Private Limited v. Union of India & Anr. Government to authorise the authorities constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 for this purpose.
5. The Bill seeks to achieve the above objectives.”
31. It is, accordingly, by the Amending Act that Section 12A came to be inserted. We should also look into the PIMS Rules that came to be published in the Gazette and thereby came into force on 03.7.2018. Rule 3 reads as follows:
“3. Initiation of mediation process.—(1) A party to a commercial dispute may make an application to the Authority as per Form 1 specified in Schedule I, either online or by post or by hand, for initiation of mediation process under the Act along with a fee of one thousand rupees payable to the Authority either by way of demand draft or through online;
(2) The Authority shall, having regard to the territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction and the nature of commercial dispute, issue a notice, as per Form 2 specified in Schedule I through a registered or speed post and electronic means including e-mail and the like to the opposite party to appear and give consent to participate in the mediation process on such date not beyond a period of ten days from the date of issue of the said notice.
(3) Where no response is received from the opposite party either by post or by e-mail, the Authority shall issue a final notice to it in the manner as specified in sub-rule (2).
(4) Where the notice issued under sub-rule (3) remains unacknowledged or where the opposite party refuses to participate in the mediation process, the Authority shall treat the mediation process to be a non-starter and make a report as per Form 3 specified in the Schedule I and endorse the same to the applicant and the opposite party.
(5) Where the opposite party, after receiving the notice under sub-rule (2) or (3) seeks further time for his appearance, the Authority may, if it thinks fit, fix an alternate date not later than ten days from the date of receipt of such request from the opposite party.
452 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(6) Where the opposite party fails to appear on the date fixed under sub-rule (5), the Authority shall treat the mediation process to be a non-starter and make a report in this behalf as per Form 3 specified in Schedule I and endorse the same to the applicant and the opposite party.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.