Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His LRs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 441; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2563
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 3 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4772/2025
- Sections
- 4, 6, 18, 23
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2563 : 2025 INSC 441 Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc.
v.
State of Haryana & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 4772-4773 of 2025)
03 April 2025 [B.R. Gavai and K.V. Viswanathan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Appellants, landowners of Village Dharuhera, Haryana, whose lands were acquired under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, by a notification dated 12.12.2008 are entitled to compensation at a higher rate—on par with the compensation awarded for similarly situated lands in adjoining villages, acquired under a later notification dated 13.05.2010, where the compensation was enhanced vide judgments in BESCO and M/s Habitat Estates.
Headnotes† Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (LA Act) – Land acquired for development and utilization of institutional sector in Dharuhera village, Haryana – Market value determined by Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) challenged – Reference Court enhanced the compensation – High Court vide impugned judgment, for reasons different from those recorded by Reference Court, maintained award as ordered by Reference Court – Impugned judgment set aside – Reasoning given by High Court to rely only on one exemplar not satisfactory – Lands acquired in adjoining villages are comparable – Compensation enhanced – Principle of de-escalation applied – Appeals partly allowed. Appellants’ land acquired for development and utilization of Institutional Sector 5A under the Haryana Urban Development Authority Act, 1977 in Dharuhera village in Haryana – Section 4, LA Act, notification issued on 12.12.2008 – Section 6, LA Act, declaration issued on 11.12.2009 – LAC determined market value at Rs. 21,00,000/- per acre – Appellants filed reference for appropriate enhancement under LA Act, Section 18 – Reference Court enhanced the compensation, relying on award in acquisition vide notification dated 13.05.2010 in adjoining village of Malpura for development of industrial sectors 15, 16 and 17 of Dharuhera – Considering the difference of 17 * Author 2564 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports months in date of two notifications, Reference Court applied deescalation of 12% and awarded compensation of Rs. 55,71,010/per acre – High Court in impugned judgment found that Reference Court erred in placing reliance on the award in Malpura village as no evidence to prove that the acquired land in village Malpura vide notification dated 13.05.2010 was comparable in its geographical location, valuation and other factors – Reference Court also faulted for not considering sale deeds produced by parties which reflected a price lesser than the amount offered by the LAC – High Court relied on one exemplar Exh. PW4/D dated 02.05.2006 and rejected the other sale deeds – Confirmed judgment of Reference Court for reasons different from the one adduced by the Reference Court – Aggrieved landowners filed Appeals:
Held: Lands of villages Malpura and Kapriwas acquired under the notification of 18.05.2010 and lands of Appellants herein acquired by notification of 12.12.2008 – Purpose of acquisition in both matters development and utilization for sectors in Dharuhera (institutional and industrial respectively) – Villages are adjoining – Acquired lands under notifications of 12.12.2008 and 13.05.2010 on two sides of the NH-8 Jaipur-Delhi Highway – Vast difference in prices in exemplar of sale deeds relied upon by the Appellants and the State – High Court rejected all, except Exh. PW4/D – Reasoning given by High Court to only rely on PW4/D not satisfactory – Reasoning given by High Court that no evidence to prove that the acquired lands in village Malpura was comparable with the then geographical location, and other factors of the Appellants’ lands bereft of merit – Map indicates the proximity of the lands – Reference Court rightly recorded that villages were adjoining and the acquisition was all part of development of sectors in Dharuhera – Reliance to be placed on the value of the land arrived at in BESCO wherein compensation awarded with respect to lands acquired in village Malpura vide notification dated 13.05.2010 and village Kapriwas was enhanced – Rs. 1,49,14,975 per acre to be treated as base value for the Appellants’ lands – Appropriate percentage of de-escalation and appropriate reduction for change of land use charges to be provided for – De-escalation @ 12% p.a. for one year and for remaining five months an additional 6% on the base value – Adjusting for change of land use charges by deducting Rs. 5 lakh – Figure of Rs. 1,18,37,668/- as the base value arrived at on which statutory benefits under Section 23(1-A), 23(2) and 28, LA Act in accordance with law to be paid after deducting the amounts already paid to the landowners.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2565Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
Eleven appeals pertain to acquisition pursuant to notification dated 13.05.2010 under Section 4, LA Act, and notification dated 12.05.2011 under Section 6, LA Act – Lands in village Malpura and Kapriwas – Same directly covered by judgments in BESCO and M/s Habitat Estates – Land losers entitled to same benefits – However, not entitled to interest for the period of delay in filing/ delay in refiling after delayed filing of the appeal(s). Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Principle of de-escalation and escalation applied to fix compensation:
Held: Principle of de-escalation to be applied while determining base value of award – Peerappa Hanmantha Harijan, Chandrashekar and Sardar Singh referred to.
