The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz Kersasp Mody & Ors
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 347; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 516
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bela M. Trivedi, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 16 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5781/2022
- Sections
- 14, 17, 19(2), 11(3), 2(1), 15, 19, 20, 27
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 516 : 2025 INSC 347 The Auroville Foundation v.
Navroz Kersasp Mody & Ors.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 5781-5782 of 2022)
17 March 2025 [Bela M. Trivedi* and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to the correctness of judgment passed by the National Green Tribunal giving directions to the appellant-Foundation as regards the construction of roads in Auroville Township. Headnotes† National Green Tribunal Act, 2010 – ss.14, 15, Schedule I – Jurisdiction of National Green Tribunal – Substantial question relating to environment – Auroville Township Project – Application by respondent nos.1 and 2 before the National Green Tribunal, with regard to cutting of large number of trees by the appellant Foundation, alleging that appellant was focusing on the manifestation of the roads mentioned in the Master Plan, the Crown Road, a road encircling the centre of the Township, and the outer ring road, and was intending to distract Darkali Forest by using huge machineries causing deterioration to the environment; that the lands were covered under the deemed forest and were entitled to the protection – Tribunal held that it would not come under the definition of “Forest” for the purposes of obtaining clearance; it applied the “Precautionary Principle”, and held that any further activity to be done by the appellant, could be permitted to be carried out only after obtaining necessary prior environmental clearance and also appointed a Joint Committee to inspect the area in question and ascertain whether any modification could be made in the width of the road, and further directed the appellant to prepare a proper Township plan – Correctness: Held: For the exercise of jurisdiction by the tribunal u/s.14, it has to be shown that a substantial question relating to environment including enforcement of any legal right relating to environment is involved and such questions arise out of the implementation * Author [2025] 3 S.C.R. 517The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz K ersasp Mody & Ors. of the enactments specified in Schedule I – Every question or dispute raised by an applicant before the tribunal pertaining to the environment cannot be treated as a substantial question – Tribunal completely misdirected itself by entering into the restricted domain of judicial review under the guise of applying “Precautionary Principle” in extraordinary circumstances, and in interfering with the implementation of Master Plan which was already approved by the competent Authority way back in the year 2001 and had attained a statutory force and a finality – Construction of roads as mentioned in the said approved Master Plan including the Crown Road, being on the verge of completion, except few patches, which could not be completed because of the obstructions caused by the disgruntled residents – Tribunal misdirected itself by directing the appellant to prepare a proper Township Plan – Directions by tribunal clearly fall outside the purview of its jurisdiction particularly when there was no substantial question relating to the environment was shown to have arisen in implementation of any of the enactments specified in Schedule I to the Act, nor violation of any of the enactments specified in Schedule-I was alleged – Thus, the tribunal committed gross error in assuming the jurisdiction and giving directions untenable in law – Impugned orders passed by the tribunal quashed and set aside. [Paras 7, 9, 11, 13, 14, 18, 19] Constitution of India – Arts.14, 19, 21 – Right to clean environment vis-à-vis right to development:
Held: Though it is true that the “Precautionary Principle” and the “Polluter Pays Principle” are part of the environmental law of the country, it is equally true that while the right to clean environment is a guaranteed fundamental right under Arts.14 and 21, but the right to development through industrialisation equally claims priority under fundamental rights particularly u/Arts.14, 19 and 21 – There is a need for “Sustainable Development” harmonising and striking a golden balance between the right to development and the right to clean environment. [Para 17] Case Law Cited T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India and Others [1996] Supp. 9 SCR 982 : (1997) 2 SCC 267; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Centre for Environment Protection Research and Development [2020] 12 SCR 1139 : (2020) 9 SCC 781; H.P. Bus-Stand Management and Development Authority v. Central 518 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Empowered Committee [2021] 1 SCR 344 : (2021) 4 SCC 309; Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum v. Union of India & Others [1996] Supp. 5 SCR 241 : (1996) 5 SCC 647; Essar Oil Ltd. v. Halar Utkarsh Samiti & Ors. [2004] 1 SCR 808 : (2004) 2 SCC 392; N.D. Jayal & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. [2003] Supp. 3 SCR 152 : (2004) 9 SCC 362 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Auroville Foundation Act, 1988; Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980; National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; Auroville (Emergency Provisions) Act, 1980; Model Town and Country Planning Act, 1960.
