A. Raja v. D. Kumar
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 629; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1809
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Justice Augustine George Masih
- Decided
- 6 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2758/2023
- Sections
- 116, 100(1), 98, 99, 81, 100, 101, 10, 4, 106, 114, 6
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1809 : 2025 INSC 629 A. Raja v.
D. Kumar (Civil Appeal No. 2758 of 2023)
06 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka, Ahsanuddin Amanullah* and Augustine George Masih, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Appellant belongs to the Hindu Parayan caste in the State of Kerala and is covered by the 1950 Order insofar as it relates to the State of Kerala; whether the Appellant had still retained the Hindu Parayan caste, as a member of the Hindu religion, when he contested from the Devikulam Assembly Constituency for Legislative Assembly of Kerala.
Headnotes† Representation of the People Act, 1951 – s.116-A and s.100(1)(a) and (d)(i) – Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950 – Part VIII of the Schedule – Validity of election – Appellant filed his nomination papers declaring therein that he belongs to the Hindu Parayan caste as per Caste Certificate from a Constituency reserved for the Scheduled Castes – Appellant was elected – Election of the Appellant was challenged – The ground of challenge laid therein was that the Appellant’s paternal grandparents had migrated from Tamil Nadu to Kerala and since the Appellant’s grandparents on the paternal side were persons who had migrated from Tamil Nadu, they and their successors were not entitled to claim that they belonged to ‘Hindu Parayan’ of Kerala State – Further, it was contended that the Appellant was a Christian and not entitled to contest from a Constituency reserved for the Scheduled Castes – High Court declared the election of the Appellant void – Correctness: Held: The twin conditions needing to be satisfied would be (i) being of the Hindu Parayan caste, and; (ii) being, himself/herself or through one’s ancestors, permanent resident of the State of Kerala as on the date of the 1950 Order – Upon fulfilment of both these conditions, a person can claim a legal right to derive any benefits * Author 1810 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports available to Hindu Parayan caste in the State of Kerala – In the instant case, fulfilment of the same would enable the Appellant to become eligible to contest from the Constituency reserved for the Scheduled Castes – There is no dispute on the factum that, originally, the grandparents of the Appellant belonged to the Hindu Parayan caste in the erstwhile State of Travancore-Cochin having migrated from the State of Tamil Nadu but prior to 1950 – In this regard, there is sufficient evidence available on the record – As far as contention that appellant is Christian is concerned, mere observance/performance of a ritual of/associated with any religion does not ipso facto and necessarily mean that the person ‘professes’ that religion – That is why the term used in the 1950 Order is ‘professes’, signifying that a person although born in a particular religion can profess another religion, inter alia, by practicing the rituals of that other religion as the basic tenets of his beliefs and lifestyle – Adherence merely to some ritual of another religion would not tantamount to giving-up the original religion, unless the person concerned makes such belief explicit – From the evidence available, it is not possible to hold that the Appellant ‘professes’ Christianity – The evidence adduced from the side of the Appellant would reveal that the Caste Certificate(s) issued in his favour by the Competent Authority till date hold the field – The Appellant’s Caste Certificate has not been interfered with, either by the Impugned Judgment or by the authority(ies) concerned – High Court erred by shifting the burden of proof on the Appellant to prove in the negative the allegations – Further, even the entries in the Register are not conclusively established in the sense that they relate to the Appellant or his family members – Apropos this, the High Court has noticed many over-writings, edits and deletions re the purported names of the Appellant and his parents as alleged to have appeared in the Register – This has prompted the High Court to note that ‘fabrication and correction’ were made to the entry(ies) in the Register(s) – The High Court, on the whole, accepted whatever was presented by the Respondent and in such approach, disregarded and ignored the material lacuna in the pleadings of the Election Petition as also the evidence brought in by the Respondent – Election Petitioner is obligated to plead and prove his case beyond reasonable doubt – Appellant retained the Hindu Parayan caste, as a member of the Hindu religion, when he contested from the constituency – Impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside – Election petition dismissed – Appellant entitled to all consequential benefits as a Member of the Legislative Assembly. [Paras 30, 34, 36, 50, 57, 58, 59] [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1811A. Raja v. D. Kumar Election Laws – Challenge to the caste certificate in election petition – Position of law:
Held: A duly issued Caste/Community Certificate would be amenable to challenge only under the provisions of the statute concerned, and not in an Election Petition – In case no statute governing the field in a State/Union Territory is operative, the Madhuri Patil guidelines, as modified in Dayaram, shall be followed. [Para 64] Case Law Cited Action Committee on Issue of Caste Certificate to SCs/STs v. Union of India [1994] Supp. 1 SCR 714 : (1994) 5 SCC 244; Punjabrao v. D. P. Meshram [1965] 1 SCR 849 : 1964 SCC OnLine SC 76; Amar Chandra Chakraborty v. Collector of Excise, Govt. of Tripura [1973] 1 SCR 533 : (1972) 2 SCC 442; Supreme Court Bar Assn. v. Union of India [1998] 2 SCR 795 : (1998) 4 SCC 409; State of A.P. v. Abdul Khader [1962] 1 SCR 737 : 1961 SCC OnLine SC 149; Ghaurul Hasan v. State of Rajasthan [1962] 1 SCR 772 : 1961 SCC OnLine SC 3; Akbar Khan Alam Khan v. Union of India [1962] 1 SCR 779 : 1961 SCC OnLine SC 4 – followed.
