State (Cbi) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 376; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 156
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 19 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1681/2009
- Sections
- 3, 15, 3(1), 19, 3(2), 160, 365, 3(3), 4(2), 302, 32, 34
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 156 : 2025 INSC 376 State (CBI)
v.
Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No. 1681 of 2009)
20 March 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the correctness of judgment and order of the Special Court acquitting the respondents for offences under Ranbir Penal Code, 1932 and Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987.
Headnotes† Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 – ss.3, 4, 15, 19 – TADA Rules – r.15 – Recording of confessional statement – Non-compliance – Effect – Complaint alleging that Vice Chancellor of Kashmir University and his Personal Secretary were kidnapped by armed terrorists from their official car and subsequently, their dead bodies were recovered – Investigation by CBI revealed that the self-styled Chief Commander of banned militant organization, Jammu & Kashmir Students Liberation Front-JKSLF, along with other members, including accused, entered into a conspiracy to kidnap the deceased to strike terror in the minds of the public, thereby to compel the Government to release their associates, and execution of the hostages if their demands were not met – As the Government did not comply with their demand, hostages were taken to a field where accused-respondent no. 1 fired upon with AK-47 rifle causing multiple bullet injuries on their persons resulting in their death – Special Court discarded the ocular evidence and confessional statements of the accused being inadmissible in evidence and acquitted the accused holding that the prosecution could not prove the guilt of the accused beyond any reasonable doubt – Correctness:
Held: Testimony of the prosecution witnesses coupled with non-recovery of the weapon of offence seriously damaged the prosecution case – As regards recording of confessional statement of respondent no. 1, there is clear departure from the norms which * Author [2025] 4 S.C.R. 157State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors. renders the confession highly suspect – Record does not contain any statement in the form of questions and answers wherefrom it could be deciphered that respondent no.1 was making the confession voluntarily – Hardly any or no time for reflection was given which vitiated the said confessional statement – Also discrepancy in the date of recording of the confessional statement – This very confessional statement of respondent no.1 was deemed inadmissible and unreliable and rejected by the Special Court in a prior case – Acceptance of the same confessional statement of respondent No.1 would disturb the finding of fact already recorded in the previous criminal trial relating to killing of one – Also, said statement clearly vitiated by non-compliance with the procedural safeguards provided u/r.15 – Furthermore, confessional statements of respondent no.2 and respondent no.6 recorded in the same manner as the confessional statement of respondent no.1, hardly any or no time was given to them for reflection before recording confessional statement – Most crucial ommission completely vitiated the said two confessional statements – Procedural safeguards for recording confessional statement of accused given a complete gobye – Special Court has stopped short of observing that it was a case of abuse of power and authority – No error or infirmity in the view taken by the Special Court in acquitting the respondents – Ranbir Penal Code, 1932 – ss.118, 120-B, 302, 341, 364, 368, 365 – Arms Act, 1959 – s.3/25. [Paras 11, 22.1-22.3, 24, 25, 25.1, 27, 28] Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 – s.15 – TADA Rules – r.15 – Provisions dealing with recording of confessional statement – Explained. [Paras 13, 14] Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 – ss.3(1), 19 – Incident relating to kidnapping and subsequent murder of General Manager of a company in Srinagar allegedly by the respondents after entering into a criminal conspiracy to strike terror in the minds of the general public and thereby to compel the Government to release their associates – Special Court acquitted the respondents for the offences u/s.3(1) of the TADA Act rw ss.120B, 302, 368 and 364 of the RPC – Challenge to:
Held: Weapon of assault not recovered and eyewitnesses deposed that the respondents produced in court were not the accused persons – Entire prosecution case centered around the confessional statement of accused SZ which has already been rejected. [Paras 32, 33] 158 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab [1994] 2 SCR 375 : (1994) 3 SCC 569 – followed.