List of Keywords National Green Tribunal; Directions issued by National Green Tribunal; Jurisdiction of National Green Tribunal; Cutting of large number of trees; Precautionary principle; Joint Committee; Substantial question relating to environment; Right to clean environment; Right to development; Sustainable Development; Forest; Master Plan; Auroville; Galaxy Model Plan; Matrimandir; Town plan; Auroville Town Development Council; Auroville Universal Township Master Plan-Perspective 2025; Darkali forest; Environmental clearance; Special Act; Crown Road; Brundtland Report; Polluter Pays Principle.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 5781-5782 of 2022 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.04.2022 of National Green Tribunal, Chennai in O.A. No. 239 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
R. Venkatramani, Sr. Adv./A.G., Vaibhav Venkatesh, Balaji Srinivasan Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G., A Yogeswaran, T. V. S. Raghavendra Sreyas, Nishanth Patil, Gurmeet Singh Makker, Nithyaesh Natraj, Ajay Marwah, M.V. Swaroop, Vikas Mehta [2025] 3 S.C.R. 519The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz K ersasp Mody & Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Bela M. Trivedi, J.
1. The present Appeals stem from the final judgment and order dated 28.04.2022 passed by the National Green Tribunal, Chennai (hereinafter referred to as the “Tribunal”) in O.A. No. 239/2021, and from an interim order dated 27.07.2022 passed by the said Tribunal in the M.A. No.6/2022 in O.A No.239/2021. The directions given by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment dated 28.04.2022 read as under:- I. “125. In the result, this Original Application is allowed in part and disposed of with the following directions: -
(i) The 1st Respondent is directed to prepare a proper township plan either in respect of 778 Ha which is in their possession now or in respect of 1963 Ha which was visualized by the MOTHER by identifying the locations where each zone will have to be located, where the roads will have to be laid showing the location of the ring roads with their width and further road, if any, to be constructed, the nature of industries and other activities which they are expected to establish in the township and if it is not going to be implemented as one phase, how many phases in which they are going to complete the project and then apply for Environmental Clearance (EC)
as it will fall under Item 8 (b) of the EIA Notification, 2006 as amended from time to time. Till then they are directed not to proceed with further construction in the project area.”
(ii) Considering it as an exceptional circumstances, even before obtaining Environmental Clearance (EC) for further activity, we are permitting the 1st Respondent to complete the crown road on the following conditions: a. The Joint Committee appointed by this Tribunal viz., (i) the District Collector who is the Chairman of the District Green Committee of the concerned district 520 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports along with (ii) the Forest Officer not below the rank of Conservator of Forest, as deputed by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, (Head of Forests Force) and Chief Wildlife Warden, State of Tamil Nadu to inspect the area in question and ascertain whether by reducing the width of the road at suitable places or by slight realignment (if any) required, so that the number of trees to be cut can be minimized so that the vision of the MOTHER of creating a green cover in that area can be protected.
b. The Joint Committee is also directed to ascertain as to whether there are any water bodies/streams exists in that area and if the road passes through the water body, then what is the manner in which the road will have to be constructed by elevation without affecting the water body/water flow or a bed level causeway with box type of vents will suffice. If such a recommendation is made, that also will have to be implemented, and the 1st Respondent is to undertake the construction as suggested by the committee.
c. The Joint Committee is directed to complete the process and submit the report to the 1st Respondent within a period of two months and on receipt of the same, the 1st Respondent is directed to carry out the crown road work, in the impugned area with tree cover, strictly in accordance with the recommendations made by the Joint Committee.
d. Till that exercise is completed, the 1st Respondent is directed not to cut any further trees from the property. The 1st Respondent is at liberty to undertake the crown road work in the remaining stretches where there are no trees. The 1st Respondent is also at liberty to take action against unauthorized occupations, if any, strictly in accordance with the law in force.
(iii) The 1st Respondent is also directed to plant trees in the ratio of 1: 10 for the number of trees to be cut, and the species to be recommended by the [2025] 3 S.C.R. 521The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz K ersasp Mody & Ors. Joint Committee may be considered for planting either on the side of the road or other area identified by the Joint Committee, in order to protect environment and also to maintain the green cover in that area.
(iv) Considering the circumstances, parties are directed to bear their respective costs in the application.
(v) The Registry is directed to communicate this order to the members of the Joint Committee appointed by this Tribunal, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (Head of Forests Force)
and Chief Wildlife Warden, State of Tamil Nadu, the Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change (MoEF&CC) and the Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Department of Environment, Forests & Climate Change for their information and compliance of directions.”
II. The following further directions were given by the Tribunal by passing the interim order dated 27.07.2022 in MA No. 6/2022: “7. In the meantime, the Joint Committee appointed by this Tribunal vide Judgment dated 28.04.2022 is also directed to file the report regarding the nature of work done and observations made by them at the time of inspection.”
2. This Court on 13.12.2023 passed the following interim order pending these Appeals.
“5. Having regard to the said prayer which was sought by the Respondent No.1 (original applicant) and having regard to the final directions given by the Tribunal in the impugned order, we are of the prima facie opinion that the direction contained in Para 125(i) being outside the jurisdiction of the Tribunal, the same is required to be stayed till further orders, and is ordered accordingly.”
