K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 617; [2025] 6 S.C.R. 22
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 1 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5822/2025
- Sections
- 22, 74, 22(1), 16, 2, 19, 73, 22(2), 21, 55(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 22 : 2025 INSC 617 K.R. Suresh v.
R. Poornima & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 5822 of 2025)
02 May 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the correctness of the order passed by the courts below dismissing the suit instituted by the appellantpurchaser for specific performance of contract; and whether the appellant entitled to the refund of the amount purportedly paid as advance money.
Headnotes† Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.22 – Specific performance of contract – Refund of advance money – Agreement for sale-ATS between the parties pertaining to suit property for a sale consideration – Appellant-purchaser issued cheques towards the advance amount – Agreement stipulated that balance amount to be paid within four months, and in the event of failure, the advance amount would be forfeited, and upon failure on part of respondents-owners, double the advance amount to be paid to appellant as compensation – Appellant did not pay the balance within the agreed time period – Respondent-owners forfeited the advance amount and cancelled the agreement, and also sold the property to subsequent purchasers – Suit for specific performance of the agreement of sale by appellants – Dismissed by trial court as also by the High Court – Correctness:
Held: No perversity or illegality in the impugned judgment – Amount termed as “advance money” in the agreement for sale-ATS, was essentially “earnest money” – It was in the nature of a guarantee for the due performance of the contract – It was liable to be forfeited in the event that the transaction fell through by reason of the default on part of the purchaser – Inclusion of the forfeiture clause in the ATS was intended to bind the contracting parties and ensure the due performance of the contract – This is particularly * Author [2025] 6 S.C.R. 23K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
significant given the stipulated four-month period for completing the sale transaction and the primary object of executing the ATS, being the urgency of the respondent-owners which was known to the appellant – Findings of the courts below affirming that time was of the essence, further substantiates the said intent – Stipulated amount under the ATS was in the nature of an earnest money deposit and thus, s.74 of the 1872 Act cannot apply to the same – Forfeiture clause was fair and equitable rather than one-sided and unconscionable, as it imposed liabilities on both the parties – Forfeiture of advance money by the respondent was lawful and justified as there was breach of contract by the appellant, which led to financial losses to the respondents – Furthermore, as regards the refund of earnest money, u/s.22(1)(b) it is not a relief that automatically flows from a decree for specific performance of a sale agreement and must, thus, be explicitly sought – No such application for an amendment of the plaint moved before the courts below, appellant never prayed for the refund of the advance money – Law aids the vigilant, not those who sleep over their rights – Contract Act, 1872 – s.74. [Paras 31, 37, 40-42, 61-65] Specific Relief Act, 1963 – s.22 – Alternative relief of refund of earnest money u/s.22 – When:
Held: Plaint may be amended at any stage of the proceedings to enable the plaintiff to seek an alternative relief, including that of refund of earnest money, and the courts have been vested with wide judicial discretion to permit such amendments – However, u/s.22 courts cannot grant such relief suo moto, since the inclusion of the prayer clause remains sine qua non for the grant of such relief – When an “appropriate case” exists for seeking the said relief under this provision, it must be specifically sought either in the original plaint or by way of an amendment. [Para 58] Contract – Agreement of sale – Forfeiture of advance money – Difference between “advance money” and “earnest money”: Held: Terms “advance money” and “earnest money” are often used interchangeably – Word “advance” means money in whole or in part, forming the consideration of an agreement paid before the same is completely payable – Word “earnest” stands for a sum of money given for the purpose of binding a contract, which is forfeited if the contract does not go off and adjusted in price if the contract goes through. [Paras 30-31] 24 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Desh Raj v. Rohtash Singh [2022] 18 SCR 65 : (2023) 3 SCC 714; Kamal Kumar v. Premlata Joshi [2019] 1 SCR 54 : (2019) 3 SCC 704; Pydi Ramana v. Davarasety Manmadha Rao (2024) 7 SCC 515; Shree Hanuman Cotton Mills v. Tata Air Craft Ltd. [1970] 3 SCR 127 : (1969) 3 SCC 522; Videocon Properties Ltd. v. Bhalchandra Laboratories [2003] Supp. 6 SCR 1197 : (2004) 3 SCC 711; Satish Batra v. Sudhir Rawal [2012] 9 SCR 662 : (2013) 1 SCC 345; Central Bank of India v. Shanmugavelu (2024) 6 SCC 641; Chand Rani v. Kamal Rani [1992] Supp. 3 SCR 798 : (1993) 1 SCC 519; Welspun Specialty Solutions Ltd. v. ONGC [2021] 11 SCR 120 : (2022) 2 SCC 382; Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Dass [1964] 1 SCR 515 : 1963 SCC OnLine SC 49; Maula Bux v. Union of India [1970] 1 SCR 928 : (1969) 2 SCC 554; Kailash Nath Associates v. DDA [2015] 1 SCR 627 : (2015) 4 SCC 136; Lakshmanan v. B.R. Mangalagiri [1994] Supp. 6 SCR 561 : (1995) Supp. 2 SCC 33; Godrej Projects Development Ltd. v. Anil Karlekar [2025] 2 SCR 343 : 2025 SCC OnLine SC 222; Sahida Bibi v. Sk. Golam Muhammad, 1982 SCC OnLine Cal 59; Tarit Bhowmik v Mukul Day, 2014 SCC Cal 5361; Manickam v. Vasantha, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 2096 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited P Ramanatha Aiyar, “Advanced Law Lexicon”, 7th Edn; Sir Frederick Pollock, 3rd Baronet, Pollock & Mulla: The Indian Contract and Specific Relief Acts, 16th Edn – referred to.