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 – Determination of compensation in each case depends upon the nature of land and the evidence adduced in each case – Compensation cannot be determined by blindly following the previous award/judgment:
Held: Reliance placed on Manoj Kumar in which it was held that the determination of compensation in each case depends upon the nature of land and what is the evidence adduced in each case, may be that better evidence has been adduced in later case regarding the actual value of property and subsequent sale deeds after the award and before preliminary notification under Section 4 are also to be considered, if filed – Not proper to ignore the evidence adduced in the case at hand – Compensation cannot be determined by blindly following the previous award/judgment – Manoj Kumar did not hold that awards in other cases which are relevant cannot be relied upon at all – Such awards will be relevant as a piece of evidence and not be conclusive in nature – Even before its notification as a municipal area, prices in Dharuhera, as evident from the exemplars cited by the land losers, indicate a range of Rs. 1,30,00,000/- per acre and Rs. 1,80,72,289/- per acre, though for varying extent of lands – Hence, even test laid down in Manoj Kumar satisfied – Reliance can safely be placed on the award in BESCO to arrive at base value. Potentiality Factor to be considered while assessing market value:
Held: Potentiality is the use to which the land is put to use or reasonably capable of being put to use – Potentiality of the land is to be taken into consideration while assessing the market value – Acquired lands surrounded by Modern Senior Secondary School, Huda Sector 4 residential colony, bus stand, commercial shops, 2566 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Bajrang Nagar residential colony, Parshavnath residential flats, M2K city, Bhagat Singh residential colony and other developed areas – Cannot be disputed that acquired lands had immense potentiality and could have been put to multifarious use.
Case Law Cited BESCO Ltd. v. The State of Haryana and Ors., Civil Appeal No. 5376 of 2023 – relied on.
M/s Habitat Estates Pvt. Ltd. v. The State of Haryana & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 2237 of 2024; New Okhla Industrial Development Authority v. Harnand Singh (Deceased) through Lrs. and Ors., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1691; Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (Registered), Faridkot and Ors. v. State of Punjab and Ors. [2012] 4 SCR 24 : (2012) 5 SCC 432; Peerappa Hanmantha Harijan (Dead) by Legal Representatives and Others v. State of Karnataka and Another [2015] 9 SCR 498 : (2015) 10 SCC 469; Chandrashekar (dead) by LRs and Others v. Land Acquisition Officer and Another [2011] 15 SCR 414 : (2012) 1 SCC 390; Sardara Singh and Others v. Land Acquisition Collector, Improvement Trust, Rupnagar and Others (2020) 14 SCC 483; Bijender and Others v. State of Haryana and Another (2018) 11 SCC 180; Vithal Rao and Another v. Special Land Acquisition Officer [2017] 6 SCR 335 : (2017) 8 SCC 558; Ravinder Narain v. Union of India [2003] 2 SCR 424 : (2003) 4 SCC 481; Atma Singh v. State of Haryana [2007] 12 SCR 1120 : (2008) 2 SCC 568; U.P. Awas Evam Vikash Parishad v. Asha Ram (Dead) through legal representatives and Others [2021] 3 SCR 751 : (2021) 17 SCC 289; Nagpur Improvement Trust & Anr v. Vithal Rao & Anr. [1973] 3 SCR 39 : (1973) 1 SCC 500; Manoj Kumar and Others v. State of Haryana and Others [2017] 8 SCR 997 : (2018) 13 SCC 96 – referred to. List of Acts Land Acquisition Act, 1894; Haryana Urban Development Authority Act, 1977.
