State of Kerala & Another v. Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 757; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2215
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 22 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9301/2013
- Sections
- 2, 65(13), 4, 65(105), 65(15), 7, 65, 15A, 65(14), 3(10), 15, 129
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2215 : 2025 INSC 757 State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others (Civil Appeal No. 9301 of 2013)
22 May 2025 [B.V. Nagarathna* and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The questions for consideration were: 1) Whether appellantsassessees, engaged in broadcasting of signals etc. through television channels to subscribers of those channels, were liable to pay entertainment tax under provisions of respective State enactments relatable to Entry 62 – List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution and also liable to pay service tax under provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended from time to time as a provider of a taxable service namely broadcasting service within the scope and ambit of Entry 97–List I; and 2) Whether decision of Supreme Court in Purvi Communication had failed to consider the tests laid down in Geeta Enterprises and to that extent was per incuriam. Headnotes† Constitution of India – Seventh Schedule – List I, Entry 97 and List II, Entry 62 – Different aspects of same activity – Taxation under two different legislations by two different legislatures – Assessees, engaged in broadcasting of signals etc. through television channels to subscribers of those channels – If liable to pay entertainment tax under provisions of respective State enactments relatable to Entry 62 of List II and also liable to pay service tax as a provider of a taxable service namely broadcasting service within the scope and ambit of Entry 97 of List I:
Held: There are two aspects in the activity undertaken by the assessees – The first is the act of transmission of signals of the content to the subscribers – The second aspect here concerns not only the content of the signals, but the effect of the decryption of the signals by the Set-Top Boxes and the viewing cards inside these boxes provided by the assessees to the subscribers, which * Author 2216 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports is providing and receiving of entertainment through the television – Without the apparatus provided for by the assessees to decrypt the signals, the subscriber would not be able to watch the content that is transmitted, the content being for the purpose of entertainment – The television entertainment provided by them through their modus operandi i.e., by broadcasting, is a luxury within the meaning of Entry 62 of List II – The assessees who are engaged in the activity of providing entertainment are liable to pay service tax on the activity of broadcasting under the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 read with relevant amendments and are also liable to pay entertainment tax in terms of Entry 62 of List II as being a specie of luxuries – Therefore, both the taxes, one by the State Legislature and the other, by the Parliament are leviable on the activity of the assessees – This is because by rendering the service of broadcasting, the assessees are entertaining the subscribers within the meaning of Entry 62 of List II –There is no overlapping in fact or in law, inasmuch as different aspects of the same activity are being taxed under two different legislations by two different legislatures – This is because the activity of broadcasting is a service and liable to service tax imposed by the Parliament (Entry 97 of List I) and the activity of entertainment is a subject falling under Entry 62 of List II and therefore, the assessees herein are liable to pay entertainment tax as well – Hence, the State Legislatures as well as the Parliament, both have the legislative competence to levy entertainment tax as well as service tax respectively on the activity carried out by the assessees herein. [Para 17.37] Doctrines – Aspect theory – Double aspect doctrine – A tool of constitutional interpretation used in Canada to resolve issues which arise when both the federal and provincial government have the right to legislate on a subject – Usage of aspect theory in the Indian context – Discussed:
Held: In India, there appears to be no clarity on the application of the aspect theory in the Canadian sense – One of the reasons being that in India, both the Parliament as well as the State Legislature do not have powers to levy tax on the same subject – The aspect theory has been applied in India essentially to ascertain whether an activity would fall within the scope and ambit of an enactment and whether the said enactment in pith and substance would fall within an Entry of a particular List of the Seventh Schedule so as to confer legislative competence to tax that aspect of the activity – Aspect [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2217State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others theory has no relevance, as such, in determining the constitutionality of any provision on the ground of legislative competence in India – Aspect theory is however relevant to determine the applicability of a taxing statute on the activity or transaction sought to be taxed i.e., whether the statute covers an activity which falls within a specific taxation entry, either in List I or in List II – Thus, an activity could be taxed by two different legislatures on the basis of the entries in the respective Lists without there being a clash and within their legislative competence – However, the aspect of the activity which is being taxed must be relatable to the legislation under a specific entry of a particular List so as to be within the legislative competence of a particular legislature – Thus, the aspect theory is used to determine if, in fact, there are different aspects within the activity sought to be taxed and whether the taxable event which forms the basis of the levy in a legislative enactment corresponds to any aspect in the activity sought to be taxed – This is in contrast to the applicability of this theory in Canada, where this theory is used therein to determine legislative competence of a federal or provincial legislature to enact a particular law. [Paras 17.27, 17.33-17.36] Taxation – Activity of Broadcasting service – Application of Aspect theory – Both entertainment tax as well as service tax can be imposed on the activity of broadcasting through television for the purpose of entertainment of the subscriber or the receiver thereof – The two taxes are different aspects of the same activity which enable two different legislatures to impose tax under distinct taxation entries in two different Lists: Held: One aspect of an activity, say broadcasting service, can be amenable to service tax, while the other aspect of the same activity, namely, providing (of) entertainment to television viewers (as that is the object of broadcasting) can be amenable to “luxury tax” under Entry 62 List II of the Constitution which could be levied on the recipients of such entertainment or on the service providers who are essentially broadcasters – Broadcasting service being a taxable service under the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994, read along with the amendments made from time to time would enable both the Parliament to impose service tax on broadcasting service and the State Legislatures having the legislative competence to levy entertainment tax on those who provide entertainment to the recipients (television viewers) to impose a luxury tax – Entry 62 of List II contemplates a tax on entertainments or amusements 2218 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports as objects on which a tax can be imposed and therefore it is not possible to differentiate between an entertainment provider and an entertainment receiver – The principle is well settled that two taxes which are separate and distinct imposed on two aspects of an activity are permissible, as in law, there is no overlapping – This is because the taxes are relatable to distinct taxation entries in separate legislative Lists – In the instant case, the Parliament under the Finance Act, 1994 and its amendments is not imposing a tax on entertainment – Such a tax is being imposed by the State Legislatures as entertainment is a luxury within the meaning of Entry 62 of List II – In the same way, the Finance Act along with its amendments seeks to impose a tax on the service rendered by the broadcasting agency which is imposed under Entry 97 of List I – In the same vein, under Entry 62 of List II, the State Governments are not imposing any service tax on the assessees. [Paras 17.27, 17.28, 17.30, 17.31] Constitution of India – Articles 246, 248 and Seventh Schedule, List I, II & III – Constitutional Scheme regarding distribution of Legislative Powers – Legislative competence to levy a tax – Expression “subject to” and “with respect to” in Article 246 – Applicability of doctrine of pith and substance: Held: Taxation entries under List I and List II (there being no taxation entry in the Concurrent List) are clearly demarcated within the scope of the entries in the aforesaid respective Lists – Subject of taxation is considered to be a distinct matter for the purposes of legislative competence and the power to tax cannot be deduced from the general legislative entry as an ancillary power – Also, a power to legislate as to the principal matters specifically mentioned in the entries shall also include within its expanse, a legislation touching upon incidental and ancillary matters – This principle is derived from the use of the expression “with respect to” in Article 246 of the Constitution – Entry 97 of List I which is a residuary entry relatable to Article 248 of the Constitution cannot be invoked or pressed into service when a particular entry empowering the Parliament or the Legislature of a State to pass laws regarding the taxation on any subject is specifically enumerated either in List I or List II – Consequently, as there is no taxation entry in List III, both the Parliament as well as the Legislature of the State cannot have competence to levy tax on any one subject of a List – While interpreting taxation entries in List I or List II, i.e., while determining [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2219State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others the legislative competence to levy a tax, all efforts must be made to interpret them in such a way as to give expansive content and meaning to the same having regard to the constitutional scheme under which the distribution of legislative powers has been envisaged in the Seventh Schedule and bearing in mind the object and intent behind them and also the advances made in human thought and technology – The expression “subject to” and “with respect to” in Article 246 of the Constitution aids the applicability of the doctrine of pith and substance to find out the true character of the enactment and the entry within which it would fall – The said doctrine is applied to resolve an issue regarding legislative competence of a legislature to enact a particular law in relation to a subject relatable to an Entry in a List under the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution – Any apparent conflict with respect to an entry in another List is resolved on the basis of the pith and substance doctrine. [Paras 17.7-17.10, 17.12, 17.13] Doctrines – Doctrine of pith and substance – If a law is in its pith and substance within the competence of the Legislature which has made it, it will not be invalid because it incidentally touches upon the subject lying within the competence of another Legislature:
Held: Where there is an apparent overlapping between two legislative entries in the Lists of Seventh Schedule of the Constitution, the doctrine of pith and substance is applied to find out the true character of the enactment concerned and the entry within which it would fall – The doctrine of pith and substance, in short, means, if an enactment substantially falls within the powers expressly conferred by the Constitution upon the legislature which enacted it, the same cannot be held to be invalid merely because it incidentally encroaches on matters assigned to another legislature – Also, in a situation where there is overlapping, the said doctrine has to be applied to determine to which entry, a piece of legislation could be related to by examining the true character of the enactment or a provision thereof – Due regard must be had to the enactment as a whole and to its scope and objects – Question of invasion into another legislative territory has to be determined by substance and not by degree – The doctrine of pith and substance is applied to consider the vires of a legislation impugned on the basis of the principle of legislative competence in the context of legislative relationship between the Centre and the 2220 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports State – Constitutional validity of a taxing statute on the ground of legislative competence has to be examined in the context of the doctrine of pith and substance as envisaged under Article 246 of the Constitution of India read with the respective entries in the List –Once the contours of an entry under which a legislation is sought to be made is ascertained, the next step is to study the legislation in question in order to ascertain whether it falls within the contours of that Entry – If it does fall within the contours of a particular entry in a particular List, then that particular legislature which has enacted it would have the legislative competence to enact such a legislation – But a legislation incidentally touching upon an entry in another List does not render it invalid, it means that so long as a piece of legislation is in pith and substance falling within an entry in a particular List, it would be valid as the legislature which has enacted it, has the legislative competence to do so. [Paras 8.2.2, 17.33] Taxation – Parameters of Taxation, as enumerated by Supreme Court in Govind Saran Ganga Saran, discussed:
Held: A legislative enactment which provides for the imposition of a tax must specify the following parameters of taxation: (i) The taxable event which forms the basis of levy, also referred to as “subject” of a tax; (ii) The measure of the tax; (iii) The rate(s) of taxation; and (iv) The incidence of the tax – The said parameters are each distinct and must not be conflated with the others – The components of tax, as stated above have been characterised in Govind Saran Ganga Saran case– In the said case, it was also laid down that a legislative scheme which seeks to impose a tax, ought to define each of the aforestated components with certainty and precision. [Paras 8.26, 17.23] Taxation – Taxation on Luxuries: Entertainments & Amusements – Words and Expressions – “Luxuries” – Meaning of – Bearing in mind the meaning of “entertainments” and “amusements” and since they come within the scope of “luxuries”, therefore, the State legislature has legislative competence to impose entertainment tax under Entry 62 of List II as a tax on luxuries – Constitution of India – Seventh Schedule, List II, Entry 33 & 62. [Paras 8.6-8.12, 17.20] Words and Phrases – “Entertainments” and “Amusements” – Meaning of – Expressions “entertainments and amusements” [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2221State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others have to be read ejusdem generis – Constitution of India – Seventh Schedule, List II, Entry 62:
Held: The expression “entertainments” is a word of general import and in common parlance, it includes cinema shows, dramatic performances, etc. – The expression ‘entertainments’ used in Entry 62 of List II does not draw a distinction between one who derives amusement and one who caters to it – It covers both categories – Expression “entertainments” cannot be interpreted in a narrow, pedantic or in a myopic way – With the advancement in technology, there can be several modes in which the activity of entertainment can be provided or received – However, what is essential is the object of providing or receiving signals etc. which must be for the purpose of entertainment – Expression “entertainments/ entertainment” includes within its scope and ambit not only the provider of entertainment but also the receiver, inter alia, through the medium of television – Thus, entertainment through television network either through cable television or DTH through set-top box with the object of providing entertainment to the viewer can be taxed in terms of Entry 62 of List II – The expression “amusement” in Entry 62 of List II would mean diversion, pass time or enjoyment or a pleasurable occupation of the senses or that which furnished it – The expressions “entertainments and amusements” would have to be read ejusdem generis. [Paras 8.20-8.23, 17.22] Words and Phrases – “Entertainment” – Interpretation of – Geeta Enterprises case versus Purvi Communication case – Discussed:
Held: There is no contradiction in the judgments of Supreme Court in Geeta Enterprises and Purvi Communications – Judgment in Geeta Enterprises can never be a binding precedent for the question raised before this Court in Purvi Communication – Discussion on the content and meaning, scope and ambit of the expression ‘entertainments’ in Geeta Enterprises is not comprehensive – This is because, having regard to the advances in technology resulting in varied forms of entertainments through various media and in a variety of ways, not only in a public place but also in the confines of private space such as a home, through mobile or a cell phone or smart watch and other personal devices etc., the expression ‘entertainments’ must be given a broad, liberal and expansive meaning than what has been discussed in Geeta Enterprises by 2222 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports this Court – Purvi Communication is not per incuriam and need not be referred to a larger Bench. [Paras 10.6, 10.14, 17.24, 17.25] Words and Phrases – “Broadcasting” and “Broadcasting agency or organization” – Prasar Bharti (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Act, 1990 – Section 2(c) – Finance Act, 1994 as amended by the Finance Act, 2001 – Section 65(13). [Para 17.14-17.18] Constitution of India – Seventh Schedule, Lists I, II & III – Fee in respect of any of the matters in the three Lists – Does not include the power to levy tax – Distinction between levy of fee and levy of tax. [Para 17.11] Service Tax – Service tax on broadcasting agency – Finance Act, 1994 as amended by the Finance Act, 2001 – Sections 65(72)(zk) and 66.
Held: Broadcasting service is a taxable service and the broadcasting service provider is required to pay service tax under the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended from time to time. [Para 17.19] Case Law Cited State of West Bengal v. Purvi Communication Pvt. Ltd. [2005] 2 SCR 954 : (2005) 3 SCC 711 – held not per incuriam. Western India Theatres v. Cantonment Board, Poona [1959] Supp. 2 SCR 63 – followed.
Union of India v. H.S. Dhillon [1972] 2 SCR 33 : (1971) 2 SCC 779; MPV Sundararamier & Co. v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1958] SCR 1422 : AIR 1958 SC 468; M/s Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. State of Bihar [1983] 3 SCR 130 : AIR 1983 SC 1019 – relied on. Anjum Kadari v. Union of India, 2024 INSC 831 : [2024] 11 SCR 365; P.M. Ashwathanarayana Setty v. State of Karnataka [1988] Supp. 3 SCR 155 : (1989) Supp. 1 SCC 696; R.K. Garg v. Union of India [1982] 1 SCR 947 : (1981) 4 SCC 675; Kodar v. State of Kerala [1975] 1 SCR 121 : (1974) 4 SCC 422; Kerala Hotel and Restaurant Association v. State of Kerala [1990] 1 SCR 516 : (1990) 2 SCC 502; Ganga Sugar Corporation Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1980] 1 SCR 769 : (1980) 1 SCC 223; Income Tax Officer, Shillong v. R. Takin Roy Rymbai [1976] 3 SCR 413: (1976) SC 670; State of Kerala v. Mar Appraem Kuri Company Ltd. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2223State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others [2012] 4 SCR 448 : (2012) 7 SCC 106; Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v. Union of India [2006] 2 SCR 823 : (2006) 3 SCC 1; K. Damodarasamy Naidu & Bros. v. State of Tamil Nadu [1999] Supp. 3 SCR 597 : (2000) 1 SCC 521; Association of Leasing & Financial Service Companies v. Union of India [2010] 13 SCR 381 : (2011) 2 SCC 352; Special Reference No.1 of 2001, In Re: Association of Natural Gas v. Union of India [2004] 3 SCR 534 : (2004) 4 SCC 489; Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Association of India v. Union of India [1989] 2 SCR 918 : (1989) 3 SCC 634; All India Federation of Tax Practitioners v. Union of India [2007] 9 SCR 527; Godfrey Phillips Ltd. v. State of U.P. [2005] 1 SCR 732 : (2005) 2 SCC 515; Geeta Enterprises v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1983] 3 SCR 812 : (1983) 4 SCC 202; Commissioner of Central Excise and Customs, Kerala v. Larsen and Toubro Ltd. [2015] 8 SCR 1046 : (2016) 1 SCC 170; Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. State of Bihar [1983] 3 SCR 130 : (1983) 4 SCC 45; Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, Imagic Creative (P) Ltd. v. CCT [2008] 1 SCR 457 : (2008) 2 SCC 614; Larsen and Toubro Limited v. State of Karnataka [2013] 17 SCR 678 : (2014) 1 SCC 708; Commissioner of Income Tax, Bangalore v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty [1981] 2 SCR 938 : (1981) 2 SCC 460; Govind Saran Ganga Saran v. CST [1985] 3 SCR 985 : 1985 Supp. SCC 205; Express Hotels (P) Ltd. v. The State of Gujarat [1989] 2 SCR 893 : 1989 3 SCC 677; State of Karnataka v. State of Meghalaya [2022] 18 SCR 516 : (2023) 4 SCC 416; Suresh v. State of T.N. [1996] Supp. 8 SCR 947 : (1997) 1 SCC 319; CCE v. Grasim Industries Ltd. [2018] 6 SCR 1099 : (2018) 7 SCC 233; Mineral Area Development Authority v. Steel Authority of India [2024] 7 SCR 1549 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1796; Navinchandra Mafatlal v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Bombay City [1955] 1 SCR 829 : AIR 1955 SC 58; Chhotabhai Jethabhai Patel and Co. v. Union of India [1962] Supp. 2 SCR 1 : AIR 1962 SC 1006; Calcutta Gas Company Ltd. v. State of West Bengal [1962] Supp. 3 SCR 1: AIR 1962 SC 1044; RMD Chamarbaugwalla v. Union of India [1957] SCR 930 : AIR 1957 SC 628; Builders’ Association of India v. Union of India [1989] 2 SCR 320 : (1989) 2 SCC 645; A.B. Abdul Kadir v. State of Kerala [1976] 2 SCR 690 : (1976) 3 SCC 219; Bangalore Turf Club Ltd. v. Regional Director, ESI Corporation [2014] 8 SCR 1021 : (2014) 9 SCC 657; State of Karnataka v. Drive-in Enterprises [2001] 2 SCR 378 : (2001) 4 SCC 60; M.J. Sivani v. State of Karnataka [1995] 3 SCR 329 : AIR 1995 SC 1770; State of M.P. v. Abha Sethi [1999] 2224 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 2 SCR 930 : (1999) 4 SCC 32; Goodyear India Ltd. v. State of Haryana [1989] Supp. 1 SCR 510 : (1990) 2 SCC 71; International Tourist Corporation v. State of Haryana [1981] 2 SCR 364; Elel Hotels & Investments Ltd. v. Union of India [1989] 2 SCR 880 : (1989) 3 SCC 698; State of West Bengal v. Kesoram Industries Ltd. [2004] 1 SCR 564 : (2004) 10 SCC 201; Union of India v. Mohit Minerals Pvt. Ltd. [2018] 13 SCR 139; State of Andhra Pradesh v. Mc Dowell & Co. [1996] 3 SCR 721; Gujarat Ambuja Cements Ltd. v. Union of India [2005] 2 SCR 1038 : (2005) 4 SCC 214; Laghu Udhyog Bharti v. Union of India [1999] 3 SCR 1199 : (1999) 6 SCC 418; Rai Ramakrishna v. State of Bihar [1964] 1 SCR 897: AIR 1963 SC 1667; Tata Sky Ltd. v. State of M.P. [2013] 2 SCR 849 : (2013) 4 SCC 656; East India Tobacco Company v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1963] 1 SCR 404; TwyFord Tea Co. v. State of Kerala [1970] 3 SCR 383 : (1970) 1 SCC 189 – referred to. Prafulla Kumar Mukherjee v. Bank of Commerce, Khulna, AIR 1947 P.C. 60; A.L.S.P.P.L. Subrahmanyan Chettiar v. Muttuswami Goundan, AIR 1941 FC 47; United Provinces v. Atiqa Begum, AIR 1941 FC 16; Re: The Central Provinces and Berar Sales of Motor Spirit and Lubricants Taxation Act, 1938, AIR 1939 FC 1; Governor General in Council v. Province of Madras (1945) FCR 179: AIR 1945 PC 98 – referred to.
Tata Sky Limited v State of Uttarakhand, Writ Petition (M/B) No. 4 of 2010; Bharti Telemedia Ltd. v. Government of NCT of Delhi, W.P.(C) No. 4935 of 2011; M/s. Tata Sky Ltd. v. State of Orissa, Writ Petition (C) No. 8966 of 2011; Cantonment Board Poona v. Western India Theatres Ltd., AIR 1954 BOM 261; Tamil Nadu Cable TV Organisers v. Government of Tamil Nadu, W.P. No. 16237/1994; Tamil Nadu Cable TV Organisers Association v. Government of Tamil Nadu, W.P. No.10013 of 1994 dt. 30.11.1994; Vasant Madhav Patwardhan v. State of Maharashtra, 2000 SCC OnLine Bom 244; Gopal Krishna Agarwal v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1982) All. L.J. 607; Sky Vision T.V v. State of Bihar, 1995 (2) BJLR 845; Dish TV India Ltd. v. State of Uttarakhand, W.P. (M/S) No. 2562 of 2007; Tata Sky Ltd. v. State of M.P., W.P. No.10148 of 2009; A. Thangal Kunju Musaliar v. M. Venkatachalam Potti (1956) 29 ITR 349 – referred to.
