P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 212; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1060
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 13 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2717/2025
- Sections
- 3(1), 3(2), 3(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1060 : 2025 INSC 212 P. Rammohan Rao v.
K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 2717-2719 of 2025)
13 February 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the period of officiating service of the temporarily appointed Assistant Executive Engineers-AEEs between 1990-1992 including the appellants should be taken into account for considering their seniority over and above the 1997 batch of regularly appointed candidates through APPSC-private respondents.
Headnotes† Service Law – Seniority – Counting of the period of officiating service – Appellants regularly appointed in 1990 as Work Inspectors in the State Corporation – For the project-based exigency, in 1992, the appellants and one other appointed as temporary AEEs u/r.10(a)(i)(1) of the Rules – Private respondents appointed as AEEs in 1997, after undergoing the regular selection process through APPSC in accordance with the Act of 1994 – Subsequently, services of appellant came to be regularized by G.O.M No. 234 on 27.06.2005, and the appellants placed below the last regularly selected candidate of AEEs in terms of seniority – Subsequently, State Government introduced a classification amongst temporarily appointed AEEs based on their dates of appointment with reference to the promulgation of Act of 1994 – Issuance of revised G.O.M No. 262, dated 17.06.2006, stipulating that the temporary AEEs appointed between 1990-1992 would be placed below the last regular AEE appointed through the APPSC, prior to the enactment of the Act of 1994 – Challenge to – High Court quashed the G.O.M No. 262 dated 17.06.2006 – Sustainability: Held: Not sustainable – State Government fully justified in issuing the revised G.O.M. No. 262 – Period of officiating service-period between 1990 to 2005 of the appellants and the batch of the AEEs appointed between 1990-1992 to be counted as regular service for determining the seniority, entitling him/them to be placed above the * Author [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1061P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc. 1997 batch of regularly appointed candidates-private respondents in the seniority list – At the time of the appointment of the appellants and other similarly placed candidates as AEEs between the years 1990-1992, there was a vacuum in rules governing the appointment of AEEs in the Panchayat Raj Department, as such it cannot be said that these appointments were de hors the rules – Notwithstanding the designation of the appointments of the appellants and similarly situated candidates as being temporary, such appointments were neither restricted by a fixed tenure nor conceived as a stop-gap or ad-hoc arrangement – While characterized as temporary, these appointments were not intended to address a transient or interim requirement, rather, they were structured to ensure continuity and stability within the workforce – Services of the appellants and other similarly situated candidates were regularised in 2005, and the same attained finality – Once the services of employees are regularised, the ad-hoc or stop-gap nature of the appointment does not survive – Since there were no selection rules in force in the Panchayat Raj Department for appointment of the appellants as temporary AEEs in 1992, the appellants clearly falls under Proposition (B) of the Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers’ Association v. State of Maharashtra’s case, that if the initial appointment is not made by following the procedure laid down by the rules but the appointee continues in the post uninterruptedly till the regularisation of his service in accordance with the rules, the period of officiating service will be counted – Furthermore, the rule-making power of the legislature cannot be curtailed or nullified by application of the concept of functus officio – Reasoning assigned by the High Court that the State Government became functus officio after issuance of G.O.M. No. 234 dated 27.06.2005 and could not have issued the revised G.O.M. No. 262 dated 17.06.2006 is untenable and ultra vires the Constitution – Reasoning by the High Court that the private respondents, as affected parties, were required to be heard before the issuance of the revised G.O.M. No. 262 is unsustainable and contrary to the established legal principles – If the State Government is compelled to afford an opportunity of hearing to every individual or entity likely to be affected by its administrative decision-making, its rule-making authority would be severely constricted, defeating the very purpose of efficient policy implementation and undermining its ability to discharge its administrative duties – Thus, the order passed by the High Court quashed and set aside – Andhra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules – Andhra Pradesh (Regulation of Appointments to Public Services and Rationalization of Staff Pattern and Pay Structure) Act, 1994. [Paras 34, 35, 37, 38, 47] 1062 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Doctrines/Principles – Principle of functus officio – Application of concept of functus officio on legislatures:
Held: Rule-making power of the legislature cannot be curtailed or nullified by application of the concept of functus officio – Principle of functus officio normally applies to a judicial forum or a quasijudicial authority and would have no application to the rule-making authority which is within the domain of the State Government by virtue of Art. 245 of the Constitution. [Para 42] Case Law Cited Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers’ Association v. State Of Maharashtra [1990] 2 SCR 900 : (1990) 2 SCC 715 – followed. Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel [1985] Supp. 2 SCR 131 : (1985) 3 SCC 398 – relied on.