Sharafat Hussain Abdul Rahaman Shaikh v. State of Gujarat [1996] Supp. 9 SCR 86 : (1996) 11 SCC 62; SN Dubey v. NB Bhoir [2000] 1 SCR 200 : (2000) 2 SCC 254; Ahmed Hussein Vali Mohammed. Saiyed v. State of Gujarat [2009] 8 SCR 719 : (2009) 7 SCC 254; Yakub Abdul Razak Memon v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 15 SCR 1 : (2013) 13 SCC 1; Raja v. State of Tamil Nadu [2020] 4 SCR 1112 : (2020) 5 SCC 118; Ravinder Singh v. Sukhbir Singh [2013] 1 SCR 243 : (2013) 9 SCC 245 – referred to.
List of Acts Ranbir Penal Code, 1932; Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987; TADA Rules; Arms Act, 1959.
List of Keywords Recording of confessional statement; Vice Chancellor of Kashmir University and his Personal Secretary kidnapped by armed terrorists; Self-styled Chief Commander of banned militant organization called Jammu & Kashmir Students Liberation Front; Kidnap to strike terror in the minds of the public; Execution of hostages; Multiple bullet injuries; Ocular evidence; Confessional statements; Inadmissible in evidence; Testimony of the prosecution witnesses; Non-recovery of weapon of offence; No time for reflection before recording confessional statement; Kidnapping and murder of General Manager of HMT watch company, Srinagar; Weapon of assault; Conspiracy; Safeguards for confessional statements; AK-47 rifle.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
1681 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.04.2009 of the High Court of Jammu and Kashmir in RC No. 5 of 1990 With Criminal Appeal No. 1770 of 2009 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 159State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors. Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. Sonia Mathur, Sr. Adv., Ms. Shubhi Bhardwaj, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Annam Venkatesh, Zoheb Hussain, Rajat Nair, Vivek Gurnani.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Kamini Jaiswal, Ms. Rani Mishra, Abani Sahu.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
Criminal Appeal No. 1681 of 2009 This is an appeal under Section 19 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 by the State (CBI) assailing the judgment and order dated 20.04.2009 passed by the 3 rd Addl. Sessions Judge, Jammu (briefly ‘the Special Court’ hereinafter). By the aforesaid judgment and order, the Special Court acquitted the respondents in CBI Case No. RC 5(S)/1990 for the offences under Sections 118, 302, 368 and 365 of the Ranbir Penal Code, 1932 (RPC) and under Sections 3 and 4 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987, hereinafter referred to as the TADA Act (since repealed).
2. Genesis of the case can be traced to FIR No. 55/1990 registered at Police Station Nageen, Srinagar under Sections 364, 341 and 120-B of RPC read with Section 3(2) of the TADA Act. The FIR was lodged on the basis of a complaint filed by Shri Ghulam Nabi Dar, a driver of Kashmir University. Informant alleged that on 06.04.1990 at about 04.20 pm, Dr. Mushir-ul-Haq, Vice Chancellor of Kashmir University, and his Personal Secretary Shri Abdul Gani Zargar were kidnapped by armed terrorists from their official car outside the Sadarbal Gate of the University. After taking them in the said vehicle for a short distance towards Lal Bazar on Sadarbal Road, they were shifted to a red Maruti van and taken away.
2.1 Subsequently, dead bodies of Dr. Mushir-ul-Haq and Shri Abdul Gani Zargar were recovered on 10.04.1990. As a result, Section 160 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 302 RPC and Section 3/25 of the Arms Act, 1959 (‘Arms Act’ hereinafter) were added to the FIR.
2.2 Investigation of the case was transferred to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) on the request of the Jammu and Kashmir Government. On the CBI taking over investigation, the case was re-registered as RC 5 (S)/90-SIU.V on 21.04.1990 under Sections 302, 341 and 364 RPC read with Section 3 of the TADA Act and Sections 3/25 of the Arms Act.
2.3 Investigation revealed that Hilal Beg was the self-styled Chief Commander of a banned militant organization called Jammu & Kashmir Students Liberation Front (JKSLF). He along with other members of JKSLF, including accused Javed Shala, Tahir Ahmed Mir, Mushtaq Ahmed Sheikh, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan, Mohd. Hussain Khan and Mohd. Salim Zargar entered into a conspiracy between 31.03.1990 and 06.04.1990 to kidnap Dr. Mushir-ul-Haq, the Vice-Chancellor of Kashmir University and others to strike terror in the minds of the public, thereby to compel the Government to release their associates, viz, Nissar Ahmed Jogi, Gulam Nabi Bhat and Fayyaz Ahmed Wani. The conspiracy included execution of the hostages if their demands were not met.
