Agniraj & Ors. Etc. v. State Through Deputy Superintendent of Police Cb-Cid
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 774; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 856
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 23 May 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1686/2023
- Sections
- 149, 3, 302, 3(1), 147, 148, 2
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 856 : 2025 INSC 774 Agniraj & Ors. etc.
v.
State through Deputy Superintendent of Police CB-CID (Criminal Appeal No(s). 1686-1688 of 2023)
23 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka* and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court was justified in upholding the conviction of the appellants/accused no. 1 to 11 for offences punishable u/ss.302 and 307 r/w. s.149 of the Penal Code, 1860 and the other offences; whether, in the instant case, the trial Court followed the condition precedent before examining a minor witness; whether the trial Court satisfied itself that minor witness understood the importance of the oath.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 307 r/w.149 – Tamil Nadu Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1992 – s.3 – FIR lodged against thirty accused persons on a complaint made by PW-1 – There was political rivalry between the parties – On the night of 14.11.2012, PW-1, deceased no. 1 (brother of PW-1) along with his son (deceased no. 2) and daughter PW-9, were travelling in a car driven by his driver (deceased no. 3) – At around 9:30 p.m., a truck came towards them from the opposite side – To avoid a collision, deceased no. 3 swerved the car, and the truck grazed the car – A group including accused no. 1, armed with weapons attacked the car and its inmates – PW-1 escaped and hid in a nearby bush – The group attacked the three other occupants to death – When the group tried setting the car on fire, they spotted some men in police uniforms and fled – PW-2 witnessed this incident with one AR – Written complaint filed by PW-1 led to the registration of the FIR – Prosecution also relied upon fingerprints lifted from the car and recovery of weapons – Out of the twentyone accused who were charged, accused nos. 1 to 11 were convicted and others were acquitted – High Court confirmed the findings of the Trial Court – Correctness:
* Author [2025] 5 S.C.R. 857Agniraj & Ors. etc. v.
State through Deputy Superintendent of Police CB-CID Held: The material prosecution witnesses are PW-1 who is the first informant and alleged eye-witness, PW-2 and PW-9, a minor witness – Firstly, the evidence of PW-1 is dealt with – It is brought on record that though the DSP and other police officers met PW-1 at the scene of the offence, they did not record his statement – It has come on record that PW-1 did not directly go to the police station to record his complaint – Instead, PW-1 along with an advocate, PW- 14 and PW15 went to the police station and handed over a written complaint to PW-52 – There was a political rivalry between him and accused No. 1 – The possibility of filing complaint after deliberation with the supporters of political party cannot be ruled out – In the written complaint, PW-1 named 22 persons as accused – During investigation, 36 persons were treated as accused, out of which, only 21 persons were charged – 15 accused persons were dropped with the consent of PW-1 – The reason given is that PW-1 was nervous and hence, he exaggerated the incident by naming the said 15 accused – He gave no objection for deletion of 15 accused – PW-1 admitted that, in his report, he stated that 36 persons stood around the car – Then he came out with the theory that there were 20 persons – PW-1 has exaggerated the incident due to their political rivalry – He was unsure about the number of accused who were present at the time of the incident – The incident happened after 09:30 pm – PW-1 has not stated the distance between the bush in which he was hiding and the spot of the incident – There is a serious doubt whether he could have seen the incident in the light of the car – Therefore, the evidence of PW-1 does not inspire confidence – Now, dealing with evidence of PW-2 – For more than one and a half months, he did not approach the police or filed a complaint in any form – Considering the conduct of the witness of remaining silent for a long period of one and a half months, the testimony of this witness cannot be believed – Moreover, during this period, he moved from place to place – It is not his case that anyone threatened him during the said period – Moreover, he stated that one AR was an eye-witness – However, the prosecution failed to examine him – Therefore, adverse inference will have to be drawn against the prosecution – Now coming to PW-9, who was 10 years old on the date of recording of evidence – The Trial Court has not followed the condition precedent before examining a minor witness – Before administering oath, the Trial Judge did not satisfy himself that the witness understood the importance of the oath – Moreover, she deposed that after the date of occurrence, for the first time in the Court, she identified several accused – But test identification parade was not held – From the answers given in the cross-examination 858 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports that her mother told her the details of what happened to her, the possibility of tutoring the witness cannot be ruled out – Minors are prone to tutoring and in this case – Considering other materials on record, the failure of the prosecution to draw a Mahazar or Panchnama at the time of taking photographs of the fingerprints on the car goes to the root of the matter – The case made out by the prosecution cannot be accepted – Since evidence of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-9 and fingerprints allegedly found are to be ignored, what remains is the evidence of the alleged recovery of weapons at the instance of the accused – Only on the basis of recovery, by no stretch of imagination can the accused be convicted – Thus, impugned judgments of the High Court and the trial Court are set aside. [Paras 27-30, 32, 35, 42] Evidence – Recording evidence of a minor – Procedure:
Held: The law is well settled that before proceeding to record the evidence of a minor witness, preliminary questions must be asked by the Court to ascertain whether the witness is able to understand the questions and answer the same – The Court must be satisfied about the capacity of the minor to understand the questions and answer the same – In the instant case, the age of PW-9 was 10 years – However, preliminary questions were not put to the witness – The Court did not ask any question to the witness to ascertain whether she understands the importance of an oath – Without satisfying himself that the witness understands the importance of an oath, the Trial Judge administered oath to her – It is very well known that child witnesses are susceptible to tutoring and therefore, not asking preliminary questions to the minor witness makes her evidence very vulnerable. [Para 25] Constitution of India – Art. 134 vis-à-vis Art. 136 – Scope of Appellate jurisdiction – Re-appreciation of evidence in criminal appeal arising out of Art. 136 – Discussed. [Paras 36-39] Case Law Cited Pappu v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2022] 2 SCR 13 : (2022) 10 SCC 321; Mst Dalbir Kaur and Others v. State of Punjab [1977] 1 SCR 280 : (1976) 4 SCC 158 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Tamil Nadu Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1992.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 859Agniraj & Ors. etc. v.
State through Deputy Superintendent of Police CB-CID List of Keywords Section 302 of IPC; Political rivalry; President of the Panchayat Board; Eye-witnesses; Minor witness; AIADMK party; Communist party; Election; Delay in recording statement; Importance of oath; Child witnesses; Susceptible to tutoring; Preliminary questions to minor witness; Test identification parade; Dropping the names; Mahazar; Panchnama; Fingerprints; Recovery of weapons; Article 134; Article 136; Distinction between appellate jurisdiction in criminal matters; Interference with concurrent findings; Re-appreciating evidence.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s).1686-1688 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.03.2019 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in Madurai in CRLA (MD) Nos. 290, 291, 292 of 2015 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
R. Basant, Siddharth Agarwal, Sr. Advs., Rajeev Maheshwaranand Roy, Manu Krishnan, Raunak Arora, Gunjan Kumar.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Amit Anand Tiwari, Sr. A.A.G., Sabarish Subramanian, Ms. Devyani Gupta, Vishnu Unnikrishnan, Ms. Tanvi Anand, Ms. Saushria Havelia, Ms. Jahnavi Taneja, Pranjal Mishra, Danish Saifi, Vishal Tyagi.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment
ABHAY S. OKA, J.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
1. These appeals have been filed against the judgment dated 21st March 2019, of the High Court of Madras at Madurai. The impugned judgment upheld the conviction of the Accused Nos. 1 to 11 for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 307 read with Section 149 of 860 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, ‘the IPC’), and Section 3(1) of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act. The Accused Nos. 1 and 9 to 11 have also been convicted under Section 147 of the IPC, while Accused Nos. 2 to 8 have been convicted under Section 148 of the IPC. The appellants were sentenced to suffer life imprisonment.
2. A First Information Report (for short, ‘the FIR’) was registered on 14th November 2012 under Sections 147, 148, 307, 302, and 120B of the IPC and Section 3 of the Tamil Nadu Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act against thirty accused persons on a complaint made by PW-1.
3. The prosecution’s case is that the family members of Accused No. 1 had occupied the post of President of the Panchayat Board for approximately four decades. In the 2011 elections, the wife of PW-1 won the elections. The brother of PW-1 (Deceased No. 1) worked extremely hard during the elections. Both sides allegedly engaged in numerous skirmishes in the months following the elections. On the night of 14th November 2012, Deceased No. 1 (Kathiresan/ brother of PW-1), along with his son Prasanna (Deceased No. 2) and daughter Nikila (PW-9), were travelling in a car driven by his driver (Deceased No. 3). At around 9:30 p.m., a truck came towards them from the opposite side. In an attempt to avoid a collision, Deceased No. 3 swerved the Scorpio car to the left, and the truck grazed the car. Deceased No. 3 stopped the car after being hit. At that time, Accused No. 1 and some others arrived by three motorbikes, while others jumped from the truck and approached the car. The group was armed with weapons and attacked the car and its inmates, and attempted to set them on fire. PW-1 managed to escape and hid in a nearby bush. The group attacked the three deceased to death and inflicted serious knife injuries to PW-9. When the group tried setting the car on fire, they spotted some men in police uniforms and fled the scene.