List of Acts Specific Relief Act, 1963; Contract Act, 1872; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Agreement of sale; Advance amount; Earnest amount; Probate certificate; Guarantee for due performance of contract; Forfeiture clause; Time was of essence; Compensation for breach of contract; Refund of earnest money; Alternative relief; Amendment to pleadings; Amendment at any stage of the proceeding; Specific performance of [2025] 6 S.C.R. 25K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
contract; Refund of the amount paid as advance money; Forfeiture of advance money; Amendment of the plaint; Alternative relief of refund of earnest money; Appropriate case.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 5822 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.08.2021 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in RFA No. 386 of 2013 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Anand Sanjay M Nuli, Sr. Adv., M/s. Nuli & Nuli, Suraj Kaushik, Firoz Gandhi, Nahar Singh Yadav.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Supreeta Sharanagouda, Sharanagouda Patil, Mrs. Supreeta Sharanagouda , Jyotish Pandey, Vinod Kumar Srivastava, Saket Gogia, Ms. Gauri Pande, Ms. Sheetal Maggon, Mansingh, Dhawesh Pahuja.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts: - INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ............................................................. 2 i. Judgment of the Trial Court ....................................... 8 B. IMPUGNED JUDGMENT .................................................... 11
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT ............... 15
D. SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
NOS. 1-4 ................................................................................ 16 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
26 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
E. SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
NOS. 5-7 ................................................................................ 17 F. ANALYSIS ............................................................................. 18 i. Validity of the Forfeiture of Advance Money .................. 19 a. Difference between Earnest Money and Advance Money ....................................................................... 19 b. Permissible Extent of Forfeiture ........................... 27 ii. Law on the Alternative Relief of Refund of Earnest Money under Section 22 of the 1963 Act ................... 35 G. CONCLUSION ...................................................................... 42
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru dated 05.08.2021 in R.F.A. No. 386/2013 (SP) (“impugned judgment”) by which the High Court dismissed the appeal preferred by the appellant (original plaintiff) and thereby affirmed the judgment and order dated 24.11.2012 passed by the Court of V Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge at Bengaluru City, dismissing O.S. No. 3559/2008 instituted by the appellant herein for the specific performance of contract.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The position of the parties before this Court, the High Court and before the Trial Court is tabulated as follows: -
BEFORE THIS
COURT
BEFORE THE
HIGH COURT
BEFORE THE
TRIAL COURT
REMARKS
Appellant Appellant Plaintiff Original Purchaser/ Agreement of Sale Holder [2025] 6 S.C.R. 27K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
Respondent No. 1 Respondent No. 1 Defendant No. 1 Original Owner (by way of an unregistered Will)
Respondent No. 4 Respondent No. 4 Defendant No. 4 Husband of respondent no. 1 and GPA Holder Respondent Nos. 2-3 Respondent Nos. 2-3 Defendant Nos.
2-3 Minor children of respondent no. 1 and respondent no. 4 Respondent No. 5 Respondent No. 5 Defendant No. 5 Subsequent Purchaser (wife of defendant no. 6)
Srinivas S. - Defendant No. 6 Subsequent Purchaser (Deceased through his LRs)
Respondent Nos. 6 and 7 Respondent Nos. 6(a) and 6(b)
- Legal heirs of defendant no. 6 For the sake of convenience, the parties shall be referred to in terms of their status before the Trial Court.