Orissa Administrative Tribunal Bar Association v. UOI [2023] 6 SCR 731 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 309; Patel Engg. Ltd. v. Union of India (2012) 11 SCC 257; Santosh Kumar v. State of A.P. [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 264 : (2003) 5 SCC 511; Amarendra Kumar Mohapatra v. State of Orissa and Ors. [2014] 2 SCR 1031 : (2014) 4 SCC 583 – referred to.
List of Acts Andra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1996; Andhra Pradesh (Regulation of Appointments to Public Services and Rationalization of Staff Pattern and Pay Structure) Act, 1994; Andhra Pradesh Panchayati Raj and Rural Development Act; Andhra Pradesh Panchayati Raj and Rural Development Rules.
List of Keywords Seniority; Counting of the period of officiating service; Work Inspectors; Temporary Assistant Executive Engineers-AEEs; Regular selection process; De hors the rules; Stop-gap or ad-hoc arrangement; Proposition (B) of the Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers’ Association v. State of Maharashtra’s case; Administrative actions; Judicial review; Rule-making power; Administrative duties; Principle of Functus Officio; Andhra Pradesh Schedule Castes Cooperative Development Corporation; Judicial forum or quasi-judicial authority; Panchayat Raj Department.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1063P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No(s). 4036-4038 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.09.2023 of the High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad in WP Nos. 3903, 3910 and 4173 of 2011 With Special Leave Petition (Civil) No(s). 4596-4597 of 2024 and Civil Appeal No(s). 2532-2541 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioner:
Gaurav Agarwal, B. Adinarayana Rao, Guru Krishnakumar, Sr. Advs., Ms. Devina Sehgal, S. Uday Bhanu, Byrapaneni Suyodhan, Kumar Shashank, Ms. Tatini Basu, Ms. Rao Vishwaja, P. Vamshi Rao Adv, P. Mohith Rao, Ms. J Akshitha, Shaik Sohil Akthar, Eugene S Philomene. Advs. for the Respondents:
Gaurav Agarwal, Gaurav Agrawal, Sr. Advs., Dr. K. Lakshmi Narasimha, Ms. Bina Madhavan, S. Uday Kumar Sagar, Ms. Niharika Tannerce, M/S. Lawyer S Knit & Co, Ms. Devina Sehgal, S Uday Bhanu.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
Civil Appeals @ SLP(Civil) Nos. 4036-4038 of 2024 Civil Appeals @ SLP(Civil) Nos. 4596-4597 of 2024
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. These appeals take exception to the final judgment and common order dated 21 st September, 2023 rendered by the High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad 1 whereby the Division Bench 1 Hereinafter, being referred to as the ‘High Court’.
1064 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports allowed the batch of writ petitions preferred by the private respondents herein and quashed the Government Office Memorandum 2 No. 262, dated 17th June, 2006, issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh.
4. Facts in a nutshell relevant and essential for the disposal of these appeals are as under.
5. The appellants who hold the qualification of B. Tech (Bachelor of Technology) were selected and appointed as Work Inspectors in the Andra Pradesh Scheduled Castes Cooperative Development Corporation 3 on 1 st January, 1990 and were serving in the said department. The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued G.O.M. No. 89, dated 9 th February, 1990, sanctioning posts of Assistant Executive Engineers 4 for achieving Phase-II of the Andhra Pradesh Primary School Project, 5 which was initiated in collaboration between the Government of Andhra Pradesh and the Government of United Kingdom in the year 1983. The said project was time-bound and hence, directions were issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh to the Chief Engineer, to fill up the posts immediately from the list available with the Andra Pradesh Public Service Commission,6 and if the list was not adequate then the Chief Engineer was permitted to recruit the candidates through the employment exchange.