M. Chandra v. M. Thangamuthu [2010] 11 SCR 38 : (2010) 9 SCC 712; J.Chandrasekhara Rao v. V. Jagapathi Rao [1992] Supp. 3 SCR 786 : (1993) Supp. 2 SCC 229 – relied on.
Puducherry SC People Welfare Assn. v. UT of Pondicherry [2014] 13 SCR 1087 : (2014) 9 SCC 236; Gajanan Krishnaji Bapat v. Dattaji Raghobaji Meghe [1995] Supp. 2 SCR 186 : (1995) 5 SCC 347; Kalyan Singh Chouhan v. C. P. Joshi [2011] 2 SCR 216 : (2011) 11 SCC 786; Goka Ramalingam v. Boddu Abraham [1969] 2 SCR 992 : (1969) 1 SCC 24; Virender Nath Gautam v. Satpal Singh [2006] Supp. 10 SCR 413 : (2007) 3 SCC 617; Hari Shanker Jain v. Sonia Gandhi [2001] Supp. 3 SCR 38 : (2001) 8 SCC 233; Punit Rai v. Dinesh Chaudhary [2003] Supp. 2 SCR 743 : (2003) 8 SCC 204; K. P. Manu v. Scrutiny Committee for Verification of Community Certificate [2015] 3 SCR 243 : (2015) 4 SCC 1; Madhuri Patil v. Commr., Tribal Development [1994] Supp. 3 SCR 50 : (1994) 6 SCC 241; Dayaram v. Sudhir Batham [2011] 15 SCR 1092 : (2012) 1 SCC 333; Food Corporation of India v. Jagdish Balaram Bahira [2017] 11 SCR 271 : (2017) 8 SCC 670; Maharashtra Adiwasi Thakur Jamat Swarakshan Samiti v. State of Maharashtra [2023] 3 SCR 1100 : (2023) 16 SCC 415; Poppatlal Shah v. State of Madras [1953] 1 SCR 677 : (1953) 1 1812 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports SCC 492; B. Premanand v. Mohan Koikal [2011] 3 SCR 932 : (2011) 4 SCC 266; Mukund Dewangan v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. [2017] 7 SCR 765 : (2017) 14 SCC 663; DDA v. Virender Lal Bahri [2019] 4 SCR 469 : (2020) 15 SCC 328; State of Bombay v. Hospital Mazdoor Sabha [1960] 2 SCR 866 : 1960 SCC OnLine SC 44; U.P.SEB v. Hari Shankar Jain [1979] 1 SCR 355 : (1978) 4 SCC 16; Rohit Pulp and Paper Mills Limited v. CCE [1990] 2 SCR 797 : (1990) 3 SCC 447; Sobha Hymavathi Devi v. Setti Gangadhara Swamy [2005] 1 SCR 848 : (2005) 2 SCC 244;
Municipal Corpn. of Delhi v. Gurnam Kaur [1988] Supp. 2 SCR 929 : (1989) 1 SCC 101; State of U.P. v. Synthetics and Chemicals Ltd. [1991] 3 SCR 64 : (1991) 4 SCC 139; A-One Granites v. State of U.P. [2001] 1 SCR 1085 : (2001) 3 SCC 537; Bhagwati Prasad Dixit v. Rajeev Gandhi [1986] 2 SCR 823 : (1986) 4 SCC 78; Lillykutty v. Scrutiny Committee, SC & ST [2005] Supp. 4 SCR 87 : (2005) 8 SCC 283; Union Territory of Ladakh v. Jammu and Kashmir National Conference [2023] 12 SCR 68 : 2023 INSC 804 – referred to.
Sapna Jacob v. State of Kerala, 1992 SCC OnLine Ker 233 – referred to.
List of Acts Representation of the People Act, 1951; Schedule to the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950; Kerala (Schedule Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificates Act, 1996; Evidence Act, 1872; Constitution of India; Kerala (Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificates Rules, 2002; States Reorganization Act, 1956; Citizenship Act, 1955.
List of Keywords Hindu Parayan caste; Election; Constituency reserved for the Scheduled Castes; Nomination papers; Scheduled Caste; Part VIII of the Schedule to the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950; Baptized; Ancestors permanent resident of the State of Kerala; Mere observance/performance of a ritual; Professes; Born in a particular religion can profess another religion; Christianity; Caste Certificate; Shifting the burden of proof; Overwritings, edits and deletions in Register; Fabrication and correction; Plead and prove beyond reasonable doubt.; Election petition.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1813A. Raja v. D. Kumar Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2758 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.03.2023 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in EP No. 11 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
V. Giri, T. Krishnanunni, N Raghuraj, Sr. Advs., Prakash, Joice George, Mrs. Beena Prakash, Jishnu M L, Mrs. Priyanka Prakash, Anoop R, Rahul Narang.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Narendra Hooda, Sr. Adv., Aljo K. Joseph, Anurag Kumar, Ms. Meenakshi, Vinay Kumar Puvvala, Dushyant Chaudhary, Santosh Kumar Kolkonda, Abhinav P Dhanodkar, Saket Jee, Ranjan Kumar.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.