4. The dispute arises from a claim for specific performance of the agreement of sale (hereinafter referred to as “ATS”) dated 25.07.2007 in respect of the property bearing Site No.307, situated at Kengeri Satellite Town Layout, Kengeri Hobli, Bangalore South Taluk (hereinafter referred to as “suit property”). The defendant no. 1 acquired absolute title over the suit property by way of an unregistered Will dated 12.11.2002 executed by her late mother.
5. The defendant nos. 1-4 executed an ATS dated 25.07.2007 in favor of the plaintiff for the purchase of the Suit Property for total sale consideration of Rs.55,50,000/-. The plaintiff issued two cheques 28 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports dated 16.07.2007 of the amount of Rs.10,00,000/- each towards part payment of the sale consideration, the receipt of which was duly acknowledged by the defendant no. 1. The said ATS stipulated that the sale transaction shall be completed by payment of the balance sale consideration of Rs. 35,50,000/- within four months from the date of the ATS, pursuant to which the sale deed was to be executed. The contents of the said ATS are extracted hereinbelow: - “ADVANCE SALE AGREEMENT This Advance Sale Agreement is executed on this Twenty fifth day of July, Two Thousand Seven (25-07-2007) -BY- Smt. R. Poornima, daughter of Late Rathnamma also wife of Sri M.L. Harsha, aged about 32 years, and Sri Lakshmisha, husband of Smt. R. Poornima, aged about 39 years, and the children of Smt. Poornima and Sri M.L. Harsha, 1) Kum. H.R. Anusha, aged about 7 years, 2)
Chi. H. Amogham aged about 3 years, both are minors represented by their mother and natural guardian Smt. R. Poornima, all are residing at House No.588, Postal Colony, Visveshwaranagara Layout, Mysore City-
IN FAVOUR OF:
Sri K.R. Suresh, aged about 42 years, son of Sri Rudrappa, residing at K. Gollahalli Village, K. Gollahalli Post, Kengeri Hobli, Bangalore South Taluk.
Whereas, the property mentioned in the schedule hereunder i.e Site bearing No.307, situated at Kengeri Ssatellite Town Layout, Kengeri Hobli, Bangalore South Taluk, the said property originally belonged to Smt.
Rathnamma, the mother of Smt. R. Poornima, which is her self-acquired property. The said site was allotted to her on dated ___ by the Bangalore City Improvement Trust Board, represented by its Chairman, vide allotment letter No. __ KST/ __ which was allotted, Thereafter Lease-Cum- Sale Deed registered in the office of the Sub-Registrar, Bangalore South Taluk, registered in Book-1 volume 2414 pages 16 to 19 as Document No.5734/85-86, thereafter the possession certificate No.33.73-74 dated 16-11-1973 [2025] 6 S.C.R. 29K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
was issued, during her life time she was in possession and enjoyment of the said property as its absolute owner and the absolute sale deed executed in her favour on 05-03-1986, in the office of the Sub-Registrar, Bangalore South Taluk, vide Book-1 volume 2414 pages 95-96 as Document No.5734/85-86, during her life time she was enjoying the same peacefully as its absolute owner and on 12-12-2022 she has executed a WILL/TESTAMENT to her only daughter Smt. R. Poormima and on 26-12-2002 she passed away. After her death, her only daughter Smt. R. Poormima and we became the sole and absolute owners, successors, title holders in possession and enjoying the said property. Khatha also got changed to the name of Smt. R. Poormima in the Town Municipal Office, Kengeri and enjoying the same happily.
In such a way we are in possession and enjoyment of the schedule property and we are in need of funds to meet our urgent necessities, hence we have sold the schedule property to you for total sum of Rs.55,50,000/ (Rupees Fifty-five lakhs Fifty Thousand only), out of the sale consideration Rs.20,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty Thousand only) I have received advance as hereunder:-
1. Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) through cheque bearing No.110581 dated 16-07-2007 drawn on Canara Bank, Yediyur Branch, Bangalore-560082.
2. Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakhs only) through cheque bearing No.110582 dated 16-07-2007 drawn on Canara Bank, Yediyur Branch, Bangalore-560082.
The remaining amount of Rs.35,50,000/- (Rupees Thirty- Five Lakhs Fifty Thousand only) we have agreed to receive the same at the time of registration. Within 4(four) months by paying the balance amount to us you can get registered sale deed either to your name or to the name of person as suggested by you.