6. Since the list available with the APPSC was inadequate to fill the posts required for the project, the Chief Engineer wrote to the State Government, and in response thereof, G.O.M. No. 429, dated 6 th March, 1990, was issued by the Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, directing that these vacancies may be filled up from the Work Inspector/ Draughtsman/Tracers who were already serving in the Panchayat Raj Department and possessed a graduation degree in Engineering i.e. B.E./B.Tech. It was further clarified that the nature of these appointments would be temporary under Rule 10(a)(i) of the Andra 2 Hereinafter, being referred to as the ‘G.O.M.’ 3 Hereinafter, being referred to as the ‘Corporation’. 4 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘AEEs’.
5 To achieve the first objective 84 primary school building with improved designs were constructed in 11 selected project districts. In order to achieve phase-II of the project construction work needed to be entrusted to the Panchayat Raj Engineering department and to have a separate class of engineer’s staff for undertaking construction of buildings of primary schools and teachers’ centres. 6 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘APPSC’.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1065P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc. Pradesh Subordinate Service Rules 7 pending amendment to the Special Rules for Panchayat Raj Engineering Services. The said G.O.M. also contained a direction to frame a formula for the promotion of the above-mentioned candidates, taking into account the strength of cadre and the retirement vacancies in the next two years as per the rules. A Committee was also constituted to consider the proposal for temporary appointments and for filling up the remaining vacancies.
7. Thereafter, another G.O.M. No. 540, dated 30 th August, 1990 was issued by the Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Department, whereby 386 posts of AEEs were sanctioned under the Cyclone Emergency Reconstruction Project. 8 The appellants herein and one individual who were already serving as Work Inspectors were appointed as temporary AEEs on 5 th December, 1992 against these vacancies. It is an undisputed fact that the appellants herein and his peers were appointed against substantiate vacancies created for the project.
8. Subsequently, the Andhra Pradesh (Regulation of Appointments to Public Services and Rationalization of Staff Pattern and Pay Structure) Act, 1994 9 came to be enacted on 15 th January, 1994 to streamline the recruitment process. The same was made effective retrospectively from 25 th November, 1993.
9. Thereafter, the G.O.M. No. 391, dated 30 th June, 1994, came to be issued by the Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Department, creating 729 posts of AEEs for taking up the works related to rural water supply and sanitation. 10 Under the said G.O.M., employment assurance scheme and employment guarantee scheme were also created.
10. In July, 1994, the Technical Grade-I Inspectors filed Original Application No. 533 of 1994 before the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, 11 to consider their cases for appointment as AEEs against the project based vacancies. The APAT vide order dated 4 th July, 1994 disposed of the O.A., wherein the State Government was directed to consider 7 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘Service rules’.
8 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘CERP’ 9 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘Act of 1994’.
10 ‘Jawahar Rojgar Yojana Scheme’.
11 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘APAT’.
1066 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the case of Work Inspectors for appointment to the posts of AEE before notifying the vacancies to employment exchange.
11. In compliance with the aforesaid direction passed by APAT, G.O.M. No. 1289, dated 10 th August, 1994, came to be issued by the Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Department in relation to the appointments under the ‘Jawahar Rojgar Yojana Scheme’, permitting the Chief Engineer to fill up the vacancies of AEEs which had been created by way of G.O.M. No. 391, dated 30 th June, 1994, from eligible Work Inspector/Draughtsman/Tracers having the requisite degree qualification. The aforesaid G.O.M. No. 1289 contained a specific stipulation that the candidates would be appointed temporarily subject to the condition that they should make an endeavour of selection through the APPSC, failing which, they would be reverted back to their original cadre of Work Inspector/Draughtsman/Tracers.