2.4 On 06.04.1990, at approximately 09.00 a.m., the accused persons grouped together at Aftab’s house. They left the house of Aftab in a red Maruti van bearing registration No. JKD-9394 and proceeded towards Kashmir University. They were fully armed. At about 01.20 p.m., the accused persons saw the car of the Vice-Chancellor coming out of the University campus towards the Sadarbal Gate. The vehicle had to stop as the gate was being opened. As it came out from the gate, some of the accused persons forcibly got inside the car of the Vice- Chancellor brandishing their weapons. They overpowered the driver, the Vice-Chancellor, his Personal Secretary and Jamadar, Malook Khan. The vehicle of the Vice-Chancellor was driven towards the Sadarbal side followed by accused Javed Shala and Mushtaq Sheikh in the red Maruti van.
2.5 After travelling some distance, the said vehicle was stopped whereafter the accused persons forced the Vice-Chancellor and his Personal Secretary to come out of the car. The Vice- [2025] 4 S.C.R. 161State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors. Chancellor and his Personal Secretary were thereafter taken to the red Maruti van. Subsequently the two kidnapped persons were taken to different locations and ultimately were taken to the residence of Mohd. Sadiq Rather at Natipura. From there the two kidnapped persons were shifted to the house of accused Shabir where they were kept confined.
2.6 Accused Hilal Beg claimed responsibility for the abduction of Dr. Mushir-ul-Haq, the Vice-Chancellor, and his Personal Secretary Abdul Gani Zargar. In this connection, accused Hilal Beg issued a press release.
2.7 As the Government did not comply with their demand, accused Hilal Beg and his associates convened a meeting on 09.04.1990 at 03.00 p.m. to decide the fate of the hostages.
2.8 On 10.04.1990, the two hostages were taken to a field. Accused Salim Zargar fired upon with an AK-47 rifle causing multiple bullet injuries on their persons as a result of which both of them died on the spot. Local police came to the crime scene and recovered 9 empty cartridges of an AK-47 rifle but the AK-47 rifle could not be recovered. On conclusion of investigation (after transfer of the same to the CBI), charge sheet was filed implicating Hilal Beg, Javed Ahmed Shala, Mushtaq Ahmed Sheikh, Mohd. Salim Zargar, Mohd. Hussain Khan, Aftab Lach Khan, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan, Shabir Butt, Hilal Sheikh, Mohammad Ashraf Butt and Gulam Qadir Mir as the accused for committing an offence under Sections 120B read with Section 365 RPC. All the above, except Aftab Lach Khan, were accused of committing an offence punishable under Sections 3(1) and 3(3) of the TADA Act. Accused Aftab Lach Khan was charged with committing an offence under Section 3(3) of the TADA Act. Additionally, Hilal Beg, Javed Ahmed Shala, Mushtaq Ahmed Sheikh, Mohd. Salim Zargar, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan and Tahir Mir were charged under Section 4(2) of the TADA Act. Accused Mohd. Salim Zargar was further charged for committing an offence punishable under Section 302 RPC while accused Hilal Beg was charged under Section 32 read with Section 34 of the RPC.
3. Vide order dated 22.04.2000 accused Abdul Aziz Dar, Gulam Qadir Mir, Shabir Ahmed Bhat, Mohd. Sadiq Rather, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan 162 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and Mohd. Salim Zargar (respondents in the present appeal) were charged for committing an offence under Sections 118/302/368/365 of the RPC read with Sections 3/4 of the TADA Act.
3.1 Accused denied their guilt and claimed to be tried. One of the accused persons Tahir Ahmed Mir was discharged on the same day but proceedings were initiated against the other accused persons. During pendency of the trial, accused Hilal Beg passed away.
3.2 To prove its case, prosecution examined a number of witnesses. After considering the evidence and other materials on record, the Special Court vide the judgment and order dated 20.04.2009 acquitted the accused persons holding that the prosecution could not prove the guilt of the accused beyond any reasonable doubt. The Special Court discarded the ocular evidence of PW-2, PW-3 and PW-6 as well as the confessional statements of the accused which were held to be inadmissible in evidence.