This is an appeal preferred under Section 116-A1 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’) against the Final Judgment and Order dated 20.03.2023 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Impugned Judgment’) 2 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam (hereinafter referred to as the ‘High Court’), in Election Petition No.11 of 2021 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Election Petition’), filed by the Respondent (hereinafter also referred to as the ‘Election Petitioner’), declaring the election of the Appellant to the Legislative Assembly of Kerala from the Devikulam 1 ‘116-A. Appeals to Supreme Court.—(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, an appeal shall lie to the Supreme Court on any question (whether of law or fact) from every order made by a High Court under Section 98 or Section 99.
(2) Every appeal under this Chapter shall be preferred within a period of thirty days from the date of the order of the High Court under Section 98 or Section 99: Provided that the Supreme Court may entertain an appeal after the expiry of the said period of thirty days if it is satisfied that the appellant had sufficient cause for not preferring the appeal within such period.’ 2 2023:KER:16955; 2023 SCC OnLine Ker 1643; (2023) 2 KLT 716; (2023) 2 KLJ 1. 1814 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Legislative Assembly Constituency 088 in Idukki District, Kerala, which is reserved for the Scheduled Castes, as void under Section 100(1)(a) and (d)(i) 3 of the Act.
FACTUAL PRISM:
2. General Elections to the Devikulam Assembly Constituency for membership of the Legislative Assembly of Kerala were to be conducted in 2021. The Appellant filed his nomination papers before the Returning Officer on 17.03.2021 declaring therein that he belongs to the Hindu Parayan caste as per Caste Certificate dated 09.03.2021 issued by the Tehsildar, Devikulam. The said caste has been declared as a Scheduled Caste in relation to the State of Kerala in Part VIII of the Schedule to the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘1950 Order’) issued on 10.08.1950 by Hon’ble the President of India. Oral objections before the Returning Officer were raised by the Respondent contending that the Appellant was not a member of the Scheduled Castes from Kerala and instead, he was a Christian. The Returning Officer, after examining the nomination papers of the Appellant rejected the objections and accepted the nomination papers. Polling in the Constituency took place on 06.04.2021 and after counting, the result of the election was declared on 02.05.2021. The Appellant secured 59,049 votes and was declared elected by a margin of 7848 votes over the Respondentdefeated candidate who had secured 51,201 votes.
3. The election of the Appellant was challenged by the Respondent in Election Petition No.11 of 2021 before the High Court. The 3 ‘100. Grounds for declaring election to be void.—(1) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (2) if the High Court is of opinion—
(a) that on the date of his election a returned candidate was not qualified, or was disqualified, to be chosen to fill the seat under the Constitution or this Act or the Government of Union Territories Act, 1963 (20 of 1963); or
(b) …
(c) …
(d) that the result of the election, in so far as it concerns a returned candidate, has been materially affected—
(i) by the improper acceptance of any nomination, or
(ii) …
(iii) …
(iv) … the High Court shall declare the election of the returned candidate to be void.’ [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1815A. Raja v. D. Kumar ground of challenge laid therein was that the Appellant’s paternal grandparents had migrated from Tamil Nadu to Kerala in 1951. They were of the ‘Hindu Parayan’ caste in the State of Tamil Nadu. ‘Parayan’ is included in the list of Scheduled Castes of both States viz. Tamil Nadu and Kerala in the 1950 Order, as originally brought into force. Since the Appellant’s grandparents on the paternal side were persons who had migrated from Tamil Nadu, they and their successors were not entitled to claim that they belonged to ‘Hindu Parayan’ of Kerala State. It was averred that hence, the Appellant is not entitled to contest from a Constituency reserved for candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes from Kerala. The Appellant was born on 17.10.1984 to Mr Antony and Mrs Esther. Mr Antony and Ms Esther, it was asserted, were Christians baptized by the CSI’s 4 Church in Kundala Estate by a pastor named Ebenezer Mani in the year 1982. The Appellant, born in 1984, also was baptized by the said Ebenezer Mani. Thus, the Appellant was a Christian and not entitled to contest from a Constituency reserved for the Scheduled Castes.
4. The High Court took up the Election Petition. It framed issues, examined witnesses, admitted documents and on consideration of the oral testimony and documentary evidence in trial proceeded to declare the election of the Appellant void, by way of the Impugned Judgment. The issues remaining 5 before the High Court and decided through the Impugned Judgment are as under:
‘(I) Whether the returned candidate is a person belonging to Scheduled Caste among Hindus in the State of Kerala? (II) Whether the acceptance of nomination of returned candidate is proper?
(III) Whether the election of returned candidate is liable to be set aside?
(IV) Reliefs and cost.’ 4 Church of South India.
5 By its Order dated 10.03.2022, the High Court had already rejected the Appellant’s contentions that
(a) the Election Petition was liable to be dismissed at the threshold under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for want of cause of action, and; (b) the Election Petition was barred by limitation.
1816 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. This Court granted a conditional stay of the Impugned Judgment by Order dated 28.04.2023 6 , which was continued on different dates subsequently. Vide Order dated 15.05.2024, this Court directed that the interim relief would ‘… continue till the final disposal of this Appeal.’ APPELLANT’S SUBMISSIONS:
6. Learned senior counsel Mr. V. Giri, for the Appellant, submitted that the paternal grandparents of the Appellant started residing in the erstwhile State of Travancore (which subsequently became part of the State of Kerala) much prior to 1950 and that the paternal grandmother and grandfather of the Appellant came to Kundala Estate in Munnar with their respective families in 1940s before their marriage and both families started residing in Munnar. From then onwards, both families have been residents of Munnar. Antony, the Appellant’s father, was born in 1952 at Kundala Estate, Devikulam, Munnar. It was submitted that the Appellant’s paternal grandmother was an employee of Kannan Devan Hills Plantation in Munnar in the year 1949, as per Certificate dated 17.11.2021 issued by the Deputy General Manager, Kannan Devan Hills Plantation at Munnar.
