The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v. The Principal, Kmct Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 518; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2593
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 16 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6908/2025
- Sections
- 8, 11, 8A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2593 : 2025 INSC 518 The State of Kerala Etc. Etc.
v.
The Principal, KMCT Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc. (Civil Appeal No(s). 6908-6911 of 2025)
16 May 2025 [Surya Kant* and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(a) Whether the Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee had the power to determine and direct that a particular amount of the fees charged to NRI students be kept in a corpus fund maintained by the State?
(b) Whether the self-financing medical colleges are entitled to retain the fees collected for the corpus fund which were to be transferred to the State?
Headnotes† Medical Education – Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee – Creation of a corpus fund for scholarships from fees of NRI students – Whether the Committee has the authority to create such a fund:
Held: Reliance is placed upon the judgement of P.A. Inamdar and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra and Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka to establish that the Committee can only decide whether the fees proposed by the institution are exploitative or not — The Committee has no discretionary power to divert a part of the approved fees for any purpose — As such, the Committee cannot create a corpus fund for the benefit of economically weaker students — It can only direct the State to come up with a suitable plan to subsidize their education through the fees charged from NRI students — Recourse to expropriatory measures cannot be sheltered under a piece of subordinate legislation, unless where the power is drawn from the plenary legislation — There is nothing discernible in Sections 8A and 11 of the 2017 Act, based on which the Committee can assert its power to divert a part of the fee * Author 2594 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports determined by it or issue a direction how such diverted fee is to be utilised — The provisions also do not permit the levy of any amount which will ultimately be retained by the State, regardless of its purpose — The High Court was correct in striking down the GO dated 06.06.2018 since its objective is not traceable to a legislative action. [Paras 13-16, 18-21, 25-27] Medical Education – Fees for NRI students – Entitlement to refund of amounts paid to a corpus fund – Whether the NRI students are entitled to a refund of the amount transferred: Held: Reliance is placed upon the judgements of Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka and Modern Dental College & Research Centre and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors. to establish that the NRI students are not entitled to a refund of the amount transferred for the creation of the corpus fund, as their fees are not determined solely by the factor of subsidization — The fees for NRI students are utilized for various purposes, including but not limited to subsidizing other students, and for upkeep and continuous development expenses to improve the quality of education — Selffinancing institutions are the best judge of their own expenses and can retain the amount that was to be transferred to the corpus fund, when those amounts came out of the fee structures already approved by the Committee. [Paras 33-36] Medical Education – Self-financing colleges – Entitlement to retain fees collected for a corpus fund – Obligation to utilize for BPL students:
Held: Colleges are obligated to provide quality education and utilize a substantial part of these retained funds for subsidizing the education of the BPL students, admitted to their institutions — The colleges will act as trustees of the corpus fund amount and will have to furnish their accounts to the State or the Committee to establish compliance with this direction — Such an arrangement shall continue till an appropriate legislation is enacted by the State. [Para 37] Case Law Cited P.A. Inamdar and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 603 : (2005) 6 SCC 537 – explained.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2595The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v.
The Principal, KMCT Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc. Modern Dental College & Research Centre and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors. [2016] 3 SCR 579 : (2016) 7 SCC 353; Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka [2003] Supp. 2 SCR 474 : (2003) 6 SCC 697 – relied on.
Najiya Neermunda v. Kunhitharuvai Memorial Charitable Trust (2021) 5 SCC 515 – referred to.
List of Acts The Kerala Medical Education (Regulation of Admission in Private Medical Educational Institutions) Act, 2017.
