Tahir V. Isani v. Madan Waman Chodankar, (Since Deceased) Now Through His Legal Representatives & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1044; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2810
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 6 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6391/2025
- Sections
- 52
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2810 : 2025 INSC 1044 Tahir V. Isani v.
Madan Waman Chodankar, (Since Deceased)
Now Through His Legal Representatives & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 6391 of 2025)
06 May 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court was justified in holding that since the appellant was a transferee pendent lite of judgment debtor, therefore, in view of provisions of Rule 102 of Or.XXI of CPC, the application filed by the appellant under Rules 97 and 101 of Or.XXI CPC was not maintainable.
Headnotes† Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.XXI, RR.97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102 – In 1996, respondent no.1-tenant filed a special civil suit no.97/1996/B against MK for dissolution of partnership, recovery of profit and ejectment – No issues relating to ownership of the property which was leased out to respondent no.1 – Appellant herein had purchased the said property not from any party to the said suit, i.e. the plaintiff or defendant, but from owner M/s. R Pvt. Ltd., who was not a party to the proceedings – In the said suit decree was granted in favour of respondent no.1 – Respondent no.1 filed an application for execution of decree – Appellant moved an application u/Or.XXI, Rules 97 and 101 of CPC objecting to execution of decree – Application of respondent no.1 was dismissed by the Executing Court – Aggrieved, decree-holder preferred writ petition – The High Court set aside the order of the Executing Court and it also closed the enquiry – Correctness:
Held: The Executing Court was right in rejecting the application of respondent no.1 – The appellant in the present case does not trace his title from the judgment-debtor, i.e. the MK and therefore, he is not a transferee pendente lite of the judgmentdebtor – The appellant is a bona fide buyer who had bought [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2811Tahir V. Isani v. Madan Waman Chodankar, (Since Deceased) Now Through His Legal Representatives & Ors.
the suit property from M/s R Pvt. Ltd., vide registered sale deed dated 24.04.2007, who traced their title from the original owner, Mrs. M, vide registered sale deed dated 16.01.1988 – The transferor, M/s R Pvt. Ltd., of the appellant was not a party to the suit bearing Special Civil Suit No. 97/1996/B, the decree of which has been put to execution – They were third party, having received the ownership rights from the original owner in 1988 – Thus, even if the appellant did buy the subjectproperty in 2007, during the pendency of the suit between the MK and the present respondents, the bar of Rule 102 of Order XXI does not affect or prohibit the appellant from raising his objections before the Executing Court under Rules 97 and 101 and subsequently receive its adjudication under Rules 98 and 100 – Thus, the impugned order of the High Court is set aside and the Executing Court is directed to proceed with the enquiry – The Executing Court is directed to decide the application u/Or.XXI, Rules 97 and 101 CPC on its own merits. [Paras 14-16] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order XXI, R.102 – Scope of – Discussed:
Held: The whole scheme of Rule 102 of Order XXI intends to preserve the idea of achieving finality of the judicial decisions – The provision imbibes the principle of “interest reipublicae ut sit finis litium” i.e., it is in the interest of the State that there should be an end to litigation – In a suit pending between a plaintiff and a defendant as to the right to a particular estate, the decision of the court in that case shall be binding not only on the litigating parties, but also on those who derive title under them by alienations (transfer) made while the suit was pending, whether such alienees, i.e. transferees, had or had not notice of the pending proceedings – Therefore, Rule 102 of Order XXI intends to protect the interests of the decree-holder against the attempts of unscrupulous judgment-debtors and their subsequent transferees who indulge in activities and leave no stone unturned to deprive the decree-holders from reaping the benefits of the decree granted in their favour – The Rule being equitable in nature, therefore, estops further creation of rights as it explicitly states that nothing in Rules 98 and 100 shall apply to the resistance or obstruction being made by the transferee pendente lite of judgment-debtor. [Para 9] 2812 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order XXI, R.102 – Ingredients of – Discussed:
Held: Rule 102 of Order XXI expressly lays down the ingredients as to when it can be applied – For a case to fall under Rule 102, it is a condition precedent that there exists a decree for the possession of immovable property – Secondly, there must be a resistance or an obstruction in the execution of the said decree – Thirdly, such obstruction or resistance must be made by a person to whom the judgment-debtor has transferred the property – Fourthly, such transfer must have occurred after the institution of the original suit, i.e. the one in which the decree was passed – If the aforesaid ingredients are made out, Rule 102 prohibits the protection of Rules 98 and 101 to such errant transferee of judgment-debtor – The transferee of a judgment-debtor who traces his title to the immovable property, that is the subject matter of a pending suit, is not entitled to seek the remedy available under Rules 97 to 102 of Order XXI – However, Rule 102 of Order XXI applies only to a person to whom the judgment-debtor has transferred the immovable property which was subject matter of that suit pendente lite – If the person who is resisting or obstructing the execution of the decree for possession of such property, is not the transferee of judgment debtor, i.e. he does not trace his title from judgment-debtor, bar of Rule 102 does not apply to him. [Paras 11, 13] Case Law Cited Usha Sinha v. Dina Ram and Others [2008] 4 SCR 1192 : (2008) 7 SCC 144; Jini Dhanrajgir and Another v. Shibu Mathew and Another [2023] 5 SCR 551 : (2023) 20 SCC 76 – relied on. Bellamy v. Sabine (1857) 1 De G & J 566 – referred to. List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Transfer of Property, 1882. List of Keywords Order XXI, R.97; Order XXI, R.102; Transferee pendente lite of the judgment-debtor; Execution; Title to the immovable property; Equitable; Interest reipublicae ut sit finis litium; Objections before the Executing Court; Ingredients of Order XXI, Rule 102; Resistance or Obstruction.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2813Tahir V. Isani v. Madan Waman Chodankar, (Since Deceased) Now Through His Legal Representatives & Ors.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6391 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.07.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Goa in WP No. 86 of 2022 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ninad Laud, Ivo Dcosta, Guruprasad Naik, Ms. Ishani Shekhar, Sahil Tagotra.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Yashraj Singh Deora, Sr. Adv., Priyesh Mohan Srivastava, M/S. Mitter & Mitter Co..
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal assails the correctness of judgment and order dated 25 th July, 2022, passed by the High Court of Bombay at Goa 1 in Writ Petition No.86 of 2022, whereby the learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition, and after setting aside the order dated 17 th September, 2021, passed by the Executing Court, allowed the application Ext.D-100 dated 22nd October, 2019, and thereby discontinued the enquiry under Order XXI Rules 97 and 101 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 2 . The above impugned order was passed placing reliance upon the provisions contained in Order XXI Rule 102 of the CPC.
3. Relevant facts necessary for adjudication of the present appeal are as under: - 3.1 Mrs. Maria Eduardo Apolina Gonsalves Misquita was the owner of plot of land measuring 477 square meters with a two-floor building ground + first standing thereon registered at No.1624, 1 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘High Court’ 2 In short, “CPC”
2814 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Book No.B(5)(new), page-156 (reverse) in the Land Registration Office, Panaji bearing Matriz No.958.
3.2 A part of the aforesaid property on the ground floor, measuring 123 square meters with plinth area and approximately 89.78 square meters area of building, was leased out on rent to Madan Waman Chodankar (respondent no.1), vide deed dated 22 nd February, 1977.
3.3 Later on, respondent no.1 entered into a partnership on 13th March, 1977 with Dyaneshwar Keshav Malik and others (‘Maliks’) for setting up a hardware business and other allied products. The business of the said firm was to be carried out from a portion of the aforesaid leased premises. However, the tenancy as per the partnership was to continue with respondent no.1. 3.4 The original owner, Mrs. Misquita, vide registered sale deed dated 16 th January, 1988, sold the entire property to M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. Thereafter, an agreement was executed between the purchaser, M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd and the Maliks (sub-lessee) for surrendering the possession in order to enable the purchaser to demolish the building, construct a new multi-storied building and thereafter provide space to the sub-lessee upon construction of the new building and in the meantime provide alternate space to the sub-lessee. In the said document of 16 th April, 1988 respondent no.1 was a confirming party.
3.5 Respondent no.1 filed a Regular Civil Suit No.112/88/C for injunction against M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. as they sought to demolish portion of the building apparently in the light of the agreement dated 16th April, 1988. In 1989, M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. preferred an application for eviction of respondent no.1 before the Court of Rent Controller being Rent Case No.17 of 1989 alleging that there has been subletting by respondent no.1 to Maliks, which was contrary to the lease deed dated 22 nd February, 1977.
3.6 In 1996, respondent no.1 filed a Special Civil Suit No.97/1996/B against Maliks for dissolution of partnership, recovery of profit and ejectment. The written statement filed by Maliks in the [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2815Tahir V. Isani v. Madan Waman Chodankar, (Since Deceased) Now Through His Legal Representatives & Ors.
said suit clearly stated that all parties had surrendered their rights in favour of M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. on 11 th April, 1988.
3.7 Meanwhile, the Court of Civil Judge, Jr. Division, vide judgment dated 22 nd July, 1999, decreed the injunction suit filed by respondent no.1 and restrained M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd. from demolishing the building. The decree and judgment of the Civil Judge was carried in appeal by way of Regular Civil Appeal No.91/99, which was dismissed, vide order dated 24 th December, 2001.
