In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service v.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 748; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1449
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice 172427, Justice 172429, Justice 179359, Justice 290215, Justice 290217 of 2024 and I.A. No(S). 105862, Justice Cji* and Augustine George Masih, Justice J.]
- Decided
- 21 May 2025
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 202/1995
- Sections
- 3, 2
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1449 : 2025 INSC 748 In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service [(I.A. No. 172422 of 2024 with I.A. No(s). 172425, 172427, 172429, 179359, 290215, 290217 of 2024 and I.A. No(s). 105862, 105864 and 105865 of 2025)
In (Writ Petition (C) No. 202 of 1995)] In Re: T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v.
Union of India and Others In the Matter of:
Gaurav Kumar Bansal ... Applicant Unnamatla Prakasham ... Applicant Indian Forest Service Association (State Unit) ... Applicant 21 May 2025 [B.R. Gavai, CJI* and Augustine George Masih, J.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as to whether the officers in the Indian Administrative Service-IAS would be a “reporting authority”, “reviewing authority” and “accepting authority” of the officers working in the Indian Forest Service-IFS.
Headnotes† Service law – Performance Appraisal Report – Writing Performance Appraisal Report of the officers belonging to the Indian Forest Service-IFS by the officers in the Indian Administrative Service-IAS – Propriety:
Held: For writing Annual Confidential Reports-ACRs, in relation to officers up to the rank of Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forest-APCCF, the “reviewing authority” or “reporting authority” should be the immediate superior authority-PCCF in the Forest Department – Thus, up to the APCCF, the “reporting authority” and the “reviewing authority” would be the person within the same department – It is only with regard to Principal Chief Conservator of Forests-PCCF that the “reporting authority” would be a person * Author 1450 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports who was familiar with the work of PCCF and would be a person to whom he reports and who is superior to him in rank and hierarchy – Said “reporting authority” would be a person other than the one belonging to the service because there was no one superior to the PCCF within the service – Government Order dated 29.06.2024 notified by the Government of Madhya Pradesh with regard to writing Performance Appraisal Report of the officers belonging to the IFS that before evaluating the performance of the Divisional Forest Officer (Territorial), Conservator or Chief Conservator of Forest (Reporting Authorities) will seek a note from the District Collector and before evaluating the performance of the Conservator of Forests and Chief Forest Conservator (Territorial), Additional Principal Chief Forest Conservator (Development) will seek a note from the Divisional Commissioner – Said G.O. in violation of the order passed by this Court in the present proceedings dated 22.09.2000 –**Santosh Bharti’s case and is quashed and set aside – State of Madhya Pradesh to reframe the rules by strictly adhering to the directions issued in – **Santosh Bharti’s case, and as clarified by the MoEF and DoPT. [Paras 34, 37, 39, 41] Case Law Cited **Santosh Bharti v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2007) 15 SCC 273 – relied on.
State of Haryana v. P.C. Wadhwa, IPS Inspector General of Police and Another [1987] 2 SCR 1030 : (1987) 2 SCC 602; State of Assam and Others v. Binod Kumar and Others [2024] 1 SCR 473 : (2024) 3 SCC 611 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Madhya Pradesh Government Business (Allocation) Rules; All-India Services Act, 1951; All-India Services (Confidential Rolls) Rules, 1970; All India Services (Confidential Rolls) Second Amendment Rules, 1970; All-India Services (Performance Appraisal Report) Rules, 2007.