3. Prelude on the History of Auroville:- I. Before appreciating the issues involved, it would be apt to peep into the history of Auroville. In 1965, the “Mother” (Mirra Alfassa, a French lady), a spiritual collaborator of Sri Aurobindo 522 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports (a Spiritual reformer, Philosopher and Educationist), envisioned to launch the project of Auroville, with an aim to establish an international universal township, where men and women of all countries are able to live in peace and harmony, above all creeds, all politics and all nationalities and to realise human unity. The project of Auroville was formerly inaugurated by the “Mother” in 28.02.1968. The Charter of Auroville given by the “Mother” was the following:
“1. Auroville belongs to nobody in particular. Auroville belongs to humanity as a whole. But to live in Auroville one must be a willing servitor of the Divine Consciousness.
2. Auroville will be the place of an unending education, of constant progress and a youth that never ages.
3. Auroville wants to be the bridge between the past and the future. Taking advantage of all discoveries from without and from within, Auroville will boldly spring towards future realisations.
4. Auroville will be a site of material and spiritual researches for a living embodiment of an actual Human Unity.”
II. The original Master Plan of the Auroville was conceptualized in Galaxy shape, and was planned to eventually accommodate 50,000 residents, a number which the “Mother” considered sufficient to allow the experiment in human unity to take on a meaningful and significant dimension. Picture of Galaxy Model Plan conceptualized in 1968 is shown below:
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 523The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz K ersasp Mody & Ors. III. The project Auroville was legally started as the project of a charitable organization, “The Sri Aurobindo Society” in Pondicherry, which was created to diffuse Sri Aurobindo’s thoughts. The development of Auroville in the initial few years showed good progress and it developed at a rapid pace. Number of Indians and foreigners settled down in Auroville and devoted themselves to various activities showing a remarkable harmony amongst the members of Auroville, which gave a promise to the Government of India of an early fulfilment of the ideals for which Auroville was established. It was also encouraged by UNESCO and other International Organizations of the world. However, after the “Mother” passed away in 1973, the situation changed, and number of complaints came to be received by the Government of India with regard to the mismanagement in the working of the Sri Aurobindo Society. Following the requests by majority of Auroville residents, the Government of India issued a Presidential Ordinance called the Auroville (Emergency Provisions) Ordinance, 1980, later replaced by the Auroville (Emergency Provisions) Act, 1980. Finally, the Government of India created a unique status for Auroville by passing the Auroville Foundation Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as the “A.F.Act”).
4. Constitution of Auroville Foundation and its Standing Orders- I. The Government of India notified the Constitution of Auroville Foundation as a statutory body on 29.01.1991 under the A.F. Act, and at present it is under the realm of Ministry of Human Resource Development (Department of Higher Education) as the Central Government undertaking.
II. As transpiring from the record, the original Galaxy Plan envisioned by the “Mother” in 1968 was the plan with four zones in Auroville, with the centripetal force, being the “Matrimandir”. The said Galaxy Plan was revised in 1972 as the First Master Plan called the “Town Plan”. As the A.F. Act required statutory Master Plan as contemplated in Section 17(e) read with Section 19(2)(c) of the said A.F. Act, the Master Plan was approved by the Governing Board and the Residents’ Assembly of the Appellant Foundation in 1999. The said 1999 Master Plan was further approved by the competent authority- the Town 524 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and Country Planning Organisation (TCPO), Ministry of Urban Development, on 15.02.2001 under the Model Town and Country Planning Act. The said Master Plan was notified on 16.08.2010 and published in the Official Gazette on 28.08.2010.
III. In view of Section 11(3) of the A.F. Act, the Governing Board decided, that “Standing Orders” not inconsistent with the provisions of the A.F. Act and the Rules made thereunder, on the matters that the Governing Board may consider appropriate and necessary, shall be notified from time to time, by the Auroville Foundation. The said Resolution was notified in the Gazette of India, Part III dated 05.03.2011 by the Ministry of Human Resource Development (Department of Higher Education). IV. Since the said approved Master Plan prescribed the “Town Development Council” as the body for implementing the Master Plan with the organizational structure as in Appendix V of the Master Plan, the Governing Board in terms of the provisions of the Master Plan, constituted the Town Development Council for the purpose of implementation of the Master Plan, vide the Standing Order No. 6/2011 dated 01.05.2011, which was notified in the Government of India Gazette, Part III, dated 11.06.2011. The said Standing Order dated 01.05.2011 came to be replaced by the Standing Order No. 1/2019 dated 04.06.2019.