Lyle Francis Smith v. Her Majesty the Queen [1960] SCR 776; Union Colliery Co. of British Columbia v. Bryden, 1899 AC 580 – referred to.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2225State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Books and Periodicals Cited Oxford English Dictionary, Second Edition, Volume IX; P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon, 6th Edition, Volume II; Reader’s Digest Family Word Finder; Webster’s Third New International Dictionary; Concise Oxford English Dictionary, 11th Edition; Canada’s Federal System by A.H.F. Lefroy; Tax, Constitution and the Supreme Court by Sri Karthik Sundaram (OakBridge, 2024); Chapter by Sri V. Niranjan, K.C. in Oxford Handbook of the Indian Constitution; Cooley on Taxation – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Finance Act, 1994; Finance Act, 2002; Finance Act, 2003; Finance Act, 2004; The Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act,1976; Uttarakhand (Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979; Rajasthan Entertainments & Advertisements Tax Act, 1957; Rajasthan Entertainments & Advertisements Tax Rules, 1957; Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Amendment) Act, 2009; Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of Direct-to Home (DTH) Broadcasting Services) Rules, 2010; Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012; Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2009; Uttarakhand (Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979) (Amendment) Act, 2009; Punjab Entertainment Duty Act, 1955; The Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996; Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment) Rules, 2010; The Assam Amusement and Betting Tax Act, 1939; The Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2006; Orissa Entertainment Tax (Amendment) Act, 2010; The Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939.
List of Keywords Entertainment Tax; Service Tax; Broadcasting Services; DTH Operators; Aspect Theory; Pith and Substance; Entry 62 List II; Entry 97 List I; Entry 31 List I; Legislative Competence; Taxing Power; Constitutional Law; Centre State Relations; Double Taxation; Residuary Powers; Federalism; Overlapping Jurisdiction; Cable Television; Private Entertainment; Public Entertainment; Judicial Review; Tax on Luxuries; Interpretation of Constitution; Harmonious Construction; Doctrine of Aspect; Doctrine of Pith and Substance; Entry 92C List I; Taxability of Services; State Tax Vs Central Tax; Communication Services; Ministry of Information and Broadcasting; 2226 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Set Top Box; Direct to Home Broadcasting; Finance Act 1994; Negative List Regime; Broadcasting and Communication; Purvi Communication Case; Geeta Enterprises Case; Bharat Sanchar Nigam Case; Godfrey Phillips Case; Entry-Based Interpretation; Concurrent List; Taxable Event; Union List; State List; Discriminatory Taxation; Tax on Admission; Constitutional Entry Interpretation; Substantial Nexus; Doctrine of Colorable Legislation. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 9301 of 2013 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.06.2012 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in WPC No. 33966 of 2006 With Civil Appeal Nos. 1629, 1765-1766, 1531, 1533, 1534, 1752, 1753, 1755, 1532, 1687, 1688, 1689, 1690, 1548-1549, 1630, 1726, 1725, 1543, 1547, 1680, 1754, 1756, 1530, 1628, 1535, 1679, 1681-1682, 1683, 1684, 1685, 1686, 1580, 1581-1583 and 1536 of 2020, Civil Appeal No. 10114 of 2011, Civil Appeal Nos. 2147, 5867 and 5228 of 2012, Writ Petition (C) No. 699 of 2014, Writ Petition (C) No. 748 of 2015, SLP (C) No. 9025 of 2023. Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Pallav Shisodiya, K.K. Venugopal, S.K.Bagaria, Tarun Gulati, Arvind P. Datar, Pallav Shisodiya, Sr. Advs., Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Ajith Anto Perumbully, Riddhi Bose, Ms. Racheeta Chawla, Ms. Rishi Agarwal, Sampriti Baksi, Mahesh Agarwal, Rishi Agrawala, Manu Krishnan, Kamaldeep Dayal, Victor Das, Ms. Madhavi Agrawal, Ms. Madhvi Agarwal, Vipul Singh, Ashwini Kumar, Ms. Chitra Agarwal, Ms. Anwesha Padhi, Ms. Manavi Agarwal, Chinmayee Chandra, Ankur Talwar, Yash Jain, Ajit Kr. Singh, E. C. Agrawala, Vivek Sarin, Aakarshan Aditya, Dibya Prashant Singh, Satish C. Kaushik, Dhruv Dev Gupta, Sahil Bhalaik, Tushar Giri, Siddharth Anil Khanna, Ritik Arora, Shivam Mishra, Gowtham Polanki, Ms. Gulshan Jahan, Md. Rashid Saeed, Harish Pandey, Gopal Singh, Akhilesh Kumar Pandey, M/S. Acm Legal, Dr. Shashwat Bajpai, Rohit Amit Sthalekar, Purnendu Bapai, Shashank Singh, Mahir Khanna, Sahil Tagotra, Ms. Shankari Mishra, Sujay Jain, Rakesh Talukdar, Ms. Abhivyakti Banerjee, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2227State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Ashwani Kumar Dubey, Praveen Kumar, C. K. Sasi, Ms. Nayantara, Dinesh Dahiya, Ms. Meena K Poulose, Kumar Visalaksh, Udit Jain, Ajitesh Dayal Singh, Devansh Garg, Harish Pandey, Praveen Kumar, Abhishek Vikas, Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Ajith Anto Perumbully, Riddhi Bose, Ms. Racheeta Chawla, Ms. Rishi Agarwal, Ms. Sampriti Baksi.
Advs. for the Respondents:
K M Nataraj, N.Venkatraman, A.S.Gs., Shadan Farasat, Sr. A.A.G., Gurminder Singh A.G. Punjab, K N Balgopal Advocate General of State of Nagaland, S. K. Bagaria, Tarun Gulati, Mrs. Shirin Khajuria, Dr. Manish Singhvi, Arunabh Chowdhury, Preetesh Kapur, K Radhakrishnan, Nalin Kohli, Ms. Nisha Bagchi, V. K. Khanna, Sanjay Kharde, Saurabh Mishra, Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Advs., M/s. Corporate Law Group, Ms. Bhavana Duhoon, Kumar Ajit Sinha, Ms. Swati Tiwari, Devansh Garg, Anshul Syal, Kumar Sambhav, Shantanu Sagar, Anil Kumar, Gunjesh Ranjan, Manoneet Dwivedi, Ms. Pallavi Langar, Manoj Kumar, Sujeet Kumar C., Ankit Khatri, Bhakti Vardhan Singh, Milind Kumar, Apurv Singhvi, Ms. Shalini Haldar, Ms. Yasha Goyal, Rajiv Shanker Dvivedi, Ms. Tulika Mukherjee, Shwetank Singh, V. Aravind, Ms. Rooh-ehina Dua, Harshit Khanduja Khanduja, Harshit Khanduja, Ankit Khera, Abhishek Babbar, Mrs. Kirti Renu Mishra, Sanjay Dutt, Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Sabarish Subramanian, C Kranthi Kumar, Vishnu Unnikrishnan, Danish Saifi, Shuvodeep Roy, Anshul Malik, Shruti Agrawal, Anando Mukherjee, Abhay Pratap Singh, M. P. Vinod, Krishnanand Pandeya, Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Ms. Srujana Suman Mund, Abhishek Atrey, Rajat Mittal, K. V. Vijayakumar, Samir Ali Khan, Sanjay Kapur, Ms. Isha Virmani, Ms. Mahima Kapur, Mrs. Shubhra Kapur, Gurmeet Singh Makker, V C Bharathi, Rajat Nair, Adit Khorana, Udai Khanna, Shivank Pratap Singh, Sarthak Karol, Chandan Kumar, Manish Kumar, Dharmendra Kumar Sinha, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Surjendu Sankar Das, Anand Murthi Rao, B. Krishna Prasad, Hitesh Kumar Sharma, Amit Kumar Chawla, Varun Varma, Ms. Tanishka Grover, Akhileshwar Jha, Ms. Sandhya G., Kamal Mohan Gupta, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Adarsh Dubey, Sachin Patil, Sarad Kumar Singhania, Sunny Choudhary, Sarad Kumar Singhania, Ms. Rashmi Singhania, Avijit Mani Tripathi, P. V. Yogeswaran, Ms. K. Enatoli Sema, Ms. Limayinla Jamir, Amit Kumar Singh, Ms. Chubalemla 2228 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Chang, Prang Newmai, Ms. Nitya Nambiar, Sameer Abhyankar, Rahul Kumar, Ms. Ayushi Bansal, Aryan Srivastava, Sarthak Dora, Ms. Astha Sharma, Srisatya Mohanty, Himanshu Chakravarty, Ms. Riddhi Bose, Ms. Racheeta Chawla, Simranjeet Singh Rekhi, Ms. Sampriti Bakshi, Rishi Agarwal, Siddharth Banerjee, M/s. Plr Chambers And Co., M/s. Venkat Palwai Law Associates, Ms. Devina Sehgal, Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki, Gopal Singh, Akshat Kumar, Ms. G. Indira, Vatsal Joshi, Krishna Kant Dubey, Ms. Indira Bhakar, Harish Pandey, Shashwat Parihar, Ms. Priyadarshini Priya, Rajesh Singh Chauhan, Ms. Priyanka, Shreekant Neelappa Terdal, Ms. Shashi Kiran, D. S. Mahra, Rajiv Kumar Choudhry, V. N. Raghupathy, Vishwanath P. Allannavar, Divyanshu Kumar Srivastava. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Nagarathna, J.
I N D E X*
1. Bird’s Eye View of the Controversy: ........................................ 6
2. Facts in brief: .............................................................................. 8
3. Writ Petitions filed before this Court: ...................................... 24 a. W.P. (C) No. 699/2014: ....................................................... 24 b. W.P. (C) No.748/2015: ........................................................ 26
4. Submissions: .............................................................................. 28 a. Submissions on behalf of Appellants: ............................ 28 b. Submissions of Respondent-States: .............................. 51 i. State of West Bengal: .............................................. 51 ii. State of Uttar Pradesh: ............................................ 53 iii. State of Odisha: ........................................................ 54 iv. State of Tamil Nadu: ................................................. 62 v. State of Rajasthan: .................................................. 70 vi. State of Punjab: ........................................................ 71 vii. State of Nagaland: .................................................... 71 viii. State of Andhra Pradesh: ........................................ 72 ix. Union of India: .......................................................... 72 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2229State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others c. Reply Arguments: ............................................................. 73
5. Points for Consideration: .......................................................... 73
6. Legal Framework: ....................................................................... 75 a. Relevant Entries of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution: ...................................................................... 77 b. Finance Act, 1994 with Relevant Amendments: ............ 78 c. Relevant Provisions of the State Enactments: .............. 91 i. Assam Amusements and Betting Tax Act, 1939: ... 91 ii. Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996: .. 94 iii. Gujarat Entertainments Tax Act, 1977: .................. 96 iv. Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012: .............. 104 v. Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976: ......................... 108 vi. Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2006: ..................... 117 vii. Punjab Entertainment Duty Act, 1955: ................... 120 viii. Rajasthan Entertainments and Advertisements Tax Act, 1957: ........................................................... 128 ix. Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939: ........... 130 x. Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979: .......................................................................... 133
7. Interpretation of Entries of the Lists of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution: .................................................................... 142
8. State of Karnataka vs. State of Meghalaya: ............................ 157
9. Meaning and Scope of the expression “Luxuries, Entertainments and Amusements” and Legislative Competence of State Legislatures to impose Entertainment Tax: ............................ 162 a. Luxuries: ............................................................................ 162 b. Entertainments and Amusements: .................................. 168 c. Amusement: ....................................................................... 171
10. Parameters of Taxation: ............................................................. 180
11. Relevant case law: .................................................................... 184 a. Suresh: .............................................................................. 184 b. Vasant Madhav Patwardhan: ........................................... 194
12. Geeta Enterprises vs. Purvi Communication: ........................ 195
13. “Aspect Theory” or Aspect Doctrine: A Discussion .............. 217
14. Criticism of its Use in Indian Context: .................................... 219 2230 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
15. Usage of Aspect Theory in the Indian Context: ..................... 222
16. Aspect Theory: Its Extent and Scope in India: ....................... 246
17. Application of Aspect Theory to the Case at hand: ............... 256
18. Modus Operandi of the Assessees and their aspects: .......... 260
19. Allahabad High Court’s Ruling on retrospective operation of the Amendment: ..................................................................... 265
20. State of Kerala vs. Asianet: ....................................................... 277 a. Submissions: ..................................................................... 282 b. Judgments relied upon by State of Kerala: .................... 283
21. Jharkhand High Court’s Ruling: ............................................... 293
22. Summary of Discussion and Conclusions: ............................. 296 a. Constitutional Scheme regarding distribution of Legislative Powers: ........................................................... 298 b. Service Tax: ....................................................................... 303 c. Tax on Luxuries: Entertainments & Amusements .......... 305 d. Parameters of Taxation under State Enactments: ........ 307 e. Geeta Enterprises and Purvi Communications: ............ 308 f. Aspect Theory: ................................................................... 310 Leave granted in Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.9025 of 2023. 1.1 Since common questions of law and facts arise in these civil appeals and writ petitions, they have been heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
1.2 The Civil Appeals arise from the judgments of the High Courts of Allahabad, Delhi, Gauhati, Gujarat, Jharkhand, Kerala, Madras, Orissa, Punjab & Haryana, Rajasthan and Uttarakhand while two writ petitions have been filed before this Court under Article 32 of the Constitution by M/s Tata Play & Another and M/s Tata Play Ltd.
Bird’s Eye View of the Controversy:
2. The assessees have filed these appeals assailing the provisions of the respective State Acts under which tax on entertainment has charged on them on the premise that their activity is relatable to [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2231State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others the field of entertainment as envisaged under Entry 62 – List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. It is their contention that they are not liable to pay entertainment tax (or luxury tax) under the respective provisions of the State enactments. It is further case of the assessee that they are engaged in broadcasting of signals etc. through television channels to the subscribers of those channels hence, possibly they are liable to pay service tax to the Central Government under Entry 97 – List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution. There are however two writ petitions filed by certain assessees who have also ventilated their grievance that they are not liable to pay service tax as well. The question whether the appellants-assessees are liable to pay entertainment tax under the provisions of the respective State enactments which are relatable to Entry 62 – List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution and are also liable to pay service tax under the provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended from time to time as a provider of a taxable service namely broadcasting service within the scope and ambit of Entry 97 – List I which is a residuary entry for the relevant purpose of assessment is the moot question which arises in these appeals.
2.1. The State of Kerala being aggrieved by the striking down of the sub-section (iv) of proviso to Section 4 under which the cable operators who have less than 7,500 connections are being exempt from payment of entertainment tax and whereas those who have over and above 7,500 connections are liable to pay the same tax being discriminatory in nature and being strike down by the Kerala High Court is questioned by the State of Kerala in its appeal. While considering the controversy between the parties, the doctrine of pith and substance in interpreting the entries of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution as well as the aspect theory as referred to by the learned senior counsel and learned counsel who have appeared for the respective parties shall be dealt with.
2.2. Since the fields of legislation are in the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India and would be referred to during the course of discussion primarily in List I and List II (Union List and State List respectively) in these cases, it shall be understood that any reference to these Lists is only with reference to the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution of India.
2232 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Facts in brief:
3. For the sake of convenience, some of the relevant facts are delineated in the form of a table which is as under:
S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
1. C.A. No.
9301/2013 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
17573/2013 State of Kerala Versus Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd.
28.06.2012 The Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act,1976
2. C.A. No.
1629/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
1173/2011 Tata Sky Limited Versus State of Uttarakhand 26.07.2010 Uttarakhand (Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979)
(Amendment) Act,
3. C.A. Nos.
1765- 1766/2020 Arising out of SLP(C)
Nos. 34237 - 34238/2014 M/s. Tata Sky Ltd. Versus State of Rajasthan 19.08.2014 Rajasthan Entertainments & Advertisements Tax Act, 1957 and Rajasthan Entertainments & Advertisements Tax Rules, 1957
4. C.A. No.
1531/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
17300/2015 Sun Direct TV Pvt. Ltd. Versus State of Gujarat 12.03.2015 Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Act, 2009 and Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Services) Rules, 2010
5. C.A. No.
1533/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
22171/2015 Dish TV India Ltd. Versus State of Gujarat 12.03.2015 Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Act, 2009 and Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Services) Rules, 2010 [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2233State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
6. C.A. No.
1534/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
20511/2015 Bharat Business Channel Ltd.
(Now Known as Videocon D2H Ltd.) Versus State of Gujarat 12.03.2015 Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Act, 2009 and Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of Direct-to-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Services)
Rules, 2010
7. C.A. No.
1752/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
4855/2014 Bharti Telemedia Ltd. Versus State of Jharkhand 30.01.2014 Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act,
8. C.A. No.
1753/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
6690/2014 Tata Play Limited Versus State of Jharkhand 30.01.2014 Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act,
9. C.A. No.
1755/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
8421/2014 Reliance Big TV Ltd. Versus State of Jharkhand 30.01.2014 Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act,
10. W.P.(C) No.
699/2014 Tata Play Ltd.
Versus Union of India Section 65(105) (zk)
and Section 65(15) of Finance Act, 1994
11. C.A. No.
1532/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
18164/2015 Bharati Telemedia Ltd.
Versus State of Gujarat 12.03.2015 Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Act, 2009 and Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of Direct-to-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Services)
Rules, 2010
12. C.A. No.
1687/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
11304/2018 IndusInd Media and Communications Ltd. Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 19.04.2018 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009 2234 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
13. C.A. No.
1688/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
13949/2018 MultiTech Digital Services Pvt.
Ltd. Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 09.04.2018 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
14. C.A. No.
1689/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
14077/2018 Siti Networks Limited Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 09.04.2018 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
15. C.A. No.
1690/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
22181/2018 Bling Ice Network Pvt. Ltd.
Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 09.04.2018 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
16. C.A. Nos.
1548- 1549/2020 Arising out of SLP(C)
No. 4233 - 4234/2020 Mansion Cable Networks Private Limited Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 09.04.2018 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
17. C.A. No. of Arising out of SLP(C) No.
9025/2023 Subhash Chand Versus State of U.P.
11.04.2018 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009 [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2235State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
18. C.A. No.
1630/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
1185/2011 Dish TV India Ltd. Versus State of Uttarakhand 26.07.2010 Uttarakhand (Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979) (Amendment)
Act, 2009
19. C.A. No.
1726/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
4755/2011 Bharti Telemedia Ltd. Versus State of Punjab 25.10.2010 Punjab Entertainment Duty Act 1955 (as amended in 2010)
20. C.A. No.
1725/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
13448/2011 M/s Tata Sky Ltd Versus State of Punjab 25.10.2010 Punjab Entertainment Duty Act 1955 (as amended in 2010)
21. C.A. No.
10114/2011 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
28836/2011 Tata Play Ltd.
Versus Govt. of NCT of Delhi 05.09.2011 The Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996 and the Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment) Rules,
22. C.A. No.
2147/2012 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
265/2012 Bharti Telemedia Ltd. Versus Government of NCT of Delhi 05.09.2011 The Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996 and the Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment) Rules,
23. C.A. No.
1543/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
18256/2012 Tata Sky Ltd.
Versus State of Assam 22.02.2012 The Assam Amusement and Betting Tax Act, 1939 and Rules 9 and 9A of the Rules framed thereunder
24. C.A. No.
1547/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
18766/2012 Bharati Telemedia Ltd.
Versus State of Assam 22.02.2012 The Assam Amusement and Betting Tax Act, 1939 and Rules 9 and 9A of the Rules framed thereunder 2236 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
25. C.A. No.
1680/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
28058/2012 Tata Sky Ltd.
Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
26. C.A. No.
1754/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
7100/2014 Dish T.V India Ltd. Versus State of Jharkhand 30.01.2014 Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act,
27. C.A. No.
1756/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
10192/2014 Dish TV India Ltd. Versus State of Jharkhand 30.01.2014 Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act,
28. C.A. No.
1530/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
17005/2015 Tata Play Limited Versus State of Gujarat 12.03.2015 Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Act, 2009 and Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of Direct-to-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Services)
Rules, 2010
29. W.P.(C) No.
748/2015 Tata Play Limited Versus Union of India
30. C.A. No.
1628/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
1182/2011 Bharati Telemedia Ltd.
Versus State of Uttarakhand 26.07.2010 Uttarakhand (Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979) (Amendment)
Act, 2009
31. C.A. No.
5867/2012 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
16255/2012 Dish TV India Limited Versus Government of NCT of Delhi 05.09.2011 The Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996 and the Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment) Rules, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2237State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
32. C.A. No.
5228/2012 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
20902/2012 Dish TV India Ltd. Versus Government of NCT of Delhi 05.09.2011 The Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996 and the Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment) Rules,
33. C.A. No.
1535/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
23533/2012 Tata Play Ltd.
Versus State of Orissa 24.04.2012 The Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2006 and Orissa Entertainment Tax (Amendment) Act, 2010 along with the Orissa Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Rules, 2010
34. C.A. No.
1679/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
31532/2012 Tata Sky Limited.
Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
35. C.A. Nos.
1681- 1682/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) Nos.
29366 – 29367 /2012 New Era Entertainment Network Ltd.
Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
36. C.A. No.
1683/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
31096/2012 Independent T.V.
Ltd. Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009 2238 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
37. C.A. No.
1684/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
31416/2012 Bharti Telemedia Ltd. Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
38. C.A. No.
1685/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
31342/2012 Bharati Telemedia Ltd.
Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
39. C.A. No.
1686/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
32123/2012 Sun Direct TV Pvt. Ltd. Versus State of Uttar Pradesh 20.07.2012 Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1979 and Uttar Pradesh Entertainments and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009
40. C.A. No.
1580/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
10555/2013 Tata Sky Limited Versus The State of Tamil Nadu 19.10.2012 The Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939 as amended by Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax (Second Amendment) Act,
41. C.A. Nos.
1581- 1583/2020 Arising out of SLP(C)
Nos. 10658 - 10660 /2013 Bharati Telemedia Ltd.
Versus Union of India 19.10.2012 The Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939 as amended by Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax (Second Amendment) Act, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2239State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others S.No. Case No. Cause Title Impugned order dated Name of enactment
42. C.A. No.
1536/2020 Arising out of SLP(C) No.
12692/2013 Bharti Telemedia Ltd. Versus State of Orissa 14.11.2012 The Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2006 and Orissa Entertainment Tax (Amendment) Act, 2010 along with the Orissa Entertainment Tax (Amendment)
Rules, 2010 3.1 From the above table, it is evident that most of the Civil Appeals have been filed by the assessees while Civil Appeal No. 9301 of 2013 has been filed by the State of Kerala assailing the judgment of the said High Court dated 28.06.2012.
3.2 The Civil Appeals have been filed by the assessees assailing the orders passed by the High Courts referred to above dismissing the writ petitions while the State of Kerala has filed its appeal being aggrieved by some of the findings arrived at by the Kerala High Court in the context of Article 14 of the Constitution vis-àvis the plea regarding discrimination raised by the respondents in the said Appeal.
3.3 The bird’s eye view of the orders and judgements passed by the Eleven High Courts referred to above can be gleaned as under: 3.3.1 The High Court of Uttarakhand by way of impugned judgment dated 26.07.2010 passed in Tata Sky Limited vs. State of Uttarakhand, Writ Petition (M/B) No. 4 of 2010 held that amendments to Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax, 1979 levying entertainment tax on DTH services was fully within the legislative competence of the State and did not encroach upon the field which the Parliament exclusively has authority to legislate. Relying on the judgment of this Court in State of West Bengal vs. Purvi Communication Pvt. Ltd., (2005) 3 SCC 711 (“Purvi Communication”), it was observed that the activity carried on by petitioners therein was not different from that carried out by cable operators in Purvi 2240 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Communication. To explain the distinctions between the imposition of service tax and entertainments tax the High Court noted that the ‘incidence’ of service tax is on the license agreement obtained from the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting whereas the ‘incidence’ for the levy of entertainment tax is based on the individual contracts executed by the petitioner with its customers. 3.3.2 Similarly, the High Court of Punjab and Haryana High Court in the impugned judgment dated 25.10.2010 held that the levy of entertainment duty falls under Entry 62 - List II which operates in a completely different field from Entry 92C - List I. Affirming the application of aspect theory to the present facts, it was observed that levies of service tax and entertainment tax can co-exist and can be harmonized as they concern different aspects. Therefore, the High Court upheld the vires of the Punjab Entertainment Duty Act, 1955, as amended in 2010, which levied entertainment duty on DTH services and dismissed the petition.
3.3.3 The impugned judgment dated 05.09.2011 of the Delhi High Court passed in Bharti Telemedia Ltd. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi, W.P.(C) No. 4935/2011 applied aspects theory to the facts in hand and held that the State legislature is competent to levy an entertainment tax on all payments for admission through DTH. It was observed that the transaction in question has an aspect of service which is amenable to service tax and an aspect of entertainment which is amenable to entertainment tax. The writ petitions were dismissed and challenge to Section 7 of the Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996 was rejected.
3.3.4 Subsequently, Gauhati High Court at Guwahati vide impugned judgment dated 22.02.2012 dismissed the petitions challenging the relevant provisions of Assam Amusement and Betting Tax Act, 1939 in terms of the judgments of the Uttarakhand High Court dated 26.07.2010 and Punjab and Haryana High Court dated 25.10.2010. The Gauhati High Court was of the view that [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2241State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others the issues raised were already covered by the aforesaid judgments.
3.3.5 By way of impugned order dated 24.04.2012, the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack dismissed the writ petition being M/s. Tata Sky Ltd. vs. State of Orissa, Writ Petition (C) No. 8966 of 2011, and held that the aforesaid decision of the Punjab and Haryana High Court dated 25.10.2010 was squarely applicable to the facts before it.
3.3.6 The High Court of Judicature at Allahabad also dismissed the writ petition preferred before it vide impugned judgment dated 20.07.2012. The High Court thought it fit to respect the broad latitude given to legislature in fiscal legislation and thereby rejected the argument that the rate of entertainment was discriminatory in comparison with cable operators. It also agreed with the findings of the Delhi High Court on the application of aspect theory. In the present batch of petitions, subsequent orders of the Allahabad High Court dated 09.04.2018, 11.04.2019 and 19.04.2018 are also challenged. These orders which were passed in terms of the impugned judgment dated 20.07.2012 are also challenged.
3.3.7 On 19.10.2012, the High Court of Judicature at Madras vide its order and judgment impugned herein held, in principle, that there could be a levy of entertainment tax on entertainment received through DTH services and the pith and substance of the levy contemplated under Entry 62 - List II is a levy on ‘entertainment’ in contradistinction to service tax levy on providing of service. The High Court also rejected the argument that Entry 62 - List II only refers to public entertainment and not entertainment through DTH vis-à-vis public entertainment. However, in the specific facts and circumstances, the High Court also held that the impugned charging provision i.e. Section 4-I of the Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939 is inadequate due to no explicitly mention of the chargeable event and incidence of tax. Therefore, the writ petitions challenging the levy of entertainment tax were allowed. In so far as the matters arising from Madras High Court 2242 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports are concerned, the questions with regard to legislative competence under Entry 62 – List I and whether DTH services were exclusively within Entry 92C/97 – List I are considered in these appeals. Further, the correctness of the findings of the High Court with regard to the charging section being defective is assailed by the State of Tamil Nadu in separate appeals which are not part of this batch of appeals.
3.3.8 The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi vide impugned judgment dated 30.01.2014 held that the Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012 levying tax on “entertainment” through DTH, in pith and substance, is on entertainment which falls under Entry 62 - List II. According to the High Court, the aforesaid levy is distinguished from tax on “broadcasting service” under Entry 62 - List II. Having found the State Legislature competent to levy such “entertainment tax” the High Court dismissed all the writ petitions.
3.3.9 Impugned order dated 19.08.2014 passed by Rajasthan High Court conducted a survey of the extant judgments of different High Courts on the issues raised and of Purvi Communication. Finally, the High Court dismissed all three writ petitions by way of the impugned order. 3.3.10 Soon thereafter, the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad by way of impugned judgment dismissed the challenge to the Gujarat Entertainment Tax (Exhibition by means of DTH Broadcasting) Rules, 2010 for similar reasons as other High Courts. The Gujarat High Court relied on Aspect Theory to dissect the two taxable events herein, firstly, the service of enabling flow of content and secondly, entertainment from content.
3.3.11 Finally, vide Impugned judgment dated 28.06.2012, the Kerala High Court allowed WP(C) No.33966 of 2006 (R) on the ground that the provisions of the impugned Act were discriminatory inasmuch as they authorized levy and collection of luxury tax on cable TV operators including petitioners only with connections of 7500 or above as discriminatory. According to the High Court, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2243State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others there could be no reasonable classification between cable TV operators with connections below 7500 and cable TV operators with connections above 7500 with reference to object of legislation.
Writ Petitions filed before this Court:
W.P. (C) No.699/2014:
3.4 W.P. (C) No.699/2014 has been preferred by the petitioner Tata Sky Ltd. (now Tata Play Ltd.) challenging the constitutional validity of Section 65 (105) (zk) read with Section 65(15) of the Finance Act, 1994, which impose service tax on the provision of “Direct to Home” (“DTH”) broadcast facility provided by the petitioner to its subscribers. In short, the petitioner’s case is that the entire operation carried on by the petitioner is one single operation and since only service tax is being imposed on this activity, the petitioner has been paying service tax on this activity since the year 2006. However, later the Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012 (Act. No.13 of 2012) came into force taxing, inter alia, the activity of the petitioners as an entertainment. As a challenge to the legality of this imposition has been rejected by the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi and several other High Courts, which is now before this Court, this writ petition has been preferred contending that once an activity is found to be subject of an enactment under Entry 62 – List II, the same cannot also be subject to service tax, which is imposed taking strength from Entry 97 – List I. Therefore, it is prayed that this Court may declare unconstitutional the imposition of service tax on the petitioner’s activity. In the alternative, it is prayed that this Court may declare that the activity of broadcasting does not constitute providing entertainment and is thereby amenable to service tax. The prayers sought for in this writ petition read as under:
“a) Declare that Section 65 (105) (zk) and Section 65(15) of the Finance Act, 1994, insofar as they purport to impose a tax on the “Direct to Home” activity provided by the Petitioner, are lacking in legislative competence and are thereby unconstitutional;
2244 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports b) Issue a writ of mandamus and/or such other appropriate writ, order or directing Respondent No.1, the Union of India, to pay to the various States, which seek to collect tax by way of entertainment tax, the amount collected by them towards service tax in discharge of the Petitioner’s liability towards entertainment tax;
c) In the alternative, declare that the activity of broadcasting does not constitute providing entertainment and is thereby amenable to service tax, and a tax by the States on such activity under Entry 62, List II, Sch. 7 of the Constitution of India is lacking in legislative competence;
d) If prayer (c) above is allowed, then issue a writ of mandamus and/or such other appropriate writ, order or directing the Respondent States which collect tax by way of entertainment tax, to pay over the tax collected by them towards entertainment tax on the service provided by the Petitioner to the Union of India in discharge of the Petitioner’s liability towards service tax.
e) Pass such other orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.”
W.P. (C) No.748/2015:
3.5 The issues raised in W.P.(C) No.748/2015 are similar to W.P.(C) No.699/2014 inasmuch as the petitioner, M/s Tata Play Ltd., challenges the constitutional validity of Section 65 (105) (zk) read with Section 65(15) of the Finance Act, 1994, which imposes service tax on the provision of DTH broadcast facility provided by the petitioner to its subscribers. Petitioner also challenges the constitutional validity of Sections 3(10), 3(11) and Section 15A of the Andhra Pradesh Entertainment Tax Act, 1939, and the Assessment Order RC No.A2/424/2014-15 (ET) dated 27.08.2015 issued by the Government of Telangana, Commercial Taxes Department for FY 2011-22, 2012-13 and 2013-14. After re-organization, the State of Telangana adopted [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2245State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others the aforementioned Act. The petitioner’s principal contention is that the petitioner cannot be burdened with imposition of ‘service tax’ and ‘entertainment tax’ on the same taxable event i.e. ‘transmission of signals’. It is also contended that the petitioner as a DTH operator does not fall within the ambit of a ‘Master Cable Operator’ within the meaning of the state enactment and therefore no entertainment tax can be levied on the petitioner’s activity. Furthermore, it is argued that the State of Telangana cannot seek to levy Entertainment Tax for the period prior to the existence of the State of Telangana especially for the areas which now form part of the Andhra Pradesh. The prayers sought for in this writ petition read as under:
“(A) Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction declaring Section 65 (105) (zk) r/w Section 65(14) of the Finance Act, 1994 insofar as they purport to impose a tax on the “Direct to Home” activity provided by the Petitioner, as lacking legislative competence and thereby unconstitutional;
(B) In the alternative, declare that the activity of broadcasting does not constitute providing entertainment and is thereby amenable to service tax and a tax by the States on such activity under Entry 62, List II, Schedule 7 of the Constitution of India is. lacking in legislative competence;
(C) Issue an appropriate Writ, Order or direction, declaring the Section 3(10), 3(11) and Section 15 A of the Andhra Pradesh Entertainment Tax Act as adopted by the State of Telangana, in so far as it purports to impose a tax on the activities carried on by the Petitioner as lacking legislative competence; (D) Issue a Writ of certiorari or any other writ, order or direction setting aside the Assessment Order (Rc. No. A2/ 424/2014-2015 (ET) dated 27.08.2015 (received by the Petitioner on 07.09.2015) issued by Respondent No. 3 as illegal, and having been issued without the authority of law;
(E) Pass such other orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.” 2246 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Submissions:
4. We have heard learned senior counsel and learned counsel appearing for the respective assessees/appellants herein and learned senior counsel and learned counsel for the respective State as well as learned senior counsel appearing for the Union of India at length and on several dates.
Submissions on behalf of Appellants:
4.1 Learned senior advocate, Sri Datar, appearing on behalf of the appellant in C.A. No. 2147/2012, drew our attention to the conscious use of the word ‘entertainments’ in Entry 62 - List II. It was contended that the word ‘entertainments’ is not the plural of ‘entertainment’ but is nomen juris. This line of argument was advanced to contend that the State cannot expand its taxing power by including DTH services within the meaning of the word “entertainments”. To buttress his submission, he took us through the consistent use of the word ‘entertainments’ from the year 1622 onwards in British legislation. It was his argument that this consistent usage reflects the continuing and underlying intention of constitutional makers for ‘entertainments’ to mean only public entertainment to the exclusion of private entertainment. Reliance in this regard was also placed on Cantonment Board Poona vs. Western India Theatres Ltd., AIR 1954 BOM 261, wherein the Bombay High Court held that ‘entertainments’ is used as a common noun and is to mean ‘entertainments in public’.
4.2 Sri Datar also argued that Entry 31 – List I refers to ‘communication’ and ‘broadcasting’. Therefore, even in the absence of an express entry taxing telecommunication or broadcasting, it was contended that these are “services” and can be taxed only by the Union, even if used for television channels. As “broadcasting service” includes DTH service, the States do not have the competence to tax the same service. He also drew our attention to the omission of Section 129 of the Government of India Act, 1935 that permitted imposing of fees on construction, use of transmitters, and use of receiving apparatus. This was contended in light of the fact that DTH operators use an apparatus to receive signals and further decode them.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2247State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others 4.3 It was further contended that vide Circular No. 61/10/2003-ST dated 14.07.2003, the Ministry of Finance directed Doordarshan and All India Radio to pay service tax as a provider of broadcasting services. It was therefore contended that, even if there is any entertainment through Doordarshan and All India Radio, it has always been treated as part of broadcasting service. By way of analogy, it was argued that Radio Tax was also levied by the Post and Telegraph Department even though radio provided entertainment. It was put forth that while Entry 31 - List I covers broadcasting and “other like forms of communication”, Entry 13 - List II applies to communications not specified in List I (which actually concerns surface transport).
4.4 Our attention was also drawn to Entry 92C – List I of the Constitution, which was inserted but not notified. Relying on a judgment of the Constitution Bench of this Court in State of Kerala vs. Mar Appraem Kuri Company Ltd., (2012) 7 SCC 106, Sri Datar argued that the subject service tax is within the exclusive domain of Parliament even though Entry 92C was not notified. Therefore, it was contended that under Article 246(1) read with Article 248, only Parliament can levy tax on any kind of services after the insertion of Entry 92C.
4.5 Furthermore, Sri Datar highlighted that, even the Negative List under Section 66D of the Finance Act, 1994 in the service tax regime also specifically excludes tax on entertainments, which, according to him, means only public entertainments. Therefore, it was contended that entertainments in public places, theatres, etc. will be subject to State taxes; whereas the same cinema shown on a personal device or on DTH/Cable TV can be taxed only by the Centre as being part of broadcasting service. 4.6 It was also contended by Sri Datar that all the impugned enactments passed by States have merely included “DTH Services” or broadcasting service as part of the definition of entertainment and therefore the tax is levied on the service itself and not on the entertainment, particularly because the entire value is taxed.
4.7 On the application of aspect theory, learned senior counsel Sri Datar’s categorical argument was that “Double Aspect” theory only comes into play when both the Union and States 2248 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports have legislative competence. However, as Parliament in 2001 declared its intent to tax DTH services, the aspect theory will have no application here.
4.8 Furthermore, on the relevancy of Purvi Communication to the matter at hand, it was pointed out by Sri Datar that while Parliament levied a tax in the year 2001, the judgment in Purvi Communication was pronounced in 2005 and has not noted the legislative history of entertainments and also did not refer to any entries pertaining to broadcasting or communications. 4.9 As an argument in the alternative, it was contended that even if the aspect theory was to apply, the impugned enactments are liable to be struck down as they ignore that in all composite transaction with different aspects, the legislature provides for bifurcation; however, herein the State legislatures have not provided for computation of the value attributable to entertainment. Only the States of Delhi and Assam have not levied entertainment tax on the gross consideration. It was contended that taxation on gross value is prohibited in law and the value of entertainment cannot be included in the value of service and vice-a-versa, vide Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited vs. Union of India, (2006) 3 SCC 1 (“Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited”); K. Damodarasamy Naidu & Bros. vs. State of Tamil Nadu, (2000) 1 SCC 521.
4.10 In that context, it was also argued that where the services are availed by the weaker section of the society as well, an interpretation that avoids double taxation should be preferred. 4.11 Sri S.K. Bagaria, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant in Civil Appeal No.1680 of 2020 and Writ Petition (Civil) No.699 of 2014, contended that the activity of the appellants herein is primarily broadcasting and has been treated and taxed as such under the statutes enacted by the Parliament. To show that the entire field of DTH services is occupied by the Central Government, Sri Bagaria drew our attention to the order dated 15.03.2001 of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, by which DTH broadcasting was permitted in India.
4.12 According to Sri Bagaria, the fact that neither Entry 62 - List II nor any other entry in the State List explicitly mentions taxes [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2249State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others on broadcasting shows that any and all taxes on broadcasting can be imposed exclusively by the Parliament. Reliance in that regard was placed on Article 248(2) of the Constitution which provides for the Parliament to make any law imposing a tax not mentioned either in the Concurrent list or in the State list. Reliance was placed on the dictum of this Court in Association of Leasing & Financial Service Companies vs. Union of India, (2011) 2 SCC 352.
4.13 It was sought to be advanced that the question before this Court was not merely regarding the scope of taxes on entertainments but also about the conspicuous absence of taxes on broadcasting in Entry 62 - List II. In other words, the question is whether the expression ‘taxes on entertainments’ can be construed so broadly as to include taxes on broadcasting within it. The argument advanced was that even a reading of the entries in their widest amplitude would not enable the respondents to read into the entry a subject not covered by it. Succinctly stated, the argument of Sri Bagaria is that giving such a wide interpretation to Entry 62 - List II will nullify Parliament’s power and legislative competence to levy taxes on broadcasting service as there can be no overlapping in the field of taxation.
4.14 While Entry 31 - List I is undisputedly acknowledged as a regulatory entry, it was also argued that a construction as argued by the appellants will also be fully in line with the structure of the constitutional scheme, especially that of the Seventh Schedule. As broadcasting and other like forms of communication are covered by Entry 31 - List I and service tax on broadcasting is imposed under Entry 97 - List I, it was argued that there is a discernible constitutional scheme which necessitates the widest possible construction of Entry 31- List I. Additionally, it was advanced that the State List has no mention of broadcasting and other like forms of communication or taxes on broadcasting whereas State List does have regulatory entries in the form of Entry 33 – List II concerning sports, entertainments and amusements, and in the form of Entry 34 – List II for betting and gambling. Thus, Entry 62 – List II relates to taxes on luxuries, including taxes on entertainments, amusements, betting and gambling. 2250 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 4.15 Sri Bagaria, learned senior counsel, placed significant reliance on the scheme of regulation and definition of broadcasting by Parliamentary statutes and orders. It was argued that the entire contour of broadcasting is a subject matter of parliamentary enactments and, therefore, as all forms, types and varieties of broadcasting are covered by Parliamentary Law, it is evident that every facet of regulation of broadcasting is subsumed under Entry 31 – List I and the taxing power for broadcasting is under Entry 97 – List I. Highlighting the importance of broadcasting, it was also argued that broadcasting and other forms of communication are subjects of national importance which were intended by the constitutional framers to be regulated and taxed by the Central Government only. It is the case of the appellants that upholding such an interpretation of Entry 62 – List II would be to truly and correctly reconcile the same with other entries in List I. According to the appellants, the constitutional scheme is with respect to all forms, types and contents of broadcasting. The consequences and effects of broadcasting are not the same thing as legislative subject matter and, consequently, all forms and attributes of broadcasting also fall within List I. It is Sri Bagaria’s argument that tax is sought to be levied merely with reference to the entertainment - causing attribute of broadcasting and is, therefore, impermissible in law.
4.16 Reliance was placed on the judgment of this Court in Special Reference No.1 of 2001, In Re: Association of Natural Gas vs. Union of India, (2004) 4 SCC 489 , wherein the validity of Gujarat Gas (Regulation of Transmission, Supply and Distribution) Act, 2001 was challenged before the Constitution Bench. The issue before the Court was whether the State had legislative competence to make laws on natural gas and liquefied natural gas under Entry 25 – List II, “Gas and Gasworks” or whether the Parliament was competent to make laws under Entry 53 – List I, “Regulation and development of oilfields and mineral oil resources; petroleum and petroleum products; other liquids and substances declared by Parliament by law to be dangerously inflammable”. While the State of Gujarat argued that Entry 25 – List II must be given the widest possible interpretation and that it includes all types of gases [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2251State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others especially when there are no words of limitation in the entry itself, this Court considered the consistent legislative practice in various legislations to hold that the term “petroleum” or “petroleum products” has been given a wide meaning to include within itself natural gas and other similar products. Sri Bagaria, learned senior counsel, contended that similarly, central legislations passed by Parliament over several decades included within “broadcasting” any form of communication like signals, images, sounds of all kinds by transmission of electromagnetic waves irrespective of the contents and their natures or types. It was further contended that this reading will not make Entry 62 – List II a “useless lumber” because any or all forms of broadcasting was never intended to be covered by the expression “entertainments”.
