Amruddin Ansari (Dead) Through LRs. & Ors. v. Afajal Ali & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 566; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2650
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 22 Apr 2025
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE TO PETITION (CIVIL)... No. 11442/2023
- Sections
- 54, 6, 99, 9, 11, 2(9), 2(2), 144
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2650 : 2025 INSC 566 Amruddin Ansari (Dead) Through Lrs. & Ors.
v.
Afajal Ali & Ors.
(Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 11442 of 2023)
22 April 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration i) Whether after the dismissal of the petition for restoration of suit u/Or. IX R.4 of the CPC a fresh suit is maintainable; ii) Whether after dismissal of suit in default u/R.2 and R.3 of Or. IX of the CPC, a fresh suit is barred by the principle of res judicata. Headnotes † Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.IX, R.4 – Whether after the dismissal of the petition for restoration of suit u/Or. IX R.4 of the CPC a fresh suit is maintainable:
Held: From bare reading of the two provisions i.e. R.4 and R.9 of Or. IX of the CPC, it is manifestly clear that u/R. 4 of Or. IX of the CPC, the legislature in express term has not precluded the plaintiff from filing a fresh suit on the same cause of action in the event suit is dismissed under R.2 or R.3 of Or. IX of the CPC, whereas R.9 of Or. IX debars the plaintiff from filing a fresh suit in a case where the suit is dismissed under R.8 of Or. IX of the CPC – The only remedy provided for such dismissal is to file an application u/R.9 of Or. IX of the CPC for restoration of suit – In case of dismissal of suit u/Or. IX R.4 of the CPC the plaintiff has both the remedies of filing of fresh suit or application for restoration of the suit – If he chooses one remedy, he is not debarred from availing himself of the other remedy – Both these remedies are simultaneous and would not exclude either of them. [Paras 17, 21] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Whether after dismissal of suit in default u/R.2 and R.3 of Or. IX of the CPC, a fresh suit is barred by the principle of res judicata:
Held: The principle of res judicata is based on the common law maxim “nemo debet bis vexari pro una et eadem causa”, which means that no man shall be vexed twice over the same cause of * Author [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2651Amruddin Ansari (Dead) Through Lrs. & Ors. v. Afajal Ali & Ors. action – It is a doctrine applied to give finality to a lis – According to this doctrine, an issue or a point once decided and attends finality, should not be allowed to be reopened and re-agitated in a subsequent suit – A dismissal of a suit or application for default particularly u/R.2 or R.3 of Or. IX of the CPC is not the formal expression of an adjudication upon any right claimed or the defence set up in a suit – An order of dismissal of a suit or application in default is also not appealable order as provided u/Or. XLIII of the CPC – If Or. XLIII CPC is read, one will find that orders passed u/Or. IX, R.9 of the CPC or Or. IX R.13 of the CPC are made appealable, but order passed u/Or. IX R.4 of the CPC is not appealable – It is, therefore, clear that an order of dismissal of a suit or application in default u/R.2 or R.3 of Or.IX of the CPC is neither an adjudication or a decree nor it is an appealable order – If that is so, such order of dismissal of a suit u/R.2 or R.3 of Or. IX of the CPC does not fulfill the requirement of the term “judgment” or “decree”, inasmuch as there is no adjudication – In considered opinion of this Court, therefore, if a fresh suit is filed, then such an order of dismissal cannot and shall not operate a res judicata. [Paras 23, 26] Case Law Cited Bhudeo vs. Musammat Baikunthi (1921) 63 I.C. 239; Govind Prasad v. Har Kishen, AIR 1929 Allahabad 131; Mt. Balkesia v. Mahant Bhagwan Gir, AIR 1937 Patna 9 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Or.IX, R.4 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Dismissal of suit in default; Dismissal of suit in default u/R.2 and R.3 of Or. IX of the CPC; Fresh suit; Principle of res judicata; Application for restoration of suit.
Case Arising From EXTRA-ORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 11442 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.10.2019 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in SA No. 424 of 2005 2652 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioners:
Vinay P. Tripathi, B. Shravanth Shanker, Abhinav Jaganathan, B. Yeshwanth Raj, Mrs. Preeti Shukla.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. V. Mohana, Kaustubh Shukla, Ms. Praveen Kumar Singh, Ms. Pushpanjali Singh, Ms. Bhavya Pande Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order J.B. Pardiwala, J.
1. This petition arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur dated 24.10.2019 in Second Appeal No.424/2005 by which the Second Appeal filed by the respondents herein (original plaintiffs) came to be allowed and thereby, the judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court reversing the decree passed by the Trial Court came to be set aside.
2. For the sake of convenience, the petitioners herein shall be referred to as the original defendants and the respondents herein shall be referred to as the original plaintiffs.
