Western Coal Fields Ltd. v. Manohar Govinda Fulzele & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 233; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 183
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia, Justice K. Vinod Chandran
- Decided
- 16 Feb 2025
- Case number
- No. 2608/2025
- Sections
- 4(6), 4
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 183 : 2025 INSC 233 Western Coal Fields Ltd.
v.
Manohar Govinda Fulzele & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 2608 of 2025)
17 February 2025 [Sudhanshu Dhulia and K. Vinod Chandran,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether forfeiture of gratuity is permissible in the event of termination of service on misconduct, which can be categorised as an act constituting an offence involving moral turpitude; without there being any conviction in a criminal case or even a criminal proceeding having been initiated.
Headnotes† Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 – s.4(6)(b)(ii) – Interpretation: Held: Under the Act, for forfeiture of gratuity, conviction in a criminal proceeding is not necessitated, if the misconduct alleged and proved constitutes an offence involving moral turpitude – In case of PSU, the employee was proceeded against for the misconduct of producing a fraudulent ‘date of birth certificate’ to obtain appointment – It has been proved that he supressed his actual date of birth – Thus, the appointment itself was illegal – Decision of the PSU forfeiting entire gratuity of the terminated employee upheld – However, in case of conductors in appeals filed by MSRTC, the act alleged and proved is of misappropriation of meagre amounts, Appointing Authority directed to limit the forfeiture to 25% of the gratuity payable and release the balance amounts to the respondent employees. [Paras 11, 13, 15] Misappropriation – Misappropriation of fares collected from passengers, if an offence involving moral turpitude:
Held: Misappropriation is an act constituting an offence involving moral turpitude – Even if the amounts misappropriated are minimal it would constitute a misconduct warranting termination. [Paras 13, 15] Words and Phrases – ‘Offence’ – General Clauses Act. [Para 10] * Author 184 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 – s.4(6)(b)(ii) – Words “duly established in a Court of Law” cannot be supplied – Relying on C.G. Ajay Babu case, the impugned judgments held that the forfeiture of gratuity is not permissible under the 1972 Act: Held: The interpretation of sub-clause (b)(ii) of sub-section (6) of s.4 was uncalled for in C.G. Ajay Babu since the provisions of the s.4 including sub-section(6) was inapplicable to the employer Bank and its employee, by virtue of sub-section (5) of s.4 – The interpretation was an obiter making a reference unnecessary – Furthermore, s.4(6)(b)(ii) does not make it a requirement that the misconduct alleged and proved in a departmental enquiry should not only constitute an offence involving moral turpitude, but also should be duly established in a Court of Law – The words “duly established in a Court of Law” cannot be supplied to the provision. [Para 9] Case Law Cited Union Bank of India and Ors. v. C.G. Ajay Babu [2018] 9 SCR 995 : (2018) 9 SCC 529; Jaswant Singh Gill v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd [2006] Supp. 8 SCR 1064: (2007) 1 SCC 663; Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd. v. Rabindranath Choubey (2020) 18 SCC 71; Devendra Kumar v. State of Uttaranchal [2013] 8 SCR 471 : (2013) 9 SCC 363 – referred to.
List of Acts Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972; General Clauses Act.
List of Keywords Forfeiture of gratuity; Termination of service; Misconduct; Offence involving moral turpitude; No conviction in a criminal case/no criminal proceeding initiated; Public Sector Undertaking (PSU); Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation (MSRTC); Fraudulent ‘date of birth certificate’; Actual date of birth supressed; Appointment illegal; Entire gratuity forfeited; Delinquent employee; Terminated employee; Conductors; Misappropriation; Misappropriation of meagre amounts, Appointing authority; Disciplinary authority; Misappropriation of fares collected from passengers; Nature of the misconduct; Extent of forfeiture; ‘Offence’; “duly established in a Court of Law”.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 185Western Coal Fields Ltd. v. Manohar Govinda Fulzele & Anr. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2608 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 29.01.2020 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Nagpur in WP No. 6006 of 2016 Appearances for Parties Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, Vyom Raghuvanshi, Ms. Akanksha Rathore, Ms. Kinjal Sharma, Uddyam Mukherjee, Swapnil Pattanayak, Agnibha Chatterjee, Advs. for the Appellant.
Pratik R. Bombarde, Devendra Singh, Jitendra Kumar, Rohit Verma, Ms. Kirti Anand, Naman Tandon, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K. Vinod Chandran, J.
Leave granted.