List of Keywords Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee; Fee fixation; Unaided professional colleges; Management quota seats; Corpus fund; Refund; NRI students.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 6908-6911 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.07.2020 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in WP(C) No. 7771, 10792, 11313 and 33160 of 2018 With Civil Appeal No(s). 6912, 6913-6914 and 6915-6916 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Jayanth Muth Raj, Kapil Sibal, Nikhil Goel, Shoeb Alam, Sr. Advs., Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Santhosh K, Haris Beeran, Azhar Assees, Anand B. Menon, Ms. Pallavi Pratap, Abdulla Naseeh V.T., Ms. Rachel Sara James, Ms. Abreeda Banu, Wills Mathews, Dhanesh M Nair, Paul John Edison, Ms. Anila T Thomas, Rakesh Garg, Ashish Gopal Garg, Ms. Shweta Garg.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Shoeb Alam, Kapil Sibal, Nikhil Goel, V. Chitambaresh, Jayanth Muth Raj, Gaurav Aggarwal, Sr. Advs., Abdulla Naseeh V.T., Haris Beeran, Azhar Assees, Anand B.menon, Ms. Pallavi Pratap, James P. Thomas, Ravi Sagar, Bibin John, Lakshmeesh S. Kamath, 2596 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Mrs. Samriti Ahuja, Ms. Aditi Prakash, Babu Karukapadath, Mohammed Sadique T.A., Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Santhosh K, Radha Shyam Jena, M. T. George, Mrs. Susy Abraham, Johns George, Zulfiker Ali P. S, Ms. Lakshmi Sree P., Ms. Lebina Baby, Alim Anvar, Shaji J Kodankandath, Ms. Smita Amratlal Vora. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave granted.
2. The issue that arises for consideration has emanated from a direction given by the State of Kerala’s Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee that a corpus fund be created to subsidize medical education for Below Poverty Line (BPL) students admitted to selffinancing medical educational institutions in the State. This corpus fund was to be created by remitting to the State Government a part of the fees collected from Non-Resident Indian (NRI) students admitted to those colleges.
3. The Kerala High Court, at Ernakulam (High Court) vide the common Impugned Judgement dated 23.07.2020 has: (i) quashed Government Order (MS) No. 107/2018/H&FWD dated 06.06.2018 (GO dated 06.06.2018); (ii) directed that the amounts collected from each NRI student to create a corpus fund be transferred to the respective institutions and maintained as a separate account to be utilized only for the benefit of students belonging to the economically weaker sections, who may be admitted to such institutions on the basis of allotment; (iii) directed such account to be operated only jointly by a nominee of the self-financing institution and a nominee of the State Government; (iv) kept it open to the State to promulgate suitable legislative measures to achieve the object of providing scholarships to students belonging to economically weaker sections of society as observed by this Court in P. A. Inamdar and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra1 ; and has further directed that (v) till suitable legislative measures are adopted by the State, no further amounts would be levied or collected from NRI students, already admitted to or to be 1 P. A. Inamdar and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra, (2005) 6 SCC 537. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2597The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v.
The Principal, KMCT Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc. admitted to NRI quota seats in that academic year, towards the creation or maintenance of the corpus fund.
4. These directions of the High Court have given rise to three sets of cross-appeals preferred by: (i) The State of Kerala, who is aggrieved by the quashing of its GO dated 06.06.2018; (ii) The self-financing medical colleges, who are challenging the direction that the corpus fund amount be utilized only to subsidize education for students from economically-weaker sections of society admitted to the respective institutions; and finally, (iii) The NRI students, who are dissatisfied that the corpus fund amounts have not been refunded to them. A. FActs
5. Owing to a parallel set of proceedings before the Courts concerning the Committee’s overall functioning, it is vital to understand the detailed facts before analyzing the legal issues.
5.1 The Kerala Medical Education (Regulation and Control of Admission to Private Medical Educational Institutions) Act, 2017 (the 2017 Act) came into force on 01.06.2017. It was introduced to, among other things, regulate the admission and fixation of fees in private medical educational institutions in the State of Kerala. Sections 3 and 3A of the 2017 Act contemplate the constitution of a Committee, described as the Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee (Committee). The Committee was tasked to determine the fees charged to students admitted to private medical educational institutions in Kerala based on the annual information and proposals submitted by those colleges.
5.2 KMCT Medical College moved an application and submitted the prospectus for Academic Year 2017-2018 before the Committee on 01.08.2017, requesting it to fix the fees for NRI students at Rs. 20 lakhs per annum.