List of Keywords Land Acquisition; De-escalation; Enhancement; Potentiality factor; Base value.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s).
4772-4773 of 2025 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2567Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
From the Judgment and Order dated 20.09.2022 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in RFA No. 4240 and 3508 of 2019 With Civil Appeal No(s). 4774, 4775, 4776, 4777, 4778-4782, 4783, 4784, 4785, 4786, 4787, 4788-4793, 4794, 4795, 4796, 4797 and 4798 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Ms. Kavita Wadia, S.B. Upadhyay, Gagan Gupta, Sr. Advs., Varun Kumar, R. C. Kaushik, Sureshan P., Shivam Yadav, Rohan Yadav, Tushar Mahajan, Ajit Kumar Ekka, Nishant Kumar, Ananta Prasad Mishra.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Alok Sangwan, Sr. AAG., Akshay Amritanshu, Ms. Pragya Upadhyay, Ms. Drishti Saraf, Ms. Swati Mishra, Sumit Kumar Sharma, Rajat Sangwan.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. Delay in filing/refiling the Special Leave Petition(s) is condoned.
2. Leave granted.
3. Sixteen1 out of the twenty-seven matters in this batch calls in question the correctness of the judgment passed by a learned Single Judge 1 1. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 5544-5545/2023 (2 Matters)
2. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4044/2023
3. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4051/2023
4. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4045/2023
5. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4058/2023
6. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4052-4056/2023 (5 Matters)
7. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4048/2023
8. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4298/2023
9. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 9166/2023
10. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 15189/2023
11. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 15188/2023 2568 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in RFA No. 701/2022 and batch dated 20.09.2022. By the said judgment, the High Court, for reasons different from those recorded by the Reference Court, maintained the award of Rs. 55,71,010/- per acre as ordered by the Reference Court in its judgment dated 29.07.2019. Holding so, both the appeals of the land losers and the State were dismissed. The land losers are in appeal(s) before us.
THE ELEVEN DIRECTLY COVERED APPEALS 2
4. Out of the twenty-seven matters in the batch, eleven matters pertain to acquisition pursuant to the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short ‘LA Act’) dated 13.05.2010 and notification under Section 6 of LA Act dated 12.05.2011. They pertained to village Malpura and Kapriwas. Insofar as these eleven matters are concerned (arising out of judgment in RFA No. 1625 of 2019 and batch dated 02.11.2021), it is not disputed at the Bar that the same are directly covered by the judgments of this Court in Civil Appeal No. 5376 of 2023 [BESCO Ltd. vs. The State of Haryana and Ors.] and Civil Appeal No. 2237 of 2024 [M/s Habitat Estates Pvt. Ltd. vs. The State of Haryana & Ors.]. The judgments have been delivered by this Court on 23.08.2023 and 13.02.2024 respectively. By the said judgment(s), this Court allowed the appeals of the land losers and enhanced the compensation to Rs. 1,49,14,975/- per acre along with other statutory benefits. Hence, the eleven matters mentioned in this para will be governed by the judgments passed by this Court in BESCO Ltd (Supra) and M/s Habitat Estates Pvt. Ltd. (Supra) and the land losers will be entitled to the same benefits as was ordered by this Court. However, they will not be entitled to interest for the period of delay in filing/delay in refiling after delayed filing of the appeal(s).