4.17 It was categorically argued that the aspect theory has no application to the activity at hand as the activity of broadcasting is taxed by the Parliament and the state legislatures have no legislative competence to tax the same under Entry 62 - List II as tax on ‘entertainments’. Sri Bagaria would argue that even in Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Association of India vs. Union of India, (1989) 3 SCC 634 (“Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Association of India”) this Court rejected the challenge to the central statute impugned therein as it found that the subject matter of the impugned statute was in pith and substance a tax on expenditure and not on luxuries or sale of goods.
4.18 Sri Gulati, learned senior advocate, argued that at a foundational level, far from carrying out any activity of entertainment, the appellant only acts as a conduit in the entire process of transmission of signals to the subscriber of television channels. In this context, he outlined that appellants perceive the nature of their activity as follows:
(i) entire activity of appellants is in relation to transmission of DTH signals; and
(ii) neither do appellants exercise any control over the content received from the broadcaster nor do they control exhibition of the content.
2252 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 4.19 It was contended that the said activity is aptly described as only rendering broadcasting service which was earlier amenable to service tax under Section 65(105)(zk) of the Finance Act, 1994 and was specifically expanded in 2005 to include DTH signals. That from the year 2007 onwards, the appellant was discharging service tax on the entire monthly subscription charges under ‘broadcasting services’ without charging any additional consideration for set-top boxes and dish antenna. It was argued that, in substance, this position continued even after the Negative List regime was brought about in 2012. 4.20 Sri Gulati highlighted that States have enacted statutes under Entry 62 – List II intending to tax the very same activity as that of providing “broadcasting service”, which is already amenable to service tax imposed by the Parliament. According to Sri Gulati, the provisions of various State enactments levying Entertainment tax can be categorized as follows:
i. Levy of tax is on admission to entertainment by way of a DTH connection;
ii. Levy is on entertainment through DTH service, and iii. No taxable event is specified in the charging provision. 4.21 It was contented that herein there is only one activity of providing DTH signal and that itself is a service. Reliance was placed on All India Federation of Tax Practitioners vs. Union of India, (2007) 9 SCR 527 (“All India Federation of Tax Practitioners”) to submit that a service is also an activity. Thus, it was contended that the only taxable event here being providing the service of broadcasting, there are no two aspects to the service provided by the Appellants and only one taxable event i.e. provision of DTH service does not enable the States under the guise of Entry 62 - List II to levy entertainment tax on the same aspect.
4.22 It was stressed on behalf of the appellants that though entertainment may, inter alia, be a consequence of DTH service, but entertainment tax cannot be levied on the activity of provision of DTH service, vide Godfrey Phillips Ltd. vs. State of U.P., (2005) 2 SCC 515 (“Godfrey Phillips”). It was contended that there being only one taxable event, there can [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2253State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others be no confounding of the service provided herein as both: a service and an entertainment.
4.23 In the same vein, reliance was placed on Godfrey Phillips to contend that the word ‘entertainments’ contemplates a tax on ‘activities’ of entertainments and not on any person being entertained or receiving entertainment per se. As no entertainment is inherently embedded in the activity conducted by appellants, namely, broadcasting service, there can be no levy of entertainment tax on them.
4.24 It was also pressed that the position of law permits tax under Entry 62 - List II only on the act of entertaining and not on the consequence of an activity being entertainment vide Western India Theatres vs. Cantonment Board, Poona, 1959 Supp
(2) SCR 63 (“Western India Theatres”). Highlighting the multitude of content transmitted by appellants, it was advanced that the activity of appellants cannot be seen as providing entertainment insofar as informational and educational shows, news, etc. as these may not have any element of entertainment at all.
4.25 Another line of argument of appellants advanced before us relates to a distinction between public entertainment and private entertainment. By way of analogy to cinema theaters, it was contended that mere provision of DTH services does not constitute a ticket “for admission to an entertainment”/or provision of “entertainment”. It was also contended that for an entertainment to be taxed as such, it should be open to public where members are invited. That is to say, Entry 62 – List II is restricted to entertainments of a public color. – vide Geeta Enterprises vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, (1983) 4 SCC 202 (“Geeta Enterprises”). However, as DTH service is provided to a subscriber in a private place, the appellants contended that the aspect of providing DTH service levy of entertainment tax is constitutionally impermissible. According to Sri Gulati, learned senior counsel, the words appearing alongside ‘entertainments’ in Entry 62 – List II must also be taken aid of to interpret the entry as having a public colour. It was argued that the juxtaposition of amusements, betting and gambling within one entry indicates that the tax contemplated 2254 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports is on establishments providing entertainment activities. Similarly, it was highlighted that the taxable event in various state legislations is the “admission for an entertainment” and not the consequence of entertainment.
4.26 The next line of contention taken by the appellants is that there is no overlap in taxing entries and that it is settled law that taxing entries must be construed with clarity and precision as to maintain exclusivity. - Commissioner of Central Excise and Customs, Kerala vs. Larsen and Toubro Ltd., (2016) 1 SCC 170 and Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. State of Bihar, (1983) 4 SCC 45 (“Hoechst Pharmaceuticals”). 4.27 On the question of applicability of aspect theory, which has been relied on by various High Courts, the appellants contend that the activity of broadcasting is only one indivisible transaction which cannot be artificially split into two taxable events and, therefore, the aspect theory would have no applicability here as splitting is permitted only when the activity represents two distinct and separate contracts which are discernible as such. - Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited.
4.28 In substance, the contention of the appellants was that the provision of providing DTH service is only one taxable event which cannot be split into various aspects to become amenable to taxation as both a broadcasting service and as entertainments. Reliance was also placed on the fact that the appellants are mandated to avail license granted under Section 4 of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 for providing telecommunication services. It was also highlighted that this Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited observed that the license under Section 4 of the Indian Telegraph Act is for providing telecommunication service and not for supply of any goods or transfer of right to use any goods. In furtherance of the same, it was noted by this Court that the integrity of the telecommunication service or license would therefore be mutilated if it were to be broken down into pieces to be taxed as supply of goods or transfer of right to use goods. 4.29 Sri Gulati, learned senior counsel, furthermore argued that there being no divisible event, the correct test to ascertain the true nature of the activity herein is the dominant nature [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2255State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others test. Having argued vehemently that the dominant intention of the appellant is to act only as a conduit for receipt and transmission of broadcasting signals, he highlighted that the aspect theory will be of no avail to the States to entrench upon the Union List and tax services by including the cost of such service in the value of the goods, vide Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited; Imagic Creative (P) Ltd. vs. CCT, (2008) 2 SCC 614 (“Imagic Creative”); Larsen and Toubro Limited vs. State of Karnataka, (2014) 1 SCC 708.
4.30 Sri Gulati took us through the origin of the aspect theory in the Canadian jurisprudence whilst highlighting at the outset a significant distinction between the Canadian and Indian jurisprudence that must be borne in mind. In Lyle Francis Smith vs. Her Majesty the Queen, (1960) SCR 776, and in several decisions since then, it has been observed by the Supreme Court of Canada that within the Canadian constitutional scheme, an overlap is inevitable between the subjects outlining the areas of legislations to be legislated on by the Parliament of Canada and provincial legislatures due to the general wording of the subjects under Sections 91 and 92 of the British North America Act, 1867 respectively. However, it is settled law that in India, there is no overlap between the taxation entries in List I and List II. It was highlighted that the double aspect doctrine has been developed to resolve these situations of inevitable overlap and has been applied to allow both federal and provincial regulation where powers overlap. It was contended that the doctrine has, however, never been allowed to enable the dominion and provincial legislatures to separately tax two aspects of the same transaction. It was therefore contented that any transplantation of the doctrine to the Indian Constitution must be tempered and exercised with caution given that in the Indian constitutional scheme, there cannot be any overlap in respect to the entries pertaining to taxation.
4.31 Furthermore, it was contended that the true nature of the activity of DTH services must be ascertained while keeping in mind that the DTH operator has no control over the content that is broadcast or received. It was contended that as the activity would continue to be a service even if no entertainment 2256 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports value is transmitted, it must be held that the true nature of the activity is predominantly that of a broadcasting service. It was repeatedly and vehemently argued on behalf of appellants that any element of entertainment is purely incidental to the provision of service.
4.32 Sri Gulati further argued that the pith and substance of the state legislations, impugned herein, is in the nature of a broadcasting service. This argument links to the foundational argument that the activity of providing broadcasting services is not in the nature of entertainment, and therefore, the levy imposed on purported entertainment isn’t different from service on which service tax is levied by the central government. It was contended that states cannot simply deem the whole activity undertaken by appellant as ‘entertainment’ which in fact is, fundamentally, a broadcasting service.
4.33 The argument further advanced on behalf of the appellants was that there is no machinery to exclude the value of service from the value of entertainment. This was argued as the impugned legislations, except those of the States of Delhi, Gujarat, and Assam, do not exclude the value of service from the value of entertainment before levying entertainment tax. According to the appellants, it is impermissible to levy entertainment tax on the value of the gross amount received by the appellants from its subscribers without segregating the value of service from the value of entertainment. In substance, the contention of the appellant was that in the absence of any machinery to compute the measure of tax for the purpose of levy of entertainment tax, the charge of entertainment tax itself would fall, vide Commissioner of Income Tax, Bangalore vs. B.C. Srinivasa Setty, (1981) 2 SCC 460.
4.34 Notably, a three-judge bench of this Court in Purvi Communication has already found that entertainment tax was leviable against cable operators. However, learned senior counsel Sri K.K. Venugopal argued that the decision of this Court in Purvi Communication failed to consider the tests laid down in Geeta Enterprises and to that extent is per incuriam and sub silentio. Appellants also contended that the decision in Purvi Communication is distinguishable as that case was [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2257State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others not concerned with attempts of both Central Government and State Governments to levy a tax on the same activity but instead dealt with the conflict between Entry 62 – List II and Entry 31 – List I i.e. between a taxing entry and a regulatory entry, whereas the conflict herein is between two taxing entries being Entry 97 – List I and Entry 62 – List II.
4.35 The appellants also contended that if the State legislatures are held competent to levy entertainment tax under Entry 62 – List II, then the taxable event would fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the State legislature and consequently the Central Government would lose competence to levy service tax under Entry 97 – List I.
4.36 Without prejudice to the foregoing arguments, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellants argued that the impugned legislations promulgated by the states of Tamil Nadu, Odisha, Assam and Gujarat fail to provide for a clear and unambiguous taxable event as they only deem the operations of DTH operators as entertainment. Therefore, it was contended that these legislations do not satisfy the test laid down by this Court in Govind Saran Ganga Saran vs. CST, 1985 Supp SCC 205 (“Govind Saran Ganga Saran”) and must be held to be unconstitutional. As only the Madras High Court accepted this argument, learned counsel for the appellants contended that the impugned judgments arising out of the High Courts including Orissa, Gauhati and Gujarat are bad in law.
4.37 It was further contended that Section 3 of the Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012, which is the charging section, merely provides a tax on entertainment and lacks any clear and unambiguous stipulation to tax entertainment through DTH. Therefore, in the absence of such express words in the charging section, there cannot be any levy of entertainment tax. It was also contended that the Notification dated 14.05.2012 issued by the State Government under Section 1(3) of the Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012 appointing 27.04.2012 as the date of implementation of the Act suffers from the vice of imposing retrospective taxation in the absence of any express legislative provision providing for it.
2258 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 4.38 Ms. Shirin Khajuria, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the subscribers, took us through the scheme of the impugned Act promulgated by the State of Kerala and brought to our attention that there was a stay on the levy of luxury tax for the period 2006 to 2010 and therefore the tax has to be collected only if leviable and not otherwise.
Submissions of Respondent-States:
State of West Bengal:
5. Sri Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State of West Bengal in W.P.(C) 699/2014, commenced his arguments by noting that the writ petitioners have not pressed the prayers challenging the constitutional validity of Section 65 (105)(zk) and Section 65(15) of the Finance Act, 1994. Further, arguing in support the constitutional validity of the entertainment tax imposed under the State enactment, he contended that there is no conflict between Entry 62 – List II and Entry 97 – List I.
5.1 According to learned senior counsel, this Court’s approach must be to first interpret Entry 62 – List I, followed by an examination of the scope of Entry 33 – List I. It was argued that the scope of Entry 62 – List II can be informed by the judgment of this Court in Western India Theatres wherein it was held that a State imposition is on the activity of entertainment. In that case, it was on the happening of a show in a theater. Reliance was placed on the following paragraph from Western India Theatres: “As pointed out by this Court in Navinchandra Mafatlal v. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay City (1), following certain earlier decisions referred to therein, the entries in the legislative list should not be read in a narrow or restricted sense and that each general word should be held to extend to all ancillary or subsidiary matters which can fairly and reasonably be said to be comprehended in it. It has been accepted as well settled that in construing such an entry conferring legislative powers the widest possible construction according to their ordinary meaning must be put upon the words used therein. In view of this [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2259State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others well established rule of interpretation, there can be no reason to construe the words “ taxes on luxuries or entertainments or amusements “ in entry 50 as having a restricted meaning so -as to confine the operation of the law to be made thereunder only to taxes on persons receiving the luxuries, entertainments, or amusements. The entry contemplates luxuries, entertainments, and amusements as objects on which the tax is to be imposed. If the words are to be so regard- ed, as we think they must, there can be no reason to differentiate between the giver and the receiver of the luxuries, entertainments, or amusements and both may, with equal propriety, be made amenable to the tax. It is true that economists regard an entertainment tax as a tax on expenditure and, indeed, when the tax is imposed on the receiver of the entertainment, it does become a tax on expenditure, but there is no warrant for holding that entry 50 contemplates only a tax on moneys spent on luxuries, entertainments or amusements. The entry, as we have said, contemplates a law with respect to these matters regarded as objects and a law which imposes tax on the act of entertaining is within the entry whether it falls on the giver or the receiver of that entertainment. ...”
(emphasis supplied)
Applying the aforesaid to the facts of the instant cases, it was argued that irrespective of the nomenclature of broadcasting or entertainment, the activity of the petitioner ends with the TV set and is therefore carried out for the purpose of entertainment.
5.2 Sri Gupta further argued that where taxing entries are not in conflict, then there is no need to go the doctrine of pith and substance. Furthermore, examining the application of aspect theory in Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Association of India, he argued that the same has been followed in All India Federation of Tax Practitioners. It was also argued that Purvi Communication is not per incuriam and was rightly decided it being distinguished from Geeta Enterprises for multiple reasons. 2260 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports State of Uttar Pradesh:
5.3 Learned senior counsel Sri Raizada appearing for the State of Uttar Pradesh, contended that the judgment in Geeta Enterprises was adjudicated on the anvil of interpretation of ‘places of entertainment’ as it appeared in the 1937 Act whereas the present impugned levy is imposed under the revised 1979 Act. It was highlighted that the period of the controversy herein is from 2005–2009 and any dictum under the 1937 Act would have no bearing on the present case. Furthermore, it was argued that if for a single transaction two levies are made out or use a measure of another tax then such an imposition would not be ultra vires the Constitution. Therefore, it was contended that ‘entertainments’ as it appears in Entry 62 – List II must be given a widest possible interpretation and it would be erroneous to define entertainment in a myopic, rigid or straightjacket formula. State of Odisha:
5.4 Sri Preetesh Kapur, learned senior advocate, appearing for the State of Odisha in C.A. No.1536/2020 contended that Entry 62 – List II must be read in the widest amplitude possible and a correct reading of the same allows imposition of tax on the act of entertaining whether it falls on the provider or receiver of entertainment, vide Western India Theatres. Furthermore, in Express Hotels (P) Ltd. vs. The State of Gujarat, 1989 3 SCC 677 (“Express Hotels”), this Court, while interpreting Entry 62 – List II on the context of luxuries, observed that a legislative entry takes within it everything that can fairly and reasonably be said to be comprehended in it while the actual measure of the levy is a matter of legislative policy and will be held to be good in law as long as it has a reasonable nexus with the concept of luxuries. It was also canvassed that the actual utilization or derivation of entertainment was irrelevant for the imposition of tax and could be of any kind including one which may be purely educative vide Express Hotels or Geeta Enterprises. 5.5 It was further argued that the Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2005 as well as the Amendment Act of 2010 are, in pith and substance, relatable to Entry 62 - List II. Applying the test expounded by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in Purvi Communication [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2261State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others to ascertain whether a tax falls within the ambit of Entry 62 - List II, learned senior counsel contended that the amendment in question, whereby entertainment tax was imposed on DTH operators, is a tax on entertainment.
5.6 Sri Kapur argued that this Court in para 46 of Purvi Communication has held that the appropriate test is whether the activity being taxed has a direct and proximate nexus with the provision (or enjoyment) of entertainment. It was also argued that once the law is found to be in pith and substance relatable to Entry 62 - List II, the mere imposition of service tax cannot by itself denude the State legislatures of their legislative competence.
5.7 Sri Kapur sought to contend that when neither entry is subject to the other, then both entries are required to be constructed so harmoniously that they are given full effect in their respective fields. Therefore, both entries herein, though they may seem overlapping, can indeed be given full effect as they deal with distinct aspects. States have also placed significant reliance on ‘aspect theory’ or the ‘double aspect doctrine’ to establish that both Central and State Acts are valid as they seek to levy tax on entirely different aspects even though they may form part of the same activity.
5.8 According to Sri Kapur, had the liability been imposed directly upon the subscriber, the distinction between service tax on the services rendered by the DTH operator and entertainment tax upon the subscribers would have been self-evident. It is settled law that entertainment tax, for administrative convenience, can either be on the receiver or equally be upon the provider of the content without causing any alteration to its nature. – Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Association of India. The same case was also relied upon to contend that a measure of tax is not determinative of the nature of the levy.
5.9 Furthermore, it was contended that the argument advanced by the appellants herein would render Entry 62 – List II redundant as almost every provision of entertainment would necessarily be borne out of rendition of some service. According to Sri Kapur, this is precisely why the distinction between the two aspects must always be kept in mind.
2262 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 5.10 On the application of aspects theory, it was contented that the same is neither contrary to the pith and substance doctrine nor is it an exception, but only compliments the latter. The operationalization of aspect theory is explained by suggesting that two competing enactments, if they deal with distinct aspects of a transaction, will not restrict each other and will continue to apply in their respective fields without inviting any question of overlap or repugnancy. It was submitted that the aspect theory is helpful at the stage of a “seeming” conflict to determine whether the aspects legislated upon are distinct and whether there is an overlap or not at all.
5.11 In response to the arguments of the appellants that Entry 31 read with Entry 97 – List I must be seen as taking out from Entry 62 – List II a tax on entertainment provided by means of broadcasting, the State of Orissa contended that such an argument overlooks the distinct aspects involved in rendition of services and entertainment. Neither could Entry 31 – List I being a regulatory entry whittle down the scope of Entry 62 – List II nor could Entry 97 – List I being a residuary entry cull out any aspect from a specific taxing entry in the State List.
5.12 Pertinently it was also highlighted that this Court in State of Karnataka vs. State of Meghalaya, (2023) 4 SCC 416 (“State of Karnataka”), specifically rejected the contention that a regulatory entry in the Union List must be construed as also covering all facets of taxation along with and through the residuary entry, even if that tax may squarely fall within the State List.
5.13 Furthermore, in response to the contentions on Geeta Enterprises and Purvi Communication, it was contended that the judgment in Geeta Enterprises categorically notes that this Court was concerned with the definition of entertainment under a particular statute and not under Entry 62 – List II. That it would be wholly erroneous to transplant the limitations and interpretations made in the context of a statute to be taken to govern the interpretation of an entry in the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution, which must be given an interpretation of the widest possible amplitude.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2263State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others 5.14 It was also highlighted that this Court in Suresh vs. State of T.N., (1997) 1 SCC 319 (“Suresh”) had already considered the argument and expressed agreement with the view of the States herein.
5.15 Summarily, it was also argued that the imposition of tax on goods or an activity that a person may ultimately enjoy or consume at home cannot be construed as an invasion of the right to privacy.
5.16 To the argument of the appellants that they are merely conduits in the chain between broadcasters and subscribers, it was responded that it is settled law that a tax under Entry 62 – List II can be on the provider of entertainment as well as or on the receiver. It was also contended that the DTH operator evidently has a direct and proximate nexus with the subscriber inasmuch as it is the DTH operator who enrolls and provides the setup box along with dish antenna to the subscriber. Finally, it was contended that the argument of merely being a conduit overlooks the well settled position that tax can be collected at any convenient stage as long as a rational connection is maintained. – vide CCE vs. Grasim Industries Ltd., (2018)
7 SCC 233.
5.17 It was also argued that the appellants have erred in relying on Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited to contend that the dominant intention of the activity must be seen and that there must be splitting of charges between services and entertainment. Learned senior counsel submitted that this argument ought to be rejected as it would be totally erroneous to draw an analogy between entertainment tax on the one hand and tax on sale of goods on the other, as in the case of entertainment the entire service rendered by the provider is for the purpose of entertainment. Even though it might be one activity, it is on one aspect, the price for services rendered and, from the point of view of the subscribers, the price for entertainment. – Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Association of India. 5.18 According to learned senior counsel, the Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited held that tax on sale of goods cannot be levied on a separate and severable component i.e. services as goods are only a component of the deemed 2264 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports severable transaction by way of a fiction. In other words, in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited, it was held that the States lacked jurisdiction to tax the services component and consequently, lacked the competency to include the price of services as a measure of tax for sale of goods and viceversa. It was for this reason that the judgment in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited held that value of services cannot be included in the value of goods. By way of analogy, it was contended that had it been the case that electromagnetic waves had also been deemed to be goods and there was an overlap of the entire consideration, only then would the judgment in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited be similar to the facts herein.