4. Aggrieved thereby, appellant (State) has approached this Court by filing criminal appeal under Section 19 of the TADA Act, being Crl. Appl. No. 1681/2009. Crl. Appl. No. 1681/2009 was admitted by this Court vide the order dated 28.08.2009.
5. We have heard Mrs. Sonia Mathur, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant and Ms. Kamini Jaiswal, learned counsel for the respondents.
6. Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant-State submits that the Special Court relied on a previous decision dated 21.12.2002 in the case of State through CBI Vs. Mohd. Salim Zargar wherein the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar was held to be inadmissible. In the present proceedings, besides the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar, there were confessional statements of two other accused persons, namely, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan and Mohd. Sadiq Rather. However, the confessional statements of both the accused persons were rejected due to the following reasons: i) No statements in the form of questions and answers were recorded by the Recording Officer to conclude that his satisfaction was based on sound material;
ii) No record was maintained by the Recoding Officer to ascertain if the confessional statement was voluntary; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 163State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors. iii) No effort was made to find out if any other Superintendent of Police was available to record the confessional statements; iv) No letter was written by the Investigating Officer to the Recording Officer requesting the later to record the confessional statements of the aforesaid two accused persons;
v) It is not mentioned that the Recording Officer had given time to the accused persons and at what time the accused persons were produced before him;
vi) Confessions of the accused persons were recorded on the same day when they were produced before the Superintendent of Police;
6.1 Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant submits that for the aforesaid lacunae the Special Court did not accept the confessional statements of Mushtaq Ahmed Khan and Mohd. Sadiq Rather.
6.2 Referring to Section 15 of the TADA Act, learned Senior Counsel submits that if a confessional statement is established as voluntary, truthful and relates to the accused directly, it holds sufficient evidentiary value. In such a case, no further corroboration is necessary. Conviction of the accused can be based solely on such confession. In the present case, the confessions of the accused persons were voluntary, true and those corroborated with each other. Recording Officer Shri AK Suri, PW-12, had followed the procedure mandated under Section 15 of the TADA Act and Rule 15 of the TADA Rules. Therefore, the Special Court was not justified in rejecting the confessional statements of the aforesaid two accused persons. 6.3 Adverting to the rejection of the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar, learned Senior Counsel submits that the doctrine of issue estoppel cannot be applied in the present case. Salim Zargar was acquitted in a different proceeding vide the judgment and order dated 21.12.2002 which was not challenged by CBI. Barring Salim Zargar, parties are different in both the cases. Present trial had arisen out of a completely different incident i.e. kidnapping of Dr. Mushir-ul-Haq, the Vice- Chancellor of Kashmir University, and his Personal Secretary, 164 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Abdul Gani Zargar, from the Sadarbal Gate of the University on 06.04.1990. Therefore, the Special Court fell in error in rejecting the confessional statement of Salim Zargar relying on the doctrine of issue estoppel.
6.4 In any case, in addition to the confessional statement of Salim Zargar, there were confessions of two other accused persons, viz, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan and Mohd. Sadiq Rather which were recorded by the Superintendent of Police on 14.08.1990 and 25.08.1990 respectively. In view of the joint trial of the accused persons, confessions of the aforesaid two accused persons which were made voluntarily and corroborated with each other should have been relied upon.
6.5 It is further submitted that confessions of the accused persons were recorded in the year 1990 when there were no guidelines prescribed for recording of statements under Section 15 of the TADA Act. Judgment in the case of Kartar Singh Vs. State of Punjab,1 came much later. Therefore, the procedure prescribed in Kartar Singh (supra) could not have been followed in the present case.