4. After this, PW-1 narrated the incident to PW-52 (Sub-Inspector) and PW-56 (Deputy Superintendent of Police). A written complaint filed by PW-1 led to the registration of the FIR mentioned above. During the investigation, thirty-six persons were arraigned as accused. Out of them, fifteen persons were dropped by the prosecution, and a chargesheet was filed against twenty-one persons. PW-1 gave his [2025] 5 S.C.R. 861Agniraj & Ors. etc. v.
State through Deputy Superintendent of Police CB-CID no objection to dropping the names of these fifteen persons. The prosecution also relied upon fingerprints lifted from the Scorpio car, which matched the fingerprints of Accused Nos. 2 and 3. PW-35, who prepared the fingerprint report, was examined as a witness. PW-46, who was a photographer and who took photographs of the fingerprints, was also examined. The prosecution has also stated that aruvals were recovered at the instance of Accused Nos. 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8. At the instance of Accused No. 5, a knife has been recovered. A wooden log was recovered at the instance of Accused No. 11. The prosecution has also placed reliance on paint flakes found in the Scorpio car that matched with that of the truck.
5. The Trial Court examined fifty-eight witnesses, out of which the material eye witnesses are PW-1(Krishnan) who is the informant, PW-2 (Loorthu Prabhu) who witnessed the incident with one Abdul Rahman, and PW-9 (Nikila) who is the minor daughter of PW-1 and sustained injuries.
6. Based on the evidence on record, the Trial Court vide judgment dated 29th September 2015 convicted Accused Nos. 1 to 11 and sentenced them to life imprisonment. The Trial Court acquitted Accused Nos. 12 to 21 of all the charges. Against this judgment of the Trial Court, Accused Nos. 1 to 11 filed an appeal against their conviction before the High Court. The State and PW-1 also challenged the acquittal of Accused Nos. 12 to 21. These appeals came to be decided by the High Court vide the impugned judgment which confirmed the findings of the Trial Court and dismissed all appeals.
SUBMISSIONS
7. The learned senior counsel appearing for the appellants submits that the case of the prosecution is based on three eye witnesses, namely PW-1, PW-2, and PW-9, all of which have material contradictions and cannot be relied upon. He took us through the depositions of PW-1 and contended that this was wholly unreliable as it has material embellishments and exaggerations. While PW-1 claims to have told PW-52 (Sub-Inspector) and PW-56 (Deputy Superintendent of Police) about the incident at the scene of the incident itself, no statement has been recorded by them. Instead, he, along with an advocate and members of his political party, went with a written complaint to the police station almost two hours after the incident. The learned senior counsel contends that PW-1 has exaggerated the incident 862 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and initially named thirty-six persons as accused. Therefore, he said that he has no objection if the names of fifteen accused persons are removed.
8. Regarding PW-2, the learned senior counsel for the appellants submits that PW-2 is a chance witness who allegedly saw the incident with one Abdul Rahman. This PW-2 emerged from thin air after 43 days from the date of the incident and Abdul Rahman has not even been examined. Accordingly, an adverse inference has to be drawn based on this. No test identification parade has been conducted either.
9. Regarding PW-9 who was 7 years and 11 months at the time of the incident and was examined at the age of about 9 years, the appellant contends that no preliminary questions were asked. In the absence of voir dire examination, the appellant argues that no reliance can be placed on her statement.
10. In relation to other corroborating evidence, the learned senior counsel for the appellants has submitted that the fingerprint evidence is unreliable as PW-46 who was the photographer had denied taking the photos of the fingerprints and these photographs have not been exhibited either. No Mazhar was prepared of the fingerprints appearing in the car or while taking the fingerprints of the accused either. The learned senior counsel for the appellants also submits that there are contradictions in the recovery of weapons. No proper procedure was followed while collecting the paint flakes on the car either as mazhar was not prepared and no record was produced to show where the paint flakes were picked up from and to whom it was handed over.
11. The learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the State made a preliminary objection regarding the jurisdiction of this Court to consider the evidence that was on record before the Trial Court and the High Court. He made a distinction between the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of India and Article 134 which is the criminal appellate jurisdiction. The learned senior counsel vehemently submitted that this Court while exercising jurisdiction under Article 136 has to only consider whether the findings recorded by the High Court or Trial Court suffers from any manifest illegality or perversity and cannot reappreciate evidence. In cases where there are concurrent findings of conviction such as the present, the learned senior counsel submitted that this Court cannot interfere with such findings by reappreciating evidence.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 863Agniraj & Ors. etc. v.