2 1. C.A. @ SLP (C) Diary No. 53634/2023 (Total-6 Matters)
2. C.A. @ SLP (C) No. 14904/2024
3. C.A. @ SLP (C) No. 14905/2024
4. C.A. @ SLP (C) No. 14903/2024
5. C.A. @ SLP (C) No. 15529/2024
6. C.A. @ SLP (C) No. 14906/2024 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2569Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
THE OTHER SIXTEEN APPEALS 3 – DHARUHERA VILLAGE
ACQUISITION BY SECTION 4 NOTIFICATION OF 12.12.2008
5. Insofar as the other sixteen matters are concerned, they pertained to acquisition in village Dharuhera and were the subject matter of acquisition by a Section 4 notification, issued on 12.12.2008. By the said notification, lands of the appellants were proposed to be acquired for Institutional Sector 5A under the Haryana Urban Development Authority Act, 1977. The lands were situated in villages Dharuhera, Garhi Alawalpur and Maheshwari, Sub-Tehsil Dharuhera, District Rewari, Haryana. On 11.12.2009, a declaration under Section 6 was issued. The Land Acquisition Collector (‘LAC’ for short), by his award of 30.11.2011, determined the market value of the land at Rs. 21,00,000/- per acre based on the Divisional Level Land Rate Fixation Committee report, though the demand of the landowners was Rs. 2,00,00,000/- per acre. Other statutory benefits were allowed and a total compensation of Rs. 12,46,27,371/- was awarded to all the landowners whose lands were acquired pursuant to notification dated 12.12.2008.
6. The appellants filed petitions under Section 18 of the LA Act, seeking a reference for appropriate enhancement. The reference came to be decided in LAC No. 122 of 2016 and LAC No. 123 of 2016. Principally, it was contended that the State of Haryana has notified Dharuhera Revenue Estate as a Municipal Committee Town in 2007; that the acquired land was located on a prime stretch near developed sectors and industrial areas in Dharuhera and had a significant development potential; that the land is situated very near to the industrial, commercial and residential sectors, already developed by the Haryana Urban Development Authority (for short ‘HUDA’); that the land is adjoining to developed residential and industrial area of Bhiwadi also known as RIICO Industrial and Commercial Complex 3 1. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 5544-5545/2023 (2 Matters)
2. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4044/2023
3. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4051/2023
4. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4045/2023
5. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4058/2023
6. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4052-4056/2023 (5 Matters)
7. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4048/2023
8. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 4298/2023
9. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 9166/2023
10. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 15189/2023
11. C.A. @ SLP(C) Nos. 15188/2023 2570 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Bhiwadi; that the acquired land is situated on the main road of Sectors 4 and 6 of Dharuhera and also on Dharuhera-Bhiwadi-Sohna Road; that HUDA had constructed main sector roads adjoining to sector 4 and 6, fully developed by HUDA from Dharuhera-Bhiwadi NH No. 71B road to Highway No. 8 more than 10 years ago; that the developers have constructed residential multistorey flats spreading over 60 acres; that commercial complexes have also been constructed; that the market price is not less than Rs. 15,000/- per sq. yard for residential flats and commercial/institutional plots; that the land is adjoining State Bank of India and very near to bus stand and Jungle Babbler Tourist Complex of Govt. of Haryana; that the Modern Public School, residential multistorey flats and petrol pumps are situated opposite to the acquired land; that similarly hospitals and a Senior Secondary School and residential complex are located on Highway No. 8, near the acquired land; and that the Director, Town and Country Planning, Haryana notified draft development plan of the Dharuhera town as a residential-cum-commercial and industrial zone on priority basis as the distance to Delhi was only 60 kms. They further contended that the LAC failed to consider the market value of the surrounding location of the already sold land where the value per acre was Rs. 1,80,72,289/- by sale deed dated 13.05.2006 (Exh.PW4/G) and sale deed dated 17.05.2006 (Exh. PW4/C) where the land was sold for Rs.1,00,00,000/- per acre. A site plan Exh.PW6/1 was filed before the Reference Court. We will deal with the site plan a little later in this judgment.