List of Keywords Indian Administrative Service; “Reporting authority”; “Reviewing authority”; “Accepting authority”; Indian Forest Service; Performance Appraisal Report; Writing Performance Appraisal Report of the officers belonging to Indian Forest Service by the officers in the Indian Administrative Service; Annual Confidential Reports; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1451In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forest; Immediate superior authority; Forest Department; Principal Chief Conservator of Forests; Superior in rank and hierarchy; Government Order dated 29.06.2024; Divisional Forest Officer (Territorial); Conservator or Chief Conservator of Forest (Reporting Authorities); District Collector; Conservator of Forests and Chief Forest Conservator (Territorial); Divisional Commissioner; **Santosh Bharti’s case. Case Arising From INHERENT/ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Under Article 32 of The Constitution of India I.A. No. 172422 of 2024 with I.A. No(s). 172425, 172427, 172429, 179359, 290215, 290217 of 2024 And I.A. No(s). 105862, 105864, and 105865 of 2025 In Writ Petition (C) No. 202 of 1995 Appearances for Parties Amicus Curiae:
K. Parameshwar, Harish N. Salve, A.D.N. Rao, Ms. Aparajita Singh, Sr. Advs., M.V. Mukunda, Ms. Kanti, Ms. Shreenivas Patil, Ms. Chitransha Singh Sikarwar, Siddhartha Chowdhury.
Advs. for the Petitioner:
Prashant Padmanabhan, Ms. Priya Sirohi, Pratyush Jain, Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, M/s. PLR Chambers And Co., Syed Mehdi Imam, T. Harish Kumar, M/s. Mitter & Mitter Co., M/s. Lawyers’ Knit & Co. Advs. for the Respondents:
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, K. M. Nataraj, Mrs. Archana Pathak Dave, A.S.Gs., Ms. Garima Prashad, Sr. A.A.G. Vaibhav Srivastava, Shiv Mangal Sharma, Nishanth Patil, Ajay Agarwal, A.A.Gs., Vivek Jain, D.A.G. Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Shyam Divan, Dama Seshadri Naidu, A.N.S. Nadkarni, Arunabh Choudhary, Sanjay Upadhyay, Ms. Dr. Monika Gusain, Sr. Advs., Gurmeet Singh Makker, Ms. Suhasini Sen, S. S. Rebello, Raghav Sharma, Gaurang Bhushan, Rohan Gupta, Shyam Gopal, Salvador Santosh Rebello, Ms. Suhasini Sen, Raghav Sharma, Ms. Ruchi Kohli, Harish Pandey, Ms. Indira Bhakar, Anuj Srinivas Udupa, Krishna Kant Dubey, Piyush Beriwal, Neeraj Kumar Sharma, Ms. Mrinal Elker Mazumdar, Shashwat Parihar, Mukesh K Verma, Vinayak Sharma, 1452 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Raman Yadav, Shreekant Neelappa Terdal, Ms. Tanya Srivastava, Ms. Ranu Purohit, Adarsh Kumar Tiwari, Ms. Sugandha Anand, Gaurav Kumar Bansal, Vishnu Kumar Gupta, Ms. Nandita Bansal, Chandrika Uppadhya, Ms. Rani Mishra, Sandeep Kumar Jha, Ms. Nidhi Jaswal, Siddharatha Jha, Saurabh Rajpal, Amogh Bansal, Ms. Nidhi Jaswal, Ms. Misha Rohatgi Mohta, Ms. Nina Nariman, Ms. Tahira Karanjawala, Arun Sharma, Shreyas Maheshwari, Sarah Ayreen Mir, Sharanya Ghosh, Samarth Suri, For M/s. Karanjawala & Co., Krishna Ballabh Thakur, T.R.B. Sivakumar, Aaditya A . Pande, Gaurav Kumar Bansal, Ms. Mrinal Gopal Elker, E.C. Agrawala, Ms. Shibani Ghosh, Ms. Pallavi Langar, Prashant Padmanabhan, Ms. Priya Sirohi, Pratyush Jain, Ms. Rani Mishra, Tarun Johri, Ankur Gupta, Vishwajeet Tyagi, Ms. Nina Nariman, Ramesh Alanki, Ms. Aruna Gupta, Sandeep Kumar Jha, Ms. Shruti Jose, Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, M/s. PLR Chambers And Co., Syed Mehdi Imam, T. Harish