7. Further, learned senior counsel submitted that the burden to prove that the Appellant’s family had migrated to Travancore only after 1950 is entirely upon the Election Petitioner and relied on paragraph no.82 of M. Chandra v M. Thangamuthu, (2010) 9 SCC 712, where this Court held that the burden of proof is on the Election Petitioner to prove the charges he alleges beyond reasonable doubt.
8. It was canvassed that the High Court took the view that even though the ancestors of the Appellant started residing in Travancore before 1950, their residence in Travancore can be only for the purpose of employment and they cannot be treated as permanent residents. 6 ‘… Till the next date of hearing, there shall be a conditional stay of the impugned judgment and order to the following extent:
(i) The appellant shall be entitled to participate in the proceedings of the Legislative Assembly;
(ii) The appellant shall, however, not be entitled to vote on any motion in the Legislative Assembly. He shall also not be entitled to vote in his capacity as a Member of the Legislative Assembly on any other matter;
(iii) The appellant shall not be entitled to receive any allowance or monetary benefits in any other form which is admissible to a Member of the Legislative Assembly. …’ [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1817A. Raja v. D. Kumar This finding is assailed on the ground that this was neither pleaded, nor proved by the respondent.
9. It was further canvassed that the 1950 Order was subsequently amended in 1956 pursuant to the passing of the States Re-organization Act, 1956. As per the direction in the States Re-Organization Act, 1956 amendments were brought about to the 1950 Order in 1956 by the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘1956 Order’). The date on which the residence of the Appellant’s grandparents changed to the State of Kerala on 01.11.1956, being the date when the then State of Travancore became part of the State of Kerala. It was the case in the Election Petition that the grandparents of the Appellant migrated to Kerala in 1951. If that be so, the Appellant’s grandparents would be, without any doubt, ‘Hindu Parayan’ of Kerala in 1956 as the State of Kerala, upon merger, was formed on 01.11.1956. The 1950 Order was again amended in 1976 by the Parliament and the date on which the ‘residence’ is to be reckoned shifted to 01.05.1976. Even in the Impugned Judgment, the High Court finds that the family of the Appellant started permanently residing in Kerala from 1970. In that case also, it was urged, the Appellant is to be treated as a ‘Hindu Parayan’ of Kerala.
10. Learned senior counsel relied on paragraph no.13 of Puducherry SC People Welfare Assn. v UT of Pondicherry, (2014) 9 SCC 236 which states ‘ … Once Presidential Order has been issued under Article 341(1) or Article 342(1), any amendment in the Presidential Order can only be made by Parliament by law as provided in Article 341(2) or Article 342(2), as the case may be, and in no other manner. The interpretation of “resident” in the Presidential Order as “of origin” amounts to altering the Presidential Order.’ It was stated that the term ‘resident’ therefore, assumes importance in the context. The evidence on record would show that the ancestors of the Appellant were residents of Kundala Estate in Munnar, a part of the erstwhile Travancore, before 10.08.1950, the date on which the 1950 Order came into force.
11. It was also argued that the High Court went beyond the pleadings of the parties and the evidence adduced and made out a third case, taking a view that even though the Appellant’s ancestors started residing in Travancore before 1950, their residence in Travancore 1818 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports can be only for the purpose of employment and they cannot be treated as permanent residents. Such case was neither pleaded, nor proved by the respondent. Even when the Appellant was examined as RW2, not even a single suggestion was put to him in this regard.
12. Learned senior counsel also contended that there was no challenge to the Caste Certificate issued in the Appellant’s favour. If the Respondent’s case is that the Appellant’s Caste Certificate is not properly issued, it is for him to prove that the Caste Certificate issued is invalid and improper. Reliance in this context was placed on paragraph no.85 of M. Chandra (supra), where it was observed: ‘There is nothing on record to show that the community certificate was issued illegally or in contravention of the valid procedure. The election petitioner should have examined the person in charge while the certificate was being issued to bring to light to alleged malpractice in issuance of the said Certificate. The validity of the issuance of the community certificate is presumed unless shown otherwise by Respondent 1, who clearly failed to do so. …’ 7 Hence, in the case at hand, the Respondent, who has not objected to acceptance of the Caste Certificate by the Returning Officer, though he makes a vague averment that he had orally objected to the acceptance of the Caste Certificate, which is disputed as being factually incorrect, has not chosen to examine either the Competent Authority, which issued the Caste Certificate, nor has he examined the Returning Officer to prove otherwise.
13. It was contended that the case of the Respondent is that in the year 1982, Pastor Ebenezer Mani baptized the father and mother of the Appellant in CSI Church and thus, they became Christians in 1982. Thereafter in 1984, the Appellant was born and the Respondent alleges that the Appellant was also baptized by the said Ebenezer Mani. Ebenezer Mani was examined as PW8, as a witness of the Respondent, and deposed that he was born in 1968, which means that he was only about 14 years of age in 1982, the year when he, according to the Respondent, had allegedly baptized the parents of the Appellant. He further deposed that he became an Evangelist at the age of 24 and that an Evangelist cannot perform the rite of baptism. Even in the examination-in-chief of PW8, there was no attempt on the side of the Respondent to prove that Ebenezer Mani 7 Emphasis added by the Appellant.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1819A. Raja v. D. Kumar was instrumental in baptizing the Appellant’s father and mother as also the Appellant.
