Om Prakash Gupta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 183; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 937
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 11 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13407/2024
- Sections
- 5, 498
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 937 : 2025 INSC 183 Om Prakash Gupta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors.
v.
Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
(Civil Appeal No(s). 13407-13408 of 2024)
11 February 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Prashant Kumar Mishra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The issues before the Hon’ble Court were as to whether the High Court was justified in dismissing the application for condonation of delay in filing the application for substitution and could the second appeal be regarded as having abated; and as to what is the proper sequence in which the said applications are to be filed. Headnotes† Section 5 of Limitation Act, 1963 – Application for setting aside abatement and application for condonation of delay in filing the former application – Principles to be kept in mind by the Court as laid down in Perumon Bhagvathy Devaswom v. Bhargavi Amma (2008) 8 SCC 321. [Para 8] Section 5 of Limitation Act, 1963 – Circumstances that are considered sufficient cause summarised in Perumon Bhagvathy Devaswom v. Bhargavi Amma (2008) 8 SCC 321. [Para 9] Order XXII of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 r/w Articles 120 and 121 of Limitation Act, 1963 – Time frames laid out in the said provisions discussed – Proper sequence to be followed explained:
Held: Order XXII of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Rule 1 states that when a party to a suit passes away, the suit will not abate if the right to sue survives – Rules 3 and 4 deal with the procedure for bringing on record the legal representative(s) of the plaintiff/ appellant and the defendant/respondent respectively when the right to sue survives – Limitation Act, 1963 – Article 120 states that the suit/appeal automatically abates when an application to substitute the legal representative(s) of the deceased party is not * Author 938 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports filed within the prescribed limitation period of 90 days from the date of death – Article 121 allows the appellant 60 days to file an application seeking setting aside of the abatement after the expiry of the aforesaid 90 days – After the expiry of the 150 days (90 + 60 days) the application to set aside abatement should be accompanied with a petition to condone delay under Section 5 of Limitation Act – Plaintiff/ appellant to satisfy the Court that sufficient cause prevented him/her from applying for setting aside the abatement within the period of limitation. [Para 11] Rule 4 of Order XXII of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Who has to present application for substitution - Examined in light of judicial pronouncements:
Held: In Union of India v. Ram Charan AIR 1964 SC 215, it was held that Rule 4 of Order XXII does not say who has to present the application and that usually it is the plaintiff/appellant who does it as it is he who stands to lose if the suit/appeal is abated – In Civil Appeal 13407/2024 the Respondent/ Defendant’s LRs had moved an application for substitution when the sole defendant (predecessor-in-interest of the Respondents herein) died – A justice oriented approach has to be applied while interpreting the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 as held by this Hon’ble Court in Chinnammal v. P. Arumugham (1990) 1 SCC 513 – Since the Court was thus informed of the death of the Respondent/Defendant and the heirs that he had left behind, the dismissal of second appeal as having abated cannot sustain. [Paras 14-16, 19] Article 136 of Constitution of India – Power of Supreme Court to cure manifestly illegal order to avoid travesty of justice: Held: This Court reiterated the ratio in A. Subash Babu v. State of A.P. (2011) 7 SCC 616 that under Art. 136 it has power to pass orders in favour of a party suo motu when it is satisfied that compelling grounds for it exist even when the order is not in challenged before it – It has the power to mould relief taking notice an obvious error of law committed by the High Court. [Para 21] Whether prayer of setting aside abatement inherent in the prayer for substitution:
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 939Om Prakash G upta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
Held: In Mithailal Dalsangar Singh v. Annabai Devram Kini (2003) 10 SCC 691 it was held that a simple prayer for bringing the legal representatives on record without specifically praying for setting aside of an abatement may in substance be construed as a prayer for setting aside the abatement – A prayer for bringing the legal representatives on record, if allowed, would have the effect of setting aside the abatement as the relief of setting aside abatement though not asked for in so many words is in effect being actually asked for and is necessarily implied – The Courts have to adopt a justice-oriented approach dictated by the uppermost consideration that ordinarily a litigant ought not to be denied an opportunity of having a lis determined on merits unless he has, by gross negligence, deliberate inaction or something akin to misconduct, disentitled himself from seeking the indulgence of the Court. [Paras 23, 32] Order XXII Rule 10-A, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Purpose and whether it is complied with:
Held: It was inserted vide the amendment of 1976 in the CPC – Thereby, a duty is cast upon a pleader appearing for a party to the suit to intimate the Court about the death of such party and once the Court is informed by the pleader of a party that he is no more, the Court “shall” notify the opposing party of the death – Court’s obligation to issue notice to the other party is indeed mandatory except when the intimation to Court is given in presence of the opposite counsel or when the Court records it in the order sheet – The purpose for its introduction as held by this Court in Gangadhar v. Raj Kumar (1984) 1 SCC 121 is to specifically mitigate the hardship arising from the fact that the party to an appeal may not come to know about the death of the other party during the pendency of the appeal but when it is awaiting its turn for being heard – It is an innovative provision to see that administration of justice is not thwarted by technical procedural lapse whereby, a duty is cast upon the learned advocate appearing for the party who comes to know about the death of the party to intimate to the Court about the death of the party represented by him – A deemed continuation of the contract between dead client and lawyer subsists to the limited extent after the death of the client – It is implicit that this information must be conveyed in a straightforward and unambiguous manner to enable the plaintiff or the appellant, as the case may be, to take steps and apply for substitution – The inclusion of such pertinent 940 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports information within an inconspicuous section of an application meant for a different purpose without the date of death does not constitute sufficient compliance with Rule 10-A. [Paras 27-30] Case Law Cited Perumon Bhagvathy Devaswom v. Bhargavi Amma [2008] 11 SCR 1 : (2008) 8 SCC 321; Union of India v. Ram Charan [1964] SCR 467 : AIR 1964 SC 215; Chinnammal v. P. Arumugham [1990] 1 SCR 78 : (1990) 1 SCC 513; A. Subash Babu v. State of A.P. [2011] 9 SCR 453 : (2011) 7 SCC 616; Mithailal Dalsangar Singh v. Annabai Devram Kini [2003] Supp. 3 SCR 822 : (2003) 10 SCC 691; Gangadhar v. Raj Kumar (1984) 1 SCC 121 – relied on. List of Acts Limitation Act, 1963; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Constitution of India, 1950.
List of Keywords Application for substitution of legal representatives; Application for setting aside abatement; Condonation of delay; Sufficient cause. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 13407 of From the Judgment and Order dated 27.02.2019 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in SA No. 885 of 1977 With Civil Appeal No. 13408 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Thomas P Joseph, Shekhar Devasa, Sr. Advs., A Velan, Ms. Navpreet Kaur, Rudraksh Gupta.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Raghenth Basant, Sr. Adv., Nishant Anand, Mrs. Gunjan Bansal Anand, Anushasit Arya, Ms. Hima Bhardwaj, Shakib, Sandeep Sury, Abhigya Kushwah, Mrs. Sunita Singh.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 941Om Prakash G upta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
B rief resume of facts
1. facts of civil appeal N o. 13407 of 2024:
a. Satish Chandra instituted a suit1 against Om Prakash Gupta2 seeking specific performance of an agreement.3 The suit was dismissed by the trial court 4 vide judgment and order dated 7th October, 1974. In first appeal,5 Satish Chandra succeeded and the suit was decreed vide judgment and decree dated 31st March, 1977. Aggrieved, Om Prakash preferred a second appeal6 before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad.7 The High Court granted stay of operation of the decree vide order dated 11th May, 1977.
b. Satish Chandra passed away on 2 nd December 1996 during the pendency of the second appeal. On 2nd January, 1997, his heirs moved an application for substitution. 8 The High Court was informed of the death of Satish Chandra by the heirs and prayer was made for their substitution. Paragraph no. 1 of the application for substitution contained details as follows: “That in the above noted second appeal, the sole respondent Satish Chandra son of Sri Ram died on 2.12.1996 leaving behind the following heirs and legal representatives: - 1 Civil Suit No. 264/1972 2 Om Prakash 3 agreement to sell dated 8th February,1970 4 the court of the Civil Judge, Bareilly 5 Civil Appeal No.11 of 1975 6 Second Appeal No. 885 of 1977 7 High Court, hereafter 8 Civil Miscellaneous Substitution Application No. 211 of 1997 942 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1/1 Anil Kumar 1/2 Vimal Kumar 1/3 Manoj Kumar”
Prayer in the said application is as follows:
“It is prayed that the Hon’ble Court may be pleased to delete the name of the respondent no. 1 Sri Satish Chandra from array of the parties and on his place the following:
1/1 Anil Kumar 1/2 Vimal Kumar 1/3 Manoj Kumar All sons of Late Sri Satish Chandra R/o Gandhi Tola, Nawabganj, Bareilly Be substituted as his heirs and legal representatives”
c. Om Prakash died on 8th December 2001.
