State of Punjab & Ors. v. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 231; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1948
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 17 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2212/2024
- Sections
- 13(1), 13(9), 70, 8, 14, 2, 13, 1(2), 5, 37, 19(20)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1948 : 2025 INSC 231 State of Punjab & Ors.
v.
Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd.
(Civil Appeal No. 2212 of 2024)
17 February 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the State could amend the Punjab Value Added Tax Rules, 2005 to provide that the input tax credit (ITC) already earned on goods kept in stock could be availed at a reduced rate as the rate of tax on the goods stood reduced in the interregnum when there was no enabling provision in the parent statute i.e., the Punjab Value Added Tax Act, 2005.
Headnotes† Punjab Value Added Tax Act, 2005 (“Punjab VAT Act”) – First proviso to s.13(1) – Amended with effect from 01.04.2014 – Punjab Value Added Tax Rules, 2005 (“Punjab VAT Rules”) – Rule 21(8) introduced and Schedule E amended with effect from 01.02.2014 – As a result, the ITC already paid for goods kept as stock in trade could only be availed at a reduced rate – Held, no statutory sanction prior to 01.04.2014 to allow applicability of Rule 21(8) on the stock in trade already purchased at a higher rate of tax – Impugned judgment of High Court upheld – Appeals dismissed:
Held: Amendment dated 25.01.2024 which inserted sub-rule (8) in Rule 21 of VAT Rules whereby a taxable person’s entitlement to get ITC on concerned goods (iron and steel) was reduced based on reduction in input tax on such goods was unjustified in the absence of there being an enabling provision to do so in the VAT Act which was the parent statute – It was held that any change in the ITC scheme by amending VAT Rules could have been done only after 01.04.2024 when first proviso to Section 13(1) of VAT Act was amended, which dealt with ITC. [Paras 31-35] * Author [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1949State of Punjab & Ors. v. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd. Comparison between pre and post amendment scenario regarding first proviso to Section 13(1) of VAT Act prejudicial and unfair:
Held: Court observed that pre-amendment, the first proviso entitled taxable persons to receive ITC in respect of goods which were for sale/use in manufacture etc., but post amendment, such persons were not entitled to receive ITC unless such goods were sold/used in the manufacture etc – Thus essentially, post amendment, the benefit of ITC became available from the date of further sale/use/ manufacture etc and therefore goods which were “stock in trade” would not attract the benefit of ITC – Additionally, as per sub-rule
(8) of Rule 21 of VAT Rules, the ITC already earned i.e., @4% was now available at the reduced rate i.e., @2% w.e.f. 25.01.2014 on sale of such goods – Held, it would be prejudicial and unfair to a taxable person who had stock in trade as on 25.01.2014 or as on 01.02.2014 (when amended rule came into effect) by paying higher rate of tax on purchase of iron and steel goods but would later on be entitled to reduced ITC due to reduction in the rate of tax on such goods on a subsequent date – Rule 21(8) could come into effect only on and from 01.04.2024 i.e., when amended the Punjab VAT Act, s.13(1) came into force. [Paras 36, 41, 41.1] Right accrued to the assessee on date of purchase of goods immutable till such goods meet the objective of their purchase or continue to exists:
Held: Court relied on Eicher Motors Limited Vs. Union of India, (1999) 2 SCC 361 which concerned ITC and held that a right accrued to the assessee on the date when he pays the tax on the raw material or the input would continue until the facility available thereto gets worked out or until those goods existed. [Para 37] Statutory amendments amounting to change in law to not have retrospective application:
Held: Court relied on Sedco Forex International Drill INC.Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Dehradun, (2005) 12 SCC 717 which stated the general principle of tax law that if any statutory amendment is clarificatory in nature, it could be read into the main provision from the date when such provision became effective 1950 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports however if any such amendment amounts to a change in law, then it cannot be presumed to have retrospective application – Court also relied on Commissioner of Central Excise, Patna Vs. New Swadeshi Sugar Mills (2016) 1 SCC 614 which dealt with CENVAT Credit Rules, 2002 and held that CENVAT credit already earned by the assessee could not be changed by a statutory amendment that did away with it and such amendment would have only prospective effect. [Paras 38-39] Reliance placed on Jayam and Company Vs. Assistant Commissioner (2016) 15 SCC 125 wherein the court that the said amendment being detrimental to the ITC entitlement of taxable persons would not have retrospective application. [Para 40] Impact on reverse ITC obligation under Section 13(9):
Held: That if Petitioner’s contention were to be accepted, it would require reversing of ITC in terms of Section 13(9) at reduced rate of tax on the goods in question if such goods were not used for the purposes specified in Section 13(1) or which remained as “stock in trade” at the time of closure of business which effectively will lead to revenue loss to State exchequer. [Para 41.2] Case Law Cited Eicher Motors Limited v. Union of India [1999] 1 SCR 295 : (1999) 2 SCC 361; Sedco Forex International Drill INC. v. CIT [2005] Supp. 5 SCR 302 : (2005) 12 SCC 717; Commissioner of Central Excise, Patna v. New Swadeshi Sugar Mills (2016) 1 SCC 614; Jayam and Company v. Assistant Commissioner [2016] 6 SCR 787 : (2016) 15 SCC 125 – relied on.
List of Acts Punjab Value Added Tax Act, 2005; Punjab Value Added Tax Rules, 2005.
List of Keywords Input tax credit; Value added tax; Parent statute; Enabling provision; Delegated legislation; Prospective effect; Retrospective effect; Legislative competence; Punjab VAT Act 2005; Punjab VAT Rules 2005.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1951State of Punjab & Ors. v. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2212 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.05.2015 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CWP No. 7951 of 2014 With Civil Appeal Nos. 2213, 2214-2216, 2217, 2218 and 2219 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Vivek Jain, D.A.G., Karan Sharma, Rajat Jain, Ms. Princy Sharma, Abhinav Jain, Mohit Siwach, Ms. Ranjeeta Rohatgi, Advs. for the Appellants.
Mohit D. Ram, Samdeep Goyal, Sandeep Goyal, Pawanshree Agrawal, Ms. Shubhangi Negi, Rishabh Chauhan, Atul Krishna, Ms. Monisha Handa, Rajul Shrivastav, Anubhav Sharma, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
This judgment and order will dispose of Civil Appeal Nos. 2212, 2213, 2214-2216, 2217, 2218 and 2219 of 2024.
2. Details of the Civil Appeals are as under:
Sl.
No.
Civil Appeal No(s).
SLP (C) No(s). Cause Title
1. 2212 of 2024 35263 of 2015 State of Punjab & Ors. Vs. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd.
2. 2213 of 2024 35269 of 2015 State of Punjab Vs. Prime Steel Processors.
3. 2214-2216 of 35265-35267 of State of Punjab Vs. JREW Engineering Ltd. Etc. Etc.
4. 2217 of 2024 35790 of 2015 State of Punjab Vs. District Taxation Bar Association (Sales Tax), Ludhiana.
1952 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. 2218 of 2024 904 of 2016 State of Punjab Vs. LSR Forge Pvt. Ltd.
6. 2219 of 2024 2407 of 2016 State of Punjab vs Jalandhar Iron and Steel Merchants Association (Regd.).
3. Since parties have advanced their arguments in Civil Appeal No. 2212 of 2024 (State of Punjab Vs. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd.), the same is taken as the lead appeal and for the sake of convenience, facts stated in the said appeal would be referred to hereunder.
4. This appeal by special leave is directed against the order dated 20.05.2015 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh (briefly ‘the High Court’ hereinafter) in CWP No. 7951/2014 (Trishala Alloys Private Ltd. Vs. State of Punjab) whereby the High Court has allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent by following its judgment and order of even date passed in CWP No. 5625/2014 (Jalandhar Iron and Steel Merchants Association Vs. State of Punjab).