12. AEEs appointed under Rule 10(a)(i) of the Service Rules from the category of Work Inspector/Draughtsman/Tracers and the candidates, who were selected from the list tendered by the employment exchange between 2 nd August, 1989 to 30 th June, 1995, made several representations requesting the State Government to regularize their services as most of them had completed more than five years in service.
13. In 1995, Notification No. 8 of 1995 came to be issued by the APPSC inviting applications from eligible candidates for appointment in various posts including that of AEEs in the Panchayat Raj Department. The recruitment process for the aforesaid appointment was to be conducted under the Act of 1994. The aspiring candidates appeared in the test conducted by the APPSC and as many as 627 posts were filled and the successful candidates including the private respondents herein were appointed in the year 1997, upon due selection by APPSC.
14. Being aggrieved by the non-consideration of their representations for regularisation, the temporary AEEs (including the appellants herein), who had been appointed between the years 1990-1995, filed Original Application No. 5730 of 1995 and batch matters before the APAT, seeking regularisation of their services as they had been working on a temporary basis for several years. The APAT, vide order dated 19 th February, 1996, disposed of these O.A.s, directing the State Government to take a decision regarding the claim of regularisation of services of temporarily appointed AEEs within a reasonable time. [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1067P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc. The APAT, further, directed that till such decision was taken, the services of the applicants therein shall not be terminated.
15. In compliance with the above direction, G.O.M. No. 997, dated 27 th July, 1996, was issued by the State Government rejecting the prayer seeking regularisation of the temporarily appointed AEEs with the observation that there was no provision in the extant service rules for recruitment to the post of AEEs by promotion.
16. Aggrieved by the aforesaid G.O.M., the temporary AEEs, who were appointed between 1990-1995, again approached the APAT via various Original Applications.12 Initially, a stay was granted by the APAT vide order dated 10 th August, 1996, suspending the operation of G.O.M. No. 997, dated 27th July, 1996, and a direction was issued to the State Government, not to notify the vacancies occupied by the applicants therein for the purpose of selection/appointment.
17. In the meantime, and during the pendency of the aforesaid Original Applications, 13 the Government issued another G.O.M. No. 234 dated 27 th June, 2005, whereby the services of all temporary AEEs appointed between 1990-1995 and continuing in service on that date were regularised. It was further clarified that the services of all the temporary AEEs, who were appointed between the years 1990-1995, shall be regularized below the last regularly selected candidate of AEEs.
18. Pursuant to the issuance of the aforesaid G.O.M., the pending Original Applications filed before the APAT were dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 13 th December, 2006, and liberty was granted to the applicants therein to work out their remedies, if they were still aggrieved after the issuance of G.O.M. No. 234.
19. Though satisfied with the regularisation of their services, but aggrieved by the denial of seniority under the G.O.M. No. 234, AEEs appointed between 1990-1992, including the appellants herein, made various representations to the State Government, claiming that they were appointed before the promulgation of the Act of 1994, and thus they were required to be treated as a different class from those appointed between 1993-1995, which was after the promulgation of Act of 1994. It was asserted that G.O.M. No. 234, had caused significant 12 O.A. No. 4991 of 1996, O.A. No. 5547 of 1996, O.A. No. 4427 of 1997 and batch matters. 13 Id.
1068 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports prejudice and injustice as the Engineers appointed between 1990- 1992 had been placed below the AEEs appointed during the year 1997 in the order of seniority, who had thereby lost nearly 10-15 years of continuous service. The State Government was requested to regularize the services of this category of AEEs appointed between 1990-1992 from the date of joining the posts.
20. The State Government, after examining the representations and the prolonged service of the temporary AEEs appointed between the years 1990-1992, modified G.O.M. No. 234, dated 27 th June, 2005, and issued a revised G.O.M. No. 262, dated 17 th June, 2006, which inter alia provided that: - “5. Accordingly, in partial modification of the orders issued in the G.O. 1 st read above, the Government hereby directs the Engineer-in-Chief, Panchayat Raj, Hyderabad to regularize the services of the Assistant Executive Engineers who were appointed during the period 1990-92 below the last regular Assistant Executive Engineer appointed through Andra Pradesh, Public Service Commission prior to the promulgation of Act, 2/94.”