d. From the sequence of orders passed in the second appeal between 17 th March, 2004 and 8 th December, 2006, it is seen that multiple opportunities were given to counsel for Om Prakash to file an application for substitution. However, pendency of the application for substitution filed by the heirs of Satish Chandra escaped the notice of the High Court.
e. Ultimately, the second appeal was ordered to have abated in the whole vide order dated 2 nd January 2007 on the ground that no application for substitution was filed by Om Prakash or his heirs to bring on record the heirs/legal representatives of Satish Chandra.
f. In the year 2017, the heirs of Satish Chandra initiated proceedings for execution of the decree. 9 g. Put on notice, the heirs of Om Prakash preferred an application for recall/restoration 10 seeking recall of the aforesaid order 9 E.A. No. 6 of 2017 10 Civil Miscellaneous Restoration Application No. 2 of 2018 [2025] 2 S.C.R. 943Om Prakash G upta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
recording abatement of the second appeal. On the same day, they also filed an application for substitution 11 along with an application for condonation of delay. 12 h. The restoration application was allowed by the High Court and the second appeal restored to its original file and number vide order dated 25th May, 2018.
i. Seeking recall of the said order, heirs of Satish Chandra preferred an application for recall13 along with an application for condonation of delay.14 These applications were allowed vide order dated 11th January 2019, with the result that the order restoring the second appeal to its original file upon setting aside of abatement stood recalled. Liberty was, however, reserved for the heirs of Om Prakash to file an application for setting aside abatement.
j. While hearing the pending applications, referred to in paragraph g. (supra), the High Court did not find sufficient reasons for condoning the delay in filing the application for substitution. Resultantly, such application filed by the heirs of Om Prakash along with the application for substitution was dismissed vide impugned order dated 27 th February 2019.
k. Taking exception to such order of the High Court, the heirs of Om Prakash have filed Civil Appeal No. 13407 of 2024.
2. facts of civil appeal N o. 13408 of 2024:
a. Smt. Rooprani,15 Satish Chandra’s wife, instituted a suit 16 for specific performance of an agreement 17 against Om Prakash and his minor sons (represented through their mother). The suit was dismissed vide order dated 7 th October, 1974 by the 11 Civil Miscellaneous Substitution Application No. 5 of 2018 12 Civil Miscellaneous Delay Condonation Application No. 4 of 2018 13 Recall Application No. 7 of 2018 14 I.A. No. 8 of 2018 15 Rooprani 16 Suit No. 94 of 1973 17 agreement to Sell dated 7 th June, 1970 944 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Trial Court. 18 In an appeal 19 preferred by Rooprani, the suit was decreed vide judgment and decree dated 31 st March, 1977. Om Prakash carried the first appellate decree in a second appeal. 20 The High Court granted stay of operation of the impugned decree vide order dated 11 th May, 1977.
b. After the death of Rooprani on 18th May, 1991, an application 21 was filed on or about November/December, 1992 by deceased Rooprani’s son, Anil Kumar, praying that the High Court may take note of an alteration made by Om Prakash and his heirs in the decretal property. In the affidavit accompanying such application, it was stated that the deponent (Anil Kumar) is one of the sons of deceased Rooprani (plaintiff). The same is reproduced below:
“That the deponent is one of the sons of the deceased respondent Smt. Roop Rani and conversant with the facts deposed.”
c. As noted earlier, Om Prakash passed away on 8 th December, 2001.
d. The second appeal of Om Prakash was dismissed for nonprosecution 22 as the counsel for the remaining appellants (the heirs of Om Prakash) submitted that his clients were not responding.
e. After almost 11 (eleven) years, on 15th September, 2017, the legal representatives of Rooprani filed for execution of the decree.23 f. This is when the heirs of Om Prakash, on 5th April, 2018, filed an application 24 seeking recall of the order dismissing the second appeal for want of prosecution. They filed an application, 25 40 (forty) days later, praying for their substitution as heirs of 18 Court of Civil Judge, Bareilly 19 Appeal No. 12 of 1975 20 Second Appeal No. 884 of 1977 21 C.M.A. No. 5306 of 1992 22 vide order dated 3 rd November, 2006 23 E.A. No. 7 of 2017 24 Recall/ Restoration Application No. 2 of 2018 in Second Appeal No. 884 of 1977 25 Civil Miscellaneous Substitution Application No. 5 of 2018 [2025] 2 S.C.R. 945Om Prakash G upta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
deceased Om Prakash, along with an application seeking condonation of delay. 26 g. Finding that sufficient cause had been shown, the High Court allowed the recall application and restored the second appeal to its original file and number vide order dated 25 th May, 2018. h. Seeking recall of the aforesaid order, the heirs of Rooprani filed a recall application 27 which was dismissed by the High Court vide order dated 11 th January, 2019. The High Court opined that restoration of the second appeal, in itself, did not amount to setting aside of the abatement and unless abatement is set aside, the second appeal is non-est in the eyes of law and no right will accrue to either side.
