State of Sikkim and Others v. Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 559; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2347
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari, Justice Rajesh Bindal
- Decided
- 23 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5464/2025
- Sections
- 29
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2347 : 2025 INSC 559 State of Sikkim and Others v.
Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal (Civil Appeal No(s). 5464-5465 of 2025)
23 April 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari* and Rajesh Bindal, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether an employee of the State who had availed the benefit of leave encashment maximum of 300 days once on attaining the age of superannuation under Rule 36 of Sikkim Government Services (Leave) Rules, 1982, can further be entitled for leave encashment again on relieving after the period of re-employment.
Headnotes† Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974 – rr.98, 102 – Sikkim Government Services (Leave) Rules, 1982 – rr.6, 17, 31, 32, 36 – Grant of benefit of leave encashment second time for the period of re-employment of respondent after attaining the age of superannuation, in particular beyond the maximum period of 300 days as prescribed – Respondent filed writ petition challenging the cancellation of the order to grant leave encashment and directing payment of sum as sanctioned – Allowed by Single Judge relying upon Rule 36 read with Rule 32 of Leave Rules, declaring him entitled for grant of leave encashment again for unutilized leave during the period of re-employment – Appeal by the State, dismissed by Division Bench – Interference with:
Held: 1.1 Under Rule 36 of Leave Rules, a regular government servant, if retires under Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974 would be entitled for leave encashment maximum for 300 days – If the government servant is re-employed after 58 years of age and continued for a long time and gets leaves accumulated during the period of re-employment, he/she cannot get benefit of leave encashment second time merely because he/she is having leave in his/her credit during the period of re-employment. [Para 33] * Author 2348 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1.2 Leave Rule 32 does not ipso facto deal with the applicability of Leave Rule 36 for grant of leave encashment – Single Judge was not correct to interpret Rule 32 and 36 by applying deeming fiction for the re-employed government servant – Hence, those findings cannot be countenanced, and the Division Bench erred in affirming the same. [Para 24] 1.3 Leave Rules recognize benefit of leave encashment to a government servant whose service has been extended and who has retired from regular service under the Service Rules, but not to the re-employed retired government servant – Therefore, the leave encashment is permissible maximum upto 300 days of leave and not beyond as on the date of retirement, including the case of extension of service. [Para 29] 1.4 Clarificatory order issued by State in the matter of grant of leave encashment for the earned leave to government employees on ‘extension of service’ subject to maximum period of 300 days and not beyond, is completely in consonance with the spirit of Rules 31, 32 and 36 of Leave Rules. [Para 30] 1.5 In the present case, the respondent was in the regular employment and superannuated on completion of 58 years of age on 31.01.2005 under Service Rules – He was granted benefit of leave encashment maximum of 300 days under Rule 36 of the Leave Rules – On re-employment, he was continued for more than 14 years and relieved on 28.05.2019 – On relieving after re employment, the benefit of leave encashment was again sanctioned on 31.05.2019 – The government on realising the mistake and interplay of Rules 32 and 36 with the spirit of the Leave Rules, issued clarificatory order on 27.02.2020 denying the benefit of leave encashment beyond 300 days, is in consonance with the spirit of Rule 36, which is just and reasonable to the extent indicated – Therefore, cancellation of sanction of leave encashment order dated 31.05.2019 is also in consonance to the law – Orders passed by Single Judge and the Division Bench set aside. [Paras 31, 33] Service Law – Leave encashment – Purpose of granting, stated – Principle of deferred compensation – Discussed – Sikkim Government Services (Leave) Rules, 1982 – r.36.
[Paras 25-29] [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2349The State of Sikkim v. Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974 – rr.98, 102 – Sikkim Government Services (Leave) Rules, 1982 – rr.6, 17, 31, 32, 36 – Interplay of, explained. [Paras 17-23] Case Law Cited State of Rajasthan and Another v. Senior Higher Secondary School, Lacchmangarh and Others (2005) 10 SCC 346 – referred to. List of Acts Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974; Sikkim Government Services (Leave) Rules, 1982.
List of Keywords Leave Encashment; Benefit of leave encashment; Superannuation; Leave encashment on relieving after re-employment; Regular government servant; Benefit of leave encashment second time; Re-employed retired government servant; Extension of service; Clarificatory order; Grant of leave encashment; Encashment of unutilized earned leave.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s).
5464-5465 of 2025 In Special Leave Petition (C) No(s). 23709-23710 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.04.2023 and 08.09.2022 of the High Court of Sikkim at Gangtok in WA No. 08 of 2022 and WPC No. 14 of 2022 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Sameer Abhyankar, Ms. Ayushi Bansal, Sarthak Dora, Krishna Rastogi, Aakash Thakur.
Advs. for the Respondent:
A. Mariarputham, Sr. Adv., Ms. Anuradha Arputham, Ms. Samten Doma Lachungpa.
2350 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.K. Maheshwari J.