3. The facts giving rise to this petition may be summarized as under: a. The history of this litigation goes something like this. In the first instance, the father of the original plaintiffs instituted a Civil Suit No.37A/1996 in the Court of Ld. Civil Judge, Ramanujganj, District- Sarguja, Chhattisgarh for declaration, cancellation of sale deed and a permanent injunction. It appears from the materials on record that the said suit came to be dismissed under the provisions of Order IX Rule 2 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (for short “the C.P.C.”). In such circumstances, the father of original plaintiffs preferred an application under Order IX Rule 4 for restoration of the suit. The said application under Order IX Rule 4 of the C.P.C. came to be dismissed. The matter was not carried further. The order passed by the Trial Court rejecting the application filed under Order IX Rule 4 of the C.P.C. attained finality.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2653Amruddin Ansari (Dead) Through Lrs. & Ors. v. Afajal Ali & Ors. b. Later, the original plaintiffs (legal heirs) instituted a fresh suit bearing No.27A/2001 in the Court of Civil Judge, 1 st Class, Ramanujganj, Tehsil Paal, District-Sarguja, Chhattisgarh for the same reliefs.
c. The Trial Court framed the following issues:
“1. Whether the Plaintiffs are having ownership right over the suit property mentioned in Appendix-A attached to the suit?
2. Whether the executed Sale Deed dated 19.12.86 is having no effect on the plaintiffs being fake, fabricated and illegal?
3. Whether the Plaintiffs are entitled for grant of a decree of permanent injunction against the defendants with respect to the suit land that the Defendant Nos.1,2,3, 4 and 5 themselves and their relatives, friends, servants and agents be restrained from claiming ownership or entering into the suit property or creating any hindrance thereupon?
4. Whether daughters of Late Rahmat Ali are necessary parties to the suit?
5. Whether the principal of res judicata is applicable in the present suit?
6. Whether there is lesser court fee paid in the suit?
7. Relief and costs?”
d. All the aforesaid issues came to be answered in favour of the plaintiffs.
e. The original defendants being dissatisfied with the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court challenged the same before the District Court in First Appeal. The First Appeal came to be allowed. The judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court was set aside.
f. Being dissatisfied with the judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court, the plaintiffs went before the High Court in Second Appeal.
2654 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports g. The High Court formulated the following three substantial questions of law for its consideration:
“i) “Whether the learned first Appellate Court was justified in holding that since the decree holder did not deposit the deficit court fees within the period allotted by the trial Court, the decree becomes in executable, is correct particularly in view of the fact that the deficit court fees has been deposited by the plaintiff/decree holder with the permission of the trial Court?”
ii) “Whether the finding. of the first Appellate Court that the instant suit was not maintainable in view of the doctrine to res judicata, is justified in the absence of any evidence that the earlier suit was between the same parties and for the same relief?”
iii) “Whether the finding of the appellate Court that the document titled as Vazib Dava of Ex.P.1, by which the patta holder Abdul Rajak has relinquished his right in favour of the plaintiffs could be ignored only on the ground that the same has not been proved by examining the attesting witnesses particularly in the light of the fact that the same has not been disputed by the defendants?”
h. The High Court, while allowing the Second Appeal answered all the three substantial questions of law referred to above in favour of the plaintiffs. The judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court was set aside and the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court came to be restored.
4. In such circumstances referred to above, the original defendants are before this Court with the present petition.
5. We heard Mr. Mr. Abhinav Jaganathan, the learned counsel appearing for the original defendants (petitioners) and Ms. V. Mohana, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent Nos.1 and 2 respectively (original plaintiffs).
6. The learned counsel appearing for the defendants (petitioners) has three-fold submissions to canvass before us. First, according to him, [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2655Amruddin Ansari (Dead) Through Lrs. & Ors. v. Afajal Ali & Ors. the second suit itself was not maintainable. He would submit that once an application under Order IX Rule 4 of the C.P.C. stands rejected and if such order is not challenged before the higher Court and attains finality, then a second suit for the same cause of action and for the very same relief is not maintainable. His second submission is with respect to the evidentiary value of the document i.e. Wajib Dava (Exhibit P-1). According to him, the Wajib Dava of 1952 could be said to be hit by Section 54 of the last principles of Mohammedan Law read with Section 6(a) of the Transfer of the Property Act, 1882. He would also submit that being an unregistered document, the same could not have been read into evidence for the purpose of establishing a valid title over the property. Thirdly, according to the learned counsel the fresh suit filed by the plaintiffs could be said to be hit by the doctrine of res judicata.
7. On the other hand, Ms. V. Mohana, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the plaintiffs would submit that no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned judgment and order. She would submit that the High Court is right in taking the view that the suit was maintainable and was not hit in any manner by the provisions of Order IX Rule 4 of the C.P.C. As regards the document i.e. Wajib Dava (Exhibit P-1), she submitted that the same has been very well considered by the High Court in all respects. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned Senior Counsel prayed that there being no merit in the petition, the same may be dismissed.
ANALYSIS
8. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, two questions fall for our consideration:
i) Whether after the dismissal of the petition for restoration of suit under Order IX Rule 4 of the C.P.C. a fresh suit is maintainable? ii) Whether after dismissal of the suit for default, a fresh suit is barred by res judicata?
9. Order IX Rule 4 of the C.P.C. reads thus:
“ORDER IX -Appearance of parties and consequence of non-appearance 2656 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. Plaintiff may bring fresh suit or Court may restore suit to file.- Where a suit is dismissed under rule 2 or rule 3, the plaintiff may (subject to the law of limitation) bring a fresh suit; or he may apply for an order to set the dismissal aside, and if he satisfies the Court that there was sufficient cause for [such failure as is referred to in rule 2], or for his non-appearance, as the case may be, the Court shall make an order setting aside the dismissal and shall appoint a day for proceeding with the suit.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.