i. Thereafter, the impugned orders were passed by the High Court on 27th February, 2019. By the first order, the application by heirs of Om Prakash for condonation of delay in filing the substitution application 28 was dismissed. The second order, having regard to the first order, dismissed their application for substitution. 29 For the reasons assigned in the first order, the High Court did not find sufficient reasons to condone the delay.
j. Taking exception to the above, the heirs of Om Prakash have filed Civil Appeal No. 13408 of 2024.
proceediNgs Before this court
3. A coordinate bench of this Court, on 12 th July, 2019, granted permission to file the special leave petitions and issued notice on such petitions as well as the accompanying applications for substitution and the connected applications. Pursuant to service of notice, the heirs of Satish Chandra and Rooprani entered appearance. Mr. Thomas Joseph, learned senior counsel and Mr. Shekar Devessa, learned senior counsel represented the heirs of Om Prakash. Heirs of Rooprani were represented by Mr. Raghenth Basant, learned senior counsel. While granting leave and reserving judgment on 26 Civil Miscellaneous Application No. 4 of 2018 27 Recall Application No. 7 of 2018 28 C.M. Delay Condonation Application No.4 of 2018 29 C.M. Substitution Application No.5 of 2018 946 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports these civil appeals, we had made an order allowing the applications for substitution and the connected applications, filed in the present proceedings, subject to just exceptions.
coNteNtioNs of the parties
4. Learned senior counsel/counsel appearing for the parties have meticulously taken us through the facts of both these appeals which, though not very complicated, are a bit extensive considering that proceedings commenced in 1972-1973.
5. Learned senior counsel/counsel for the appellants have argued that the High Court fell in error on both occasions by not granting the prayers of the appellants and having the two second appeals heard on merits. According to them, procedural requirements have been allowed to steal a march over substantive justice without duly appreciating the materials on record.
6. Per contra, Mr. Basant appearing for the respondents has assiduously contended that there is no infirmity, far less manifest infirmity, in the impugned orders of the High Court and no interference under Article 136 of the Constitution is warranted. He highlighted how Om Prakash was negligent in pursuing the second appeals before the High Court. According to him, it well within the knowledge of Om Prakash that Rooprani and then Satish Chandra passed away and who their heirs were. Lack of due diligence by Om Prakash being writ large, he prayed that the longstanding dispute between the parties be laid to rest by dismissing these appeals and leaving it open to the respondents to pursue the execution applications in accordance with law, should the need arise.
issues
7. The issue arising for decision in C.A. No.13407 of 2024 is, whether the High Court was justified in dismissing the application for condonation of delay in filing the application for substitution and could the second appeal be regarded as having abated.
8. In C.A. No. 13407 of 2024, whether the High Court was justified in passing the impugned orders dismissing the applications filed by the appellants seeking substitution and condonation of delay is the issue.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 947Om Prakash G upta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
aNalysis aNd reasoNs
9. The principles to guide courts while considering applications for setting aside abatement and application for condonation of delay in filing the former application are laid down by this Court in Perumon Bhagvathy Devaswom v. Bhargavi Amma.30 An instructive passage from such decision reads as follows:
“13. The principles applicable in considering applications for setting aside abatement may thus be summarised as follows:
(i) The words ‘sufficient cause for not making the application within the period of limitation’ should be understood and applied in a reasonable, pragmatic, practical and liberal manner, depending upon the facts and circumstances of the case, and the type of case. The words ‘sufficient cause’ in Section 5 of the Limitation Act should receive a liberal construction so as to advance substantial justice, when the delay is not on account of any dilatory tactics, want of bona fides, deliberate inaction or negligence on the part of the appellant.
(ii) In considering the reasons for condonation of delay, the courts are more liberal with reference to applications for setting aside abatement, than other cases. While the court will have to keep in view that a valuable right accrues to the legal representatives of the deceased respondent when the appeal abates, it will not punish an appellant with foreclosure of the appeal, for unintended lapses. The courts tend to set aside abatement and decide the matter on merits, rather than terminate the appeal on the ground of abatement.