1. Leave granted.
2. Assailing the order dated 27.04.2023 passed in Writ Appeal No. 8 of 2022 confirming the order dated 08.09.2022 passed in Writ Petition (C) No. 14 of 2022, by High Court of Sikkim at Gangtok, the State of Sikkim (in short ‘State’) has filed these appeals. The discord between the parties is regarding grant of benefit of leave encashment second time for the period of re-employment of respondent after attaining the age of superannuation, in particular beyond the maximum period of 300 days as prescribed.
3. Being aggrieved by the order dated 21.05.2020 cancelling the order dated 31.05.2019 to grant leave encashment and directing payment of sum as sanctioned, the respondent preferred writ petition before the High Court. Learned Single Judge allowed the same relying upon Rule 36 read with Rule 32 of ‘Sikkim Government Services (Leave) Rules, 1982’ (in short ‘Leave Rules’), declaring him entitled for grant of leave encashment again for unutilized leave during the period of re-employment. On filing the Writ Appeal by State, it came to be dismissed by the impugned order. Hence the present appeals by State challenging both orders passed by learned Single Judge and Division Bench.
FACTS IN BRIEF
4. Prequel to the present litigation, the respondent was appointed on deputation in year 1980 in the State services. On attaining the age of superannuation 1 , he retired on 31.01.2005 in terms of Rule 98 2 of Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974 (in short ‘Service Rules’) from the post of ‘Medical Advisor and Chief Consultant’, working at Sir Thutob Namgyal Memorial (STNM) Hospital, in Health Care, Human Services and Family Welfare Department, Government of Sikkim at 1 58 years.
2 Retirement on superannuation.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2351The State of Sikkim v. Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal Gangtok. Upon his retirement and while settling post retiral benefits, he was paid leave encashment maximum of 300 days unutilized leave as prescribed in Rule 363 of Leave Rules.
5. After retirement, the respondent was re-employed on the same post for a period of 2 years, w.e.f. from 01.02.2005 to 31.05.2005, which was extended time to time upto 28.05.2019, i.e., the date on which he was officially relieved. Vide Office Order No. 710/G/DOP dated 31.05.2019 (in short ‘2019 office order’), he was allowed cash equivalent to leave salary of 300 days of earned leave standing to his credit for the period of re-employment.
6. The controversy was set into motion when the State on scrutiny found that the Leave Rules do not provide for grant of leave encashment to the re-employed employees second time beyond 300 days, which was paid to them once on their retirement. It was noticed that, leave encashment was being paid to the employees after their retirement and ‘again’ after relieving from re-employment, though it was not in conformity to the Leave Rules. The State Government took a decision to correct the perpetual mistake and issued Office Memorandum No. 4528/GEN/DOP, dated 27.02.2020 (the “clarificatory order”), clarifying that maximum of 300 days of leave encashment specified in Rule is inclusive of the period of leave earned during extension of service, re-employment etc. The said clarification is pivotal to the controversy involved, hence, reproduced as under – “GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL
GANGTOK
No. 4528/GEN/DOP Dated: 27/02/2020
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: Clarification on leave encashment of earned leave to Government Employees on Extension of Service, Re-Employment etc.
Rule 36 of the Sikkim Service (Leave) Rules, 1982 provides to a government employee who retires from service 3 Cash payment in lieu of unutilized earned leave on the date of retirement. 2352 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports under the Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974, cash equivalent of leave salary in lieu of earned leave on full day standing at his/her credit on the date of his retirement subject to a minimum of 300 days. Therefore, a maximum of 300 days of earned leave due at credit also includes the period of leave earned by a Government Employee during extension of service, Reemployment etc.
This issues with the approval of Competent Authority.
Sd/- (Tashi Cho Cho) SCS SPECIAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT”
7. After clarification, on 31.05.2019, order extending the benefit of cash equivalent to leave salary in lieu of 300 days of unutilized leave standing at the credit of Mr. M.R. Kotwal, Principal Medical Advisor (Petitioner before High Court/Respondent herein) during the period of his re-employment was cancelled vide order dated 21.05.2020 passed by the Government of Sikkim, Department of Personnel, Gangtok. The representation made by the respondent was also rejected on 18.02.2022 and the Chief Accounts Officer, Home Department, Government of Sikkim, vide letter No. GOS/Home/Acctt./726 dated 21.03.2022 sent the information that payment of leave encashment as prayed by the respondent cannot be released. That is how the dispute arose, and litigation commenced.
8. Being aggrieved, the respondent preferred Writ Petition (C) No. 14 of 2022 seeking writ in the nature of mandamus and prayed for quashment of the Office Order No. 493/G/DOP dated 21.05.2020 issued by Department of Personnel, Government of Sikkim, and letter no. GOS/Home/Actt./726 dated 21.03.2022 and to declare that the respondent is entitled to receive Rs. 20,51,100/- towards leave encashment alike similarly placed other re-employed employees.