7. At the hearing before the Reference Court, Mr. Motiram, Patwari of LAC Office Gurugram, testified that the land of the appellants were located on Highway No. 8 adjoining to Sector 6 and 4 developed by HUDA at Dharuhera; that the land was adjoining to Bhiwadi (RIICO Industrial Area) which was well developed for many years; though he denied that the market value of the land was Rs. 15,000/ per sq. yard.
ACQUISITIONS IN MALPURA AND KAPRIWAS VILLAGES –
SECTION 4 NOTIFICATION OF 13.05.2010
8. At this stage, we need to digress a bit and deal with the acquisition that was happening in the adjoining villages of Malpura and Kapriwas for development of Dharuhera Industrial Sectors 15, 16 and 17. On 13.05.2010, a Section 4 notification was issued with regard to those areas, followed by a Section 6 declaration on 12.05.2011. For those lands, the LAC, by his award of 10.05.2013, awarded staggered rates [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2571Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
of Rs. 40,000/- per acre, Rs. 48,000/- per acre and Rs. 50,000/per acre, based on the recommendations of the District Collector, Rewari who was a member of the Divisional Level Land Rates Fixation Committee. The land losers filed reference in LAC No. 208 of 2016. By the judgment of 21.11.2018, the Reference Court held that the most relevant sale deed in that reference was Exh.PW4/3, a sale deed executed on 13.08.2008 pertaining to village Malpura near to the lands acquired therein. The sale deed involved lands to the extent of 12 kanals and 2 marlas. The sale consideration was Rs. 2,16,00,000/- (Rs. 1,42,80,960/- per acre). Applying 60% deduction for development costs, the Reference Court fixed the market value at Rs. 67,12,050/- per acre along with statutory benefits. In appropriate cases, compensation for super structure was also awarded.
REFERENCE COURT DECISIONS IN THE DHARUHERA
ACQUISITION
9. Coming back to the land of the appellants in the sixteen matters, their reference LAC No. 122 of 2016 and LAC No. 123 of 2016 came to be decided on 29.07.2019. This reference, in turn, relied on the reasons in Inderpal vs. State of Haryana & Ors. delivered in LAC No. 119 of 2016 which also arose under the same acquisition and notification of 12.12.2008 (Section 4) and 11.12.2009 (Section 6). The Reference Court in LAC No. 119 of 2016 which was the relied upon judgment in LAC No. 122 of 2016 and LAC No. 123 of 2016 had, in turn, relied upon the judgment in LAC No. 208 of 2016 which pertained to acquisition in village Malpura and Kapriwas, pursuant to notification dated 13.05.2010 (under Section 4) and 12.05.2011 (under Section 6). The reasons why the Reference Court relied on LAC No. 208 of 2016 were set out in the following terms:- “16…..This court is alive of Award/Judgments passed by it regarding acquisition of a adjoining village Malpura passed by this court on 21.11.2018 in LA Case No.208 of 2016 titled as ‘Sultan Singh Vs State of Haryana & Others (set of 53 cases) vide which compensation was assessed at the rate of Rs.67,12,050/- (Rupees Sixty- Seven Lac Twelve & Fifty only) per acre, irrespective of the nature of land, in respect of the land of village Malpura, which was acquired for the purpose for development of industrial Sector 15,16 & 17 Dharuhera and present set 2572 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of 18 petitions are for the purpose of development & utilization of institutional sector 5A Dharuhera.
17. Justice cannot be causality in the game of litigation and Court on its own is competent to change the rules of the game to do justice. It was so observed by Hon’ble Delhi High Court in case-law Hoshiar Singh Mann Vs Charan Singh - 2009(162) DLT 208; Law Finder Doc Id#203842.
Hence, this court gone directing the Reader of the court to retrieve from the National eCourts portal (www.ecourts. gov.in) above- referred judgment dated 21.11.2018 of this court passed in LA Case No.208 of 2016 titled as ‘Sultan Singh Vs State of Haryana & Others’ and place it on the records of this case-file and henceforth said judgment would be referred as Exh.C1.