(iii) The decisive factor in condonation of delay, is not the length of delay, but sufficiency of a satisfactory explanation.
(iv) The extent or degree of leniency to be shown by a court depends on the nature of application and facts and circumstances of the case. For example, courts view
30 (2008) 8 SCC 321
948 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports delays in making applications in a pending appeal more leniently than delays in the institution of an appeal. The courts view applications relating to lawyer’s lapses more leniently than applications relating to litigant’s lapses. The classic example is the difference in approach of courts to applications for condonation of delay in filing an appeal and applications for condonation of delay in refiling the appeal after rectification of defects.
(v) Want of ‘diligence’ or ‘inaction’ can be attributed to an appellant only when something required to be done by him, is not done. When nothing is required to be done, courts do not expect the appellant to be diligent. Where an appeal is admitted by the High Court and is not expected to be listed for final hearing for a few years, an appellant is not expected to visit the court or his lawyer every few weeks to ascertain the position nor keep checking whether the contesting respondent is alive. He merely awaits the call or information from his counsel about the listing of the appeal.”
(emphasis supplied in original)
The aforesaid passage is followed by other instructive passages too on special factors which have a bearing on what constitutes “sufficient cause”, with reference to delay in applications for setting aside abatement and bringing the legal representatives on record. To the extent relevant for decisions on these two appeals, the same are extracted hereunder:
“15. The first is whether the appeal is pending in a court where regular and periodical dates of hearing are fixed. There is a significant difference between an appeal pending in a subordinate court and an appeal pending in a High Court. In lower courts, dates of hearing are periodically fixed and a party or his counsel is expected to appear on those dates and keep track of the case. The process is known as ‘adjournment of hearing’. ...
16. In contrast, when an appeal is pending in a High Court, dates of hearing are not fixed periodically. Once the appeal is admitted, it virtually goes into storage and [2025] 2 S.C.R. 949Om Prakash G upta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) & Ors. v. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased)
is listed before the Court only when it is ripe for hearing or when some application seeking an interim direction is filed. It is common for appeals pending in High Courts not to be listed at all for several years. (In some courts where there is a huge pendency, the non-hearing period may be as much as ten years or even more.) When the appeal is admitted by the High Court, the counsel inform the parties that they will get in touch as and when the case is listed for hearing. There is nothing the appellant is required to do during the period between admission of the appeal and listing of the appeal for arguments (except filing paper books or depositing the charges for preparation of paper books wherever necessary). The High Courts are overloaded with appeals and the litigant is in no way responsible for non-listing for several years. There is no need for the appellant to keep track whether the respondent is dead or alive by periodical enquiries during the long period between admission and listing for hearing. When an appeal is so kept pending in suspended animation for a large number of years in the High Court without any date being fixed for hearing, there is no likelihood of the appellant becoming aware of the death of the respondent, unless both lived in the immediate vicinity or were related or the court issues a notice to him informing the death of the respondent.
17. The second circumstance is whether the counsel for the deceased respondent or the legal representative of the deceased respondent notified the court about the death and whether the court gave notice of such death to the appellant. Rule 10-A of Order 22 casts a duty on the counsel for the respondent to inform the court about the death of such respondent whenever he comes to know about it. When the death is reported and recorded in the order-sheet/proceedings and the appellant is notified, the appellant has knowledge of the death and there is a duty on the part of the appellant to take steps to bring the legal representative of the deceased on record, in place of the deceased. The need for diligence commences from the date of such knowledge. If the appellant pleads ignorance even after the court notifies him about the death of the 950 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports respondent that may be an indication of negligence or want of diligence.
18. The third circumstance is whether there is any material to contradict the claim of the appellant, if he categorically states that he was unaware of the death of the respondent. In the absence of any material, the court would accept his claim that he was not aware of the death.
19. Thus it can safely be concluded that if the following three conditions exist, the courts will usually condone the delay, and set aside the abatement (even though the period of delay is considerable and a valuable right might have accrued to the opposite party—LRs of the deceased—on account of the abatement):
(i) The respondent had died during the period when the appeal had been pending without any hearing dates being fixed;
(ii) Neither the counsel for the deceased respondent nor the legal representatives of the deceased respondent had reported the death of the respondent to the court and the court has not given notice of such death to the appellant;
(iii) The appellant avers that he was unaware of the death of the respondent and there is no material to doubt or contradict his claim.
(emphasis supplied)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.