(emphasis supplied)
21. In effect, the above G.O.M. directed that the temporary AEEs appointed before promulgation of the Act of 1994 would retain their seniority from the date of their initial induction on the posts.
22. Being aggrieved by the issuance of the revised G.O.M. No. 262, dated 17th June, 2006, the AEEs regularly appointed through the APPSC Notification No. 8 of 1995, i.e., the private respondents herein, who had joined service in the year 1997 and also, the AEEs appointed on a temporary basis between 1993-1995, filed Original Applications 14 before the APAT. In these batches of Original Application, the State Government filed an affidavit specifically asserting that the appointments made between 1990-1992 were not de hors the service rules and there was no requirement of selection on these posts through the APPSC as the same were exempted from the purview of the Commission (APPSC).
14 O.A. No. 5818/2009, O.A. No. 10733/2009, O.A. No. 5933/2009, O.A. No. 6020 of 2009 and batch matters.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1069P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc.
23. Vide a common order dated 3 rd February, 2011, the APAT dismissed the Original Applications 15 preferred by the 1997 Batch regularly appointed candidates (private respondents herein) and allowed the Original Applications 16 preferred by the temporary AEEs selected between 1993-1995. The APAT, while upholding the validity of G.O.M. No. 262, dated 17 th June, 2006, also held that the temporary AEEs appointed between 1993-1995 were also entitled to a similar treatment as extended to those appointed between 1990-1992 and that the candidates regularly appointed through APPSC in 1997 (private respondents herein) could not claim seniority over the candidates whose regularisation was done in the year 2005.
24. The 1997 batch regularly appointed candidates (private respondents herein) assailed the common order dated 3 rd February, 2011 passed by the APAT by filing writ petitions 17 before the High Court. These writ petitions came to be allowed by the learned Division Bench vide final judgment and common order dated 21st September, 2023 which is subjected to challenge in these appeals by special leave. Submissions on behalf of the appellants: -
25. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants advanced the following pertinent submissions assailing the impugned judgment: -
(a) That the appellants hold the qualification of Bachelor in Engineering. They were duly selected and appointed as Work Inspectors on 1st January, 1990 in the Andhra Pradesh Scheduled Castes Co-operative Development Corporation against a sanctioned post.
(b) That the State Government felt an imminent need for qualified engineers to carry out the Cyclone Emergency Reconstruction Project (CERP) in the year 1990. The Panchayat Raj Department issued G.O.M. No. 540, dated 30 th August, 1990, sanctioning another 386 posts of AEEs under the CERP. At that point in 15 O.A. No. 5018/2006, O.A. No. 5109/2006, O.A. No. 5789/2006, O.A. No. 6394/2006, O.A. No. 6423/2007, O.A. No. 1892/2010 and O.A. No. 4056/2010.
16 O.A. No. 5818/2009, O.A. No. 5933/2009, O.A. No. 6020/2009, O.A. No. 6023/2009, O.A. No. 6038/2009, O.A. No. 10733/2009 and O.A. No. 10897/2009.
17 Writ Petition Nos. 3903, 3910, 3954, 4173, 4434, 4435, 4437, 4439, 4441 and 22422 of 2011. 1070 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports time, no rules were in place for the appointment of Engineers in the Panchayat Raj Department. To meet the exigency, the appellants and one other who were already serving as Works Inspectors in the Cooperative Department Corporation were appointed as temporary AEEs under Rule 10(a)(i)(1) of Andhra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules vide order dated 5 th December, 1992. Their appointment was in no manner de hors the rules or a backdoor appointment.