V. Again, the said Standing Order dated 04.06.2019 came to be replaced by the Standing Order No.1/2022 dated 01.06.2022, which was notified in the Gazette of India, Part III, on 15.07.2022. On 01.06.2022, the Auroville Foundation issued the Office Order for the re-constitution of the Auroville Town Development Council (ATDC). The Appellant-Foundation thereafter also issued a Corrigendum dated 07.12.2022, to the Standing Order No. 1/2022 dated 01.06.2022, in order to clarify and add the source of statutory power in the Preamble to the said original Standing Order dated 01.06.2022. The said Corrigendum was also published in the Gazette of India, Part III, on 10.12.2022.
5. Prefatory Facts:- I. The Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (the original Applicants) had filed an Application being O.A. No.239/2021 before the Tribunal, [2025] 3 S.C.R. 525The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz K ersasp Mody & Ors. raising a grievance with regard to cutting of large number of trees by the Appellant-Auroville Foundation, alleging inter alia that the Master Plan for Auroville as envisaged by the ‘Mother’ was approved by the Governing Board of the Auroville Foundation in consultation with the Residents’ Assembly, and it further led to preparation of the Auroville Universal Township Master Plan-Perspective 2025, which was approved by the Ministry of Human Resources Development in 2001. However, now the Appellant-Foundation was focusing on the manifestation of the roads mentioned in the Master Plan, e.g. the Crown Road, a road encircling the centre of the Township, and the outer ring road, and was intending to distract Darkali Forest by using huge machineries causing deterioration to the environment. According to the Respondents-original Applicants, the said lands covered under the deemed Forest, were entitled to the protection as mandated in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad Vs. Union of India and Others 1 case.
II. The Respondents Applicant therefore had sought the following reliefs in the said O.A. No.239/2021.
“INTERIM RELIEF:
A. Injunct the 1st respondent from felling any tree or clearing undergrowth in the Darkali forest or any area in Auroville for the proposed crown road project. B. Issue such other orders as it deems fit in the interest of the case and render justice.
MAIN PRAYER:
A. Direct the 1st respondent to prepare a Detailed Development Plan including a mobility plan which is based on and respects the present-day ground realities, to be approved as mandated in the Master Plan and implement projects based on such plan after necessary impact assessments and feasibility studies in an environmentally sustainable manner.
1 (1997) 2 SCC 267
526 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports B. Direct the respondent to pay costs to the applicant. C. Issue such other orders as it deems fit in the interest of the case and render justice.”
III. The Tribunal initially vide the order dated 10.12.2021 granted an interim order directing the Appellant-Foundation not to cut any further trees till the next date of hearing. The said interim order thereafter was extended till the final disposal of the case. IV. The Appellant-Foundation (1st Respondent before the Tribunal) had filed a counter affidavit raising various contentions including the maintainability of the Application itself as also the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to entertain the Application. It was specifically contended that neither the word ‘Forest’ did appear in the Auroville Charter nor in the Act of 1988. Auroville or any part of it, was neither a Forest nor a deemed Forest requiring protection or clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980.
V. The Respondent No.3-Union of India through the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CCthe Respondent No.2 before the Tribunal) had also filed a counter-affidavit stating in detail the stand and role of the Ministry and contending inter alia that the requirement of prior Environmental Clearance for certain categories of construction and developmental activities (new construction projects and new industrial estates) in the country was inserted in Schedule-I, after Item 30, through an amendment in EIA Notification, 1994 (operative at that time) vide the Notification dated 07.07.2004. The Central Government under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 had issued Environment Impact Assessment Notification dated 14.09.2006 superseding Environment Impact Assessment Notification 1994, which required prior Environmental Clearance from the concerned Regulatory Authority. It was further contended that the Auroville Project was examined by the said regulatory authority for the applicability of environmental clearance as directed by the Tribunal and it was found that the Auroville Township Project was under construction much before the EIA Notification, 1994 and its amendment in 2004, and substantial building work of Auroville Project was completed at various stages as far back as in 2001. Therefore, it could not have [2025] 3 S.C.R. 527The Auroville Foundation v. Navroz K ersasp Mody & Ors. been considered as a new project under the provisions of the Notification dated 07.07.2004. It was specifically contented that there was no change in the scope of Township project from the original Master Plan, and as such the Township project would not affect the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006 and its amendments for grant of Environmental Clearance.
VI. The Tribunal raised the following points for consideration. “65. The points that arise for consideration are:
(i) Whether the application is maintainable?
(ii) Whether it was barred by limitation?
(iii) Whether the intended activity of the 1st respondent requires any prior Environmental Clearance or clearance under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 as claimed by the applicant. Even if they are not required, is there any necessity to issue any directions applying the “Precautionary Principle” to protect environment and if so, what are the nature of directions to be issued?”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.