Kumar, M/S. Mitter & Mitter Co., M/s. Lawyer S Knit & Co, Gaichangpou Gangmei, Raj Kishor Choudhary, Shuvodeep Roy, Saurabh Tripathi, Deepayan Dutta, K. V. Vijayakumar, Mrs. Rani Chhabra, Ms. Divya Roy, Radha Shyam Jena, Ajit Pudussery, Ashok Mathur, M/s. Parekh & Co., M/s. K J John And Co, Amarjit Singh Bedi, Ms. Surekha Raman, Shreyash Kumar, Harshit Singh, Yashwant Sanjenbam, V. Balachandran, S. C. Birla, Ram Swarup Sharma, T. Mahipal, Umesh Bhagwat, Mrs. M. Qamaruddin, H. S. Parihar, Ms. Baby Krishnan, P. R. Ramasesh, Rakesh K. Sharma, P. N. Gupta, Sarad Kumar Singhania, Mahesh Agarwal, Shivam Shukla, Nilay Gupta, Ms. Deepti Arya, Salvador Santosh, E. C. Agrawala, Kuldip Singh, Ms. Bina Madhavan, Ms. Pratibha Jain, Rajat Joseph, Gopal Prasad, Ms. Jyoti Mendiratta, S.. Udaya Kumar Sagar, Ranjan Mukherjee, Ms. Sharmila Upadhyay, Sarvjit Pratap Singh, Tejaswi Kumar Pradhan, Pradeep Kar, Pranab Samantaray, M/s. Arputham Aruna And Co, Mrs. Nandini Gore, Raj Kumar Mehta, Ms. Madhu Moolchandani, Mrs. B. Sunita Rao, Rajeev Singh, Mrs. Kanchan Kaur Dhodi, Surya Kant, E. C. Vidya Sagar, M/s. M. V. Kini & Associates, Mrs. Manik Karanjawala, Kamal Mohan Gupta, Prashant Kumar, Dharmendra Kumar Sinha, P. Parmeswaran, Ms. Sujata Kurdukar, Ms. Charu Mathur, A. Venayagam Balan, Sudarsh Menon, Ramesh Babu M. R., Vikrant Singh Bais, Shiva Pujan Singh, Ms. K. V. Bharathi Upadhyaya, Rajiv Mehta, Ejaz Maqbool, Rajesh, M/s. Corporate Law Group, Lakshmi Raman Singh, B V Deepak, T. N. Singh, C. L. Sahu, Ms. Sumita Hazarika, Ms. Abha R. Sharma, Abhishek Chaudhary, Mrs. Rekha Pandey, Ms. Gauri Pandey, Gopal Singh, T. V. George, Krishnanand Pandeya, Neeraj Shekhar, Rajesh Kumar Maurya, Ujjwal Ashutosh, Ramendra Vikram Singh, Ms. Asha Gopalan Nair, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1453In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service Rajesh Singh, Ms. Hemantika Wahi, Mohd. Irshad Hanif, Punit Dutt Tyagi, Rathin Das, Ratan Kumar Choudhuri, Sudhir Kulshreshtha, Himanshu Shekhar, Parth Shekhar, Shubham Singh, Youkteshwari Prasad, Mukesh Kumar Verma, Mata Prasad Pathak, Vijay Singh, Ms. Ambali Vedasen, Ms. Sushma Suri, Sudhir Kumar Gupta, A. N. Arora, Irshad Ahmad, G. Prakash, E. M. S. Anam, Mrs. Bina Gupta, P. V. Yogeswaran, Jitendra Mohan Sharma, Ms. Malini Poduval, Ms. C. K. Sucharita, Ms. Binu Tamta, Shibashish Misra, K. L. Janjani, Naresh K. Sharma, Ms. A. Sumathi, Jai Prakash Pandey, Mrs. Anjani Aiyagari, M. Yogesh Kanna, Vikash Singh, M/s. D.s.k. Legal, Ms. Shibani Ghosh, Rishad A Chowdhury, Ms. Sohini Sanyal, Chandra Bhushan Prasad, Ms. Pallavi Langar, Ashish Jha, Sujeet Kumar Chaubey, Rajeev Kumar Dubey, Naveen Kumar, V. N. Raghupathy, Arijit Dey, Milind Kumar, Mohit Paul, Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Ms. Manika Tripathy, Ms. Ankita Sharma, Arjun D Singh, Ms. Supreeta Sharanagouda, Sharanagouda Patil, Jyotish Pandey, M/s. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, Amrish Kumar, Ms. Purnima Krishna, M.f. Philip, Karamveer Singh Yadav, Togin M. Babichen, Ms. Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Ms. Suhasini Sen, S.s. Rebello, Raghav Sharma, Gaurang Bhushan, Jagdish Chandra Solanki, Dr. Surender Singh Hooda, Sunil Kumar Verma, Prakash Kumar Singh, Ms. Adarsh Nain, Guntur Pramod Kumar, Keshav Singh, Bp Naidu, Ms. Anzu. K. Varkey, Ms. Astha Sharma, T. R. B. Sivakumar, Sujit Kumar Mishra, Aldanish Rein, Kunal Mimani, Ms. Shraddha Chirania, Ms. Seita Vaidyalingam, Kumar Anurag Singh, Anando Mukherjee, Shwetank Singh, Ajay Marwah, Ravindra S. Garia, Karan Sharma, Avijit Mani Tripathi, Deeptakirti Verma, Nishanth Patil, M/S. Venkat Palwai Law Associates, Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Shubham Upadhyay, Vivek Jain, Sudeep Kumar, Ms. Manisha, Ms. Rupali, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Karun Sharma, Ms. Rajkumari Divyasana, Ms. Anupama Ngangom, Venkata Raghuvamsy D., Ms. Vanshaja Shukla, Chirag M. Shroff, Ms. Ruchira Goel, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Ms. Aditya Krishna, Adarsh Dubey, Parth Awasthi, Pashupathi Nath Razdan, Tarun Gupta, Sameer Abhyankar, Krishna Rastogi, Ms. Ripul Swati Kumari, Ms. Ranjeeta Rohatgi, Rajeev Kumar Dubey, Ashiwan Mishra, Kamlendra Mishra, Somesh Chandra Jha, Siddhartha Jha, M/s. V. Maheshwari & Co., Mayank Aggarwal, Sanjeev Kumar, Shovan Mishra, Ashutosh Kumar Sharma, P. S. Sudheer, Sunny Choudhary, Vinod Sharma, Ms. Surbhi Mehta, Rajeev Singh, Ms. Parul Shukla, Abhishek Pandey, Prashant Kumar Umrao, Arun K. Sinha, Naveen Kumar, P. K. Manohar, A. Karthik, Rajiv 1454 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Kumar Choudhry, Anurag Tandon, Akshay Amritanshu, Hariom Yaduvanshi, Arjun Yaduvanshi, Ms. S. Harini, Avi Dhankhar, Vansmani Tripathi, Ms. Aahana Jaiswal, Ms. Drishti Rawal, Ms. Pragya Upadhyay, Omanakuttan K. K., B. K. Pal, James P. Thomas, S. Gowthaman, Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Neha Singh, Siddharth Sharma, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Mrs. Ruchi Kohli, Uday Prakash Yadav, Suhasini Sen, S S Rebello, Raghav Sharma, Sughosh Subramanium, Samir Ali Khan, Pranjal Sharma, Kashif Irshad Khan, Anil Kumar Verma, Ms. Shalini Kaul, Sunil Kumar Sharma, Nishit Agrawal, Krishna Ballabh Thakur, Ms. Aruna Gupta, Ms. K. Enatoli Sema, Amit Kumar Singh, Ms. Chubalemla Chang, Prang Newmai, Shishir Deshpande, Shubhranshu Padhi, Nishe Rajen Shonker, Raghvendra Kumar, Sravan Kumar Karanam, Abhiram Bannur, Ms. M. Harshini, Anant Mann, Lakshmeesh S. Kamath, Ms. Samriti Ahuja, Ms. Aditi Prakash, Mrs. Pragya Baghel, Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Satyalipsu Ray, Ms. Sunieta Ojha, Dinesh Chandra Pandey, Saurabh Rajpal, Arpit Bamal, Himinder Lal, Gopal Balwant Sathe, Sarvam Ritam Khare, Kushagra Sharma, Anuj Agarwal, Akarsh Khare, , Mrs. Kirti Renu Mishra, Atul Sharma, Anirudh Sanganeria, Chinmay Deshpande, Shrey Kapoor , Ms. Anne Mathew, Yash S. Vijay, Kaushik Choudhury, Aravindh S., Aman Gautam, Ms. Jyoti P, Dhaval Mehrotra, Binay Kumar Das, Ms. Lakshmi N. Kaimal, Subhasish Mohanty, Mr Rahul Jain, Sabarish Subramanian, Abhishek Atrey, Dr. Abhishek Atrey, Brijesh Kumar, Ms. Vidyottma Jha, Ms. Mrinal Gopal Elker, Chinmoy Chaitanya. Applicant-in-person.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court INDEX* I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................... 3 II. SUBMISSIONS ............................................................................ 4 III. DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS ................................................... 7
(i) Statutory Provisions ......................................................... 7
(ii) Internal Communications ................................................. 10
(iii) Legal Precedents .............................................................. 17
(a) State of Haryana v. P.C. Wadhwa, IPS, Inspector General of Police and Another ............................... 17