5.19 It was also contended that the argument of splitting the consideration between services and entertainment is an indirect manner of contending that the entire subscription amount cannot form the measure of tax. It was argued that in case of a composite transaction including services and sale of goods, a measure for one is distinct from the other by virtue of there being two deemed separate transactions. However herein, as the employment of aspect theory as laid down in the Federation is justified, the full subscription amount can indeed constitute the measure for both taxes as the rational nexus between the levy and the measure is maintained. – vide Mineral Area Development Authority vs. Steel Authority of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1796.
State of Tamil Nadu:
5.20 Sri Radhakrishnan, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent-State of Tamil Nadu in C.A. No.1580/2020 and C.A. No.1581/2020, invited this Court’s attention to the history of the legislation on the subject in the State of Tamil Nadu. Promulgated in 1939, the preamble to the Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939 reflects that the Act was intended “to impose a tax on amusement and other entertainments in the Province of Madras.” Vide Act No.XVII of 1949 w.e.f. 1 st August 1949, the words “a tax” was substituted by “taxes” and by Madras Act No.V of 1958, the words “amusements and other entertainments” were substituted by the word “entertainments”. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2265State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others 5.21 Thus, as it stands today, the Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939 is “an Act to impose taxes on entertainments in the State of Tamil Nadu”. It was shown that Section 3(4) of the Act, which defines “entertainment” was amended to levy tax on gross collection per show made by the theatres-touring, permanent and semi-permanent.
5.22 Of note is the charging section of the Act i.e., Section 4 which sought to tax entertainment provided through cinematograph exhibition in the theatres on payment for admission. The system of levy gradually underwent changes to pay a percentage on gross collection and based on theatre location. Pertinently, it was submitted that in the wake of new age medium of recreation on television screen through a VCR or cable television network, the legislature in its wisdom inserted Section 4-D to the Act w.e.f. 17.05.1984. The aforesaid Section was substituted by Amendment Act 37 of 1994 with effect from 01.09.1994, which inserted a charging provision under Section 4-E to levy tax on entertainment through cable television at 40% of contribution or subscription or installation or connection charges or charges collected in any manner for television exhibition. Similarly, appropriate changes were made to the definition of “entertainment” under Section 3(4) of the Act to include cable TV and another source of entertainment. Thereafter, the State of Tamil Nadu, having taken note of further technological advancement in offering entertainment through DTH and through IPL matches, inserted section 4-I in the said Act to levy tax. Therefore, DTH service and cricket tournaments conducted by the IPL were brought within the definition of the term ‘entertainment’.
5.23 Aggrieved, several DTH service providers preferred Writ Petitions before Madras High Court challenging the levy of entertainment tax. By judgment dated 19.10.2012, the High Court accepted the contention of DTH service providers that the charging section was defective and the levy of entertainment tax is contrary to Article 14; however, the High Court held that the State Legislature was competent to levy tax on the entertainment aspect of the DTH services.
5.24 Learned senior counsel submitted that while construing an entry in a List conferring legislative power, the widest possible 2266 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports construction according to their ordinary meaning must be given to the words used therein. – vide Navinchandra Mafatlal vs. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Bombay City, AIR 1955 SC 58. It was submitted that the most liberal and widest construction must be given to accommodate within an organic Constitution the changing meaning of the text in tune with an evolving society. In that context, it was submitted that in today’s society, it is pedantic to contend that the term ‘entertainment’ does not cover within its ambit DTH service providers. Furthermore, it was argued that merely because individuals can derive entertainment in their private space does not denude the public character of entertainment through DTH services. The facility of choosing the time, place, mode or content does not convert entertainment through DTH into private entertainment and therefore, the subject matter of tax is not a justifiable ground to read any limitation into this expression.
5.25 Learned senior counsel vehemently argued that the theory of occupied field advanced by the appellants herein has already been rejected by this Court. Our attention was drawn to the judgment of Madras High Court dated 30.11.1994 in Tamil Nadu Cable TV Organisers vs. Government of Tamil Nadu, W.P. No. 16237/1994. Therein, Section 4-E of the State legislation which levied an entertainment tax on the entertainment aspect of service provided by cable operators was challenged in the aforementioned petition before the Madras High Court. Rejecting the challenge, it was held that there being nothing in Entry 62 – List II to warrant a restrictive meaning, the definition of entertainment would not be restricted to cinematographic exhibitions alone and would include other forms of entertainment as well. It was submitted that the challenge made therein was most similar to the challenge made here against Section 4-I of the same Act. As noted, the Madras High Court rejected the restricted interpretation of entertainments and rejected the contention based on the theory of occupied field as it found that in pith and substance the impugned legislation fell within Entry 62 - List II. Thereafter, an appeal was preferred before this Court by cable TV operators which was rejected in Suresh, while [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2267State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others observing that there was no reason as to why the entertainment aspect of the transaction could not be taxed.
5.26 It was further argued that in India, the subject of tax can be the person, thing or activity on which the tax is imposed and herein the subject of tax is the receiver of entertainment by subscription to DTH: Godfrey Phillips.
5.27 Sri Radhakrishnan referred to the distinct and different senses in which the words ‘levied’, ‘paid’ and ‘recoverable’ are used in Section 4-I of the Act. While the tax is ‘levied’ on entertainment, it is ‘paid’ on all payments for admission to an entertainment and it is ‘recovered’ by the proprietor and paid to the government. Sri Radhakrishnan also agreed that even if the DTH service provider only acts as a conduit between content providers and the subscribers, since it is clarified that the subject matter of the tax is the entertainment derived from the content, there is no scope for confusing the entertainment with the service of enabling the flow of content through the DTH system. It was also argued that there are two aspects of the DTH service; i.e. the service aspect and the entertainment aspect. The taxable event for the former being the flow of content through satellites and for the latter being the entertainment derived from the subscription of the content.
5.28 It was also canvassed that the specific power of taxation within the legislative competence of State of Tamil Nadu cannot be fettered by the general power of regulation or the residuary power of taxation available to the Union Government under Entry 31 or even Entry 97 – List I. It was contended that this Court has already observed that legislative competence of the State to levy entertainment tax could not be fettered by the enactment of any regulatory enactment law, vide Purvi Communication.
5.29 It was therefore contended that the state’s specific power of taxation cannot be cut down by regulatory power of the Union. To assail any question of overlapping in the present case, learned senior counsel submitted that Entry 62 – List II operates in an entirely different sphere to that of Entry 92C or Entry 97 – List I.
2268 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 5.30 It was further contended that a reading of Entry 33 – List II makes it evident that entertainment and amusement is a class by itself not subject to Entry 60 – List I. Although cinemas mentioned in Entry 33 – List II are made subject to Entry 60 – List I relating to sanctioning of cinematographic films for exhibition, but other forms of entertainment qua which general power of regulation is given to the state are not made subject to any entries in List I.
5.31 It was reiterated that this Court has held that under the Indian Constitution, the scheme of division of taxing powers is not based on any criterion depending on the incidence of the tax. – Chhotabhai Jethabhai Patel and Co. vs. Union of India, AIR 1962 SC 1006. The importance of the doctrine of pith and substance in deciding the scope of legislation qua the entries in the three Lists was also emphasized. - MPV Sundararamier & Co. vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1958 SC 468 (“MPV Sundararamier”). It was also contended that to decide the true nature and character of a particular levy with reference to legislative competence, the Court has to look into the pith and substance of the legislation as a whole. - All India Federation of Tax Practitioners. On an application of the aforesaid principles to the facts of these cases, the learned senior counsel concluded that taxes on DTH service is on a different subject when compared to taxes on entertainment as the pith and substance of the relevant state legislation is to tax the subject of entertainment.
5.32 Sri Radhakrishnan submitted that the question in Geeta Enterprises was limited to the interpretation of the word ‘entertainment’ as used in Section 2(3) of the United Provinces Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1937 and therefore nonconsideration of the ratio of the said case does not make the judgment in Purvi Communication bad in law.
5.33 Additionally, it was also argued that DTH operators are not merely engaged as conduits in the service of broadcasting but also create their exclusive content and channels available to their subscribers.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2269State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others State of Rajasthan:
5.34 Dr. Manish Singhvi, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the State of Rajasthan, submitted that if the activity of the petitioners is within Entry 62 – List II then nothing more is to be seen and the imposition of service tax is wholly irrelevant. After taking us through the provisions of the relevant Act promulgated by the State of Rajasthan Act, it was argued that imposition of service tax is not a tax on entertainment, validity of which needs to be determined only by testing if in pith and substance it is traceable to Entry 62 – List II.
State of Punjab:
5.35 Learned senior counsel Sri Farasat appearing for the State of Punjab, argued that broadcasting is merely a means to the entertainment derived, by the content being delivered and that the imposition of service tax would not detract from the competence of the State Legislature to levy entertainment tax under Entry 62 – List II. In the absence of any conclusive intent apparent from the Constituent Assembly Debates, he argued against drawing any myopic inference on the scope of Entry 62 – List II.
State of Nagaland:
5.36 Ms. K. Enatoli Sema, learned counsel appearing for the State of Nagaland in W.P.(C) No.699/2014, brought to our attention that the relevant state Act was amended in the year 2011 and that the definition of entertainment includes DTH operators. That the enactment promulgated by the State of Nagaland has not been challenged and that in fact even after filing of the writ petition, entertainment tax has in fact been paid by the writ petitioner without any protest.
State of Andhra Pradesh:
5.37 Sri Sahel, learned counsel appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.(C) No.748/2015, similarly highlighted that there is no challenge to the State Act in the writ petition. 2270 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Union of India:
5.38 Learned senior counsel Ms. Nisha Bagchi appearing for the Union of India in W.P.(C) No.699/2014, submitted that the issue of service tax has been conceded in almost all High Courts and has not been disputed as such. She submitted that in view of the dismissal of the C.A. No. 261/2013 and C.A. Nos. 1582-1583/2020 the prayers (a) and (b) in W.P. Nos. 699/2014 and 748/2015 do not survive for consideration. She particularly highlighted that the Delhi High Court dismissed the challenge to the constitutional validity of service tax, as did Madras High Court, on the basis of categorical concessions made by the assessees. Learned senior counsel also submitted that no controversy with regard to payment of service tax arises in the Civil Appeal arising from the decision of the Kerala High Court. Reply Arguments:
5.39 We have heard the arguments made by way of reply by the respective senior counsel and counsel appearing for the parties. 5.40 We have perused the voluminous material on record as well as the judicial dicta cited before us.
Points for Consideration:
6. Whether the judgments of the High Courts (Eleven High Courts) impugned in these cases would call for any interference and if so, to what extent?
6.1 Whether Purvi Communications has been correctly decided by this Court?
6.2 Whether the prayers sought for in the writ petitions are to be granted and if so, to what extent?
6.3 What order?
6.4 On 11.09.2024, learned senior counsel Ms. Nisha Bagchi submitted that in view of the dismissal of CA No.261/2013 and CA Nos.1582-1583/2020 by this Court, prayers (a) and
(b) in WP Nos.699/2014 and 748/2015 would not survive for consideration. By way of response, learned senior counsel Sri Bagaria has also conceded that the controversy in these writ [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2271State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others petitions is essentially on the imposition of entertainment tax and therefore, prayer (a) in the writ petitions would not be pressed. 6.5 His submission is placed on record.
6.6 Learned senior counsel Ms. Bagchi also submitted that in the Civil Appeal which arises from the decision of the Kerala High Court dealing with luxury tax, there is no controversy with regard to the payment of service tax by appellants therein. 6.7 The said position is not disputed at the Bar.
6.8 In view of the aforesaid submissions, the issue regarding the payment of service tax on broadcasting service would be considered only in light of the issue whether the activity of the appellants herein is within the scope and ambit of Entry 62 – List II, namely, providing entertainment to the subscribers or receivers of entertainment by means of broadcasting through television channels and the relevant technology applicable for providing entertainment through television to the subscribers. 6.9 In view of the fact that the correctness of the findings of the High Court of Madras with regard to the charging section of the State enactment being defective is assailed by the State of Tamil Nadu in separate appeals which are not part of this batch of appeals, the question of correctness or otherwise of the finding of the High Court does not come up for our consideration here. Legal Framework:
7. Before proceeding further, it is useful to refer to the relevant provisions of the Constitution, relevant entries of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution and the relevant provisions of the State Act under considerations. We also would advert to the relevant provisions of the Finance Act, 1994 as amended from time to time having a bearing on the controversy in question.
7.1 The following provisions of the Constitution of India are adverted to as under:
“245. Extent of laws made by Parliament and by the Legislatures of States.—(1) Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, Parliament may make laws for the whole or any part of the territory of India, 2272 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and the Legislature of a State may make laws for the whole or any part of the State.
(2) No law made by Parliament shall be deemed to be invalid on the ground that it would have extraterritorial operation.
246. Subject-matter of laws made by Parliament and by the Legislatures of States.- (1) Notwithstanding anything in clauses (2) and (3), Parliament has exclusive power to make laws with respect to any of the matters enumerated in List I in the Seventh Schedule (in this Constitution referred to as the “Union List”).
(2) Notwithstanding anything in clause (3), Parliament, and, subject to clause (1), the Legislature of any State also, have power to make laws with respect to any of the matters enumerated in List III in the Seventh Schedule (in this Constitution referred to as the “Concurrent List”).
(3) Subject to clauses (1) and (2), the Legislature of any State has exclusive power to make laws for such State or any part thereof with respect to any of the matters enumerated in List II in the Seventh Schedule (in this Constitution referred to as the “State List”).
(4) Parliament has power to make laws with respect to any matter for any part of the territory of India not included in a State notwithstanding that such matter is a matter enumerated in the State List.
xxx
248. Residuary powers of legislation.- (1) Subject to Article 246A, Parliament has exclusive power to make any law with respect to any matter not enumerated in the Concurrent List or State List.
(2) Such power shall include the power of making any law imposing a tax not mentioned in either of those Lists.
xxx [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2273State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
265. Taxes not to be imposed save by authority of law.—No tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law.”
Relevant Entries of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution: 7.2 In order to understand the foundation of the controversy in these cases, it is necessary to consider Article 246 of the Constitution and the relevant entries of the two Lists which can be usefully extracted as under:
“List I – Union List xxx
31. Posts and telegraphs; telephones, wireless, broadcasting and other like forms of communication. xxx 92C. Taxes on Services.
[Omitted by the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016, Section 17(a)(ii) (with effect from 16.09.2016). Prior to omission it read as aforementioned.] xxx
97. Any other matter not enumerated in List II or List III including any tax not mentioned in either of those Lists.
xxx List II – State List
33. Theatres and dramatic performances; cinemas subject to the provisions of entry 60 of List I; sports, entertainments and amusements.
xxx
62. Taxes on luxuries, including taxes on entertainments, amusements, betting and gambling.” 2274 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Finance Act, 1994 with Relevant Amendments:
7.3 Chapter V of the Finance Act, 1994 (2001 amended) which deals with various types of service tax, perhaps under the said Act has defined “broadcasting” as under- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter unless the context otherwise requires,-
(13) “broadcasting” has the meaning assigned to it in clause (c) of Section 2 of the Prasar Bharti (Broadcasting Corporation of India)
Act, 1990 (25 of 1990);”
7.3.1 In view of the aforesaid definition reference has to be made to Section 2 (c) of the Prasar Bharti (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Act, 1990 (“Prasar Bharti Act, 1990”, for short), which define “broadcasting” as under:- “2. Definitions- In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,-
(c) broadcasting’ means the dissemination of any form of communication like signs, signals, writing, pictures, images and sounds of all kinds by transmission of electro-magnetic waves through space or through cables intended to be received by the general public either directly or indirectly through the medium of relay stations and all its grammatical variations and cognate expressions shall be construed accordingly.”
7.3.2 Section 65(63) of the Finance Act, 1994 (amended in 2001) defines “service tax” as under:
“65. Definitions.- In this Chapter unless the context otherwise requires,-
(63) “service tax” means tax leviable under the provisions of this Chapter;”
7.3.3 Section 65 (72) (zk) defines “taxable service” with regard to “broadcasting agency” as a “service provider” as under: [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2275State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter unless the context otherwise requires,-
(72) “taxable service” means any service provided,xxx
(zk) to a client, by a broadcasting agency or organization in relation to broadcasting, in any manner;
And the term “service provider” shall be construed accordingly;”
7.3.4 Section 66(5) specifics the quantum of tax liability on a ‘service provider” providing broadcasting services which is extracted as :
“66. Charge of service tax.-(5) With effect from the date notified under Section 137 of the Finance Act, 2001, there shall be levied a service tax at the rate of five per Cent of the value of the taxable services referred to in sub-clauses (za), (zb), (zc), (zd), (ze), (zf), (zg), (zh), (zi), (zj), (zk), (zl), (zm), (zn) and (zo) of clause (72) of Section 65 and collected in such manner as may be prescribed.”
Thus, tax at the rate of five per cent of the value of taxable services was levied on a broadcasting agency (i.e. five per cent of the gross amount charged by the service provider).
7.3.5 The term “broadcasting” was re-defined under Section 65(14) of the Finance Act, 1994 by way of 2002 Amendment which reads as under:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires,- (14). “broadcasting” has the meaning assigned to it in clause(c) of Section 2 of the Prasar Bharti (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Act, 1990 (25 of 2276 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1990) and also includes programme selection, scheduling or presentation of sound or visual matter on a radio or a television channel that is intended for public listening or viewing, as the case may be; and in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes the activity of selling of time slots or obtaining sponsorships for broadcasting of any programme or collecting the broadcasting charges on behalf of the said agency or organization, by its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or by any person who acts on its behalf in any manner;”
7.3.6 The term “broadcasting agency or organization” was also re-defined under Section 65(15) by way of an amendment in the year 2002 to the Finance Act, 1994, which is extracted as under:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires,-
(15) “broadcasting agency or organization”
means any agency or organisation engaged in providing service in relation to broadcasting in any manner and, in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or any person who acts on its behalf in any manner, engaged in the activity of selling of time slots for broadcasting of any programme or obtaining sponsorships for programme or collecting broadcasting charges on behalf of the said agency or organization;”
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2277State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others 7.3.7 Section 65 (80) defines the term “service tax” by way of an amendment to the Finance Act, 1994 in the year 2002, which reads as under:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires,-
(80) “service tax” means tax leviable under the provisions of this Chapter;”
7.3.8 Section 65 (90) (zk) again while defining “taxable services”, it included therein a “broadcasting agency” as a “service provider”. Section 65 (90) (zk) of the Finance Act, 2002 is reproduced hereunder:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires,xxx (90). ‘’taxable service” means any service provided,-
(zk) to a client, by a broadcasting agency or organization in relation to broadcasting in any manner and, in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes service provided by its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or by any person who acts on its behalf in any manner, engaged in the activity of selling of time slots for broadcasting of any programme or obtaining sponsorships for programme or collecting broadcasting charges on behalf of the said agency or organization.
Explanation.- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that so long as the radio or television programme broadcast is received in India and intended for listening or viewing, as the case may be, by the 2278 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports public, such service shall be a taxable service in relation to broadcasting, even if the encryption of the signals or beaming thereof through the satellite might have taken place outside India;
And the term “service provider” shall be construed accordingly;”
7.3.9 Section 66 (5) of the Finance Act, 2002 specified the quantum of tax liability on a service provider, providing broadcasting service to the following effect. Section 66(5) aforesaid is reproduced hereunder:- “66. Charge of service tax.-(5) With effect from the date notified under Section 137 of the Finance Act, 2001 (14 of 2001), there shall be levied a service tax at the rate of five per cent of the value of the taxable services referred to in sub-clauses (za), (zb), (zc), (zd), (ze), (zf), (zg), (zh), (zi), (zj), (zk), (zl), (zm), (zn) and (zo) of clause (90) of Section 65 and collected in such manner as may be prescribed.”
7.3.10 A perusal of the provisions of the Finance Act, 2002 reveals, that as hitherto before (under the Finance Act 2001) service tax at the rate of five per cent of the value of taxable service was leviable on a service provider rendering broadcasting services (i.e. five per cent of the gross amount charged by the service provider) even under the Finance Act, 2002.
7.3.11 Under the Finance Act, 2003, the term “broadcasting” was re-defined through Section 65(15), which is being extracted hereunder:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires.xxx
(15) ‘(broadcasting” has the meaning assigned to it in clause (c) of Section 2 of the Prasar Bharti (Broadcasting [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2279State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Corporation of India) Act, 1990 ( 25 of 1990)
and also includes programme selection, scheduling or presentation of sound or visual matter on a radio or a television channel that is intended for public listening or viewing, as the case may be; and in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes the activity of selling of time slots or obtaining sponsorships for broadcasting of any programme or collecting the broadcasting charges on behalf of the said agency or organization, by its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or by any person who acts on its behalf in any manner;”
7.3.12 The Finance Act, 2003 also defined the term ‘’broadcasting agency or organization” in Section 65(16). Section 65(16) of the Finance Act, 2003 is also being reproduced hereunder:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires.-
(16) “broadcasting agency or organization”
means any agency or organization engaged in providing service in relation to broadcasting in any manner and, in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or any person who acts on its behalf in any manner, engaged in the activity of selling of time slots for broadcasting of any programme or obtaining sponsorships for programme or collecting the broadcasting charges on behalf of the said agency or orgnisation;”
2280 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 7.3.13 Section 65 (95) of the Finance Act, 2003, defines the term “service tax”.