The aforesaid property except you we have not encumbered the same in any manner to whomsoever, also in respect of said property except ourselves there are no any other title 30 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports holders or successors, if any such dispute arisen in future the same will be solved by us out of our own expenses and for which we have agreed.
In the event failure on your part to pay the remaining amount within stipulated period, the advance amount paid by you will be forfeited. In the event failure on our part to execute the sale deed, even though you are ready to pay the balance sale consideration and get registration of sale deed, in such an event we agreed to pay the double amount of the advance which you have paid as compensation. Hence, we have executed this Advance Sale Agreement by affixing our signature.
SCHEDULE:-
All that part and parcel of the site bearing No.307, 5th Main Road, Kengeri Satellite Town Layout, Kengeri Hobli, Bangalore South Taluk, now comes under Kengeri Town Municipal limits, old Khatha No.129, present khatha No.130, present property No.307, which comes within the limits of Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Paluk, bounded on the;
East by: Road West by: Site No.317 & 318 North by: Site No.308 South by: Site No.306 As bounded above measuring East-West 60-0 (sixty) feet, North South 40-0 (Forty) feet, together with house standing thereon is covered under this Advance Sale Agreement.
WITNESSES:-
1.
2.
3. VENDOR
PURCHASER”
6. It is the case of the plaintiff that upon approaching the bank on 20.09.2007 for a loan to purchase the suit property, he was instructed [2025] 6 S.C.R. 31K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
by the bank advocate to secure the original title documents and a probate certificate from the defendant no. 1, as the defendant no. 1 had acquired title over the suit property by virtue of an unregistered Will. Accordingly, the plaintiff requested the defendant nos. 1 and 4 respectively to obtain the probate certificate from the competent court to establish absolute and marketable title over the suit property. However, despite allegedly promising to furnish the required documents, the defendant no. 1 failed to do so. Further, the plaintiff purports to have repeatedly approached the defendant nos. 1 and 4 respectively between 20.09.2007 and 18.02.2008, orally expressing his readiness and willingness to complete the sale transaction, yet the defendants did not come forward to perform their part of the contract.
7. It is the case of the plaintiff that having no other alternative left, he ultimately issued a legal notice dated 18.02.2008 through his advocate, expressing his readiness and willingness and calling upon defendant nos. 1-4 to execute the sale deed by receiving the balance sale consideration. Thereafter, the plaintiff claims to have discovered that the defendant no. 1 was attempting to alienate the suit property in favour of the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively while the ATS dated 25.07.2007 was subsisting.
8. The defendant no. 1 issued a reply dated 15.03.2008 denying the allegations levelled in the legal notice dated 18.02.2008, stating that the advance amount of Rs.20,00,000/- paid by the plaintiff stood forfeited and consequently, the ATS stood cancelled on account of the default by the plaintiff in making the payment for the balance sale consideration within the specified four-months.
9. Aggrieved by the foregoing, the plaintiff instituted original suit being O.S. No. 3559 of 2008 before the Trial Court, praying for the following:
(i) an order directing defendant no. 1 to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff; (ii) deliver the possession of the suit property in favour of the plaintiff and; (iii) a declaration to the effect that the subsequent sale deed dated 15.02.2008 in favour of the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively is not binding on the plaintiff.
10. It is the case of the defendant nos. 1-4 that they were in urgent need of the sale consideration money to avail of the One-Time Settlement (for short, “OTS”) benefit from the Indian Overseas Bank 32 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports K.R. Mohalla, Mysore Branch which was time-bound for 3 months, thereby making time the essence of the contract. The defendant nos. 1-4 denied having ever agreed to produce the probate or the original title deeds as contended by the plaintiff. Furthermore, they have contended that owing to the plaintiff’s non-performance of the contract, they suffered substantial losses.
11. Pursuant to this, the defendant nos. 1-4 terminated the ATS and forfeited the advance paid by the plaintiff, going by the express covenant of the ATS. According to the defendants, at no point of time during the validity of the ATS did the plaintiff convey or express his readiness and willingness to complete the transaction. The defendants have also asserted that the plaintiff instituted the suit long after termination of the ATS.