5.3 The Committee, on 27.02.2018, approved the fixation of fees for NRI students at Rs. 20 lakhs per annum for all medical colleges whose fee was to be regulated under the 2017 Act. Notedly, it decided to enhance the fees for NRI students from Rs. 15 lakhs per annum in Academic Year 2016-2017 to Rs. 20 lakhs per annum in Academic Year 2017-2018 and 2598 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 2018-2019, with the condition that the extra amount of Rs. 5 lakhs would be kept as a ‘corpus fund’ to provide scholarships to BPL students. The Committee further directed that the corpus fund amount would be remitted to the State Government, as and when so directed by the State, the Committee, or a Court of Law. This decision was substantiated by quoting paragraph 131 of P. A. Inamdar (supra), where it was held that the fees collected from NRI students should be utilized to benefit students from economically-weaker sections of society. 5.4 KMCT Medical College, being aggrieved, laid challenge to the Committee’s decision before the High Court.
5.5 During the pendency of the writ proceedings before the High Court, the Government of Kerala issued the GO dated 06.06.2018, seemingly to validate and support the Committee’s decision dated 27.02.2018. It emphasized that the mainstay of the corpus fund would be the amounts earmarked and collected from NRI students who were admitted to self-financing medical educational institutions in the State. Much like the Committee’s decision, the GO dated 06.06.2018 was statedly issued in pursuance of the directions contained in paragraph 131 of P. A. Inamdar (supra). Compelled by the GO dated 06.06.2018, the self-financing medical colleges consequently began collecting Rs. 20 lakhs per annum as fees from the newly-admitted NRI students, while remitting Rs. 5 lakhs to the corpus fund.
5.6 The Committee, meanwhile, continued to assess the fee proposals submitted by various colleges. In some instances, it rejected the proposals and determined the fees to be charged on its own initiative. Viewing this as an overstep of the Committee’s powers and a violation of the institutions’ autonomy, several medical colleges filed writ petitions before the High Court. This resulted in a parallel set of proceedings concerning the Committee’s overall powers.
5.7 These proceedings culminated in a common judgment dated 19.05.2020, whereby the High Court remanded the matter to the Committee to re-examine the proposals afresh and to pass suitable orders. The High Court observed that though the Committee had the power to fix the fee to be collected from [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2599The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v.
The Principal, KMCT Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc. NRI students, there was no power vested in it under Section 8 of the 2017 Act to direct that a portion of the fee amount be utilized for any other purpose.
5.8 The aggrieved State approached this Court in Civil Appeal No. 606-616/2021, which came to be decided on 25.02.2021, 2 holding that the fee, as proposed by the colleges, should be considered by the Committee. This Court noted that it was no longer res integra that the right conferred on the institutions to fix fees for professional courses was subject to regulation. It was reiterated that unaided professional institutions had the autonomy to decide on the fees to be charged, subject to the condition that such fees do not result in profiteering or collection of capitation fees. The Committee was only required to ensure that the fee charged was non-exploitative and reasonable. This Court thus directed the Committee to reconsider the proposals submitted by the colleges, by taking into account the factors mentioned in Section 11 of the 2017 Act and the law laid down in Modern Dental College & Research Centre and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors.3 5.9 While this Court was seized of the above-mentioned matter, various self-financing medical colleges and their NRI students initiated a second round of litigation before the High Court, this time, challenging the amounts collected from NRI students to create the corpus fund to benefit BPL students enrolled in the same institutes. The High Court clubbed these writ petitions with the earlier petition filed by KMCT Medical College, and has decided all these writ petitions through the common Impugned Judgment.
5.10 The High Court, being conscious of the fact that the Committee was considering the fee proposals afresh, as was directed by it vide the judgement dated 19.05.2020, restricted its assessment only qua the ‘validity of the creation of the corpus fund.’ 5.11 The question that was formulated by the High Court for its consideration was whether the creation of the corpus fund 2 Najiya Neermunda v. Kunhitharuvai Memorial Charitable Trust, (2021) 5 SCC 515. 3 Modern Dental College & Research Centre and Ors. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors., (2016) 7 SCC 353.
2600 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports through the GO dated 06.06.2018 could be sustained in the absence of law in the form of plenary legislation or subordinate legislation. The High Court opined that, regardless of the nature of the levy, such a fee could be imposed only under the authority of law and not merely by an executive order. Since there was no provision in the 2017 Act authorizing the Committee or the State Government to levy an amount to be credited to a corpus fund, the GO dated 06.06.2018 could not be sustained. Accordingly, the GO was quashed and the directions, as specified in paragraph 3 above, have been issued.