Section 65 (95) aforesaid is being reproduced hereunder:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires.xxx
(95) “service tax” mean tax leviable under the provisions of this chapter;”
7.3.14 Section 65 (105) (zk) of the Finance Act, 2003 again while defining the term ‘taxable service”, it included therein a “broadcasting agency” as a ‘service provider”. Section 65(105) (2k) aforesaid is being extracted hereunder:
“65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires.xxx (105) “taxable service” means any service provided,-
(zk) to a client, by a broadcasting agency or organization in relation to broadcasting in any manner and, in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes service provided by its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or by any person who acts on its behalf in any manner, engaged in the activity of selling of time slots for broadcasting of any programme or obtaining sponsorships for programme or collecting the broadcasting charges on behalf of the said agency or organization.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2281State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Explanation.- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that so long as the radio or television programme broadcast is received in India and intended for listening or viewing, as the case may be, by the public, such service shall be a taxable ser vice in relation to broadcasting, even if the encryption of signals or beaming thereof through the satellite might have taken place outside India;”
and the term “service provider” shall be construed accordingly;”
7.3.15 Section 66(1) of the Finance Act, 2003 specified, that quantum of tax liability on a service provider providing broadcasting services as under:- “66. Charge of service tax.-(l) There shall be levied a tax (hereinafter referred to as the service tax) at the rate of eight per cent of the value of the taxable services referred to in sub-clauses (a), (b), (c), (d), (e), (f), (g), (h), (i), (j), (k), (l), (m), (n), (o), (p), (q), (r), (s), (t) (u), (v), (w), (x), (y), (z), (za), (zb), (zc), (zd), (ze), (zf), (zg), (zh), (zi), (zj), (zk), (zl), (zm), (zn), (zo), (zp), (zq), (zr), (zs), (zt) (zu), (zv), (zw), (zx), (zy), (zz) and (zza) of clause (105) of Section 65 and collected in such manner as may be prescribed.”
7.3.16 A perusal of the aforesaid provisions reveals, that under the Finance Act, 2001, service tax levied on service providers rendering broadcasting services were enhanced from five per cent to six per cent of the value of taxable service (i.e. eight per cent of the gross amount charged by the service provider) under the Finance Act, 2003.
7.3.17 The provisions of the Finance Act, 2004 on the subject matter of the controversy in hand were identical to the ones incorporated under the Finance Act, 2002, and as such, the relevant provisions of the Finance Act, 2004 are not being reproduced here.
2282 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 7.3.18 Insofar as the Finance Act, 2005 is concerned, it redefined the term “broadcasting” under Section 65(16). Section 65(16) of the Finance Act, 2005 is being reproduced hereunder:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires.xxx
(15) “broadcasting” has the meaning assigned to it in clause (c) of Section 2 of the Prasar Bharti (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Act, 1990 ( 25 of 1990) and also includes programme selection, scheduling or presentation of sound or visual matter on a radio or a television channel that is intended for public listening or viewing, as the case may be; and in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes the activity of selling of time slots or obtaining sponsorships for broadcasting of any programme or collecting the broadcasting charges or permitting the rights to receive any form of communication like sign, signal, writing, picture, image and sounds of all kinds by transmission of electro-magnetic waves through space or through cables, direct to home signals or by any other means to cable operator including multisystem operator or any other person on behalf of the said agency or organization, by its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or by any person who acts on its behalf in any manner;”
7.3.19 Likewise, the term “broadcasting agency or organization” was again re-defined under Section 65(16) of the Finance Act, 2005, which is being reproduced hereunder:- [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2283State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires.xxx
(16) “broadcasting agency or organization”
means any agency or organization engaged in providing service in relation to broadcasting in any manner and, in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or any person who acts on its behalf in any manner, engaged in the activity of selling of time slots for broadcasting of any programme or obtaining sponsorships for programme or collecting the broadcasting charges or permitting the rights to receive any form of communication like sign, signal, writing’ picture, image and sounds of all kinds by transmission of electro-magnetic waves through space or through cables, direct to home multisystem operator or any other person on behalf of the said agency or organization;”
7.3.20 The term “service tax” retained the same definition as was assigned to it by the Finance Act, 2003 even for the Finance Act, 2005. However, sub-clause (zk) as defined in the Finance Act, 2005 was given a different meaning and effect. In this behalf Section 65(105)(zk) of the Finance Act, 2005 is being reproduced hereunder:- “65. Definitions.- In this Chapter, unless the context otherwise requires,xxx (105) “taxable service” means any service provided,- 2284 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(zk) to a client, by a broadcasting agency or organization in relation to broadcasting in any manner and, in the case of a broadcasting agency or organization, having its head office situated in any place outside India, includes service provided by its branch office or subsidiary or representative in India or any agent appointed in India or by any person who acts on its behalf in any manner, engaged in the activity of selling of time slots for broadcasting of any programme or obtaining sponsorships for programme or collecting the broadcasting charges or permitting the rights to receive any form of communication like sign, signal, writing, picture, image and sounds of all kinds by transmission of electro-magnetic waves through space or through cables, direct to home signals or by any other means to cable operator, including multisystem operator or any other person on behalf of the said agency or organization.
Explanation.- For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that so long as the radio or television programme broadcast is received in India and intended for listening or viewing, as the case may be, by the public, such service shall be a taxable service in relation to broadcasting, even if the encryption of signals or beaming thereof through the satellite might have taken place outside India;
and the term “service provider” shall be construed accordingly;”
7.3.21 The quantum of service tax under the Finance Act 2005, on service providers, rendering broadcasting services [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2285State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others was sustained at the same rate as in the preceding Finance Act, 2004.
7.3.22 A perusal of the provisions of the various Finance Acts reproduced hereinabove, according to the learned counsel for the petitioners, reveals, that “service tax” was levied on “Direct-to-Home” (DTH) broadcasting services thereunder. The aforesaid ‘legislation, according’ to the learned counsel for the petitioners had obviously been enacted by the Parliament under Entry 92C of the Union List, contained in the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India.
Relevant Provisions of the State Enactments:
Assam Amusements and Betting Tax Act, 1939:
7.4 The relevant State Acts can be adverted to as under:
(a) The relevant provisions of Assam Amusements and Betting Tax Act, 1939 are as under:
“2. Definitions. – In this Chapter, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context – xxx (3B) “Cable service” means the transmission by cables of programme including transmission by cables of any broadcast television signal;
Explanation-- For the purpose of this clause--
(a) “cable operator” means any person who provides cable service directly to customer or transmits signal to a sub-cable operator through a cable television network otherwise controls or is responsible for the management and operation of a cable television network;
(b) “sub-cable operator” means a person other than any owner or person who is a cable operator referred to in this Explanation who, on the basis of an agreement, contract or any other agreement made between him and such 2286 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports cable operator, receives signal from such cable operator and provides cable service for exhibition of performance, film or any programme to the customers”.
(3C) “cable television network” means any system consisting of a set of closed transmission paths and associated signal generation, control and distribution equipment designed to provide cable service for reception by multiple subscribers”.
(3CC) “direct to home service” means a service for multi channel distribution of programmes direct to subscribers’ premises by up-linking to a satellite system”;
(4) “Entertainment” includes any exhibition, performance, amusement, game, sport, music, cultural and dramatic performances, entertainment by electronic devices and entertainment by direct to home service and cable television network or a series of exhibitions, performances, amusements, games, sports, music, cultural and dramatic performances, entertainment by electronic devices and entertainment by direct to home service and cable television network, to which persons are admitted for payment, and the continuity of which is either broken or unbroken as the case may be, or is only broken by such intervals as are in the opinion of the State Government a normal or usual feature thereof.
xxx
(8) ‘Proprietor’ in relation to any entertainment means the owner and shall also include manager, organiser and any person responsible for, or, for the time being, in charge of the management thereof;
xxx [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2287State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
(10) “Subscriber” means a person who receives the signal of cable television network or of direct to home service at any place indicated by him without further transmitting to any other person;
Explanation- In case of hotels, each room or premise where signals of cable television network or of direct to home service are received shall be treated as a subscriber”
xxx Section 3C : Tax on cable service and direct to home service. - (1) The proprietor of a cable television network providing cable service [and the service provider of the direct to home service]1 shall be liable to pay entertainment tax at such rates not exceeding rupees one thousand and two hundred for every subscriber for every year, as the Government may from time to time, notify in this behalf.
(2) Nothing in sub-section (1) shall preclude the Government from notifying different rates of entertainment tax for household or for different categories of hotels.
(3) Where the subscriber is a proprietor of a hotel, he shall pay the entertainment tax to the Government on such condition, and in such manner as may be prescribed and at such rate as the Government may from time to time notify and different rates of tax may be notified for different categories of such subscribers.
(4) The tax payable under this section shall be paid, collected or realised in such manner as may be prescribed.”
Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996:
(b) The relevant provisions of Delhi Entertainments and Betting Tax Act, 1996 are as under:
2288 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “2. Definitions In this Act, unless the context otherwise require,-
(a) “addressable system” means an electronic device or more than one electronic devices put in an integrated system through which television signals and value added services can be sent in encrypted or unencrypted form, which can be decoded by the device or devices at the premises of the subscriber within limits of the authorization made, on the choice and request of such subscriber, by the service provider to the subscriber;
(aa) “admission to an entertainment” includes admission to any place in which the entertainment is held and in case of entertainment through cable service and direct-to-home (DTH) service with or without cable connection, each connection to a subscriber shall be deemed to be an admission for entertainment’ xxx
(ha) “direct-to-home (DTH) service” means distribution of multi-channel television and radio programmes and similar content by using a satellite system, by providing signals directly to subscriber’s premises without passing through an intermediary or otherwise;
(i) “entertainment” means any exhibition, performance, amusement, game, sport or race (including horse race) or in the case of cinematograph exhibitions, cover exhibition of news-reels, documentaries, cartoons, advertisement shorts or slides, whether before or during the exhibition of a feature film or separately, and also includes [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2289State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others entertainment through cable service and direct-to-home (DTH) service;
xxx
(m) “payment for admission” includes— xxx
(vi) any payment made by a person by way of contribution, subscription, installation or connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever for entertainment through direct-to-home (DTH)
broadcasting service for distribution of television signals and value added services with the aid of any type of addressable system, which connects a television set, computer system at a residential or non-residential place of subscriber’s premises, directly to the satellite or otherwise.
xxx
(s) “subscriber” means a person who receives the signals of television network and value added services from multi-system operator or from cable operator or from direct-to-home (DTH) broadcasting service at a place indicated by him to the service provider, without further transmitting it to any other person;
Explanation I: In case of hotels, each room or premises where signals of cable television network are received shall be treated as a subscriber;
Explanation II : In case of direct-to-home (DTH), every television set or computer set receiving the signals shall be treated as a subscriber;
xxx 2290 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. Tax on cable, video service and directto-home (DTH) service.- (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, there shall be levied and paid an entertainment tax on all payments for admission to an entertainment through a directto-home (DTH) or through a cable television network with addressable system or otherwise, other than entertainment to which section 6 applies, at such rates not exceeding rupees six hundred for every subscriber for every year as the Government may, from time to time, notified in this behalf, which shall be collected by the proprietor and paid to the Government in the manner prescribed.
xxx
8. Information before holding entertainment.xxx
(2) No proprietor of a cable television network or video cinema or Direct-to-Home (DTH)
shall provide entertainment unless he obtains permission from the Commissioner in the manner prescribed.”
Gujarat Entertainments Tax Act, 1977:
(c) The relevant provisions of Gujarat Entertainments Tax Act, 1977 are as under:
“2. Definitions. – In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires, xxx
(dd) Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service means a system of distribution of multichannel television programmes in Ku Band by using Satellite system, by providing television signals direct to the subscriber’s premises without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2291State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Explanation.- For the purpose of this clause and clause (g), “Ku Band” ordinarily means the 11.7 – 12.7 GHz (Giga Hertz) frequency band which splits into two segments, viz. the first having the frequency of 11.7 – 12.7 GHz, known as FSS (Fixed Satellite Service) and the other having the frequency of 12.2 – 12.7 GHz, known as BSS (Broadcasting Satellite Service), or it may have such other band width as may be approved by the Government of India from time to time;
2(e) ‘entertainment’ includes any exhibition, performance, amusement, game or sport to which persons are admitted for payment or in the case of television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television, for which persons are required to make payment by way of contribution or subscription or installation charges of connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever.
Explanation. - For the purpose of this clause, the expression “exhibition” includes any exhibition by cinematograph including video exhibition or television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television; or Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting System;
xxx 2(g) ‘Payment for admission’ includes –
(i) any payment made by a person who, having been admitted to one part of a place of entertainment, is subsequently admitted to another part thereof for admission to which a payment involving tax or more tax is required;
(ii) any payment for seats or other accommodation in a place of entertainment;
2292 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(iii) any payment for a programme or synopsis of an entertainment;
(iv) any payment made for the loan or use of any instrument or contrivance which enables a person to get a normal or better view or hearing of the entertainment which, without the aid of such instrument or contrivance, such person would not get;
(v) any payment for any purpose whatsoever connected with an entertainment which a person is required to make a condition of attending or continuing to attend the entertainment in addition to the payment, if any, for admission to the entertainment;
(vi) any payment for admission of a motor vehicle into the auditorium of a cinema known as Drive-in-Cinema;
(vii) any payment made by a person by way of contribution or subscription or installation charges or connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever for television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television;
(viii) any payment made by a person to the proprietor of a Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service by way of contribution, subscription, installation charges or connection charges, or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever for Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service with the aid of any type of set top box or any other instrument of like nature which connects television set at a residential or non-residential or any other place of connectionholder directly to the Satellite;”
2(gg) ‘place of entertainment’ includes a house, building, tent or any other place where the books [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2293State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others of account, ticket books and other relevant records pertaining to the entertainment or pertaining to the management of providing cable connections from any type of antenna or cable television or pertaining to the management of providing Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service are kept or are believed to have been kept;”
xxx 2(j) ‘proprietor’ in relation to any entertainment, includes the owner thereof, and any person –
(i) responsible for, or for the time being in charge of, the management thereof, or
(ii) connected in whatsoever manner with the organization of the entertainment for any duration, or
(iii) charged or entrusted or authorized with the work of admission to the entertainment, or (iii-a) a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, having license to provide Direct-To- Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service by the Government of India under section 4 of the Telegraph Act, 1885 and the Wireless Telegraphy Act, 1933 or;
(iv) responsible for, or for the time being in charge of, management of providing of maintaining or operating cable connection from any type of antenna or cable television;
Whether or not he has obtained license or Certificate of Registration, if any, for such entertainment under any law for the time being in force;
2(jj) ‘set top box’ means an apparatus connected to a television set at a residential or nonresidential or any other place which receives encrypted television signals through dish 2294 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports antenna from satellite directly and provides decrypted television signals to the television set, which enables the viewers to tune into multichannel television programmes in Ku Band, on payment, by the connection-holder, of the charges collected in any manner whatsoever by the proprietor;
xxx 6C. Registration.- (1) No proprietor providing an entertainment with the aid of any type of antenna or cable television or Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service shall carry on television exhibition without obtaining a valid Certificate of Registration from the prescribed officer.
(2) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall not be deemed to have been contravened if the proprietor having applied for such registration as provided in this section within three months from the date of the commencement of the Gujarat Entertainments Tax (Amendment) Act, 1993, carries on television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television.
(2A) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall not be deemed to have been contravened if the proprietor having applied for such registration as provided in this section within three months from the date of the commencement of the Gujarat Entertainments Tax (Amendment) Act, 2009, carries on television exhibition with the aid of Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service.
(3) Every proprietor providing an entertainment with the aid of any type of antenna or cable television or Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service shall apply in such form, in such manner and on payment of such fee as may be prescribed to the prescribed officer.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2295State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
(4) If the prescribed officer is satisfied that the requirements of provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder have been complied with, he shall issue a Certificate of Registration. xxx 6E (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in section 3, 4, 6, 6A or 6B or any other provisions of this Act, there shall be levied and paid, by the proprietor of every Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service, to the State Government, the entertainments tax, per television set which receives radio frequency signals for exhibition of films or moving pictures or series of pictures with the aid of a set top box or any other apparatus attached to it for securing transmission through Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service, a tax at the annual rate of Rs.200 per television set for which such proprietor has provided Direct-To- Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service Connection.
(2) Where the number of Direct-To-Home (DTH)
connection holders increase in any month during the financial year, the proprietor shall be liable to pay the tax proportionately in the manner as may be prescribed.
(3) The tax leviable under this section shall be paid in advance in quarterly installment of onefourth of the annual rate within such period and in such manner as may be prescribed.
Explanation. - For the purpose of this section, ‘quarter’ means a period of three months commencing on the 1st day of April, 1st day of July, 1st day of October or the 1st day of January of each year, and the term ‘quarterly’ shall be construed accordingly.”
The relevant provision of Gujarat Entertainments Tax (Exhibitions by means of Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service) Rules, 2010 are as under:
2296 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “3. Application for Certificate of Registration. - A proprietor providing an entertainment with the aid of Direct to Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service shall apply for the Certificate of Registration under Section 6C in Proforma-I in triplicate I and shall be renewable after every twelve months.
4. Granting of Certificate of Registration.-
(1) The Commissioner may, on receipt of an application in Proforma-I under rule 3 and having satisfied that all the rules have been complied with, grant Certificate of Registration to the proprietor. The Commissioner shall, while deciding whether to grant or refuse such a certificate shall have regard to the following matters namely:
(i) the interest of the public generally;
(ii) status of antecedents and the previous experience, if any, of the proprietor;
(iii) the adequate precaution made for safety, convenience and comfort of the persons covered under Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service as per the guidelines issued by the Government of India from time to time.
Explanation. For the purpose of sub-rule (1) the expression ‘antecedents’ means the conduct of the applicant in relation to the regular payment of any tax or other dues payable by him.
(2) The Certificate of Registration under section 6C shall be issued Proforma-2 and the Commissioner may prescribe special condition or conditions to be fulfilled, in the certificate.
5. Refusal to Grant Certificate.- The Commissioner shall have absolute discretion to refuse a Certificate of Registration for grounds to be recorded in writing for refusal of granting the [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2297State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Certificate of Registration. The Commissioner before refusing the Certificate shall afford to the proprietor an opportunity of being heard.
6. Fees.- The fees for a Certificate of Registration shall be rupees 10 lacs, the fees for renewal of Certificate of Registration shall be ten thousand and the fees for duplicate Certificate of Registration shall be rupees five thousand.
7. Security Deposits.- Every proprietor shall furnish as required under section 7, security amount of rupee ten lacs in form of Demand Draft to the Commissioner or shall deposit the National Savings Certificate or furnish Bank Guarantee of a Nationalized Bank in favour of Government of Gujarat, Information and Broadcasting Department on obtaining Certificate of Registration.
xxx
11. Applicability of other Acts.- The proprietor shall comply with such of the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003 (36 of 2003), the Wireless Technology Act, 1933 (17 of 1933), the Telegraph Act, 1885 (13 of 1885), Guidelines, Policies and Notifications issued by Government of India from time to time and such other Acts and the rules made thereunder as are applicable to the Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Services.
12. Free access or public servants on duty.- Free access to any place in respect of which a certificate is issued under these rules for Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service shall be given at all hours to the Commissioner or any officer authorized by the Commissioner, the Collector or any other officer as may be authorized by the State Government in the execution of their duties.
2298 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
13. Receipt for payment.- The proprietor shall give a receipt to the connection holder for every payment and shall also furnish the connection number to such connection holder when he receives payment for installation charges or any other charges by whatsoever it may be called.
A copy of the receipt shall be kept in the receipt book by the proprietor till the assessments is completed and thereafter for a period of one year.
14. Return.- (1) The returns under clause (b) of sub-section (1) of section 8 shall be furnished to the prescribed officer.
(2) The returns relating to the payment of tax under section 6E shall be furnished quarterly in every financial year by the proprietor to the prescribed officer in Proforma-3, Proforma-4 and Proforma-5 along with challan within fifteen days of the completion of the respective quarter:
Provided that the return relating to the second and third quarter of the financial year 2009-10 shall be furnished within fifteen days from the publication of these rules in the official Gazette.
(3) Every proprietor shall maintain a register in Proforma-6 for each financial year.
xxx
16. Order of Assessment.- (1) The assessment of tax in the respect of an entertainment shall be made within thirty days after the return in respect of such entertainment is furnished.
(2) After the assessment is made, the prescribed officer shall serve a notice upon the proprietor for payment of tax, if any additional amount of tax is found to be due.”
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2299State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012:
(d) The relevant provisions of Jharkhand Entertainment Tax Act, 2012 are as under:
“2. Definitions. - In this Act, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context,xxx
(k) “Direct to Home (DTH) Service” means a system of distribution of multi-channel television programmes by using a Satellite system by providing television signals through Antenna direct or any other similar devices to the subscriber’s premises/hotels/clubs, without passing through an intermediary such as cable service;
(l)”Direct to Home (DTH) Service provider”
means any person or proprietor or agency, who provide Direct to Home (DTH) Service, whether by means of “Set top boxes” or any such antenna or instruments or equipments or any other similar devices and includes the activation or renewal of such DTH service.