12. The defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively in their written statement took the stance that they are bona fide purchasers of the suit property for a valuable consideration of Rs.38,40,000/- through registered sale deed dated 15.02.2008. They averred that they had no knowledge of the prior ATS between the plaintiff and the defendant nos. 1-4. Further, they argued that the suit filed by the plaintiff was not maintainable against them as the sale deed in their favor was not challenged by the plaintiff.
i. JUDGMENT OF THE TRIAL COURT
13. Upon appreciation of the oral as well as documentary evidence on record, the Trial Court vide its judgment and order dated 24.11.2012 dismissed the O.S. No. 3559/2008 filed by the plaintiff on the ground that the plaintiff had not approached the Court with clean hands. The Trial Court framed the following issues for its consideration: “1. Whether the plaintiff proves the due execution of agreement of sale dated 25.7.2007 for sale of suit property for total consideration amount of Rs.55,50,000/- and paid the earnest money of Rs.20,00,000/-?
2. Whether the plaintiff is always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract?
3. Whether the first defendant proves the termination of agreement of sale dated 25.7.2007?
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 33K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
4. Whether defendant No. 5 and 6 prove that they are bonafide purchasers of the suit property for valuable consideration?
5. Whether plaintiff is entitled for relief claimed in the suit?
6. What order or decree?”
14. The findings recorded by the Trial Court in its judgment and order can be better understood in five parts:
(i) First, on the issue of time being the essence of the contract, the Trial Court recorded that the defendant nos. 1-4 were acting under a necessity wherein they required the sale consideration money urgently to discharge the loan availed for the purpose of their business expansion which was in the nature of an OTS facility, a fact which the plaintiff was cognizant of as per his testimony. The Trial Court held that the defendants proved that time was the essence of the contract and hence, it was the bounden duty of the plaintiff to complete the transaction within the specified period.
(ii) Secondly, the Trial Court, while examining the issue of the unregistered Will and probate, noted that the defendant no. 1, as the sole legal heir of her mother, became the absolute owner of the suit property upon her mother’s demise. The Court also underscored the settled law that a Will need not be registered and lack of such registration does not impute its authenticity, thus making the procurement of probate unnecessary. Additionally, there was nothing on record to indicate that the advocate for the bank insisted for a probate certificate. The plaintiff claimed to have forgotten the name of the said advocate and had no opinion in writing to rely upon. Further, neither the legal advisor nor DW2 (defendant no. 4) was examined on the issue of probate, leading to an adverse inference against the plaintiff. The Court held that in the absence of any recitals in the ATS requiring the defendants to furnish original title deeds to the bank within four months, the plea taken by the plaintiff was false, frivolous, and concocted.
(iii) Thirdly, on the issue of readiness and willingness to perform, the Trial Court recorded that the plaintiff did not produce any 34 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports bank passbook, account extracts, ITR or other documents, to establish that he had sufficient finances to pay the balance sale consideration within the stipulated four-month period. The plaintiff, in his oral evidence, admitted that he had no funds in his bank account and lacked documentary evidence to substantiate possession of the required amount. Further, in his oral evidence, the plaintiff categorically conceded that his legal notice dated 18.02.2008 was issued only after the four-month period had lapsed. In view of these facts, the Court concluded that the plaintiff failed to prove his readiness and willingness to perform the ATS.
(iv) Fourthly, the Trial Court held that the defendant nos. 1-4 were not required to notify the plaintiff about the lapse of the fourmonth period or the subsequent sale of the suit property to the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively, as no such obligation was stipulated in the ATS. It further ruled that the defendant no. 1 had the absolute legal right to alienate the suit property. The Court, relying on the testimony of DW1 (defendant no. 6), found the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively to be bona fide purchasers of the suit property, who were unaware of the prior ATS and its cancellation. Consequently, the allegation of collusion between the defendant nos. 1 and 4 & the defendant nos. 5 and 6, as regards the subsequent sale of the suit property, was found baseless.
(v) Lastly, on the issue of forfeiture of advance money, the Trial Court held that the advance money, being primarily a security for the due performance of the ATS, was rightfully forfeited by the defendant nos. 1-4 in view of the plaintiff’s failure to perform and the resultant huge loss sustained by the defendant nos. 1-4. The Court also took note of the fact that the ATS contained explicit recitals regarding forfeiture. In light of the aforesaid, it was held that the plaintiff was not entitled to a refund of the advance money.
B. IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
15. Aggrieved by the judgment and order of the Trial Court, the appellant/ plaintiff, preferred First Appeal before the High Court in R.F.A. No. 386/2013 (SP).