(b) Santosh Bharti v. State of Madhya Pradesh ......... 21 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1455In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service
(iv) Order of this Court in I.A. No.776 of 2002 in the present proceedings ....................................................................... 26
(v) Recent judgment of this Court in State of Assam and Others v. Binod Kumar and Others ................................ 30
(vi) Impugned G.O. dated 29th June 2024 .............................. 32 IV. DIRECTIONS ............................................................................... 37 Judgment B.R. Gavai, CJI
I. INTRODUCTION
1. The present batch of applications pertains to an issue as to whether the officers in the Indian Administrative Service (hereinafter referred to as, “IAS”) would be a “reporting authority”, “reviewing authority” and “accepting authority” of the officers working in the Indian Forest Service (hereinafter referred to as, “IFS”).
2. The present applications basically challenge the Government Order dated 29th June 2024 (hereinafter referred to as the, “said G.O.”) notified by the Government of Madhya Pradesh with regard to writing Performance Appraisal Report (hereinafter referred to as, “PAR”) of the officers belonging to the IFS. The relevant part of the said G.O. reads thus:
“2. Before evaluating the performance of the Divisional Forest Officer (Territorial), the concerned Conservator or Chief Conservator of Forest (Reporting Authorities) will seek a note from the District Collector. Similarly and before evaluating the performance of the Conservator of Forests and Chief Forest Conservator (Territorial), the Additional Principal Chief Forest Conservator (Development) will seek a note from the Divisional Commissioner and these notes shall be considered during the time of Performance Appraisal Report (PAR).
3. Comments by Collector and Divisional Commissioner on performance of Indian Forest Service officers in field positions 1456 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports on areas such as MANREGAS, Joint Forest Management, Forest Rights Act, land acquisition for development projects, mining, district planning committee decisions, livelihood and skill development, district archeological and tourism council, implementation initiatives related to any other development will be sent on a separate sheet.”
3. The applicants have a grievance with regards to the “reporting authority”, “reviewing authority” and “accepting authority” as prescribed in the said G.O., insofar as certain posts in the IFS are concerned. The applicants also have a grievance with regard to the aforementioned paragraphs 2 and 3 of the said G.O.
II. SUBMISSIONS
4. We have heard Shri K. Parameshwar, learned amicus curiae and Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General appearing on behalf of the State of Madhya Pradesh.
5. Shri Parameshwar, learned amicus curiae submits that the said G.O issued by the Government of Madhya Pradesh is directly in violation of the judgments delivered by this Court in the cases of State of Haryana v. P.C. Wadhwa, IPS, Inspector General of Police and Another1 , Santosh Bharti v. State of Madhya Pradesh2 , and the order passed by this Court in the present proceedings dated 19 th April 2004. The learned amicus curiae therefore submits that the said G.O. is liable to be quashed and set aside.