14. Learned senior counsel contended that a totally new case was attempted to be developed while examining PW9, on 17.10.2022, on the strength of some alleged tampering in a Baptism Register and Family Register produced before the High Court by Church authorities. The case attempted to be projected was that in 1992, the Appellant’s father, mother and their children (including the Appellant) together converted to Christianity. It is submitted that entries in the so-called Baptism Register are not proved. In fact, since the said Baptism Register from 1997 to 2008 was marked through PW9, who admittedly joined as a pastor in the CSI Church concerned only in 2013, he is incompetent to prove any of the entries. The person who conducted the baptism ceremony was not identified or examined. Anybody knowing the handwriting and signature of the person/s who made those entries was also not examined. Above all, the dates of birth of the persons so baptized shown in the afore-mentioned Registers do not tally with the actual dates of birth of the Appellant’s father, mother and their children, including the Appellant, as per official records.
15. It was further argued that as per Section 81 8 of the Act, dealing with the pleadings in an Election Petition, the petitioner should plead specifically, the ground(s) on which he claims the election is to be set aside, relying on the following decisions of this Court in support of above said proposition: paragraph no.33 of Gajanan Krishnaji Bapat v Dattaji Raghobaji Meghe, (1995) 5 SCC 347; paragraph no.79 of M. Chandra (supra), and; paragraph no.19 of Kalyan Singh Chouhan v C. P. Joshi, (2011) 11 SCC 786.
16. Learned senior counsel stressed that the specific case pleaded in the Election Petition was that the ancestors of the Appellant migrated to 8 ‘81. Presentation of petitions.—(1) An election petition calling in question any election may be presented on one or more of the grounds specified in sub-section (1) of Section 100 and Section 101 to the High Court by any candidate at such election or any elector within forty-five days from, but not earlier than the date of election of the returned candidate or if there are more than one returned candidate at the election and dates of their election are different, the later of those two dates. Explanation.—In this sub-section, “elector” means a person who was entitled to vote at the election to which the election petition relates, whether he has voted at such election or not.
(2) [Omitted]
(3) Every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of the petition.’ 1820 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Kerala in 1951. Without even a whisper in the Election Petition or in the evidence adduced by the Respondent that the ancestors came for employment to Kerala, a completely new case was developed after the period of limitation to file an Election Petition that the Appellant’s ancestors came for employment to Kerala. Learned senior counsel relied on Goka Ramalingam v Boddu Abraham, (1969) 1 SCC 24 and contended that after the period of limitation, a new contention, changing the whole nature of the case, can neither be raised nor pressed into service.
17. Learned senior counsel for the Appellant, further argued that the instant appeal be allowed, pointing out that in the Impugned Judgment, the High Court held that the burden to prove that the Appellant is a member of the Scheduled Castes within the State of Kerala and that his family had migrated prior to 1950 was entirely cast upon the Appellant, which is contrary to the settled proposition of law in M. Chandra (supra). Emphasis was placed particularly on paragraphs no.81 & 82 thereof.
RESPONDENT’S SUBMISSIONS:
18. Learned senior counsel, Mr. Narender Hooda, for the Respondent submitted that the burden of proving the authenticity of the Caste Certificate was fully on the Appellant as per Section 10 of the Kerala (Schedule Castes and Scheduled Tribes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificates Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Kerala Act’), which reads as under:
‘10. Burden of proof:- Where an application is made to the Competent Authority under Section 4 for the issue of a community certificate in respect of a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe or in any enquiry conducted by the Competent Authority, the Expert Agency, or the Scrutiny Committee or in any trial or offence under this Act, the burden of proving that he belongs to such Caste or Tribe shall be on the claimant.’9
19. Learned senior counsel laid emphasis on ‘or in any trial’ to support the proposition that an Election Petition would fall within the ambit 9 Emphasis added by the Respondent.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1821A. Raja v. D. Kumar of the burden contemplated under Section 10 of the Kerala Act. It was argued that in the present case, it was rightly understood by all parties, based on the pleadings and the issues formulated by the High Court and evidence adduced, that the challenge was made to the Caste Certificate produced by the Appellant before the Returning Officer issued by the Competent Authority under the Kerala Act. The burden of proving the authenticity of the Caste Certificate was fully on the Appellant which he failed to discharge. It was urged that the Election Petitioner/Respondent had pleaded material facts and particulars, as laid down in Virender Nath Gautam v Satpal Singh,
(2007) 3 SCC 617.
20. Learned senior counsel submitted that the Caste Certificate issued to a returned candidate can be challenged in an Election Petition and he relied on Hari Shanker Jain v Sonia Gandhi, (2001) 8 SCC 233 and Punit Rai v Dinesh Chaudhary, (2003) 8 SCC 204.
21. It was submitted that a 5-Judge Bench of this Court in Action Committee on Issue of Caste Certificate to SCs/STs v Union of India, (1994) 5 SCC 244 has interpreted the word ‘Resident’ as used in the 1950 Order to mean ‘permanent resident’.