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 35K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
16. A Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the appeal and thereby affirmed the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court on the following four grounds:
(i) First, the High Court held that, in the absence of any obligation under the ATS for the defendant no. 1 to furnish probate certificate before executing the sale deed, time was the essence of the contract. Thus, the plaintiff, having failed to pay the balance sale consideration within the stipulated four-month period, committed breach of the conditions specified in the ATS. Further, the Court took note of the fact that it was only after a lapse of three months from the expiry of the stipulated four-month period that the plaintiff issued legal notice dated 18.02.2008 to the defendant no.1 calling upon her to execute the ATS. The relevant observations read as under:
“14. […] There is no recital in the agreement of sale that the defendant No.1 was required to furnish the probate certificate from the competent Court before executing the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff upon receipt of the balance sale consideration. […] In the absence of requirement for furnishing probate certificate, the contention of the plaintiff that the defendant No.1 failed to perform her part of the contract is not acceptable having regard to the fact that it was well within his knowledge that the defendant No.1 acquired the suit property by virtue of the will executed in her favour by her mother, and the same was acted upon and her name was entered in the concerned revenue records.
15. The sale transaction was required to be completed within four months from the date of execution of sale agreement. The plaintiff failed to perform his part of the contract by coming forward to pay the balance sale consideration within four months as specified in the sale agreement. It is only after expiry of three months from the said date, the plaintiff issued the legal notice to the defendant No.1 calling upon her to execute the sale agreement.”
36 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(ii) Secondly, the High Court observed that the plaintiff, in his crossexamination, admitted that he did not possess any documents to establish his ability to pay the balance sale consideration. Further, the application moved by the plaintiff for production of additional documents, to show his ‘readiness’, was rejected by the Court, on the ground that any prior lacuna could not be allowed to be filled up at the appellate stage. Pursuant to the aforesaid, the High Court held that the plaintiff, having failed to prove his readiness and willingness to perform his part of the contract under Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (for short, “the 1963 Act”), was not entitled to the relief of specific performance. The relevant observations read as under:
“17. PW1 in his cross-examination has clearly admitted that he has no documents to show that he possessed the requisite amount to pay the balance sale consideration. The documents sought to be produced by the plaintiff by way of additional evidence also discloses that the plaintiff did not possess the requisite amount from the date of execution of sale agreement till filing of the suit or had the capacity to raise the requisite amount to pay the balance sale consideration. Further, the said additional documents cannot be permitted to be produced to fill up the lacuna before the Appellate Court and the same cannot be considered and accordingly, the application for production of additional documents is rejected.
18. […] In view of the aforesaid proposition of law enunciated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and Division Bench of this Court, it is held that plaintiff having failed to prove that he had the requisite funds to pay the balance consideration is not entitled for relief for granting the decree for specific performance under Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963.”
(iii) Thirdly, the High Court held that the defendant no. 1 failed to prove the termination of the ATS in favour of the plaintiff, as no documentary evidence to substantiate the same was placed on record. However, the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively [2025] 6 S.C.R. 37K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
were deemed bona fide purchasers for value, in view of the fact that the sale deed dated 15.02.2008 was executed in their favour only after the expiry of the four-month period in the ATS. Additionally, it is an admitted position of the plaintiff that he had obtained the certified copy of the sale deed executed in favor of the defendants nos. 5 and 6 respectively at the time of filing of the suit. On account of the plaintiff’s omission to challenge the said sale deed, the Court held that the suit was not maintainable against the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively. The relevant observations read as under:
“19. The defendant No.1 in her reply notice dated 15.3.2008 -Ex.P.13 has stated that the sale agreement was terminated on the ground that the plaintiff has failed to perform his part of the contract by paying the balance sale consideration within the specified time vide letter. However, the defendant No.1 has not placed any documentary evidence to substantiate the said claim. Hence, it is held that the defendant No.1 has failed to prove that the sale agreement was terminated.
20. […] The sale deed executed in favour of defendants No.5 and 6 after expiry of four months specified for completion of sale transaction cannot be held to be executed during subsistence of the sale agreement. Hence, the defendants No.5 and 6 are held to be bonafide purchasers for value.
21. The plaintiff in the cross-examination has admitted that he obtained the certified copy of the sale deed executed in favour of defendants No.5 and 6 at the time of filing of the suit. However, the plaintiff for the reasons best known to him has not challenged the sale deed. In the absence of challenge to the same, the suit filed by the plaintiff against defendants No.5 and 6 is not maintainable.”