6. Per contra, Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General appearing on behalf of the State of Madhya Pradesh submits that as per the Order of Precedence of the Government of Madhya Pradesh dated 23 rd December 2011, the Additional Chief Secretary (hereinafter referred to as, “ACS”) and the Principal Secretary (hereinafter referred to as, “PS”) hold ranks superior to that of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (hereinafter referred to as, “PCCF”). He further submits that in accordance with the provisions as contained in clauses (2) and (3) of Article 166 of the Constitution of India, the Governor of Madhya Pradesh has framed the Madhya Pradesh Government Business (Allocation) Rules. He submits that under the said Rules,
1 (1987) 2 SCC 602
2 (2007) 15 SCC 273
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1457In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service each Secretariat Department is required to have a Secretary to the Government (ACS/PS). It is submitted that for the Forest Department, ACS/PS is the official administrative head of the IFS.
7. The learned Solicitor General submits that the Forest Officers and particularly the Divisional Forest Officer (hereinafter referred to as, “DFO”) who is the Head of the Division, discharges diverse responsibilities. It is submitted that the DFO is also responsible for various duties like conservation of forests, implementation of government schemes, enforcement of forest laws, forest fire management, legal matters, financial administration, and interdepartmental coordination, amongst others. He submits that therefore, it is necessary that the evaluation of the performance of DFOs should be accepted by the Secretary of the Forest Department who is normally an ACS/PS. He submits that similarly even insofar as the PAR of the Chief Conservators of Forests (hereinafter referred to as, “CCFs”) is concerned, the “accepting authority” should be only ACS or PS. He further submits that assigning PCCF or the Head of Forests as “reviewing authority” or “accepting authority” for the Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (hereinafter referred to as, “APCCF”) working in vertical roles at the headquarters is not consistent with the revised appraisal rules. He submits that the performance must be evaluated by those who have continuing engagement with the officer’s work.
8. Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General fairly submits that ignoring the role of the ACS/PS in the PAR channel of IFS officers would not only be contrary to legislative intent but also inconsistent with principles of governance, accountability and equity in public administration that demand accountability through real supervision. He fairly submits that in order to alleviate the fear in the minds of the IFS officers, the State of Madhya Pradesh has agreed that it will not insist on marking by the ACS/PS, instead, only comments of the reviewing officers would be called for.
III. DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
(i) Statutory Provisions
9. For examining the controversy, it will be relevant to refer to subsection (1) of Section 3 of the All-India Services Act, 1951 (hereinafter referred to as, “AIS Act”), which reads thus:
1458 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “3. Regulation of recruitment and conditions of service.—(1) The Central Government may, after consultation with the Governments of the States concerned including the State of Jammu and Kashmir and by notification in the Official Gazette, make rules for the regulation of recruitment, and the conditions of service of persons appointed, to an all-India Service.”
10. In exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the AIS Act, the Central Government, after consultation with the Governments of the States concerned, has made the All-India Services (Confidential Rolls) Rules, 1970 (hereinafter referred to as, “1970 Rules”).
11. Rule 2 of the 1970 Rules provides various definitions. It will be relevant to refer to the following definitions provided in the 1970 Rules: “2. Definitions.—In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires:—
(a) ‘accepting authority’ means the authority who was, during the period for which the confidential report is written, immediately superior to the reviewing authority and such other authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government”;
………..
(e) ‘reporting authority’ means the authority who was, during the period for which the confidential report is written, immediately superior to the member of the Service and such other authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government;
(f) ‘reviewing authority’ means the authority who was, during the period for which the confidential report is written, immediately superior to the reporting authority and such other authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government;”
12. In exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the AIS Act, the Central Government, after consultation with the Governments of the States concerned, by a notification dated 8 th December 1987, has made the All-India Services (Confidential [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1459In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service Rolls) Second Amendment Rules, 1970, by which the definitions of “accepting authority”, “reporting authority” and “reviewing authority” were amended, which read thus:
“(a) ‘accepting authority’ means such authority or authorities supervising the performance of the reviewing authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government”;
………..