18. Perusal of award dated 21.11.2018 (Exh.C1) passed by this court in LA Case no.208 of 2016 titled as ‘Sultan Singh Vs State of Haryana & Others; notification under Section 4 of the Act in said case was issued on 13.05.2010. The land acquired in Exh.C1 pertains to village Malpura and for the purpose of development of industrial sector- 15, 16 & 17 Dharuhera. The land acquired in present matter is of village Dharuhera for the development & utilization of land as institutional sector-5A Dharuhera. The acquired land in both the matters is for the purpose of development & utilization of sectors Dharuhera, but there is a difference in the date of notification under Section 4 in both the matters as notification in the present case is one year five months prior to the notification’ of award dated 13.05.2010 (Exh.C1). Case-law Harbhajan Kaur Vs Union Territory Chandigarh -2009(9) PLR 520 (P&H) become relevant on this point as therein award for adjoining village was made six months prior and Hon’ble High Court placed reliance thereupon by making reasonable cut of 6% for the time gap in the two notifications. Since basic rule is of 12% increase/decrease and Hon’ble High Court in case-law Harbhajan Kaur (supra) has applied cut of 6% for six month’s time gap, so on that analogy a reasonable cut of 12% can well be applied in the present matter for time gap of one year & five months (17 months) in the two notifications.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2573Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
19. In view of peculiar facts & circumstances of the case, this court has arrived at the conclusion that the acquisition in the present case was made seventeen months prior to the notification pertaining to award Exh.C1. If a Reasonable cut of 12% is applied over Rs.67,12,050/- (compensation awarded in Exh.C1) for the time gap in the two notifications, the value of the acquired land in the present case comes to Rs.55,71,010/- per acre. Accordingly, it is held that the landowners in the present set of petitions shall be entitled to compensation for the acquired land at the rate of Rs.55,71,010/- (Rupees Fifty Five Lac Seventy One Thousand & Ten only) per acre. They shall also be entitled to all the statutory benefits available under the Act and this issue is decided, accordingly.”
(Emphasis supplied)
10. It will be clear from the above reasoning, the Court considered placing reliance on award in LAC No. 208 of 2016 pertaining to the adjoining village of Malpura will not be mechanical for the reason that acquisition was for development of industrial sectors 15, 16 & 17 Dharuhera whereas in LAC No. 119 of 2016 (similar to LAC No. 122 of 2016 and LAC No. 123 of 2016) is for development and utilization of Institutional Sector 5A Dharuhera. Considering the difference in the date, the Court applied the principle of reverse deduction and fixed the compensation at Rs. 55,71,010/- per acre along with statutory benefits for the land losers in LAC No. 119 of 2016 (similar to LAC No. 122 of 2016 and LAC No. 123 of 2016).
11. The land losers in the present appeal(s) filed appeal in RFA No. 4240 of 2019 and batch before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana. The State of Haryana also filed appeals challenging the award in Inderpal case (Supra) in RFA No. 701 of 2022.
HIGH COURT PROCEEDINGS IN THE MALPURA-KAPRIWAS
ACQUISITIONS
12. Simultaneously, there were developments before the High Court in the Regular First Appeals filed by the land losers and the beneficiary in the reference arising out of LAC No. 208 of 2016. In the said RFAs, namely, RFA No. 1350 of 2019 and RFA No. 3991 of 2019, the High Court allowed the appeal(s) of the land losers on 02.11.2021under 2574 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the notification of 13.05.2010 (Section 4) and dismissed the cross objections of the beneficiary and enhanced the compensation from Rs. 67,12,050/- per acre to Rs. 1,21,33,320/- per acre. The High Court held as follows:- “4.12 Keeping in view the aforesaid discussion, it is evident that the Reference Court has committed an error in deducting 60% from the sale exemplar produced by the landowners and relied upon by it.”