6.6 Learned Senior Counsel submits that Section 15 of the TADA Act provides the substantive legal frame work for recording confessions while Rule 15 of the TADA Rules lays down the procedural safeguards necessary to uphold the validity of such confessional statements. Section 15(2) of the TADA Act should be read with Rule 15 of the TADA Rules. Notably, sub-rule 3(b) of Rule 15 mandates the police officer recording a confession to append a memorandum at the end of the confession. In the present case, Shri AK Suri, PW-12, ensured before recording the confessional statements that the accused were doing so voluntarily and they were duly warned about the legal consequences of such confession. The accused signed every page of the statements and the Recording Officer appended the mandatory memorandum confirming the voluntary nature of the confessions. The certificates, duly signed and sealed, were forwarded to the competent authority. Hence the issuance of the certificates complied with Rule 15(3) of the TADA Rules
1 (1994) 3 SCC 569
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 165State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors. reflecting the officer’s satisfaction regarding the voluntariness of the confessions.
6.7 That apart, it is further submitted that the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar was additionally recorded under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.PC) which was duly exhibited during the trial.
6.8 Thus, the confessional statements of Mohd. Salim Zargar, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan and Mohd. Sadiq Rather were recorded following the legal procedure mandated by the statute. Therefore, the Special Court was not at all justified in discarding the confessional statements of the abovenamed accused persons. On the basis of such confessional statements, the guilt of the accused persons stood conclusively established. In the circumstances, learned Senior Counsel submits that the appeal may be allowed setting aside the impugned judgment of the Special Court.
6.9 In support of her submissions, learned Senior Counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions:
i) Kartar Singh (supra);
ii) Sharafat Hussain Abdul Rahaman Shaikh Vs. State of Gujarat;2 iii) SN Dube Vs. NB Bhoir;3 iv) Ahmed Hussein Vali Mohammed. Saiyed Vs. State of Gujarat;4 v) Yakub Abdul Razak Memon Vs. State of Maharashtra;5 and, vi) Raja Vs. State of Tamil Nadu;6
7. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits that Special Court had acquitted all the accused persons as the only actionable
2 (1996) 11 SCC 62
3 (2000) 2 SCC 254
4 (2009) 7 SCC 254
5 (2013) 13 SCC 1
6 (2020) 5 SCC 118
166 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports evidence were the alleged confessional statements of the three accused persons. In so far the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar is concerned, the same was already rejected by the Special Court vide the judgment and order dated 21.12.2002 in a separate TADA proceeding. No appeal was preferred by the CBI against the said acquittal order which was passed following rejection of the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar. Thus, the said finding had become final. In the present proceeding, prosecution relied upon the same confessional statement which was rightly rejected by the Special Court.
7.1 Learned counsel submits that trial in this case took more than 19 years to complete as the prosecution was very tardy in producing the witnesses before the Court while the accused persons remained in custody as under-trial prisoners. The alleged confessional statements were recorded by one Shri AK Suri, PW-12, who was holding the post of Superintendent of Police, CBI at the relevant point of time and was also supervising the investigation of the present case. Prosecution could not produce any authorization whereby PW-12 was authorized to record the confessional statements. After due consideration, the Special Court discarded the confessional statements of all the three accused persons. While the confessional statement of Mohd. Salim Zargar was rejected because the same confessional statement was relied upon by the prosecution in another trial where it was rejected, in so far the confessional statements of Mushtaq Ahmed and Mohd. Sadiq Rather are concerned, the Special Court expressed serious doubt about the voluntary nature of such confessions.
7.2 Elaborating further, learned counsel for the respondents submits that PW-12 did not testify as to how the accused persons had appeared before him on their own. He was also silent about the production of the accused persons before him and also in respect of any request regarding recording of such confessional statements made to him by the Investigating Officer. The Investigating Officer deposed that he had never arrested the accused persons and had not even produced the accused before the Court. He further stated that he did not ask the SP, CBI (Shri AK Suri) to come for recording the statement of the accused persons. There is no record to show from whose [2025] 4 S.C.R. 167State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors. custody the accused persons were produced before Shri Suri when the alleged confessions were recorded or whether the accused persons made any desire in writing or orally to get their confessions recorded. The testimony of Shri AK Suri also shows that no questions were put to and answers sought from the accused persons before recording their confessions. There is no contemporaneous record to show that questions were put to the accused persons by Shri AK Suri before the statements were recorded. No satisfaction was recorded that the confessional statements were made voluntarily and were truthful. Admittedly, the confessional statements were recorded under compelling circumstances in places which were fortified and heavily guarded, such as, BSF camp and Joint Interrogation Centres.