(e) ‘reporting authority’ means such authority or authorities supervising the performance of the member of the Service reported upon as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government;
(f) ‘reviewing authority’ means authority or authorities supervising the performance of the reporting authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government;”
13. In exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the AIS Act, the Central Government, after consultation with the Governments of the States concerned, made the All-India Services (Performance Appraisal Report) Rules, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as, “2007 Rules”). The definitions of “accepting authority”, “reporting authority” and “reviewing authority” as provided in the 2007 Rules, read thus:
“(a) ‘accepting authority’ means the authority which supervises the performance of the reviewing authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government”;
………..
(j) ‘reporting authority’ means such authority or authorities supervising the performance of the member of the Service reported upon as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government;
(k) ‘reviewing authority’ means such authority or authorities supervising the performance of the reporting authority as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government;”
1460 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(ii) Internal Communications
14. For deciding the issue in question, it will also be necessary to refer to certain clarifications and Office Memorandum (hereinafter referred to as, “O.M.”) issued by the Union of India.
15. Clause 4 of the clarification dated 28th December 1990 reads thus: “4. Reporting Authority should be in a higher grade of pay than the officers reported upon and the Reviewing Authority should be in a higher grade than the Reporting Authority.- I am directed to refer to Rule 2(e) of the AIS (CR) Rules, 1970, wherein the reporting authority has been defined as the authority or authorities supervising the performance of the member of the Service reported upon as may be specifically empowered in this behalf by the Government.
2. It appears that some States have kept in view the seniority and pay scale of the reporting officer vis-à-vis the Member of the Service reported upon while assigning reporting authorities whereas others have not. Instances have come to the notice of this Department wherein ACRs of the members of All India Service have been initiated by officers belonging to the same batch or drawing pay in the same scale as that of the officer reported upon.
3. It is suggested to the State Govts. that while assigning reporting/reviewing authorities efforts may be made to ensure that a member of the Service or any other officer does not initiate the C.R. of another member of the Service in the same grade of pay. It is also desirable that the reviewing authority is in a higher grade than the reporting authority within the limits of administrative convenience.”
16. It can thus be seen that seniority and pay-scales of the reporting officer vis-à-vis the Member of the Service reported upon is required to be taken into consideration while assigning reporting authorities. It further states that various instances have come to notice wherein Annual Confidential Reports (hereinafter referred to as, “ACRs”) of the Members of All India Service have been initiated by officers belonging to the same batch or drawing pay in the same scale as [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1461In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service that of the officer reported upon. It has therefore been suggested to the State Governments that while assigning reporting/reviewing authorities, efforts should be made to ensure that a Member of the Service or any other officer does not initiate the Confidential Report (hereinafter referred to as, “C.R.”) of another Member of the Service in the same grade or pay. It further provides that it is desirable that the reviewing authority is in a higher grade than the reporting authority within the limits of administrative convenience.
17. It will also be relevant to refer to a letter of the Ministry of Environment & Forest (hereinafter referred to as, “MoEF”) dated 8 th November 2001, which reads thus:
“(V) WRITING OF REPORTS OF MEMBERS OF THE
INDIAN FOREST SERVICE
1. Writing of Reports of members of the Indian Forest Service.- Attention of the State Government is invited to this Ministry’s letter No. 14/20/2000-SU dated 28th September, 2000 vide which a copy of order dated 22/09/2000 passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in I.A. No. 424 (Civil Writ Petition No. 202 of 1995) : T.N. Godavarman Thirumulkpad had been forwarded for implementation of various directions given by the Apex Court.
2. One of the directions of the Apex Court was in regard to writing of Annual Confidential report of the members of the Indian Forest Service. The Hon’ble Supreme Court had directed that upto the officers of the rank of Addl. Principal Chief Conservator of Forests the reporting authority has to be the immediately superior officer within the Forest Department. It is only in the case of Principal Chief Conservator of Forest that the reporting authority would be a person other than the one belonging to the Service because there is no one superior to him within the EFS. Therefore, in his case the reporting authority would be a person to whom he reports and who is superior to him in hierarchy.