3.8 M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd., vide registered sale deed dated 24 th April, 2007, sold the property in question to the appellant, Tahir V. Isani. Thereafter, the Maliks executed a surrender deed on 5 th October, 2007 in favour of the appellant after accepting Rs.10 lakhs.
3.9 The Trial Court hearing, the suit for dissolution of the partnership and eviction of Maliks decreed the Special Civil Suit No.97/1996/B in favour of the respondent no.1 (being decreeholder now), vide an ex parte judgment dated 24th April, 2008, as the Maliks did not contest the suit any further.
3.10 Respondent no.1 filed an application for execution of the decree dated 24 th April, 2008, which was registered as Execution Application No.22 of 2008 (B). In February 2009, the appellant moved an application under Order XXI Rules 97 and 101 of CPC objecting to the execution of the decree. The said application was opposed by the respondent no.1.
3.11 The appellant applied for framing of issues on 18 th August, 2011. The Executing Court while framing issues, vide order dated 5 th September, 2013, dealt with the issue relating to Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 on the ground that that the sale deed dated 24 th April, 2007, was prior to the decree and further noted that the tenancy rights had been surrendered by a written agreement dated 11 th April, 1988.
3.12 The evidence was being recorded in the proceedings under Order XXI Rules 97 and 101 of CPC, in which the statement of the appellant was also recorded sometime around 2019. It 2816 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports was at this stage, i.e. after ten years, that the legal heirs of respondent no.1, who were brought on record on account of his death, moved an application to discontinue the enquiry on the basis of doctrine of lis pendens. The Executing Court dismissed the application of the respondent, vide order dated 17 th September, 2021. Aggrieved, the decree-holder preferred Writ Petition No.86 of 2022, which has since been allowed by the impugned order dated 25 th July, 2022. Hence, the appellant is before us.
4. This Court while issuing notice on 2 nd September, 2022 had passed an order of status quo of possession with regard to the suit property.
5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on record. Before proceeding further, it would be worthwhile to briefly refer to the findings recorded by the Executing Court while dismissing the application dated 20 th December, 2019, and also the findings recorded by the High Court in the impugned order dated 25th July, 2022.
6. The Executing Court recorded the following reasons: i. The suit in question i.e. 97/1996/B was only for dissolution of partnership and recovery of profits and ejectment. It did not deal with the title to the property in question.
ii. There was no issue relating to ownership of the said property as admittedly respondent no.1 had claimed to be a tenant under a lease deed dated 22 nd February, 1977 and subsequently, having sub-let the same had formed a partnership with Maliks. iii. The appellant had purchased the property not from any party to the said suit, i.e. the plaintiff or the defendant, but from the owner M/s. Rizvi Estate and Hotels Pvt. Ltd., who was not a party to the proceedings in which decree was granted in favour of respondent no. 1.
iv. The appellant being the owner of the property in question had a right to raise objection under Order XXI Rules 97 and 101 of CPC and the Executing Court was bound to enquire into and thus, adjudicate upon the said objection.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2817Tahir V. Isani v. Madan Waman Chodankar, (Since Deceased) Now Through His Legal Representatives & Ors.
v. It relied upon a judgment of this Court in the case of Dev Raj Dogra and others v. Gyan Chand Jain and others3 and concluded that the doctrine of lis pendens was not applicable to the present case and, therefore, the enquiry should be continued and brought to its logical conclusion.
7. The High Court was of the view that since the appellant was a transferee pendente lite of judgment debtor, therefore, in view of provisions of Rule 102 of Order XXI of CPC, the application filed by the appellant under Rules 97 and 101 of Order XXI CPC was not maintainable. It accordingly allowed the writ petition filed by respondent no. 1, and set aside the order of the Executing Court dated 17 th September, 2021, thereby allowing the application, Ext.D-100 and closing the enquiry.
8. In order to appreciate the controversy at hand, we deem it fit to reproduce hereinbelow the relevant provisions of Order XXI of CPC as applicable to the present case: - “Resistance of delivery of possession to decree-holder or purchaser
97. Resistance or obstruction to possession of immovable property.—(1) Where the holder of a decree for the possession of immovable property or the purchaser of any such property sold in execution of a decree is resisted or obstructed by any person in obtaining possession of the property, he may make an application to the Court complaining of such resistance or obstruction.
(2) Where any application is made under sub-rule (1), the Court shall proceed to adjudicate upon the application in accordance with the provisions herein contained.
98. Orders after adjudication.—(1) Upon the determination of the questions referred to in rule 101, the Court shall, in accordance with such determination and subject to the provisions of sub-rule (2),—
3 (1981) 2 SCC 675
2818 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(a) make an order allowing the application and directing that the applicant be put into the possession of the property or dismissing the application; or
(b) pass such other order as, in the circumstances of the case, it may deem fit.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.