22. It was further argued by learned senior counsel that the marriage of the Appellant was also conducted according to Christian rituals and customs. None of the Hindu rituals or customs were followed during the marriage function of the Appellant. Thus, when these are the special facts within the knowledge of the Appellant, the burden shifts to the Appellant, and it becomes his duty to explain such facts within his knowledge. It was canvassed that simple denial of material facts is not sufficient discharge of the burden under Section 106 of the Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Evidence Act’), nor rebuts the presumption under Section 114 of the Evidence Act.
23. Learned senior counsel further contended that a person claiming the status of a Schedule Caste in a particular State has to demonstrate his/his ancestors’ permanent residence in that particular State on the date of the Presidential Order. In India, a Hindu inherits his caste from his father. In the instant case, the Appellant would inherit his caste from his father i.e., Mr. Anthony, who, in turn, would get his caste from his father Lachmanan. To claim the benefit of reservation for Schedule Castes in relation to the State of Kerala, the Appellant had to establish that his grandfather Lachmanan was 1822 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a permanent resident of Kerala much prior to the 1950 Order as per Action Committee (supra). The High Court in paragraph no.17 of the Impugned Judgment has recorded a categorical finding of fact, after meticulous examination of the entire documentary as well as oral evidence before it, that the Appellant’s grandfather was not a permanent resident of the State of Kerala before the 1950 Order.
24. It was further argued that when the Appellant himself admitted the fact of migration of his grandparents from Tamil Nadu to Kerala, it was his responsibility to prove that his grandparents migrated before independence to the erstwhile State of Travancore-Cochin from Tamil Nadu and were permanent residents of Travancore-Cochin on 10.08.1950 i.e., the date the Presidential Order was issued.
25. It was submitted that since the Appellant was a minor when he converted, the doctrine of eclipse followed him till he became a major. The Appellant ought to have converted to Hinduism by following any custom/ritual which was otherwise prescribed to be followed by the community at large. The case of the Appellant that he never converted to Christianity cannot be accepted since it was proved that the parents converted to Christianity. The minor has no right to claim any religion or caste so long as the parents have converted to another religion along with the family. This being the factual position, it would be the Appellant’s responsibility to prove that he had come out of the eclipse by explaining the facts in his personal knowledge under Section 106 of the Evidence Act. As long as the Respondent had discharged his initial burden of proving the allegation against the Appellant, unless the presumption is rebutted, under Section 114 of the Evidence Act, it would be presumed that the circumstances and evidence are conclusive qua the allegations made in the Election Petition.
26. Learned senior counsel in support of his proposition apropos the doctrine of eclipse relied on K. P. Manu v Scrutiny Committee for Verification of Community Certificate, (2015) 4 SCC 1.
27. Learned senior counsel summed up his arguments and contended that even though it is not mandatory under the Kerala Act to obtain a certificate from the Scrutiny Committee, but if any challenge to such Caste Certificate comes before any enquiry conducted by the Competent Authority, the Expert Agency, or the Scrutiny Committee or in any trial or offence under the Kerala Act, the burden will be on the claimant (in this case, the Appellant herein) to prove that [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1823A. Raja v. D. Kumar he belongs to such caste or tribe. It was urged that the appeal be dismissed, and the Impugned Judgment be upheld.
ANALYSIS, REASONING AND CONCLUSION:
28. Having heard learned senior counsel for the parties at length and bestowed our anxious consideration to the rival contentions assiduously advanced at the Bar, we are of the opinion that the judgment impugned warrants interference.
29. Article 341 of the Constitution of India, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Constitution’) reads as under:
‘341. Scheduled Castes.—(1) The President may with respect to any State or Union Territory, and where it is a State, after consultation with the Governor thereof, by public notification, specify the castes, races or tribes or parts of or groups within castes, races or tribes which shall for the purposes of this Constitution be deemed to be Scheduled Castes in relation to that State or Union territory, as the case may be.
(2) Parliament may by law include in or exclude from the list of Scheduled Castes specified in a notification issued under clause (1) any caste, race or tribe or part of or group within any caste, race or tribe, but save as aforesaid a notification issued under the said clause shall not be varied by any subsequent notification.’
30. In exercise of power conferred under Article 341(1) of the Constitution, Hon’ble the President issued the 1950 Order. The central issue in the entire controversy is whether the Appellant belongs to the Hindu Parayan caste in the State of Kerala and is covered by the 1950 Order insofar as it relates to the State of Kerala. The twin conditions needing to be satisfied would be (i) being of the Hindu Parayan caste, and; (ii) being, himself/herself or through one’s ancestors, permanent resident of the State of Kerala as on the date of the 1950 Order. Upon fulfilment of both these conditions, a person can claim a legal right to derive any benefits available to Hindu Parayan caste in the State of Kerala. In the instant case, fulfilment of the same would enable the Appellant to become eligible to contest from the Devikulam Legislative Assembly Constituency 088 in Idukki District, Kerala, reserved for the Scheduled Castes.
1824 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
31. There is no dispute on the factum that, originally, the grandparents of the Appellant belonged to the Hindu Parayan caste in the erstwhile State of Travancore-Cochin having migrated from the State of Tamil Nadu but prior to 1950. In this regard, there is sufficient evidence available on the record. The next relevant question which would arise would be as to whether the Appellant had still retained the Hindu Parayan caste, as a member of the Hindu religion, when he contested from the Devikulam Legislative Assembly Constituency?
