Arunkumar H Shah Huf v. Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 524; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1350
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 21 Apr 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5377/2025
- Sections
- 11, 11(3), 11(4), 11(5), 4, 5A, 2, 4(1), 10
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1350 : 2025 INSC 524 Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 5377 of 2025)
21 April 2025 [Abhay S Oka* and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the correctness of the judgment passed by the High Court affirming the order of the competent authority issuing certificate of deemed conveyance in respect of a plot to first respondent.
Headnotes† Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer Act) 1963 – s.11 – Promoter to convey title, and execute documents, according to agreement – Scope of power of competent authority u/s.11 – Interference with the order granting deemed conveyance – Deed of dissolution between the parties and larger plot partitioned between L (L plot) and A (A plot) – L took over the firm as sole proprietor and it was provided that if L transfers his interest in favour of flat purchasers, perpetual lease in favour of the appellant or its nominees in respect of A plot would be executed – 10th respondent firm constituted with L as one of its partners, L brought in L Plot as his capital contribution to the firm – 10th respondent constructed building and entered into flat purchase agreements with flat purchasers – First respondent-co-operative society of flat purchasers in the building constructed on L Plot filed application u/s.11(3) seeking deemed conveyance of L Plot along with the portion of A Plot – Competent authority granted ex parte deemed conveyance in respect of the larger plot, on the condition of the first respondent executing a permanent lease in respect of A Plot in favour of the appellant or its nominees – Thereagainst, appellant filed writ petition – High Court confirmed the order of the competent authority – Correctness:
* Author [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1351Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors. Held: MOFA is a beneficial legislation enacted to protect home buyers and the provisions of s.11 are for the benefit of the flat purchasers – In writ jurisdiction, the Court should not interfere with the order granting deemed conveyance u/s.11(4), unless the order is manifestly illegal – Writ court should generally be slow in interfering with such orders because notwithstanding the order u/s.11(4), the remedy of aggrieved parties to file a civil suit remains open – On facts, clause of deed of dissolution provides for the execution of a lease in respect of the A plot in favour of A by L or a cooperative society formed after the construction of new buildings by L – This was to protect the interests of the appellant – Deed of partnership shows that 10th respondent had no right over the property allotted to the appellant under the deed of dissolution – 10th respondent is the lessor of the appellant – Effect of the order of competent authority is that there shall be a deemed conveyance in favour of the first respondent in respect of the entire larger plot subject to the condition of executing a permanent lease deed in favour of the appellant or its nominees – First respondent, after a conveyance in its favour, steps into the shoes of the appellant’s lessor – In view of the fact that deed of dissolution is binding, the appellant cannot object to the condition of the first respondent executing a lease incorporated in the certificate – To protect the appellant’s interest, the impugned order and the certificate provide for the execution of a permanent lease in favour of the appellant – Thus, there will be a perpetual lease executed by the first respondent in favour of the appellant or its nominees – No fault can be found with the order of the competent authority and the impugned order of the High Court – Substantial justice has been done by protecting the appellant’s rights as a perpetual lessee with a right to develop the A plot – Thus, interference in writ jurisdiction not warranted. [Paras 29, 31, 32, 34-36] Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer Act) 1963 – s.11 – Promoter to convey title, etc., and execute documents, according to agreement – Scope of power of competent authority u/s.11:
Held: Quasi-judicial powers have been conferred upon the competent authority while dealing with applications u/s.11(3) – However, proceedings before the competent authority u/s.11(3) are of summary nature, as can be seen from the MOFA Rules – 1352 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Competent authority, while passing the final order, must record reasons – Competent authority, while following the summary procedure, cannot conclusively and finally decide the questions of title – Thus, notwithstanding the order made u/s.11(4), aggrieved parties can always file a civil suit for establishing their rights – Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Rules, 1964. [Paras 20, 37] Registration Act, 1908 – s.11(5) – Scope of powers of registration officers – Harmonious construction of s.11(4) and s.11(5):