(c) That no challenge was ever laid by the private respondents to the G.O.M. No. 234 dated 27 th June, 2005, vide which the services of the appellants and other similarly situated candidates were regularized and thus, the same has attained finality. He urged that the services of the appellants and the similarly situated candidates could not be regularized at an earlier point in time due to the need for amendment of the Andhra Pradesh Panchayati Raj and Rural Development Act/Rules and for the creation of a channel for the absorption of the appellants and similarly placed persons. He urged that the delay in amending the aforesaid rules cannot be attributed to the appellants and they cannot be put to a disadvantage for this reason by placing them below the last regularly appointed employee selected after the promulgation of the Act of 1994.
(d) That the appellants and the other similarly situated candidates are of the 1990-1992 batch and have continued to discharge their functions uninterruptedly for the last 31 years while securing periodic promotions. If the impugned order is not set aside, they would be placed below the regularly recruited batch of 1997(private respondents herein) and thereby, they would lose 7 years of seniority. He further stated the appellants are due to retire in January, 2026 and they will superannuate without receiving the promotion to which they are rightfully entitled.
(e) The learned counsel tried to draw a clear distinction between the G.O.M. No. 540, dated 30 th August, 1990, vide which the sanctioned posts under CERP were created and the appellants were appointed as AEEs, and the G.O.M. No. 1289, dated 10 th August, 1994. He urged that G.O.M. No. 1289, which permitted the department to fill up the further project-based vacancies to the posts of AEEs, contained an express stipulation that the [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1071P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc. candidates were being appointed temporarily, subject to the condition that they should seek selection by APPSC, failing which, they would be reverted as Work Inspectors, whereas, no such condition existed in G.O.M. No. 540 dated 30th August, 1990.
(f) That though the terms of appointment would show that the appointment of the appellants and the similarly situated candidates was temporary, however, it was neither limited by time, nor was it meant to be a stop-gap/ad hoc arrangement. He drew the Court’s attention to the G.O.M. No. 391, dated 30 th June, 1994, which dealt with Jawahar Rozgar Yojana Scheme and urged that this G.O.M. contained a clause providing that as and when the Cyclone Emergency Reconstruction Project/ Circles/Divisions are abolished, the persons working in these Circles/Divisions/Sub-Divisions shall be posted in newly sanctioned Circles and Divisions. The posts that were sanctioned for the CERP in the office of the Chief Engineer, CERP would stand abolished w.e.f. 30 th June, 1994, but the staff would continue to attend the residual work till the work is completed. He urged that there was a clear intent on the part of the State Government while issuing this G.O.M. that the persons working in the Sub-divisions created under the CERP would be posted to new Circles/Divisions/Sub-Divisions under the Panchayat Raj Department and thus, for all practical purposes, the services of the appellants and his peers who were appointed as AEEs under the CERP were to be absorbed into the cadre of Panchayat Raj Department upon the completion of the project.
(g) That the State Government had filed a counter affidavit in the writ petitions 18 filed before the Division Bench by the regularly appointed 1997 batch recruits(private respondents herein) challenging the G.O.M. No. 262, dated 17 th June 2006, wherein a specific plea was taken that the appointments to the post of AEEs made between 1990-92 were not de hors the service rules and at that point of time, there was no requirement for these selections to be made through the APPSC as the same were exempted from the purview of the Commission (APPSC). 18 Supra Note 16.
1072 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(h) That the Division Bench has passed the impugned order on an erroneous assumption that once the State Government issued G.O.M. No. 234 dated 27 th June, 2005, it became ‘functus officio’ and could not have modified the same by re-examining the case of the temporary employees appointed between 1990- 1995 and supersede the same by issuance of the G.O.M. No. 262, dated 17th June, 2006. He submitted that the doctrine of ‘functus officio’ is not applicable to administrative decisions based on policy considerations and if such doctrine is made applicable to the rule-making power of the Government, the administrative setup would be virtually crippled. In this regard, he placed reliance on Rule 25 of the Andhra Pradesh State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1996, and the judgment of this Court in Orissa Administrative Tribunal Bar Association v. UOI.19
(i) That the reasoning given by the Division Bench for quashing the G.O.M. No. 262, dated 17th June, 2006, vide which the benefit was given to the temporary appointees (including the appellants herein) that the same was issued without hearing the affected persons i.e. the writ petitioners(private respondents herein) is ex-facie misplaced. He urged that there is no requirement in law for issuance of notice to the set of employees likely to be affected where the Government takes a policy decision of conferring the benefit of regularisation and fixing the date from which the seniority is to be reckoned for a particular set of employees.