32. This is hotly contested between the parties. The Respondent-Election Petitioner contends that the Appellant’s parents had converted to Christianity and the entire family, including the Appellant, were baptized. In this regard, certain registers of the CSI Church were produced before the High Court. However, from the evidence, it is also apparent that the entries in such registers were not very specific, inasmuch as the name of the Appellant was not mentioned and other details with regard to the age of his siblings also did not match. Even some names of the siblings were different. Were this an ordinary civil suit at trial, we could have possibly applied the ‘preponderance of probabilities’ yardstick, which may have resulted in some leeway and latitude in favour of the Respondent and against the Appellant. However, as per the dicta in J. Chandrasekhara Rao v V. Jagapathi Rao, 1993 Supp (2) SCC 229 and M. Chandra (supra), Election Petitions, including those wherein no allegations of corrupt practices are levelled, have to be treated akin to criminal proceedings and the Election Petitioner has to prove the charges levelled beyond reasonable doubt. This enunciation of the law has guided our decision-making.
33. Most importantly, Ebenezer Mani/PW8, from the Respondent’s side, who claimed to have baptized the Appellant and his family, during evidence, admitted that he was aged 54 years on the date of deposition, which meant he was aged only 14 years in the year 1982, when he purportedly baptized the Appellant’s parents. This is, clearly, unbelievable and unsustainable.
34. It is relevant to observe that mere observance/performance of a ritual of/associated with any religion does not ipso facto and necessarily mean that the person ‘professes’ that religion. That is why the term used in the 1950 Order is ‘professes’, signifying that a person although born in a particular religion can profess another religion, inter alia, by practicing the rituals of that other religion as the basic tenets of [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1825A. Raja v. D. Kumar his beliefs and lifestyle. Adherence merely to some ritual of another religion would not tantamount to giving-up the original religion, unless the person concerned makes such belief explicit. In Sapna Jacob v State of Kerala, 1992 SCC OnLine Ker 233, a learned Single Judge of the (Kerala) High Court (as he then was) observed:
‘6. … It may be true that the court cannot test or gauge the sincerity of religious belief; or where there is no question of the genuineness of a person’s belief in a certain religion, the court cannot measure its depth or determine whether it is an intelligent conviction or ignorant and superficial fancy. But a court can find the true intention of men lying behind their acts and can certainly find from the circumstances of a case whether a pretended conversion was really a means to some further end. …’ (emphasis supplied) 10
35. The term ‘professes’ has been examined by five of our learned predecessors in Punjabrao v D. P. Meshram, 1964 SCC OnLine SC 76 in like background:
‘13. What clause (3) of the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950 contemplates is that for a person to be treated as one belonging to a Scheduled Caste within the meaning of that Order, he must be one who professes either Hindu or Sikh religion. The High Court, following its earlier decision in Karwadi v. Shambharkar [AIR 1958 Bom 296] has said that the meaning of the phrase “professes a religion” in the aforementioned provision is “to enter publicly into a religions state” and that for this purpose a mere declaration by a person that he has ceased to belong to a particular religion and embraced another religion would not be sufficient. The meanings of the word “profess” have been given thus in Webster’s New World Dictionary:“to avow publicly; to make an open declaration of … to declare one’s belief in : as, to profess Christ. To accept into a religious order”. The meanings given in 10 The afore-extract recently found this Court’s approval in C. Selvarani v Special Secretary-cum-District Collector, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3470.
1826 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the Shorter Oxford Dictionary are more or less the same. It seems to us that the meaning “to declare one’s belief in: as to profess Christ” is one which we have to bear in mind while construing the aforesaid order because it is this which bears upon religious belief and consequently also upon a change in religious belief. It would thus follow that a declaration of one’s belief must necessarily mean a declaration in such a way that it would be known to those whom it may interest. Therefore, if a public declaration is made by a person that he has ceased to belong to his old religion and has accepted another religion he will be taken as professing the other religion. In the face of such an open declaration it would be idle to enquire further as to whether the conversion to another religion was efficacious. The word “profess” in the Presidential Order appears to have been used in the sense of an open declaration or practice by a person of the Hindu (or the Sikh) religion. Where, therefore, a person says, on the contrary, that he has ceased to be a Hindu he cannot derive any benefit from that Order.’ (emphasis supplied)
36. From the evidence available, it is not possible to hold that the Appellant ‘professes’ Christianity. In the factual setting of the present lis, the evidence adduced from the side of the Appellant would reveal that the Caste Certificate(s) issued in his favour by the Competent Authority till date hold the field. The Appellant’s Caste Certificate has not been interfered with, either by the Impugned Judgment or by the authority(ies) concerned. In Madhuri Patil v Commr., Tribal Development, (1994) 6 SCC 241, the Court stated, in the context of fake certificate(s) having been obtained to secure admissions in educational institutions:
‘13. The admission wrongly gained or appointment wrongly obtained on the basis of false social status certificate necessarily has the effect of depriving the genuine Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes or OBC candidates as enjoined in the Constitution of the benefits conferred on them by the Constitution. The genuine candidates are also denied admission to educational institutions or [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1827A. Raja v. D. Kumar appointments to office or posts under a State for want of social status certificate. The ineligible or spurious persons who falsely gained entry resort to dilatory tactics and create hurdles in completion of the inquiries by the Scrutiny Committee. It is true that the applications for admission to educational institutions are generally made by a parent, since on that date many a time the student may be a minor. It is the parent or the guardian who may play fraud claiming false status certificate. It is, therefore, necessary that the certificates issued are scrutinised at the earliest and with utmost expedition and promptitude. For that purpose, it is necessary to streamline the procedure for the issuance of social status certificates, their scrutiny and their approval, which may be the following:
1. The application for grant of social status certificate shall be made to the Revenue Sub-Divisional Officer and Deputy Collector or Deputy Commissioner and the certificate shall be issued by such officer rather than at the Officer, Taluk or Mandal level.