State through Deputy Superintendent of Police CB-CID
12. The learned senior counsel supported the findings of both the Trial Court and the High Court and submitted that the appellants have not been able to controvert any of these findings. He stated that there is nothing to show that PW-1 was planted or was not present at the scene of the incident. The presence of PW-1 is also established by the statement of PW-9 and other witnesses. He submitted that there is no embellishment or material contradictions in the testimony of PW-1. The allegation of tutoring and making false allegations was rejected by the Trial Court and the High Court. He has also explained the delay of approximately 2 hours in registering the FIR by explaining the chain of events after the incident.
13. On the argument that there was a delay in recording the statement of PW-2, the learned senior counsel for the State contends that PW-2 could not approach the police as he had witnessed a gruesome attack by and against people he knew making his fear justifiable. The conduct of a person who has witnessed such a murderous assault can differ from person to person. As the statement of PW-2 has been consistent, it cannot be disregarded only because of the delay and because he knew PW-1 and his family. Further, it is not necessary that adverse inference has to be drawn for not examining Abdul Rahman as the totality of circumstances has to be seen.
14. The learned senior counsel submitted that the Trial Court and High Court found the testimony of PW-9 as reliable. The High Court had made an observation that preliminary questions were put to PW-9. Even if they were not put, it cannot be the sole reason for rejecting the witness testimony of PW-9. He has also relied on corroborating evidence such as the fingerprints of accused Nos. 2 and 3 being found in the car, blood recovery from bikes of the accused, and the paint flakes of the truck matching with the car. Accordingly, the learned senior counsel submitted that there is no scope to interfere with the concurrent findings of both the Trial Court and the High Court in the limited jurisdiction that this Court has when hearing cases under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.
CONSIDERATION
Consideration of material prosecution witnesses
15. The material prosecution witnesses are PW-1 (Krishnan) who is the first informant and alleged eye-witness, PW-2 (Loorthu Prabhu) and 864 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports PW-9 (Nikila), a minor witness. Firstly, we deal with the evidence of PW-1 (Krishnan). He stated that one of his brothers was working as the Secretary of the District Student Group in the AIADMK party. PW-1 (Krishnan) further deposed that the said brother was the deceased, Kathiresan. His wife is Prema. Kathiresan and Prema had two children, Prasanna and Nikila (PW-9). He stated that for 40 years, the father of the accused No.1 (since deceased), was the Panchayat President of Periyakannoor. After the demise of his father, accused No.1 and thereafter, his wife became the President. PW-1’s wife (Sathya) and accused No.1’s wife contested the election against each other in the year 2011. PW-1’s wife was elected as the Panchayat President. Kathiresan worked hard in the election of Sathya. According to PW-1 (Krishnan), the accused No. 1 belonged to the Communist Party. He has given a history of the dispute between his family and the family of the accused.
16. He deposed about the incident that occurred on 14 th November 2012 by stating that at about 6:30 pm, his brother Kathiresan, his son Prasanna and daughter Nikila (PW-9) came by a Scorpio car which was driven by his driver, Boominathan, to his village. He stated that when he along with Kathiresan started for Sivagangai in the night at 9 pm, Kathiresan was sitting on the seat to the left of the driver, PW-1 was on the rear seat behind his brother and Nikila (PW-9) and Prasanna were sitting on his right-hand side. He stated that at about 9:30 pm, an oncoming truck came towards the Scorpio car. To avoid a collision, the driver turned the car to the left side but the truck grazed the car. At that time, Kathiresan asked the driver to switch on the lights inside the car. He saw accused No. 7 (Vijaykumar) getting out of the truck with a 10-litre white can. At that time, 6 to 7 people got out of the truck with weapons like aruval, knife and wooden log. Four motorcycles came there. From the said motorcycles, accused No. 1 (Arjunan), accused No. 2 (Agniraj), accused No. 3 (Sathyaraj), accused No. 4 (Paulpandi), accused No. 6 (Yoganathan), accused No. 9 (Kanthamalai), accused No. 10 (Ganesan), accused No. 13 (Muthukumar) and accused No. 17 (Bose), came there. Accused No.1 (Arjunan) shouted to cut the persons sitting inside the car and burn them by pouring kerosene. At that time, accused Nos. 5 (Siva Kumar), 8 (Suresh @ Lenin Kumar),11 (Jayakumar), 14 (Kanagarajan) and 16 (Rajamani) also came with accused No.7 (Vijaykumar). Accused No.8 (Suresh @ Lenin Kumar) broke the car [2025] 5 S.C.R. 865Agniraj & Ors. etc. v.