5.12 This is how these cross-appeals have arisen for our consideration.
B. contentions oF the PArties
6. Mr. Kapil Sibal and Mr. Nikhil Goel, Learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of KMCT Medical College and other self-financing medical colleges in the State, contended that the High Court has partly erred and the Impugned Judgement deserves to be suitably modified in light of the following submissions:
(a) This Court has time and again permitted institutions to charge a higher amount of fees from NRI students as the fees paid by them enable such institutions to strengthen their level of education and enlarge their educational activities. KMCT Medical College has always followed this dictum and has been using the enhanced fees levied on NRI students to grant scholarships to students from economically-weaker sections of society. For instance, in 2014 and 2015, KMCT Medical College awarded scholarships worth Rs. 1.28 crores and Rs. 1.55 crores, respectively, to enable its students from economically-weaker sections of society to pursue their education.
(b) The fee proposed to be charged from the NRI students was only Rs. 20 lakhs per annum, which is one of the lowest fees in the entire country. KMCT Medical College charges only Rs. 5.5 lakhs per annum as fees for general category students. Thus, if the tuition fee for NRI students was further reduced from Rs. 20 lakhs to Rs. 15 lakhs, by virtue of the corpus fund, the college would be unable to continue financing its day-to-day activities. Consequently, the failure of the High Court to direct [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2601The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v.
The Principal, KMCT Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc. a refund, of the amount charged from NRI students towards the corpus fund, to the institutions is violative of Article 19 (1)
(g) and Article 30 of the Constitution.
(c) The State or the Executive cannot impose any levy, whatever may be the nature of it, through an executive order, except under the authority of law. At present, there is no provision in the 2017 Act which empowers the State or its machinery to impose any tax or levy of any nature on self-financing medical colleges. The only power granted to the Committee is to satisfy itself that the fees charged by the self-financing medical educational institutions do not lead to profiteering or payment of capitation fees. If the Committee finds the fees charged to be exploitative, it can propose a different fee structure.
(d) Once the High Court quashed the GO dated 06.06.2018 on the ground that the Committee was not authorized under law to create a corpus fund, it could not have permitted such unauthorized action to continue by directing that the amounts collected for the corpus fund be utilized only to subsidize education for other students. The denial of a refund of the illegally-collected fees has put the self-financing medical colleges under financial strain.
(e) KMCT Medical College, like other self-financing medical colleges, specifically requested the Committee to approve its fixation of fees at Rs. 20 lakhs per annum for NRI students, under the expectation that if approved, it would be able to utilize the entire amount of Rs. 20 lakhs for educational purposes and for running the institution. It was improper and imprudent of the Committee to approve the fees of Rs. 20 lakhs per annum, only to retain Rs. 5 lakhs for the creation of the corpus fund.
7. Mr. Shoeb Alam, Learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of the NRI students, supported the quashing of the GO dated 06.06.2018 but contended that the High Court erred in disallowing a refund to them. In furtherance of this, he adduced the following submissions:
(a) NRI students are admitted to colleges on a higher fee scale to subsidize the fees of students from economically-weaker sections of society. When an NRI student is admitted to a 2602 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports particular college, the higher fees paid are utilized to subsidize the fees of a BPL student in that particular college, alone. It is unfair and unjust that a higher fee charged from NRI students of a particular college be utilized to subsidize the fees charged in another college or multiple other colleges in the State.
(b) Paragraph 67 of P. A. Inamdar (supra) states that “each NRI student would subsidize two other students belonging to the economically and socially weaker sections.” Thus, if the fee fixed for a general category student for a particular year is only Rs. 5 lakhs, there is no reason to fix the fees for NRI students above Rs. 15 lakhs as the NRI student would be subsidizing the fees of two other students from economically-weaker backgrounds. As a result, any amount levied as a corpus fund, without the authority of law, is over and above the amount contemplated for an NRI student to bear.
(c) In addition to this, some colleges have forced the NRI students to give post-dated cheques of Rs. 5 lakhs, in advance, to create the corpus fund. The NRI students are thus either liable to be refunded the amounts collected under the guise of setting up the corpus fund or the amounts so collected must be set off against their future fees.