Held: Power conferred on the registration officer does not enable him to reopen or set aside the findings recorded by the competent authority while passing an order of grant of certificate – Registration officer is neither an appellate authority nor a revisional authority – Scope of adjudication by the registering officer u/s.11(5) is limited – Registering officer has no power to sit in appeal over the order of the competent authority while exercising the power u/s.11(5) – He has no power to go into the correctness or otherwise of the order of the competent authority – He can refuse registration only on certain grounds – Thus, the scope of the powers conferred on the registering officer is limited – This is the only way sub-sections (4) and (5) of s.11 of MOFA can be harmoniously construed. [Paras 22, 23] Case Law Cited Abdul Kuddus v. Union of India [2019] 8 SCR 669 : (2019) 6 SCC 604; Indian National Congress (I) v. Institute of Social Welfare & Ors. [2002] 3 SCR 1040 : (2002) 5 SCC 685 – referred to. Mazda Construction Company & Ors. v. Sultanabad Darshan CHS Ltd. & Ors., 2012 SCC Online Bombay 1266; Marathon Next Gen Realty Ltd., Mumbai and Another v. Competent Authority, District Deputy Registrar of Co-Operative Societies, Mumbai and Others (2015) 5 Maharashtra Law Journal 318; ACME Enterprises and Another v. Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies and Others (2023) SCC Online Bombay 1102; Tanish Associates & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., 2016 SCC Online Bombay 12653; Subash Ramchandra Navare v. Premji Megji Rambia & Ors., 2020 SCC Online Bombay 316; M/s. Shree Chintamani Builders v. State of Maharashtra and Ors., 2016 SCC Online Bombay 9343; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1353Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors. Mahanagar Housing Partnership Firm and Others v. District Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies (Pune City), Pune and Others, 2018 SCC Online Bombay 19563 – referred to.
List of Acts Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer Act) 1963; Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Rules, 1964; Registration Act, 1908.
List of Keywords Hindu Undivided Family; Deed of partnership; Deed of dissolution; Development Control Regulations; Flat purchase agreements; Deemed conveyance; Ex parte deemed conveyance; Principles of natural justice; Quasi-judicial powers; Summary procedure; Scope of power of registration officer; Appellate authority; Revisional authority; Prohibitory order; Restraint order; Harmoniously construction; Floor space index; Karta; Co-operative society; Scope of power of competent authority; Perpetual lease; Permanent lease; Malpractices by developers; Beneficial legislation; Protect home buyers; Housing shortage; Certificate of deemed conveyance; Writ jurisdiction; Execution of lease; Deed of partnership.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 5377 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.04.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WP No. 4373 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Kush Chaturvedi, Saroj Iyer, Ms. Puwina Priyadarshini, Syed Faraz Alam, Ms. Gauri Joshi, Atharva Gaur, Aayushman Aggarwal, E. C. Agrawala.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Nikhil Nayyar, Sr. Adv., Gautam narayan, Ms. Aakashi Lodha, Sanyat Lodha, Naveen Hegde, Gaurav Goel, M/s. Karanjawala & Co., Ms. Jasmine Damkewala, Mac Bhodhanwalla, Sheroy Bodhanwalla, Ms. Vaishali Sharma, V. N. Raghupathy, Anand 1354 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Dilip Landge, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Aadarsh Dubey, Mrs. Preet S. Phanse.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Abhay S. Oka, J.
FACTUAL DETAILS
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal takes exception to the judgment and order dated 25 th February 2021 passed by the learned Single Judge of the Bombay High Court. To appreciate the controversy, a brief reference to the facts of the case would be necessary.
3. One Champaben Hiralal Shah owned a plot of land being Final Plot No.61 in Town Planning Scheme III, Vile Parle (West), admeasuring 2814.38 sq.mtrs. (for short ‘the larger plot’). On 1 st April 1972, Champaben Hiralal Shah and the Hindu Undivided Family consisting of her three sons, Lalbhai, Ranjit and Arun, constituted a partnership firm M/s. CH Shah & Sons (for short, ‘the firm’) by executing a deed of partnership. The larger plot was Champaben Hiralal Shah’s contribution to the firm’s capital. After the death of Champaben, the firm was reconstituted, amongst the rest of the partners, as per the deed of reconstitution dated 30 th June 1983.