3. Keeping in view the directions given by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, all the State Governments are advised to ensure that for writing the Annual Confidential Reports of the IFS officers upto the rank of Additional Principal 1462 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Chief Conservator of Forests, the reporting authority should be their immediate superior authorities in the Forest Department. As regards reviewing/reporting authority in relation to officers of the rank of Addl. Principal Chief Conservator of Forests and Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, the concerned authority would person who is familiar with their work and that will be the person to whom addl. PCCF/PCCF reports and who is superior to them in rank and hierarchy.
4. The State Government may, if necessary direct the Collectors and Commissioners to record their comments on a separate sheet about the performance of the IFS officers in relation to implementation of developmental work (including 20-point programme) funded by the District Administration for being considered by the superior departmental officers at the time of writing of ACRs.
5. The State Governments are requested to ensure that the directions given by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of writing of ACRs, as explained above, are strictly followed.”
18. It can thus be seen that the said letter specifically noted the order passed by this Court in the present proceedings titled dated 22nd September 2000 3 , wherein this Court had directed that up to the rank of APCCF, the “reporting authority” had to be an immediate superior officer within the Forest Department. It further noted that this Court had also directed that it was only in the case of PCCF that the “reporting authority” would be a person other than the one belonging to the Forest Service because there was no one superior to him/her within the IFS. It noted that this Court further directed that in that case, the “reporting authority” would be a person to whom he reported and who was superior to him in hierarchy.
19. The aforesaid communication of the MoEF directed all the State Governments to ensure that for writing the ACRs of the IFS officers up to the rank of APCCF, the “reporting authority” should be their immediate superior authorities in the Forest Department. It further directed that regarding the reviewing/reporting authority in relation
3 (2007) 15 SCC 273
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1463In Re: Performance Appraisal Reports of the Officers of the Indian Forest Service to officers of the rank of APCCF and PCCF, the concerned authority would be a person who was familiar with their work and that would be the person to whom APCCF/PCCF reported and who was superior to them in rank and hierarchy. It further directed that the State Governments may, if necessary, direct the Collectors and Commissioners to record their comments on a separate sheet about the performance of the IFS officers in relation to the implementation of developmental work (including 20 point programme) funded by the District Administration for being considered by the superior departmental officers at the time of writing of ACRs.
20. It will be relevant to refer to the O.M. dated 2nd September 2004 notified by the Department of Personnel and Training (hereinafter referred to as, “DoPT”), which reads thus:
“2. Writing of ACRs of All India Services Officers – instructions regarding.- The Hon’ble Supreme Court in I.A. No.424 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 202 of 1995 (T.N. Godavarman Thirumulkpad Vs. Union of India & Others)
had considered the issue of the competent authority to write the confidential report of Forest Department Officers (implementation of the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court). The Ministry of Environment & Forests issued instructions vide letter No. 22019/1/2001-IFS-I dated 8th November, 2001 (Copy enclosed).
2.1 This Department filed I.A.No. 477/2003 for modification or clarification of the above order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Hon’ble Supreme Court directed that the matter be heard by the Central Empowered Committee (CEC), constituted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. The CEC has agreed with the views of Department of Personnel & Training (DOP&T) that the Hon’ble Court’s order dated 22.09.2000 was issued in a particular context and should not be generalized to cover other Services. It has also agreed with the view of the DOP&T that if the Forest Officer is working in the Secretariat or other Departments where his immediate supervising officer is a non-forest officer, his C.R should be written by such an officer [para 8(x)]. 2.2 The relevant recommendation of the CEC is reproduced below:- 1464 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “In the light of the above, the Committee is of the considered view that this Hon’ble Court’s order dated 22.09.2000 requires no modification.
The Hon’ble Court’s order has set right the anomaly that existed in the State of Madhya Pradesh regarding CRs of the Forest Officers.
The Hon’ble Court’s order is not inconsistent with the amended CR Rules. It may be clarified that the order of 22.09.2000 of this Hon’ble Court is applicable only for reporting, reviewing or accepting the confidential reports of the Forest Officers working within the Forest Department and is not applicable for Forest Officers working outside the Department or for other Services”.
(para 10).
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.