5. State of Punjab has filed the related petition for special leave to appeal (civil) No. 35263/2016 assailing the order dated 20.05.2015.
6. Question for consideration is whether Rule 21(8) of the Punjab Value Added Tax Rules, 2005 (Punjab VAT Rules) could have been introduced during the period between 25.01.2014 to 01.04.2014 when there was no enabling provision in the parent statute i.e. the Punjab Value Added Tax Act, 2005 (Punjab VAT Act)? The above issue has arisen in the following factual backdrop.
7. Respondent is a manufacturer of iron and steel goods. For manufacturing such goods, it purchases raw material of iron and steel from within the State of Punjab as well as from outside the State of Punjab.
8. Punjab VAT Act came into force from 01.04.2005. As per the scheme of Punjab VAT Act, value added tax (VAT) paid or payable under the said Act by a taxable person on the purchase of taxable goods for resale or for use by him in the manufacture or processing or packing of taxable goods in the State of Punjab would be termed as input tax. The credit of input tax available to a taxable person under the Punjab VAT Act is referred to as input tax credit (ITC). There is a concept called reverse input tax credit which means the amount of [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1953State of Punjab & Ors. v. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd. input tax credit which is required to be reversed by a taxable person on account of credit note for output tax received from the previous seller of goods on purchase in respect of which input tax credit (ITC) is claimed etc. Output tax in relation to a taxable person means the tax charged or chargeable or payable in respect of sale and/or purchase of goods, as the case may be, under the Punjab VAT Act.
9. A taxable person shall be entitled to input tax credit in such manner and subject to such conditions as may be prescribed in respect of input tax on taxable goods including on capital goods purchased by him from a taxable person within the State during the tax period. However, such goods must be for sale in the State of Punjab or in the course of inter-state trade, commerce or in the course of export or for use in the manufacture, processing or packing of taxable goods for sale within the State of Punjab or in the course of inter-state trade or commerce or in the course of export.
9.1. Taxable person has been defined to mean a person who is registered for the purpose of paying value added tax under the Punjab VAT Act and tax period means the period for which a person is required to pay tax under the Punjab VAT Act or the rules framed thereunder.
10. Section 13(1) of the Punjab VAT Act read with the first proviso thereto, as it stood prior to amendment, provided that a taxable person shall be entitled to input tax credit in respect of input tax on taxable goods purchased by him from a taxable person within the State during the tax period if such goods are for further sale etc or for manufacture etc of taxable goods.
10.1. After amendment with effect from 01.04.2014, the mandate of the provision undergoes a change in that input tax credit would be available only if the goods are sold or are used in manufacture etc.
11. In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 70 of the Punjab VAT Act, the Punjab VAT Rules have been framed.
11.1. Rule 18 deals with conditions for input tax credit whereas input tax credit on capital goods is dealt with in Rule 19.
11.2. Rule 21 is relevant. It provides for inadmissibility of input tax credit in certain cases, such as, no input tax credit shall be 1954 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports admissible to a person for tax paid on purchase of goods if such goods are lost or destroyed or damaged beyond repair etc. Calculation of input tax credit is dealt with in Rule 22.
12. Government of Punjab in the Department of Excise and Taxation issued notification bearing No.G.S.R.5/P.A.8/ 2005/S.70/Amd. (53)/2014 dated 25.01.2014 making the Punjab Value Added Tax (First Amendment) Rules, 2014 (‘First Amendment Rules’ hereinafter) to further amend the Punjab VAT Rules. It is mentioned therein that the amendments would come into force with effect from 01.02.2014. As per the First Amendment Rules, after sub-rule (6) of Rule 21 of the Punjab VAT Rules, sub-rules (7) and (8) were added. Sub-rule (8) as inserted in Rule 21 vide the First Amendment Rules reads as under:
(8) where some goods as input or output are lying in the stock of a taxable person and where rate of tax on such goods is reduced from a particular date, then from that date, input tax credit shall be admissible to the taxable person on the sale of goods lying in stock or on using the goods as input for manufacturing taxable goods, at the reduced rate.