4.15 ……In the considered view of this Court, once the land measuring 12 Kanals & 2 Marlas, which is more than one and a half acre, located across the National Highway (theeastern side of the National Highway) has been sold @ ₹ 1,42,80,916/- per acre, then, it was not appropriate for the Reference Court to apply 60% cut. One and a half acre of land is not a small area of land. Further, the acquired land cannot be said to be used only for agricultural purposes particularly when the companies have started purchasing the same. In fact, Delta Cables Limited has purchased the land measuring, 12 kanals & 2 Marlas.
4.16 From a careful perusal of the layout plan (Ex.R12) along with the sale deeds, it becomes evident that the sale instance (Ex.P2) is with respect to the land measuring 6 Kanals & 19 Marlas. This is with respect to the land comprised in rectangle No. 49, 50, 51 and 52, located in village Kapriwas, which has also been acquired under the same notification. The layout plan clearly shows that the aforesaid parcel of land is abutting the boundary of village Malpura. In fact, there is no physical boundary between the villages. It is only a notional/fictional boundary so as to identify the land located in different villages. Furthermore, it is evident that in village Malpura, the land abutting the Delhi-Jaipur Highway upto the depth of approximately 10 acres has been acquired. It is significant to note that the land in village Malpura was sold @ ₹ 1,42,80,991/- per acre vide a sale deed dated 13.08.2008 (Ex.PW.4/3). However, this parcel of the land is comprised in rectangle No. 29 and khasra No. 4 & 5, which is on the other side (western side) i.e. across the National Highway-8. Although this parcel of land is not comparable however, it corroborates [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2575Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
Ex.P2 with respect to the market value of the acquired land. Moreover, in additional evidence, the landowners have produced the sale instance dated 15.02.2010 with respect to the land measuring 5 Kanals & 2 Marlas sold @ ₹ 2,23,72,463/- per acre. This parcel of the land is also located on the western side of the National Highway-8 and at some distance from the acquired land.
4.17 Since the most appropriate sale exemplar appears to be Ex.P2, which is not only abutting the acquired land but also forms a part of the acquired land, therefore, it is safe to rely upon the same. However, the sale instance is of 19.06.2008, whereas the notification under Section 4 of the 1894 Act was issued on 13.05.2010. The Court is required to determine the market value of the acquired land as on 13.05.2010. From a careful perusal of the sale exemplar (Ex.PW4/3) and the sale deed produced in additional evidence (Ex.PY), it becomes evident that the price of the land was increasing quite rapidly. The location of the acquired land is prime. In fact, the Industrial Estate of Dharuhera has already been developed and a lot of builders/developers/industrialists have already started purchasing the properties in and around the Industrial Estate of Dharuhera. Hence, it will be safe to assume that the market value of the land was increasing @ 10% per annum. Taking into consideration the aforesaid facts, the amount arrived at comes to ₹1,21,33,320/- per acre. The Court is expected to take a pragmatic view while assessing the market value, particularly when the parcel of land covered by Ex.P2, although situated in village Kapriwas, is abutting the acquired land of village Malpura. The land sold through Ex.P2 has also been acquired Hence, the market value of the land is assessed at ₹1,21,33,320/- per acre.”
(Emphasis supplied)
13. Ultimately, the High Court with regard to the lands pertaining to acquisition made under the notification of 13.05.2010 (Section 4) fixed the compensation at Rs. 1,21,33,320/- per acre along with other statutory benefits. Holding so, it allowed the appeal(s) of the 2576 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports land losers and dismissed the cross objection of the beneficiary. The same result followed in RFA No. 3091 No. 2019 (HSIIDC v. Deepak Kumar & Ors.)
14. The land losers under the notification of 13.05.2010 (Section 4) who were ordered to be paid Rs. 1,21,33,320/- per acre, aggrieved, filed Special Leave Petition (C) No. 4487 of 2022 & batch and Special Leave Petition (C) No. 6127 of 2022 and batch before this Court which was later converted to Civil Appeal No. 5376 of 2023 and Civil Appeal 2237 of 2024 respectively.