(i) Lastly, the High Court recorded that the plaintiff had not sought for an alternative prayer for refund of the advance sale consideration in the suit as mandated by Section 22 of the 1963 Act. In view of the requirements under Sub-section 2 of the said 38 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Section, it was held that, in the absence of a specific claim for refund of advance money, the plaintiff was not entitled to such refund. The relevant observations read as under:
“22. The plaintiff has not sought for an alternative prayer for refund of the advance sale consideration in the suit as required under Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. In the case of Sukhwinder Singh (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the plaintiff therein is entitled for refund of advance sale consideration from the defendant No.2 - the purchaser of suit property from the defendant No.1 who had remained absent since the defendant No.2 benefited from the property. However, the defendants No.5 and 6 cannot be directed to repay the advance sale consideration and compensate the plaintiff since the plaintiff had not sought for alternative prayer for refund of earnest money in the suit as was done in the case before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In the absence of alternative prayer for refund of earnest money, the prayer for refund of earnest money cannot be granted in view of Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act. Sub-Section 2 of Section 22 of the said Act specifies that no relief under clause (a) or clause
(b) of sub-section (1) shall be granted by the court unless it has been specifically claimed. In the absence of such a claim, the plaintiff is held not entitled for refund of earnest money.”
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
17. Mr. Anand Sanjay M. Nuli, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant/plaintiff, submitted that the defendant no. 1 failed to obtain the promised probate certificate with respect to the suit property despite multiple requests from the plaintiff. It was further submitted that the defendant no. 4 has specifically admitted that between 18.02.2008 and 20.02.2008, the plaintiff voluntarily offered to pay an additional Rs.10,00,000/- beyond the agreed sale consideration of Rs.55,50,000/-. The learned Senior Counsel contended that the aforesaid admission proved the readiness and willingness of the plaintiff to fulfill his part of the contract.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 39K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
18. Mr. Nuli submitted that the defendant nos. 1-4, exhibiting mala fide intent, sold the suit property to the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively for Rs.38,40,000/- within just two months after the expiry of the stipulated four-month period. It was argued that the purported cancellation of the ATS was allegedly effected via a letter from the defendant nos. 1-4, though the said letter was never produced before the Trial Court. Further, he asserted that no prior notice had been served on the plaintiff before forfeiting the advance sale consideration or executing the sale deed in favour of the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively.
19. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant/plaintiff submitted that the plaintiff, as an alternative to the relief of specific performance, is entitled to a refund of the advance money paid by him. Mr. Nuli relied upon the judgments of this Court in Desh Raj v. Rohtash Singh, reported in (2023) 3 SCC 714 and Kamal Kumar v. Premlata Joshi, reported in (2019) 3 SCC 704, to argue that the relief of refund of advance money can be granted under Prayer (C) of the plaint which beseeches the Court to pass any order as it deems fit, despite there being no specific prayer to that effect.
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT NOS. 1-4
20. Ms. Supreeta Sharanagouda, the learned Counsel for respondent/ defendant Nos. 1-4, submitted that the plaintiff, in his crossexamination, admitted that he had no documents to show that he possessed the requisite amount to pay the balance sale consideration. Further, it was argued that the additional documents sought to be produced by the plaintiff also disclosed his financial incapacity from the date of execution of the ATS until the filing of the suit. The learned Counsel, relying upon Pydi Ramana v. Davarasety Manmadha Rao, reported in (2024) 7 SCC 515, asserted that the plaintiff failed to show his “readiness” and “willingness” to perform the contract.
21. Ms. Sharanagouda argued, that having regard to the fact that the balance sale consideration of Rs.35,50,000/- was to be paid within four months from the date of the execution of the ATS, time was evidently the essence of the contract. This was further established by the very purpose of the sale, which was the urgent business requirement of the defendant nos. 1 and 4, that got frustrated owing to the failure of the plaintiff to pay the balance consideration on time. 40 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
22. The learned Counsel further contended that pursuant to the recitals in the ATS, there was consensus between the parties with respect to the forfeiture of advance money in the event of the purchaser’s default in fulfilling the terms of the agreement.
E. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT NOS. 5-7
23. Mr. Dhawesh Pahuja, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent nos. 5-7 herein, submitted that the original defendant nos. 5 and 6 fall under the exception carved out by Section 19(b) of the1963 Act, having purchased the suit property in good faith and without notice of the prior ATS in favour of the plaintiff. It was argued that the factum of the prior ATS was suppressed and could not be discovered even on thorough due diligence, considering that the ATS was unregistered. An encumbrance certificate was placed on record to substantiate the same, which did not reveal any prior agreement in relation to the Suit Property.