13. Government of Punjab in the Excise and Taxation Department issued a revised public notice/clarification drawing the attention of taxable persons, advocates, chartered accountants and cost accountants that the rate of tax on iron and steel goods stood reduced from 4.5 per cent to 2.5 per cent. It was mentioned therein that input tax credit (ITC) on stock held as on 31.01.2014 would be restricted to the new rate of tax plus surcharge. It was further clarified that the new tax regime would come into effect from 01.02.2014.
14. Punjab Government in the Department of Excise and Taxation also issued notification bearing No. S.O.9/P.A.8./2005/ S.8/2014 dated 25.01.2014 making amendment in Schedule ‘E’ appended to the Punjab VAT Act mentioning that the same was being done in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (3) of Section 8 of the Punjab VAT Act dispensing with the condition of previous notice. As per the amendment, serial No.21 was added to Schedule E whereby iron and steel goods as enumerated in Clause IV of Section 14 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 except non-cenvat paid iron and steel scrap would attract tax at 2.5 per cent whereas non-cenvat paid iron and steel scrap would attract tax at 1 per cent.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1955State of Punjab & Ors. v. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd.
15. Respondent filed CWP No. 7951 of 2014 before the High Court for a declaration that Rule 21 (8) of the Punjab VAT Rules as inserted vide the notification dated 25.01.2014 was ultra vires the Constitution and the Punjab VAT Act. Contention of the respondent was that credit for the tax already paid by the taxable person on goods kept as stock in trade would be reduced by virtue of Rule 21 (8) which is illegal and unconstitutional.
16. By the impugned judgment, High Court allowed the writ petition holding that on the date of introduction of sub-rule (8) in Rule 21 of the Punjab VAT Rules, the State did not possess any power traceable to the Punjab VAT Act to confine the rate of input tax credit to the reduced rate of tax on the stock in trade i.e. on those concluded transactions where the taxable person had already earned input tax credit at the previous higher rate of tax.
17. Aggrieved thereby, the State is in appeal.
18. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the High Court was not at all justified in allowing the writ petition filed by the respondent holding that on the date of introduction of sub-rule (8) in Rule 21 of the Punjab VAT Rules, the State did not possess any power to confine availing of input tax credit (ITC) to the reduced rate of tax on the stock in trade i.e. in respect of transactions that stood concluded with the taxable person already earning input tax credit at the previous higher rate of tax. Judicial intervention in such a case was not warranted.
18.1. Referring to Section 2(o) of the Punjab VAT Act, he submits that input tax is the tax paid or payable in the course of business on the purchase of any goods made from a registered dealer of the State. It is a tax in relation to a taxable person which is paid or is payable by him on the purchase of taxable goods for resale or for further use by the taxable person in the manufacture or processing or packing of taxable goods in the State. Output tax which is the tax charged or chargeable or payable under the Punjab VAT Act extends the benefit of ITC subject to fulfilment of certain conditions. Learned counsel submits that High Court has completely misread Rule 21(8) of the Punjab VAT Rules holding that there would be retroactive application of the said Rule whereas no such intent is decipherable therefrom.
1956 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
18.2. ITC is not a privilege but merely a facility to avoid the cascading effect of tax. State government introduced the scheme of ITC under Section 13 of the Punjab VAT Act to minimise the effect of VAT and to reduce the burden of tax on the ultimate consumer. Every dealer (taxable person) calculates the output tax liability and reduces the tax paid on purchases to reach the quantum of tax payable. Therefore, the state government has the power to impose tax at the stage of sale and in certain cases, no ITC may be available. A dealer would be entitled to ITC on the stock in trade held as on 31.01.2014 equal to the new rate of tax plus surcharge effective from 01.02.2014. The goods purchased prior to 31.01.2014 and not sold or utilised till 31.01.2014 would be eligible to ITC at the new rate enforced till further sale. Thus, he would not be entitled to credit at the same rate of tax which was applicable at the time of procurement.