H I G H C O U R T P R O C E E D I N G S I N T H E D H A R U H E R A
ACQUISITIONS:- PRESENT APPEALS
15. Pending those appeals in this Court, the High Court took up the appeals (RFA) of the landowners in the present appeals. Since the Reference Court had found justification for reliance on the award in LAC No. 208 of 2016 (arising out of acquisition notification 13.05.2010 with appropriate reverse deduction), the land losers pointed out to the High Court that in those matters there has been further enhancement from Rs. 67,12,050/- to Rs. 1,21,33,320/- and wanted at least parity, if not a further increase. The High Court held that there was no evidence to prove that the acquired land in village Malpura vide notification dated 13.05.2010 was comparable in its geographical location, valuation and other factors and hence the Reference Court erred in placing reliance on the award in LAC No. 208 of 2016.
16. The High Court also faulted the Reference Court for not considering the sale deeds produced by the parties including sale deeds which reflected a price lesser than the amount offered by the LAC. The High Court referred to the layout plan produced by the State and relied on Exh. PW4/D dated 02.05.2006 and rejected the other sale deeds and after applying cumulative increase @ 12% per year from the sale deed amount of Rs. 40,55,000/- per acre, arrived at a figure of Rs. 54,42,653/-. Thereafter, the High Court concluded that the awarded amount by the Reference Court of Rs. 55,71,010/- was broadly the same. For reasons other than the one adduced by the Reference Court, the High Court confirmed the judgment of the Reference Court and dismissed the appeals of the landowners as well as the State. Aggrieved, the landowners are in appeal(s). [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2577Ram Kishan (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs Etc. v. State of Haryana & Ors.
PROCEEDINGS IN THIS COURT IN THE MALPURA-KAPRIWAS
ACQUISITION
17. In the meantime, this Court, by its judgment of 23.08.2023 and 13.02.2024 decided Civil Appeal No. 5376 of 2023 and Civil Appeal No. 2237 of 2024 and enhanced the compensation with respect to lands acquired in village Malpura vide notification dated 13.05.2010 and village Kapriwas from the awarded amount of Rs. 1,21,33,320/- to Rs. 1,49,14,975/- per acre along with statutory benefits. This Court held that the applicable deduction should be 33% and not 60% and enhanced the compensation to Rs. 1,49,14,975/-. During the course of the discussion, this Court observed as follows:
“The landowners based on the potential of the acquired land claim commensurate market value as of 13.05.2010. The acquired land is in a controlled area declared by the State of Haryana. Industrial Estate Dharuhera, Primary School at Village Maheshwari, Ghatal Mahaniawas and Aakera are at a proximate distance. The acquired land is claimed as situated in the industrial zone at Sector 15, Dharuhera. Apart from the advantageous neighborhood of establishments and industries, the land under acquisition is located alongside National Highway No. 8, i.e., Delhi- Jaipur Highway and Industrial Sectors 15, 16 & 17. Further, land sectors 8, 9, 10, 12 & 13 are opposite the industrial sectors of 17 and 16 across National Highway No. 8. Many development activities have occurred in and around the land acquired. The landowners refer to the existence of industrial units such as Penam Labs, U.B. Group, Capsu Gel, Weston, Hero Motors Ltd., RIICO, Omax, Sona Koya, M. Teck, Bestech, Utility Engineering, Luthra, IST etc. within a radius of 1 k.m. of the acquired land. The acquired land had change in land use (CLU) under the Punjab Scheduled Roads and Controlled Areas Restriction of Unregulated Development Act, 1963. The gist is that the acquired land cannot be treated as an agricultural land.”
CONTENTIONS IN THE PRESENT APPEALS
18. We have heard Mr. S. B. Upadhyay, Ms. Kavita Wadia and Mr. Gagan Gupta, Learned Senior Counsels for the appellants and Mr. Alok Sangwan, Learned Additional Advocate General for the respondents. 2578 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.