(m)”Entertainment” includes any exhibition, performance, amusement, game shows or sports to which persons are admitted for payment, or in the case of television exhibition with the aid and any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television network or Direct-to-Home (DTH) Service, for which persons are required to make payment by way of contribution or subscription or installation or rent or security and connection charges or by any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever; but does not include magic show and temporary amusement including games and rides;
For the purposes of this clause - 2300 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports The expression “exhibition” includes any exhibition by cinematograph including video exhibition or television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it, or cable television network as provided by the cable operator incidental to cable service(s);
Explanation. - For the purpose of this provision, exhibition shall include exhibitions in Multiplex Cinema Complex(s).
The expression “game” includes video games which are played with the aid of machine which is operated electronically or mechanically or electro-mechanically for the purposes of entertainment or otherwise and;
The expression “temporary amusement”
means the amusement rides and games which are not provided on fairly permanent basis like in amusement park or meals or fair.
(n)”Entertainment Tax” means a tax levied on “entertainment” under this Act.
xxx 2(s) “Payment for entertainment” includes – xxx
(iv) any payment made by a person by way of contribution or subscription or installation or connection charges or valuable consideration or any other charge collected in any manner whatsoever for television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television network as provided by the cable operator; or
(v) any payment made by a person to the proprietor of a Direct to Home (DTH) service by way of contribution, subscription, installation [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2301State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others or rent or security or activation charges or connection charges, or valuable consideration or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever for Direct to Home (DTH) service with the aid of any type of set-top box(s) or any other instrument/equipment of like nature, or any other similar devices, which connects television set at a residential/hotels/clubs or non-residential place or a connection holder directly to the Satellite.
Explanation. - For the purposes or this subclause any expenditure incurred by any cooperative housing society, residential complexes as valuable consideration or by the management of any factory, hotels, lodge, bar, permit room pub, or by a person or group of persons, for the purchase of any type of antenna or any other apparatus equipments for securing transmission through the cable network of cable television attached to it, for its members, or for workers or customers or for himself or themselves, as the case may be, shall be deemed to be the payment made under this sub-clause for the television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with cable network attached to it or cable television network no DTH service provider.
xxx
3. Incidence of entertainment tax. - (1) Save as provided in sub- section (2), there shall be levied and paid to the State Government by an assessee: a tax on the entertainment at the rate(s) as specified in the notification issued under this Act.
Provided that the State Government may specify different rate or rates of entertainment tax in respect to different categories of the entertainments for the different specified periods and for different specified areas.
2302 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Provided further that the rate of entertainment tax shall not exceed thirty percent of the value of gross collection / admission charge(s) / subscription(s) / contribution(s) / rent / security / sponsorship / activation charges or by any other valuable consideration(s) received or receivable for providing entertainment(s).
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (1), entertainment tax shall be levied in relation to cinematograph exhibition on the proprietor of an entertainment at compounded rate(s) as specified in the schedule.
Provided that the state Government may specify different rate or rates of tax in respect to the different specified areas and for different specified periods.
Provided further the State Government may specify different rates in relation to the separate units of Multiplex Cinema Complex, depending upon their respective sitting capacity.
4. Assesses to collect entertainment tax from persons admitted to entertainment. - Save as provided under sub-section (2) of Section 3 of this Act, every assessee shall be entitled to collect, from persons admitted to the entertainment(s), an amount equal to the entertainment tax payable in respect to the valuable consideration of tickets or complimentary tickets or the sponsorship amount.
5. Payment of tax. - Subject to the provisions of this Act and such rules as may be prescribed, entertainments tax shall be payable by every assessee for the following class of entertainments-
(i) For the cinematograph exhibition falling under sub-section (2) of Section 3, before commencing of the week;
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2303State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
(ii) For the video exhibition falling under subsection (2) of Section 3 read with serial number 2 of the schedule, before commencing of the week;
(iii) for the Multiplex Cinema Complex exhibition falling under sub-section (2) of Section 3 read with serial number 3 of the schedule, before commencing of the week;
(iv) for the sponsored programmes falling under clause (x) and (ad) of Section 2, before commencement of such sponsored programmes
(v) for the cable operators, operating cable television network and Direct-to-Home Service Provider, and all other descriptions of entertainment falling under sub-section (2) of Section 3 read with serial number 4, 5 and 6 of the Schedule; by 7th day of the month after the expiry of the respective month.
Explanation. - If the specified date happens to be holiday, the next working day shall be treated to be the payment day.”
Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976:
(e) The relevant provisions of Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976 are as under:
“2. Definitions. – In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires.xxx
(ca) “cable operator”, means a person engaged in the business of receiving and distributing satellite television signals, communication network including production and transmission of programmes and packages for a monetary consideration.
xxx 2304 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(ee) “luxury” means a commodity or service that ministers comfort or pleasure;
xxx
(fa) “Luxury provided by a cable operator”
means any service by means of transmission of television signals by wire, where subscriber’s television set is linked by metallic co-axial cable or optic fibre cable to a central system called the ‘headend’ and by using a video cassette or disc or both, recorder or player or similar such apparatus on which pre-recorded video cassettes or disc or both are played or replayed and the films or moving pictures or series of pictures which are viewed and hear on Television receiving set at a residential or a non residential place of a connection holder.
xxx
(g) “prescribed” means prescribed by rules made under this Act;
(h) “Proprietor” in relation to a hotel, house boat, hall auditorium, home stay, hospital Kalyanamandapam or place of like nature includes the person who for the time being is in charge of the management of such hotel, house boat, hall, auditorium home stay, hospital or kalyanamandapam or place of like nature as the case may be.
xxx
4. Levy and collection of luxury tax. – (1)
Subject to the provisions of this Act, there shall be levied and collected a tax, hereinafter called the ‘luxury tax’ in respect of any luxury provided, -
(i) in a hotel, house boat, hall, auditorium or kalyanamandapam or including t h o s e a t t a c h e d t o h o t e l s , c l u b s , Kalyanamandapam and places of the like [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2305State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others nature which are rented for accommodation for residence or used for conducting functions, whether public or private, exhibition;
(ii) by cable operators;
(iii) in a hospital; and
(iv) in a home stay Provided that the sub-section shall not apply to halls and auditoriums located within the premises of ‘places of worship’ owned by such institutions;
Provided that the sub-section shall not apply to halls and auditoriums located within the premises of ‘places of worship’ owned by such institutions.
(2) Luxury tax shall be levied and collected, xxx
(d) in respect of a cable TV operator at the rate of rupees five per connection per month, and shall be collectable from the person enjoying the luxury:
Provided that no luxury tax shall be payable in respect of a connection provided by a cable operator engaged in the distribution of programmes of Doordarshan channels only:
Provided further that luxury tax, if any, collected shall be paid over to the Government:
xxx Provided also that a proprietor of a hotel who had claimed exemption under sub-clause (1) of clause 4 of the Kerala Finance Bill, 2006 (Bill No. 355 of the XI Kerala Legislative Assembly)
from the 1st day of April 2006 being the charges of accommodation below rupees two hundred 2306 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports per room per day, shall be permitted to avail such exemption till 30th June, 2006.
xxx
(3) The luxury tax shall be collected by the proprietor and paid within such period and in such manner as may be prescribed, into a Government treasury” or a Nationalised Bank notified by Government in this behalf.
xxx
5. Returns. – Every proprietor liable to pay luxury tax under this Act shall submit such return in such manner and within such period as may be prescribed.
xxx The Kerala Finance Act, 2006
3. Amendment of Act 32 of 1976.- In the Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976 (32 of 1976), -
(1) in Section 2, xxx
(c) after clause (f), the following clause shall be inserted, namely:- “(fa) “Luxury provided by a cable operator”
means any service by means of transmission of television signals by wire, where subscriber’s television set is linked by metallic co-axial cable or optic fibre cable to a central system called the headend and by using a video cassette or disc or both, recorder or player or similar such apparatus on which pre-recorded video cassettes or disc or both are played or replayed and the films or moving pictures or series of pictures which are viewed and heard on Television receiving set at a residential or a non-residential place of a connection holder;”;
xxx [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2307State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others The Kerala Tax on Luxuries Rules, 1976
3. Filing of return. – (1) The return referred to in section 5 shall be xxx
(b) in Form 1A in the case of cable TV Operator;
xxx The Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976 (Act 32 of 1976)
(Incorporating Amendments up to the Finance Act, 2010)
2. Definitions: - In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires: xxx
(ca) “cable operator” means a person engaged in the business of receiving and distributing satellite television signals, communication network including production and transmission of programmes and packages for a monetary consideration”
xxx “(da) “Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service” means a system of distribution of multi-channel television programmes in ku band using a satellite system of providing television signals direct to the subscriber’s premises in an encrypted form which will be received by an antenna and decrypted by an electronic device, thus providing television signals to the television set or other viewing devices of the subscriber, without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator.
(db) “Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service Provider” means, a company registered 2308 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports under the Companies Act, 1956 (Central Act 1 of 1956) having granted license to provide Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service by the Government of India under section 4 of the Telegraph Act, 1885(Central Act 13 of 1885) and Indian Wireless Telegraphy Act, 1933 (Central Act 17 of 1933) and providing such service within the State.
xxx
(ee) “luxury” means a commodity or service that ministers comfort or Pleasure:
xxx
(fa) “Luxury provided by a cable operator”
means any service by means of transmission of television signals by wire, where subscriber’s television set is linked by metallic co-axial cable or optic fibre cable to a central system called the ‘headend’ and by using a video cassette or disc or both, recorder or player or similar such apparatus on which pre-recorded video cassettes or disc or both are played or replayed and the films or moving pictures or series of pictures which are viewed and heard on Television receiving set at a residential or a non-residential place of a connection holder;
xxx “(fd) “Luxury provided by Direct-To-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service Provider” means any service by means of transmission of television signals and the films or moving pictures or series of pictures which are viewed and heard on television receiving set or other devices through a Direct-To-Home (DTH) service at a residential or a non-residential place of a subscriber, providing pleasure, comfort and entertainment to the subscribers and viewers.”;
xxx [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2309State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others “(l) “subscriber” means a person who enjoys the luxury by receiving the signal of cable television network or a direct-to-home service at a place indicated by him to the cable operator or the Direct-To-Home (DTH) Service Provider, without further transmitting it to any other person.”;
xxx
4. Levy and collection of luxury tax: (1)
Subject to the provisions of this Act, there shall be levied and collected a tax, hereinafter called the ‘luxury tax’, in respect of any luxury provided,xxx
(ii) by cable operators; (“and by Direct-to-Home (DTH) Service Providers”)
xxx Provided that the sub-section shall not apply to,xxx
(iv) to cable operators whose total number of connections, including those given through franchisees, is seven thousand and five hundred or less:
Provided further that the cable operators with seven thousand and five hundred or less connections shall not be liable to tax from 1st July, 2006
(2) Luxury tax shall be levied and collected, xxx
(d) in respect of a cable TV operator(“and Direct-to-Home(DTH) Broadcasting Provider”)
at the rate of rupees five per connection per month, and shall be collectable from the person enjoying the luxury :
xxx 2310 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Provided that no luxury tax shall be payable in respect of a connection provided by a cable operator engaged in the distribution of programmes of Doordarshan channels only:
Provided further that luxury tax, if any, collected shall be paid over to the Government:
Provided also that a proprietor of a hotel who had claimed exemption under sub-clause (1) of clause 4 of the Kerala Finance Bill, 2006 (Bill No. 355 of the XI Kerala Legislative Assembly)
from the 1st day of April 2006 being the charges of accommodation below rupees two hundred per room per day, shall be permitted to avail such exemption till 30th June, 2006.
(2A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2), there shall be levied a luxury tax at the rate of rupees one hundred per year per member and the same shall be collected by the person responsible for the management of the club, by whatever name called.
Explanation: For the purpose of this section, ‘club’ means a club which provides more than two facilities like card room, bar, billiard rooms, snooker room, tennis court, swimming pool, Sauna Jacuzzi and the like, gymnasium, golf course, internet facility, video, video compact disk, digital video disk and computer games and having a membership strength of at least twenty five.
xxx
(4) In computing the luxury tax, a fraction of a rupee, which is not a multiple of five paise, shall be rounded of to the next higher multiple of five paise.
“ ( 5 ) E v e r y D i r e c t - To - H o m e ( D T H ) Broadcasting Service Provider in the State shall pay luxury tax at the rate of two [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2311State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others per cent on the gross charges received or receivable by him every month in any manner including installation charges, subscription charges, recharges, or other charges by whatever name called from the subscribers in the State in respect of the luxury provided by him.”;”
xxx 4D. Registration of cable operators and Directto-Home(DTH) Broadcasting Service Provider.- Every cable operator (“and Direct-to-Home(DTH)
Broadcasting Service Provider”) shall get himself registered with such authority and in such manner, as may be prescribed and the application for registration shall be accompanied by a registration fee of Rupees one thousand.
The registration shall be for a period of one year and shall be renewed annually.
xxx
5. Returns: - Every proprietor liable to pay luxury tax under this Act shall submit such return in such manner and within such period as may be prescribed.
ACT 10 of 2010
THE KERALA FINANCE ACT, 2010
6. Amendment of Act 32 of 1976. In the Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976 (32 of 1976),-
(1) in section 2,-
(i) after clause (d), the following clauses shall be inserted, namely:- “(da) “Direct-To-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service” means a system of distribution of multi-channel television programmes in ku band using a satellite system of providing television 2312 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports signals direct to the subscriber’s premises in an encrypted form which will be received by an antenna and decrypted by an electronic device, thus providing television signals to the television set or other viewing devices of the subscriber, without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator.
xxx
(2) in section 4,-
(i) (a) in sub-section (1), in item (ii), the words, symbols, brackets and letters “and by Direct- To-Home (DTH) Service Providers” shall be added at the end:
(b) for the existing proviso to sub-section (1), the following provisos shall be substituted, namely:- “Provided that the sub-section shall not apply to.xxx
(iv) to cable operators whose total number of connections, including those given through franchisees, is seven thousand and five hundred or less:
Provided further that the cable operators with seven thousand and five hundred or less connections shall not be liable to tax from 1ª July, 2006;
ACT 16 OF 2011
THE KERALA FINANCE ACT, 2011
6. Amendment of Act 32 of 1976.-In the Kerala Tax on Luxuries Act, 1976 (32 of 1976),—
(1) in section 2,-
(i) clause (ca) shall be omitted;
(ii) clause (fa) shall be omitted;
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2313State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2006:
(f) The relevant provisions of Orissa Entertainment Tax Act, 2006 are as under:
“2. Definitions. - In this Act, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context,—
(a) “admission to an entertainment” includes admission to any place in which the entertainment is held and in case of entertainment through cable service (or Direct-to-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service) each connection to a subscriber shall be deemed to be an admission for entertainment;
xxx
(d) “cable television network” means any system consisting of a set of closed transmission paths and associated signal generation, control and distribution equipment, designed to provide cable service for reception by multiple subscribers;
xxx (e1): Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service” means system of distribution of multichannel television programme in KU Band by using a satellite system, by providing television signals to a television set with the aid of set-top box direct to subscribers without passing through an intermediary such as Cable Operator.
Explanation.- For the purpose of this clause and clause (k1) “KU Band” ordinarily means the 11.7-12.7 Ghz. (Gigahertz) frequency band which splits into two segments viz. the first having the frequency of 11.7-12.2 Ghz. Known as FSS (Fixed Satellite Service) and the other having the frequency of 12.2-12.7 Ghz. Known as BSS (Broadcasting Satellite Service), or it 2314 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports may have such other brand width as may be approved by the Government of India from time to time.”
(f) “entertainment” means any cinematographic exhibition including exhibition of news reels, documentaries, cartoons, advertisement shots or slides, whether before or during exhibition of a feature film or separately, and includes any other exhibition, performance, amusement and entertainment through cable service (or Directto-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service);
xxx
7. Tax on cable and DTH service. - (1) The proprietor of a cable television network providing cable service (and of a Direct-to-Home (DTH)
Broadcasting Service) shall be liable to pay entertainment tax at such rate as specified in Part II of the Schedule.
(2) The tax payable under this section shall be paid, collected or realised in such manner as may be prescribed.
xxx
9. Intimation before holding entertainment.-
(1) No entertainment on which tax is leviable shall be held without prior information being given to the Commissioner in the manner prescribed.
(2) No proprietor of a cable television network (or Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service)
shall provide entertainment, unless he obtains permission from the Commissioner in the manner prescribed.
xxx [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2315State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
(3a) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsections (2) and (3) where any proprietor of a Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service is providing entertainment immediately before the commencement of the Orissa Entertainment Tax (Amendment) Act, 2010 he may continue to provide entertainment,—
(a) for a period of three months from the date of commencement of said amendment Act; or
(b) till the permission under sub-section (2) is granted by the Commissioner, if an application to that effect is made in the prescribed manner within the period specified in clause (a).”
The relevant provisions of Orissa Entertainment Tax Rules, 2006 are as under:
“12. Permission to operate cable television network or connection for the Directto-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service. –
(1) The proprietor of a cable television network or a Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service shall submit to the Commissioner an application in Form XA within fifteen days from the date of commencement of these rules bringing the Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service under the purview of the Act or at least fifteen days before the date of such entertainment and shall furnish any other information which may be so required by the Commissioner for the purpose.
(2) The Commissioner, after making such enquiry as he may deem proper and after being satisfied that the application is in order, shall issue certificate in form XIIIA permitting the proprietor of a cable television network or a Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting Service.”
2316 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Punjab Entertainment Duty Act, 1955:
(g) The relevant provisions of the Punjab Entertainment Duty Act, 1955 are as under:
“2. Definitions. - In this Act unless the context otherwise requires -
(a) ‘admission to an entertainment’ includes admission to any place in which the entertainment is being held or is to be held and where television exhibition is being provided with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable television or direct-to-home television in residential or non-residential areas of which persons are required to make payment by way of contribution or subscription or installation and connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner, whatsoever.
xxx
(aa) ‘antenna’ means an apparatus which received television signals which enable viewers to tune into transmissions including national or international satellite transmissions and which is erected or installed for exhibition of films or moving pictures or series of pictures by means of transmission of television signals by wire where subscriber’s television sets at the residential or non-residential place are linked by metallic coaxial cable or optio-fibre cable to a central system called the head-end, on payment by the connection holder of any contribution or subscription or installation and connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever.
(aaa) ‘cable television’ means a system organised on payment by a connection holder of any contribution or subscription or installation [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2317State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others and connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever, for exhibition of films or moving pictures or series of pictures by means of transmission of television signals by wire where subscriber’s television set is linked by metallic coaxial cable or optio-fibre cable to a central system called the head-end, by using a video cassette or disc or both, recorder or player or similar such apparatus on which prerecorded vide cassettes or discs or both are played or replayed and the films or moving pictures or series of pictures which are viewed and heard on the television receiving set at a residential or non-residential place of a connection holder.
(b) ‘Commissioner’ means the Excise and Taxation Commissioner, Punjab, for the time being;
(bb) “direct-to-home television” means the reception of satellite programmes with the aid of a dish by a subscriber in his home or any other place for exhibition of films or moving pictures or series of pictures on payment basis;
(bbb) “dish” means a large circular antenna for receiving television signals from a satellite;”;
‘Entertainment Tax Officer’ means the officer appointed as such under this Act;
(d) ‘entertainment’ includes any exhibition, performance, amusement, game, sport or race to which persons are ordinarily admitted on payment for exhibition of films or moving pictures or series of pictures which are shown in a cinema house or on the television receiving set, with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable net work attached to it or cable television or dish relating to direct-to-home television 2318 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports network for which persons are required to make payment by way of contribution or subscription or installation and connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever.
Explanation.- For the purpose of this clause, the expression “Cinema house” shall have the same meaning as has been assigned to it in the Punjab Entertainments Tax (Cinematograph Shows) Act, 1954 (Punjab Act 8 of 1954).
(e) ‘payment for admission’ includes –
(i) any payment made by a person admitted to any part of a place of entertainment and in a case where such person is subsequently admitted to another part thereof for admission to which an additional payment is required, such additional payment, whether actually made or not;
(ii) in cases of free, surreptitious, unauthorised or concessional entry, whether with or without the knowledge of the proprietor, the payment which would have been made if the person concerned had been admitted on payment of the full charges ordinarily chargeable for such admission;
(iii) any payment for any purpose whatsoever connected with an entertainment which a person is required to make as a condition of attending or continuing to attend the entertainment in addition to the payment, if any, for admission to the entertainment;
(iv) any payment made by a person by way of contribution or subscription of installation and connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever for television exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or cable [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2319State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others television or a dish relating to direct-to-home television network.
(f) ‘prescribed’ means prescribed by rules made under this Act;
(g) ‘proprietor’ in relation to any entertainment includes the owner, partner or a person responsible for the management thereof and any person responsible for or for the time being incharge of the management for providing cable connection from any type of antenna or cable television or for providing direct-to-home television service.
xxx
3. Duty on payments for admission to entertainments.
(1) A person admitted to an entertainment shall be liable to pay an entertainment duty at a rate of twenty-five per centum, which shall be collected by the proprietor and rendered to the Government in the prescribed manner.