8. Per contra, Mr. Jayant Muth Raj, Learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of the State of Kerala, put forth the following submissions:
(a) The GO dated 06.06.2018 was issued in pursuance of paragraph 131 of P. A. Inamdar (supra). The last line of paragraph 131 specifically permitted the Committee to create a mechanism to subsidize education through the fees collected from NRI students, in the absence of State Legislation on the subject. The authority to create the corpus fund thus, came primarily from the Constitution Bench judgement of this Court, which, being the law of the land, need not be supplemented or supplanted by any State Legislation or Regulations.
(b) The conduct of the self-financing medical colleges is questionable as they have collected the corpus fund amount of Rs. 5 lakhs in advance from the NRI students who were admitted in the 2017-2018 batch, even in respect of their second, third, fourth, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2603The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v.
The Principal, KMCT Medical College and Ors. Etc. Etc. and fifth years. They collected Rs. 43.6 crores in total but remitted only Rs. 4.15 crores to the State for the purpose of the corpus fund. The college management did the same for the next 5 successive batches of NRI students, i.e. the batches of 2018-2019, 2019-2020, 2020-2021, 2021-2022, and 2022-2023. Rs. 145.45 crores were collected from these batches for the corpus fund, but only Rs. 2 crores have been remitted to the corpus fund maintained by the Commissioner for Entrance Examinations. Thus, the colleges have retained a total of Rs. 182.9 crores from the batches of 2017-2018 to 2022- 2023. As a direct corollary to such action, the State of Kerala’s larger objective, of subsidizing education for students from economically-weaker sections of society, has been frustrated.
9. Mr. Gaurav Aggarwal, Learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of the intervenors, i.e. certain BPL students admitted to various selffinancing medical colleges across Kerala, supported the GO dated 06.06.2018 and put forth the following submissions:
(a) The GO dated 06.06.2018 was adopted as a welfare measure by the State of Kerala. The object of the GO dated 06.06.2018 was laudable and the observations of this Court in P. A. Inamdar (supra) clearly compel the State to adopt such a course of action. The GO dated 06.06.2018 should not have been quashed merely due to the absence of legislative support. The Courts should ordinarily not interfere with a policy decision of the Executive unless the same is mala fide, unreasonable, arbitrary, or unfair.
(b) After the High Court directed that no further amount should be credited towards the corpus fund, many BPL students have been finding it difficult to continue their studies due to financial hardships. Not only this, the self-financing medical institutions are exerting pressure on BPL students to remit the regular tuition fees. These students chose to take admission to the respective colleges, with the understanding that they would only have to pay subsidized fees. Since they no longer receive BPL scholarships, they have been unable to pay their tuition and hostel fees and many of them will be forced to discontinue their studies.
2604 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports c. issues
10. Having given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions at length, we find that the following issues arise for our consideration: i. Whether the Committee had the power to determine and direct that a particular amount of the fees charged to NRI students be kept in a corpus fund maintained by the State?
ii. Whether the NRI students are entitled to a refund of the amount so charged or whether it can be set off against fees to be charged for later years?
D. A nAlysis D.1 Issue No. 1: Power of the Committee to direct the creation of a corpus fund for scholarships
11. To understand and deduce the powers of the Committee, we must conduct a detailed examination of the two sources from where it is stated to have derived its powers: (i) The Constitution Bench Judgement of this Court in P. A. Inamdar (supra); and (ii) Section 8A and Section 11 of the 2017 Act.
D.1.1 The Constitution Bench Judgement of this Court in P. A. Inamdar (supra)
12. Before we delve into the analysis, it will be useful to reproduce the text of paragraph 131 of P. A. Inamdar (supra) to appreciate the rival submissions raised by the parties. It elucidates that: “131. Here itself we are inclined to deal with the question as to seats allocated for Non-Resident Indians (“NRI” for short) or NRI seats. It is common knowledge that some of the institutions grant admissions to a certain number of students under such quota by charging a higher amount of fee. In fact, the term “NRI” in relation to admissions is a misnomer. By and large, we have noticed in cases after cases coming to this Court, neither the students who get admissions under this category nor their parents are NRIs. In effect and reality, under this category, less meritorious students, but who can afford to bring more money, get [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2605The State of Kerala Etc. Etc. v.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.