4. A deed of dissolution of partnership was executed on 13th February 1987 (‘the deed of dissolution’) by which the firm was dissolved. The larger plot was partitioned between one Lalbhai H. Shah (predecessor of the 2 nd to 5 th respondents) and one Arun H. Shah (the Karta of the appellant). Under the deed of dissolution dated 13 th February 1987, the portion of the larger plot shown in a verged blue colour line on a plan attached (for short, ‘Lalbhai Plot’) was allotted to Lalbhai, being the Manager and Karta of Lalbhai Hiralal Shah HUF. The remaining portion of the larger plot below building No.3 and the land surrounding it, shown in a verged yellow line (for short ‘the Arun Plot’), was allotted to Arun as the Karta and manager of Arun Hiralal Shah HUF (the appellant). It was provided that construction [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1355Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors. on the Lalbhai Plot will be restricted to the development potential thereof, and the construction on the Arun Plot will be restricted to the development potential thereof in accordance with the prevailing Development Control Regulations. Lalbhai took over the firm as the sole proprietor. It was provided that if Lalbhai transfers his interest in favour of an organisation of flat purchasers, then Lalbhai/such organisation would execute a perpetual lease in favour of the appellant or its nominees in respect of the Arun plot.
5. 10 th Respondent firm was constituted with Lalbhai as one of its partners by a deed of partnership dated 30 th March 1987. Lalbhai brought in the Lalbhai Plot as his capital contribution to the firm. The 10 th respondent constructed a building consisting of two wings, each with ground plus two upper floors on the Lalbhai Plot. The 10 th respondent entered into flat purchase agreements (for short, ‘the FPAs’) from the year 1991 onwards with the flat purchasers in respect of flats in the building. It was claimed that the FPAs were executed in terms of Section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer Act) 1963 (for short, ‘the MOFA’). On 6th November 1993, the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (for short, ‘the MCGM’) issued an occupation certificate in respect of the building. It is pointed out by the appellant that the first respondent, a co-operative society of the flat purchasers in the building constructed on Lalbhai Plot, was formed and registered on 15th July 2005.
6. The first respondent filed a complaint before the Additional Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Mumbai, seeking conveyance of only the Lalbhai Plot. The District Forum allowed the complaint and directed the 10th respondent to convey the Lalbhai plot to the first respondent by order dated 19th August 2017.
7. Thereafter, on 13 th January 2020, the first respondent filed an application under Section 11(3) of the MOFA seeking a deemed conveyance of the Lalbhai Plot along with the portion of Arun Plot (totally admeasuring 2,753 sq. mtrs). The conveyance was sought of the larger plot. But after taking into account the road setback area of 131.40 sq. meters, the area thereof was mentioned as 2753 sq meters. The application was filed before the District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Mumbai City [3] (11 th respondent), being the competent authority appointed under Section 5A of the MOFA. On 1356 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 18 th September 2020, the said application was allowed. Ex parte deemed conveyance in respect of the larger plot was granted, and a certificate of deemed conveyance was issued to the first respondent on the condition of the first respondent executing a permanent lease in respect of the Arun Plot in favour of Arun Hiralal Shah HUF (the appellant) or its nominees. Being aggrieved by the said order, Arun Hiralal Shah HUF (the appellant), filed a writ petition before the Bombay High Court, which was decided by the impugned judgment and order of the Bombay High Court. The order of the competent authority was confirmed. But a liberty was reserved to the appellant to file a suit for adjudication of the title.