9. Learned Single Judge allowed the Writ Petition observing that Leave Rule 36 should be read in conjunction with Rule 32, making the Leave Rules applicable to the re-employed government servants. The phrase ‘retires from service’ in Rule 36 is broad enough and includes the re-employed employees. It is noted that after an order allowing to receive cash equivalent for 300 days, withdrawal of such benefit by a subsequent office memorandum is arbitrary. The clarificatory [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2353The State of Sikkim v. Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal order couldn’t nullify the right accrued to the petitioner. While allowing the Writ Petition, the Court did not accept the argument of the State about financial burden because other similarly placed employees have been extended similar benefit of second time leave encashment.
10. Being aggrieved, the appellants preferred the writ appeal which came to be dismissed by the Division Bench observing that Rule 32 of the Leave Rules creates a legal fiction treating re-employed and regular employee at par as if former had entered into service for the first time, and made the Leave Rules applicable, and consequently held that Rule 36 applies to re-employed government servants also. The Court refused to interfere with the judgment of learned Single Judge and noted that no palpable infirmity or perversity warranting interference in intra-court appeal is made out.
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED BY APPELLANT – STATE
11. Mr. Sameer Abhyankar, learned counsel representing the appellants extensively urged that Leave Rule 36 prescribes leave encashment maximum of 300 days after retirement on attaining the age of superannuation as specified in Service Rules. It was noticed that employees who were re-employed after retirement were availing benefit of leave encashment of the leave available in their credit after being relieved. On examining the issue, the government found that grant of such benefit is not as per the spirit of Rule 36 of Leave Rules, therefore, issued the office memorandum dated 27.02.2020 clarifying the same. In consequence to the clarificatory order, the benefit of leave encashment allowed to the respondent was cancelled vide order dated 21.05.2020. Accordingly, after availing the benefit of leave encashment of maximum of 300 days on retirement, he was not found entitled to same benefit for the period of re-employment. He submitted that the findings of learned Single Judge in reference to Rule 36, re-affirmed by the Division Bench are not in conformity to the real intent and object to grant benefit of leave encashment under Rules to the retired employees. Rule 32 and Rule 36 of Leave Rules deal with different spheres and they cannot be read in conjunction, therefore, the interpretation as made in the impugned judgment is not correct. On independent reading of Leave Rule 36, it is clear that a person who has attained the age of retirement as per Service Rules, i.e., 58 years, would be entitled for leave encashment maximum up to 300 days. The said rule does not deal with relieving after the 2354 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports re-employment, rather, it merely deals with contingency of grant of leave encashment on retirement of an employee under Service Rules. Therefore, the findings as recorded by the learned Single Judge and affirmed by the Division Bench misinterpreting the formula of granting leave encashment to an employee after retirement, require due indulgence and interference in these appeals and interpretation of the rules in right perspective.
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED BY RESPONDENT – EMPLOYEE
12. Per contra, learned senior counsel Mr. A. Mariarputham for the respondent submits that on relieving from re-employment, sanction of leave encashment was allowed vide office order dated 31.05.2019. The same was cancelled vide order dated 21.05.2020 relying on the office memorandum dated 27.02.2020, without notice and affording an opportunity of hearing. Further, the rejection of representation is discriminatory and violates Article 14 of the Constitution of India because similarly situated other re-employed relieved employees have been allowed the same benefits. In addition, the order cancelling the benefit of leave encashment is in violation of the principles of natural justice and without affording opportunity of hearing, the action of the State was unfair which has rightly been interfered with by the High Court.
13. It is further urged that Rule 32 applies to the re-employed government servants alike an employee entered into service at first instance. Leave Rule 36 also applies to the employees on whom Leave Rules are applicable, however, on conjoint reading, the grant of benefit of leave encashment, again to re-employed employee is not prohibited. Thus, pretext taken to rectify the mistake by the State Government cannot defeat the right of the re-employed employees conferred under the Leave Rules. It is urged that two Courts have rightly dealt with the interplay of Rules 32 and 36 of Leave Rules and it does not call for any interference.
ANALYSIS AND REASONINGS
14. After having heard learned counsels at length and on perusal of the material, in our view, the short question falls for our consideration is, ‘whether an employee of the State who had availed the benefit of leave encashment maximum of 300 days once on attaining the age of superannuation under Rule 36 of Leave Rules, can further [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2355The State of Sikkim v. Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal be entitled for leave encashment again on relieving after the period of re-employment?’
15. Prior to adverting to the issue and the submissions on merits, it is necessary to refer the relevant Rules governing the controversy involved in the present case. The retirement on attaining the age of superannuation has been prescribed in the Service Rules and the relevant Rules are reproduced below for ready reference – “Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974
98. Retirement on Superannuation –
(1) The date of retirement on superannuation of any Government Servant in the regular service shall be the afternoon of the last day of the month in which he attains the age of 58 years. The Government retains the right to change the prescribed age of retirement.
Provided that the Government Servant who had attained the age of 58 years or more on the date of issue of this Notification shall retire from the service with effect from the afternoon of 31 st October 1983.
xx xx xx xx Explanation. – For the purpose of this rule, a Government Servant whose date of birth falls on the first day of any month shall have attained the age of fifty-eight years on the afternoon of the last day of the preceding month.
xx xx xx xx
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.