2. The parent, guardian or the candidate, as the case may be, shall file an affidavit duly sworn and attested by a competent gazetted officer or non-gazetted officer with particulars of castes and sub-castes, tribe, tribal community, parts or groups of tribes or tribal communities, the place from which he originally hails from and other particulars as may be prescribed by the Directorate concerned.
3. Application for verification of the caste certificate by the Scrutiny Committee shall be filed at least six months in advance before seeking admission into educational institution or an appointment to a post.
4. All the State Governments shall constitute a Committee of three officers, namely, (I) an Additional or Joint Secretary or any officer high-er in rank of the Director of the department concerned, (II) the Director, Social Welfare/ Tribal Welfare/Backward Class Welfare, as the case may be, and (III) in the case of Scheduled Castes another officer who has intimate knowledge in the verification and issuance of the social status certificates. In the case of the 1828 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Scheduled Tribes, the Research Officer who has intimate knowledge in identifying the tribes, tribal communities, parts of or groups of tribes or tribal communities.
5. Each Directorate should constitute a vigilance cell consisting of Senior Deputy Superintendent of Police in over-all charge and such number of Police Inspectors to investigate into the social status claims. The Inspector would go to the local place of residence and original place from which the candidate hails and usually resides or in case of migration to the town or city, the place from which he originally hailed from. The vigilance officer should personally verify and collect all the facts of the social status claimed by the candidate or the parent or guardian, as the case may be. He should also examine the school records, birth registration, if any. He should also examine the parent, guardian or the candidate in relation to their caste etc. or such other persons who have knowledge of the social status of the candidate and then submit a report to the Directorate together with all particulars as envisaged in the pro forma, in particular, of the Scheduled Tribes relating to their peculiar anthropological and ethnological traits, deity, rituals, customs, mode of marriage, death ceremonies, method of burial of dead bodies etc. by the castes or tribes or tribal communities concerned etc.
6. The Director concerned, on receipt of the report from the vigilance officer if he found the claim for social status to be “not genuine” or ‘doubtful’ or spurious or falsely or wrongly claimed, the Director concerned should issue show-cause notice supplying a copy of the report of the vigilance officer to the candidate by a registered post with acknowledgement due or through the head of the educational institution concerned in which the candidate is studying or employed. The notice should indicate that the representation or reply, if any, would be made within two weeks from the date of the receipt of the notice and in no case on request not more than 30 days from the date of the receipt of the notice. In case, the candidate seeks for an opportunity of hearing and claims an inquiry to be made in that behalf, the Director on receipt of such [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1829A. Raja v. D. Kumar representation/reply shall convene the committee and the Joint/Additional Secretary as Chairperson who shall give reasonable opportunity to the candidate/parent/guardian to adduce all evidence in support of their claim. A public notice by beat of drum or any other convenient mode may be published in the village or locality and if any person or association opposes such a claim, an opportunity to adduce evidence may be given to him/it. After giving such opportunity either in person or through counsel, the Committee may make such inquiry as it deems expedient and consider the claims vis-à-vis the objections raised by the candidate or opponent and pass an appropriate order with brief reasons in support thereof.
7. In case the report is in favour of the candidate and found to be genuine and true, no further action need be taken except where the report or the particulars given are procured or found to be false or fraudulently obtained and in the latter event the same procedure as is envisaged in para 6 be followed.
8. Notice contemplated in para 6 should be issued to the parents/guardian also in case candidate is minor to appear before the Committee with all evidence in his or their support of the claim for the social status certificates.
9. The inquiry should be completed as expeditiously as possible preferably by day-to-day proceedings within such period not exceeding two months. If after inquiry, the Caste Scrutiny Committee finds the claim to be false or spurious, they should pass an order cancelling the certificate issued and confiscate the same. It should communicate within one month from the date of the conclusion of the proceedings the result of enquiry to the parent/guardian and the applicant.
10. In case of any delay in finalising the proceedings, and in the meanwhile the last date for admission into an educational institution or appointment to an officer post, is getting expired, the candidate be admitted by the Principal or such other authority competent in that behalf or appointed on the basis of the social status certificate 1830 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports already issued or an affidavit duly sworn by the parent/ guardian/candidate before the competent officer or nonofficial and such admission or appointment should be only provisional, subject to the result of the inquiry by the Scrutiny Committee.
11. The order passed by the Committee shall be final and conclusive only subject to the proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution.
12. No suit or other proceedings before any other authority should lie.
13. The High Court would dispose of these cases as expeditiously as possible within a period of three months. In case, as per its procedure, the writ petition/miscellaneous petition/matter is disposed of by a Single Judge, then no further appeal would lie against that order to the Division Bench but subject to special leave under Article 136.
14. In case, the certificate obtained or social status claimed is found to be false, the parent/guardian/the candidate should be prosecuted for making false claim. If the prosecution ends in a conviction and sentence of the accused, it could be regarded as an offence involving moral turpitude, disqualification for elective posts or offices under the State or the Union or elections to any local body, legislature or Parliament.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.