18.3. High Court has failed to appreciate that amendment to the Punjab VAT Rules applies only to the rate of tax prevailing on the date of sale of the stock in trade and, therefore, does not affect the rights of a dealer or the ITC on the transaction which stood concluded.
18.4. Learned counsel has referred to the rule making provision in the Punjab VAT Act i.e. Section 70. He submits that as per sub-section (2) of Section 70, the rules under the Punjab VAT Act may be made either with prospective effect or with retrospective effect. However, he concedes that as per the proviso thereto, the rules shall be made with retrospective effect only if the same are required to be made in public interest.
18.5. He finally submits that State has a larger affirmative responsibility towards the society. Therefore, the impugned provision may be examined from that perspective also.
19. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent submits that the High Court had rightly observed that on the date of introduction of sub-rule
(8) in Rule 21, the State did not possess any power emanating from the Punjab VAT Act to confine the availing of input tax credit (ITC) to the reduced rate of tax on the stock in trade i.e. on the transaction which stood concluded with the dealer already earning input tax credit at the previous higher rate of tax. He submits that a perusal of the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1957State of Punjab & Ors. v. Trishala Alloys Pvt. Ltd. amendment in the first proviso to Section 13(1) of the Punjab VAT Act would reveal that the said provision is not retrospective but applies to transactions after 01.04.2014. The amendment in the said Rule which came into effect prior to the amendment in the Punjab VAT Act could therefore not be enforced by the appellant before 01.04.2014 to take away a vested right already determined and accrued to the respondent without any statutory sanction.
19.1. Based on the above submission, learned counsel for the respondent contends that the limited issue in this appeal is whether Rule 21(8) of the Punjab VAT Rules could have been introduced and made applicable during the period between 25.01.2014 to 01.04.2014.
19.2. In that context learned counsel contends that on the date when Rule 21(8) of the Punjab VAT Rules was introduced i.e. on 25.01.2014 there was no enabling provision in the Punjab VAT Act that empowered the State to reduce the rate of input tax credit already earned by reference to the sale of goods lying in stock. The statutory position is clear in that input tax credit (ITC) would be earned on the date of purchase in accordance with Section 13 of the Punjab VAT Act as it stood on that date i.e. on the date of purchase. Amendment to the Punjab VAT Act empowering the State to notify such a rule came into effect only on 01.04.2014 when the first proviso to Section 13(1) of the Punjab VAT Act was amended. The words ‘are for sale’ appearing in the first proviso to Section 13(1) were deleted and substituted with the words ‘are sold’. Similarly, the words ‘for use in the manufacture’ were replaced by the words ‘are used in the manufacture’. Effect of this amendment was to limit the input tax credit earned on the goods already sold or used in manufacture. This amendment therefore enabled the State to reduce the input tax credit already earned on the stock in trade by reference to the reduced rate of taxation.
19.3. State of Punjab introduced Rule 21(8) in the Punjab VAT Rules vide the notification dated 25.01.2014, the effect of which was that though the respondent would have paid tax at the existing higher rate on the purchase of raw material used as input, it would not be in a position to recover the whole of it from the customers because of subsequent reduction in the rate of tax. 1958 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
19.4. Learned counsel vehemently argued that the State did not have the legislative competence to reduce the input tax credit already earned by inserting sub-rule (8) in Rule 21 before making amendment in the corresponding enactment i.e. Section 13 of the Punjab VAT Act. Amendment in the Punjab VAT Act having come into effect from 01.04.2014, the amendment in Rule 21(8) of the Punjab VAT Rules could not have come into force prior thereto.
19.5. Learned counsel for the respondent submits that there is no error or infirmity in the view taken by the High Court. Appeal filed by the State lacks merit and, therefore, should be dismissed.
20. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.