SUBMISSIONS
8. The learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant invited our attention to the relevant clauses in the dissolution deed dated 13 th February 1987 by which the said firm was dissolved. He pointed out that the deed of dissolution recites that Ranjit (the predecessor of the 6 th to 9 th respondent) and Arun were not interested in carrying on the real estate business of the firm. He pointed out that the deed of dissolution of the firm provided that on the dissolution, the goodwill and trade name of the firm as well as the right to recover all the outstandings of the said firm shall remain with Lalbhai who was entitled to carry on the business of the erstwhile firm as the sole proprietor in the name of M/s. CH Shah & Sons. However, it was provided that if any rental is received from any tenant of building No.3, the same shall be paid over by Lalbhai to Arun without any deduction whatsoever therefrom. It was also provided that Arun will bear all the outgoings of the said building No.3. The learned counsel pointed out that in the deed of dissolution, it is provided that the portion of the larger plot shown in verged blue colour line (the Lalbhai Plot) shall belong to Lalbhai as the Manager and Karta of Lalbhai Hiralal Shah HUF and the remaining portion of the said property being building marked no.3 and the surrounding land shown in verged yellow line on the said plan (the Arun Plot) shall belong to the present appellant (Arun Hiralal Shah HUF). It is also provided in the deed that the Floor Space Index (FSI) of the Lalbhai plot shall be utilised by Lalbhai save and except the FSI which is utilised for the construction of the existing building No.3. It was provided that the appellant will be entitled to reconstruct structure or structures in [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1357Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors. place of existing building No.3. Another important clause which he pointed out was that after Lalbhai develops the remaining property excluding building No.3, the incorporated body of the purchasers of the premises in the redeveloped property/ Lalbhai shall execute a lease in perpetuity in favour of Arun at nominal yearly lease rent of Re.1 in respect of the Arun plot.
9. Thereafter, the learned counsel invited our attention to the order dated 18 th September 2020 passed by the 11 th respondent, which is the competent authority within the meaning of Section 5A of the MOFA. He submitted that the power of the 11th respondent was to enforce the rights of the first respondent society and the corresponding obligation of the 10th respondent developer to execute the conveyance in terms of the agreements executed in favour of the flat purchasers. Learned counsel relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Mazda Construction Company & Ors. v. Sultanabad Darshan CHS Ltd. & Ors. 1 . He submitted that the Arun Plot allotted to Arun under the deed of dissolution was not the subject matter of the agreement between the 10 th respondent and members of the 1 st respondent society. Therefore, the 11 th respondent had no jurisdiction to pass an order granting deemed conveyance to the first respondent in respect of the Arun Plot allotted to the appellant. He further submitted that the appellant was not amenable to the jurisdiction of the 11 th respondent.
10. After noticing that serious disputed questions regarding the title and demarcation of the land were arising, the competent authority ought to have directed the first respondent society to file a suit. Relying upon the judgment of the learned Single Judge of Bombay High Court in the case of Marathon Next Gen Realty Ltd., Mumbai and another v. Competent Authority, District Deputy Registrar of Co-Operative Societies, Mumbai and others, 2 the learned counsel submitted that the competent authority under Section 5A of the MOFA is not empowered to adjudicate upon the disputed questions of fact and the questions which will have impact on third parties. He submitted that the competent authority is not empowered to decide any lis between the parties. He relied upon another decision of a learned Single Judge 1 (2012) SCC Online Bombay 1266 2 (2015) 5 Maharashtra Law Journal 318 1358 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the Bombay High Court in the case of ACME Enterprises and Another v. Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies and Others.3 Learned counsel also placed reliance on a decision of this Court in the case of Abdul Kuddus v. Union of India.4 He submitted that the competent authority is not empowered to receive any evidence. He submitted that the order passed by the competent authority under Section 11(4) of the MOFA is not final inasmuch as the registration officer is empowered under Section 11(5), after hearing the parties, to decide whether such a unilateral deed of conveyance ought to be registered or not.
11. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that the impugned order of the competent authority dated 18th September 2020 is as vague as possible, and even the terms and conditions on which the permanent lease deed is to be executed by and between the appellant and the first respondent have not been specified.
12. Another submission of the learned counsel appearing for the appellant is that the first respondent had already filed a consumer complaint before the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (the State Commission) and therefore, the first respondent should not have taken recourse to the proceedings under the MOFA. Lastly, he submitted that the High Court ought to have interfered and set aside the impugned order of the competent authority.
13. Learned senior counsel appearing for the first respondent on facts submitted that the larger plot was not subdivided after the execution of the deed of dissolution, and the building constructed by the 10th respondent developer is an extension of the building No.3. He submitted that no prejudice has been caused to the appellant by the impugned order of the 11 th respondent, as admittedly the appellant will be entitled to perpetual leasehold rights in respect of land below building No.3 and the land abutting thereto (the Arun Plot). He invited our attention to the FPAs between the members of the 1 st respondent and the 10 th respondent under the MOFA. He submitted that the leasehold rights of the appellant have been protected under the impugned order passed by the 11th respondent.