24. The learned Counsel argued that the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively issued a legal notice dated 05.05.2008 against defendant nos. 1-4 soon after receiving objections regarding transfer of Khata from Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (for short, “BBMP”). It was asserted that only in the reply dated 23.05.2008 to the said legal notice that the defendant nos. 5 and 6 respectively were informed about the prior ATS dated 25.07.2007 and the eventual lapse of the said ATS on 25.11.2007 due to the default on part of the plaintiff.
25. In the last, it was argued that it would be too much to ask the bona fide purchasers to refund Rs.20,00,000/- to the appellant/plaintiff. Such a liability ought to be fastened upon the party guilty of suppression, i.e. the respondent/defendant nos. 1-4.
F. ANALYSIS
26. In view of the order dated 20.03.2023 passed by this Court, we are limiting our consideration in this matter solely to the issue of refund of earnest money.
27. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the appellant (original plaintiff) is entitled to the refund of the amount of Rs.20,00,000/- purportedly paid as “advance money”?
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 41K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
28. We intend to answer the aforesaid question in two parts, carefully delineating the following:
i. Validity of the Forfeiture of Advance Money; and ii. Law on the Alternative Relief of Refund of Earnest Money under Section 22 of the 1963 Act.
29. At the cost of repetition, we deem it necessary to state that there existed an explicit forfeiture clause in the ATS, which stipulated that the advance money paid would stand forfeited in the event of default by the buyer in fulfilling the terms of the contract. Similarly, in case of default on part of the seller, the advance money was to be doubled and paid back to the buyer. Pursuant to the aforesaid forfeiture clause, the respondent nos. 1-4 herein forfeited the advance money on account of the default by the appellant in paying the balance sale consideration of Rs.35,50,000/- within the stipulated four-month period. i. Validity of the Forfeiture of Advance Money a. Difference between Earnest Money and Advance Money
30. At the outset, it is pertinent to distinguish between “advance money” and “earnest money”. The said terms are often used interchangeably. The distinction becomes all the more essential, given that the ATS explicitly refers to the forfeited sum as “advance money”.
31. Here, we consider it apposite to refer to the meanings of the said terms. The word “advance” means money in whole or in part, forming the consideration of an agreement paid before the same is completely payable. On the other hand, the word “earnest” stands for a sum of money given for the purpose of binding a contract, which is forfeited if the contract does not go off and adjusted in price if the contract goes through. [See: P Ramanatha Aiyar in “Advanced Law Lexicon”, 7th Edn.]
32. The principles governing the scope of “earnest money” were succinctly explained in the case of Shree Hanuman Cotton Mills v. Tata Air Craft Ltd., reported in (1969) 3 SCC 522, reproduced as under: “21. From a review of the decisions cited above, the following principles emerge regarding ‘earnest’:
‘(1) It must be given at the moment at which the contract is concluded.
42 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(2) It represents a guarantee that the contract will be fulfilled or, in other words, “earnest” is given to bind the contract.
(3) It is part of the purchase price when that transaction is carried out.
(4) It is forfeited when the transaction falls through by reason of the default or failure of the purchaser.
(5) Unless there is anything to the contrary in the terms of the contract, on default committed by the buyer, the seller is entitled to forfeit the earnest.’” (Emphasis supplied)
33. In the case of Videocon Properties Ltd. v. Bhalchandra Laboratories reported in (2004) 3 SCC 711, while assessing the difference between “advance” and “earnest”, this Court took the view that the words used in the agreement alone cannot be determinative of the true nature of the amount advanced. Instead, the intention of the parties and the surrounding circumstances serve as more apt indicators. Further, the Court observed that earnest money fulfils a dual purpose: first, it operates as part-payment of the purchase price and; secondly, as security for the performance of the contractual obligations. Thus, its true character and purpose can only be canvassed on a close reading of the agreement, and the relevant contextual factors. The relevant observations are reproduced hereinbelow:
“14. […] Further, it is not the description by words used in the agreement only that would be determinative of the character of the sum but really the intention of parties and surrounding circumstances as well, that have to be looked into and what may be called an advance may really be a deposit or earnest money and what is termed as ‘a deposit or earnest money’ may ultimately turn out to be really an advance or part of purchase price. Earnest money or deposit also, thus, serves two purposes of being part-payment of the purchase money and security for the performances of the contract by the party concerned, who paid it.”
(Emphasis supplied)
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 43K.R. Suresh v. R. Poornima & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.