2. The question raised in the above cases is the permissibility of forfeiture of gratuity, in the event of termination of service on misconduct, which can be categorised as an act constituting an offence involving moral turpitude; without there being any conviction in a criminal case or even a criminal proceeding having been initiated.
3. The appellant in one of the appeals is a Public Sector Undertaking1 on whose behalf learned Solicitor General Mr. Tushar Mehta appears. The other appeals are by the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation 2 for whom Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, learned Standing Counsel appears. Impugned judgments found the forfeiture of gratuity to be not permissible under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (the Act) relying on the decision of this Court in Union Bank of India and 1 For brevity ‘PSU’ 2 For brevity ‘MSRTC’ 186 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Ors. vs. C.G. Ajay Babu.3 On behalf of the contesting respondent in the appeal filed by the PSU, Mr. Shivaji M. Jadhav appears to defend the reasoning in the judgment and none appears for the respondent in the appeals filed by the MSRTC; though served with notice.
4. Before we look into the facts of the separate cases, we have to dwell upon the law as declared in C.G. Ajay Babu. 3 C.G. Ajay Babu 3 was a case in which a delinquent employee, while working as Branch Manager in a Bank was dismissed from service pursuant to allegations of misconduct being proved against him in a departmental proceeding. The misconducts alleged and proved were the failure to take steps to ensure and protect the interests of the Bank, failure to discharge duties with utmost devotion, diligence and honesty and for acts unbecoming of an Officer employee. Further show cause notice was issued threatening forfeiture of gratuity, on the ground that the misconducts proved, amounts to acts involving moral turpitude. The challenge made against the dismissal before the High Court failed, but the forfeiture was held to be bad. The forfeiture was upset, on the finding that, there was no allegation of financial loss caused to the bank; which was the only ground on which gratuity could be forfeited as per the Bipartite Settlement regulating the conduct and behaviour of the employees of the Bank; including disbursal of gratuity.
5. A Division Bench of this Court found that sub-section (5) of Section 4 of the Act is a non obstante clause which does not affect the right of an employee to receive better terms of gratuity, under any award, agreement or contract with the employer. While sub-section (5) made inapplicable the other provisions of Section 4, sub-section (6); which deals with forfeiture of gratuity, despite being a non obstante provision made inapplicable only the provisions of sub-section (1); which created the statutory right for gratuity on an employee, limited for the purposes of forfeiture. It was held that, insofar as the delinquent employee having been in the service of a bank, which service is regulated by the Bipartite Settlement, which also contains provisions for payment of gratuity and its forfeiture, sub-section (6) of Section 4 of the Act is inapplicable to the employees of the bank. The Settlement providing for better terms of gratuity also provided for
3 (2018) 9 SCC 529
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 187Western Coal Fields Ltd. v. Manohar Govinda Fulzele & Anr. its forfeiture when the misconduct results in financial losses to the bank and only to the extent of the loss; while specifically prohibiting forfeiture of gratuity for dismissal on any other ground. The order of the High Court was upheld finding that the forfeiture; in the teeth of the provisions of the Bipartite Settlement, could not have been carried out by the bank.
6. Having held the forfeiture to be bad, the Bench also looked at the provision for forfeiture under Section 4(6) of the Act and specifically found that “the requirement of the statute is not the proof of misconduct of acts involving moral turpitude but the act should constitute an offence involving moral turpitude and such offence should be duly established in a Court of Law” (sic Para 19). The Court placed reliance on another judgment of this Court in Jaswant Singh Gill vs. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd.4
7. Jaswant Singh Gill, 4 an employee of a PSU; the services in which were regulated by the Conduct, Discipline and Appeal Rules, 1978 5 , retired during the pendency of disciplinary proceedings, with the gratuity payable withheld, due to the pending proceedings. On finalization of the disciplinary proceedings, the appellant was found guilty of misconduct relatable to the role played in causing shortages in stock and concealing it from the higher authorities, which was held to be a very serious misconduct warranting punishment of dismissal; which, however, was not imposed considering the fact that the employee had superannuated. The Disciplinary Authority hence imposed the punishment of forfeiture of the entire gratuity, which was challenged unsuccessfully before the High Court. This Court found that the provision in the CDA Rules to withhold the gratuity of an employee retiring, against whom disciplinary proceedings are pending, and the provision to recover from the gratuity, the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused to the company were contrary to the provisions under Section 4 of the Gratuity Act, which provisions of the Act prevail over the CDA Rules. It was held that though the CDA Rules provided for disciplinary proceeding to be continued after superannuation, the major penalty of dismissal could not have been imposed after superannuation. Looking
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.