State through Deputy Superintendent of Police CB-CID mirror and accused No.2 (Agniraj) smashed the windscreen of the car with the aruval in his hand. When Kathiresan got out of the car, accused No.2 (Agniraj) assaulted him with an aruval. By that time, PW-1 (Krishnan) had gotten out of the car. Kathiresan told him to run away. He ran into Karuvelam tree bush. He deposed that the accused No.3 (Sathyaraj) hit the head of Prasanna, and he fell into the nearby stream. Accused No.4 (Paulpandi) assaulted the driver of the car on his head with an aruval.
17. Accused No. 5 (Sivakumar) stabbed and injured the driver Boominathan with a knife. Accused No.6 (Yoganathan) pulled out Nikila (PW-9) and assaulted her on her head with an aruval. Thereafter, all the accused came together and assaulted Kathiresan, his son and the driver. They poured kerosene, which was in the 10-litre white colour can, around the car. At the time of setting the car on fire, a van came from the other side. Accused No.3 (Sathyaraj) told the driver of the Tata Magic van to go away. However, the van stopped and two police men wearing uniforms got down of that van. The accused who came by motorcycles went back by motorcycles, and others sat in the truck of accused No.7 (Vijaykumar) and left. The witness stated that he saw two police men coming, and after the accused left, he came to the place of occurrence from the place where he was hiding in the bush. The witness claimed that he had seen the occurrence through the headlight of the car, the light inside the car and the light of the truck. The witness stated that he received a call from his father. At that time, the witness talked about the details of the incident to his father. Thereafter, one person stopped his Maruti car, and he called the telephone No. 108. The witness further stated that a bus came there and 4 to 5 policemen got down from the bus. The policemen enquired about the incident. These policemen informed the police department. He stated that Kathiresan, his son Prasanna and his driver died. Thereafter, the 108 van came. On his complaint, an FIR was registered.
18. Now, we come to the cross-examination of the PW-1. In the crossexamination, he stated that he was hiding in a bush during the occurrence. He came out after the police had arrived. He stated that when he went to the place of occurrence from the bush, the Deputy Superintendent of Police (for short ‘the DSP’) had arrived at the place. When he was crying, the DSP questioned him. He told the details to the DSP. He was not sure whether the DSP recorded 866 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the information given by him in writing. He stated that from the Superintendent of Police to the higher police officers, all came to the place of occurrence. He stated that he went to the hospital at 10:45 pm. In the hospital, the doctors asked him about the incident. Though there were number of police officials in the hospital, no one enquired with him about the incident. He stated that he did not disclose anything to anyone. He stated that he went to the Taluka Police Station from the hospital, which is where he gave a complaint.
19. He admitted that when he gave the report for the first time, he stated that 36 persons stood around the car by which they were travelling. When his deceased brother got down from the car, he also got down from the car. In further cross-examination, he stated that he got down from the car and ran through the field and did not hide. He stated that he did not tell that to the police. He stated that he did not hide in the stream, he just ran across the stream and disappeared. He stated that no one had an axe in their hand and they were carrying rods. They did not attack anybody with the rods. They only attacked the car with the aruval and rod.
20. The witness stated that he showed to the DSP, the place where he was hiding. He accepted that it was dark at the time of the incident and nothing could be seen without light. He stated that he saw the incident with the help of the car light and other lights. Thereafter, he stated that there were more than 20 persons who were attacking the car by using aruvals, rods and wooden logs. The witness stated that when he lifted the deceased Prasanna, there was blood all over his head and body. He stated that his shirt and dhoti were fully stained in blood when the police arrived. In the cross-examination, he again claimed that he could see the incident from the place where he was hiding. He stated that he did not remember whether he told in the police enquiry that accused-Vijayakumar got down along with a kerosene can.
21. A very lengthy cross-examination was done on political parties such as AIADMK and Community Party. He admitted that he had no objection for removal of persons named as accused by him earlier.
22. Then we come to the evidence of PW-2 (Loorthu Prabhu). At the time of incident, one Abdul Rehman was with PW-2. It must be noted here that the said Abdul Rehman has not been examined by the prosecution. He stated that while he, along with Abdul Rehman, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 867Agniraj & Ors. etc. v.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.