7.3 Learned counsel for the respondents submits that it is not the case of the prosecution that no other Superintendent of Police was available at the relevant point of time and that only Shri AK Suri was available which necessitated him to record the confessional statements. Learned counsel asserts that Shri Suri was keen and overzealous to get the confessional statements recorded by himself for more than one reason. There is nothing on record to show from whose custody the accused persons were produced before Shri Suri for recording of the confessional statements in the BSF camp and at the Joint Interrogation Centres and at whose instance. There was no independent evidence to support the prosecution case and, therefore, the only way the prosecution could succeed in proving the guilt of the accused persons was to resort to the draconian law for getting the confessions recorded by themselves.
7.4 Learned counsel for the respondents submits that no offence under the TADA Act was made out or proved as against the respondents. It is evident that the accused persons were subjected to harsh interrogation, treatment and unlawful incarceration to make out a case of TADA but without any evidence. Special Court rightly acquitted the respondents. There is no illegality or perversity in the order of acquittal. No case is made out to reverse the order of acquittal.
7.5 Learned counsel has relied upon the decisions of this Court in Kartar Singh (supra), SN Dube (supra) and also in the case of Raja (supra) which clearly lay down the proposition that the 168 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports guidelines prescribed by this Court for recording of confessional statements under Section 15 of the TADA Act and Rule 15 of the TADA Rules are mandatory in nature which have to be followed if such confessions are to be relied upon. If the guidelines or conditions are not complied with, such confessional statements cannot be relied upon to convict the accused.
7.6 In the circumstances, learned counsel for the respondents submits that there is no merit in the appeal which should, therefore, be dismissed.
8. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
9. Prosecution presented PW-2, Ghulam Mohiuddin Khan, PW-3, Molu Khan, and PW-6, Ghulam Nabi Dar, the driver, as the eyewitnesses. PW-2 and PW-3 in their evidence described the kidnappers as young men with moustaches but could not identify them. PW-6 detailed how armed individuals hijacked the vehicle and later transferred the kidnapped persons to another car but he could not recognize the individuals. Therefore, evidence of the aforesaid witnesses are of not much assistance to the prosecution.
10. Though the medical and forensic evidence confirmed that both the deceased were killed by bullets fired from AK-47 rifle, the weapon (AK-47 rifle) used in the crime could not be recovered. In fact, PW- 11 Shri Roop Singh, a Senior Scientific Officer from the Central Forensic Science Laboratory, New Delhi testified that the cartridges recovered and sent to him for forensic examination were from a 7.62 mm AK-47 rifle. However, during cross-examination, he admitted that he had not seen the AK-47 rifle from which the cartridges were fired.
11. It is evident that the aforesaid testimony of the prosecution witnesses coupled with non-recovery of the weapon of offence seriously damaged the prosecution case. Prosecution therefore relied entirely on the confessional statements of Mohd. Salim Zargar, Mushtaq Ahmed Khan and Mohd. Sadiq Rather to prove the case against the respondents.
12. Before we deal with the admissibility or otherwise of the aforesaid confessional statements, it would be apposite to analyse the relevant legal provisions under the TADA Act and the TADA Rules dealing with recording of confessional statements.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 169State (CBI) v. Mohd. Salim Zargar @ Fayaz & Ors.
13. TADA Act was a special legislation enacted to make special provisions for the prevention of and for coping with terrorist and disruptive activities and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. Section 15 provides for certain confessions made to police officers to be taken into consideration. Section 15 is as under:
15. Certain confessions made to Police Officers to be taken into consideration.-
(1) Notwithstanding anything in the Code or in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872), but subject to the provisions of this section, a confession made by a person before a police officer not lower in rank than a Superintendent of Police and recorded by such police officer in writing or on any mechanical device like cassettes, tapes or sound tracks from out of which sounds or images can be reproduced, shall be admissible in the trial of such person or co-accused, abettor or conspirator for an offence under this Act or rules made thereunder: Provided that co-accused, abettor or conspirator is charged and tried in the same case together with the accused.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.