(1-A) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (1), the Government may, by notification, levy lumpsum entertainment duty at a rate not exceeding, -
(a) eight thousand rupees per annum in the local area of a City constituted as such under the Punjab Municipal Corporation Act, 1976, or of a Municipality declared as such under the Punjab Municipal Act, 1911; and
(b) Six thousand rupees per annum in areas other than the local areas specified in clause (a); in respect of entertainments arranged by a proprietor by replay of video cassette player or 2320 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports video record player and the lumpsum duty so levied shall be recoverable from the proprietor, (1-B) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (1), a proprietor may, at his option, pay in lump sum entertainment duty on an amusement park at the rates, specified in the Schedule appended to this Act, per annum per ride.
SCHEDULE
(See Section 3 (1-B)
Category of rides Description of rides Rate of duty per ride (in Rupees)
1 2 3 A
1. Dragon Roller Coaster
2. Big Apple 3.Dragon Coaster
4. Roller Coaster
5. Bumper Car
6. Cyclone
7. Striking Cars
8. Go karts
9. Water Chute
10. Octopus
11. Twister
12. Enterprise
13. Kamikaze
14. Rainbow
15. Power Tower
16. Family Swinger Sixty thousand [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2321State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others B
1. Break Dance
2. Caterpillar
3. Paratrooper
4. Round About
5. Train
6. Dream Boat
7. Formula Cars
8. Family Slide
9. Love Boats
10. My Fair Lady
11. Tea Cup or Cup and Saucer
12. Gandola
13. Jumping Frogs
14. Parachute Towers
15. Ship or Pandulum
16. Harakiri
17. Slide
18. Razzle Dazzle
19. Ferris Wheel
20. Rock ‘N’ Roll
21. Telecombat
22. Bumper Boats Forty thousand C
1. Baby Train
2. Toto Train
3. Fun Spin
4. Fun Channel
5. Vintage Cat
6. Jingle Ride Twenty thousand 2322 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. Scooters
8. Guided Cars
9. Money Tree
10. Snail
11. Kiddie Boats
12. Coin Operated Rides
13. Children Slide
14. Any other un-specified Ride
15. Merry Go Round
16. Carousel
17. Water Merry
18. Go Round
19. Sun and Moon
20. Mini Coaster
21. Water Canal
22. Crazy Submarine D
1. Boating
2. Play Pen
3. Little Kingdo
4. Funny Boats
5. Kids Castle
6. Bike Mania
7. Water Slide (1-B) (a) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) Government may, by notification, levy lump-sum entertainment duty of amusement park at a rate not exceeding rupees sixty thousand per annum.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2323State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
(b) A proprietor may, however, opt to pay an entertainment duty either under sub-section (1)
or he may pay lump-sum entertainment duty under the proceeding clause (a).
(2) A draft of the proposed order specifying the rate of entertainments duty referred to in subsection (1) shall be notified for the information of all persons likely to be affected thereby and it shall take effect only after the Government has considered all objections received within a period of thirty days from the date of such publications, and has notified the same again, with or without modification:
Provided that if the Government consider that such an order should be brought into force at once, the final notification may issue without previous publication:
Provided further that Government may impose an entertainments duty on complimentary tickets at a different from that imposed on other kinds of payment for admission subject to the maximum specified in sub-section (1).
(3) Until such time as the duty referred to in sub-sections (1) and (2) has been finally notified, the entertainments duty shall be levied at the rates in force in this behalf immediately before the commencement of this Act.
(3-A) Notwithstanding anything in this section, the amount of duty shall be calculated to the nearest multiple of 5 naye paise by ignoring 2 naye paise or less and counting more than 2 naye paise as 5 naye paise.
(4) The final notification specifying the rates of entertainment duty shall be laid before the Legislature at the session immediately following its publication.
2324 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 3.A. Entertainment duty is not leviable in case tax is paid under Punjab Act 8 of 1954.- Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, no entertainment duty shall be leviable on the proprietor who is able to pay entertainment tax under the Punjab Entertainment Tax (Cinematograph Shows) Act, 1954.
(3B) Notwithstanding anything contained in subsections (l), (1-A), (2) and (3), in the case of entertainment provided with the aid of antenna or cable television to a connection holder, the proprietor of such entertainment shall pay entertainment duty of fifteen thousand rupees per annum at a time.
(3C) Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, in the case of entertainment, provided with the aid of dish, relating to direct-to-home television, the proprietor of such entertainment shall pay entertainment duty at the rate of ten per cent of the charges, received by such proprietor from the subscriber. The entertainment duty shall be paid by the proprietor by the 10 th day, commencing from the close of the concerned calendar month.”
Rajasthan Entertainments and Advertisements Tax Act, 1957:
(h) The relevant provisions of the Rajasthan Entertainments and Advertisements Tax Act, 1957 are as under:
“3. Definitions. – In this Act, unless the subject or context otherwise requires,xxx (4A).- “direct to home broadcasting service”
means distribution of multi channel television programmes by using satellite system by providing television signals direct to the premises of subscribers without passing through an intermediary such as cable services.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2325State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others (4AAA.)- “levy of tax on direct to home broadcasting service”- The proprietor of a direct to home broadcasting service shall be liable to pay entertainment tax at such rates, not exceeding twenty percent of the monthly subscription charges per subscriber, as the State Government may from time to time, notify in the Official Gazette, in this behalf and different may be notified for different categories of subscribers
(5) “entertainment” includes –
(i) any exhibition, (show), performance, amusement, game or sport to which persons are admitted for payment.
(ii) providing cable service to a subscriber.
(iii) providing direct to home broadcasting service and,
(6) “entertainment tax” means the tax levied and charged under section 4, 4AA and 4AAA and the expression 4AA shall be deemed to have been inserted with effect from 26.03.1999 and the expression 4AAA shall be deemed to have been inserted with effect from 25.02.2008 and includes the additional tax payable under section 6A, xxx
(8) “proprietor” in relation to an entertainment includes any person responsible for, or for the time being in-charge of the management thereof;
xxx (11A) “subscriber” means a person who receives the signals of cable television network at a place indicated by him to the proprietor of the cable television network without further transmitting it to any other person;
2326 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Explanation : In case of hotels each room or premises where facility for receiving signals of cable television network have been attached shall be treated as a subscriber.”
The relevant provisions of the Rajasthan Entertainments and Advertisements Tax Rules, 1957 are as under “Rules 18BBBB.- Permission to be obtained to operate direct to home broadcasting service.
(1) the proprietor of a direct to home broadcasting service shall submit to the Commissioner an application within fifteen days from the date on which these rules come into force or at least within fifteen days of his commencing entertainment through direct to home broadcasting service, whichever is later.
(2) the proprietor shall submit to the Commissioner a security of an amount fixed by the Commissioner along with any other information which may be so required by the Commissioner.
Rules 18BBBBB.- Payment of tax for direct to home broadcasting service.
(1) The proprietor of a direct to home broadcasting service liable to pay tax in accordance with section 4AAA of the Act, shall maintain a true and correct record of the number of subscribers, the amount received from each subscriber and the amount of tax.
(2) The proprietor of a Direct to Home broadcasting service shall be required to deposit tax payable within seven days of the close of each calendar month.
(3) The proprietor of a Direct to Home broadcasting service shall file quarterly return in Form S-7 in duplicate, within fifteen days [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2327State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others of the end of each quarter along with proof of deposit of tax payable under the Act.”
Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939:
(i) The relevant provisions of the Tamil Nadu Entertainments Tax Act, 1939 are as under:
“3. Definitions: In this Act, unless there is anything repugnant in the subject or context :
xxx (3B) “direct to home service” means distribution of multi-channel television programmes by using a satellite system by providing television signals direct to subscribers’ premises without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator;
xxx 3(4) “entertainment” means a horse race or cinematograph exhibition to which persons are admitted on payment; or television exhibition for which persons are required to make payment by way of contribution, or subscription, or installation or connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever or an amusement or a recreation parlour where a game such as bowling, billiards, snooker or the like is provided or direct to home service or a cricket tournament conducted by the Indian Premier League.
xxx 3(9) “proprietor” in relation to any entertainment means a licensee of Cinematograph exhibition under the Tamil Nadu Cinemas (Regulation)
Act, 1995 (Tamil Nadu Act No.IX of 1955) or the licensee of an Exhibition of Cinematograph film on Television Screen through Video Cassette Recorder or through Cable Television Network under the Tamil Nadu Exhibition of Films on 2328 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Television Screen through Video Cassette Recorders and cable Television Network (Regulation) Act, 1984 (Tamil Nadu Act No.
VII of 1984) or any person providing Television exhibition or any person providing amusement or any person providing recreation parlour or any person providing direct to home service or the Indian Premier League and includes the State Government, any local authority or any person responsible for the management thereof.
xxx 3(11) “Television exhibition” means an exhibition with the aid of any type of antenna with a cable network attached to it or a cable television, of a film or moving picture or series of moving pictures, by means of transmission of television signals by wire where subscribers’ television sets at residential or non-residential place are linked by metallic coaxial cable or optic fibre cable to a central system called the head-end.
xxx 4-I. Tax on direct to home service.—(1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in Sections 4 and 7, there shall be levied and paid to the State Government a tax (hereinafter referred to as the “entertainment tax”) calculated at the rate of thirty per cent of the gross charges excluding the service tax, received by the provider of a direct to home service.
(2) The tax levied under sub-section (1) shall be recoverable from the proprietor.
(3) The provisions of this Act (other than Sections 4, 7 and 13) and the rules made thereunder shall, so far as may be, apply in relations to the tax payable under sub-section (1).
xxx [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2329State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others 4-E. Tax on television exhibition.- (1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in Sections 4 and 7, there shall be levied and paid to the State Government a tax (hereinafter referred to as the entertainment tax) on television exhibition at the following rates namely:- (i)
Within the limits of the Municipal Corporation of Chennai, Madurai, Coimbatore, Tiruchirapalli, Tirunelveli, Salem or any other Corporation that may be constituted under any law for the time being in force;
Six thousand rupees per month.
(ii)
Within the limits of the Municipalities constituted under the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920 (Tamil Nadu Act No. V of 1920)
Three thousand rupees per month (iii)
Within the limits of Town Panchayats constituted under the Tamil Nadu District Municipalities Act, 1920 (Tamil Nadu Act No. V of 1920)
or any other area not specified in items (i), (ii), or (iv)
One thousand and five hundred rupees per month (iv)
Within the limits of Village Panchayats constituted under the Tamil Nadu Panchayats Act, 1994 (Tamil Nadu Act No. 21 of 1994).
One thousand rupees per month.
(2) The tax levied under sub-section (1) shall be recoverable from the proprietor.
2330 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(3) The provisions of this Act other than Sections 4, 4-B, 4-D, 4-F, 4-G, 5-F, 5-G, 6(1), 7 and 13 and the rules made there under shall, so far as may be, apply in relation to the tax payable under sub- section (1).
Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979:
(j) The relevant provisions of Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979 as amended by Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax (Amendment)
Ordinance, 2009 are as under:
“2. Definitions.- In this Act-
(a) ‘admission to an entertainment’ includes admission to any place which the entertainment is held or any place wherefrom entertainment is provided by means of the cable television network of Direct to Home service or any other emerging transmission by whatever name called.”
(a-1) ‘amusement park’ mean a place wherein various type of amusements, which includes games or rides or water sports, water park, splash pool etc. but does not include exhibition by means of cinematograph and video, are provided on payment of admission.”
xxx
(ee) ‘cable operator’ means any person who provides cable service through a cable television network or otherwise controls or is responsible for the management and operation of cable television network and includes the proprietor of a hotel who provides cable service in the hotel through his own cable television network”;
xxx (f-1) ‘Direct-to-Home service’ means a system of distribution of multi-channel television [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2331State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others programmes in Ku band by using a satellite system, by providing television signals direct to the subscriber’s premises without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator.”
(g) ‘entertainment’ includes any exhibition, performance, amusement, game, sport or race (including horse rase) to which persons are admitted for payment and in the case of cinematograph exhibition, includes exhibition of news-real, documentaries, cartoons, advertisement shorts or slides, whether before or during the exhibition of a feature film or separately,; It also includes any activity notified as entertainment by the State Government from time to time.”
xxx (i-1) ‘Ku Band’ ordinarily means the 11.7 to 12.7 Gigahertz frequency band which splits into two segments namely Fix Satellite Service having the frequency of the 11.7 to 12.2 Gigahertz and Broadcasting Satellite service having the frequency of 12.2 to 12.7 Gigahertz, or any other band of width as may be approved by the Government of India and from time to time.”
xxx (k.1) “Multi System Operator” means a cable operator who receives a programming service from a broadcaster or his authorized agencies and retransmits the same or transmits his own programming service for simultaneous reception either by multiple subscribers directly or through one or more local cable operators, and includes his authorized distribution agencies by whatever name called.
(l) ‘payment for admission’ includes- 2332 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(i) a n y p a y m e n t f o r s e a t s o r o t h e r accommodation in any form in a place of entertainment;
(ii) any payment for a programme or synopsis of an entertainment;
(iii) any payment made for the loan or use of any instrument or contrivance which enables a person to get a normal or better view of hearing or enjoyment of the entertainment, which without the aid of such instrument or contrivance such person would not get;
(iv) any payment, by whatever name called or any purposes whatsoever, connect with an entertainment, which a person is required to make in any form as a condition of attending or continuing to attend the entertainment, either in addition to payment, if any, entertainment or without any such payment for admission.
(v) any payment made by a person, who having been admitted to one part of a place of entertainment is subsequently admitted to another part thereof, for admission to which a payment involving tax or more tax is required.
Explanation.-Any subscription raise or donation collected in connection with an entertainment in any form shall be deemed to be payment for admission;
(vi) Any payment made by a person by way of contribution or subscription or installation and connection charges or any other charges collected in any manner whatsoever, by whatever name called, for television exhibition through cable television network or any other such [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2333State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others network by whatever name called, attached to television set or any other device at a residential or non-residential place of a connection holder; or
(vii) Any payment made by person to the proprietor of a Direct-to-Home service or any other service by whatever name called, by way of contribution or subscription or installation and connection charges or any charges collected in any manner by whatever name called either directly or through any agency established for the purpose for Direct-to-Home service with the aid of set top box or any other device of like nature which connects television set or any other device at a residential or non-residential place of a connection holder directly to the satellite without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator;
Explanation-For the purposes of sub-clauses
(vi) and (vii) any expenditure incurred by any co-operative society including a co-operative housing society or by the management of any factory, hotel, lodge, bar, permit room, pub or by a person or group of persons for the purchase of any type of antenna or any other apparatus for securing transmission through cable television network, Direct-to-Home service or any other service by whatever name called, for its member or for workers or customers or for himself or themselves, as the case may be shall be deemed to be payment made under the sub-clause;
(viii) Where in any entertainment admission has been allowed on a gross payment, such gross payment shall be deemed to be aggregate payment”.
2334 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports (l-l) ‘Place of entertainment includes-
(i) a house, building, tent, site to be used for purpose of cinema building or other structure and description of transport whatsoever;
(ii) any addition to the place of entertainment;
(iii) a house building, tent or any other place where the books of account, ticket books or any other relevant records pertaining to the entertainment or pertaining to the management of providing cable service or Direct-to-Home service or Broadband service or any emerging transmission services, by whatever name called, are kept or purported to have been kept;.
xxx
(m) ‘proprietor’ in relation to any entertainment includes any person-
(i) connected with the organisation of the entertainment, or
(ii) charged with the work of admission to the entertainment, or
(iii) responsible for, or for the time being incharge of the management thereof, or
(iv) any cable operator registered under Section 4 of the Cable Television Network (Regulation) Act, 1995 (Act No. 7 of 1995) or any person responsible for or for time being in charge of management of providing cable connection through cable television network or any other emerging technology; or
(v) any company registered under the Company Act, 1956 having license to provide Directto-Home service or any other emerging [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2335State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others transmission services by whatever name called by the Government of India under Section 4 of the Telegraph Act, 1985 and the Indian Wireless Telegraph Act, 1933 or any agent thereof appointed for the purpose of sale, letting on rent or distribution of equipment related thereto;”.
xxx (p-1) television signal receiver’ means any device, by whatever name called, used to receive and/or decode the transmission programme of particular channel and without which no person is able to see a particular channel programme.”
(p-2) ‘television signal receiver agency’ means a place of entertainment by whatever name called, where business of selling or letting on hire or distribution or exchange or putting into circulation in any manner whatsoever of television signal receiver.”.
xxx
(t) Words and expressions used in this Act but not defined, shall have the meaning respectively assigned to them in the Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1952.
(u) Words and expression used in this Act not defined, shall have the same meaning as respectively assigned to them in the Uttar Pradesh Cinema (Regulation) Act, 1955 or the rules made thereunder and the Cable Television Network (Regulation) Act, 1995 and the rules made thereunder.
3. Tax on entertainment. - (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act, there shall be levied and paid on all Aggregate payments required for admission to any entertainment other than an entertainment to which Section 4 or Section 2336 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 4-A or Section 4-B applies or a compounded payment is made under the proviso to this sub-section an entertainment tax at such rate not exceeding one hundred and fifty per cent of each such payments as the State Government may form time to time notify in this behalf, and the tax shall be collected by the proprietor from the person making the payment for admission and paid to the Government in the manner prescribed.
Provided that a proprietor of a cinema or cable operator in a local area having a population not exceeding one lac. may, in lieu of payment under this sub-section, pay a compounded payment to the State Government on such conditions and in such manner as may be prescribed and at such rate as the State Government may from time to time notify, and different rates of compounded payments may be notified for different categories of local areas.
Provided further that in the case of cable service, the proprietor of the cable service control room/ multi system operator shall be liable to pay the tax irrespective of the fact whether he collect it directly from the person making the payment for admission or indirectly through an associate or franchise cable operator or an agent, who in turn collects it from the person making the payment:
Provided also that a proprietor of a cinema, in lieu of payment under this sub-section, shall make a lump sum payment to the State Government on such conditions and restrictions and in such manner as may be prescribed and at such rate as the State Government may from time to time notify, and different rates of lump sum payments may be notified for different categories of local areas or cinemas or for different payment for admission.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2337State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others
(2) Nothing in sub-section (1) shall preclude the State Government form notifying different rate of entertainment tax for different areas or for different classes of entertainment or for different Aggregate payment required for admission to entertainment.
(2-a) It shall be lawful for the State Government to notify lump sum rate of entertainment tax for any entertainment or class of entertainments or for different payment for admission to entertainment or for different area;
(3) Where the aggregate payment required for admission to an entertainment together with any other charge leviable under this Act, is not a multiple of one rupee then notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in sub-section
(1) or sub-section (2) or any notification issued thereunder, the tax shall be increase to such extent and be so computed that the aggregate of such aggregate payment and other charges is rounded off to the next higher multiply of one rupee and such increased tax shall also be collected by the proprietor and paid to the State Government in such manner as may be prescribed,
(4) If in any entertainment, referred to in subsection (1), to which admission is generally on payment, any person is admitted free of charge or on a concessional rate, the same amount of tax shall be payable as would have been payable had such person been admitted on full payment.
(5) Where the Aggregate payment required for admission to an entertainment, referred to in sub-section (1), is made wholly or partly, by means of a lump sum paid as subscription, contribution, donation or otherwise, the tax shall be paid on the amount of such lump sum and 2338 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports on the amount of Aggregate payment required for admission if any made otherwise.
(6) Where in hotel or a restaurant, entertainment by way of cabaret or floor show (by whatever name called, by excluding a mere band in attendance or recorded music) is provided alongwith any meal or refreshment with a view to attracting customers, whether or not Aggregate payment required for admission is charged distinctly for such entertainment, Thirty per cent of the amount payable by the customer such meal or refreshment or the amount charge distinctly for such entertainment, whichever is higher, shall be deemed to be the Aggregate payment required for admission to such entertainment and the tax shall be levied and pain accordingly.
(7) Where in a hotel, entertainment by way of cable service is provided in rooms or other places, the entertainment so provided in each room or other place shall be deemed to be a separate entertainment and the subscription for admission to each such entertainment shall be deemed to be equal to the amount of subscription charged from a subscriber in the vicinity of the hotel by the cable operator providing cable service in the hotel, and the tax shall be levied and paid on the basis of such subscription:
Provided that where the cable operator himself is the proprietor of the hotel, the subscription for admission to each such entertainment shall be deemed to be equal to the amount of subscription charged from a subscriber in the vicinity of the hotel by any other cable operator. Explanation.- (1) For the purposes of this subsection and clause (ee) of Section 2, ‘hotel’ includes an accommodational unit wherein [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2339State of Kerala & Another v.
Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. & Others rooms are provided to the customers on rent, but does not include the units approved under the ‘Paying Guest Scheme’ of the Department of Tourism of the State Government.
Explanation - (2) For the purposes of this Act, the expression aggregate payment shall mean a sum paid by a person for admission to the entertainment which shall include entertainment tax and other amount required to be paid under this Act but does not include any fee or other charges which is not a part of entertainment tax under this Act.”
The State Legislature of Uttarakhand amended the Uttar Pradesh Entertainment and Betting Tax Act, 1979 (as applicable to the State of Uttarakhand) by Act No.4 of 2009 notified on 16.03.2009 which are as under:
“Section 2 – Definitions.– xxx
(ff) “Direct-to-Home (DTH) Broadcasting” a service for multichannel distribution programmes direct to subscriber’s premises without passing through an intermediary such as cable operator by uplinking to a satellite system. Section 2(g) has been amended as under –
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.