(j) That neither was the State Government denuded of the power to amend the earlier G.O.M. nor was there any requirement of hearing the candidates likely to be affected by the revised G.O.M. before its issuance thereof. He urged that the rule-making power of the State Government cannot be curtailed by the principle of ‘Audi alteram partem’ because such a view would virtually bind the hands of the State Government, and it would lose the right to exercise the rule-making power. In this regard, he placed reliance on Patel Engg. Ltd. v. Union of India.20
(k) That the G.O.M. No. 262 was passed in consonance with the 19 2023 SCC OnLine SC 309.
20 (2012) 11 SCC 257.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1073P. Rammohan Rao v. K. Srinivas and Ors. Etc. extant rules and the procedural requirements. The representations filed by the appellants and his peers pursuant to the issuance of G.O.M. No. 234, dated 27th June, 2005, were objectively considered by the State Government, and a well-considered equitable policy decision was taken to count the services of the candidates appointed between 1990-92 from the date of their initial induction in service as temporary AEEs and as a sequel thereto, the appellants were assigned seniority from the said date.
(l) That the instant case falls under Proposition(B) enumerated by the Constitution Bench of this Court in the case of Direct Recruit Class II Engg. Officers’ Association v. State Of Maharashtra, 21 which lays down that “If the initial appointment is not made by following the procedure laid down by the rules but the appointee continues in the post uninterruptedly till the regularisation of his service in accordance with the rules, the period of officiating service will be counted.” He urged that no rules were in force in the Panchayat Raj Department when the appellants were appointed. They continued in his post till regularisation in 2005, and thus, the period of the temporary service (i.e. from 1990 to 2005) of the appellants before the regularisation, has to be counted for determining their seniority. He concluded his submissions by urging that the impugned judgment has disturbed the settled seniority of the cadre posts which has been in vogue for the past two decades, and as a result, the appellants are placed below the private respondents who are more than seven years junior to them at the fag end of their career and thus, deserves to be set aside.
26. Learned senior counsel representing the State Government has supported the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellants.
On these grounds, learned counsel appearing for the appellants and the State implored the Court to allow the appeals, set aside the impugned judgment passed by the Division Bench, and restore the judgment passed by the Tribunal (APAT).
21 (1990) 2 SCC 715.
1074 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Submissions on behalf of the private respondents:
27. E-converso, learned senior counsel representing the private respondents strenuously supported the impugned judgment. He advanced the following submissions:-
(a) That the respondents were appointed as AEEs in 1997 after undergoing a regular selection process in pursuance of Notification No. 8 of 1995, dated 8 th December, 1995 issued by APPSC. On the other hand, the appellants and other similarly situated candidates were appointed as AEEs purely on a temporary basis during 1990-1995, either on promotion, on recruitment by transfer or were sponsored by the employment exchange.
(b) That the appellants and other similarly situated employees were neither appointed with due adherence to any selection procedure nor was their appointment made in accordance with any service rules. He urged that the appellants were not even borne in the cadre as on the date on which the respondents were regularly selected as AEEs in the Panchayat Raj Department and thus, the respondents who were directly recruited through APPSC are entitled to be placed above the appellants and other similarly situated temporary AEEs in the order of seniority.
(c) That the APPSC published Notification No. 4 of 1990 calling for applications from all persons aspiring to be appointed as AEEs on a regular basis. Further, a second opportunity was given vide another Notification No. 8 of 1995 calling for applications for regular selection on the post of AEEs. He thus urged that sufficient opportunities were given to the appellants and similarly situated persons to get appointed via the direct recruitment process conducted by the APPSC, but they did not avail of the same.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.