3 (2023) SCC Online Bombay 1102
4 (2019) 6 SCC 604
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 1359Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors.
14. He submitted that there are 93 flat purchasers who are members of the first respondent. Even after the grant of the occupation certificate, the 10 th respondent delayed the execution of the conveyance. He pointed out that the occupation certificate was granted as far back as in 1993. In fact, the obligation of the 10 th respondent was to execute a conveyance within four months from the date of registration of the first respondent society. He submitted that the execution of the conveyance in respect of the larger plot has been pending for over three decades, and the appellant, in collusion with the 10th respondent, has always been making efforts to delay the execution of the conveyance.
15. He invited our attention to Rule 13 and other relevant rules forming part of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Rules, 1964 (for short, ‘the MOFA Rules’), which explain the powers of the competent authority. He also invited our attention to the object of incorporating Section 11(3) of the MOFA with effect from 25 th February 2008. The object was to curb malpractices by the developers. The object of the said amended provision is to safeguard the interests of flat purchasers. After inviting our attention to various provisions contained in the MOFA Rules, learned counsel appearing for the first respondent relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Indian National Congress (I) v. Institute of Social Welfare & Ors.. 5 He submitted that, looking to the powers of the competent authority, it is required to adhere to the principles of natural justice and act judicially. He submitted that the object of the provisions of the MOFA cannot be defeated by allowing parties to raise frivolous disputes. The learned counsel relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Tanish Associates & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., 6 which was confirmed by this Court. He also relied upon observations made in paragraph 7 of the decision of the learned Single Judge of the Bombay High Court in the case of Tanish Associates & Ors.. 6 He also relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Subash Ramchandra Navare v. Premji Megji Rambia & Ors.. 7
5 (2002) 5 SCC 685
6 (2016) SCC Online Bombay 12653 7 (2020) SCC Online Bombay 316 1360 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports He submitted that the observations made in paragraph 7 of the said decision protect the appellant. He also relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Mazda Construction Company & Ors. 1, which was relied upon by the appellant. He submitted that the decision of the learned Single Judge of the Bombay High Court in the case of Mazda Construction Company & Ors. 1 has been affirmed by a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of M/s. Shree Chintamani Builders v. State of Maharashtra and Ors.. 8 He also relied upon a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Mahanagar Housing Partnership Firm and Others v. District Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies (Pune City), Pune and Others. 9
CONSIDERATION
POWER OF THE COMPETENT AUTHORITY UNDER SECTION
11 OF THE MOFA
16. Now, we turn to the scope of powers conferred on the competent authority under the MOFA. The term ‘promoter’ is defined in Section 2(c), which means a person or a partnership firm or a body or association of persons who constructs or causes to be constructed a building consisting of flats or apartments. Thus, the developer (10 th respondent) is a promoter. Under Section 4(1) of the MOFA, a promoter is required to execute a registered agreement for sale in favour of the flat purchasers in the form prescribed under the MOFA Rules. Under Section 10, it is the promoter’s obligation to take steps to form a cooperative society or a company representing the flat purchasers.
17. Section 11 is the most important provision, which calls for interpretation in this appeal. Section 11 reads thus:
“11. – Promoter to convey title, etc., and execute documents, according to agreement
(1) A promoter shall take all necessary steps to complete his title and convey to the organisation of persons, who 8 (2016) SCC Online Bombay 9343 9 (2018) SCC Online Bombay 19563 [2025] 4 S.C.R. 1361Arunkumar H Shah HUF v.
Avon Arcade Premises Co-Operative Society Limited & Ors. take flats, which is registered either as a co-operative society or as a company as aforesaid or to an association of flat takers [or apartment owners], his right, title and interest in the land and building, and execute all relevant documents therefor in accordance with the agreement executed under section 4 and if no period for the execution of the conveyance is agreed upon, he shall execute the conveyance within the prescribed period and also deliver all documents of title relating to the property which may be in his possession or power.
(2) It shall be the duty of the promoter to file with the Competent Authority, within the prescribed period, a copy of the conveyance executed by him under sub-section (1).
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.